영성, 몸-마음, 젠더, 생태, 평화 Scapbook: Did Jesus Exist?

2022/05/08

Did Jesus Exist?

Al-Muqaddimah: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhND4...

Useful Charts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptYz-...

Sources/Suggested Reading:

Chilton, Bruce & Craig A. Evans (ed.) (1998). Studying the historical Jesus: Evaluations of the state of Current Research.
Brill. Ehrman, Bart D. (2013). Did Jesus Exist?: The Historical Argument for Jesus of Nazareth. HarperOne.
Holmén, Tom & Stanley E. Porter (ed.) (2011). Handbook for the study of the historical Jesus. Volume 1. Brill.
Levine, Amy-Jill; Dale C. Allison Jr. & John Dominic Crossan (2006). The Historical Jesus in Context. Princeton University Press.

#Jesus #History #ProjectHistoricity
SHOW MORE
13,214 Comments

Pinned by Let's Talk Religion

Let's Talk Religion 1 year ago (edited)
To those wondering about the reference to Hinduism and its incorporation of Jesus, this claim is based on several contemporary movements in Hinduism, like the group assoicated with Sri Ramakrishna (d. 1886) who have indeed argued for Jesus as an Avatar. Thank you all for watching! Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/letstalkreligion Or through a one-time donation: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/letstalkreligionShow less

======

Making the Muslim World (Islamic History)

• 1 / 40

Avatar image

Shen Yun 2022

shenyun.com/adelaide

Book now

Ad 1 of 2 ·

3:50

shenyun.com/adelaide

0:03 / 3:53

#Jesus #History #ProjectHistoricity

Did Jesus Exist?

1,638,118 viewsFeb 20, 2021

42K

DISLIKE

DOWNLOAD

THANKS

CLIP

SAVE

Let's Talk Religion

329K subscribers

Check out the other videos:

Al-Muqaddimah: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhND4...

Useful Charts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptYz-...

Sources/Suggested Reading:

Chilton, Bruce & Craig A. Evans (ed.) (1998). Studying the historical Jesus: Evaluations of the state of Current Research. Brill.

Ehrman, Bart D. (2013). Did Jesus Exist?: The Historical Argument for Jesus of Nazareth. HarperOne.

Holmén, Tom & Stanley E. Porter (ed.) (2011). Handbook for the study of the historical Jesus. Volume 1. Brill.

Levine, Amy-Jill; Dale C. Allison Jr. & John Dominic Crossan (2006). The Historical Jesus in Context. Princeton University Press.

#Jesus #History #ProjectHistoricity

13,214 Comments

Sejin Lifeforce 生命

Add a comment...

Let's Talk Religion

Pinned by Let's Talk Religion

Let's Talk Religion

1 year ago (edited)

To those wondering about the reference to Hinduism and its incorporation of Jesus, this claim is based on several contemporary movements in Hinduism, like the group assoicated with Sri Ramakrishna (d. 1886) who have indeed argued for Jesus as an Avatar.

Thank you all for watching!

Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/letstalkreligion

Or through a one-time donation: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/letstalkreligion

540

Nas PB

1 year ago

great video as always filip. at the end of the day, i think its fair to say that jesus did in fact exist as a person. whatever someone wants to think besides that depends on their own views. quick question, which was the first book of the new testament that mentioned jesus as the son of god or as divine? thanks and have a great day sir. I shall donate to you soon, love your work

Let's Talk Religion

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago (edited)

@Nas PB Mark,

Not just divine, but GOD Himself

tbh, in every Gospel, in pauline epistles, and in acts

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

Why make a video like this right after your Advaita Vedanta video

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini no that’s your opinion

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago why couldn't he?

It is his channel, and it is an important question for many, as they think he didn't exist, when he did

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago I can prove it

Nasir Khan

1 year ago

Where u guys get the info and find out the info is legit

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago Bart Ehrman great scholar, and nt critic, and atheist, also believes that he atleast existed(this is not my proof tho)

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini he didn’t explain anything that hasn’t already been discussed

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago be more specific, I'm unable to comprehend

Let's Talk Religion

1 year ago

@Nas PB Thanks!

That depends on one's interpretation of the Gospels. As early as the Gospel of Mark (the earliest), he is called the Son of God, for example where God says "you are my beloved son" during the baptism.

Where it first states that he is divine is hard to answer, what do we mean by divine? Most of the Gospels seem to imply that he is somehow divine, but not necessarly that he is God Himself. The youngest Gospel of John is the most clear on that stuff. Just in the first lines it claims that Jesus is the Word (logos) and thus a divine pre-creation principle.

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion yes, and in mark 6:50, It is I, is actually ego eimi, which is in Greek equivalent of I'm who I Am, God's name, so he claimed ot be the creator

Nas PB

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion i mean divine in the sense that he is more than just a human. Not necessarily that he's the messiah rather that he is the son of God. I've read that the gospel of John is the first one according to Bart Ehrman and others. Peace

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Dk well that’s total disrespect on his part

just a human being.

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago why not? it's a channel about religions!

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Nas PB do you know that Jews despise jesus right and don’t consider him to be either

Tori Santiago

1 year ago (edited)

@just a human being. no what it is, is total confusion and a meshing of these unique systems. If he’s trying to do this by confirming his positions then that is a weak attempt

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Dk a true historian or scholar doesn’t do that they understand the uniqueness of these religions and traditions

Nas PB

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago I'm just asking a question Santiago. It's just interesting to hear when exactly it was mentioned for the first time. That's it. Peace

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

What I’m saying is he’s trying to use his video on Advaita Vedanta in trying to support the argument that Jesus was God and that is wrong. In the process disrespecting another tradition.

Nas PB

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago who? I'm not doing any such thing and Filip definitely isn't either. Filip is probably the most unbiased youtuber who talks about religion there Is.

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Nas PB it’s funny how coincidentally he makes a video about Advaita Vedanta and then right after a video on if jesus existed and discusses the divinity of Jesus. And the other ideas different religious systems have about that. Unbiased maybe, reckless yes

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini “be more specific, I’m unable to comprehend”, well that’s your problem. What I mean is he hasn’t said anything that hasn’t already been said before about jesus

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini and I don’t care if jesus existed or not, or the claims about jesus. Just don’t use another tradition to help confirm your beliefs or position

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@Let's Talk Religion you should’ve at least did a video on the Hare Krishna movement or something Hindu or even Buddhist related. But you wanted to show your biases

Haroula Todoulos

1 year ago

I really enjoyed your video (1st timer). Looking forward to further content.

Let's Talk Religion

Tijan Jeng

1 year ago

Thanks for sharing. Other than whats written on papers, there's no other proof. Is what I get from the video

112deeps

1 year ago

Based on the teachings recorded & disciples recorded yes he did exist. His teachings are similar to some of the famous masters from other Religions in east.

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@112deeps no they definitely aren’t

Tori Santiago

1 year ago

@112deeps famous masters from other religions in east don’t preach or threaten you with hellfire

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Nas PB i don't agree with him on that, as I said, he has done things only done by God, in the earliest of the Gospels, and I can prove that

And also that he is the Messiah and he resurrected

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago many did, many didn't,

I can prove that he was the Jewish Messiah, Just ask!

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago an ignoramus would say so, if he wants he would do that, and this comment shows your biases too, you sound like a bigot tho,there are many channels who makes videos on your interest, find one, don't force him to make videos according to your will, you alone aren't subscribed, others are too, So don't think you control the account

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@Tori Santiago I'm adding a new comment in this video, find me there, and have discussion, and we both would learn something new,

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@TwoB Btwo thats just non sense to me,

Jesus?

In Hebrew

Yahshua or Yehshua Ha'Masiach or Moshiach

Yehshua is a form of Yehoshua, meaning God saves,

Moshiach is the Messiah, or the anointed one,

So I don't see any problem

I didn't get your point

Niccolò Paganini

1 year ago

@TwoB Btwo just adding random letters out of no where from English to Hebrew, makes no sense, that's stupid, I know Jesus is the Messiah, but that's no way to prove it,

Who uses it? Or supports it?

No one with a brain probably

Dan Zan

1 year ago

Can you do a video on Mullah Sadra?

thatdudeforeal

1 year ago

I would like to hear your views on the documentary Caesar’s messiah that posits that it’s all a Flavian creation

razor reverent

1 year ago

this channel is bias cant research about muhammed of islam haha

Sputnik One

1 year ago

Did Jesus Exist? Yes he is a Mexican who lives in El Paso.

Cat PBatista

1 year ago

Hi~ could you please, please, please!!! do a video about the three wise men and the implications of the fact that they visited Christ must have brought at the time?? Please!!

Yogesh Patil

1 year ago

Middle East Book,Story converted all Europian

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

Could you do a video on who wrote the first Gospel, this would assist in determining whether Jesus was the son of god, man, or didn't exist. I have read where some scholars believe Josephus wrote the first (Marks)

Raverraver9999

1 year ago

Proof Eucharist is body of Jesus Christ and Virgin Mary is his mother.

48I am the bread of life.

49Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died;z

50this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die.

51I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.”a

52The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us [his] flesh to eat?”

53Jesus said to them, “Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you.

54Whoever eats* my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day.

55For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink.

56Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him.

57Just as the living Father sent me and I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on me will have life because of me.b

58This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever.”

