Christianity Made in Japan A Study of Indigenous Movements
Mark R. Mullins
Contents
Preface vii
Ch 1 Christianity as World Religion and Vernacular Movement
- Sociological Considerations
- The Japanese Context
- Approaching Indigenous Christian Movements
Ch 2 The Social Sources of Christianity in Japan
- From Roman Catholic to Protestant Mission Churches
- From Transdenominational Cooperation to Denominational Mission Churches
- Christianity As a Lay Movement: The Sapporo and Kumamoto Bands
- The Development and Growth of the Mission Churches
- Transplanted Churches under Japanese Civil Religion
- The Postwar Period
- From Transplanted Churches to Indigenous Movements
- ChurchSect Theory and the Study of Indigenization
Ch 3 Charisma, Minor Founders, and Indigenous Movements
- The Social Background of the Indigenous Movements
- The Enabling Factor: Imported and Native Elements
- Minor Founders, Innovation, and Charismatic Authority
- The Reappearance of Charismatic Christianity
Ch 4 The Fountainhead of Japanese Christianity Revisited
- Uchimura Kanzo * and the Nonchurch Movement
- Western Traditions and the Bible in Uchimura's Christianity
- Christianity as a Japanese Religion
- Conclusion
Ch 5 Christianity As a Path of Self Cultivation
- Matsumura Kaiseki and The Way
- Kawai Shinsui and Christ Heart Church
- Some Comparative Observations
Ch 6 Japanese Versions of Apostolic Christianity
- Murai Jun and the Spirit of Jesus Church
- Otsuki* Takeji and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus
- Teshima Ikuro* and the Original Gospel Movement
- Conclusion
-
Ch 7 Japanese Christians and the World of the Dead
- The Place of Ancestors and Spirit Belief in Japanese Culture
- Protestant Missionary Theology and the Ancestors
- Memorialism in Indigenous Christianity
- Reading the Bible with Japanese Eyes
- Care for the Dead in the Spirit of Jesus Church
- The Japanese Christian Response to Indigenous Spirit Beliefs
- Conclusion
Ch 8 Comparative Patterns of Growth and Decline
- The Sociology of Transplanted Churches
- Indigenization: A CureAll?
- The Dilemmas of Christianity in Japan
- Intersocietal Relations: The Neglected Dimension
- The Transplantation of Korean Christianity to Japan
- The Shamanization of Korean Christianity
- The Expansion of Korean Pentecostalism to Japan
- Healing Services and Testimonials in the Japan Grace Academy
- The Future of Korean Pentecostalism in Japan
Ch 9 The Broader Context of Japanese Christianity
- The "Ways" of Japanese Christianity
- Charisma and Leadership Succession
- Alternative Patterns of Appropriation
- The Global Context
Appendix: Bibliographical Guide to Indigenous Christian Movements 201
- Notes 217
- General Bibliography 261
- Acknowledgments 266
- Index 267
=====
====
Christianity Made in Japan
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
Hayashi Makoto
Aichi Gakuin University
James W. Heisig
Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture
Thomas Kasulis
Ohio State University
Robert Kisala
Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture
Paul L. Swanson
Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture
Watanabe Manabu
Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture
James W. Heisig & John Maraldo, editors, Rude Awakenings: Zen, the Kyoto School, & the Question of Nationalism (1995)
Jamie Hubbard & Paul L. Swanson, editors, Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm over Critical Buddhism (1997)
Mark R. Mullins, Christianity Made in Japan: A Study of Indigenous Movements (1998)
Christianity Made in Japan
A Study of Indigenous Movements
Mark R. Mullins
Copyright © 1998 University of Hawai'i Press
All rights reserved
Printed in the United States of America
03 02 01 00 99 98 5 4 3 2 1
Library of Congress CataloginginPublication Data
Mullins, Mark.
Christianity made in Japan : a study of indigenous movements / Mark. R. Mullins.
p. cm. — (Nanzan library of Asian religion and culture) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0824821149 (alk. paper).
ISBN 0824821327 (pbk.: alk. paper)
1. Christian sects—Japan. 2. Japan—Church history.
3. Christianity and culture—Japan. I. Title. II. Series.
BR1307.M85 1998
275.2—dc21 9835083 CIP
Cameraready copy for this book was prepared by the Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture.
University of Hawai'i Press books are printed on acidfree paper and meet the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Council on Library Resources.
Contents
Preface vii
1 1
Christianity as World Religion and Vernacular Movement
Sociological Considerations
The Japanese Context
Approaching Indigenous Christian Movements
2 11
The Social Sources of Christianity in Japan
From Roman Catholic to Protestant Mission Churches
From Transdenominational Cooperation to Denominational Mission
Churches
Christianity As a Lay Movement: The Sapporo and Kumamoto Bands
The Development and Growth of the Mission Churches
Transplanted Churches under Japanese Civil Religion
The Postwar Period
From Transplanted Churches to Indigenous Movements
ChurchSect Theory and the Study of Indigenization
3 31
Charisma, Minor Founders, and Indigenous Movements
The Social Background of the Indigenous Movements
The Enabling Factor: Imported and Native Elements
Minor Founders, Innovation, and Charismatic Authority
The Reappearance of Charismatic Christianity
4 54
The Fountainhead of Japanese Christianity Revisited
Uchimura Kanzo * and the Nonchurch Movement
Western Traditions and the Bible in Uchimura's Christianity
Christianity as a Japanese Religion
Conclusion
5 68
Christianity As a Path of SelfCultivation
Matsumura Kaiseki and The Way
Kawai Shinsui and Christ Heart Church
Some Comparative Observations
6 95
Japanese Versions of Apostolic Christianity
Murai Jun and the Spirit of Jesus Church
Otsuki* Takeji and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus
Teshima Ikuro* and the Original Gospel Movement
Conclusion
7 129
Japanese Christians and the World of the Dead
The Place of Ancestors and Spirit Belief in Japanese Culture
Protestant Missionary Theology and the Ancestors
Memorialism in Indigenous Christianity
Reading the Bible with Japanese Eyes
Care for the Dead in the Spirit of Jesus Church
The Japanese Christian Response to Indigenous Spirit Beliefs
Conclusion
8 156
Comparative Patterns of Growth and Decline
The Sociology of Transplanted Churches
Indigenization: A CureAll?
The Dilemmas of Christianity in Japan
Intersocietal Relations: The Neglected Dimension
The Transplantation of Korean Christianity to Japan
The Shamanization of Korean Christianity
The Expansion of Korean Pentecostalism to Japan
Healing Services and Testimonials in the Japan Grace Academy
The Future of Korean Pentecostalism in Japan
9 183
The Broader Context of Japanese Christianity
The "Ways" of Japanese Christianity
Charisma and Leadership Succession
Alternative Patterns of Appropriation
The Global Context
Appendix: Bibliographical Guide to Indigenous Christian Movements 201
Notes 217
General Bibliography 261
Acknowledgments 266
Index 267
Preface
There is in Japan another Christianity than the familiar array of churches left behind by missionaries from the West, one virtually unknown abroad and as yet largely neglected by scholars of religion. It is the Christianity of indigenous movements established in a direct act of resistance to the failure of imported varieties of Christianity to reach deeply into the Japanese soul. This is a book about those movements: where they came from and how they developed.
Contrary to what one might at first expect, resources concerning Japan's indigenous Christian movements are plentiful, but since most of these groups publish their own materials and distribute them privately for use by the faithful, the literature rarely attracts the attention of those outside their own circles. From the time I began my visits to different movements, I was amazed—not to say in some cases dismayed by the work that lay in store—to discover that the collected works of individual founders alone typically ran to ten or twenty volumes, in addition to which most of the movements publish their own magazines and journals. As obscure and arcane as much of the material is, in sheer volume it is an embarrassment of riches.
Extensive contact with members of these movements, their leaders, and in some cases even their founders, has provided a healthy counterbalance to the written resources. My observation and interviews were by and large concentrated in the Kanto * and Kansai areas of Japan's main island, where movement headquarters or larger churches tend to be located, but my fieldwork also took me on occasion to the islands of Shikoku, Kyushu*, and Okinawa, and to as far north as Sendai. Over the years I have participated in a wide range of religious services, from subdued memorial services for the dead to emotional revival meetings and charismatic healing services. I have sat with believers to study the Confucian classics following Sunday worship services, received training in meditation in summer seminars, and even celebrated a Friday evening sabbath meal with Japanese Christian Zionists singing in Hebrew in an isolated monastic retreat in the mountains outside of Kyoto. One particular group even made it their special mission to teach me how to speak in tongues. (To their collective disappointment, I turned out to be a slow learner.)
Needless to say, a project of this kind relies from start to finish on the cooperation of many people, and I count myself fortunate to have received so much kindness from so many. Religious leaders regularly opened their archives
to my curious eyes and arranged for me to attend services and conduct interviews around the country. I cannot begin to record the names of all the individuals who welcomed me into their homes and churches, and who responded so patiently to my academic prying. The warm hospitality they showed through so many hours of conversation was a constant encouragement. At the same time, I suppose that not a few of those who thus shared in this study must be wondering about now what has happened to all the notes I was scribbling and all the experiences I had in their midst. I would like to say that this book is the answer, but the fact is, I have had to leave out far more than I have been able to put in in order to attempt a coherent interpretation of a dozen different movements. Each of them deserves an indepth treatment of its own, and I trust that this labor lies in the near future of some other scholars. Meantime, I must content myself with scratching the surface of this unexplored world so as to focus on a broader perspective for placing these experiments in indigenous Christianity within the religious history of Japan.
The project has not been without its share of personal challenges. Like anyone who is a committed member of a church that has transplanted itself in Japan, the scholar's objectivity often proves thin armor against the sharp and often telling criticisms of Western Christianity put forward by leaders of indigenous movements. If my remarks ring defensive at times, I can only beg the reader to pass them over indulgently. My greater intention is to allow these Japanese Christians to speak their own minds in these pages.
In redirecting scholarly attention away from the study of Western missionary Christianity and its problems with selfinculturation to the indigenous and independent expressions of Christianity, I mean to do more than describe these minority movements as a socioreligious phenomenon peculiar to modern Japan. If it is not too wishful to think so, I would like this study to be seen as a small contribution to the shift from perceiving Christianity as a "Western" religion to imagining its unfulfilled possibilities as a truly "world" religion.
Many of the chapters of this book were presented in raw form to different audiences whose input has been invaluable. In particular, I would like to express
appreciation to colleagues who responded to me at academic conferences: the Association for the Sociology of Religion (1988), the Canadian Society for the Study of Religion (1990), the Society for the Scientific Study of Religion (1990, 1991, 1992), the International Sociological Association (1994), and the Religious Research
Association (1995, 1996). I was also privileged to make presentations of some of this material at the University of Calgary Institute for the Humanities Conference,
"Global Culture: Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements
Worldwide" (1991), the St. Mary's College (London, England) Conference on "Japanese Culture: Christian Contributions" (September 1991), the Meiji Gakuin
University's Institute for Christian Studies Conference on "Christianity in East Asia" (1993), the University of Stirling's Scottish Centre for Japanese Studies' Japan Seminar Series (1997), and the Centre for the Study of Christianity in the NonWestern World, New College, University of Edinburgh (1997). Here in Japan,
Professor Yuki Hideo and Dr. Martin Repp were kind enough to offer me the opportunity of summarizing my findings to the 20th Annual Seminar on Japanese Religions sponsored by the NCC Center for the Study of Japanese Religions in Kyoto (September 1997). Although a number of these presentations were subsequently published as journal articles or as chapters in several books (for details of which, see the concluding Acknowledgments), everything has been thoroughly reworked for this volume.
The scholars and friends whose ideas have stimulated and shaped my research over the past decade are too many to mention, but I would like to single out for special thanks Araya Shigehiko (Seikei University), Shimazono Susumu (University of Tokyo), Ikegami Yoshimasa (Tsukuba University), Inoue Nobutaka (Kokugakuin University), Ian Reader (Scottish Centre for Japanese Studies, University of Stirling), Anthony Blasi (Tennessee State University), Thomas Hastings (Tokyo Union
Theological Seminary), and Kayama Hisao, Richard Young, and Kuyama Michihiko (all colleagues at Meiji Gakuin University). Shortly after I returned to Japan in 1985, I had the good fortune of coming to know David Reid and David Swain, two veteran translators and editors (of the Japanese Journal of Religious Studies and the Japan Christian Quarterly, respectively). Their careful scholarship and scrupulous attention to detail left me with high standards for work in this field, and their friendship has given me encouragement on more occasions than I can count. During what often seemed an interminable project Joseph and Yuki Dunkle were a constant source of consolation and reinforcement, which I shall always remember as a special grace.
A sabbatical leave from Meiji Gakuin University from April 1996 to March 1997 enabled me to engage in several months of concentrated field research around Japan and to spend eight months as a visiting research fellow at the University of Edinburgh's Centre for the Study of Christianity in the NonWestern World in the Faculty of Divinity. I thank Professors Andrew Walls and David Kerr for arranging this enriching association. The Centre provided a stimulating environment for my work and I am grateful to the faculty and staff for their kind hospitality and for several opportunities to make presentations regarding my research.
Over the years, I have had a number of opportunities to work with the members of the Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture on various projects. It is always reassuring to have such a capable team of editors, translators, and writers watching over your manuscript before publication. Without the help of Jim Heisig, Paul Swanson, Bob Kisala, Tom Kirchner, Ed Skrzypczak, and Clark Chilson, this would be a different book and probably still a long ways from seeing publication. I am proud to have my work listed as a title in the Nanzan Library of Asian Religion and Culture, and am grateful to Pat Crosby and the editors at the University of Hawai'i Press for their interest in the project.
Funding for research leading to this publication was provided by the Research Enablement Program, a grant program for mission scholarship supported by the Pew Charitable Trusts, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S.A., and administered by the Overseas Ministries Study Center, New Haven, Connecticut, U.S.A.
Like just about everything else I have written over the past two decades, a large share of the credit goes to my wife, Cindy. Ever a willing companion for my trips and a ready ear to my tales from the field, she is also a professional editor whose touch is everywhere in evidence to me. I dedicate these pages to her and to our two daughters, Sara Rachel and Megumi Catherine, with whom we make our life in Japan.
TOKYO, JAPAN 1 JUNE 1998
Chapter One—Christianity As World Religion and Vernacular Movement
In this book I am concerned with what happens to a world religion when it is transplanted from one culture to another. By ''world religion" I mean those missionizing religions of the world, such as Buddhism, Christianity, and Islam, that regard their religious teachings to be "truths" of ultimate significance for people of all times and places (truths, in other words, that transcend the boundaries of tribe, clan, and nation). For most of my adult life I have had a keen interest in the crosscultural diffusion of these world religions. My interest is undoubtedly related to the fact that when I was still quite young my parents transplanted me—along with the gospel— to Japan. What was at one time no more than a vague, subconscious attempt to make sense of my crosscultural childhood experiences and sense of marginality has evolved into my vocation.
It is no accident, therefore, that my studies in this field have focused on the twoway religious traffic between Japan and North America. Two decades ago I began by considering the transmission of Japanese Buddhism to North America, first through a study of Zen Buddhism and the counterculture movement of the 1960s and 1970s. This initial exploration prompted me to consider the transplantation of Pure Land Buddhism (Jodo * Shinshu*), a tradition that accompanied Japanese immigrants to the United States and Canada during the past century. Since returning to Japan over a decade ago I have been studying various aspects of the transmission of Western Christianity and its encounter with Asian religion and culture. Just as the transplanters of Japanese Buddhist traditions have experienced considerable difficulty in adapting an essentially family based religious tradition to the individualistic religious culture of North America, Christian missionaries to Japan have discovered that their message regarding faith and practice is difficult for most Japanese to accept or, perhaps, even to understand. Some of the "natives" in both cultures are currently engaged in the reinterpretation of these transplanted religious traditions. It is this process of appropriation—of making something foreign one's own—that I am concerned with in this study of Japanese Christianity.
Scholars have recently referred to these universalistic world religions as global cultures, drawing attention to the dialectic between the "universal" and "particular" in the process of crosscultural transmission. Irving Hexham and Karla Poewe, for example, explain that
a global culture is a tradition that travels the world and takes on local color. It has both a global, or metacultural, and a local, or situationally distinct, cultural dimension. As global cultures, the aim of universalistic world religions has been to spread a religious metaculture that was perfectly capable of remaining identifiable while being absorbed by local cultures.1
While it is often quite difficult to distinguish or disentangle the "metaculture" (universal elements) from the local variations or indigenous forms, these plural cultural expressions can be designated as part of a larger world religion because one can identify "striking continuities over time and space."2 These "continuities," of course, are based on the fact that specific sacred texts (the Bible, Koran, or Tripitaka) record the central experiences and revelatory events that represent salvation for humankind. In the case of Christianity, Andrew Walls suggests that it is possible to identify such common features, as "continuity of thought about the final significance of Jesus, continuity of a certain consciousness about history, continuity in the use of Scriptures, of bread and wine,
of water." 3 The fact that Christians often disagree about the significance and interpretation of these features need not concern us here.
While the category "world religion" is useful for referring to various religious traditions that share certain common features, it must be recognized that it only represents an ideal or abstraction. Religion only exists in the vernacular, or, to adapt a biblical phrase, the "treasure" only exists in "earthen vessels" (2 Corinthians 4:7). There is no such thing as a "pure" transcultural expression of Christianity or any other world religion—there are only particular cultural manifestations. Wendy James and
Douglas Johnson accurately point out that
Christian identity, as a confession of faith, does not bring with it or produce cultural and social uniformity; but because, as a personal experience, it inevitably goes with a characteristic sense of particular place or time, the theme of personal religious identity cannot be separated from that vernacular context. In this sense, every Christian is a native.4
Standing in the shadow of magnificent European cathedrals and churches, we find it easy to forget that Christianity was at one time a foreign religion on Western soil. Christianity began as a new religious movement, initially confined to the social world of Palestinian Judaism. Jesus of Nazareth was understood by his first followers in terms of the rather "particular" Jewish categories of rabbi and messiah. As this movement expanded out of Palestine into the larger Roman world, Gentile followers of "the way" came to confess this Jewish messiah as the divine Lord and Savior of humankind. The process of "deJudaization" began as these new Christians were allowed to practice the faith without complete observance of traditional Jewish laws and customs. Greek and Latin vernacular expressions of the faith transformed the face of Christianity as it spread throughout Asia Minor and the Roman Empire over the course of the next several centuries. While deJudaization characterized this first phase of crosscultural transmission, the global development of Christianity over the past century has involved considerable efforts at "deWesternization." In response to the modern missionary movement from Western Europe and North America, Asians and Africans have organized numerous independent churches and movements in an effort to disengage Christianity from its Eurocentric orientation and relativize the transplanted "vernacular'' forms.
These expressions of Christianity cannot be understood as simple extensions of European and American mission churches, as they are often viewed in the West. Wilbert Shenk's frank observations regarding this tendency in Western scholarship are on the mark:
In the West, the history of the churches in Asia, Africa, and Latin America is generally assumed to be a subcategory of Western mission history. The development of the nonWestern churches is indeed intertwined with the modern mission movement. However, the empirical reality of the Christian ecumene at the end of the twentieth century cannot be comprehended adequately through the category of mission history per se—it is considerably more than that. . . . We must move beyond the conventional framework, which is governed by the assumption that what happened in the course of Western Christendom is universally normative for Christian history. 5
Wherever Western Christianity has been transplanted there have been those who have accepted what they regard as the "universal" significance of Jesus but have chosen, nevertheless, to develop their newfound faith outside of the mission churches. "Just as missionary orientation is fundamental to Buddhism and Christianity," James Heisig reminds us, "so is the vernacular orientation needed to loosen the hold that one particular time or culture or way of thinking has on teachings held sacred in order that they might enter other times and circumstances freely."6 Although independent and indigenous forms of Christianity in Japan have not met with the success of similar movements in the African continent and Korea, for example, these movements nevertheless represent the "other side'' of the Christian story in Japan. In order to accurately grasp the nature of world Christianity, we must give attention to the movements that fall outside standard mission histories.
Sociological Considerations
Before focusing on these Japanese movements, it seems worthwhile to consider in more general terms some of the issues surrounding the transmission of religion from one culture to another. From a sociological perspective, the crosscultural spread of religion is a complex process related to the interaction of several factors— ideological, environmental, and organizational. Ideology here is not used as a pejorative term. It refers to the beliefs, theology, or worldview of a social group, and more specifically to the "definition of mission" or understanding of the "world" embedded in the religious tradition. The manner in which groups define themselves and their relation to the surrounding environment has practical implications for the transplantation and development of an imported meaningsystem. The nature or orientation of religious traditions varies considerably, from those that are ethnic and nationalistic to those that are missionary in orientation. This ideological factor largely determines the degree of effort that
will be made in spreading the new meaningsystem and the approach taken in proselytization. In particular the policies and allocation of resources for missionary activity is essentially shaped by this consideration. Robert Montgomery has recently drawn particular attention to Buddhism, Christianity, and Islam as three world religions that "have diffused most extensively," adding that "the cases of Judaism and Hinduism demonstrate that being a 'world religion' with universalistic doctrines apparently is a necessary, but not a sufficient, reason for a religion to diffuse widely by crossing many sociocultural boundaries." 7
The environmental factor refers to the social, economic, and political conditions external to the "carriers" (i.e., immigrants, missionaries, religious organizations) of the transplanted meaningsystem. It is therefore important to consider various aspects of the receiving society: the nature and role of the established or indigenous religion (s); the relationship between religion and the political order (i.e., are alternative religions permitted or tolerated?); the relative degree of social stability; and the potential for the existence of social groups outside of or excluded from the established religion or power structure. We are primarily concerned here with whether there exists a pool of likely or potential converts for an alternative meaningsystem.
Finally, the organizational factor refers to the polity and social form of the carriers of the new meaningsystem. This would include the relationship of a religious organization's headquarters to other levels or units of organization (congregations, temples, mission societies); the nature of religious authority; and the division of labor (this particularly concerns the relationship between the laity and religious professionals). Crucial to the transplantation process is the nature of the carriers of the new meaningsystem. Is it carried by immigrants to another country as cultural baggage or is it brought by missionaries for the primary purpose of propagation? Does it accompany an ethnic community as a means of maintaining cultural identity or is it a part of a large missionary enterprise?
While these broad environmental factors help determine whether an alternative religion can be transplanted, the success of the transplantation process itself is significantly influenced by the degree to which forms of leadership, organizational structure, belief, and ritual are adapted to indigenous patterns and felt needs. As long as an imported religion retains its "foreign" character, it will more than likely have only a limited appeal to marginal individuals. For wider acceptance the imported religion must be rooted in the culture of the receiving society to the extent that it is no longer perceived as an alien or deviant phenomenon.
This indigenization process takes many years, of course, and is usually only achieved after considerable friction between the initial foreign carriers of the religion and the emergent indigenous leadership. The process whereby these "foreign" and previously irrelevant traditions become meaningful and rooted in local culture is referred to by such terms as indigenization, inculturation, contextualization, or syncretism. The choice of nomenclature is dependent on one's academic reference group or theological commitments. In the social sciences, for example, indigenization has been defined as the process whereby foreignborn religions are transformed through contact with native religion and culture. 8 In theological and missiological circles, the legitimate indigenization of Christianity is often referred to as the "inculturation" or "contextualization" of the Gospel. ''Syncretism," a pejorative term, is reserved for illegitimate forms of religious synthesis. While the missionary "carriers" of a religious tradition certainly contribute to the process of cultural transformation through their translation efforts,9 indigenization ultimately depends upon the creative efforts of those who belong to the local culture. Independent efforts to create vernacular Christian movements, in fact, are often resisted by the missionary carriers. This is not surprising, as F. F. Bruce explains:
One important aspect of the fixing, or indeed petrifying, of tradition often appears when a community is transplanted from its former environment to a new and unfamiliar one. It may try to preserve its sense of identity and security by holding tenaciously to its traditions in the form which they had reached at the moment of transplantation. The Amish are perhaps the best known example of this—best known because their traditions comprise their total way of life. But on a less comprehensive scale the phenomenon is common enough. . . .
To many it seems safer and more comfortable to stay within familiar and oldestablished boundaries. The admission of more light may show up inadequacies in cherished traditions—inadequacies that would otherwise have remained hidden.10
This same tendency is certainly observable in many missionary situations. Representatives of established churches frequently regard adaptations of their traditions by the natives as "unauthorized religious production" and illegitimate syncretisms.11
The Japanese Context
Japanese history provides rich data for the study of transplantation and indigenization with regard to several religious traditions in vastly different socio
historical circumstances. The Buddhist tradition was introduced to Japan via China and Korea from the late sixth century, Roman Catholic Christianity was transplanted in the sixteenth century, and various Protestant denominations began missionary efforts from the latter half of the nineteenth century after Japan reopened its doors to the West. Although the focus of this study is on the Japanese reshaping of Christianity since the nineteenth century, we need to briefly consider the nature of Japanese religion and society prior to the arrival of Protestant missionaries.
Perhaps because of the vast, popular literature depicting the Japanese as a "homogeneous people," we tend to forget that in premodern Japan the population was highly divided by a variety of factors. Politically, Japanese were divided into 270 political domains (bakuhan) with their loyalty given to regional feudal lords.
According to Maruyama Masao, it was not until the Meiji Restoration (1868) that national consciousness truly developed and led to "a sense of political solidarity and national unity." Describing the sociopolitical situation of the late Tokugawa period, Maruyama recalls the observations of Fukuzawa Yukichi, who commented that it was as if the "many millions of people throughout Japan were sealed up in many millions of separate boxes or separated by many millions of walls." 12
Religious institutions also played their part in this divided nation. In the premodern period most Japanese were divided into particularistic village communities and united around local Shinto cults. Communal identities were reinforced through support of the local shrine and participation in various annual festivals. Shinto functioned essentially as the legitimizer of"subworlds," and was unable to integrate Japan under a "sacred canopy," to use Peter Berger's familiar phrase.13 During the Tokugawa period (1600–1867), Buddhist temples received state patronage in exchange for administering the danka seido, a system in which all the residents of a given area were required to register their household with a local temple and notify it of births, marriages, and deaths. As a part of this system, priests issued certificates (terauke) to individuals each year attesting that the person in question was not a member of the proscribed religion (Christianity). Thus Buddhist priests were used by the Tokugawa regime to monitor and control the entire population. The system was localized, however, and did not provide a means of unifying the nation—for the most part it served to firmly link Buddhist temples with individual households or extended families (ie).
In this way, Japanese religiosity evolved in the premodern period into a syncretistic system of "layered obligations.14 Living in rather isolated village communities, most
Japanese naturally participated in the annual festivals and rituals
of the local Shinto shrine and Buddhist temple. Participation in religious events and rituals was primarily motivated by the sense of duty and obligation that accompanied membership in a household and community, not by clearly defined beliefs or exclusive creeds. Over time, Shinto came to dominate rituals associated with thisworldly concerns of birth and fertility, and Buddhism the rituals associated with otherworldly concerns and care for the dead. In fact, the dominant role of Buddhism in the care of the dead has earned it the popular designation "funeral Buddhism. 15 By the time Japan embarked on its push to modernization most Japanese were integrated into this system of household (Buddhist) and communal (Shinto) religious obligations. This is the religious and cultural context within which we must try to understand the transplantation and indigenization of Christianity over the past century.