Eucharistic miracle..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soCkftBBsBo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oogJ-cdi7yI (Rome Reports)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whbzLYi7cyc (Lanciano)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PJ8BORx1p8

Incorruptible bodies of saints due to the Eucharist – only happens in the Catholic church. No other religion has this miracle

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSCk0qs-2-M (Padre Pio)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN4SvtRje2I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TrR1CEWdbc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCDBekAQ-FI (Carlo Acutis)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=33vlkJh2iJc

Apparition of Virgin Mary

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQnKS7YUE7Q (Virgin Mary apparition in Ivory Coast)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PPGuMmn6TQ (Virgin Mary statue moving)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tVU8bhbQInw (Virgin Mary apparition in Egypt)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMEWxRB-1dc 1968 Egypt

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YR6INkTK7Q (Miracle of the sun)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yF0_ysUivxE (Miracle of the sun)

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion, please help, why does Christianity saddle itself with the god of the old testament when the God of the new testament seems incongruous with the old god. Indeed the old testament god seems to only love his chosen people and is spiteful, vengeful and murderous in comparison to the God of love and forgiveness for all in the new testament. The God of the new testament does not require animal sacrifice etc.

Let's Talk Religion

1 year ago

@Damo Sounds like you'll really like Gnosticism.

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion Not at all (I had to look up what Gnosticism means), I simply can't relate the God of the new and old testaments. The new testament God is about (to summarize) love one and other as you love yourself. This is in-congruent with the old testament god. I can't imagine the God of the new testament telling Moses to kill every man woman and child, in the holy land, as the holy land is meant for them (paraphrased). I hate the current age of identity politics and intersectionality, however, the old testament god is not inclusive, being the god only of the Jews.

I have read and watched some other works on who wrote the first Gospel, one argument put forward and very compelling (to this non practicing catholic but still believer in God) on numerous levels is that Josephus was the author of the first (Mark's) gospel on behalf of the (Flavian) Romans; to quell the Jews who historically spurned accepting the gods of their conquerors and assimilation and were waiting for (and still are) an all conquering messiah.

PS. Thanks for replying.

Damo

1 year ago

@Let's Talk Religion I would also love if you could explore the Talmud.

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion Or you could explore how the roots of the Abrahamic religious beliefs appear to stem form earlier Sumerian , Egyptian etc belief systems, i.e. book of the dead, creation and flood myths etc.

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion How about Akhenaten and monotheist beliefs, did the Jews escape captivity or were they forced out of Egypt? The timing of the exodus may also line up with the expulsion of the Hyksos.

Damo

1 year ago (edited)

@Let's Talk Religion Lastly (promise), I have also read that "Yahweh" was the original name of a god of the pre-Jewish copper age (or earlier) smelters/metallurgists in the area of current day Israel (Canaanites or others?). Would love your opinion. All the best, and God be with you, to all.

Edgar The Atheling

1 year ago

21:16 CORRECTION!!!!!!!!! Iesus is NEVER called SPIRIT OF ALLAH but A SPIRIT FROM ALLAH, CORRECT THIS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YISHAI ISSACHAR

1 year ago

@Let's Talk Religion how do I get ahold of you privately? It could be important.

Mitchell C

1 year ago

The gospel is the GOSPEL OF THE KINGDOM!

Repent and believe the gospel! Follow Jesus’ teachings!

Jesus is going to return and set up the kingdom of God ON THE EARTH! God’s government ON THE EARTH! The Messiah will resurrect his people! The destiny of the Messiah and his people is to be ON THE EARTH! The renewed restored earth! God also dwelling with them! Rev 21

Jesus said the Father is the only true God!

John 17

3 And this is eternal life, that they know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom thou hast sent.

YISHAI ISSACHAR

1 year ago

@Mitchell C jesus christ is the psilocybin mushroom. Exodus 16, numbers 11, psalms 78, Deuteronomy 8, Ezekiel 4, john 4:34-38, john 6:51-58, also in jeramiah 10 talks about the amenita muscaria mushroom. It says don't be like the one that cuts down the 🎄 tree and decorate it with gold and silver, but the inhabitants of the fortress will pick up the packages from off thy land. The fly agaric is in a symbiotic relationship with the pine tree and grows under it.

YISHAI ISSACHAR

1 year ago

@Andrew Valladolid jesus christ is the psilocybin mushroom. Exodus 16, numbers 11, psalms 78, Deuteronomy 8, Ezekiel 4, john 4:34-38, john 6:51-58, also in jeramiah 10 talks about the amenita muscaria mushroom. It says don't be like the one that cuts down the 🎄 tree and decorate it with gold and silver, but the inhabitants of the fortress will pick up the packages from off thy land. The fly agaric is in a symbiotic relationship with the pine tree and grows under it.

YISHAI ISSACHAR

1 year ago

@Andrew Valladolid I see them

Steve Govea

1 year ago

Jesus had high blood pressure.

Anas Syazwan Mohd Ghazali

1 year ago

Refer 1:7

Adelina Cano

1 year ago

If Jesus was the Messiah, i would not deny this

But if James is the family of Jesus it means Jesus is Rome and we don't know what Rome has to do with the Middle East except as invaders please why is there no explanation about this

and the real name of Jesus is ishua(arabic) / yishua(aram) / Iesus(rome) / Jesus (united states???)????

secondly, Jesus is not a god of other traditions

when talking about other traditions at least you need proof such as an explanation of your own bible

we cannot accept an opinion without having a clear basis

ፕ ኗ

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini the biblical Jesus never existed but there were plenty men named Jesus as it was a common name.

ፕ ኗ

1 year ago

@Niccolò Paganini Bart just means there was a man named Jesus as it was a common name.

MysteryTuber123

1 year ago

Very informative and unbiased video! Tip: try to read Jesus’ teachings.

ፕ ኗ

1 year ago

@MysteryTuber123 no such thing as Jesus teaching the Bible is just a fictional book claiming to be the teaching of Jesus.

MysteryTuber123

1 year ago

@ፕ ኗ I’m not talking about the Bible, I’m talking about the Gospel.

ፕ ኗ

1 year ago

@MysteryTuber123 the gospel mis the Bible both were made up by man Jesus didnt exist to teach anything.

MysteryTuber123

1 year ago

@ፕ ኗ Try to read the Sermon on the Mount. Search for it.

MysteryTuber123

1 year ago

@AnarchoRepublican If you will follow those teachings, it will change your life. If you love others, then you're born of God,

MysteryTuber123

1 year ago

@J M That’s gonna take a long time to answer that, but the best thing to answer your question is getting to know Jesus himself by reading the four Gospels.

ፕ ኗ

1 year ago

@J M yeap they even get offended if someone claims that god sacrifice himself to himself. Even though that is what they claim by claiming Jesus nis god.

Carl Hobson

11 months ago

@Let's Talk Religion jesus is the word meant he brought the word of God, he was the messenger, that's why later he said these aren't my words.

anonymous johnson

11 months ago

@MysteryTuber123 : You do know that the gospels were not written by those authors, don't you? The catholic church put those names on those documents. Look it up and learn something.

anonymous johnson

11 months ago

@Khalon A : A lot of the quran was copied from the bible.

Khalon A

11 months ago

@anonymous johnson Also check this man used to be a breacher of Christianity https://youtu.be/cfTBcXaSlbM

Ranjit Jayachandran

11 months ago

Abandoned Void

11 months ago (edited)

This was absolutely irresponsible to post. You don't know anything about the modern historicity debate. You clearly haven't read Dennis R. MacDonald, Richard Carrier, Bart Ehrman, Robert Price, or even Tim o'Neill. This entire video is extremely misinformed and you should do better research in the future. I'm not trying to be mean, but maybe leave history to the actual historians? At least have a bare grip on the topic you present!

Abandoned Void

11 months ago

You have the wrong Josephus reference, misuse Tacitus, and try to shoehorn the Bible as first-person accounts which no reputable historian does, not even those who argue in support of a historical Jesus. This needed more research and care put it into it before you sent it out to so many people.

Glenn Rothgeb

10 months ago

@Raverraver9999 Some of your claims have been substantiated but there is also the case of Yogananda who is considered a "modern day miracle." It was witnessed at the Forest Lawn Cemetery where his body was available for followers to see and show last respects.Yogananda was raised in the Hindu tradition as were most. Indians.He was a believer that basically all major religions are paths to the ONE ABSOLUTE GOD.He was beyond sectarian differences and discrediting other religions.He wrote an awesome book called Autobiography of a Yogi in which he mentioned quite a few miraculous people and events.He was a devotee of Jesus Krishna, etc.He was chosen to bring an ancient tradition called Kriya to the west as well as promote religious understanding.He started a fellowship called Self Realization which exists today.He was a true spiritual master in a line of spiritual masters.He gave examples of Catholics, Hidus,etc. who showed miraculous abilities.Many confirmed that his body showed no signs of decomposition for more than 21 days after his passing.His book is a classic and his life is a testimony of spiritual righteousness..

Glenn Rothgeb

10 months ago

@Damo Zoroastrianism was the religion of Cyrus the Great.He freed the Jews from captivity in Babylon and soon after financed and helped build the second temple in Jerusalem.Both religions served One God . Zoroastrianism was nearly wiped out by Alexander.It's earliest texts called the Vestas, and Gathas predated the Bible by centuries.It is very obvious how the Old Testament writings were influenced by Cyrus the Great from belief in angels, demons, to heaven, hell and the God Ahura Mazda having an evil adversary responsible for the material world and the sins and wickedness that exists.His name was Ahriman also Ahura Mazda.Zoroastrianism also speaks of an apocalyptic battle and coming of a Messiah after which the righteous destroy Angra Mainyu and his followers.Zoroastrianism was the progenitor to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.They were mostly wiped out by the Moslems when they invaded Persia.Many took refuge in India.Home of the earliest known religion and earliest known texts.The Vedas and Upanishads.They have a history of Ahimsa (non violence)and tolerance towards different religious beliefs.They have the Zoroastrians (now called Farsees) refuge as well as the Jews after Rome destroyed the second temple and later Christians who came to India with St. Thomas.They also give the Buddhists govt. In exile and the Dalai Lama refuge after the invasion of Tibet by China in the 1950's where the got. In exile still resides.