Approaching Indigenous Christian Movements
Although the study of new religious movements represents one of the main concerns of sociologists and religious studies scholars in Japan, generally speaking those movements with origins in the Christian tradition have not received serious attention. The main reason for this comparative neglect is probably the fact that such movements are rather modest in size, with memberships ranging from several hundred to more than twenty thousand. With half a dozen New Religions each claiming memberships equal to or several times larger than the total number of Protestants and Catholics in Japan, and with scores of other movements claiming to have memberships numbering in the hundreds of thousands, it is not surprising that these smaller Christian movements have yet to claim the attention and time of scholars. It is only natural to focus attention on the most prominent or successful groups.16
For the most part, scholarship within Christian circles has also ignored the "unauthorized religious production" represented by these independent religious traditions, though the Christian Yearbook usually provides a brief paragraph on each movement. While the issue of the indigenization of the Gospel has been a serious topic for theological discussion on and off for decades, the conversation has been largely confined to transplanted mission churches and those Japanese denominations ecumenically related to the churches in the West. Even Jan Swyngedouw, a veteran observer of the religious scene in contemporary Japan, is puzzled by the general neglect and indifference toward these indigenous movements:
Japan is known as a fertile ground for new forms of religion. The Christian tradition is no exception, and there exist in fact many indigenous groups that claim a Christian label. It is, however, somewhat surprising that these groups, even when their numerical growth or some other factor gains public attention, are seldom viewed by mainline Christian bodies in terms of orthodoxy versus heterodoxy. It is as though the new groups hardly merit any notice. 17
In fact, it is these groups—independent of the Western churches and their concerns for theological and ritual conformity—that have been able to deal more directly and freely with the issues related to indigenization that so often remain latent or suppressed in many of the "mainline" and transplanted Christian denominations.18
Because of its relatively recent arrival in Japan, Christianity is often regarded as a "foreign" and "Western" religion. This study will show that for some smaller religious subcultures in Japan this is no longer the case. Simply because Christianity lacks a long history and is sometimes in tension with other Japanese traditions does not mean it cannot be "authentically" Japanese. "In seeking to parse the tradition and culture of any people,'' Robert J. Smith reminds us, "it behooves the outsider always to remember that authenticity is not a function of antiquity and that recency is not evidence of triviality."19 Cultures are made and remade from old and new elements. As noted above, Buddhism and Confucianism were initially "foreign" (Chinese) elements, but over the course of many centuries were adapted and reinterpreted so that they became part of the native cultural tradition.20 Through the process of indigenization, Japanese have similarly transformed Christianity into a religion of their own. For the members of indigenous movements, Christianity is now perceived as a Japanese religion.
In this volume I have attempted to document forms of Christianity that have fallen outside the scope of traditional studies. Although scores of independent evangelical sects or churches are scattered throughout Japan, I have restricted my study to a dozen representative indigenous Christian movements, each established by a charismatic founder and made up of an association of groups or translocal congregations.
My primary concern has been to understand what Japanese Christians have done with Christianity, independent of the authority and control of the mission churches. In order to explain the development of these movements it is first necessary to understand them, which means becoming familiar with the language, symbols, and practices of those involved and discovering the significance accorded this involvement by the participants themselves. Field research, partic
ipant observation, and interviews, therefore, have been as important as documentary and archival research in this study.
In this book I draw on various sociological perspectives, typologies, and concepts, but my concern has not been to develop a general theory of indigenous Christian movements. Rather, I attempt to answer some basic questions about their emergence, character, and development. Why did some Japanese accept Christianity but reject the missionary carriers and their traditions? What role did charismatic leaders play in this process? What new social forms were developed by Japanese Christians? How do these Japanese Christians understand their faith and its relation to the "preChristian" religious traditions? What new rituals have been institutionalized in the development of indigenous Christianity?
Since this book is written from a sociological standpoint, it necessarily bears the limitations inherent to such a perspective. As an initial effort in interpretive understanding and descriptive analysis, it does not address important theological questions or attempt to evaluate these Japanese expressions of Christianity. While these are certainly legitimate areas of inquiry, they are beyond the scope of this study. Nevertheless, I hope that people from churches in the West can gain a deeper selfunderstanding through careful attention to these Japanese responses to transplanted mission traditions.
In order to enhance the readability of this volume, I have relegated much detail and reference information to the endnotes and appendix (Bibliographical Guide to Indigenous Christian Movements). Those wishing to pursue some of the issues raised in the body of this work will find that I have left a sufficient bibliographical trail to follow.
Chapter Two—The Social Sources of Christianity in Japan
Christianity in contemporary Japan consists of diverse subcultures. It includes the many church traditions transplanted by Western missionaries, numerous indigenous movements (churches or sects organizationally independent of Western churches), as well as the personal belief systems of Japanese influenced by Christianity but unaffiliated with any of its organizational forms. It may sound rather strange—especially to those from countries where many "mainline" or established churches have dominated the religious landscape for centuries—to refer to Christian subcultures in this way, given that less than one percent of the Japanese population are affiliated with a Christian church of any kind. Nevertheless, cultural diversity is one of the undeniable features of Christianity in Japan, although the size of most denominations or groups, admittedly, reminds one of the miniature bonsai plants or small gardens that Japanese have cultivated so remarkably for centuries.
This chapter briefly introduces the two primary sources of Christianity in Japan: first, the transplanted churches and denominations from the West, and second, the independent Christian movements founded by Japanese leaders. 1 Although this book is primarily concerned with the new indigenous Christian traditions, it is impossible to understand them in isolation from the imported traditions introduced by foreign missionaries.
From Roman Catholic to Protestant Mission Churches
Although there is some evidence that Nestorian Christianity may have reached Japan as early as the thirteenth century,2 the first historically verifiable encounter between Christianity and Japanese culture began in the midsixteenth century with the Roman Catholic mission to Japan. Accompanying the colonial expansion of the Portuguese and Spanish into Asia, Jesuit missionaries arrived in the archipelago in 1549. These missionaries met with considerable success, so much so that this period has been referred to as "the Christian century in Japan,"3 with the ratio of Christians to nonChristians probably several times higher than what it is today.
In light of the macropolitical situation at the time, it is hardly surprising that many Japanese authorities came to regard Christianity as the deviant religion of incursive foreign powers with designs on Japan, and as a serious threat to the nation's internal stability and national security. This first encounter between Christianity and Japan "officially" ended by the midseventeenth century with government decrees prohibiting Christianity, ordering the expulsion of European missionaries, and mandating the systematic persecution of Japanese converts. Although the Christian success story was thereby brought to an abrupt end, the encounter with Christianity continued "unofficially" for the next two centuries as the "hidden Christians'' (kakure kirishitan) sought to survive in the hostile environment and secretly carry on the faith they had received.4
The second phase of mission to Japan began in 1859 (only six years after Commodore Perry persuaded Japan to open its doors to the West) with the arrival of the first Protestant missionaries and the return of the Roman Catholics. This was a time of widespread confusion and chaos. The feudal order was disintegrating rapidly by the end of the Tokugawa period (1600–1868), and the new Meiji government had not yet begun to build the new social order. It was during this difficult transition period that missionaries arrived in Japan. It is important to recall that they did not begin their work with a "clean slate." Christianity continued to be popularly understood as a heretical and evil religion ( jakyo*).
Since the midnineteenth century over two hundred mission societies, representing scores of churches and denominations as well as numerous national cultures, have been transplanted to Japanese soil (see table 1 on pages 14–15). The missionary impulse has been especially strong in North America, with the United States and Canada being the home base for approximately onethird of all missionary societies that have been active in Japan.
From Transdenominational Cooperation to Denominational Mission Churches
Although Christianity in Japan today consists of a bewildering array of transplanted denominations and sects, the earliest Protestant missionaries initially made serious efforts to cooperate in providing a more united witness to the Christian faith. The first Protestant church in Japan was organized along nondenominational (or transdenominational) lines in 1872 under the leadership of Samuel Robert Brown (Dutch Reformed), James Curtis Hepburn, and James Ballagh (both Presbyterian). Avoiding Western denominational labels, this church was called the Church of Christ in Japan ( Nihon Kirisuto Kokai *). Missionaries from Reformed, Presbyterian, and Congregational church traditions met that same year for the first Protestant Missionary Conference to discuss how cooperative missionary activities could be carried out and schismatic Westernstyle denominationalism averted in Japan. In order to create a united "body of Christ in Japan," it was decided that denominational names would be avoided and missionaries from various traditions would all use the name "Church of Christ" when organizing new congregations. The form of church government adopted (i.e., whether presbyterian or congregational polity) would be determined on a congregationbycongregation basis, taking into account the missionary leadership and consensus of the local members.5
This was the general orientation of the Protestant missionaries until 1873, when the notices proscribing Christianity were finally removed. With the change in political climate to one of relative freedom came a rather sudden reversion to the old denominational orientation on the part of many missionaries. The concern for a united witness through cooperative mission was soon replaced by a focus on establishing Western denominational churches. Although some missionaries continued to stress collaborative efforts and had by 1875 organized Church of Christ congregations in fifty locations in the Kanto* and Kansai areas, it was only a matter of time until the denominationalism of the other missionaries won the day. Missionaries found that they could no longer work
Table 1. Start of Work by Christian
Mission Organizations in Japan, 1859–1992
Year Organization Country of Origin Year Organization Country of Origin
1859 Presbyterian Church in the U.S. U.S.A. 1907 SocietasVerbi Divini Germany
1859 Protestant Episcopal Church U.S.A. 1908 Missionskongregation Holland
1859 Reformed Church in America (Dutch) U.S.A. 1908 Societas Jesu France
1859 Société des Missions Etrangères France 1908 Societas Sacratissimi Cordis Jesu France
1860 American Baptist Churches U.S.A. 1910 Apostolatus Orationis France
1860 American Seamen's Friend Society U.S.A. 1913 Missionary Band ofthe World U.S.A.
1860 Southern Baptist Convention U.S.A. 1915 Society of SaintVincent de Paul France
1861 Holy Orthodox Church in Japan Russia 1917 Church of Christ, Scientist U.S.A.
1869 American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions
U.SA. 1918 American Wesleyan Mission U.S.A.
1920 Community of the Epiphany England
1869 Congregational Church U.S.A. 1920 Kongregation der Franziskanerinnen Germany
1869 Church Missionary Society England 1921 Sceurs * de la Charité France
1871 Wesleyan Methodist Church Canada 1923 American Friends Service Committee U.S.A.
1872 L'Institut des Sceurs* de l'Enfant France 1925 Congregacion de Religiosas Philippines
1872 Methodist Episcopal Church U.S.A. 1925 Franciscan Sisters of Annunciation Canada
1873 Methodist Church of Canada Canada 1926 Maryknoll Sisters of St. Dominic U.S.A.
1873 Finnish Missionary Society Finland 1926 Pia Societas sancti Francisci Salesii Italy
1873 Methodist Church of Canada Canada 1926 Les Sceurs* Missionnaires Canada
1873 Methodist Women's Missionary Society Canada 1927 Liebenzeller Mission Germany
1873 Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts England 1927 Ordo Sancti Benedicti Italy
1927 WatchTower (Jehovah's Witnesses) U.S.A.
1874 Edinburgh Medical Mission Scotland 1928 Congregación de Adoratrices Spain
1874 United Presbyterian Church Scotland 1928 Opus Dei Spain
1875 National Bible Society of Scotland Scotland 1929 Instituto delle Figlie di Maria Italy
1876 British and Foreign Bible Society England 1929 Student Christian Movement England
1876 Evangelical Church of North America U.S.A. 1930 Ordo Fratrum Minorum Italy
1877 Congrégation des Sceurs* de l'Enfant France 1930 St. Benedict's Priory U.S.A.
1877 Cumberland Presbyterian Church U.SA. 1931 Congrégation Romaine de Dominique Italy
1878 Baptist Missionary Society England 1931 Les Sceurs* des Saints Noms Canada
1879 Reformed Church in U.S. (German) U.S.A. 1932 Congrégation de Notre Dame Canada
1880 Methodist Protestant Church U.SA. 1932 Fratres Scholarum Christianarum France
1880 Young Men's Christian Association England 1933 Maryknoll Missioners U.S.A.
1883 Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) U.S.A. 1933 Society of St. John the Evangelist U.S.A.
1885 Evangelical Protestant Missionsverein Germany 1933 Sceurs* Missionnaires du ChristRoi Canada
1885 Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) U.S.A. 1934 Ancillae Sacratissimi Cordis Jesu Spain
1885 Presbyterian Church in the U.S. (South) U.S.A. 1934 Pia Societas Sancti Pauli Apostoli Italy
1885 Wesleyan Missionary Society England 1934 Les Sceurs de l'Assomption Canada
1886 Methodist Episcopal Church (South) U.S.A. 1934 Sceurs de Sainte Anne Canada
1887 America Christian Convention U.S.A. 1935 Christian Evangelistic Church U.S.A.
1887 La Société de Marie France 1935 Congrégation de Notre Dame France
1887 Unitarian Association U.S.A. 1936 Ordre de Ste. Ursule Canada
1888 Christian and Missionary Alliance U.S.A. 1938 Orthodox Presbyterian Church U.S.A.
1888 Plymouth Brethren England 1946 Missionsbenediktinerinnen Germany
1890 Church of Christ U.S.A. 1947 Congregatio Immaculati Cordis Mariae Belgium
1890 Missionary Society of the Church of England Canada 1947 Ordo Saecularis Carmelitarum Spain
1947 Conservative Baptist Mission U.S.A.
1890 Universalist General Convention U.S.A. 1948 Clerics of St. Viator Canada
1892 Evangelical Lutheran Church (South) U.SA. 1948 Congregatio Missionariorum France
1892 Women's Auxiliary, Church of England Canada 1948 Far East Gospel Crusade U.S.A.
1895 United Brethren in Christ U.S.A. 1948 Franciscan Friars of the Atonement U.S.A.
1895 Free Methodist Church of North America U.S.A. 1948 Missionsgesellschaft Bethlehem Switzerland
1895 Salvation Army England 1948 Scarboro Foreign Missionary Society Canada
1896 Trappist Order (men) France 1948 Baptist General Conference U.S.A.
1896 Seventhday Adventists U.S.A. 1948 Societas Sancti Columbani Ireland
1898 Franciscaines Missionnaires de Marie India 1949 Congregatio Missionis France
1898 Trappist Order (women) France 1949 Evangelical Lutheran Church U.S.A.
1901 Latterday Saints (Mormons) U.S.A. 1949 Gideons International U.S.A.
1901 Young Women's Christian Association England 1949 Misioneras Eucaristicas Mexico
1905 Church of the Nazarene U.S.A. 1949 Mennonite Central Committee U.S.A.
1907 Ordo Fratrum Minorum Italy 1949 Sweden Mission Sweden
(table continued on next page)
(table continued from previous page)
Year Organization Country of Origin Year Organization Country of Origin
1943 Evangelical Free Church Mission U.S.A. 1953 Sceurs * de la Charité de Québec Canada
1950 Church of the Foursquare Gospel U.S.A. 1954 Free Will Baptists U.S.A.
1950 Free Christian Mission Norway, 1954 Ordre de Moniales Cisterciennes Belgium
Denmark 1954 Fraternité des Petites Sceurs* de Jésus France
1950 Ordo Scholarum Piarum Spain 1955 Catholic Mission Sisters U.S.A.
1950 Philadelphia Church Mission U.S.A. 1955 Religiosas de Maria Immaculada Cuba
1950 Societas Missionariorum France 1956 Congregation of Sisters of St. Joseph U.S.A.
1950 St. Benedict's Priory U.S.A. 1956 Instituto de Santa Maria de Guadalupe Mexico
1950 Suore Pie Discepole Italy 1956 Our Lady's Missionaries Canada
1950 Swedish Holiness Union Sweden 1956 Petits Frres de Jésus France
1951 Apostolic Christian Church U.S.A. 1957 Franciscan Sisters of the Atonement U.S.A.
1951 Christian Reformed Church U.S.A. 1957 Religiose della Passione Italy
1951 Deutscher Diakonissenerband Germany 1958 Association des Prêtres du Prado France
1951 Evangelical Orient Mission Norway 1958 Institutum Saeculare Missionariarum Italy
1951 Figlie della Carità Canossiane Italy 1959 Ordinis Societatis Mariae France
1951 Filiae Iesu Spain 1959 Società Missionarie di Maria Italy
1951 Frères de l'Instruction Chrétienne France 1959 Unification Church Korea
1951 Grey Sisters Canada 1961 Gospel Fellowship Mission U.S.A.
1951 Hospitaller Brothers Spain 1970 Fratres Caritatis Belgium
1951 Institut des Sceurs* des Missions France 1972 The Family U.S.A.
1951 Ordo Carmelitarum (men) Italy 1975 Evangelical Baptist Churches Canada
1951 Les Petites Filles de St. Joseph Canada 1975 Rex Hubbard World Outreach U.S.A.
1952 Congregatio Passionis Jesu Christi Italy 1976 Full Gospel Church Mission Korea
1952 Religious of the Assumption Philippines 1977 Verbum DeiApostolic Institute Spain
1952 United Pentecostal Church U.S.A. 1979 Petites Sceurs* de l'Évangile France
1953 Ancillae Divini Cordis Spain 1980 P.T.L. Club U.S.A.
1953 Apostolic Faith Mission U.S.A. 1984 Jimmy Swaggart Ministry U.S.A.
1953 Brethren in Christ Missions U.S.A. 1992 Baptist Church of Denmark Denmark
1953 Church of God U.S.A. 1992 Japan Free Evangelical Mission Norway
1953 Religiosas Concepcionistas Spain 1992 Volunteer Youth Ministry U.S.A.
This is an adaptation of data from Noriyoshi Tamaru and David Reid, eds., Religion in Japanese Culture: Where Living Traditions Meet a Changing World (Tokyo: Kodansha International, 1996), 185–86, used here with the permission of the publisher and author. In preparing this table, I have only included those organizations that define themselves as "Christian" (though several are not always recognized as such by the older established churches and denominations); drawing on a more complete listing of evangelical mission organizations active in Japan, I have also added some religious organizations that were not listed in the earlier table.
together on the basis of a common confession in Jesus Christ and the Bible as the standard of faith. Unable to reconcile the various church polities within the Church of Christ congregations, missionaries resorted to establishing denominational churches, each with its distinctive form of government and confession of faith. By this time the presence of the Methodist Episcopal Church had contributed another alternative polity to add to the confusion.
It should be noted that this conflict and subsequent denominationalism was not entirely the result of missionary opinion and leadership. After ten years of study in the
United States, Niijima Jo* returned to Japan in 1874 and made a strong appeal to the Church of Christ congregations in the Kansai area to adopt
the congregational polity in order to create a free and independent church in Japan. No new Church of Christ congregations were established after 1877, and all existing congregations eventually became part of either the Presbyterian, Congregational, or Methodist Episcopal denominations. 6
A case could be made that the cooperative outlook of the earliest missionaries was shaped in part by their fewness in number and their need for mutual support in the difficult environment they found themselves in. For over a decade Protestant missionaries had to cope with the fact that their faith and missionary activity were illegal. The number of missionaries from various Protestant traditions increased significantly after the notices proscribing Christianity were removed in 1873. With increasing numbers, each church had enough missionaries to create distinct communities of support without relying on missionaries from other denominations. Likewise, missionaries felt increasing pressure from the organizations that were supporting them financially to report on the number of "their" churches that had been established in Japan.
Christianity As a Lay Movement: The Sapporo and Kumamoto Bands
Studies of Protestantism in Japan often refer to the three "bands," or initial groups of Christians, that formed in the locations of Kumamoto, Yokohama, and Sapporo.7
While the influence of ordained Presbyterian and Dutch Reformed clergy was dominant in the Yokohama Band, it is particularly significant that in Kumamoto and Sapporo Christianity was spread by lay Christian educators who had been invited by the Japanese to serve as teachers in newly established institutions. Their interpretion of the Christian faith provided an alternative to that of the churchrelated missionaries who seemed preoccupied with ecclesiastical matters and the preservation of denominational distinctiveness.
In 1871 Captain Leroy Lansing Janes arrived in Kumamoto to teach English in the School of Western Learning (Yogakko*) established by Lord Hosokawa. Janes also taught his students the Bible in his home, and from 1875 a number of these students converted to the Christian faith. Even though Janes was only a lay person, he nevertheless baptized these early converts and led them in the celebration of the Lord's Supper. Janes transmitted his Christian faith and understanding of the Bible without the theological confessions and churchrelated political concerns that characterized many of the ordained missionaries. In 1876 some thirty individuals from the Kumamoto school moved to Kyoto and entered Doshisha* English School, which had been established the year before.
This became the center for the development of Congregational churches in Japan under the strong leadership of Niijima Jo *.
Another lay Christian, William S. Clark, arrived in Hokkaido* in 1876 to assist the Japanese government in the establishment of Sapporo Agricultural College. In addition to providing instruction in agricultural studies, Clark taught his students the Bible and introduced them to the Christian faith. In 1877 he organized the Covenant of Believers in Jesus with several of his students. This "Covenant" involved a commitment to read the Bible and live an ethical life, but did not require baptism and made no reference to the church or to theological confessions and creeds. Although Clark was only in Sapporo for a short period of eight months, his evangelistic efforts had a lasting influence. The year after Clark returned to the United States, Uchimura Kanzo* entered the college and converted to Christianity under pressure from the "Covenant" group Clark left behind. This tradition of ''lay Christianity" is an important background for understanding the subsequent development of indigenous Christian movements that had an "experiential" orientation and little sympathy for the "theological" and "ecclesiastical" concerns of the mission churches.8
The Development and Growth of the Mission Churches
Christian missionary efforts in Japan finally began to meet with some success after the Japanese government rescinded the edict prohibiting Christianity in 1873. After two long decades of antiChristian sentiment and resistance, Japan entered a brief period of seiyosuhai*, or "worship of the West." The persistent efforts of Protestant missionaries suddenly began to pay off in this new social climate of openness. Even missionaries were overwhelmed by the positive response and rapid growth of mission churches and institutions in the 1880s. In addition to churchplanting efforts, by 1882 Protestant missions had established 9 schools for boys, 15 for girls, 39 coeducational institutions, and 7 theological seminaries.9
According to the statistics compiled by the Christian Yearbook,10 there were only 59 Japanese Protestant Christians in 1873. Less than two decades later, by 1891, Protestant church membership had grown to 31,361. The rapid growth of Protestant churches during this period has been attributed to a series of revivals that occurred between 1882 and 1885 and to the "craze for everything Western" from 1885 to 1890. This brief honeymoon period was so encouraging that at the second
Conference of Protestant Missionaries of Japan held in 1883 it was almost taken for granted that Japan would become a Christian nation in the
near future. As Otis Cary observed in his history of this early period, "Some went so far as to say that, if the call sent out by the Conference asking for reenforcements was heeded by the churches at home, the work of evangelising Japan could be accomplished within ten years, or at least before the close of the century."
11 Even some nonChristian Japanese leaders and politicians were advocating that Christianity be adopted as the state religion of Japan. This was understood as an effective strategy for making Japan a recognized member of the international community as quickly as possible. By the end of the "glorious" 1880s, Protestant missions were successfully organizing churches, recording baptisms, and watching their enrollments increase in over one hundred mission schools.12
The Roman Catholic Church, recovering some members from among those who had remained "hidden" during the Tokugawa period (1600–1868), also grew during this decade, and by 1890 had a membership of 44,505. More remarkable during this same period was the development of the Russian Orthodox Church under the leadership of Bishop Nikolai. By 1900 the church had trained "376 Japanese clergy (compared to 196 for the Congregationalists, Anglicans, Presbyterians, and Roman Catholics combined) and 25,698 members, only slightly less than the Congregationalists, Anglicans, and Presbyterians combined."13
This initial period of growth for Christian churches ended as the Meiji government stabilized and began to recast a national identity based upon State Shinto and the emperor system. The leaders of the Meiji government established an alternative ideology to control the process of Japan's modernization: Western technology and learning would be adopted without Christianity. The Constitution of 1889 and the Imperial Rescript on Education of 1890 symbolized the national polity being cultivated by the Meiji authorities. From this point on there was a negative reaction to Westernization which, combined with the emergence nationalistic sentiments, served to put a damper on the growth of Christianity for at least a decade. As the strong arm of the state took control of Japan's modernization, the role of Christian institutions was quickly overshadowed.14
The strong antiWestern sentiments of the 1890s subsided and Christian mission activity began to experience a greater responsiveness from the Japanese from the early 1900s until around 1930. By this time, Japan was well into its industrial revolution and experiencing the many problems associated with a rapidly changing economy. Individuals most responsive to the Protestant missionary efforts were found among the rapidly growing whitecollar class concentrated in urban areas, and the membership of the Protestant denominations grew from 50,785 in 1901 to 193,937 in 1930.15 The Roman Catholic Church
similarly grew from a membership of 56,321 in 1901 to one of 92,798 in 1930. While Christian denominations continued to record growth on into the 1930s, by the end of that decade the growing nationalism supported by State Shinto brought the growth of the churches to a virtual halt.
Transplanted Churches under Japanese Civil Religion
Although the Meiji Constitution guaranteed religious freedom, by the late 1930s the government became increasingly totalitarian, requiring members of every religious group to participate in civil religious rituals and conform to the statedefined orthodoxy. The national religion created by the government bureaucrats was largely an
"invention of tradition" 16 projected back on Japanese history; though nominally Shinto, it differed considerably from the previous forms of Shinto belief and practice. It was used, nevertheless, to unify and integrate the heterogeneous population and mobilize the people for nationbuilding, modernization, and military expansion.
The authorities defined Shinto as a "nonreligious" institution of the state, and participation in its rituals came to be viewed as the "patriotic" duty of all Japanese regardless of personal religious convictions. These civil religious demands coalesced with traditional religious obligations in the wartime period to create an almost unbearable tension for Christian churches. Christians who did not comply with the government directive to worship at the shrines of State Shinto—the duty of all loyal citizens—faced not only persecution but constant suspicion concerning their identity as Japanese.
In order to deal with religious deviants and bring all groups into conformity with the statedefined orthodoxy, the Diet passed the Religious Organizations Law (shukyo*dantai ho*) in 1939. This empowered the state to disband any religious organization whose teachings were in conflict with the Imperial Way (kodo*). In addition, the Peace Preservation Law (chian'iji ho*) was revised in 1941 in order to address the subversive potential of various religious groups. Designed initially in 1925 to control radical socialists and the communist movement, this law prohibited the organization of any association or group that denied the right to private property or sought to overthrow the national polity (kokutai). The revised version, however, was extended to suppress a wide variety of dangerous ideas (kiken shiso*) that showed disrespect toward the imperial household and its shrines or were in conflict with the national polity (by this time interpreted to mean Japan as a divine country under the absolute rule of one manifest deity—arahitogami—the emperor).
Given the legal measures and intense government pressures noted above, it is not surprising that most transplanted churches and Christian institutions gradually accommodated themselves to the nationalistic environment. After varying degrees of resistance to the claims of the state, the Roman Catholic Church and most Protestant denominations eventually instructed their members to participate in the rituals of civil religion. By the late 1930s most churches had also created some form of theological rhetoric to legitimize the Imperial Way, including support for Japanese military expansionism. According to these indigenous theologies, the rule and kingdom of the emperor were none other than the kingdom of God, and the Japanese people were a chosen race with a destiny to establish this kingdom of peace and prosperity throughout Asia. 17
The formation and subsequent activities and policies of the United Church of Christ in Japan (Nippon Kirisuto Kyodan*, hereafter referred to as the Kyodan) provides one of the clearest illustrations of this dominant pattern of accommodation and collaboration.18 While a number of church leaders had worked for a united Christian witness for many years, it was not until the Japanese government forced the creation of this union that the diverse Protestant religious bodies actually came together. In accordance with the 1939 Religious Organizations Law, Christian churches were required to comply with conditions set by the Ministry of Education in order to receive official recognition or legal status. Indicating that it would only recognize one Protestant denomination, the Ministry directed the various churches to form one organization. Denominational representatives met for serious discussion in August 1940, and on October 17 passed a resolution to unite their various churches. In 1941, as a governmentdirected union of thirtyfour denominations, the Kyodan absorbed all transplanted Protestant mission churches (with the exception of a section of the Anglican Church, the Seventhday Adventists, and a few small evangelical churches who refused to cooperate).19 Needless to say, for many of the participating churches this was a less than happy union that resembled a forced or arranged marriage.