Shmuly BeitParzal

10 months ago

Thank you very much for a balanced exploration of the topic. I belong to a Jewish movement that includes the Ebionites. I believe that he was a fully human, Jewish prophet, who was called by God to warn the Jewish people of the coming destruction in the year 70 CE. I believe that he spoke of the Kingdom of God to contrast this with the messianic kingdom of the Zealots. I believe that he felt that the Jewish people could be saved from annihilation by returning to the high ideals of the original Israelite faith ('The old wine is good enough'). A major problem in his ministry was the fact that the Pharisees taught that there were no more prophets. If they had accepted at least the idea of continued prophecy among the Jewish people, then there would have been no need to proclaim him a messiah, but since a messiah was the only type of person that the Pharisees would listen to, I think that the early Jewish followers of Yeshua made the fatal error to make him into a messiah. As a movement, we concentrate on the ethical teachings of Yeshua. If you examine this side of his teachings, they have a very uniform and discernible style, and I think that the person who said those things - whether it was Yeshua or someone else - THAT person existed. Our version of the New Testament - 'The Exhortations' - concentrates on his ethical teachings, rather than on him:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/168907650X

Theresa Shuller

10 months ago

Do one on imaginary Muhammed. And the fact that the super rare mentions of "messenger" may even refer to Jesus.

B N

10 months ago

I'm Muslim and Yes he (Jesus or Isa) existed, he exist (lives) and will come back to earth again.

Ford Trucks

10 months ago

I believe he exist

Jesus really did exist

why ?

because he comes to me in my body all the time

he's always showing me how to repent and live rightly

Inessa Medina

9 months ago

@Orrakl Benedict l

Ford Trucks

9 months ago

I don't know either does anyone else know if Jesus really

existed plus a lot of history

is nothing but FRAUDULENT

Ford Trucks

9 months ago

I think if he does exist

everyone's going

to hell when he gets back

Ford Trucks

9 months ago

It's very controlling

religions and god or gods

and devil's and demons

Time to Reason

9 months ago

Could you do one on Mohamed; Did Mohamed Exist or perhaps Who was Mohamed as you are very verse in Islam and Islamic history. As far as I know what we know of him are by his own followers/faithfuls. Thanks for this nice video, cheers.

Steampunkkids

9 months ago

@Let’s Talk Religion I wish you had used charts/ maps/ timelines as Useful Charts did in his discussion. The way you presented the information made your argument more convoluted and less likely to provoke thoughtful discussion. The sources you discussed were weak at best. You didn’t really give much scientific/ archeologic proof to back up your claims. After watching Useful Charts, I had high hopes for you and your channel. I left feeling disappointed and like I had wasted so much time. By the way, Josephus is biased and self-serving. I understand that the church destroyed all other evidence from that time that would go against their beliefs. But, you should have discussed this in much more detail as well as how untrustworthy a source he was. Come on, man, do better.

lulu branch

9 months ago

Thanks a lot for your information,so interesting to wach6

thewhitemustang

9 months ago

The background music is distracting and unnecessary.

Add1son

9 months ago

exactly my mindset

Add1son

9 months ago

@Je-Free Norman sry i think i replyed to the wrong comment

1982 man

8 months ago

Close in time? My father and I where discussing a trip 20 years ago he said that we went to a museum, however I stated that we didn't because it was closed. Thankfully I took pictures of all the tourist sites. If I didn't we would never of closed the mystery and debate. My point is that history can be filled with inaccuracies when recalling something years or decades later.

Fidde Lozza

8 months ago

Who anointed Jesus? Acts 4: On hearing this, Peter and John raised their voices with one accord to God and said: 26 The kings of the earth took their stand and the rulers gathered together as one against JEHOVAH and against HIS ANOINTED ONE. 27 For truly both Herod and Pontius Pilate with men of the nations and with peoples of Israel were gathered together in this city against YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS, 'WHOM YOU ANOINTED', 30 while you stretch out your hand for healing and while signs and wonders occur THROUGH THE NAME OF YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS.

8 months ago

You do good work...just not in this video. Shameful. The gospels are not evidence nor is “the opinion of historians” many if not all of whom are staunch Christians, and thus, incredibly biased. Also if you spent any time in higher academia/science you would know that consensus is the norm, not an aberration. Academics are followers and go where the citation count/prestige leads them, not Truth.

marta guzman

8 months ago

Peter and John prayed to Jehovah The Father about the son of God saying your Holy Servant Jesus whom you anointed. (Acts 4: On hearing this, Peter and John raised their voices with one accord to God and said: 26 The kings of the earth took their stand and the rulers gathered together as one against JEHOVAH and against HIS ANOINTED ONE. 27 For truly both Herod and Pontius Pilate with men of the nations and with peoples of Israel were gathered together in this city against YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS, 'WHOM YOU ANOINTED', 30 while you stretch out your hand for healing and while signs and wonders occur THROUGH THE NAME OF YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS.)

Joseph George

8 months ago

Judas turned on him I wonder why did he realize the the guy was a fake

Marwa Houda

8 months ago

@Nasir Khan 😣😑

7 months ago

@xi li I agree

Tamara

7 months ago

@Damo what do you mean the God in new and Old testament? There's only one God in both

Tamara

7 months ago (edited)

@Khalon A my friend the Quran has been changed, and have Arabic mistakes. You don't have the Quran during the time of Muhammad. You only have recitation according this and that. You have Hafs Qur'an, y'all Muslims call a liar. The word Qur'an it's not even Arabic

Mike S

7 months ago

Why don't you link ot the other videos?

Krishnan B.S.

7 months ago

@Nas PB I have seen only the existence of lord Ram Questioned Nobody else. This is done because Our beliefs and traditions have always been abused and ridiculed with no retaliation. We know what happened in Paris Belgium on those who didn't even question but just spoke about the prophet. Beheadings are not done in our faith that's why people have the Guts to do these things.

Krishnan B.S.

7 months ago

@Tori Santiago Did you Question him on his questioning the Vedanta which all the Hindus Believe and revere. There are some Brutus's who operate among the Hindu Faith as well.

Mayank Bisht

7 months ago

Wait which sect of Hindus believe Jesus is Vishnu's Avatar

Àngèlo Èlk

7 months ago

@Let's Talk Religion are you a Muslim brother?

Erdood

6 months ago

is Jesus himself really that important? I'd argue that it's the Christians that came after him that did most of the legwork in making him and his teachings (which were mostly not original ideas, but stuff from Judaism, hell, for the first centuries of it's existence, scholars can't meaningfully separate belief in Jesus from Judaism. it became separate when Christians influencers went on an antisemitic spree, and wanted and did de-Jewify their religion, by cutting down on demands present in Judaism. they said that followers of Jesus don't need to keep kashrut)

Paul Northam

6 months ago

Thank you LTR! I think this is a very fair treatment of the data.

What interests me about the 'Jesus Movement' are the traditions and rituals of worship that grew up after his death, many of which are based on his commandments found in scripture. Such as the Sunday breaking of bread, baptism, plus care of the poor, evangelisation etc. There were certainly things in the teaching of Christ that appear to be more central than others, and which the early community followed from very early on.

Ken Smith

6 months ago

If the Gospels were written as late as you claim, how come they don’t mention the destruction of Jerusalem in 70ad? Or the death of Peter or James directly?

01 with 30% less Asbestos

5 months ago

I like how our calendar is based around his birth, but we were off by four years.

Ken Smith

5 months ago

@01 with 30% less Asbestos : Unfortunately, the keeping of historical time back then was not as stringent as today, However despite the discrepancy,the date decided upon did finally anchor the chronicling of historical time for the past two thousand years.

Laurence Abuzo

5 months ago

This hash x2 commentary is full of holes.

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

I have a problem with the Flavius Josephus account as a reliable source on the Jesus topic.

He was borne 37 CE, how on earth could he be a witness to the Jesus character.

He was a military commander of Galilee during the Judaeans revolting against Rome. 66–70 CE.

After this he moved to Rome and became a writer under imperial patronage.

When did he wrote his Jesus history and where did he get his information at least 50 years after the event?

We have different opinions on reliable material.

Ken Smith

5 months ago

@Willie Van Straaten : First, off he was Jewish himself and as a kid I’m sure he heard from the people around him all of what Jesus had done.

Secondly he mentioned about twenty other people from the New Testament including John, Jesus’ brother, John the Baptist, Herod, Herod Antipas, Pontius Pilate, Felix, Ciaphas the high priest etc

And yet no one questions him on these people. I even heard the Jews themselves refer to him to fill out their history

01 with 30% less Asbestos

5 months ago

@Willie Van Straaten Josephus was a historian?

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@01 with 30% less Asbestos 01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?”

So what?

Where and how did he get his information 40 : 60 years after the event?

So, you imply that all historians are always correct just because they are called historians.

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?”

Yes, and not all history is a factual reality. Legendary stories do have the tendency of developing fascinating results introduced by different storytellers (historians).

History is not just what really happened in the past, but a complex intersection of truths, bias and hopes and recording hearsay without any verification. History encompasses at least three different ways of accessing the past: it can be remembered or recovered or even invented. All are imperfect in some way.

The more it is based on hearsay and retelling the more it gets distorted.

Josephus recorded 40 : 60 years after the event?

How do you think the Bible got into existence?

Scribes, (historians) with info gathered from folklore, traditional stories and myths.

How reliable are the information and events described in the Bible?

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@01 with 30% less Asbestos 01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?”

Yes, and not all history is factual reality. Legendary stories do have the tendency of developing fascinating results introduced by different storytellers (historians).

The more it is based on hearsay and retelling the more it gets distorted.

Josephus recorded 40 : 60 years after the event?

How do you think the Bible got into existence?

Scribes, (historians) with info gathered from folklore, traditional stories and myths.

How reliable is the information and events described in the Bible?

Ken Smith

5 months ago

@Willie Van Straaten : Legend I’m told usually develops about a hundred years, however, in the case of Josephus he was born very close to the event and as a Jew would have no motivation to promote a supposed Christian “myth”

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@Ken Smith Ken Smith: “and as a Jew would have no motivation to promote a supposed Christian “myth”

Your second comment. As far as my view is concerned, I responded on your first and have nothing to add on this comment.

jayonnaj18

5 months ago

Yes, Jesus existed, and HE STILL DOES!!! He is coming back to this earth one day and redeem it!!!

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@jayonnaj18 jayonnaj18: “Yes, Jesus existed, and HE STILL DOES!!!

I understand that you believe this through indoctrination but how do you know for sure that he was the son of god borne by a virgin. What proof or evidence can you present.

What evidence is there that god his father is real and not ancient myth.

jayonnaj18: “He is coming back to this earth one day and redeem it!!!”

What do you mean by 'redeem'?

John Doe

5 months ago

Why did you use the talmud as a non-biblical reference to jesus?

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@John Doe The Talmudic stories make fun of Jesus' birth from a virgin, fervently contest his claim to be the Messiah and Son of God, and maintain that he was rightfully executed as a blasphemer and idolater.

Willie Van Straaten

5 months ago

@John Doe John Doe, I don’t get your point or dispute. There are 147 comments under this initial comment by “ Let's Talk Religion” I might have made one or several. Please be clear what you are talking about.

S33N3R 626

5 months ago

Maybe Jesus did exist and ate mushrooms 🍄

Joshua Bacon

5 months ago

YHWH is the Heavenly Father the Creator the Father of the Messiah YHSWH HaMashiach aka Jesus aka Joshua

mjfleming319

4 months ago

All the ancient writers - most notably Augustine - agreed that Matthew was the first gospel written, probably in Aramaic. I’m curious about why videos such as this accept the modern theory of Markan priority, which is based layers on highly speculative “textual criticism”. According to the guidelines set forth at the beginning of the video, the ancient writers, being over a thousand years closer to the facts and in possession of even earlier texts, would be more reliable than the speculative modern scholars. Or am I missing something?

Tim Rickard

4 months ago

I think it should be pointed out that the passages used to add evidence of Jesus were not written by Flavium Josephus but we're latter altered by the Christian Church. It is has been established that these passages, whilst convincing as an independent source if accurate, are in fact false.

Ali Baba Heru

4 months ago

@Niccolò Paganini Nupuqi Om-Re Khonectics chamber degrees will guide you

Komitas Komitas

4 months ago

It’s interesting that author been so knowledgeable about subject, he mentioned Armenia and Arameans..

He talks about jews and Romans and totally ignored Armenian sources.

It’ll be more professional if you talk about Armenia because Armenia was the first country in the world to adopt Christianity as a state religion in 301 A.D. Christianity has played an immensely important role in the shaping of the Armenian people for over 1,700 years. Religion has been an essential part of Armenian identity and has reshaped the course of history. Just FYI

【vivek】

4 months ago

Can anybody help me with what's the background ambient music used in this video

Jesilea

4 months ago

I stumbled on these three videos while going down YouTube rabbit holes, and I thoroughly enjoyed them. Thank you to all of you for taking the time to dive into these historical figures.

Lucas O'heyze

4 months ago

Why are you in this video, are you so desperate for attention?

Let's Talk Religion

4 months ago

@Lucas O'heyze Yes

Caleb Berman

2 months ago

Everyone reading this, I want to tell you that Jesus Christ isn't just real, but that he's God and the Son of God, and that 2,000 years ago, Jesus Christ died on the cross for you to be saved. God sent his Son to pay the price for your sins, and he loves you very much. The Bible also says that if you confess that Jesus Christ is Lord and believe in your heart that God has raised him from the dead, you'll be saved. God bless you all! He loves you all so very much.

James Stevenson

2 months ago

Judaism began 500ad. Jesus was no Jew

Say What ?

2 months ago

Hinduism claiming Jesus is bullshit , some gurus claim corona is form of God , it's mess in here.TBH Don't count their Claims. It's Sick.

Xaviar 77versus99

2 months ago

@YISHAI ISSACHAR you have to eat it

YISHAI ISSACHAR

2 months ago

@Xaviar 77versus99 first you dry the amanita muscaria to reduce ibotenic acid

Xaviar 77versus99

2 months ago

@YISHAI ISSACHAR blue Meanies ya know

YISHAI ISSACHAR

2 months ago

@Xaviar 77versus99 those you can eat fresh LOL

Xaviar 77versus99

2 months ago

@YISHAI ISSACHAR never ever have I tried the amanita

YISHAI ISSACHAR

2 months ago (edited)

@Xaviar 77versus99 I have once when I was 16. but, I ate half of a fresh one with an LSD sugar cube. Not sure if I had effects from the amanita if it did anything. But, I was on a beach, full moon, fast moving cloud and waves rolling in, lake Huron in Michigan. It was pretty powerful. But, I would dry the amanita if it were today. Dry them and make tea. Its recommended, otherwise can be toxic.

Dmp -

1 month ago

Christianity can be religion but true Relationship is with Jesus apart from religion. Religious Followers if YHWH even killed Jesus. Religion doesn’t bear fruit but a relationship does. God is for unity and religion is man made; but God isn’t and neither His word and His relationships❤️

YISHAI ISSACHAR

1 month ago

WARES=🎁= UNDER THE🌲=🍄 AMENITA

🌲🌲🍄🌲🌲🍄🍄🌲🍄🌲🌲🌲🍄🌲🍄🍄🍄🌲🌲🍄🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈

Jeremiah 10:15-17 KJV — They are vanity, and the work of errors: in the time of their visitation they shall perish. The portion of Jacob is not like them: for he is the former of all things; and Israel is the rod of his inheritance: The LORD of hosts is his name. Gather up thy wares out of the land, O inhabitant of the fortress.

🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬🧬

Sonja Petrovic

1 month ago

@letstalkreligion - Actually there is an archeological video on Timeline: "Could This Be the Real Tomb of Jesus" - on You Tube that found His family's tomb that held the ossuaries, or "bone boxes" of His family! Check it out.. 🙏🏼😇

And, if He was in fact God incarnate, He cannot be described, or defined! He just was, is & will always be the divine Messiah! 💜

Reinier Verly

1 month ago

There is a major lack in understanding and reading the original texts and religion traditions. First the Romans were horribly bureaucratic, if Jesus or any one comparable to him would have lived, you would find writings about him because he would have been seen as a dangerous rebel.

Second for Jews than and until now aswell for the Romans death is and was unclean and never ever would someone be buried within the city walls. Executing any one was never done inside the city either, no it was done at the entrance of the city as a possible repellent. Remember Nero's burning crosses with executed people on it on the main way to Rome.

David Keith

1 month ago

Thank you for yr comment. I was just about to suggest to you that Jesus's teachings seem to be far closer to Hinduism than Judaism Islam or even christianity itself. Christianity because they have made a man their god instead of his message

David Keith

1 month ago

@Myth Buster I agree

David Keith

4 weeks ago

@Watchmen of Truth it is very sad initially to find this out as because as a child you get loyal to Jesus as you do father Xmas. But when you consider the magic that Jesus did bringing people back from the dead, giving sight to the blind as miracles I started to question about creating a real live bird out of clay and decided that was the work of a magician. So now I only pray directly to God.

Ancient Ruins

2 weeks ago

Lets Talk Religion - Why JESUS and you may say why not. JESUS firstly wasnt the name where so called Christians jump around the or shall i say part of the world. As per many records which is mainly from Romans, there was no Jesus or son of god as he supposedly was a criminal. We do the same today to any extremists.

Myth Buster

4 days ago

@BDHN Network "DELUSIONAL DISORDER, previously called paranoid disorder, is a type of serious mental illness called a psychotic disorder. People who have it can’t tell what’s real from what is imagined." Schizophrenia Guide, WebMD

Myth Buster

4 days ago

@BDHN Network Delusion: “A delusion is a belief that is obviously false, and yet the individual experiencing it thinks it is absolutely true. A delusion is not a belief that is false because of a person’s intelligence, education, culture, religion, or other similar factor; instead, it is false because it of some abnormality in the individual’s thinking. That person will firmly believe in the delusion even when repeatedly shown evidence to the contrary.” - BrightQuest Treatment Centers.

Paul

2 days ago

I cant wait to give Jesus a hug.

Myth Buster

2 days ago

@Paul You can give him a hug today! "And these signs will accompany those who believe...when they drink deadly poison, it will not hurt them at all" (Mark 16:17-18). Go ahead! Post a video showing you drinking deadly poison! Tell Jesus that he shouldn't have lied about the deadly poison resistance when you get to heaven!

Boötes void

4 months ago

Coming from a Muslim background, I love how this channel comment section is gathering religious and non religious people to debate without any ounce of biggotry or harassment. It proves that most people who tears down another people beliefs are often the ignorant ones. Peace to everyone, whoever and wherever you are!

Thanks for the owner of the channel for his unbiased rigorously selected presentations!

Cesar Sanchez

3 months ago

Cheers 🥂 to that comrade

sapperyor

3 months ago

Those kind of peoplr dont take the time to watch these high quality, long videos with knowledge.

Greek Productions

3 months ago

Im glad someone finally adressed that. Thank you.

Daniel M Connolly

3 months ago

Everyone will stand before God to give account of everything we have ever said and done in our lives.

Let that sink in...