From the beginning, as David Reid points out, the "Kyodan rested on an uneasy combination of 'sacred' and 'secular' motivation."20 At least for its first four years of existence, the 'secular' demands of the state proved to be the most dominating influence. Writing in the midst of this difficult period, D. C. Holtom suggested that the overall weakness of Christianity made this pattern of response almost inevitable:
The Christian movement in Japan today is still too weak, in numbers as well as influence, to take more than a subordinate position when powerful forces in the state set about turning all the resources of the national life into directions that cut across those along which the Christian church has traveled. Under the circumstances the church has only two roads open to it: persecution and martyrdom or compromise and accommodation. The Japanese Christian church has chosen the latter. 21
Until the end of the war, the Kyodan* was largely guided and controlled by numerous government demands. On 11 January 1942, for example, representatives of the Kyodan went to Ise Jingu* (the major Imperial Shinto shrine) to report to the national gods the founding of the Kyodan, to pray for its development, and to pledge contributions to the nation. Before the end of 1942 (10 December) the head office of the Kyodan instructed all churches to precede each worship service with kokumin girei (citizen rituals), which involved bowing in the direction of the imperial palace, singing the Kimigayo (hymn to the emperor), and silently praying for those who had died in service to the emperor. All aspects of church life came under the increasing scrutiny and control of the authorities. Hymnbooks were edited and shortened to about one hundred selected entries; songs with references to peace or God as creator and judge were excised. In order to show that it was fully behind the government's war effort, the Kyodan even began a fundraising campaign for the military in November 1943 for a warplane named Nippon Kirisuto Kyodan. By 1944, the government went so far as to issue themes for sermon topics to all the churches through the Kyodan office. The General Secretary of the Kyodan even instructed the churches to choose another date to celebrate Christmas, since 25 December was to be observed as a national holiday honoring the late Emperor Taisho's* birth. While the Kyodan during wartime may be regarded as a "Japanized" expression of Christianity, it can hardly be regarded as a spontaneous development and example of what I understand as an indigenous Christian movement.
The Postwar Period
The development of Christianity in postwar Japan has been framed by the fundamental changes in the political and legal system that resulted from Japan's defeat on 15
August 1945 and the arrival of the Occupation Forces. Within several months the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers (SCAP) issued the Directive for the
Disestablishment of State Shinto (15 December 1945) and set in motion policies that effectively reduced Shinto to the status of a voluntary
organization without special legal authority or financial support from the state. In accord with the Directive, the wartime laws regulating religion were abolished and all religious organizations, including Shinto groups, were required to register as "religious juridical persons" (shukyo * hojin*) and placed on equal legal footing. Articles 20 and 89 of the postwar Constitution of Japan (1947) clearly articulated the principle of religious freedom and separation of religion and state, thus fulfilling the constitutional reform objectives of the Occupation authorities. The disestablishment directive accomplished the "secularization" of State Shinto in record time, but it also created a freemarket religious economy that allowed diverse religious groups to compete on a relatively level playing field for the first time in Japanese history.
Another major factor shaping postwar religious trends was the population shift that accompanied the rebuilding of Japan following the wartime devastation. Japan's economic recovery required an extensive pool of laborers to work in the developing industries located primarily in the urban areas, necessitating a major population shift from rural regions to the cities. Abandoning agricultural communities in search of a better livelihood, workers poured into urban areas in the 1950s and 1960s to meet the demands of the recovering and expanding industrial economy. An urban population of 37.5 percent in 1950 had increased to 76.1 percent by 1980.
The demographic changes related to postwar industrialization helped to create a more favorable environment for Christian missionary activities, since Christian organizations were largely concentrated in metropolitan areas (unlike Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples). In addition to these political and demographic changes, a largescale crisis of meaning had been created by the wartime devastation and the shock of defeat. The ideology that had united and propelled Japan as a nation since the 1930s disintegrated with Japan's surrender. Christianity and various new religions that emerged from the war's aftermath provided one means of coping with this crisis.
With the establishment of religious freedom by the Occupation Forces in 1946, many groups left the Kyodan* to reestablish their prewar denominational identities. The most significant departures were the Anglican Episcopal Church, the Lutheran Church, plus numerous Baptist and smaller Evangelical and Holiness churches. In addition to these reestablished prewar denominations, numerous other evangelical churches from North America and Europe responded to General MacArthur's call for missionary reinforcements to join in building a new Japan. Between 1949 and 1953 over fifteen hundred new missionaries arrived in Japan, and the churches began to show signs of recovery.
During this early postwar period Christian churches made considerable progress, particularly among members of the educated middle class. The Roman Catholic Church, whose membership had dropped to around 100,000 during the war, grew to a membership of 323,599 by 1960. Protestant churches experienced a similar expansion, from a low of about 190,000 in 1942 to over 400,000 in 1960. The annual growth rate, however, began to decline gradually for both Protestants and Catholics alike in the early 1950s. David Barrett notes that the Roman Catholic Church's relatively high annual growth rate of 10.4 percent in 1951 fell to 7.9 percent in 1953, initiating a trend that by 1971 had skidded to only 0.34 percent. 22 A similar pattern can be seen in the Protestant churches. While churches have continued to report membership increases, annual statistics have indicated for decades that no more than one percent of the Japanese are church members. The hard reality is that the rate of defections and the increase in the Japanese population have kept Christian churches from gaining a larger share of the market in Japan's religious economy. Indigenous new religious movements, on the other hand, have capitalized on the new demographic profile and deregulated religious economy and, according to the most reliable Japanese scholarship, have memberships totaling between 10 and 20 percent of the population.
As this brief review has shown, many of the transplanted mission churches have experienced significant periods of growth over the past century. In spite of the numerous challenges and difficulties, the missionary impact on Japan has been significant. In addition to the transplantation of many denominations and churches, the missionary movement contributed to the development of modern Japan through its efforts in the fields of education and social welfare. While acknowledging this widespread influence, it must be said that the evangelistic efforts of the mission churches have not found a very receptive audience. When one considers the number of missionaries and financial resources invested by both Roman Catholic and Protestant mission societies, it is hardly a picture of success. As noted above, institutionally affiliated Christians still only amount to approximately one percent of the population. In a word, the dominant response to Western missionary efforts has been one of rejection. Over a decade ago, the NHK Survey on Japanese Religious Consciousness (1984) provided a slightly more optimistic picture, finding that two percent of the Japanese identify themselves as Christian and 12 percent feel a certain empathy toward Christianity.23 Nevertheless, even accepting the more generous assessment provided by survey research that suggests there may be some kakure kirishitan in contemporary Japan, the efforts to transplant Christianity in Japan have not been too successful.
Also hidden within these meager statistics are the numerous indigenous Christian movements that developed in reaction to the transplanted mission churches over the past century, the story that we now consider.
From Transplanted Churches to Indigenous Movements
As latecomers to Japan's religious scene, both Catholic and Protestant churches have experienced considerable difficulty in shedding their reputation as "foreign religions." While at times the "Westernness" of Christianity has contributed to its appeal among Japanese, for the most part it has been viewed as a problem. Many early Japanese converts to Christianity felt that this was largely the fault of the foreign missionaries. Christianity was unnecessarily bound to Western organizational forms, denominational politics, and missionary control. Although the statistics indicate that most Japanese have rejected the evangelistic appeals and demands of Western missionaries, the development of indigenous and independent Christian movements suggests the possibility of a more nuanced yet critical response to transplanted Christianity. This distinctive approach was expressed as early as 1890 in rather strong terms by Nitobe Inazo *, a close friend of Uchimura Kanzo* from their days together at Sapporo Agricultural College in Hokkaido*:
The sectarian bigots revive on a heathen land their own petty jealousies, for which their forefathers fought and burned one another. Nothing is more ugly and repugnant to Japanese eyes than these sectarian quarrels and jealousies; worse than that, the Japanese seekers find themselves puzzled by a maze of conflicting teachings of different Christian bodies.24
Nitobe goes on to say that "the divine religion of Christ, divested of all human wrappage—of sacramentalism, sacerdotalism, sectarianism—alone is welcome." If human wrappings are necessary, he concludes, they should be "a homemade garment."25 Religion without "human wrappings,'' of course, is not really an option. The choice is only between imported or indigenous forms. The development of indigenous forms usually takes many years and is only achieved after struggles between the initial foreign "carriers" of the religion and the emergent native leadership. The nativistic reactions of Japanese to mission churches and their creative appropriations of Christianity have led to the development of numerous "homemade garments," providing alternative interpretations and sociocultural expressions of this foreignborn religion. As may be seen in table 2, a wide variety of indigenous groups have been organized over the past century.
Table 2. Indigenous Christian Movements in Japan
INDIGENOUS MOVEMENTS FOUNDER YEAR ORGANIZED
With the exception of the Nonchurch movement founded by Uchimura Kanzo *, our knowledge regarding most of these indigenous movements has been limited to a brief paragraph provided each year in the Christian Yearbook. The current membership of these groups varies widely, ranging from several hundred to over twenty thousand. Together, therefore, they constitute a significant development of the Christian tradition in Japan. (Consult the Appendix for basic information and resources on each movement.)
Figure 1.
Typology of Indigenization
ChurchSect Theory and the Study of Indigenization
Japanese scholars refer to many of these movements as Christianrelated New Religions, and several such groups were included in the massive reference work on New Religions published in 1990. 26 These groups, however, do not fit easily into typologies of Japanese New Religions because of their indebtedness to the established Christian traditions. For this reason, in fact, several years ago Shimazono Susumu, one of the leading scholars in the study of new religious movements in Japan, suggested that a separate typology was needed to adequately deal with Christianrelated New Religions in Japan.27
Adapting churchsect theory, figure 1 provides a comparative typological framework for understanding Christian religious organizations in Japan according to three criteria: basic orientation, selfdefinition, and degree of indigenization. This framework is hardly intended to be a definitive statement, but it should serve as a typological "bridge" to carry readers from the familiar world of
Western Christianity to the relatively unmapped territory of Japanese indigenous Christianity and, hopefully, clarify in a new way the complex relationship between imported and indigenous traditions. 28 This typology is based on an interpretative sociology of religion rather than on theological criteria, and priority is given to the actors' definition of the situation. As Peter Berger and Hansfried Kellner explain, sociological concepts "must relate to the typifications that are already operative in the situation being studied."29 While some groups included in figure 1 might be regarded as heretical and nonChristian by certain established churches, I have included them in this typology because the actors involved define themselves and their organizations in Christian terms or in continuity with the Christian tradition.
First of all, it is necessary to distinguish indigenous movements from the imported denominations and independent evangelical churches in terms of their basic orientation or dominant reference group. Christian religious bodies in Japan tend to be either "foreignoriented" or "nativeoriented." Transplanted religious organizations, including the Anglican Church, the Roman Catholic Church, the Lutheran denominations, and the United Church of Christ (the largest Protestant religious body in Japan, which incorporated Methodist, Reformed, Presbyterian, and Congregational churches) are still "foreignoriented" in many respects and therefore located at the nonindigenous end of the continuum. These denominations still receive foreign missionaries, and their understanding of theology and models for church polity and organization are taken primarily from Western churches. This tendency is so strong that it is not uncommon to hear it referred to in terms of the "German captivity" of the churches. Noting how Troeltsch, Barth, or Brunner inevitably emerge from the pages of the Bible when it is opened in many Japanese churches, one Japanese sociologist rather cynically remarked that ''one cannot help but wonder to whom these churches are trying to communicate their message."30
Readers should keep in mind that this framework is based on a continuum and understand that I am not arguing that indigenization has not occurred in these foreignoriented religious bodies, only that the process has proceeded more slowly than in indigenous movements founded by Japanese. Similarly, there are scores of independent evangelical groups in Japan whose dominant reference group tends to be American evangelicalism. While these independent groups are indigenous in terms of the standard criteria of selfgovernment, selfsupport, and selfpropagation, their "foreignorientation" is still apparent in their literature, tracts, and theology, which is largely "translated" material from North America. Indigenous movements, on the other hand, are "nativeoriented"
and do not measure their perception of religious truth by the standards of orthodoxy defined by Western theology or ancient church councils. Whether sectarian or denominational, the important point is that all of these movements are indigenous in terms of the standard criteria of selfcontrol, selfsupport, and selfpropagation. All are selfgoverning and have adopted their own style of leadership and organization. None receive financial support from foreign churches and all are selfpropagating (in fact, some even send their own missionaries abroad).
According to most indigenous movements, God's selfrevelation did not end with the canon of the Christian Scriptures. God continues to reveal deeper truths to those who are open to the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit. While some of these movements operate with the closed canon (the Nonchurch movement, for example), many share a common belief that God continues to reveal new truths hidden from or as yet ungrasped by Western churches. Most of these groups produce their own literature, including monthly or quarterly magazines, editions of the Bible (sometimes specially edited versions), and collections of the founder's writings and lectures. If not revealing radically new truths, indigenous movements at least share in common the conviction that God is calling them to develop Japanese cultural expressions of the Christian faith that are at least as legitimate as the national churches and denominational forms that have emerged over the centuries in Europe and North America.
Although indigenous movements share many common features, they can be distinguished in terms of their selfunderstanding and claims to legitimacy. Religious organizations can be distinguished according to whether they claim to be "uniquely legitimate," thus denying the legitimacy claims of other groups, or "collegially legitimate," thus accepting the claims of other groups. This distinction has been incorporated in the typology and is regarded as the basic feature that distinguishes a
"sect" from a "denomination." 31
The mission churches have a checkered history in this regard. Although often making efforts in cooperative Christian work, the competition and conflict between various "denominational" mission churches led many Japanese to regard them as sectarian groups, each claiming to be uniquely legitimate. In this typology, however, I have placed most transplanted mission churches in the denominational category, since this has usually been their selfunderstanding (even though not consistently practiced).32
Most indigenous movements are placed in the denominational category (for want of a better term) because they make only modest claims for themselves.33 The
Nonchurch movement, The Way, Christ Heart Church, the
Original Gospel, and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, for example, only claim to be Japanese expressions of Christianity, not exclusive paths to salvation. In other words, they usually regard themselves as legitimate expressions of a Christianity for Japan, not as exclusive "vessels" of truth. Uchimura Kanzo *, the founder of the Nonchurch movement, clearly articulated this point of view as follows:
To us it makes no difference whether that man becomes a Roman Catholic, or a Greek Catholic, or a Baptist, or a Presbyterian, or a member of any one of the sixhundred and more of the Christian sects and churches, which, we hear, exist in Christendom. We are thankful, yea, we rejoice, when a man is saved from his sins to a pure, humble life in Jesus Christ. But missionaries seem not to rejoice and be thankful unless a heathen is converted and he joins their own respective churches.34
The central affirmations of most indigenous movements indicate that they understand their particular expression of Christianity to be a part of a larger Christian tradition. Nevertheless, some of these groups appear rather separatistic or sectarian at times because they usually do not emphasize ecumenical or cooperative relations with other Christian bodies and often criticize each other on various points of theology or practice. Many leaders in the Nonchurch movement, for example, have condemned the Original Gospel (Tabernacle) as a heretical movement because of its Pentecostal distinctives.
The Spirit of Jesus Church is the only group in the category of indigenous sects because of its tendency to emphasize exclusive truth claims. The Spirit of Jesus Church is consistently sectarian and regards all other Western and Japanese expressions of Christianity as apostate. Murai Jun, the founder of the movement, was extremely critical of conservative evangelical churches for their rejection of his pentecostal emphasis on speaking in tongues and healing. According to Murai, these groups had "blasphemed the Holy Spirit" and were unpardonable. He was equally harsh in his assessment of the indigenous Nonchurch movement for its rejection of spirit and water baptism, going so far as to say that "Mukyokai* cannot last very long since it is not something from heaven."35
With all due respect to Nitobe, it is only fair to note that Western churches are not fully responsible for the "sectarianism" and conflicting interpretations of Christianity in Japan. A study of indigenous Christian movements reminds us that there are numerous "homegrown" sources of conflict and diversity. The rather idealistic image of a
"harmonious" Japan prior to the impact of the West is highly misleading. The Japanese population has always been more heterogeneous than such popular characterizations would suggest. It is probably safe to
say that the myth of the homogeneous Japanese is largely a creation of the Meiji, Taisho *, and Showa* eras. Prior to the Meiji Restoration and unification of the population under the emperor system and State Shinto, Japan lacked a strong national identity. Too often, in fact, we forget that premodern Japan was characterized by its diversity, and that there were politicized Buddhist sects, protest groups comprised of peasants and small landowners, and various groups distinguished by loyalties to different lords and clans. D. C. Holtom, writing during the Second World War, explained that the unification of Japan under Shinto nationalism was extremely difficult because of this social, political, and religious diversity:
Modern Japan has had to struggle for the unification and coordination of her national life in the face of strongly diversifying, not to say disintegrating, tendencies. There has been much internal heterogeneity to overcome. The particularism of a feudal regime that was split into rival clans and pocketed behind mountain barriers and secluded on separate islands has not even yet been fully transcended. Religious diversity has revealed itself in a tendency toward separatism that seems to reflect what amounts almost to a national genius for sectmaking and for breaking up into small esoteric groups.36
Holtom goes on to point out that in Japan this diversity has usually been under the control of a ruling class or small elite from above.
The typological framework introduced in this chapter is only intended to provide an initial orientation to the study of indigenous movements by delineating their basic characteristics and clarifying their relationship to imported religious bodies. While selfgovernment, selfsupport, and selfpropagation are understood as the minimum requirements for an indigenous church, indigenization involves much more than mere organizational independence. It also refers to the process whereby foreignborn religions are transformed through contact with native religion and culture. This transformation may involve new organizational forms, new styles of leadership, and adaptations in beliefs, rituals, and liturgies. In the following chapter I will sketch the social background of these indigenous movements and consider the role of charismatic minor founders in the development of these new cultural forms.
Chapter Three—Charisma, Minor Founders, and Indigenous Movements
Those of US familiar only with the world of established churches, denominational bureaucracies, and large Christian institutions tend to forget that Christianity began as a new religious movement with a leader who was known as a healer and exorcist. In Jesus: A New Vision, Marcus J. Borg draws attention to the charismatic nature of the early Jesus movement and maintains that it is necessary for us to give serious attention to the "world of Spirit" in order to accurately understand the place of
Jesus in the JudeoChristian tradition. The world of Spirit, he explains, refers to
another dimension or layer or level of reality in addition to the visible world of our ordinary experience. This notion of "another world," understood as actual even though nonmaterial, is quite alien to the modern way of thinking. The
modern worldview or "picture of reality" sees reality as having essentially one dimension, the visible and material realm. . . . But the notion of another reality, a world of Spirit, was the common property of virtually every culture before ours, constituting what has been called the "primordial tradition."
According to Borg's analysis, Jesus belonged to the charismatic stream of Judaism that took this worldview for granted, and he served as a mediator between the world of everyday reality and the world of spirit. 1
It is widely recognized that early Christianity continued to develop as a part of this charismatic stream. The Acts of the Apostles and various New Testament letters indicate that the disciples of Jesus and many leaders in the early Christian church were also deeply rooted in the world of Spirit.2 Prophetic messages from God, speaking in tongues, healing, and exorcism were important features of Christianity as it spread through the Roman empire.3 In time, however, charismatic gifts declined, and the rituals of healing and exorcism were institutionalized in the priesthood and became incorporated into the sacramental system of the Roman Catholic Church. The renewed interest in the Scriptures that characterized the Protestant Reformation, we should note, did not extend to the New Testament materials on charismatic gifts and healing. It has only been in the last century that these "spiritual gifts" have again become a prominent feature of Christianity in various regions of the world.
The reappearance of charismatic Christianity is due in part to the indigenous responses to transplanted Protestant mission churches from Europe and North America. Over the course of the past century scores of Protestant mission organizations have established churches throughout Asia and Africa. For the most part these missionary efforts have been by churches that no longer recognize the use of charismatic gifts or healing rituals. One particularly interesting and persistent pattern of response to this missionary movement has been the development of independent and indigenous Christian movements in various regions of the nonWestern world. These movements are generally founded by charismatic individuals who accept the Christian faith but reject the missionary carriers and their "Western" and "doctrinal" understanding of religion. In many cases the size of these indigenous movements has surpassed that of the mission churches (whose sponsoring denominations in North America and Europe are struggling with serious declines in membership). A decade ago, according to D. B. Barrett, there were already some 332 million Pentecostalcharismatic Christians worldwide. Most of these individuals belonged to one of the 11,000 Pentecostal or 3,000 independent charismatic denominations, though some were involved in the charismatic renewal movement within one of the old estab
lished churches. Barrett emphasizes that the growth of Pentecostalcharismatic forms of Christianity is truly multicultural, with members "found in 8,000 ethnolinguistic cultures and speaking 7,000 languages." 4 Christianity in Japan certainly reflects this global pattern of development (though the growth figures are on a much smaller scale than in South Korea and various African countries).
In approaching the study of Christianity in Japan, it is important to recognize that in some respects it is a "New Religion" in this context and cannot be viewed as an established religion, as in many Western countries. In referring to Christianity as a New Religion, I am not simply drawing attention to the fact that it is a foreignborn tradition that only arrived in Japan relatively recently. Rather, "newness" is related primarily to the fact that the indigenous Christian movements broke away from the mission churches and share many features not only with other Japanese New Religions but also with the early Christian movement. The prominent role of charismatic leaders and the manifestation of various charismatic phenomena are important features of indigenous Christian movements that distinguish them from most transplanted mission churches. One cannot explain the break with the mission churches nor account for the various innovations in Christian belief, practice, and social organization apart from these charismatic founders. In this sense, therefore, it is necessary to analyze these Christianrelated movements as New Religions in the Japanese context. Hence Byron Earhart's proposal that we give attention to precipitating factors, enabling factors, and personalinnovative factors in the rise of New Religions has influenced the shape of the following discussion.5
The Social Background of the Indigenous Movements
As noted in the previous chapter, the development of numerous indigenous and independent expressions of Christianity represents a nuanced response to the missionary initiatives: an acceptance of Christianity, but a rejection of the missionary carriers. For the most part, these movements began by breaking away from the Protestant mission churches rather than from the Roman Catholic, Anglican, or Russian Orthodox traditions. This poses some interesting questions for Protestant missionary theology and practice. What is it about the Protestant approach to Christianity that these Japanese Christians were unwilling to accept?
Although the Japanese founders of indigenous Christian traditions were indebted to the Protestant missionary movement in many respects, tensions and conflicts emerged over time as a result of fundamental differences in their understanding of the relationship between the Gospel and Japanese culture.
"Christ against culture," to borrow H. Richard Niebuhr's familiar expression, was the perspective that shaped the attitudes of most missionaries. This was true for the earliest pioneer missionaries of the late nineteenth century as well as for the wave of evangelical Protestant missionaries that arrived in Japan during the postwar period. Most came with a great zeal for evangelizing Japan, but their theological training had provided them with very few resources for understanding other cultures and religious traditions. Without denying that Protestant missionaries have also been "transformers of culture" through their activities in the fields of education (particularly for women) and social welfare, the fact remains that their understanding of the relationship between the Gospel and Japanese culture has been fundamentally negative.
Missionary theology and practice have tended to emphasize a total discontinuity between the Christian faith and Japanese religious traditions and practices. Indigenous traditions needed to be "displaced" or removed to make room for the Gospel and authentic Christian faith. The missionaries had the "truth of the Gospel," and the Japanese were totally lost in sin. Cyril Powles sums it up succinctly:
American Protestantism challenged the Japanese tradition. Theologically, it regarded the latter as pagan and corrupt. Culturally, it believed it to be archaic and outmoded. The American missionary therefore looked for the conversion of Japan to Christianity, which implied the destruction of the old cults. 6
While there were certainly some exceptions to this perspective,7 the dominant missionary model viewed Christianity as antithetical to Japanese religious culture (see figure 2).
Figure 2.
Dominant 19th–early 20thc. Protestant Missionary Model
Although the missionaries were capable of distinguishing the Christian faith from Japanese culture, they often lacked such critical reflection when it came to their own cultures. It has been noted in many different contexts that foreign missionaries often fail to distinguish their national culture from the religious faith they seek to transplant. Many Protestant missionaries operated as though their transplanted churches and traditions were the normative expression of the JudeoChristian Scriptures. Transplanted missionary cultures, which included creeds, confessions, polity, and the missionary way of doing things, were the authentic expression of Christian faith. Protestant missionaries to Japan have been no exception, as Joseph Kitagawa explains:
More often than not, European and American missionaries attempted to Westernize as well as Christianize the Japanese people and culture. Japanese converts were made to feel, consciously or unconsciously, that to decide for Christ also implied the total surrender of their souls to the missionaries. The task of evangelism was interpreted by most missionaries as transplanting in toto the church in the West on Japanese soil, including the ugly features of denominationalism—an unhappy assumption, indeed. 8
There was an initial attempt to establish a nondenominational church in Yokohama, as we noted earlier, but it was a shortlived experiment. As the number of missionaries and denominations increased each felt it must recreate its own denominational tradition on Japanese soil. Hence Presbyterians felt that an authentic church in Japan must adopt the Westminster Confession and organize churches with elders, sessions, presbyteries, and synods. Methodists, of course, needed a Bishop. Baptists and Congregationalists, on the other hand, wanted no authority above the local church, pastor, or missionary. Despite the fact that these various traditions and interpretations of Christianity had developed in very different culturalnationalpolitical contexts over many centuries, missionaries assumed that their tradition was the "authentic" or "normative" one. The "plurality of cultures" within the Protestant missionary movement was not overlooked by the native Christians. Uchimura Kanzo* expressed his pessimism regarding the prospects of transplanted Western Christianity as early as 1886 with the following words:
Which of the nineteen different Christian denominations which are now engaged in evangelizing Japan is to gain the strongest foothold there? In our view—and let us express this view with the most hearty sympathy toward the earnest endeavors of the missionaries of all the denominations—none of them. One reason is that mere transplanting of anything exotic is never known on
Japanese soil. Be it a political, scientific, or social matter, before it can be acclimatized in Japan, it must pass through great modifications in the hands of the Japanese. 9
Early on in missionary circles there were certainly discussions on developing indigenous churches, but this was understood primarily in terms of the "three selfs": selfsupport, selfcontrol, and selfpropagation. The idea that Japanese Christians might have their own insights and ways of organizing and practicing the faith was generally not entertained. Transmission of the missionary culture—without corruption or addition—was the primary concern. It is not surprising that Japanese found this displacement theology rather abrasive and hard to swallow. In a culture that had found a place for Buddhist, Shinto, and various folk beliefs and practices, the stress by Christian missionaries on exclusive belief and practice required too great a reorientation. Even many Japanese who made a commitment to the Christian faith struggled with lingering doubts about the "absoluteness" of missionary versions of Christianity.
After Japanese converts were introduced to the Scriptures and went on to serious theological studies, many realized that it was possible to distinguish the Christian faith and biblical tradition from the theology, church polity, and cultural values of the American and European missionaries. As native leaders gained a more critical understanding of the Christian tradition and saw the significant differences between the mission churches, they began to assert themselves more confidently as equals of their missionary teachers. The fact that numerous denominations were competing for converts on Japanese soil (each with its own doctrinal peculiarities and forms of government) indicated to many leaders that there might be room for Japanese interpretations and cultural expressions of Christianity.
For the founders of independent Christian movements, the transplanted missionary traditions, though a valuable resource to draw upon, were hardly the absolute truth. As the Japanese struggled to make sense of the Christian faith for themselves, they found it necessary to criticize missionary versions of Christianity on a number of grounds. Many Japanese leaders sought to distinguish between the religion of Jesus recorded in the Scriptures and the interpretation, and cultural expression, of Christianity that had been transplanted by mission churches. A recurring phrase in the Japanese Christian literature is that transplanted Christianity is batai*kusai (literally, "reeking of butter"). In other words, Japanese recognized that missionaries were bringing too much unnecessary (and "smelly") cultural baggage with them as they sought to transmit the
Gospel. This was essentially a critique of the missionary imposition of Western denominational forms. Writing in 1926, Uchimura Kanzo * reflected on his struggle with missionaries over this issue:
I am blamed by missionaries for upholding Japanese Christianity. They say that Christianity is a universal religion, and to uphold Japanese Christianity is to make a universal religion a national religion. Very true. But do not these very missionaries uphold sectional or denominational forms of Christianity which are not very different from national Christianity? . . . Is not Episcopalianism essentially an English Christianity, Presbyterianism a Scotch Christianity, Lutheranism a German Christianity, and so forth? Why, for instance, call a universal religion ''Cumberland Presbyterianism"? If it is not wrong to apply the name of a district in the state of Kentucky to Christianity, why is it wrong for me to apply the name of my country to the same? I think I have as much right to call my Christianity Japanese as thousands of Christians in the Cumberland Valley have the right to call their Christianity by the name of the valley they live in.10
Uchimura's observations effectively relativized the absolutist claims of many mission churches and cleared the way for other Japanese to move ahead with the creation of Japanese cultural expressions of this universal faith.
Teshima Ikuro*, the founder of the Original Gospel movement, a Pentecostal expression of Nonchurch Christianity, elaborated upon Uchimura's view with his distinction between a religion's external forms and its inner reality or truth.11 He argued that missionaries had brought the external forms of Western Christianity (music, architecture, doctrine, and rituals, for example) and given them to Japanese to wear like uniforms. The heart of religion, however, is spiritual and hidden from the eye. In worrying so much about transplanting the proper "shell" of Christianity, Teshima concluded that missionaries had failed to effectively communicate the heart of the faith. In a word, missionaries should have been more concerned with communicating a spiritual message and allowed the Japanese to develop their own cultural expression of the faith.
Another common criticism of the mission churches had to do with their doctrinal rigidity and intellectualism and their failure to give adequate attention to the experiential dimension of faith. Dissatisfaction with this overly cerebral version of Christianity appears in the writings of all the founders of indigenous movements. Some refer to it disparagingly as "conceptual Christianity," while others suggest it is a lifeless, hardened, or frozen form of Christianity. This hardened doctrinal understanding of
Christianity, these critics maintained, prevented missionaries from seeing the experiential dimension of faith so central to
the New Testament as well as the truth and goodness outside of their narrow denominational traditions.
While these theological differences were the source of considerable conflict, what the Japanese leaders found most unbearable was the condescending attitude of missionaries. Many missionaries, it seems, were unwilling to receive instruction from their Japanese disciples. Uchimura Kanzo * severely criticized this characteristic as he argued for an indigenous church:
Missionaries come to us to patronize us, to exercise lordship over us, in a word, to "convert" us; not to become our equals and friends, certainly not to become our servants and wash our feet. . . . We believe that the Gospel of Christ is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; but unless through God's grace we save ourselves, we shall not be saved—certainly not by foreign churches and missionaries.12
An incident recorded in the biography of Matsumura Kaiseki (1859–1939), an early convert of Dutch Reformed missionary James Ballagh and a member of the Yokohama Band, illustrates the tensions that existed between missionary teachers and their students. Matsumura, who had returned to Ballagh's school to assist with the teaching and supervision of students, recalls that on one occasion he explained to Ballagh that all of their missionary teaching and preaching would be of no avail if they continued to treat Japanese as no more than cooks or helper boys. Coming to her husband's defense, Mrs. Ballagh accused Matsumura of being possessed by the devil. He was promptly dismissed from his school responsibilities. After a varied career as a pastor, newspaper editor, and teacher, he eventually went on to organize an independent church, The Way.13
The founder of Christ Heart Church, Kawai Shinsui, who also began his Christian training and ministry at a missionrelated theological institution, departed because of conflict with the missionaries, and eventually went on to establish an independent church.14 Following theological studies at Tohoku* Gakuin College, an institution in Sendai related to the German Reformed Church, Kawai was assigned to a struggling mission church in the town of Tsuruoka in Yamagata Prefecture in 1901. Upon receiving word that his father was extremely ill, he left Tsuruoka to check on his condition without prior permission from the mission office in Sendai. His father's illness was so serious that he had his wife stay and care for him and requested a new assignment nearer his father's home. The mission board responded that it could neither give him another assignment nor approve of husband and wife living separately. Kawai, concluding that the missionary leadership was unreasonable and that his
Christian conscience demanded he fulfill his filial duties, terminated his association with the mission. Following a brief term as editor of the Hakodate Daily
Newspaper and several years as principal of Kyoai * Girls' School in Maebashi City, Gumma Prefecture, Kawai was appointed as head of the education department of the Gunze Silk Manufacturing Company in 1909. In 1927 Kawai established the independent Christ Heart Church within the grounds of Gunze.
However, the development of indigenous Christian movements was not merely the result of personality conflicts and power struggles with foreign missionaries. These disagreements, we must remember, did not occur in a placid environment. By the late Meiji period the social climate, following an earlier phase of worshipping everything Occidental, had become decidedly antiWestern and nationalistic. In his study of attitudes toward modernization in Japan, Marius Jansen notes that "the responses of representative and leading Japanese were necessarily conditioned by the climate of opinion within which they moved."15 This statement is equally valid with respect to Japanese Christian leaders active during this period. The establishment of State Shinto and the revival of Confucianism were thus accompanied by parallel developments among Japanese Christians.16 In the increasingly nationalistic environment the identification of Christianity with the West had become a stumbling block to propagation, and many leaders became convinced that "Japanization" or "deWesternization" was the only way forward.17 Independent indigenous movements were the most obvious expression of this process. While nationalism and conflict with missionaries were important precipitating factors that clarify the timing of these movements, we must consider other factors to explain their content.
The Enabling Factor: Imported and Native Elements
In referring to indigenous Christian movements as New Religions, I do not intend to suggest that they were created ex nihilo. New religions do not appear out of thin air, as Byron Earhart points out, but draw on "vital elements of the religious heritage."18 Consequently, we must give attention to this "enabling factor" in the development of New Religions.
In the Japanese context, New Religions draw from a vast reservoir of beliefs and practices related to ancestors, the spirit world, Buddhism, Shinto, and Confucianism. In his book Salvation Religions in Contemporary Society, for example, Shimazono Susumu, one of the leading scholars of Japanese New Religions, identifies syncretic folk religion, lay associations of the Nichiren Buddhist tradition, and Confucianistic moral cultivation movements as the
three primary sources that founders have drawn on in the development of new religious movements during the past two centuries. 19
Similarly, although the charismatic founders of Christian movements may have unusual insights and creative insights, they do not start from scratch when organizing a new church or movement. Rather, they draw on the imported teachings, rituals, and organizational forms of the mission churches as well as on various indigenous religious traditions. Notwithstanding the popular myth of the homogeneous Japanese, it is necessary for us to recognize the cultural diversity of this receiving society in order to understand these new indigenous forms of Christianity. Religious diversity (folk religion, Shinto, Buddhist sects, Confucianism) and competing group loyalties (rival clans, social classes, and regions) provided the complex matrix for Japan's encounter with Christianity. This is a significant point when we consider the reception, understanding, and reinterpretation of Christianity by indigenous movements in Japan. In our study of indigenization it is necessary to distinguish between the beliefs and practices of the various social strata that constitute the native culture to which Christianity has been forced to adapt. At the very least, we must distinguish between what might be called "elite religiosity" and "mass religiosity," the former being associated with the educated ruling class of samurai (and their successors) and the latter with the "ruled" majority of Japanese.
The Confucian ethos has certainly been a dominant element of the "elite" strata, while folk religion has provided the basic orientation for the masses. In terms of the movements under consideration in this study, those organized in the first three decades of this century largely represent an indigenous Christian expression of "elite religiosity," while those organized since the 1940s have closer connections with the folk religious traditions.20
In spite of the fact that indigenous movements share a number of features in common, each represents a distinct Christian subculture and must be understood as such. The founders of Japanese movements have maintained that truth and goodness are found not only in the Bible and Christian tradition but also in the religions of Asia, and that new insights could be drawn from spiritual experience or additional revelation from God. This inclusivistic approach to understanding Christianity is illustrated in figure 3. The religious experiences of indigenous leaders and their unique combination of foreign and native elements have given rise to the development of new Christian traditions in Japan. According to most indigenous movements, religious truth is not limited by the standards of orthodoxy as defined by Western theology and ancient church councils.21 Their newly crafted theology interprets the Bible in the light of native culture without
Figure 3.
Religious and Cultural Sources of Indigenous Christianity
the authoritative guidance of the ecumenical creeds. As one might expect, most missionary interpreters of Christianity maintained that the "orthodox" faith was to be based solely on the Scriptures (as defined and understood by the missionary's denominational tradition) and regarded religious experiences and additional sources of truth as unreliable or completely out of bounds. 22
It is no easy task to unravel the various transplanted and indigenous elements that have been adapted and incorporated into Japanese Christian subcultures. The JudeoChristian Scriptures add to the complexity of the situation, since many of the movements under consideration have attempted to recover "apostolic Christianity" by reading the Bible unmediated by church tradition and interpretation. This strategy is hardly new, and has been attempted repeatedly throughout the history of Christianity. The attempt to "return to the origins," however, inevitably results in the creation of new cultural forms. It has certainly led the Japanese in many different directions. This should hardly surprise us since the New Testament canon itself has preserved a "pluralism" of Christian traditions. In a widely known study, James D.
G. Dunn identifies Jewish Christianity, Hellenistic Christianity, Apocalyptic Christianity, and Early Catholicism as the primary traditions contained in the New Testament, noting:
There was no single normative form of Christianity in the first century. When we ask about the Christianity of the NT we are not asking about any one entity; rather we encounter different types of Christianity, each of which viewed others as too extreme in one respect or other—too conservatively Jewish or too influenced by antinomian or gnostic thought and practice, too enthusiastic or tending towards too much institutionalization.23
The differences between the various indigenous movements are related in part to those strands or traditions of the New Testament that they emphasize or neglect. Just like churches in the West, indigenous movements invariably operate with a "canon within the canon."
Table 3 highlights the dominant foreign and native influences on selected minor founders, whom we shall take up in more detail shortly. The religious experiences of minor founders and their unique combination of exogenous and indigenous elements have provided the basis for new formulations of Christian beliefs and doctrine, new rituals and forms of religious practice, new forms of social organization, and in some cases an enlarged canon of sacred texts. In the following chapters we will explore in more detail how different streams of foreign influence (reformed theology, pentecostalism, dispensationalism, Unitarianism) have been mixed in unique ways with indigenous elements to produce these alternative Japanese Christian traditions.
Table 3. Selected Minor Funders and Indigenous Movements
MINOR FOUNDER MOVEMENT DOMINANT WESTERN INFLUENCES DOMINANT NATIVE INFLUENCES
Uchimura Kanzo * (1861–1930) Nonchurch Movement (1901) William S. Clark, Professor and lay
Christian, Sapporo Agricultural
College, Amherst Confucianism Bushido*
Matsumura Kaiseki (1859–1939) Church of
Japan (1907)
The Way (1907) James Ballagh, Dutch Reformed
Church, Yokohama Band, New
Theology, Darwinism NeoConfucianism (Yomeigaku*), Shinto
Kawai Shinsui (1867–1962) Christ Heart Church (1927) Tohoku* Gakuin College (German Reformed Church) Confucianism, Buddhism,
mountain asceticism, Kyokenjutsu*
Murai Jun (1897–1970) Spirit of Jesus Church (1941) Aoyama Gakuin College
Methodism), True Jesus Church, Taiwan, Unitarian Pentecostalism Folk religious traditions and the ancestor cult
Otsuki* Takeji (1906–) Holy Ecclesia of Jesus (1946) Dispensationalism, Holiness tradition, revivalism, Roman Catholic spirituality, Jewish traditions, Zionism Nembutsu, ancestor cult
Teshima Ikuro* (1910–1973) Original Gospel or Tabernacle (1948) Zionism, Jewish traditions Uchimura Kanzo and
Nonchurch movement, folk religious traditions, mountain asceticism
Nakahara Masao (1948–) Okinawa Christian (Gospel (1977) Plymouth Brethren Missionary influence, Dispensationalism Okinawan shamanism
Minor Founders, Innovation, and Charismatic Authority
As we have seen, the antiWestern social climate, growing nationalism, and dissatisfaction with Western missionaries were important precipitating factors in the development of indigenous Christian movements. However, they still do not provide a complete explanation of the birth of these movements. Like other Japanese New Religions, indigenous Christian movements represent much more than reactions to social crises and imported Christianity. The break with Western mission churches and the creation of viable alternative forms required strong charismatic leaders. "The innovative decision of the founder," Byron Earhart points out, "cannot be completely subsumed by either social factors or the influence of prior religious factors." 24
Drawing attention to this "personalinnovative factor" in the study of religion is hardly new, but it is a factor worth reemphasizing in relation to the study of indigenous movements. Writing years ago, Joachim Wach also emphasized the need to consider the central experiences of the founders in order to understand the development of religions:
A sociological study of the personalities of the great founders of religion involves a difficulty which must be clearly recognized. The sociologist, though not called upon to deny or confirm religious claims, cannot ignore them. In estimating the effects of the initiative of the founders, their own theological claims must be taken into account, because the sociological effectiveness of their work is dependent on the significance which they attach to themselves and to their message.25
How are we to understand the charismatic leaders who play such a key role in the development of indigenous movements? Max Weber made no distinction between charismatic individuals who renewed an old religion and those who founded new religions, but subsumed both under the category of prophet.26 Werner Stark, however, drew attention to the need for another concept to deal with innovations within a religious tradition:
In order to describe Paul of Tarsus correctly, we need some such concept as that of a minor founder. In Paul, we behold an archetype which was to be reincarnated many times in the history of the Church. Behind him, there appear such figures as Benedict, Francis, Dominic, Bernard, Ignatius, Alphonso, and many others. They were all minor founders, revolutionaries and reformers and even reactionaries (goers back to the original) rolled into one, and certainly not routinizers in the sense of Kipling and Weber.27
Although Stark's comments are limited to the role of minor founders in the history of European or Western Christianity, this category seems equally relevant to understanding the development of Christianity in nonWestern contexts.
More recently, Anthony Blasi has drawn attention to the category of"minor founder" in his study of early Christianity, Making Charisma: The Social Construction of
Paul's Public Image. Arguing that Paul was much more than a "routinizer" of the charisma of Jesus, Blasi characterizes him as
a "minor founder," a founder who resembles major founders in so far as he was an agent of change but who was more conservative than they insofar as he maintained a basic continuity with what had come before him. Paul did something new, but he did it within an already recognizable Christian subculture. 28
Similarly, the charismatic leaders of indigenous Christian movements also create something new, but in recognizable continuity with an existing religious tradition. Minor founders in Japan departed from the religious traditions imported by foreign missionaries in significant ways, but at the same time passed the Christian heritage on to people in this new cultural context. Perhaps we could summarize by saying that a "minor founder" is a charismatic individual who gives birth to a new religious movement in an effort to address the needs of a new type of member, while at the same time conceiving of the movement as an extension, elaboration, or fulfillment of an existing religious tradition.
Although the indigenization of Christianity in Japan is the focus of this study, it is interesting to consider suggestive hints and parallels from the history of Buddhism in Japan. A number of Japanese scholars have noted the important role played by charismatic native leaders in the development of Japanese forms of Buddhism during the Kamakura period (1192–1336). Innovative Buddhist leaders such as Honen* (1133–1212), Shinran (1173–1263), and Nichiren (1222–1282) did much more than copy or translate Chinese Buddhist traditions. "New sects of 'Japanese' Buddhism," Fujii Masao explains, "were established through recording the founder's particular religious experience and particular doctrines."29 Similarly, Hoshino Eiki points out that these "founding figures in Japanese Buddhism appear, not only as eminently creative figures that initiated new doctrinal systems and methods of practice, but as beings that transcend time and place and have secured a kind of eternity in their charisma." In short, the indigenization and popularization of Buddhism in Japan had a great deal to do with these charismatic and innovative leaders.30
Interesting parallels have also been noted in the study of other Japanese New Religions. Shimazono Susumu, for example, makes a similar distinction
between those founders who are regarded as the "carriers" of ultimate truth and the embodiment of salvation and those who are seen as reformers or revitalizers of an existing religious tradition. In the latter case, the "founderlike leader" is essentially trying to recover the "original teaching" or rearticulate an existing religious tradition under new circumstances. The founders of Rissho * Kosei* Kai and Soka* Gakkai, for example, are regarded as revitalizers of the Nichiren Buddhist tradition rather than creators of entirely new religious traditions. Shimazono refers to this process as the placing of a particular religious movement within an existing tradition. This is precisely what has occurred in the development of indigenous Christian movements in Japan.31
From a sociological perspective, "charisma" and "charismatic authority" can only be understood in terms of the social relationship between leader and followers. An individual may claim to have had direct contact with God and to have received new revelations, but a movement will not be born unless the new message meets the needs and aspirations of a significant audience. The message must have some appeal, and potential followers must be convinced that the messenger has a special connection with the sacred.32 The break with existing tradition—in this case with imported mission churches—requires a powerful figure whose personhood authenticates the inevitable rupture. While founders vary in the degree to which they reject existing traditions and introduce new elements, at the very least they claim to have direct access to the sacred and an independent basis of religious authority. In Weberian terms, therefore, the appearance of minor founders in Japanese Christianity represents a shift from institutional "charisma" (i.e., the authority of the mission churches, creeds, clergy, and traditions) to the "personal charisma" of Japanese leaders.
Thus the charismatic authority of minor founders is based not only on their charismatic personalities but also on the persuasiveness of their claims to direct contact with the sacred and, occasionally, to additional revelations. Kawai Shinsui, the founder of Christ Heart Church, for example, argued that direct religious experience— satori—is what is required for real confidence, unmoving faith, and authority in religious matters. In his lectures on the New Testament letter to the Galatians, Kawai finds parallels between Paul's relationship with the church in Jerusalem and his own relationship with the mission churches.33 According to Kawai's reading of
Galatians, Paul taught that the core of the faith is direct experience of and relationship to God. Although Paul was criticized for not being a direct disciple of Jesus and had to face challenges to his authority, he maintained that his personal encounter with the living Christ on the road to Damascus legitimized his ministry. The legitimacy of Kawai's own ministry—
a ministry independent of the mission churches—was likewise grounded in profound religious experiences, in Kawai's case gained through intense training in remote mountain areas. Kawai elaborates this experiential foundation in his autobiography as follows: "As Jehovah appeared to Moses in thunder on Mt. Sinai, and Christ called to Paul in lightning in the neighborhood of Damascus God renewed all things in me through sacred Mt. Fuji." 34
All of the other minor founders likewise emphasize the importance of direct encounter with God through the Scriptures or religious experience—that is, through ways unmediated by Western theology or tradition. In addition to religious experience, miraculous healings have been important support for religious authority with most founders in the early stages of these movements. Thus Matsumura, Kawai, Murai, Teshima, Otsuki*, and Nakahara—six of the seven founders included in table 3 above—each claimed to have either experienced personal healing or been used by God to heal others.
During subsequent phases of the institutionalization process the charismatic authority of these minor founders is reconfirmed and routinized. In some cases the teachings and writings of the founder come to be viewed as of equal or similar authority to the Bible. Even if religious groups distinguish in principle between the canon (Bible) and the founder's writings, in practice the latter tend to function with similar authority in the community. Religious services normally include numerous references to the founder's teachings, actions, or writings. Just as Christians normally view the Hebrew Bible and Jesus' interpretations of these ancient texts as "sacred," members of indigenous Christian movements tend to merge the Scriptures and their founder's interpretation.35
These minor founders sometimes even become the object of veneration. Kawai Shinsui, for example, is paid ritual respect, with bows to his photograph at the beginning and end of each service. His writings are also quoted as frequently as the JudeoChristian scriptures. On a number of occasions I have even heard the deceased founder addressed in prayer ("Chichinaru Kamisama, Iesu Kirisuto, mata Kawai Shinsui Sensei" ["Father God, Jesus Christ, and Kawai Shinsui . . ."]), expressing the conviction that he is now in the immediate company of the heavenly hosts.
This tendency to venerate minor founders has a long history, as Nakamura Hajime explains with reference to Japanese Buddhism:
One result of this absolute devotion to a specific person is that the faithful of the various Japanese sects are extreme in the veneration with which they acknowledge the founder of the sect and perform religious ceremonies around him as the nucleus. One has absolute faith in the master as well as in the Buddha, with
out feeling that there is the slightest contradiction. It is not that one pays less attention to the Buddha, but the idea is perhaps that a profound faith in the master and devotion to the Buddha have the same significance. 36
In much the same way, members of Christ Heart Church appear to experience no cognitive conflict in ''believing in Jesus Christ" and venerating the founder, Kawai Shinsui, who made the salvific significance of Christ real to them through his teaching and example.37
What distinguishes indigenous Christian movements from other New Religions is the fact that minor founders link their new insights to the existing religious tradition.
This can take the form of "fulfillment" or "restorationist" explanations. In fulfillment explanations the teaching of these founders is understood as the additional truth
Jesus promised his disciples ("when the Spirit comes he will guide you into all truth," John 16:13). This new insight fulfills or even supersedes the understanding of Christianity found in the Western churches. In restorationist explanations Western churches are viewed as degenerate, and indigenous movements assert that they are only recovering or restoring important truths once held by the early church. No matter how severely these movements are assessed or criticized by mission churches or the dominant orthodoxy, in one form or another each regards itself as a continuation of the Christian religion or, at the very least, as a fuller expression of the teachings and intention of Jesus.
The Reappearance of Charismatic Christianity
All of the indigenous movements established in Japan had charismatic beginnings and emphasized direct religious experience. The break with the mission churches required the strong leadership of charismatic individuals who had selfauthenticating religious insight and authority. Japanese Christianity, as Uchimura Kanzo* put it,
"is Christianity received by Japanese directly from God without any foreign intermediary; no more, no less."38 For Uchimura this direct encounter with God came about through reading the Scriptures with one's own eyes and heart. This required that one ignore the denominational traditions and creeds and "return to the original Scriptures." Uchimura's Sunday services became, therefore, Bible lectures that explored the original Greek and Hebrew.39
Without denying the importance of Uchimura's movement in the development of Christianity in Japan, it must be recognized that the Nonchurch movement represents only one type of indigenous Christianity. The attention given to
Uchimura Kanzo * by both Japanese and Western scholars and the productivity of many biblical scholars associated with the Nonchurch movement have contributed to a onesided and somewhat distorted understanding of indigenous Christianity. Uchimura clearly served as an inspiration to many other Japanese Christians, but his interpretation of Christianity, and the Nonchurch movement itself, subsequently became the target of criticism because of their intellectual and Confucian orientation.
While the charismatic nature (in Weberian or sociological terms) of Uchimura and other founders is important, in what remains of this chapter I would like to consider the broader manifestation of the "world of Spirit" in indigenous Christian movements. As may be seen in table 4, the development of most indigenous movements has been accompanied by a wide range of charismatic or Pentecostal phenomena. In many respects these indigenous expressions of Christianity represent a revitalization of the primordial spiritualistic worldview referred to above. In spite of Uchimura's personal charisma, the Nonchurch movement has lacked the charismatic phenomena associated with Christianity in the New Testament and reemphasized by most indigenous movements in Japan. Perhaps it would be more accurate to say that charismatic expressions of Nonchurch Christianity have been forced to develop as separate movements—both the Original Gospel movement and the Japan Ecclesia of Christ were founded by teachers who began as members of the Nonchurch movement.40 Thus the charismatic features that characterize most indigenous movements deserve fuller treatment.
Continuing Revelation and Modified Canon
The traditional Protestant understanding of revelation has been that God spoke through the prophets, Jesus, and the apostles, and that this process of revelation ended with the canonization of the Old and New Testament Scriptures. Most Protestant denominations maintain that the charismatic gifts also ended with the early church, since their primary purpose was to confirm the truth of the Gospel for the first Christian communities. Indigenous movements, for the most part, maintain that God's selfrevelation did not end with the canon of the Christian Scriptures, and that God continues to reveal deeper truths to those who are open to the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit. While most of these movements operate with the closed canon, many share a common belief that God continues to reveal new truths hidden from or as yet ungrasped by Western churches.
Table 4. Charismatic Features of Indigenous Christianity
Matsumura Kaiseki and Kawai Shinsui, the founders of two of the older movements, The Way and Christ Heart Church, both believed that revelation from God not only continues today but is also to be found outside of the JudeoChristian Scriptures. In their various writings they record a number of revelations from God that were important for shaping their religious consciousness. While many Protestant missionaries interpreted commitment to Jesus Christ as requiring a rejection and devaluation of all other religious traditions, both Matsumura and Kawai argued that the scriptures of various Asian religions were likewise vehicles of revelation. Kawai pointed out repeatedly that Jesus came to "fulfill" rather than "destroy" what had come before him (Mt. 5:17). For Kawai this included not only the Old Testament but also the wisdom, ideals, and aspirations of the religious traditions of Asia. In fact, Kawai referred to these traditions and their writings as the "Old Testament for Japanese
Christians."
Kawai claimed that saints like Buddha and Confucius, like Jesus Christ and the Old Testament prophets before him, were sent to their respective countries according to the grace and providence of God. Through the discipline of meditation he likewise realized that "the mind of Christ and the spirit of Confucius were indeed similar manifestations," so much so that he revered Confucius "as a forerunner to Christ." The reason why there is truth and goodness in these Asian traditions worthy of our study and inclusion, Kawai explains, is that both Buddha and Confucius had encountered the spirit of Christ. 41
Prophecies, visions, and special messages from God have also been important for the Christian Canaan Church, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, and the Spirit of Jesus Church. In 1938, for example, the founder of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus received special revelations regarding Israel and the Second Coming of Christ—revelations that have come to be central to the life and mission of this church today. Followers believe that the founder, Father Otsuki*, continues to receive special guidance from God. Examples of continuing revelation also abound in the Spirit of Jesus Church. In 1941 the founder's wife, Murai Suwa, received a direct revelation from God that the official name of the church was to be Iesu no mitama Kyokai*. The indigenous hymnbook used by this church is likewise based on revelatory experiences. Rei sanka (Spirit hymns) is a collection of 166 hymns all said to have been received from heaven by Tsuruhara Tama, a woman who was active in the early years of this church. The preface to this hymnbook states that no changes in the contents are permitted since the hymns were given in a direct revelation from God.
While all of these movements recognize the validity of continuing revelation, only The Way and the Christ Heart Church have redefined the Christian
canon according to their new understanding of the faith. As early as 1908, Matsumura Kaiseki stated that The Way would add to its canon of Scriptures as it deemed appropriate. 42 In 1928, The Way published a selection of passages from the writings of the NeoConfucian O* Yomei* (Chin., Wang YangMing ) for one service each month.45
The Christian canon was also modified by Christ Heart Church under the influence of Kawai Shinsui. As noted above, Kawai felt that many of the sacred writings of the East represented a form of "Old Testament" for the Japanese. Next to the Bible, for example, he recommended that his followers read the Analects of Confucius. Although Kawai expressed high regard for these other scriptures, he did not designate them officially as a part of the canon. Several of his own writings, however, have been designated as such and have a central place in the teaching and liturgy of the church today. These include the Seven Great Vows ( Kanzen no shinko*).
Spirit Baptism, Tongues, and Healing
The recovery of apostolic Christianity has been regarded as the primary aim of many indigenous movements. Teshima Ikuro*, the founder of the Original Gospel, explained that for this to occur Japanese would have to encounter the
same heavenly light that transformed "Saul" into "Paul." The Old Testament prophets, the apostles, and all of the early Christians after Pentecost had this transformative encounter with the Holy Spirit and the light from above. According to Teshima, two things are essential for authentic religion: the encounter with light and the baptism of the Spirit. Belief in Christian teachings alone is clearly inadequate. We need an experience that converts us and brings us new life. 46
While the baptism of the Holy Spirit is regarded as indispensable by many of these movements, their interpretation of this experience tends to differ somewhat, following two basic patterns. The Glorious Gospel Christian Church, Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church, the Sanctifying Christ Church, and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus all resemble the Holiness tradition, emphasizing baptism by the Holy Spirit and the miraculous gift of healing. These groups do not regard speaking in tongues as a necessary "sign" of this baptism, nor do they regard tongues as significant for church life today. The Christian Canaan Church, Spirit of Jesus Church, Original Gospel movement, LifeGiving Christ, Japan Ecclesia of Christ, and the Okinawa Christian Gospel maintain that the signs, miracles of healing, exorcism, and tongues that accompanied the coming of the Holy Spirit in the New Testament (Acts 2, 5, 19) are still present and will be until the end of the church age.47 Most groups follow the New Testament example of anointing with olive oil to cure sickness (James 5:14). In fact, oil is kept in a small container on the front altar of many churches for regular use in healing rituals (this is especially true in the Spirit of Jesus Church and Holy Ecclesia of Jesus).
In order to experience the baptism of the Holy Spirit, a number of different approaches are advocated. When the Spirit of Jesus Church presents the Gospel to newcomers they call individuals to accept Jesus and encourage them to be baptized in the spirit and water immediately, chanting "receive the Holy Spirit, receive water baptism." To bring on the experience of spirit baptism and speaking in tongues, individuals are encouraged to repeat the phrase "hallelujah" over and over again. Teshima Ikuro* often held allnight prayer meetings to provide the time necessary and create the atmosphere conducive to this emotional religious experience. Other movements introduce this teaching more gradually and usually with less pressure. While these groups may differ in their interpretation of baptism and in the significance they place on speaking in tongues, all of them agree that Christianity today is to be a religion of "signs and wonders" just as in New Testament times (see Mark 16).