Noah M

3 months ago

@Daniel M Connolly why cant you just post anything that you would say eye to eye to an actual person. nobody other than new york street preachers would say 'You will be judged and go to hell' in ANY conversation. how about you keep it to yourself cause that is the least convincing thing anyone could say, even religious people cringe at the sight of your comment

Rebecca Ringler

3 months ago

I believe we have a creator, source and those who oppose the creator, but we don’t even know our true history because of all the lies.

Noah M

3 months ago

@Señor Sombrero almost sounds like politics, eh

Viktor Ulfrikson

3 months ago

I recall a couple months ago on Twitter there were some atheists blaspheming the Blessed Virgin, and I have never seen Muslims and Catholics more united then when they were ratioing them.

====

Hide 188 replies

Nas PB 1 year ago
great video as always filip. at the end of the day, i think its fair to say that jesus did in fact exist as a person. whatever someone wants to think besides that depends on their own views. quick question, which was the first book of the new testament that mentioned jesus as the son of god or as divine? thanks and have a great day sir. I shall donate to you soon, love your work

10

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago (edited)
@Nas PB Mark, Not just divine, but GOD Himself tbh, in every Gospel, in pauline epistles, and in acts

8

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
Why make a video like this right after your Advaita Vedanta video

1

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini no that’s your opinion

5

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago why couldn't he? It is his channel, and it is an important question for many, as they think he didn't exist, when he did

4

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago I can prove it

4

REPLY

Nasir Khan 1 year ago
Where u guys get the info and find out the info is legit

1

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago Bart Ehrman great scholar, and nt critic, and atheist, also believes that he atleast existed(this is not my proof tho)

5

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini he didn’t explain anything that hasn’t already been discussed

1

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago be more specific, I'm unable to comprehend

1

REPLY

Let's Talk Religion 1 year ago
@Nas PB Thanks! That depends on one's interpretation of the Gospels. As early as the Gospel of Mark (the earliest), he is called the Son of God, for example where God says "you are my beloved son" during the baptism. Where it first states that he is divine is hard to answer, what do we mean by divine? Most of the Gospels seem to imply that he is somehow divine, but not necessarly that he is God Himself. The youngest Gospel of John is the most clear on that stuff. Just in the first lines it claims that Jesus is the Word (logos) and thus a divine pre-creation principle.Read more

10

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion yes, and in mark 6:50, It is I, is actually ego eimi, which is in Greek equivalent of I'm who I Am, God's name, so he claimed ot be the creator

4

REPLY

Nas PB 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion i mean divine in the sense that he is more than just a human. Not necessarily that he's the messiah rather that he is the son of God. I've read that the gospel of John is the first one according to Bart Ehrman and others. Peace

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Dk well that’s total disrespect on his part

REPLY

just a human being.1 year ago
@Tori Santiago why not? it's a channel about religions!

1

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Nas PB do you know that Jews despise jesus right and don’t consider him to be either

2

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago (edited)
@just a human being. no what it is, is total confusion and a meshing of these unique systems. If he’s trying to do this by confirming his positions then that is a weak attempt

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Dk a true historian or scholar doesn’t do that they understand the uniqueness of these religions and traditions

REPLY

Nas PB 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago I'm just asking a question Santiago. It's just interesting to hear when exactly it was mentioned for the first time. That's it. Peace

2

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
What I’m saying is he’s trying to use his video on Advaita Vedanta in trying to support the argument that Jesus was God and that is wrong. In the process disrespecting another tradition.

REPLY

Nas PB 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago who? I'm not doing any such thing and Filip definitely isn't either. Filip is probably the most unbiased youtuber who talks about religion there Is.

1

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Nas PB it’s funny how coincidentally he makes a video about Advaita Vedanta and then right after a video on if jesus existed and discusses the divinity of Jesus. And the other ideas different religious systems have about that. Unbiased maybe, reckless yes

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini “be more specific, I’m unable to comprehend”, well that’s your problem. What I mean is he hasn’t said anything that hasn’t already been said before about jesus

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini and I don’t care if jesus existed or not, or the claims about jesus. Just don’t use another tradition to help confirm your beliefs or position

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@Let's Talk Religion you should’ve at least did a video on the Hare Krishna movement or something Hindu or even Buddhist related. But you wanted to show your biases

REPLY

Haroula Todoulos 1 year ago
I really enjoyed your video (1st timer). Looking forward to further content.

2

Tijan Jeng 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing. Other than whats written on papers, there's no other proof. Is what I get from the video

REPLY

112deeps 1 year ago
Based on the teachings recorded & disciples recorded yes he did exist. His teachings are similar to some of the famous masters from other Religions in east.

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@112deeps no they definitely aren’t

REPLY

Tori Santiago 1 year ago
@112deeps famous masters from other religions in east don’t preach or threaten you with hellfire

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Nas PB i don't agree with him on that, as I said, he has done things only done by God, in the earliest of the Gospels, and I can prove that And also that he is the Messiah and he resurrected

2

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago many did, many didn't, I can prove that he was the Jewish Messiah, Just ask!

2

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago an ignoramus would say so, if he wants he would do that, and this comment shows your biases too, you sound like a bigot tho,there are many channels who makes videos on your interest, find one, don't force him to make videos according to your will, you alone aren't subscribed, others are too, So don't think you control the account

2

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@Tori Santiago I'm adding a new comment in this video, find me there, and have discussion, and we both would learn something new,

2

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@TwoB Btwo thats just non sense to me, Jesus? In Hebrew Yahshua or Yehshua Ha'Masiach or Moshiach Yehshua is a form of Yehoshua, meaning God saves, Moshiach is the Messiah, or the anointed one, So I don't see any problem I didn't get your pointRead more

1

REPLY

Niccolò Paganini 1 year ago
@TwoB Btwo just adding random letters out of no where from English to Hebrew, makes no sense, that's stupid, I know Jesus is the Messiah, but that's no way to prove it, Who uses it? Or supports it? No one with a brain probably

1

REPLY

Dan Zan 1 year ago
Can you do a video on Mullah Sadra?

REPLY

thatdudeforeal 1 year ago
I would like to hear your views on the documentary Caesar’s messiah that posits that it’s all a Flavian creation

REPLY

razor reverent 1 year ago
this channel is bias cant research about muhammed of islam haha

REPLY

Sputnik One 1 year ago
Did Jesus Exist? Yes he is a Mexican who lives in El Paso.

2

REPLY

Cat PBatista 1 year ago
Hi~ could you please, please, please!!! do a video about the three wise men and the implications of the fact that they visited Christ must have brought at the time?? Please!!

1

REPLY

Yogesh Patil 1 year ago
Middle East Book,Story converted all Europian

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
Could you do a video on who wrote the first Gospel, this would assist in determining whether Jesus was the son of god, man, or didn't exist. I have read where some scholars believe Josephus wrote the first (Marks)

REPLY

Raverraver9999 1 year ago
Proof Eucharist is body of Jesus Christ and Virgin Mary is his mother. 48I am the bread of life. 49Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died;z 50this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die. 51I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.”a 52The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us [his] flesh to eat?” 53Jesus said to them, “Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you. 54Whoever eats* my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. 55For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink. 56Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him. 57Just as the living Father sent me and I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on me will have life because of me.b 58This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever.” Eucharistic miracle.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soCkftBBsBo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oogJ-cdi7yI (Rome Reports) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whbzLYi7cyc (Lanciano) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PJ8BORx1p8 Incorruptible bodies of saints due to the Eucharist – only happens in the Catholic church. No other religion has this miracle https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSCk0qs-2-M (Padre Pio) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN4SvtRje2I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TrR1CEWdbc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCDBekAQ-FI (Carlo Acutis) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=33vlkJh2iJc Apparition of Virgin Mary https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQnKS7YUE7Q (Virgin Mary apparition in Ivory Coast) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PPGuMmn6TQ (Virgin Mary statue moving) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tVU8bhbQInw (Virgin Mary apparition in Egypt) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMEWxRB-1dc 1968 Egypt https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YR6INkTK7Q (Miracle of the sun) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yF0_ysUivxE (Miracle of the sun)Read more

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion, please help, why does Christianity saddle itself with the god of the old testament when the God of the new testament seems incongruous with the old god. Indeed the old testament god seems to only love his chosen people and is spiteful, vengeful and murderous in comparison to the God of love and forgiveness for all in the new testament. The God of the new testament does not require animal sacrifice etc.

1

REPLY

Let's Talk Religion 1 year ago
@Damo Sounds like you'll really like Gnosticism.

2

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion Not at all (I had to look up what Gnosticism means), I simply can't relate the God of the new and old testaments. The new testament God is about (to summarize) love one and other as you love yourself. This is in-congruent with the old testament god. I can't imagine the God of the new testament telling Moses to kill every man woman and child, in the holy land, as the holy land is meant for them (paraphrased). I hate the current age of identity politics and intersectionality, however, the old testament god is not inclusive, being the god only of the Jews. I have read and watched some other works on who wrote the first Gospel, one argument put forward and very compelling (to this non practicing catholic but still believer in God) on numerous levels is that Josephus was the author of the first (Mark's) gospel on behalf of the (Flavian) Romans; to quell the Jews who historically spurned accepting the gods of their conquerors and assimilation and were waiting for (and still are) an all conquering messiah. PS. Thanks for replying.Show less

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago
@Let's Talk Religion I would also love if you could explore the Talmud.

1

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion Or you could explore how the roots of the Abrahamic religious beliefs appear to stem form earlier Sumerian , Egyptian etc belief systems, i.e. book of the dead, creation and flood myths etc.

1

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion How about Akhenaten and monotheist beliefs, did the Jews escape captivity or were they forced out of Egypt? The timing of the exodus may also line up with the expulsion of the Hyksos.