Spirit World Interaction
Most of the movements covered in this study share what might be referred to as a "spiritualistic worldview." This worldview consists of a belief in the reality and interdependence of "this world" and another "spirit world" (i.e., the world of the ancestors). Transplanted missionary Christianity, for the most part, advocated a complete severing of relations with the spirit world. Many indigenous Christian movements, on the other hand, articulate the meaning of the Christian faith in terms of an ongoing interaction between these two worlds. This is a particularly important dimension of indigenous movements, one that we will consider in some detail in chapter seven.
Chapter Four— The Fountainhead of Japanese Christianity Revisited
While one of the aims of this book is to give attention to a number of relatively unknown indigenous movements, the numerous references to the Nonchurch movement and quotations from Uchimura's writings thus far show how impossible it is to entirely ignore this earliest expression of Japanese Christianity. Uchimura's writings contained numerous strands of thought that were subsequently elaborated (and sometimes rejected) by other leaders and movements. In short, the Nonchurch movement is significant not only as an independent expression of Christianity but also for what it has given birth to throughout its history. Without a central authority or bureaucracy, it has functioned as the fountainhead of indigenous Christianity in Japan and given rise to many other movements.
Many Japanese critics of transplanted mission churches expressed a longing for the "pure" or "spiritual" religion of Jesus without Western institutions, rites, and dogmas. The God of Christianity "is spirit and truth," Uchimura wrote, ''and they that worship Him are commanded to worship in spirit and truth—i.e., without forms, or with a minimum of forms." 1 Nitobe Inazo*, however, recognized that ultimately a religion without forms or "human wrappage" [sic] was impossible and pleaded for the development of"homemade garments." The fact that a number of Japanese accepted Christianity but rejected missionary traditions implied there were alternative interpretations of the Christian faith with their accompanying cultural forms and institutions. Charismatic minor founders were not only responsible for the break with transplanted mission churches and traditions but subsequently became the creative force in the development of new Christian traditions. As F. F. Bruce has perceptively observed, "It is noteworthy how often the renunciation of an old tradition is followed by the speedy development of a new one, held at least as tenaciously as ever the old one was."2 Although these words were written in a very different context, they accurately capture the process of "traditionmaking" in Japanese Christianity.
Uchimura Kanzo* and the Nonchurch Movement
The Nonchurch movement is undoubtedly the most widely known and respected expression of Japanese Christianity. This is due largely to the fact that Uchimura was a prolific writer respected by many individuals both within and outside Christian circles. The complete works of Uchimura consists of some 50 volumes: 17 primarily biblical and exegetical studies, 25 volumes of theological and topical works, and 8 volumes of diaries and correspondence. Many of his disciples have likewise been wellknown intellectual figures, authors, and university presidents. In light of Uchimura's prominent place in Japanese intellectual history and in the development of Christianity in Japan, it is understandable why he and his movement have been the focus of so much attention. The literature produced by or about this movement is now so immense that a 1990 bibliography of materials related to Uchimura and the Nonchurch movement exceeded 100 pages.3 Each year since then new materials have continued to roll off the press.
Another reason Uchimura and the Nonchurch movement are widely recognized, at least in church circles, is due in part to the work of Emil Brunner, the Swiss theologian, who became fascinated with this movement during his stay in Japan from 1953 to 1955. Brunner was quite sympathetic with the aims
of the Nonchurch movement as a lay reform movement within Christianity. He subsequently played a major role in introducing this form of Christianity to the Western world through his writings in German and English. Many observers have recognized that Brunner was an important "bridge" between this independent movement and the established churches while in Japan. 4
Uchimura Kanzo*, on a walk near Tozanso*, 1917 (age 57).
In his otherwise illuminating monograph, Carlo Caldarola mistakenly defined his study of the Nonchurch movement as an analysis of an indigenous form of Christianity
"totally independent of Western influence."5 While the Nonchurch movement and other indigenous movements have clearly been independent of Western "control," they have hardly been independent of Western influence. In stark contrast to Caldarola's view, Ohta maintains that "Uchimura was a man nurtured by Western culture for the whole of his life," and as evidence points to the library Uchimura bequeathed to Hokkaido* University: 746 titles were books in European languages (mostly English) and only 109 titles in Japanese and Chinese.6 What obviously needs to be clarified is how Uchimura and leaders of other movements have critically appropriated imported traditions and reshaped them in light of Japanese concerns and native religious and cultural traditions.
Western Traditions and the Bible in Uchimura's Christianity
For all his stress on "independence" and the need for a Japanese Christianity, Uchimura's version of the faith is clearly indebted to various Western traditions. His first serious encounter with Christianity occurred as a young man at Sapporo Agricultural College. Prior to Uchimura's arrival, William S. Clark had spent the year assisting the Japanese government in the establishment of this
Uchimura Kanzo *, standing beside a stack of his biblical writings, 1925 (age 65).
college. While his primary role was to teach agriculture, Clark was a committed lay Christian who introduced his students to the Christian faith through a Bible class (see chapter two). All of his students converted and signed the "Covenant of Believers in Jesus," committing themselves to continue studying the Bible and to do their best to live ethical lives. Clark returned to the United States after less than one year, but Uchimura felt his influence through the small Covenant group that was left behind. Under considerable pressure from his sempai (the upper classmen), Uchimura signed the Covenant during his first year at the college at the age of sixteen and went on to receive baptism from a Methodist missionary in 1878.7 Dissatisfaction with the mission church, however, led Uchimura and his Japanese cohorts to establish an independent church in Sapporo, an experiment that was a precursor to the Nonchurch movement. Through Clark's teaching and example, this small band of Japanese Christians understood that it was possible to practice or live an authentic life of faith without dependence on an institution or clergy. This became the central affirmation of Uchimura's Christianity.
This evangelical faith was nurtured over a fouryear period (1884–1888) in the United States. Uchimura departed for the United States following a brief and unhappy first marriage. He was first befriended by Mr. and Mrs. Wister Morris, a committed Quaker couple, who helped him find employment shortly after his arrival in Pennsylvania. The faith and pacifism of these Quakers made a lasting impression upon Uchimura. Following eight months of stressful work in a mental hospital, Uchimura resigned and traveled through New England, entering Amherst College in September 1885. Julius Hawley Seelye, the president of Amherst College, became his spiritual mentor and guided him into a deeper understanding of the Christian faith.
It was while a student at Amherst College that Uchimura had a profound religious experience that gave him an inward confirmation of his faith. Settling into his dormitory room at Amherst, he vowed "never to move from the place till the Almighty should show Himself unto me." The 8 March 1886 entry to his diary records the revelatory experience as follows:
Very important day in my life. Never was the atoning power of Christ more clearly revealed to me than it is today. In the crucifixion of the Son of God lies the solution of all the difficulties that buffeted my mind thus far. Christ paying all my debts, can bring me back to the purity and innocence of the first man before the Fall. Now I am God's child, and my duty is to believe Jesus. For His sake, God will give me all I want. He will use me for His glory, and will save me in Heaven at last. 8
This religious experience, combined with studies with Dr. Seelye and others at Amherst, had a lasting influence. Writing many years later in his magazine, The
Christian Intelligencer, Uchimura still spoke highly of this man: "The great president opened my eyes to the evangelical truth in Christianity. He is my father. For forty years, since then, I preached the faith taught me by that venerable teacher."9 Reflecting on his spiritual pilgrimage thus far, Uchimura explains that he became aware of his condition as a "sinner" through his participation in the Covenant of Believers in Sapporo, but for years had tried to achieve personal holiness by his own efforts. It was not until the "revelatory" experience at Amherst that he truly realized the evangelical gospel that his righteousness was in the crucified Christ and not something achieved by his own effort.
With Seelye's encouragement, Uchimura went on to Hartford Theological Seminary in the fall of 1887, after graduation from Amherst. He only studied at the seminary for one year, returning to Japan in 1888. While Uchimura had a great deal of respect for some clergymen and theologians, he wanted no part of the ordained ministry. Uchimura explains that his samurai background was the basis for rejecting ordination, because "priests live by charity, and we believed the sword to be a more honorable means of existence than charity." In Japan the Christian ministry, furthermore, implied subservience to a foreign power:
To be a priest is bad enough; but to be a Christian priest I considered to be the end of my doom. In a heathen country like mine, Christian ministers are supported either directly or indirectly by foreigners, and are to place themselves under the jurisdiction of foreign bishops of one kind or another.10
Uchimura returned to Japan in 1888 at the age of twentyseven with an evangelical Protestant faith deeply rooted in the Bible and New England
Puritanism. These were the formative Christian traditions behind Uchimura's independent expression of Japanese Christianity. Even today, insiders define the
Nonchurch movement as an expression of Christianity whose "father" is Puritanism and whose "mother" is Quakerism, born in Japan according to the direct revelation of God. 11 In essence, Uchimura gratefully received the Bible and its message of salvation from the missionaries, but found he had no use for Western ecclesiastical traditions. In fact, Uchimura conceived of the Nonchurch movement as an effort to complete the Protestant Reformation, which had ended prematurely as "an arrested movement." According to Uchimura:
Protestantism institutionalized was a return back to the discarded Roman Catholicism. We need another Reformation to bring Protestantism to its logical conclusion. The new Protestantism must be perfectly free without a trace of ecclesiasticism in it—a fellowship, not an institution—free communion of souls, not a system or an organization. Practically, it will be a churchless Christianity, calling no man bishop or pastor, save Jesus Christ, the Son of God. (April 1928)12
As a continuation of the Protestant movement, Uchimura stressed the "priesthood of all believers" and rejected an ordained clergy or priesthood that stood as an intermediary between the individual and God. Likewise, Uchimura continued to stress the characteristic Protestant doctrine of salvation by faith, and for that reason rejected the sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper (Eucharist). These were understood as the two remaining ritual obligations associated with Christianity that the Protestant Reformation in Europe had failed to eliminate. Requiring observance of these rituals, Uchimura reasoned, obscured the Biblical teaching of salvation by faith and cultivated a dependence on a separate priestly class. In an effort to complete the Reformation, therefore, Uchimura rejected the sacraments and an ordained clergy set apart for their proper observance. These theological emphases in Uchimura's faith are hardly "unique" Japanese interpretations of the Biblical tradition, but resemble other movements that developed in the West. As Paul Peachey explains:
Phenomenologically, the movement Uchimura initiated would fall somewhere between Quakerism and Anabaptism. Like the Quakers, though not for the same reasons,
Mukyokai*shugi [Nonchurch ideology] rejects clergy, hierarchy, and sacraments. Like the Anabaptists, Mukyokaishugi is Biblecentered rather than dependent on the "inner light."13
Uchimura's faith continued to evolve over the course of his life. Two particular emphases that emerge later on are pacifism and a strong faith in the Second Coming of
Christ. Within a few years of his return to Japan, Uchimura
backed the Japanese government in the SinoJapanese War. He regarded Japan's involvement in Korea as a "holy war," necessary to protect this small struggling nation from China. Following the end of the war in 1895, however, he came to regret his earlier support, since Japan did not honor the provisions of the peace treaty. A decade later Uchimura took a stand against the Japanese government in the RussoJapanese War (1904–1905). Over against his earlier support of the use of the sword to bring about justice, Uchimura had become an outspoken critic of Japan's military involvements and a convert to the pacifism of his Quaker friends. 14 Some years later Uchimura reached the conclusion that peace could ultimately be realized only by God's direct intervention in human affairs. It was this rather late discovery of faith in the Second Coming of Christ that gave Uchimura hope for the future.15 He declared his belief in the Second Coming of Christ in 1918 and became actively involved in promoting this doctrine among Christians throughout Japan. Uchimura felt that this issue was so important that he participated in a speaking tour with the Holiness Church leader Nakada Juji* and Congregationalist Pastor Kimura Seimatsu, traveling to Osaka, Kyoto, Kobe*, Hokkaido*, Fukushima, Miyagi, Okayama, and Yamagata. During the course of one year Uchimura gave sixty lectures dealing with the Second Coming, reaching close to twenty thousand with his message. Uchimura came under considerable criticism for his advocacy of this "apocalyptic" version of Christianity.16
Christianity As a Japanese Religion
With so much in common with Western interpretations of Christianity, one may wonder what could be "indigenous" about Uchimura's version of the faith. While Uchimura was clearly indebted to certain aspects of Western Christianity, he rejected the denominationalism and displacement theology of the mission churches, arguing that native traditions provided a positive foundation for Christianity in Japan. In order to create authentic faith in Japan, Uchimura reasoned, Japanese Christians must build on this foundation independent of Western church control and finances. Uchimura's first job upon returning from the United States was as principal of Hokuetsu Gakkan, a boys' school in Niigata. Uchimura quickly ran into trouble with missionaries associated with the school when he sought to introduce lectures on Confucianism and Buddhism into the curriculum. Fundamental differences with these missionaries over educational policy led Uchimura to resign from this post in less than a year after his appointment.
While missionaries could only see discontinuity between the Gospel and Japanese culture, Uchimura found many positive connections. One significant pattern in the new indigenous traditions of Christian thought may be referred to as the "Christianization of the preChristian past." 17 As Japanese struggled to make sense of the
Christian faith for themselves, it was only natural that they sought to find common ground and points of continuity with native traditions and religious experience. Japanese Christians felt the need to redeem the past and consider how God had been at work in Japanese history and culture before the arrival of Western missionaries. Again, Uchimura Kanzo* led the way in articulating this more inclusive conception of truth over against the dominant missionary perspective. Writing in his English magazine, the Christian Intelligencer, Uchimura argued:
The faultfinder can never be Christian. He is bound to be a truthhunter in everybody and in everything. Those representatives of the Christian Religion who take delight in finding darkness in other religions other than their own are very poor representatives of their religion. The Christian is glad when he meets goodness in Buddhism, Confucianism, Taoism, anywhere. His eyes are sharpened to detect light, and he is loathe to look at darkness. Therefore, when Christianity shines with its genuine light, it is the discoverer of what is best in the world.18
In his April 1926 editorial, Uchimura went on to express the inclusive orientation of his faith in a short piece on the relationship between Buddha and Christ. Buddha and Christ
Buddha is the Moon; Christ is the Sun.
Buddha is the Mother; Christ is the Father. Buddha is Mercy; Christ is Righteousness.
. . . I love the moon and I love the night; but as the night is far spent and the day is at hand, I now love the Sun more than I love the Moon; and I know that the love of the Moon is included in the love of the Sun, and that he who loves the Sun loves the Moon also.19
Uchimura spent most of his life in serious Bible study and teaching and never went on to elaborate this perspective in a detailed study of Asian religions, but his fundamental outlook was shared by other founders of indigenous Christian movements. Truth and goodness were to be found outside of the narrowly defined missionary traditions.
Uchimura's interpretation of Christianity reveals an indebtedness to the ethical traditions associated with the samurai or warrior class. Born into a samurai
family, Uchimura was shaped by the values and traditions summed up by the word bushido *, the way of the samurai. According to Uchimura's account, his father was a "good Confucian scholar" who passed on to him the precepts of the Chinese sages. "Loyalty to my feudal lords, and fidelity and respects [sic] to my parents and teachers, were the central themes of the Chinese ethics."20 Uchimura's Confucian version of Christianity is related to the fact that his primary concern was to graft Christianity on to bushido.
Bushido* is the finest product of Japan. But bushido by itself cannot save Japan. Christianity grafted upon Bushido will be the finest product of the world. It will save, not only Japan, but the whole world. . . . There was a meaning in the history of Japan. For twenty centuries God has been perfecting bushido with this very moment in view. Christianity grafted upon bushido will yet save the world. (January 1916)21
"Independent, moneyhating, loyal"—these were the values and virtues that made even the Apostle Paul "a true samurai, the very embodiment of the spirit of bushido."22
In addition to the ethical values of loyalty, duty, and filial piety, Uchimura looked to the Confucian educational model based on a personal relationship between teacher and disciple as the appropriate pattern for the development of Christianity in Japan.23 After his return from the United States, he reached the conclusion that the Western denominational forms were illsuited to Japan and decided to organize along the lines of a school or juku. Instead of worship services in church buildings, Uchimura held lectures in rented halls and homes. Although Uchimura rejected Western denominationalism, he could not entirely resist the need for some kind of organization.
During Uchimura's lifetime, the Nonchurch movement took various organizational forms. His direct disciples were essentially paying members of his private school. As subscribers to his magazine grew, supporters outside of Tokyo sought some ongoing relationship with other Nonchurch members. Uchimura organized the Kyoyukai* in 1905, with 14 branches and 119 members. The purpose of this association was defined in the following profession of faith:
We who believe in God and His Only Son whom he sent (into the world), uniting together, form the Kyoyukai. With the help of God the Father we shall help our comrades and live lives that are in harmony with His sovereign Will.
Membership was restricted to individuals who had "endeavored to live the Christian life for at least a year." The guidelines for this early association included a commitment to meet monthly, to spend Sunday nurturing faith and
morals, and to abstain from tobacco and liquor. Another group called the Kashiwagi Brotherhood formed around Uchimura in 1918 to support his adventist lecture meetings around the country. This group was dissolved after two years. 24
Uchimura was surrounded by various informal groups of supporters throughout the remainder of his life and continued his Sunday Bible lectures. After his death the group that had formed around his weekly Bible lectures was disbanded and his publication, Seisho no kenkyu* (Bible studies) was terminated. Following Uchimura's example, the Nonchurch movement continued as a lay movement guided by a number of charismatic teachers and evangelists. As a lay Christian movement, members were expected to evangelize in and through their secular occupations. The religious authority of Nonchurch movement leaders continues to be based on personal charisma, since there is no central organization or institution for the training and ordination of religious specialists. In clear contrast to the understanding and practice of leadership and authority in established churches, where leaders are educated, tested, and ordained, successive leaders in the Nonchurch movement embark on an independent ministry on the basis of their individual charismatic authority without fulfilling formal requirements.25 New groups are formed when an individual is confident of his own understanding of the Bible and senses a personal call to form an independent meeting. Following Uchimura's example, most teachers publish their own monthly Bible study magazines. These publications and special lectures are regarded as the primary means of evangelism.
The financial base of the Nonchurch movement also differs from that of the mission churches. Admission fees to Bible lectures and magazine subscriptions have replaced the church finances based on offerings or tithe. In other words, the Nonchurch movement leaders "earn" their own way rather than receiving a salary. Although Uchimura rejected Western institutions and the ordained clergy, one could make the case that the teachers or sensei in the Nonchurch movement have a special status in spite of their rhetoric about being equal participants in a lay movement. While the Nonchurch movement's organizational structure is quite fluid, with Bible study groups dissolving and reforming, charismatic teachers exercise considerable religious authority over their followers. As Ohara Shin points out:
Each sensei functions as a minor 'shaman' who has charisma. He is not only the teacher for the religious subject concerned, but also an advisor in the personal affairs of his disciples—as in arranging marriages and choosing occupations.26
In spite of Uchimura's numerous references to the bushido * foundation of his faith, in many respects the ethos and practice of the Nonchurch movement resembles the expression of Christianity he encountered during his time of study in the United States. Some would argue that it is much more than simple "resemblance." Tosh Arai, for example, maintains that the Nonchurch movement is as indebted to New England Puritan Christianity as the transplanted mission churches. His observations are worth quoting at length:
Both the Mukyokai* and church Christians in Japan are twin babies of New England Puritanism. After I had discovered that nineteenthcentury American Protestantism was the prototype for Japanese Protestant institutions, I spent two years in New England comparing the two. To my surprise, the Mukyokai Christians, who have claimed to be the most nationalistic and indigenous Japanese Protestants, can be shown to have deep roots in American Christianity. The distinctive spirit of American Christianity over the last two hundred years has been one of independence and selfsupport. I checked through the records of missionary conferences in Japan during the 1880s, and I found a strong emphasis on establishing "selfsupporting churches." The long Biblecentered sermons, the simple antiliturgical services, the attacks on church symbolism, and the teetotaler moralism were all there. We even adopted a style of church buildings at the time when American churches were at their ugliest. In fact, New England church buildings were called "meeting houses," and the Mukyokai people translated this into Japanese, kogisho*.27
Impossible as it is to determine whether "native" elements or "foreign" elements were most influential in shaping the stark and simple style of the movement, the subservient place of women in the movement is clearly indebted to Uchimura's Confucian heritage. The Confucian orientation of this movement, especially during the first and second generations, has been widely recognized. Uchimura was far more conservative than many missionaries and Japanese church leaders when it came to the status and role of women. Unlike more progressive leaders, such as Uemura Masahisa and Ebina Danjo*, Uchimura continued to hold the oldfashioned view that women should walk behind men. Even at his Bible lectures, men and women were expected to sit on different sides of the hall.28 Carlo Caldarola's study discovered that the Nonchurch movement prides itself on being a "manly expression of Christianity." This is reflected not only in the dominance of male leadership, but also in the fact that over sixty percent of the membership is male. Today there are feminist groups within the Nonchurch movement who are critical of this Confucian heritage and who actively advocate change, but the Confucian orientation still predominates.
Closing ceremony of Uchimura's Kashiwagi Bible Seminar.
For Uchimura, the Confucianoriented bushido * tradition provided the foundation for Japanese Christianity; at the same time, the Gospel was understood as a fulfillment of the religious aspirations of Japanese Buddhists. A common distinction in Japanese Buddhism is often made between the two paths of selfpower (jiriki
). Carlo Caldarola referred to the Nonchurch movement as a ''Zenlike Christianity," because Uchimura and his followers reported a satoritype experience of forgiveness and salvation.29 I find this designation misleading, however, since Zen is associated primarily with the path of jiriki, whereas Uchimura placed a primary emphasis on a tarikilike salvation by faith. Furthermore, Biblical teaching and lectures, rather than meditation, form the core of the Nonchurch movement religious life. Uchimura, in fact, points to close parallels between Christianity and the Pure Land Buddhist faith in Amida, or "other power."
Salvation by faith is a higher and deeper faith than salvation by works. If Buddhists should know upon what firm ethical bases the Christian justification by faith is grounded, they would transfer their allegiance to Christianity, without repudiating their allegiance to their old faith. The simple fact that Amida
was a mythical personage while Jesus Christ was a historical person ought to be enough to induce all thinking people to seek the rest to their minds and souls in the latter rather than in the former. I speak this without any spirit of proselytism, which I hate with all my heart. The time when the Japanese evangelical Buddhists find the true foundation of their faith in "Him who was crucified for the sins of the world," will be the time when the world will witness the greatest revival that has ever happened. . . . May such a time come soon; and come it will, if Christianity is presented to them not as a foreign religion by foreign missionaries, but as a Japanese religion by Japanese messengers.( June 1926) 30
For almost a century Uchimura and his successors have presented Christianity as an authentic "Japanese religion." The mass conversion of Japanese Buddhists, nevertheless, seems as remote a possibility today as it did when these words were first written.
Conclusion
Uchimura's Japanese interpretation of Christianity, although highly influential among intellectuals, never became the foundation for a mass movement. It did, however, contain potent ideas that were developed by other indigenous leaders. Over against the ecclesiasticism and extrabiblical traditions of the transplanted mission churches, Uchimura and his followers claimed to have a Biblecentered faith rooted in the apostolic message of the cross, resurrection, and second coming of Christ. Even though Uchimura identified the bushido* tradition as a positive indigenous foundation, the Bible is regarded as central to Nonchurch Christianity. The lectures, magazine articles, and scholarly studies of the original Hebrew and Greek Bible are clear enough evidence of this. But while it is undeniable that Uchimura drew heavily on the Biblical tradition, at the same time it must be recognized that he was selective and clearly operated with a "canon within the canon."
In general terms, one could say that Uchimura was enamored of the "prophetic" tradition over against the "priestly" tradition in the HebrewChristian Scriptures. His writings clearly echo the prophetic critique of ceremonialism and hypocrisy in religious practice. His closest disciples certainly regarded him as a modern prophet, placing him in the company of Amos, Isaiah, and Jeremiah.31 Although the Hebrew Bible also accords an important place and legitimacy to the Levitical priesthood in the religious life of Israel, this form of religion is clearly inferior for Uchimura and irrelevant to his concerns. Likewise, the earliest "Jewish" version of the Jesus movement, which included
traditional Jewish laws, observances, and customs, is also largely ignored. In terms of the New Testament traditions identified by James Dunn, Uchimura's Christianity was based primarily on the Hellenistic tradition. The Apostle Paul, missionary to the Gentiles, was in many respects Uchimura's ideal. Independent of the Jerusalem church, Paul worked as a tentmaker to support himself as he spread the Gospel throughout the Roman Empire. Although Uchimura did discover the New Testament's Apocalyptic tradition rather late in life, he never recognized (or rejected) what scholars regard as the "early Catholic" tradition in the New Testament, writings that show the early "routinization of charisma" and concern with church structures, religious authority, and leadership (i.e., bishops, presbyters, and deacons).
32 These neglected traditions were to become important for several indigenous Christian movements that developed in the postwar period as new efforts to recover "apostolic" Christianity.
Chapter Five—Christianity As a Path of SelfCultivation
As we have seen, Uchimura Kanzo * was the first Japanese leader to articulate a clear alternative to transplanted Christian churches. His call for the development of an independent and indigenous expression of the faith resonated with the deep aspirations of numerous other Japanese Christians. Many shared Uchimura's independent spirit and sympathized with his break from mission churches, but some were not entirely satisfied with the alternative version of Christianity he created. Carlo Caldarola has referred to Uchimura's Nonchurch movement as "Christianity the Japanese Way," implying that it was the only authentic Japanese expression of
Christianity. The successive appearance of indigenous movements over the past century, however, suggests that there are other ways to be both Japanese and Christian.
This chapter considers the reinterpretation of Christianity by two other important figures involved in the earliest phase of indigenization: Matsumura
Kaiseki, who founded The Way in 1907, and Kawai Shinsui, who founded Christ Heart Church in 1927. These two groups represent important Japanese alternatives to both the mission churches and Uchimura's Nonchurch movement. In some respects the early faith of both these founders closely resembled Uchimura's evangelical Christianity, despite the fact that their introduction to the faith came by way of missionaries of the Presbyterian and Reformed traditions with strong ecclesiastical concerns that contrast with those of W S. Clark, the lay educator who had a formative influence on the Sapporo Band that nurtured Uchimura's early faith. In their autobiographies, Matsumura and Kawai refer to their early understanding of Christianity, a reliance on OtherPower. Eventually they came to the conclusion that this is only the beginning of the Christian life, and that authentic faith also requires the exercise of selfpower. It seemed to them that Uchimura, like the Western missionaries, put too much stress on OtherPower to the neglect of selfcultivation and selfexertion. One of Kawai's disciples went so far as to claim that the founder had "graduated" from the intellectualism of Uchimura and laid the experiential foundation for Japanese Christianity.
Matsumura and Kawai also conceived of Christianity more as a "path" or "way" than as a narrowly defined set of doctrines. Kawai, for example, referred to his version of Christianity as the "heavenly way"; and the name that Matsumura chose for his movement, Dokai *, means literally ''Association of the Way." Despite their shared conviction of the excessively doctrinal leanings of Western Christianity, their own Japanese reinterpretations of the faith were not without distinctive creeds and the contours of a basic theology. Moreover, although Matsumura and Kawai show a similar stress on the importance of selfcultivation in the religious life, their interpretations of Christianity differ markedly. A comparison of the two founders and the movements they initiated further illustrates the complex interaction of various religious traditions that goes into the process of indigenization. The following treatment does not by any means aim to be exhaustive, but it will attempt to identify the major religious and cultural elements that have been incorporated into these distinct interpretations of the teaching and practice of Christianity.
Matsumura Kaiseki and the Way
Matsumura Kaiseki (1859–1939) is relatively unknown today, but in the world of Japanese Christianity during the lateMeiji, Taisho*, and early Showa* periods he was a leading intellectual figure In fact, it was not uncommon for him to be
referred to as one of the "three muras" along with Uchimura and Uemura Masahisa. 1 While the latter have been given a central place in most historical accounts, Matsumura has largely dropped out of the picture, even though he played a similarly important role in the Japanese church of his time. Matsumura was not only an important intellectual figure within Japanese Protestantism but also a widely respected leader in the field of moral education. Like Uchimura, Matsumura was a prolific writer and popular speaker. The bibliography of his published works runs to over fifty pages and includes more than forty books and pamphlets devoted to religion.2 Through his lectures and writings he also had an influence on the founders of other new religious movements.3
In spite of Matsumura's importance, it is not hard to understand why his name has fallen into obscurity. The movement he initially intended as an authentic Japanese expression of Christianity soon evolved into a new religion that denied the traditional doctrines of the incarnation and atonement. Consequently, Matsumura was labeled as an apostate4 and ignored by the wider Christian community in Japan. His movement had to struggle for survival in the postwar period and in the end all but disappeared, leaving today no more than three hundred members nationwide. Notwithstanding the ambiguous status of The Way as a "Christian" movement, I have included it in this study because at various stages in its historical development the founder and followers understood themselves as an indigenous expression of Christianity.