REPLY

Damo 1 year ago (edited)
@Let's Talk Religion Lastly (promise), I have also read that "Yahweh" was the original name of a god of the pre-Jewish copper age (or earlier) smelters/metallurgists in the area of current day Israel (Canaanites or others?). Would love your opinion. All the best, and God be with you, to all.

REPLY

Edgar The Atheling 1 year ago
21:16 CORRECTION!!!!!!!!! Iesus is NEVER called SPIRIT OF ALLAH but A SPIRIT FROM ALLAH, CORRECT THIS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 1 year ago
@Let's Talk Religion how do I get ahold of you privately? It could be important.

REPLY

Mitchell C 1 year ago
The gospel is the GOSPEL OF THE KINGDOM! Repent and believe the gospel! Follow Jesus’ teachings! Jesus is going to return and set up the kingdom of God ON THE EARTH! God’s government ON THE EARTH! The Messiah will resurrect his people! The destiny of the Messiah and his people is to be ON THE EARTH! The renewed restored earth! God also dwelling with them! Rev 21 Jesus said the Father is the only true God! John 17 3 And this is eternal life, that they know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom thou hast sent.Show less

2

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 1 year ago
@Mitchell C jesus christ is the psilocybin mushroom. Exodus 16, numbers 11, psalms 78, Deuteronomy 8, Ezekiel 4, john 4:34-38, john 6:51-58, also in jeramiah 10 talks about the amenita muscaria mushroom. It says don't be like the one that cuts down the

tree and decorate it with gold and silver, but the inhabitants of the fortress will pick up the packages from off thy land. The fly agaric is in a symbiotic relationship with the pine tree and grows under it.

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 1 year ago
@Andrew Valladolid jesus christ is the psilocybin mushroom. Exodus 16, numbers 11, psalms 78, Deuteronomy 8, Ezekiel 4, john 4:34-38, john 6:51-58, also in jeramiah 10 talks about the amenita muscaria mushroom. It says don't be like the one that cuts down the

YISHAI ISSACHAR 1 year ago
@Andrew Valladolid I see them

REPLY

Steve Govea 1 year ago
Jesus had high blood pressure.

REPLY

Anas Syazwan Mohd Ghazali 1 year ago
Refer 1:7

REPLY

Adelina Cano 1 year ago
If Jesus was the Messiah, i would not deny this But if James is the family of Jesus it means Jesus is Rome and we don't know what Rome has to do with the Middle East except as invaders please why is there no explanation about this and the real name of Jesus is ishua(arabic) / yishua(aram) / Iesus(rome) / Jesus (united states???)???? secondly, Jesus is not a god of other traditions when talking about other traditions at least you need proof such as an explanation of your own bible we cannot accept an opinion without having a clear basisShow less

1

REPLY

ፕ ኗ 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini the biblical Jesus never existed but there were plenty men named Jesus as it was a common name.

REPLY

ፕ ኗ 1 year ago
@Niccolò Paganini Bart just means there was a man named Jesus as it was a common name.

REPLY

MysteryTuber123 1 year ago
Very informative and unbiased video! Tip: try to read Jesus’ teachings.

REPLY

ፕ ኗ 1 year ago
@MysteryTuber123 no such thing as Jesus teaching the Bible is just a fictional book claiming to be the teaching of Jesus.

REPLY

MysteryTuber123 1 year ago
@ፕ ኗ I’m not talking about the Bible, I’m talking about the Gospel.

REPLY

ፕ ኗ 1 year ago
@MysteryTuber123 the gospel mis the Bible both were made up by man Jesus didnt exist to teach anything.

REPLY

MysteryTuber123 1 year ago
@ፕ ኗ Try to read the Sermon on the Mount. Search for it.

1

REPLY

MysteryTuber123 1 year ago
@AnarchoRepublican If you will follow those teachings, it will change your life. If you love others, then you're born of God,

REPLY

MysteryTuber123 1 year ago
@J M That’s gonna take a long time to answer that, but the best thing to answer your question is getting to know Jesus himself by reading the four Gospels.

REPLY

ፕ ኗ 1 year ago
@J M yeap they even get offended if someone claims that god sacrifice himself to himself. Even though that is what they claim by claiming Jesus nis god.

1

REPLY

Carl Hobson 11 months ago
@Let's Talk Religion jesus is the word meant he brought the word of God, he was the messenger, that's why later he said these aren't my words.

1

REPLY

anonymous johnson 11 months ago
@MysteryTuber123 : You do know that the gospels were not written by those authors, don't you? The catholic church put those names on those documents. Look it up and learn something.

REPLY

anonymous johnson 11 months ago
@Khalon A : A lot of the quran was copied from the bible.

REPLY

Khalon A 11 months ago
@anonymous johnson Also check this man used to be a breacher of Christianity https://youtu.be/cfTBcXaSlbM

REPLY

Ranjit Jayachandran 11 months ago
0

REPLY

Abandoned Void 11 months ago (edited)
This was absolutely irresponsible to post. You don't know anything about the modern historicity debate. You clearly haven't read Dennis R. MacDonald, Richard Carrier, Bart Ehrman, Robert Price, or even Tim o'Neill. This entire video is extremely misinformed and you should do better research in the future. I'm not trying to be mean, but maybe leave history to the actual historians? At least have a bare grip on the topic you present!

2

REPLY

Abandoned Void 11 months ago
You have the wrong Josephus reference, misuse Tacitus, and try to shoehorn the Bible as first-person accounts which no reputable historian does, not even those who argue in support of a historical Jesus. This needed more research and care put it into it before you sent it out to so many people.

1

REPLY

Glenn Rothgeb 10 months ago
@Raverraver9999 Some of your claims have been substantiated but there is also the case of Yogananda who is considered a "modern day miracle." It was witnessed at the Forest Lawn Cemetery where his body was available for followers to see and show last respects.Yogananda was raised in the Hindu tradition as were most. Indians.He was a believer that basically all major religions are paths to the ONE ABSOLUTE GOD.He was beyond sectarian differences and discrediting other religions.He wrote an awesome book called Autobiography of a Yogi in which he mentioned quite a few miraculous people and events.He was a devotee of Jesus Krishna, etc.He was chosen to bring an ancient tradition called Kriya to the west as well as promote religious understanding.He started a fellowship called Self Realization which exists today.He was a true spiritual master in a line of spiritual masters.He gave examples of Catholics, Hidus,etc. who showed miraculous abilities.Many confirmed that his body showed no signs of decomposition for more than 21 days after his passing.His book is a classic and his life is a testimony of spiritual righteousness..Read more

REPLY

Glenn Rothgeb 10 months ago
@Damo Zoroastrianism was the religion of Cyrus the Great.He freed the Jews from captivity in Babylon and soon after financed and helped build the second temple in Jerusalem.Both religions served One God . Zoroastrianism was nearly wiped out by Alexander.It's earliest texts called the Vestas, and Gathas predated the Bible by centuries.It is very obvious how the Old Testament writings were influenced by Cyrus the Great from belief in angels, demons, to heaven, hell and the God Ahura Mazda having an evil adversary responsible for the material world and the sins and wickedness that exists.His name was Ahriman also Ahura Mazda.Zoroastrianism also speaks of an apocalyptic battle and coming of a Messiah after which the righteous destroy Angra Mainyu and his followers.Zoroastrianism was the progenitor to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.They were mostly wiped out by the Moslems when they invaded Persia.Many took refuge in India.Home of the earliest known religion and earliest known texts.The Vedas and Upanishads.They have a history of Ahimsa (non violence)and tolerance towards different religious beliefs.They have the Zoroastrians (now called Farsees) refuge as well as the Jews after Rome destroyed the second temple and later Christians who came to India with St. Thomas.They also give the Buddhists govt. In exile and the Dalai Lama refuge after the invasion of Tibet by China in the 1950's where the got. In exile still resides.Show less

REPLY

Shmuly BeitParzal 10 months ago
Thank you very much for a balanced exploration of the topic. I belong to a Jewish movement that includes the Ebionites. I believe that he was a fully human, Jewish prophet, who was called by God to warn the Jewish people of the coming destruction in the year 70 CE. I believe that he spoke of the Kingdom of God to contrast this with the messianic kingdom of the Zealots. I believe that he felt that the Jewish people could be saved from annihilation by returning to the high ideals of the original Israelite faith ('The old wine is good enough'). A major problem in his ministry was the fact that the Pharisees taught that there were no more prophets. If they had accepted at least the idea of continued prophecy among the Jewish people, then there would have been no need to proclaim him a messiah, but since a messiah was the only type of person that the Pharisees would listen to, I think that the early Jewish followers of Yeshua made the fatal error to make him into a messiah. As a movement, we concentrate on the ethical teachings of Yeshua. If you examine this side of his teachings, they have a very uniform and discernible style, and I think that the person who said those things - whether it was Yeshua or someone else - THAT person existed. Our version of the New Testament - 'The Exhortations' - concentrates on his ethical teachings, rather than on him: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/168907650XShow less

REPLY

Theresa Shuller 10 months ago
Do one on imaginary Muhammed. And the fact that the super rare mentions of "messenger" may even refer to Jesus.

REPLY

B N 10 months ago
I'm Muslim and Yes he (Jesus or Isa) existed, he exist (lives) and will come back to earth again.

1

REPLY

Ford Trucks 10 months ago
I believe he exist Jesus really did exist why ? because he comes to me in my body all the time he's always showing me how to repent and live rightlyRead more

1

REPLY

Inessa Medina 9 months ago
@Orrakl Benedict l

REPLY

Ford Trucks 9 months ago
I don't know either does anyone else know if Jesus really existed plus a lot of history is nothing but FRAUDULENT

1

REPLY

Ford Trucks 9 months ago
I think if he does exist everyone's going to hell when he gets back

REPLY

Ford Trucks 9 months ago
It's very controlling religions and god or gods and devil's and demons

REPLY

Time to Reason 9 months ago
Could you do one on Mohamed; Did Mohamed Exist or perhaps Who was Mohamed as you are very verse in Islam and Islamic history. As far as I know what we know of him are by his own followers/faithfuls. Thanks for this nice video, cheers.

2

REPLY

Steampunkkids 9 months ago
@Let’s Talk Religion I wish you had used charts/ maps/ timelines as Useful Charts did in his discussion. The way you presented the information made your argument more convoluted and less likely to provoke thoughtful discussion. The sources you discussed were weak at best. You didn’t really give much scientific/ archeologic proof to back up your claims. After watching Useful Charts, I had high hopes for you and your channel. I left feeling disappointed and like I had wasted so much time. By the way, Josephus is biased and self-serving. I understand that the church destroyed all other evidence from that time that would go against their beliefs. But, you should have discussed this in much more detail as well as how untrustworthy a source he was. Come on, man, do better.Read more

2

REPLY

lulu branch 9 months ago
Thanks a lot for your information,so interesting to wach6

REPLY

thewhitemustang 9 months ago
The background music is distracting and unnecessary.

REPLY

Add1son 9 months ago
exactly my mindset

REPLY

Add1son 9 months ago
@Je-Free Norman sry i think i replyed to the wrong comment

REPLY

1982 man 8 months ago
Close in time? My father and I where discussing a trip 20 years ago he said that we went to a museum, however I stated that we didn't because it was closed. Thankfully I took pictures of all the tourist sites. If I didn't we would never of closed the mystery and debate. My point is that history can be filled with inaccuracies when recalling something years or decades later.

REPLY

Fidde Lozza 8 months ago
Who anointed Jesus? Acts 4: On hearing this, Peter and John raised their voices with one accord to God and said: 26 The kings of the earth took their stand and the rulers gathered together as one against JEHOVAH and against HIS ANOINTED ONE. 27 For truly both Herod and Pontius Pilate with men of the nations and with peoples of Israel were gathered together in this city against YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS, 'WHOM YOU ANOINTED', 30 while you stretch out your hand for healing and while signs and wonders occur THROUGH THE NAME OF YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS.Show less

REPLY

K 8 months ago
You do good work...just not in this video. Shameful. The gospels are not evidence nor is “the opinion of historians” many if not all of whom are staunch Christians, and thus, incredibly biased. Also if you spent any time in higher academia/science you would know that consensus is the norm, not an aberration. Academics are followers and go where the citation count/prestige leads them, not Truth.

REPLY

marta guzman 8 months ago
Peter and John prayed to Jehovah The Father about the son of God saying your Holy Servant Jesus whom you anointed. (Acts 4: On hearing this, Peter and John raised their voices with one accord to God and said: 26 The kings of the earth took their stand and the rulers gathered together as one against JEHOVAH and against HIS ANOINTED ONE. 27 For truly both Herod and Pontius Pilate with men of the nations and with peoples of Israel were gathered together in this city against YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS, 'WHOM YOU ANOINTED', 30 while you stretch out your hand for healing and while signs and wonders occur THROUGH THE NAME OF YOUR HOLY SERVANT JESUS.)Show less

1

REPLY

Joseph George 8 months ago
Judas turned on him I wonder why did he realize the the guy was a fake

REPLY

Marwa Houda 8 months ago
@Nasir Khan

K 7 months ago
@xi li I agree

REPLY

Tamara 7 months ago
@Damo what do you mean the God in new and Old testament? There's only one God in both

1

REPLY

Tamara 7 months ago (edited)
@Khalon A my friend the Quran has been changed, and have Arabic mistakes. You don't have the Quran during the time of Muhammad. You only have recitation according this and that. You have Hafs Qur'an, y'all Muslims call a liar. The word Qur'an it's not even Arabic

REPLY

Mike S 7 months ago
Why don't you link ot the other videos?

REPLY

Krishnan B.S.7 months ago
@Nas PB I have seen only the existence of lord Ram Questioned Nobody else. This is done because Our beliefs and traditions have always been abused and ridiculed with no retaliation. We know what happened in Paris Belgium on those who didn't even question but just spoke about the prophet. Beheadings are not done in our faith that's why people have the Guts to do these things.

REPLY

Krishnan B.S.7 months ago
@Tori Santiago Did you Question him on his questioning the Vedanta which all the Hindus Believe and revere. There are some Brutus's who operate among the Hindu Faith as well.

REPLY

Mayank Bisht 7 months ago
Wait which sect of Hindus believe Jesus is Vishnu's Avatar

REPLY

Àngèlo Èlk 7 months ago
@Let's Talk Religion are you a Muslim brother?

REPLY

Erdood 6 months ago
is Jesus himself really that important? I'd argue that it's the Christians that came after him that did most of the legwork in making him and his teachings (which were mostly not original ideas, but stuff from Judaism, hell, for the first centuries of it's existence, scholars can't meaningfully separate belief in Jesus from Judaism. it became separate when Christians influencers went on an antisemitic spree, and wanted and did de-Jewify their religion, by cutting down on demands present in Judaism. they said that followers of Jesus don't need to keep kashrut)Show less

REPLY

Paul Northam 6 months ago
Thank you LTR! I think this is a very fair treatment of the data. What interests me about the 'Jesus Movement' are the traditions and rituals of worship that grew up after his death, many of which are based on his commandments found in scripture. Such as the Sunday breaking of bread, baptism, plus care of the poor, evangelisation etc. There were certainly things in the teaching of Christ that appear to be more central than others, and which the early community followed from very early on.Read more

1

REPLY

Ken Smith 6 months ago
If the Gospels were written as late as you claim, how come they don’t mention the destruction of Jerusalem in 70ad? Or the death of Peter or James directly?

2

REPLY

01 with 30% less Asbestos 5 months ago
I like how our calendar is based around his birth, but we were off by four years.

REPLY

Ken Smith 5 months ago
@01 with 30% less Asbestos : Unfortunately, the keeping of historical time back then was not as stringent as today, However despite the discrepancy,the date decided upon did finally anchor the chronicling of historical time for the past two thousand years.

REPLY

Laurence Abuzo 5 months ago
This hash x2 commentary is full of holes.

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
I have a problem with the Flavius Josephus account as a reliable source on the Jesus topic. He was borne 37 CE, how on earth could he be a witness to the Jesus character. He was a military commander of Galilee during the Judaeans revolting against Rome. 66–70 CE. After this he moved to Rome and became a writer under imperial patronage. When did he wrote his Jesus history and where did he get his information at least 50 years after the event? We have different opinions on reliable material.Show less

1

REPLY

Ken Smith 5 months ago
@Willie Van Straaten : First, off he was Jewish himself and as a kid I’m sure he heard from the people around him all of what Jesus had done. Secondly he mentioned about twenty other people from the New Testament including John, Jesus’ brother, John the Baptist, Herod, Herod Antipas, Pontius Pilate, Felix, Ciaphas the high priest etc And yet no one questions him on these people. I even heard the Jews themselves refer to him to fill out their historyShow less

REPLY

01 with 30% less Asbestos 5 months ago
@Willie Van Straaten Josephus was a historian?

1

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@01 with 30% less Asbestos 01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?” So what? Where and how did he get his information 40 : 60 years after the event? So, you imply that all historians are always correct just because they are called historians.

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?” Yes, and not all history is a factual reality. Legendary stories do have the tendency of developing fascinating results introduced by different storytellers (historians). History is not just what really happened in the past, but a complex intersection of truths, bias and hopes and recording hearsay without any verification. History encompasses at least three different ways of accessing the past: it can be remembered or recovered or even invented. All are imperfect in some way. The more it is based on hearsay and retelling the more it gets distorted. Josephus recorded 40 : 60 years after the event? How do you think the Bible got into existence? Scribes, (historians) with info gathered from folklore, traditional stories and myths. How reliable are the information and events described in the Bible?Show less

1

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@01 with 30% less Asbestos 01 The History Guy: “Josephus was a historian?” Yes, and not all history is factual reality. Legendary stories do have the tendency of developing fascinating results introduced by different storytellers (historians). History is not just what really happened in the past, but a complex intersection of truths, bias and hopes and recording hearsay without any verification. History encompasses at least three different ways of accessing the past: it can be remembered or recovered or even invented. All are imperfect in some way. The more it is based on hearsay and retelling the more it gets distorted. Josephus recorded 40 : 60 years after the event? How do you think the Bible got into existence? Scribes, (historians) with info gathered from folklore, traditional stories and myths. How reliable is the information and events described in the Bible?Show less

REPLY

Ken Smith 5 months ago
@Willie Van Straaten : Legend I’m told usually develops about a hundred years, however, in the case of Josephus he was born very close to the event and as a Jew would have no motivation to promote a supposed Christian “myth”

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@Ken Smith Ken Smith: “and as a Jew would have no motivation to promote a supposed Christian “myth” Your second comment. As far as my view is concerned, I responded on your first and have nothing to add on this comment.

1

REPLY

jayonnaj18 5 months ago
Yes, Jesus existed, and HE STILL DOES!!! He is coming back to this earth one day and redeem it!!!

2

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@jayonnaj18 jayonnaj18: “Yes, Jesus existed, and HE STILL DOES!!! I understand that you believe this through indoctrination but how do you know for sure that he was the son of god borne by a virgin. What proof or evidence can you present. What evidence is there that god his father is real and not ancient myth. jayonnaj18: “He is coming back to this earth one day and redeem it!!!” What do you mean by 'redeem'?Show less

1

REPLY

John Doe 5 months ago
Why did you use the talmud as a non-biblical reference to jesus?