Matsumura's Conversion and Religious Development
Matsumura was born in Akashi, a town just southwest of Kobe, in 1859—the very year the first Protestant missionaries arrived in Japan. Like Uchimura, Matsumura was from a samurai family and received his early education in the Chinese Confucian classics from his father. Following the Meiji Restoration and the new government's 1873 promulgation of a new law of military conscription for all, many a young man born into the several hundred thousands of samurai families of Japan found himself without land or stipend, and was forced to find another means of livelihood. With the encouragement of his father, Matsumura decided to pursue an academic career. At the age of twelve he was sent to Tokyo to continue Confucian studies in the juku of Yasui Sokken (1799–1876). Many leaders in the early Meiji period recognized the importance of Western learning for Japan's modernization, with the result that scores of young men from samurai families were prompted to continue their education in one of the schools of Western Learning that were being set up in various locations around the coun
try. In 1874, at the age of sixteen, Matsumura began his study of English at the Osaka School of Foreign Languages. Later that year he moved to Kobe * and continued his English studies with the missionary John Atkinson. This was Matsumura's first direct encounter with Christianity and the Bible. Two years later he returned to Tokyo to pursue his studies and in 1876 entered the Hepburn School in Yokohama, then under the direction of John Ballagh, an American missionary of the Dutch Reformed Church.
Besides his study of English, Matsumura wrestled with the doctrines of Christianity that were being taught by missionaries associated with the Hepburn School and the
Yokohama Band. According to his spiritual autobiography, Fifty Years in the Faith, one night in December 1876 he had a divine revelation that the God of
Christianity was none other than Tentei , the God of Confucianism. As a result of this experience he made a profession of faith and was baptized in 1877 in the Sumiyoshicho* Church. The following year he returned home for a brief visit to evangelize members of his own family. For a short while he supported himself on a meager income by assisting missionaries with translation and evangelistic activities and by working as an elementary school teacher. Unable to cope with the pressures of his new responsibilities, Matsumura had a nervous breakdown diagnosed as neurasthenia, apparently triggered by overwork and an erratic diet. James Ballagh made arrangements for him to recuperate in the village of Yamanaka in the Hakone region. During his convalescence, while at prayer one evening in the mountains, Matsumura had another decisive revelatory experience, which persuaded him that he was being called by God to serve in Christian ministry as an evangelist.
To prepare for the ministry Matsumura returned to Tokyo in 1880 and enrolled in Union Theological School, an institution established by a number of Presbyterian and Dutch Reformed missionaries associated with the Yokohama Band. After only two months Matsumura felt obliged to withdraw from the program. By his own account, he was disappointed with the quality of the teachers and students. He was also unable to accept the strict missionary interpretation of the Sabbath and the prescription against smoking and drinking, which led to conflicts with various missionary instructors, including James Ballagh and the President James Amerman. The final straw was the refusal of the school authorities to observe a school holiday commemorating the anniversary of the death of Emperor Jinmu. The missionaries argued that this festival was simply a form of idol worship and as such should not be honored with a school holiday. Matsumura maintained that the missionaries were ignorant of Japanese history and the national character of the Japanese people, and that the school should
cancel classes out of respect for tradition. The missionaries went on with business as usual, but a number of the students sided with Matsumura and absented themselves. After being called in and reprimanded for the negative influence he was having on his classmates, Matsumura had no choice but to leave the seminary. 5
Following this abrupt departure in 1881, Matsumura moved to the Kansai area for a period of six years. After being employed briefly by a newspaper in Osaka, he served as pastor of the Takahashi Church in Okayama for three years and then returned to Osaka as a writer for the Christian newspaper Fukuin shimpo* (Gospel news). This was a formative period in Matsumura's intellectual development as he encountered many new ideas and came in contact with a much larger circle of missionaries and Japanese Christian leaders. His first year in Osaka, for example, he read Darwin's Origin of the Species, which shook the foundations of his traditional Christian faith. While he was able to recover his "faith in God" after several days of deep doubt and distress, he found he was no longer able fully to accept the "orthodox" doctrines of traditional Christianity.6
During this time he also came to the realization that the ReformedPresbyterian tradition of the Yokohama Band was only "one among many" versions of Christianity. Some European missionaries and denominations, in fact, were advocating a more rational interpretation of Christianity and, in stark contrast to Matsumura's American missionary teachers, were far more relaxed in their attitudes toward alcohol, tobacco, and the Sabbath. In particular, the leaders associated with the Congregational and Unitarian churches exposed him to new ideas that were to radically reshape his interpretation of the Christian tradition. Two persons deserve mention in this connection.
Kanamori Michitomo (1857–1945), who was trained at Doshisha* and ordained for ministry in the Congregational Church by Niijima Jo*, befriended Matsumura when he moved to the Kansai area and helped position him in his first pastorate. Niijima also introduced Matsumura to the new theology and the higher biblical criticism that had recently been imported from Europe. Several years later Kanamori was to make a name for himself as the leading exponent of the new theology. In
1892, his free translation of Otto Pfleiderer's Religionsphilosophie auf geschichtlichter Grundlage (1878) appeared in Japanese, and along with his own book, The Present and Future of Christianity in Japan (1891), played a major role in introducing the new theology to Japan.7
It was also during his stay in Osaka that Matsumura was introduced to the NeoConfucian philosophy of O* Yomei* by another Japanese pastor, Yoshioka Koki*
(1847–1932). Matsumura's encounter with Yoshioka not only rekindled his interest in the Confucian classics, which had formed the core of his early child
hood education, but also provided him with a new philosophical perspective from which to integrate the spiritual wisdom of East and West. From that point on, Matsumura began thinking seriously about forging a Confucian Christianity that could be integrated with the new theology from Europe.
After a brief stint as editor of the Kirisutokyo * shimbun (Christian newspaper) in Tokyo, Matsumura spent a time in educational work. He served as the head teacher of the Yamagata English School for approximately six months and then moved to Niigata, where he succeeded Uchimura Kanzo* at the Hokuetsu Gakkan in 1887. Like Uchimura, Matsumura's educational philosophy was to excite serious criticism from the missionaries associated with the school, leading to his resignation in 1891. His next appointment was as lecturer at the Kanda Kirisutokyo* Seinen Kaikan, which lasted for approximately five years. Through his lectures and writings his influence spread. By the end of his term his Saturday lectures were attended by four or five hundred people. Despite his popularity, the board of directors were less than pleased with his theological views, and he was asked to resign in 1897.
Withdrawing from public life, Matsumura spent the next few years in Kamakura engaged in serious study and writing, publishing such works as A History of the Rise and Fall of Nations (1902), Modern European History (1903), and Saint Socrates (1903). This was a time of harsh religious discipline for Matsumura and of deep reflection on his life and future. Although he had been planning to return to the field of education, another "direct revelation" from God instructed him to devote the rest of his life to religious work. In 1905, at the age of fortyseven, Matsumura resolved to begin an independent church and to commit his remaining years to teaching "pure religion" with the aim of bringing about a new, reformed Christianity for Japan.8
From Church of Japan to New Religion
During the first several years of its development Matsumura's independent expression of Christianity evolved rapidly.9 He initially called his movement the One Heart Association, but in 1907 renamed it the Church of Japan and rented quarters to hold regular meetings. The following year he launched the magazine The Way, which became the primary carrier of his new Confucian version of Christianity. In one of the early issues Matsumura laid out the purposes of the magazine as to express independent religious views, to explore psychic phenomena, to apply higher criticism to Christianity, and to integrate the culture and ideas of East and West.10
Matsumura Kaiseki, founder of The Way.
Matsumura initially organized the Church of Japan, as we mentioned, to create a new and reformed Japanese Christianity independent of Western control. As his religious beliefs and convictions gradually came to be systematized, it became increasingly apparent that it was misleading to refer to his movement as a "Church." Ironically, it was his most sympathetic Japanese colleagues from the Unitarian Church who forced him to recognize that he had clearly departed from the Christian faith. 11 To reflect his new orientation, Matsumura renamed the movement The Way in 1912, referring to it as a "new religion" of the "eternal way." Some years later Matsumura explained that he started the Church of Japan in an effort to reform the traditional version of Christianity, to rid it of its many superstitions, and to ground faith and religious beliefs on scientific thought. What began as a reform ended up as a revolution that could only be called a "new religion."12 Although Matsumura's new position took shape over a number of years in the pages of The Way, it was the publication of his 1925 book, New Religion, that was the final turning point.
Matsumura understood his new religion as an effort to get back to the essentials of authentic religion. He maintained that all religions had been corrupted by unnecessary accretions that were only a source of competition and conflict. In this sense, The Way represented an attempt at purification and simplification. It was also an effort to reconcile religious belief and practice with the results of higher criticism and modern science. This emphasis is particularly clear in his 1929 book, A Critique of Religions. Matsumura admits that he had once believed in the traditional Christianity of the missionaries and worked to spread this version of the faith. But critical scholarship had convinced him that the central beliefs of orthodox Christianity were no longer tenable. In fact, he went so far as to claim that the doctrines of the infallibility of the Bible, the virgin birth of Jesus, and the theory of atonement are nothing more than lies.
Traditionalist churches have no future, he concluded, because they continue to proclaim these falsehoods, ignoring the advance of knowledge and scholarship. 13 Critics argued that a Christianity without Christ as Savior would not stand, but Matsumura stood his ground and maintained that the Fatherhood of God and the
Brotherhood of Man were the only essential teachings of Jesus.14
The Teachings of The Way
In addition to the claim that he was establishing a New Religion, Matsumura argued that he was elaborating the basic truths shared by all the ancient religions of the world. His teaching was based on claims to personal experiences of revelation as well as on an appreciation of the truths contained in the sacred writings of Christianity, Buddhism, and Confucianism.15 His approach is condensed in a small booklet, The Summit Moon, which was based on a radio talk he gave on 7 February 1926.16 In it he summarizes in simple terms the basic beliefs and intent of The Way. The title is drawn from the line of the wellknown waka poem:
Many are the roads
ascending from the foot of the mountain, but the same summit moon is visible to all.
Gautama the Buddha looked at the moon from India, Confucius from China, and Jesus from Palestine, but each was affirming the same basic reality. Established religions have obscured this common religious experience and faith through corruption and the secondary trappings of scriptures and doctrinal elaborations. All doctrinal debates between religions and between denominations within Christianity are ultimately irrelevant and fruitless. (He mentions by name the conflict between James and Paul in the New Testament, between Luther and Zwingli within the Reformed tradition, and between Catholics and Protestants.) What ultimately matters is spirit, sincerity, and character—not theory. The Way is based on the conviction that it is possible to reduce the central truths of all major religions to the following four basic teachings, which he calls the shi koryo* :
1. Belief in God ( shinjin)
The most basic shared belief is faith and worship of the Lord of the universe ( Tenchi shusai no kami). In Christianity this is spoken of as faith in the
Creator who is God the Father; Buddhism speaks of True Suchness or ultimate reality; and in Shinto the focus of this faith is referred to as Omoto* no Kami
( ). Whether faith be monotheistic, polytheistic, or pantheistic, each religion is founded on belief in the same ultimate reality—the same summit moon. Faith in ultimate reality or God is central, but not in the sense of an absolute OtherPower. Human character can never be improved without discipline and selfexertion. 17 Indeed, Matsumura notes, many religions have deteriorated precisely because they focused exclusively on belief in God without teaching that individuals are responsible for their own development.
2. Cultivation of Moral Character ( shutoku*)
Authentic religion is not concerned with "thisworldly benefits" but focuses on the cultivation of virtue and requires strenuous effort to follow the Way. In one fashion or another, all religions instruct us to cultivate virtue and harmonize our lives with the Way. In Shinto this is referred to as rokkon shojo* ( mi o osameru). In short, true religion requires discipline and ascetic practice. It is worth dwelling briefly on this point, which is central to the faith of The Way.
Matsumura rejected the Christian doctrine of original sin in favor of the Confucian understanding of human nature as essentially good ( seizensetsu).
Accordingly, he saw religious life as a process of selfcultivation that proceeds by stages, not as the onceandforall dramatic conversion so often emphasized in the
Christian churches. Matsumura felt that his understanding was more suited to the Japanese psyche, and in 1916 published a short booklet explaining the famous Zen Oxherding Pictures as a guide to the path of spiritual cultivation and awakening to ultimate reality. At the same time, he insisted that such an understanding is not incompatible with the teaching of Jesus, who taught in the Parable of the Prodigal Son that individuals can come to their senses and return to God the Father on their own. The transformation that took place in the character of the son was the result of a gradual awakening and did not depend on an outside mediator or on any vicarious sacrifice.18
The standpoint taken by Matsumura and his successors is clearly indebted to the NeoConfucianism of O* Yomei*. There we see a strong faith in the divine and an emphasis on cultivating the inner insight ( kokoro no ryochi*), which is the innate capacity of each individual to follow the correct path and
enter into union with the Great Void of the universe ( Taikyo). 19 All persons, not just the saints and sages, are born with the same "true heart" that needs only to be stimulated and developed. The problem is that the average person is not aware of this inherent power to live according to the Way. One contemporary member expressed it this way: "Each person's heart is like a mirror that simply needs to be polished in order to choose the correct path." Worship, study, and seated meditation
( shinjin gattai).
3. Love of Neighbor ( airin)
Selfcultivation should not be misunderstood as a form of religious individualism. At their best, all religions teach us to live for others rather than to focus on individual or personal salvation. Our worship and respect of the "one lofty moon" requires that we love our neighbors. This is interpreted broadly to mean that each individual is responsible to live for emperor, nation, and humankind. In short, selfcultivation is not simply for individual liberation but the necessary first step in the wider process of bringing all of life—family, nation, world, universeinto harmony with the way. If we cultivate a heart of sincerity ( makoto), then we will naturally love our neighbor and contribute to the reordering of all things.20
4. Eternal Life ( eisei)
All religions teach that there is more to life than material existence. Eternal life refers to the indestructibility of the soul and life in the world to come. The Shinto
tradition explains this as the process of becoming divine and entering the Plain of High Heaven ( kami ni natte takamagahara ni agaru). The notion of eternal life with God in heaven is also central to Christianity. Death may be inevitable but it is not the end. Our bodies may be burned or buried, but we are spiritual beings that continue to exist in the spirit world. This last teaching is the special gift of religion that enables us to live with hope.
Matsumura defined The Way as an association dedicated to putting these four beliefs into practice in everyday life. The vows that its members recite together at the conclusion of each religious service and in daily practice are expressions of commitment to follow this way:
We promise to hold fast to belief in God and always seek to serve him.
We promise to hold fast to the cultivation of virtue and always seek to improve and elevate our character.
We promise to hold fast to our belief in love of neighbor and always serve our nation, the universe, and humankind.
We promise to hold fast to our belief in eternal life and always live with hope. 21
The Practice of the Way
As we have seen, NeoConfucianism (more specifically, Yomeigaku*) provided the primary orientation for Matsumura's spiritual path of selfcultivation. The scientific theory of evolution and higher criticism laid the foundations for his critique and eventual rejection of traditional Christianity. In the early years of the movement, services and rituals were largely patterned after the other Christian churches in Japan. The Bible, the Protestant hymn book, and the organ were used in worship services; the sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper were observed. It was not long, though, before Matsumura came to realize that traditional Christian worship contained ideas contrary to his own fundamental beliefs. Since the words of most hymns contradicted what he was teaching, he decided to replace them with his own lyrics. He also experimented briefly with the use of traditional Japanese instruments in services. In the end, however, he returned to the organ, but only for a carefully selected number of hymns that were judged consistent with the teachings of The Way or for traditional tunes to which he had supplied new words.
Matsumura also realized that he could not simply imitate the rituals observed in Christian churches. Baptism in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, for example, was clearly out of place as a rite of initiation for a movement that rejected the doctrine of the Trinity. Within two years, baptism was dropped as a requirement for membership and replaced with a signature and oath. Since Matsumura had thrown out traditional Christology with its doctrine of the atonement, it was inevitable that he would also discontinue the sacrament of the Lord's Supper. Christian influence remained, but borrowings from Shinto rituals were introduced to give a more authentically Japanese character to worship services.
In 1915 Matsumura secured a piece of land in Tokyo on which to build his headquarters. It was located in an area of Shibuya providentially named Kamiyama,
God's mountain. A Shinto ceremony of purification ( jichin
Followers of The Way with the founder, (second row, eighth from the right), in front of the Hall of Divine Worship.
sai) was held on the site, and by the following year several buildings had been erected there. The main structure was called the Haitendo * ( ), or Hall of Divine Worship, and was modeled on Japanese religious buildings rather than on Westernstyle churches. The dedication of this building in 1917 for worship and religious training, along with the publication of the Dokai* Guidebook, confirmed the establishment of the movement as a religion.
According to my informants, the founder felt that in its original form Shinto was a simple and pure reflection of Japanese culture and customs. It only stood to reason, therefore that Shinto traditions would play a role in shaping forms of worship. Matsumura had a Shintolike altar placed in the Hall of Divine Worship, where a mirror and sacred strips of paper ( makoto no hyogen*). One member described the Hall as follows:
It was built at a time when Japan was caught up in ''worshipping the West." It was unusual to build such a Japanese building at this time. The outside was constructed in the style of a Buddhist temple, but the inside was designed according to the Shinto pattern.
The services also had a Shinto character. At each service, Matsumura performed the Shintostyle clapping of the hands ( kashiwade) prior to reciting written
prayers before the altar. Services included a period of quiet sitting, a scripture reading (from the Dokai * Bible or some Confucian text), and a sermon elaborating some aspect of the four basic teachings of The Way. The service concluded with a prayer, a collective recitation of The Way's oath, and a hymn. Although the Christian rituals of baptism and the Lord's Supper were dropped, weddings and funerals continued to be provided for members.
In addition to formal worship services, members were encouraged to recite the oath daily, and to observe times of prayer and meditation each morning and evening. Just as a Shintolike altar was used as a focus for worship in the Hall of Divine Worship, Matsumura felt that individual members needed a similar focus for religious practice in their homes. For this purpose he prepared a hanging scroll inscribed with the name of God in Chinese characters: . He instructed his followers to place it over a Shinto altar or in an alcove so that incense could be burned before it during daily prayer and meditation. One of my informants explained that many people regarded these hanging scrolls as protective amulets. Outsiders criticized the use of these hanging scrolls as no more than idol worship, but Matsumura considered that beginners needed a concrete symbol on which to center their religious activity.22
The Way in Process
The religious teaching and practice described above were characteristic of The Way until the end of World War II. Several of my informants who were active in
Inner sanctuary of the Hall of Divine Worship, at Matsumura's funeral (1939).
The Way as students during the war years insisted that they understood it as a separate religion and not as a part of Christianity. The building and worship were Japanese style, the Confucian classics and Eastern thought were always stressed, there were very few references to the Bible in lectures and sermons, Christian hymns were rarely sung, and one never heard the refrain "Amen" used at any of the services. In short, there was very little "smell of Christianity" in The Way.
Since the end of the war, the leaders of The Way have reemphasized the Christian roots of the movement. Matsumura's successor, in fact, referred to the movement as a form of "liberal Christianity." 23 A sign displayed outside the headquarters of The Way in Tokyo identifies itself today with the same phrase. This new selfunderstanding only gradually evolved in the postwar environment. The "antiShinto atmosphere" that followed Japan's defeat and the American Occupation persuaded the leaders that it was prudent to dismantle the Shinto altar in the Hall of Divine Worship and put in its place a simple table with flowers. In 1955 Bible lectures were resumed and the use of the Bible and hymns in religious services gradually increased. The postwar transformation was completed with the rebuilding of the Hall of Divine Worship in 1989, this time designed like a Western church with stainedglass windows and pews. On the surface, The Way looks very much like a Christian institution today, and its high regard for Jesus' teaching about the Fatherhood of God and love of neighbor reconfirm this impression. Other traditional Christian doctrines, however, are still dismissed and the emphasis continues to be placed on the NeoConfucian teaching regarding selfcultivation.
Kawai Shinsui and Christ Heart Church
Matsumura was not the only Japanese leader to stress the importance of selfcultivation in the religious life. Another important illustration of this concern in Japanese Christianity can be found in the life and work of Kawai Shinsui (1867–1962), the founder of Christ Heart Church. Reinterpreting the faith through the lenses of Confucian and Buddhist traditions, this Japanese church maintains that Christianity offers a more complete path of selfcultivation and advocates traditional Buddhist disciplines of meditation to achieve a Christian satori (enlightenment), which is understood in terms of union with God. Although not as prolific a writer as Uchimura and Matsumura, Kawai did author a number of books, and his disciples edited and published a number of his lectures.24 Although he shared their concern for the development of an inde
pendent Japanese expression of Christianity, his own understanding and expression of the faith differed significantly from the intellectualism of the Nonchurch movement, the liberalism of The Way, and the simplistic interpretation of Christianity he encountered in most of the mission churches.
Kawai's Religious and Intellectual Development
Like Matsumura, Kawai's early Christian formation began in mission churches and institutions. Born in the village of Onuma in Yamanashi Prefecture in 1867, Kawai's serious encounter with Christianity dates from a personal tragedy as a young man of twentytwo. Over the course of one year, five members of his family became seriously ill and died. His search for meaning in the midst of this despair led him to the New Testament. Comforted by Jesus' words in the Sermon on the Mount, "Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted," Kawai converted and received baptism in a Methodist mission church in 1890. Three years later he enrolled in Tohoku * Gakuin, a theological school related to the German Reformed mission, in order to prepare for Christian ministry. Although he received instruction from missionary teachers during his time at Tohoku Gakuin College, his principal mentor was Oshikawa Masayoshi.25 From Oshikawa he learned that deep religious experience and union with God ( shinjin goitsu*) through selfcultivation were important aspects of the Christian faith that its Western missionary
representatives had overlooked. Although Kawai was not to establish an independent church of his own for several decades, a new understanding of the Christian faith was largely shaped during his time of study and work in Sendai (1893–1901).26
In his religious autobiography, My Spiritual Experiences, Kawai recalls how he began to reflect on the relationship between his Christian faith and the Asian religious traditions rooted from of old in the soil of Japan:
While thus I was pursuing my study, a sudden idea came to me: What if Buddha, Confucius, Socrates should meet Christ? What if Wang YangMing, Dogen*, Nichiren, or Hakuin should believe in Christ? I am sure they would discover something in addition to what Peter, James, John, and Paul had found. This being so, some greater truth beyond the Christianity conveyed from the West may be revealed by embodying the minds of these saints, and thus providing the West with the secret of truth found also in Japan.27
Kawai thus came to the realization that the Bible does not exhaust the teaching and richness of Christ. In fact, he reasoned, Jesus' message and teaching would have been different had he encountered Confucius or Buddha, rather
than the simple peasants of Israel. To explain the teaching of Christ through an encounter with these saints from Asia became Kawai's mission.
Kawai Shinsui in his study at the Fujiyoshida headquarters, (1954, age 88).
In order to achieve an understanding of Christianity that could unite East and West, Kawai saw that more than academic study of ancient texts was needed—nothing less than an existential encounter with the wisdom of these Asian saints. While carrying on his theological studies, Kawai began to meditate every evening for five or six hours in a nearby field. After two years of serious practice, he experienced firsthand the reality of union with God, a teaching that his mentor Oshikawa had shared with him several years before. "At that instant," Kawai recalls, "I experienced and understood these words too: 'Blessed are the pure in heart: for they shall see God' (Mt. 5:8)." 28 This confirmation of faith provided Kawai with the confidence to develop his own independent expression of Christianity. "Once I had seen God with my own eyes, the logic of the learned was no match for my faith."29
Kawai's Interpretation of Christianity
In 1927 Kawai established Christ Heart Church within the grounds of Gunze Silk Manufacturing Company, where he had been head of the education department for almost twenty years. As he explained in one of his early lectures at Gunze, his reinterpretation of the Christian faith is based on thirtysix years of study, insights gained through intense meditation, direct revelations from God, and the wisdom of the saints of East and West.
As I pointed out earlier in the discussion of continuing revelation (chapter three), Kawai came to understand and elaborate the significance of Jesus for Japanese in terms of the "fulfillment" theology contained in the Gospel of Matthew. Like Uchimura, he argued that God had been actively at work in
Kawai with students from his Gakusei Shudoin * in Tokyo, 1919.
Asian history and culture long before the arrival of Western missionaries. This new understanding and conviction was expressed in the creed of Christ Heart Church as follows: "We believe the ways of the ancient saints are not destroyed but fulfilled by the coming of Christ." For Kawai, these "ancient saints" included Buddha, Confucius, the NeoConfucianist WangYang Ming, and a number of Buddhist saints (Honen*, Shinran, Nichiren, Dogen*, and Hakuin).30 Like John the Baptist in ancient Palestine, these Asian saints prepared the way for the coming of Christ and in essence constitute the "Old Testament" for Japanese Christians. Kawai writes that, while engaging in meditation in May of 1921, he experienced communion with the soul of Confucius and ''reached the conviction that the mind of Christ and the spirit of Confucius were indeed similar manifestations." His elaboration of this fulfillment theology in relation to Confucius is worth quoting at length:
I revere your brightest life as a forerunner to Christ with your seventyfour years on earth when you labored courageously. The great work you left behind you of saving the world depends now entirely upon us. Though you have been long in the realm of the unseen world, and I am here on earth, I will ask you to come to our help that we may together accomplish the sacred work to build up the Kingdom of Heaven.31
Students engaged in the morning practice of kyokenjutsu * (Tokyo, 1925).
In stark contrast to the displacement theology to which the missionaries appealed in their rejection of Japanese religiosity, Kawai stressed that the Confucian and Buddhist traditions offered much of value that could be incorporated into the lives of Christians. Accordingly, Zen meditation and kyokenjutsu ( , another influential form of bodily training and discipline) became important means of spiritual development in the Christ Heart Church. Christianity does not require that we reject the goodness that appears outside of the Christian tradition; rather, we are called in Christ to "gather together all of the truth, goodness, and beauty from other religious traditions."32 Kawai expressed a deep appreciation for the "riches" of Asian religions, but at the same time he was convinced that Jesus the Christ fulfilled and transcended these traditions.33 What distinguished Jesus from the saints of earlier times and other places was his unique teaching that the spirit of the living God would dwell in us and guide us along the path of perfection, and the fact of his resurrection from the dead and promise of the world to come.
Two passages from the New Testament form the core of Kawai's interpretation of Christianity.34 The first passage is from Philippians: "Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus" (2:5). This text constitutes the first pillar of Kawai's teaching and the inspiration for the name of his church. To be a Christian, Kawai explains, means to take on the "mind [heart] of Christ." In the
same way that Zen Buddhism is referred to as the religion of the Buddhamind (Busshinshu * ). Christianity is not just about "believing" in Jesus as savior, but involves discipleship, training, and practice in order to acquire the mind of Christ. Medical learning does not of itself cure illness if one does not follow the prescribed treatment. So, too, a knowledge of doctrine does not save without practice of the faith. In Kawai's words, "One cannot be saved by a faith based on doctrinal knowledge alone. There is no transformation without practice, and no salvation without transformation."35 The transplanted doctrinal expressions of Christianity are like guidebooks to Mount Fuji sitting on a shelf Their descriptions of slopes, trails, and peaks may all be correct, but the point is to climb and experience the mountain for oneself. Similarly, the aim of religion is to experience God directly and to undergo personal transformation. Instead of talking about salvation and union with God, Kawai's concern was to guide individuals to experience the reality firsthand.
The second New Testament passage emphasized by Kawai are the words of Jesus recorded in the Gospel of Matthew: "Be ye perfect, therefore, as your heavenly
Father is perfect" (5:48). Christ requires perfection of his disciples, which can only be accomplished through serious spiritual training.36 Commenting on the passage, Kawai explains that God's ultimate purpose is to bring all of creation to perfection, including human beings who have been created in the image of God. Just as the time it takes to complete a marathon varies from runner to runner, the time it will take each one of us to complete the path of perfection also varies. Those of us who fail to open our eyes and make progress on the path in this life will face the purifying fire of God's "education" in the world to come.37 While we are reconciled with God through faith in Christ, the process of being remade in the image of Christ takes discipline and effort.
Borrowing the language of this New Testament passage, Kawai refers to his teaching of the way as the "Perfect Faith." God is perfect and his son Christ is both the perfect savior and the perfect teacher of humankind.38 Kawai continued to affirm the traditional Christian doctrine of salvation from sin and eternal life through Jesus Christ.39 He insisted, however, that this was not the whole of Christianity and that an exclusive emphasis on this teaching led to a shallow or superficial form of religion. I cite from the official translation:
To take Jesus as a mere savior is to see His half side. To take Jesus as a mere master is also to see His other half. Both sides are of equal importance, and we should neither show any partiality nor weigh the importance of the two. As His way of salvation, plain and allpermeating, is necessary, so His way of instruc
tion, solid and uplifting, is indispensable. In order that we may be saved, reliance would always suffice us; but in order that we may be educated, spiritual training is necessary. 40
The way of Christ, therefore, includes both OtherPower and selfpower.41 One must persevere and complete the training process in order to become like the
Master.42
Although Christianity is supposed to be a religion that unifies faith and ethical practice, Kawai observed that many Christians have fallen into a kind of "Pure Land Buddhist faith" that lacks a concern for moral training and discipline.43 If all we do as Christians is pray and ask God for favors, we are in no position to criticize others for their religion of thisworldly benefits. This is precisely what he found troubling about the transplanted mission churches and the Protestant theology that accompanied it. Kawai argued that most Protestants followed the interpretation of the German Reformer Martin Luther and failed to understand and appreciate the Epistle of James and its teaching about practice or the "works" of faith. Luther thought this New Testament letter obscured the gospel of "grace" taught by the Apostle Paul and hence regarded it as an "epistle of straw.'' By doing so, however, Luther was only able to grasp half of the New Testament faith.44 It is interesting to note here that Kawai spoke positively of the Roman Catholic tradition insofar as it affirmed the value of ascetic discipline in the lives of the saints and mystics.45
This special concern and emphasis on practice and selfcultivation is incorporated into the creed of Christ Heart Church, along with Kawai's fulfillment theology and affirmation of traditional Christian doctrines.
1. We believe in God the only Perfect Heavenly Father: Infinitely Great, Truly Sincere, Supremely Strong, Absolutely Good, Omniscient, Omnipotent, Supremely Beautiful, and of Divine Love; who made this heaven and earth and all things therein; and reigns, teaches, saves, judges, protects, destroys, and completes in the end.
2. We believe in Jesus Christ who represents and reveals this Heavenly Father in perfection, and saves and educates all the world, always working together with the Heavenly Father.
3. We believe in the Holy Spirit who develops, helps, comforts, and sanctifies us, working in our hearts all the time.
4. We believe the ways of ancient saints are not destroyed but rather fulfilled by the coming of Christ.
5. We believe that the practical way of serving our Heavenly Father and contributing to our fellowmen is to stand on the basis of sincerity which Christ valued most, and to aim at the perfection of the Heavenly Father which Christ indicated, and then, through perfect faith, to develop perfect character, do our duty perfectly, love men perfectly—thus each of us advance to perfection and thereby bring on earth the Kingdom of God.
6. We believe in the life everlasting and the existence of the world to come. 46
On 1 January 1927, Kawai made a public declaration that he was establishing Christ Heart Church as a new and independent religious path.47 That same year he published the final version of his poem, A Eulogy on Jesus Christ. These verses on the life of Christ, along with the Seven Great Vows and Prayers, became a part of the enlarged canon of the Christ Heart Church. Kawai had worked on the poem during his many years at Gunze and published an earlier and shorter version in Matsumura's magazine The Way in 1914. The revised version was based on "additional revelations from God." Written in classsical kanbun style, the text provided a concise synopsis of the life of Christ that could be memorized easily and used as a focus for daily meditation. It was also read in Sunday services along with the
Bible.48
From the very beginning, Kawai made it clear that he had no intention of developing a popular movement for the masses; rather, his aim was to gather a small group of dedicated disciples who were committed to the path of selfcultivation and perfection. Enhancing the character of the few was regarded by him as more important than attracting a large number of mediocre or average members. The Seven Great Vows and Prayers ( Shichi dai seigan), which define the meaning of membership and discipleship in the Christ Heart Church, reveal the high expectations and elitist orientation of the movement (what Max Weber referred to as "virtuosi religiosity").49 Inspired by the Buddhist tradition in his development of these vows, Kawai expanded the four great vows "that all bodhisattvas make at the outset of their spiritual careers."50 These vows were regarded as the perfect expression of the heart of religion and understood to be a "completion and fulfillment" of Buddhist wisdom in light of the revelation of Christ.51 I reproduce the text of the vows here:
The Seven Great Vows and Prayers
We pray and vow that we may ever be loving and adoring our Heavenly Father and the Son.
We pray and vow that we may ever be faithful to the Holy Spirit and conscience.
We pray and vow that we may ever be repentant and void of all sin and all folly.
We pray and vow that we may ever be serving all men and cherishing
all things in all the world. 52
We pray and vow that we may ever be diligent in our day's exertions, thinking highly of our duties.
We pray and vow that we may ever be learning, the mysterious perfect way pursuing.
We pray and vow that the sacred peace of the Kingdom of God may come and abide with us.
Religious Practice in Christ Heart Church
Kawai instructed his disciples that to keep these vows and complete the path to perfection that ends with union with God requires the daily discipline of prayer, meditation, Bible study, and practice. He likened these four to "a fourwheeled carriage that runs on the rail of love and leads individuals to the Kingdom of God." If the carriage does not ride smoothly when one of the wheels is missing, neither can spiritual development advance without all its elements in place. Prayer and meditation are referred to as the quiet disciplines; Bible study and practice, as dynamic disciplines.53
Prayer marks the beginning of the religious life; it is the means whereby we express our basic faith in God and seek to understand his will for us. Care must be taken not to allow prayers to become shallow and selfcentered by constantly asking special favors of God. Prayer is how we honor God and prepare our hearts for meditation.
Meditation guides us to personal transformation and enlightenment. Although the term meiso* , a repetitive prayer or chant) during meditation: "I appeal to you therefore, brothers and sisters, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship."54 Meditation is understood as a duty to God and not simply as a means to enlightenment. Through it one loses the sense of separate existence and experiences oneness
Saint Takahashi Mutsuko laid out in state, with Kawai and three disciples (Fujiyoshida, 1947).
with God. Without it, one can only hunger for the heaven and eternal life Jesus Christ spoke, but not taste it. Not even prayer and good works are complete without the discipline of meditation.
Spiritual Bible study opens the faithful to knowledge of Jesus as savior and teacher, to the indwelling Spirit of God, the kingdom of God, and life in the world to come. The Bible is a book of faith and must be read with eyes of faith and internalized through quiet reflection.
Finally, authentic faith requires practice. Selfcultivation, personal spiritual advancement, and enlightenment are not the terminus of the religious life. Their whole purpose is to open one to live for others and for the kingdom of God. Those who seriously pursue the path and acquire the heart of Christ will be engaged in lives of service to humankind.
By following these methods for four years in Sendai Kawai "encountered the living Christ" and experienced "union with God" as a young man of thirty in 1896. 55 His debt to the wisdom of the East is clear, and yet Kawai insisted on a clear difference between the Zen enlightenment of satori and his own teaching and experience of "the perfect, wondrous way" ( kanzen myodo*). Zen creates the sense of equality with ultimate reality, whereas the Christian path preserves the idea that God transcends all.56
During his lifetime, only five or six direct disciples were recognized by Kawai as having achieved this enlightenment experience. One of them, a
The Seven Great Vows and
Prayers in Kawai's calligraphy.
The Holy Image used in the Christ Heart Church.
woman named Takahashi Mutsuko, took her asceticism to extremes. While serving as Kawai's secretary and personal assistant, Takahashi committed herself to lifelong religious training and celibacy. In spite of frequent illnesses, she fasted regularly and seriously pursued the fourfold disciplines advocated by Kawai. Upon her untimely death at the young age of fortyfour, it was discovered that she had been engaging in more austere measures. Among her belongings were found a box containing Kawai's A Eulogy on Jesus Christ and no less than 115 copies of the New Testament. Every page of every book—about 30,000 pages in all—had been drenched in blood drawn from an incision in her side. Kawai was moved by Takahashi's "bloodstained sanguiscripts," and encouraged other disciples to imitate her spirit but not her methods. Clearly she had gone too far, but this did not deter Kawai from declaring her a saint, affirming that she had achieved satori and penetrated the inner mystery of Christ Heart Church. 57
Like Matsumura before him, Kawai recognized the need for visible symbols on which to focus one's spiritual cultivation. He encouraged followers to keep a small copy of a portrait of Christ with them to remind them of the presence of Christ. The founder himself carried one in the sleeve of his kimono for many years as an aid to his own spiritual development. A larger version of that same "holy image" may be found today on the sanctuary walls of the movement's churches.
Despite the special stress put on individual spirituality in Christ Heart Church, various forms of community worship and training are also observed. Following the pattern of traditional Christian churches, services are usually held on Sunday morning and generally follow the Protestant order of worship, including hymns, Bible reading, a sermon, and prayer. In addition, services today include a reading from Kawai's A Eulogy on Jesus Christ, ritual bowing before the "holy image" and a photograph of the founder also hung in the sanctuary, and a group chanting of the Seven Great Vows. Baptism is observed as a membership ritual, but the Lord's Supper has never been observed. Curiously, Kawai's writings make no mention of this traditional Christian observance, either as a memorial or as a sacrament, and no one in the movement today seems to have any explanation for why it was left out of religious practice in the Christ Heart Church. 58
The buildings used by Christ Heart Church are frequently referred to as a dojo*, since they serve as a place for religious training and not just as a sanctuary for worship services. Sunday services are frequently followed by meditation and study sessions. Since, as we saw, Kawai had come to regard the Confucian classics as a kind of Old Testament for the Japanese, these works are often studied along with his own commentaries and lectures.
In addition to local weekly and monthly meetings, a churchwide Cultivation Meeting is held for several days each summer at the Sohonzan* church located near the founder's birthplace in Fujiyoshida (Yamanashi Prefecture). These meetings contain lectures and worship services, teachers providing concentrated instruction in meditation and bodily training.59 As a part of the training program participants clean the buildings, grounds, and grave sites. The annual retreat concludes with a memorial service for the founder.
Another feature of Christ Heart Church that distinguishes it from most other Christian churches in Japan is its flexible position regarding participation in the rituals of other religious traditions. Unlike the mission churches, which generally took a strong stand against such involvement with other groups, members are encouraged to show proper respect and to share in traditional customs as their conscience dictates. As a result, in addition to memorial services within the church, many members continue to participate in various Buddhist services for deceased family members and friends. For example, the church avoids conducting services during the annual period of festivals for the dead known as obon in order that members can freely participate in ancestral memorial rituals with other relatives.
The stated position of the church is that it is appropriate for Christians to show respect for those who have died, whether it be at church services, Buddhist memorials, or even Yasukuni Shrine (the Shinto shrine where many of Japan's war dead are enshrined). At one time Christ Heart Church was a member of the Kirisutokyo * Rengokai*, an ecumenical association of Christian churches in Japan, but found it necessary to withdraw because of the strong opposition voiced by the association against taking part in rituals honoring the war dead at Yasukuni Shrine. The leaders of Christ Heart Church decided it could no longer remain a part of an organization that would discourage its members from showing proper reverence for their deceased relatives.
Some Comparative Observations
In this chapter I have tried to highlight some of the major influences on Matsumura and Kawai in their development of independent Japanese expressions of Christian belief and practice. Both movements illustrate the complexity of the indigenization process and some alternative ways in which Western traditions and ideas (Reformed theology, higher criticism, and the new theology) have been interpreted and appropriated in light of diverse Asian or indigenous traditions (NeoConfucianism, Zen Buddhism, Shinto). In response to the doctrinal emphases and rigidity of Western churches, Matsumura and Kawai stressed the importance of personal religious experience. Following in the steps of Uchimura Kanzo*, these founders rejected the control of Western mission churches and shared a positive orientation toward different aspects of Asian religious and philosophical traditions, as well as a general disdain for priestly and sacramental traditions and rituals of Western churches (although Christ Heart Church has continued baptism as a rite of initiation). Matsumura's acceptance of higher criticism and the new theology distinguishes him from both Uchimura and Kawai.
Without denying the importance of faith in OtherPower, what distinguishes both founders and movements from Uchimura's Nonchurch movement is their conviction that selfpower and moral cultivation are equally important aspects of the authentic religious life. This particular emphasis is hardly unique to these new Christian movements. It resembles in many ways the Shingaku movement that flourished in the Tokugawa period. As an earlier synthesis of NeoConfucianism and Zen traditions, this movement similarly stressed cultivation of the mind or heart through meditation.60 This movement was in rapid decline by the early Meiji period, but the concern for selfcultivation reappeared
in a number of New Religions that were established over the course of Japan's modernization. This has been widely recognized with reference to such movements as Kurozumikyo *, Hitonomichi Kyodan*, and PL Kyodan.61 The foregoing pages should make it clear that even the subculture of Japanese Christianity has been reshaped significantly by this important tradition.
Chapter Six—Japanese Versions of Apostolic Christianity
Christianity in Japan has long had the reputation of being a difficult and demanding religion, one primarily for intellectuals and the educated whitecollar middle class. In stark contrast to the scores of other New Religions that have emerged in Japan's modern century, Christianity has rarely been regarded as a viable alternative for the general population. 1 This image is no doubt related to the decision of the earliest Protestant missionaries to concentrate their attentions on Japanese from the samurai class, for whom popular folk religiosity was of little concern. In the Meiji period the samurai class, the most literate and intellectual class of Japanese society of the time, was overrepresented in the churches: the mere 5 percent of the total Japanese population in the 1880s and 1890s who were of samurai origins accounted for approximately 30 percent of total membership in the Protestant churches.2 The image of Japanese Christianity as an intellectual's religion is further reflected in the
fact that the greatest majority of church leaders were drawn from these same samurai families, where they had received a Confucian education that set them apart from the rest of the population.
Taken together, then, the preferences of the missionaries and the native orientation of those singled out for proselytization made it difficult for the new religion to appeal to the ordinary masses of Japanese. Ariga Tetsutaro * describes persuasively the dominant place of this "elite" in the first Protestant churches and their disdain for the religiosity of the common people:
Christian leaders of the Meiji period, being of samurai origin, had shared the samurai prejudice against Buddhism and Shinto. For precisely because these were the religions of the lower classes upon which the samurai looked down, they were bound to be more important factors of the society where all the former classes were mixed. This point they seemed to have missed. And here perhaps should be sought the chief reason why Japanese Protestantism has neither been able to extend its influence widely beyond the educated middle classes nor to answer successfully the challenges made by Buddhism, Shinto, and more recent popular sects.3
The similarly elitist indigenous versions of Christianity articulated by Uchimura, Matsumura, and Kawai—as we have seen in the preceding chapters—did little to remedy the imbalance. Like the majority of the foreign missionaries and the early Japanese Christian leaders, they tended to underestimate the strength and persistence of traditional and popular religious concerns, and hence failed to come to terms theologically with the needs of the broader population. This was to be the role of a second wave of indigenous movements organized in the 1930s and 1940s. Critical of both the mission churches and existing indigenous forms, these movements have succeeded in responding most directly to the needs of ordinary people and to the concerns embodied in folk religiosity.
Carlo Caldarola's study of Japanese Christianity included a worthy analysis of one of these movements, the Original Gospel (or Makuya, Tabernacle Movement), whose roots go back to Nonchurch movement, but concluded with a misleading generalization:
Makuya is the only movement to indigenize Christianity—traditionally an upperclass religion—in the Japanese lower classes. By emphasizing its pentecostal aspects, the
Makuya has ingeniously succeeded in fostering the continuity of a Japanese folkreligious tradition dominated by shamanism, magic, and miracles.4
The fact is, however, there are a number of other indigenous movements that have made similar cultural adaptations and attracted members from among the less educated layers of society. They include the Glorious Gospel Christian Church (1936), the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church (1939), Christian Canaan Church (1940), Japan Ecclesia of Christ (1940), the Spirit of Jesus Church (1941), Holy Ecclesia of Jesus (1946), and the Sanctifying Christ Church (1948). All of these movements show a common concern with recovering an ''apostolic faith" that they consider missing in the transplanted mission churches. This chapter focuses on two of the larger movements from this second period, the Spirit of Jesus Church and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, and briefly reconsiders the Pentecostal version of the Nonchurch Christianity that was introduced in Caldarola's study.
Murai Jun and the Spirit of Jesus Church
The founder of the Spirit of Jesus Church, Murai Jun, was born in 1897, the second son of a Methodist minister. Raised in a Christian environment, he went on to study theology at the Methodistaffiliated Aoyama Gakuin in Tokyo. At one point during his studies Murai became deeply troubled and was contemplating suicide. In 1918, while taking a ferry in Okayama Prefecture, he made up his mind to throw himself overboard and put an end to it all. At that moment he felt the presence of the
Holy Spirit overpower him and he began to speak in tongues. The experience cleared his mind of all religious doubt and filled him with new strength and vision for the Christian mission.
Murai dropped out of Aoyama Gakuin and began evangelistic work. In time he assumed the post of pastor in the Japan Bible Church (the church that was to become the Japan Assemblies of God in 1949). In 1933, word of the pentecostal experience that had changed his life spread among the membership of his small congregation in Nishisugamo, Tokyo. But in 1941, after visiting the True Jesus Church in Taiwan, a Chinese indigenous movement that had been in existence for just over twenty years, 5 Murai decided to take leave of his congregation. It was in this same year that his wife, Suwa, received a revelation from God in which the name Iesu no Mitama Kyokai* (Spirit of Jesus Church) was given to designate them as a new church.
As we have already remarked in chapter two, Murai launched a rather strident critique of the existing mission churches and indigenous movements in the course of defending the establishment of his independent Spirit of Jesus Church. This is hardly surprising, given that conservative evangelical groups accused
him of being a "servant of satan" for practicing tonguesspeaking and sponsoring emotional healing services. 6 Speaking in tongues, in their view, was a mark of possession by an evil spirit, not the work of the Spirit of God. For his part, Murai insisted that he was restoring the authentic form of New Testament Christianity that was no longer practiced by churches in the West or in transplanted mission churches.
Unlike Uchimura and Matsumura, who were prolific authors, Murai left behind very few writings. As far as I have been able to determine, his only publications are Biblical Theology ( ), both of which are still used for training pastors in the Spirit of Jesus Bible School in Tokyo. These writings elaborate traditional pentecostal traits (Spirit baptism, speaking in tongues, healing), the unitarian Jesusonly doctrine, the renewed emphasis on sabbath worship, the restoration of the New Testament rituals of footwashing and baptism for the dead, and a strong eschatological orientation and emphasis on the doctrine of the Second Coming of Christ. Murai maintained that true Christianity is a religion of signs and miracles, and that the church today is called on to reproduce what went on in the early Christian movement in preparation for the triumphant return of Christ.
Spirit of Jesus Church pastors are fond of quoting from the Gospel of Mark (16:15–18) to define their basic mission. There the disciples are commanded to preach the gospel and baptize believers, and are promised the power to perform miracles, drive out demons, speak in strange tongues, and heal the sick. Pastors are also prepared to quote chapter and verse for all of the other practices enjoined by Murai. Baptisms, for example, are only performed in the name of Jesus Christ in accord with the example and teaching of the Apostle Peter (Acts 2:38; 10:48), rather than with the trinitarian formula of Father, Son, and Spirit that was adopted by the Western churches. Similarly, baptisms for the dead are conducted according to biblical teaching and precedent (1 Cor 15:29). Healing by prayer and anointing with oil is another New Testament practice (James 5: 14–16) neglected by many churches but encouraged in the Spirit of Jesus Church. The ritual of the washing of feet performed by Jesus (John 13) has also been revived with pastors washing the feet of new members immediately following baptism. In colloquial Japanese the expression washing one's feet of something—roughly equivalent to the English expression to wash one's hands of something—is used by former Yakuza (gangsters) to express their decision to leave the underworld. In the same way, as one pastor explained to me, ritual footwashing in the church symbolizes that members have cut ties with the devil and embarked on a new life. In addition to these practices, the Spirit of Jesus
Church also preserves the sacrament of the Lord's Supper that earlier Japanese founders had all rejected.
Foreign Influences: Pentecostal and Dispensational Connections
Without gainsaying the personal charisma of Murai, it should be noted that the doctrines and practices he promoted were by and large the result of foreign influences. Prior to his encounter with the True Jesus Church on a visit to Taiwan in 1941, Murai had already aligned himself with pentecostal Christianity with its stress on Spirit baptism and speaking in tongues, but his subsequent emphasis on sabbath worship, washing of the feet, and "Jesusonly" (i.e., unitarian) doctrine was clearly prompted by what he found in the True Jesus Church. 7
Actually, the genealogy is a bit more complicated. In his study of independent Christian movements in China, Daniel Bays has shown that many of the doctrinal peculiarities that attracted the attention of Murai were themselves of foreign origin. The antitrinitarian "Jesusonly" teaching goes back to developments within Christianity in the United States and was widespread among Pentecostals there and in Canada some years before the first Pentecostal missionaries were sent to China.8 Bays also suggests that the teaching regarding sabbath worship was probably due to the influence of early American SeventhDay Adventist missionaries and their publications, which became increasingly evident in China after 1902.9 In the light of these various influences, Bays describes the True Jesus Church as an "international transnational phenomenon.
Murai's eschatological orientation and emphasis on the Second Coming of Christ shows a similar reliance on outside developments, though I have not been able to document the immediate sources. In particular, dispensationalism has had an unmistakable impact on theology of the founder. A theological current that first emerged among Plymouth Brethren in England and Ireland during the 1830s and subsequently spread in North America, dispensationalism became the dominant model of scriptural interpretation in fundamentalist circles and is still popular in evangelical and pentecostal churches today.10 Eschatological in focus, it divides biblical history into distinct periods, or dispensations, during which God deals with humanity through different covenants or conditions. In 1909 C. I. Scofield (1843–1921), an American pastor and Bible teacher, published his dispensational and premillennial Bible, in which he popularized the idea of seven dispensations: "Innocence (before the Fall), Conscience (from the
Fall to Noah), Human Government (from Noah to Abraham), Promise (from Abraham to Moses), Law (from Moses to Christ), Grace (the Church age), the Kingdom (the Millennium). The close of the Millennium ushers in the Eternal State." 11 It seems likely that Murai Jun was exposed to dispensationalism through his contact with American missionaries or Japanese Bible teachers who had adopted this approach to reading the scriptures.
An examination of Murai's publications suggests that Scofield's notes provided his study of the Bible with a frame of reference. Based on his writings, figure 4 depicts the dispensational and eschatological theology of the Spirit of Jesus Church. The period from the fall of humankind into sin until the time of the coming of Jesus covers a span of four thousand years. The death, resurrection, and ascension of Jesus are followed by the coming of the Holy Spirit, whose outpouring inaugurates a period of grace, salvation, the Holy Spirit, and the Church. Murai and his church maintain that the signs, miracles, and tongues that accompanied the coming of the Holy Spirit in the New Testament story are still present and will continue in effect until the end of the age of the church, when the rapture of true Christians will occur. After a sevenyear period of tribulation, Satan will be cast into hell and Jesus Christ will return to earth with his followers to establish the millennial kingdom. At the end of this period, Satan is to be released for a brief period prior to the final judgment, at which time the human race will be divided into those who are to live eternally with God and those who will be cast into the lake of fire for eternal punishment. The old
Figure 4.
Cosmology of the Spirit of Jesus Church
heaven and earth will be destroyed as the new heaven and earth, the eternal home of the people of God, is at last revealed.
Those familiar with dispensationalism and pentecostalism in North America will hardly be surprised by Murai's theological scheme. Like other pentecostal groups, the Spirit of Jesus Church rejects intellectualism and emphasizes the importance of religious experience. Speaking in tongues, anointing with oil, dancing in the spirit, miracles of healing, and revelations from God are all basic components of everyday religious life. The symbolic world of the believer is filled with spirits, signs, miracles, and wonders. Miraculous healings and religious experience, rather than intellectual or theological sophistication, are the church's defining traits. Unlike many other Christian churches in Japan, the Spirit of Jesus Church does not engage in educational activities like running kindergartens or offering Bible classes in English. Only "biblical" ministry that focuses on sabbath and Sunday worship services and on home meetings during the week are regarded as legitimate church activities. While it does operate a Bible School for the training of pastors and evangelists, there is in effect no Christian education or Bible study for ordinary members.
The message is simple and clear: believe in Jesus Christ and receive the baptism of water and the Spirit. Virtually the only teaching that is offered has to do with what one must do to be saved and baptized. 12 Seekers are instructed—under not inconsiderable pressure, I would add—to repeat "Hallelujah, hallelujah!" over and over again until Holy Spirit baptism is experienced and the gift of speaking in tongues is granted.
The version of Christianity advanced by the Spirit of Jesus Church tends to appeal to those Japanese already deeply rooted in folk religious traditions. Considerable emphasis is placed on what is usually referred to as gense riyaku , or the worldly benefits of religion.13 In sharp contrast to the preoccupation with selfcultivation that marked earlier indigenous movements, sermons in the Spirit of Jesus Church tend to reiterate promises of spiritual and material blessing that await the true believer, and testimonials by the faithful bear witness to God's fulfillment of these promises. On one occasion, I heard Bishop Murai Suwa, the founder's wife, assure members of the congregation that God would bless their business enterprises. "For those of you who are shopkeepers," she explained, "God will lead customers past the stores of your competitors and through your front doors."
The promise of worldly benefits is complemented by the benefits of physical healing that are available to each member. A small flask of oil is kept on the pulpit beside the Bible for use in healing rituals that take place at many ser
vices. 14 Individuals frequently step forward toward the end of services to receive special prayer and anointing with oil for personal healing.
Unlike the earliest Japanese founders who looked for common ground between indigenous religious traditions and Christianity and tried to show the continuity from the one to the other, Murai's Spirit of Jesus Church sees itself engaged in "spiritual warfare" with traditional Japanese religiosity and condemns its practice as "idolatrous." In Okinawa, for example, church leaders pit themselves in an ongoing struggle against the Yuta (leaders of traditional religion) for spiritual control of the islands.15 By conducting healing services and exorcisms, pastors claim to have proved their religious authority by surpassing the spiritual power of local religious leaders. In their aggressive evangelistic campaigns, pastors have instructed followers to destroy pagan idols and abstain from participation in pagan rituals. Despite these strict measures, however, the Spirit of Jesus Church has managed to establish more churches across Japan than any other indigenous movement. It has done so not by rejecting the religious needs of its members but by offering Christian alternatives designed to perform the same functions as traditional religious practices. Thus, for instance, members are forbidden to practice traditional rites of ancestor veneration while at the same time the church takes care of the dead by conducting vicarious baptisms and other special services throughout the year. In other words, the theology and practice of the Spirit of Jesus Church are far from exhausted by thisworldly concerns. Considerable attention is given to the dangers and fears associated with ancestors and the spirit world in both formal religious services and pastoral care. Clergy also provide "Christianized" rituals of land purification ( jichinsai) to protect members from evil spirits and make it safe for Christians to build homes and live in them. More than anything else it is the way Murai and his followers have directly addressed these folk religious concerns that distinguishes the Spirit of Jesus Church from Western pentecostal movements.
The Organization of Indigenous Christianity
In sharp contrast to Uchimura's rejection of Western church polities, clergy, and sacraments, Murai claimed to have rediscovered the strands of biblical tradition that legitimize a structure of authority with a special class of religious leaders. The Spirit of Jesus Church makes a clear distinction between the respective roles and responsibilities of clergy and laity. The bishop stands at the highest rung of the religious hierarchy, albeit in a largely symbolic role. The current bishop is Murai Suwa, the wife of the deceased founder. While she is respected as an
authority by pastors and members alike, her role carries no "official" political power. As one pastor explained to me, "the function of the bishop is to provide spiritual guidance, not to rule or dominate." There are no church councils or meetings over which the bishop must preside, but Bishop Murai symbolizes the authority of the church and officiates at the communion service each year on the occasion of the annual conference. Similarly, the bishop often participates in dedication services for new church buildings and officiates at funeral services for pastors.