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@John Doe The Talmudic stories make fun of Jesus' birth from a virgin, fervently contest his claim to be the Messiah and Son of God, and maintain that he was rightfully executed as a blasphemer and idolater.

REPLY

Willie Van Straaten 5 months ago
@John Doe John Doe, I don’t get your point or dispute. There are 147 comments under this initial comment by “ Let's Talk Religion” I might have made one or several. Please be clear what you are talking about.

1

REPLY

S33N3R 626 5 months ago
Maybe Jesus did exist and ate mushrooms

1

REPLY

Joshua Bacon 5 months ago
YHWH is the Heavenly Father the Creator the Father of the Messiah YHSWH HaMashiach aka Jesus aka Joshua

REPLY

mjfleming319 4 months ago
All the ancient writers - most notably Augustine - agreed that Matthew was the first gospel written, probably in Aramaic. I’m curious about why videos such as this accept the modern theory of Markan priority, which is based layers on highly speculative “textual criticism”. According to the guidelines set forth at the beginning of the video, the ancient writers, being over a thousand years closer to the facts and in possession of even earlier texts, would be more reliable than the speculative modern scholars. Or am I missing something?Show less

1

REPLY

Tim Rickard 4 months ago
I think it should be pointed out that the passages used to add evidence of Jesus were not written by Flavium Josephus but we're latter altered by the Christian Church. It is has been established that these passages, whilst convincing as an independent source if accurate, are in fact false.

REPLY

Ali Baba Heru 4 months ago
@Niccolò Paganini Nupuqi Om-Re Khonectics chamber degrees will guide you

1

REPLY

Komitas Komitas 4 months ago
It’s interesting that author been so knowledgeable about subject, he mentioned Armenia and Arameans.. He talks about jews and Romans and totally ignored Armenian sources. It’ll be more professional if you talk about Armenia because Armenia was the first country in the world to adopt Christianity as a state religion in 301 A.D. Christianity has played an immensely important role in the shaping of the Armenian people for over 1,700 years. Religion has been an essential part of Armenian identity and has reshaped the course of history. Just FYIRead more

1

REPLY

【vivek】4 months ago
Can anybody help me with what's the background ambient music used in this video

1

REPLY

Jesilea 4 months ago
I stumbled on these three videos while going down YouTube rabbit holes, and I thoroughly enjoyed them. Thank you to all of you for taking the time to dive into these historical figures.

1

REPLY

Lucas O'heyze 4 months ago
Why are you in this video, are you so desperate for attention?

1

REPLY

Let's Talk Religion 4 months ago
@Lucas O'heyze Yes

1

REPLY

Caleb Berman 2 months ago
Everyone reading this, I want to tell you that Jesus Christ isn't just real, but that he's God and the Son of God, and that 2,000 years ago, Jesus Christ died on the cross for you to be saved. God sent his Son to pay the price for your sins, and he loves you very much. The Bible also says that if you confess that Jesus Christ is Lord and believe in your heart that God has raised him from the dead, you'll be saved. God bless you all! He loves you all so very much.

1

REPLY

James Stevenson 2 months ago
Judaism began 500ad. Jesus was no Jew

1

REPLY

Say What ?2 months ago
Hinduism claiming Jesus is bullshit , some gurus claim corona is form of God , it's mess in here.TBH Don't count their Claims. It's Sick.

1

REPLY

Xaviar 77versus99 2 months ago
@YISHAI ISSACHAR you have to eat it

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 2 months ago
@Xaviar 77versus99 first you dry the amanita muscaria to reduce ibotenic acid

1

REPLY

Xaviar 77versus99 2 months ago
@YISHAI ISSACHAR blue Meanies ya know

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 2 months ago
@Xaviar 77versus99 those you can eat fresh LOL

1

REPLY

Xaviar 77versus99 2 months ago
@YISHAI ISSACHAR never ever have I tried the amanita

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 2 months ago (edited)
@Xaviar 77versus99 I have once when I was 16. but, I ate half of a fresh one with an LSD sugar cube. Not sure if I had effects from the amanita if it did anything. But, I was on a beach, full moon, fast moving cloud and waves rolling in, lake Huron in Michigan. It was pretty powerful. But, I would dry the amanita if it were today. Dry them and make tea. Its recommended, otherwise can be toxic.

1

REPLY

Dmp -1 month ago
Christianity can be religion but true Relationship is with Jesus apart from religion. Religious Followers if YHWH even killed Jesus. Religion doesn’t bear fruit but a relationship does. God is for unity and religion is man made; but God isn’t and neither His word and His relationships

️

1

REPLY

YISHAI ISSACHAR 1 month ago
WARES=

= UNDER THE

AMENITA

Jeremiah 10:2-4 KJV — Thus saith the LORD, Learn not the way of the heathen, and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven; for the heathen are dismayed at them. For the customs of the people are vain: for one cutteth a tree out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe. They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and with hammers, that it move not. Jeremiah 10:15-17 KJV — They are vanity, and the work of errors: in the time of their visitation they shall perish. The portion of Jacob is not like them: for he is the former of all things; and Israel is the rod of his inheritance: The LORD of hosts is his name. Gather up thy wares out of the land, O inhabitant of the fortress.

Show less

1

REPLY

Sonja Petrovic 1 month ago
@letstalkreligion - Actually there is an archeological video on Timeline: "Could This Be the Real Tomb of Jesus" - on You Tube that found His family's tomb that held the ossuaries, or "bone boxes" of His family! Check it out..

And, if He was in fact God incarnate, He cannot be described, or defined! He just was, is & will always be the divine Messiah!

Show less

REPLY

Reinier Verly 1 month ago
There is a major lack in understanding and reading the original texts and religion traditions. First the Romans were horribly bureaucratic, if Jesus or any one comparable to him would have lived, you would find writings about him because he would have been seen as a dangerous rebel. Second for Jews than and until now aswell for the Romans death is and was unclean and never ever would someone be buried within the city walls. Executing any one was never done inside the city either, no it was done at the entrance of the city as a possible repellent. Remember Nero's burning crosses with executed people on it on the main way to Rome.Show less

REPLY

David Keith 1 month ago
Thank you for yr comment. I was just about to suggest to you that Jesus's teachings seem to be far closer to Hinduism than Judaism Islam or even christianity itself. Christianity because they have made a man their god instead of his message

REPLY

David Keith 1 month ago
@Myth Buster I agree

REPLY

David Keith 4 weeks ago
@Watchmen of Truth it is very sad initially to find this out as because as a child you get loyal to Jesus as you do father Xmas. But when you consider the magic that Jesus did bringing people back from the dead, giving sight to the blind as miracles I started to question about creating a real live bird out of clay and decided that was the work of a magician. So now I only pray directly to God.

REPLY

Ancient Ruins 2 weeks ago
Lets Talk Religion - Why JESUS and you may say why not. JESUS firstly wasnt the name where so called Christians jump around the or shall i say part of the world. As per many records which is mainly from Romans, there was no Jesus or son of god as he supposedly was a criminal. We do the same today to any extremists.

REPLY

Myth Buster 4 days ago
@BDHN Network "DELUSIONAL DISORDER, previously called paranoid disorder, is a type of serious mental illness called a psychotic disorder. People who have it can’t tell what’s real from what is imagined." Schizophrenia Guide, WebMD

REPLY

Myth Buster 4 days ago
@BDHN Network Delusion: “A delusion is a belief that is obviously false, and yet the individual experiencing it thinks it is absolutely true. A delusion is not a belief that is false because of a person’s intelligence, education, culture, religion, or other similar factor; instead, it is false because it of some abnormality in the individual’s thinking. That person will firmly believe in the delusion even when repeatedly shown evidence to the contrary.” - BrightQuest Treatment Centers.Show less

REPLY

Paul 2 days ago
I cant wait to give Jesus a hug.

REPLY

Myth Buster 2 days ago
@Paul You can give him a hug today! "And these signs will accompany those who believe...when they drink deadly poison, it will not hurt them at all" (Mark 16:17-18). Go ahead! Post a video showing you drinking deadly poison! Tell Jesus that he shouldn't have lied about the deadly poison resistance when you get to heaven!

REPLY

Boötes void 4 months ago
Coming from a Muslim background, I love how this channel comment section is gathering religious and non religious people to debate without any ounce of biggotry or harassment. It proves that most people who tears down another people beliefs are often the ignorant ones. Peace to everyone, whoever and wherever you are! Thanks for the owner of the channel for his unbiased rigorously selected presentations!

1K

REPLY

Hide 56 replies

Cesar Sanchez 3 months ago
Cheers

to that comrade

30

REPLY

sapperyor 3 months ago
Those kind of peoplr dont take the time to watch these high quality, long videos with knowledge.

24

REPLY

Greek Productions 3 months ago
Im glad someone finally adressed that. Thank you.

22

REPLY

Daniel M Connolly 3 months ago
Everyone will stand before God to give account of everything we have ever said and done in our lives. Let that sink in...

3

REPLY

Noah M 3 months ago
@Daniel M Connolly why cant you just post anything that you would say eye to eye to an actual person. nobody other than new york street preachers would say 'You will be judged and go to hell' in ANY conversation. how about you keep it to yourself cause that is the least convincing thing anyone could say, even religious people cringe at the sight of your comment

22

REPLY

Rebecca Ringler 3 months ago
I believe we have a creator, source and those who oppose the creator, but we don’t even know our true history because of all the lies.

14

REPLY

Noah M 3 months ago
@Señor Sombrero almost sounds like politics, eh

4

REPLY

Viktor Ulfrikson 3 months ago
I recall a couple months ago on Twitter there were some atheists blaspheming the Blessed Virgin, and I have never seen Muslims and Catholics more united then when they were ratioing them.