The actual control of the church is in the hands of the local pastors. A phrase one commonly hears among church members to express this sociopolitical reality is
bokushi ichinin shugi, which in essence means that the pastor of a local church is entrusted with its responsibility. No outside interference is permitted. The laity in each local church fall under the authority of the pastor and have no official role to play in the governing of the church. There are no congregational meetings and no lay leaders (elders or deacons). Neither is there a treasurer. 16 The pastor is in charge of the finances of the local church. Members, of course, are encouraged to tithe, but the use of church funds is determined by each pastor. In sum, the Spirit of Jesus Church is a streamlined religious organization with no committees or bureaucracy.
The responsibilities of the laity are summed up in the often heard expression , which literally translates as "Sheep give birth to more sheep, the pastor shepherds the flock." The choice of images is significant. As sheep, the laity have only a passive role to play in the organization. One leader explained to me that pastors view themselves as a family of priests, much like Aaron and the Levitical priests in the Old Testament.17 They have been "set apart" from ordinary believers for their priestly activities. In order to train pastors for this high calling, a twoyear program of Bible School is maintained in the church headquarters in Tokyo, with some ten to twenty students participating at any one time. The Bible and the writings of the founder form the content of the curriculum. After completing the twoyear course, graduates assist in the work of the head church or engage in new church development.
We should note that the relatively high status and power enjoyed by pastors in the Spirit of Jesus Church has been a factor in its growth. Kinship ties have helped the church to spread in general, but this is particularly so among its leaders. Anzai Shin's study of the growth of the church in Okinawa noted that the founder of the church there had passed on the faith to his family so that after his death, his wife continued to work in the church, one daughter and one son became pastors, and two daughters became wives of pastors in this movement.18
Spirit of Jesus Church sanctuary, showing pulpit with flask of oil.
I discovered a similar pattern in my own study of a church in Shikoku. The pastor's father had converted to the Spirit of Jesus Church from an Assemblies of God congregation and became a leader in the movement. Two of her brothers and one sister also became pastors. At the time of the interview some years ago, three nieces or nephews were serving as pastors and two nieces were in the Bible School preparing for pastoral work. If this pattern is at all typical, it is not hard to understand the remarkable growth of the movement.
For all its foreign influences, the Spirit of Jesus Church clearly qualifies as an independent indigenous movement. In chapter two the defining characteristics of an indigenous church were given as selfgovernment, selfsupport, and selfpropagation. The Spirit of Jesus Church is selfgoverning and has adopted its own style of leadership and organization. It is completely selfsupporting, receiving no financial support from foreign churches. In fact, this organization sends its own missionaries abroad. Finally, it is selfpropagating and receives no assistance from foreign missionaries in evangelistic work. As a movement, it clearly emerged from a foreignborn or imported religion, but today those churches and Christian traditions are viewed as apostate. The Spirit of Jesus Church claims that it alone has truth and legitimacy. In terms of churchsect theory, it can only be characterized as an indigenous Christian sect: indigenous in that it has been transformed through contact with native culture and by virtue of its organizational independence from Western Christianity; sectarian in that it conceives of itself as the only true Christian way and continues to exist in tension with the larger society.
Otsuki * Takeji and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus
Another movement defining itself as a restoration of apostolic Christianity is the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus founded by Otsuki Takeji in the early postwar period. Otsuki was born in Ayabe City in 1906, and as a young man converted to Christianity while a student at Doshisha* Middle School, a private mission school in Kyoto. Otsuki was attracted to the faith through the evangelistic preaching of Kanamori Michinori during the daily chapel program and went on to receive baptism. Dissatisfied with Doshisha's "liberal and socialistic" form of Christianity, Otsuki found his way into the Holiness Church in 1930.
The Holiness Church in Japan traces its origins to the early evangelistic work of the Oriental Missionary Society, organized by Nakada Juji* (1870–1939) and by Mr. and Mrs. Charles Cowman in 1901. Nakada had become acquainted with the Cowmans during a period he spent at the Moody Bible Institute in Chicago (1896– 1898). Although the Oriental Missionary Society began as a nondenominational evangelistic movement, it changed shape over time until it became the Japan Holiness Church in 1917. From an initial membership of 1,600 and fortysix churches, it grew rapidly to a membership of 19,523 in 1932. A controversy erupted the following year around a shift in Nakada's teaching regarding eschatology, bringing the phase of growth to an abrupt halt. Apparently Nakada had received a new revelation from God during a special visitation of the Holy Spirit. Tetsunao Yamamori summarizes the change in doctrine as follows:
The doctrinal emphases had always been placed on justification, sanctification, divine healing, and the Second Coming of Christ. To this list, Nakada now wished to add a fifth point, that Christ's Second Coming would be possible only through the restoration of Israel. Therefore, he admonished the members to pray for this to take place. To many it seemed as though Nakada believed that by praying for the salvation of the Jews the Japanese race might be saved. This was in direct conflict with the traditional view that salvation was an individual matter.19
As Bishop of the Holiness Church, Nakada expected all seminary teachers and pastors to accept his new vision, but many leaders rejected his authority, which in turn led to a schism within the ranks. Otsuki was among those who remained loyal to the end.
Nakada Juji was a charismatic individual whose impact on Otsuki was enormous. Indeed, to this day Otsuki refers to Nakada as his teacher and a great prophet, adding that before meeting him he had understood nothing of the
Bible's teachings regarding personal sanctification, the restoration of Israel, and the Second Coming of Christ. 20 Otsuki* completed his theological training at the Holiness Bible Seminary in Tokyo and engaged in evangelistic work in several locations around Japan before accepting appointment as a missionary to Manchuria in 1936.
Religious Experience and Direct Revelation
It was while serving as a Holiness missionary in Manchuria that Otsuki had a "direct encounter with the living Christ," a lifetransforming experience that was to become the foundation of his independent ministry.21 While praying in preparation for the New Year Convention (the first seikai or revival meeting of the year) and asking God to send him a guiding motto, he was presented with the words of Jesus from the Sermon on the Mount, "Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God." Otsuki explains that his belief in God was beyond question, even though he had never seen God. In his own congregation, however, a small girl named Kiyoko who testified that she had seen God went through a remarkable transformation before her short life came to its end. Inspired by the faith of this young girl, Otsuki asked God to purify his heart so that he might have the same experience. His prayer was answered on the evening of 9 January 1938. As Otsuki recounts, he lost all consciousness of himself and his surroundings and was confronted by the living Christ. He felt the "breath of God blowing on him" and saw a bright and beautiful light coming toward him until it entered his body. In seeking to make sense of the experience, Otsuki searched the scriptures and discovered that the Hebrew prophets and apostles had reported similarly moving experiences.22
As a result, Otsuki came to understand what the Apostle Paul meant when he wrote, "It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me" (Gal 2:20). He saw that as individuals and as the church, we now form the body of Christ on earth, our bodies being the temple and dwelling place of the living Christ (2 Cor 6:16). This is why the early apostles did not merely preach Christ, but through the laying on of hands passed the living Christ to others. Through this same indwelling power Otsuki's life was transformed and healing became an increasingly important part of his ministry. (The church reports that over 8,000 individuals were healed during Otsuki's missionary work in China.) On the same evening that his personal transformation occurred, Otsuki also recorded specific revelations regarding the salvation of Israel and his future role in the fulfillment of the Bible's apocalyptic vision, which we will consider more closely below.
After returning to Japan in 1942, Otsuki * engaged in evangelistic work and led revival meetings in various locations around Japan. In 1946 he received another revelation from the Lord in which he was instructed to establish an independent church to be named the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. The mission of the church was to recover and spread the Apostolic faith in place of the Westernized version of Christianity that missionaries had planted in Japan. The motto of the church today emphasizes this concern to recover the apostolic faith:
Christians are called to be like Christ and the Church to be like the Acts of the Apostles.
Obedient to these divine instructions, Otsuki left the Holiness Church with a small group of disciples and organized the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. After a brief period based in Fukuyama City, Hiroshima Prefecture, Otsuki moved the headquarters of the movement to Kyoto in 1949. This has been the organizational center for a nationwide evangelistic ministry, which has grown to include over 100 churches scattered across the country from Okinawa in the south to Hokkaido* in the north.
The Theology and Practice of Apostolic Christianity
The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is a movement aimed at recovering apostolic Christianity and entrusted with a special mission regarding the nation of Israel in these ''last days." Otsuki writes that "authentic mission is not to transmit the doctrine or theology of Christianity, but to manifest the living Christ in our lives."23 The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, understood as Christ's body on earth, is called to pass on the living Christ and to provide opportunities for individuals to encounter the living Christ. As an expression of apostolic Christianity, the movement emphasizes spirit baptism, healing, and continuing revelation from God as normative for Christians today.24
Reflecting on his experience in China and numerous other revelatory experiences, Otsuki came to the conclusion that he had rediscovered the truth of the biblical and apostolic teaching that it is by "calling on the name" that one encounters the living God. The invocation of the divine name, he claims, is the prototype of all religion. It can be traced back to the earliest human civilizations mentioned in the Bible (Gen 4:26), and is repeated throughout the biblical record. Important examples include these: "Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved" (Joel 2:32). "For there is no distinction between Jew and
Greek; the same Lord is Lord of all and is generous to all who call on him. For 'Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved"' (Rom 10:12–13). Or again, the earliest Christians were also known as those who "called on the name of the Lord" (Acts 9:21). Unfortunately, this central teaching of the Bible disappeared from view as Christianity developed in Europe. 25
Working his way systematically through the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, Otsuki* identified the ways in which God revealed himself through a variety of names. Today these names and expressions are studied, chanted, and prayed in both corporate and private worship in the belief that the God of the Bible will be present whenever his name is invoked. The founder's writings and numerous church publications list the following "holy names of God" ( ) for believers to use in devotional practice:
I am God almighty. (Gen 17:1)
I am who I am. . (Ex 3:14)
I am God. . (Is 43:13)
I am the first and I am the last. . (Is 44:6, Rev 22:13)
The Word was God. . (John 1:1)
I am the bread of life. . (John 6:35)
I am the light of the world. . (John 8:12)
I am the resurrection and the life. . (John 11:25)
I am the way, the truth, and the life. . (John 14:6)
God is love. . (I John 4:16)
According to Otsuki, God always reveals himself in a name and is actually present in his name. The actual practice of "calling on the name of God" closely resembles the sound and rhythm of the Buddhist practice of reciting the nembutsu. The center and climax of worship services in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus comes when the entire congregation, following the direction of the minister, chants in unison one of the names of God—for example, Kami wa ai nari (God is love). In worship services a small bell is rung to mark the end of the chanting. It is by invoking the name of God collectively and in private that one is brought into a direct encounter with the living God.26
Given the centrality of this practice, it seems fitting to classify the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus as a form of nembutsu kirisutokyo*. The tradition of the nembutsu, calling on the name of Amida Buddha for protection and salvation, was a practice that began in China and first flourished in Japan during the tenth and eleventh centuries.27 It subsequently became an important part of the Pure Land
Otsuki * Takeji, founder of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus.
Buddhist sects. As many Japanese come from households belonging to the Pure Land tradition, the chanting of the nembutsu is a natural and common form of religious practice.28 Otsuki himself was raised in a home that practiced the nembutsu as an expression of faith in the OtherPower of Amida Buddha. Against this religious backdrop, Otsuki suggests, his Christianizing of the practice is wellsuited to Japanese sensibilities. Despite wellknown similarities between the Buddhist and Christian dependence on OtherPower, Otsuki and other leaders of the Church are quick to point out that Amida Buddha was not a historical figure. "A being who does not actually exist," as one pastor put it, "cannot answer our prayers." The God of the Bible, by contrast, was revealed in human history in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. Through his life, death, and resurrection, Jesus is now the living Lord who has accomplished salvation on our behalf and can truly respond to our prayers.
As Otsuki himself noted, this practice of invoking the name of God is nothing unique to Japanese religion. William J. Jackson points out in his study of religious traditions in India that "devoted faith in the practice of calling on a divine name in prayer or incantation may be the oldest and most pervasive form of religious life in human history." He concludes that "in a wide range of Hindu traditions and circumstances the holy name was believed to have an inherent extraordinary potency, bringing one in touch with the being or reality named."29 I
cite his words because this is the very claim that Otsuki * and his followers make regarding the cornerstone of their devotional practice.
Recognizing that the God of the Bible is living and as active today as in firstcentury Palestine, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus expects to experience miracles and God's healing power.30 The outpouring of the Holy Spirit and indwelling power of Christ is thought as a matter of course to reproduce the miracles performed by Jesus and the early apostles. Healing is understood to be a sign of the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. Church altars typically display a Bible, a flask of oil, written requests for healing, and sometimes a handkerchief inscribed with a saying penned by the founder. This is also understood to be a continuation of the early Christian practice recorded in the New Testament with reference to the Apostle Paul: "God did extraordinary miracles through Paul, so that when the handkerchiefs or aprons that had touched his skin were brought to the sick, their diseases left them, and the evil spirits came out of them" (Acts 19:11–12). Prayers and anointing with oil for healing form a regular part of group worship services and pastoral ministry. In many homes one will also find an altar where the dead are memorialized and where oil is kept for prayer and healing of family members in the home.
In addition, the church has recently identified a healing spring ( ) in Ayabe City, Kyoto Prefecture, close to the birthplace of the founder and to the site of the discovery of a "MariaKannon" figure.31 The spring has since become a pilgrimage site for members. Members often fill containers with water from the spring and share it with persons suffering from all sorts of maladies. Those who are ill are encouraged to drink the water "while calling on the name of God" in the belief that God can heal them. Numerous healings have been reported by members during worship service testimonials and recorded in church publications. The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is convinced that this healing spring was a providential sign meant to witness to a skeptical and doubting generation that the God of the Bible is still living and active today. Followers are reminded that healing does not occur because of some special properties in the water, but because of the supernatural power of God.32 Incorporation and Adaptation of Western Church Traditions
The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, as we have noted, was established with the aim of restoring the practice of apostolic Christianity. Over the course of several decades, however, the movement has come to a reappreciation of many elements in Western church tradition. One sign of this more ecumenical orientation is the
fact that it is the only independent movement in Japan that has recognized the Apostles' Creed as it own confession of faith. While continuing to recognize the mistaken policies and practices of many mission churches in Japan, the founder has been able at the same time to acknowledge the value of spiritual disciplines, symbols, and rituals that were developed within Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox traditions.
One area in which the influence of these older Western traditions is particularly apparent in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is in the understanding and use of sacred space and religious symbols. The movement regards the sanctuary within church buildings as the "sacred space" for an encounter with the living God. Protestant mission churches in Japan, they feel, have largely failed to appreciate the need for buildings that create a sense of the sacred and an atmosphere for worship. As one pastor observed, "it is hard to distinguish many Christian churches in Japan from classrooms or a gymnasium—with their bare walls and folding chairs. Japanese need more symbols and atmosphere in order to sense that they are in a religious place." The same could be said, of course, of Uchimura's Nonchurch movement, which usually meets in rented facilities and lecture halls.
According to Otsuki * and other representative leaders, the Japanese people need more symbol and form in order to experience religion, While these "forms" should not be mistaken for the reality to which they point, religious symbols are an important entrance way to authentic faith. In order to create this sacred space and religious atmosphere, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus borrows extensively from the Roman Catholic and Jewish traditions. At the front of each church sanctuary behind the pulpit is always an altar on which is placed a Bible, candles, a menorah, and often a flask of olive oil. Above the altar is a crucifix and nearby usually hangs a sanctuary lamp. Stained glass windows often add to the visual effect. In addition to symbolically rich sanctuaries, church buildings and gardens are decorated with many other statues and images of the Holy Mother and St. Francis, who are regarded as models of Christian humility, discipleship, and spirituality. Leaders emphasize that the use of these symbols or images should not be interpreted as a form of idol worship, the misguided judgment to which most Protestant churches are prone.33 Rather, they need to be understood as aids to worship that point individuals to a reality beyond themselves.
The sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper are observed with particular seriousness in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. Before individuals are allowed to receive baptism and admitted to church membership, they must have attended church as "seekers" ( ) for a minimum period of six months,
completed a basic course of instruction in the faith, and had a personal experience of baptism by the Holy Spirit. Each individual must write a detailed confession of sin before receiving baptism. In addition to this initial confession of sin, members and clergy are also encouraged to submit written confessions ( ) periodically in preparation for receiving the sacrament of the Lord's Supper (communion services are usually observed four times a year). 34 This practice is based on the New Testament teaching that individuals should only "eat of the bread and drink of the cup" after selfexamination (see 1 Cor 11:28). After reading an individual's confession, the pastor lays hands on the head of the member and declares absolution in the name of Christ. Some larger churches even maintain a special confessional room. While this kind of formal confession is standard religious practice in this movement, there is no requirement that individuals perform acts of penance, as is the custom in Roman Catholic churches.
The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus has also continued to observe traditional Christian services for confirmations, weddings, and funerals. In addition, the church provides
Christian alternatives for a number of rituals traditionally observed by Japanese at Shinto shrines. On a Sunday nearest the annual Shichigosan festival in midNovember, for example, an occasion when girls of seven and three and boys of five visit a shrine with their parents, the church holds a special service for blessing infants and children ( ) are provided as an alternative to traditional Buddhist services. All of these additional observances represent an effort by church leaders to show that Christianity is not just an individualistic religion with concerns for personal salvation, but a religion that cares for and supports the extended family and all of its needs.
In the process of institutionalization, Otsuki* adapted the polity with which he was familiar in the Holiness Church and fitted it out with a tightly organized hierarchical authority structure. The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is based on the biblical tradition of a priesthood "set apart" and invests considerable efforts in the selection and training of its ministers and evangelists.35 Although this is a church with Protestant roots, Otsuki rejected the traditional Protestant approach to theological education and adopted elements from the Roman Catholic monastic tradition as the basis for training religious leaders. In Otsuki's view, most Protestant churches and theological schools fail to provide adequate attention to
Church altar with Bible, prayer requests, and handkerchief.
Holy Ecclesia of Jesus sanctuary, with Jewish and Christian symbols.
the spiritual disciplines required for ongoing transformation. Theological training in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is based on the conviction that each person is called to pursue the path toward sainthood and become another Christ. While Protestants emphasize salvation by faith, very few churches give notice to the biblical teaching that each person is to be transformed into the image of Christ. 36 This is the vocation of all Christians, but is said to be especially important for those who are training for religious leadership.
The fouryear program of ministerial training at Logos Theological Seminary includes both biblical and doctrinal studies, referred to as intellectual formation, and attention to the disciplines that are necessary for spiritual formation. Following the Catholic monastic tradition, seminarians are called to purity, poverty, and obedience, and the church covers all tuition and living expenses. The day is divided into periods of prayer, study, silence, and work, but the center of communal life is clearly prayer and worship. Prayers are observed three times a day at the seminary chapel (6:30 A.M., 3:00 P.M., and 7:00 P.M.). Seminarians renew their vows at each of these services, chanting in unison their response to the question of why they are enrolled in Logos: that is, "to become a saint, to become another Christ."
Unlike other theological institutions in Japan, students at Logos also receive instruction in traditional Japanese arts. Women are taught flower arranging and the tea ceremony and men are trained in the art of calligraphy. These traditional Japanese arts are regarded as valuable disciplines for spiritual
training that enable one to focus the mind and even experience union with the living Christ. Many churches maintain a tea room both to provide hospitality to guests and as a place for quiet meditation.
All students preparing for the ministry at Logos are single, and men and women are segregated for all activities. They sit at separate tables in the dining hall and on different sides of the classroom for lectures. In the chapel, too, the women sit on the left and the men on the right. During this fouryear training period, private or personal communication between men and women is not permitted. This is what the founder refers to as the practice of "holy disinterestedness." At the end of the fouryear training program, however, the Catholic tradition of celibacy is abandoned and the seminary director plays the role of matchmaker to arrange marriages for many of the men and women as they return to the world to begin their active ministry. Logos graduates are usually matched for marriage within one or two years of graduation, but as persons trained for the ministry they are not allowed to marry a lay person. Moreover, it is stipulated that marriage partners among the ordained are not to be selected on the basis of romance. Since the church only allows ordained members to marry within the "priesthood," many women recognize that they are destined to the single life as the number of women training for the ministry always outnumbers that of men. (In a recent year, for example, there were 26 women and
14 men enrolled at Logos.) 37
Following completion of the Logos program, individuals must complete a threeyear trial period as an associate teacher. In order to become fully recognized as a pastor or teacher, each candidate must pass a written examination and lead at least twelve individuals to the faith (which is understood to include both spirit and water baptism). The latter expectation reflects the strong evangelistic emphasis of the movement—a requirement that would no doubt quickly diminish the ranks of the ordained in most mainline denominations.38
Eschatology and Zionistic Orientation
As we have noted, the practice of apostolic Christianity and gradual incorporation of various older Western church traditions constitute important aspects of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. It is Father Otsuki*'s eschatological vision, however, that provides the central dynamic and an atmosphere of expectancy that characterize the movement. In these "last days," Otsuki explains, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus has been set apart by God to play an important role as salvation history approaches its climax. This idea of a time of special "kairos" is based on Otsuki's
reading of the Apostle Paul's teaching that after "the full number of Gentiles have come in . . . all Israel will be saved" (Rom 11:25). Although evangelism of Gentiles is understood as an important mission in order to perfect the "Bride of Christ" (ecclesia), it is the national and spiritual salvation of Israel that constitutes the special mission and ultimate goal of the movement.
Otsuki *'s concern for the nation of Israel clearly reflects the views of Nakada Juji*, his mentor in the Holiness Church, whose theology was dominated in his later years by eschatological concerns and the idea that Japan was somehow connected to the salvation of Israel.39 Without denying this influence, Otsuki claims that he also received special revelation concerning the movement's responsibilities toward Israel while he was a missionary in China. He reports that the Lord instructed him: 1. to pray for the restoration of the nation of Israel;
2. to pray for the spiritual renewal of Israel, which is the condition for the return of Christ;
3. to pray for the peace of Jerusalem, which is the key to the peace of the world; and
4. to pray for the coming of the Messiah of Peace.40
Ten years after Otsuki received this revelation and began praying fervently for the restoration of Israel, the nation of Israel was reestablished as an independent state. This provided important confirmation for Otsuki and his followers at the early stage of this movement's development. This apocalyptic consciousness and concern for the nation of Israel pervades all aspects of this movement today.
Even though the movement is concerned with the salvation of Israel, it does not engage in evangelistic mission to the Jews as do a number of other Protestant mission groups. In light of the history of ChristianJewish relations—persecution, murder, and the holocaust—the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus claims that Gentiles have no right to evangelize the Jews. Their calling is simply to pray for the restoration of Israel and peace in Jerusalem. Only then will the Messiah come again and establish peace throughout the world. At the present time, Otsuki explains, the church's primary concern should be to heal the wounds that Christians have inflicted on Jews over the centuries and to learn how to express selfless love. God will take care of the salvation of the Jews in his own time.41 Although the cross and the star of David have usually represented separation and conflict, this movement combines them to symbolize their vision of reconciliation and harmony between Christians and Jews.
Symbol of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus: the star of David and a cross designed with sakura flower petals.
Over the past several decades this movement has made numerous efforts to heal the past and forge good relations between Jews and Gentiles. 42 Several examples are worth mentioning here. Under the leadership of the founder's son, Otsuki* Masaru, the Shinonome (Dawn) Choir was organized in 1970 to contribute to peace and improved relations through a ministry of music and a program composed of Hebrew and Japanese songs. Over the years the choir has made a number of concert tours to Israel and North America and has even performed in the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C. Some of these performances have been preceded by an apology for the past atrocities committed against Jews in the name of Christ. Many in the audience are visibly moved and after the concert some have indicated that it is the first time a Christian has apologized to them about anything. In 1995, to join in the celebrations commemorating the founding of the holy city of Jerusalem 3,000 years ago, the choir toured Israel and gave concerts in Tel Aviv and Haifa and at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.43
In 1971 the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus also established the Bet Shalom (House of Peace) in Kyoto, where guests from Israel are accommodated for three nights free of charge. Another house is also maintained in Hiroshima. Over 10,000 Israelis and Jews have enjoyed the hospitality of these Bet Shalom guest houses during the past three decades. The 1972 terrorist attack on Tel Aviv's Lod airport—in which three Japanese participated—left twentyfour dead and another seventysix wounded. In an effort to heal the damaged relations between Japanese and Israelis as a result of this tragedy, the movement established the Otsuki Peace Scholarship to assist students from Israel studying in Japan. Several years ago the movement also raised funds to support a professorship at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.44
The most recent manifestation of this concern for the people of Israel is the Japan Holocaust Museum and Education Center, which was established in June 1995. The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus established the center in memory of the 1.5 million Jewish children and to contribute to peace education in Japan.45 Church members donated the 50 million yen required for the construction of the center
and memorial hall. Materials on display in the museum were donated by Jews from twentytwo countries. During the first year of operation, the center received over eight thousand visitors, which included teachers and students from thirty different universities, sixty elementary and junior high schools, and representatives from various city government offices and human rights groups. One of the first visitors was Hannah Pick, a classmate of Anne Frank. 46 Through the displays, lectures, videos, and discussions, the director general of the center, Rev. Otsuka* Makoto, challenges students to think about the Holocaust, the greatest tragedy of our century, as well as about the realities of Japan's exploitation of its Asian neighbors over the past century. Students are urged to become peacemakers. The activities of the center have opened up many new opportunities for this pastor to give public lectures and to speak to school groups about the holocaust and on pressing problems in Japanese society like bullying and discrimination.47
The close relationship to the people of Israel reflected in these various activities has had a significant impact on religious practice within the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. In particular, the movement has been inspired to recover the Jewish roots of early Christianity. A number of leaders have been sent to Israel to study Hebrew and Jewish traditions and a Center for Judaic Studies has been established at Logos Theological Seminary in order to devote more attention to the Jewish foundation of
Christianity. The Center often hosts Jewish rabbis and scholars for various lectures and special events. The orientation of the group toward Israel and Jewish traditions is also reflected in the official church calendar, which includes dates for Purim (March 5), a memorial day for the six million victims of the holocaust (April 16), Israel's
Independence Day Anniversary (April 24), Anne Frank's birthday (June 12), the destruction of the Jerusalem temple (July 25), Yom Kippur (September 23), and Israel Day (October 10).
While churches do not observe special services on all of these occasions, concern for Israel is manifested in various ways throughout the church year.48 Again, this orientation is evident in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus hymnbook, which includes eleven hymns (41–51) dealing with the second coming of Christ, eight hymns dealing with the salvation of Israel (85–92), and twelve Jewish folk songs (202–13). The hymnal also contains a guide to prayer with eleven prayers related to the people of Israel, including prayers for Jews who are scattered throughout the world, for the peace of Jerusalem, and for the spiritual anointing of the 144,000 chosen ones who are destined to fulfill a special role in the final days.49 Members are encouraged to offer these prayers on behalf of Israel three times each day.50 The church has also been encouraging its members to observe
a form of family worship based on the ancient Jewish sabbath tradition. 51 All of these connections with Israel have resulted in the majority of members setting themselves the goal of making at least one pilgrimage to the Holy Land during their lifetime. The founder, who has made three pilgrimages to Israel, wrote a number of poems and meditations regarding his own experiences for members to use for reflection on their pilgrimages to sacred sites in the Holy Land and Europe.52
At first glance, it may be difficult to appreciate the way in which all of these diverse elements—healing practices, chanting the names of God, Christian and Jewish symbols and rituals—can combine to form a coherent subculture for the participants involved in the movement. Otsuki*'s former colleagues in the Holiness Church are extremely critical of what he has created and tend to look down on it as so much kitsch. The founder's response is that, like the Apostle Paul, he is called to be ''all things to all men." Otsuki believes that the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus must be an oburoshiki*, a cloth large enough to wrap up all the ingredients necessary to satisfy diverse human needs.53
Teshima Ikuro* and the Original Gospel Movement
As we have noted at several points in the course of this study, Uchimura Kanzo*'s Nonchurch interpretation of Christianity has been influential in the development of various groups in the course of this century. The Original Gospel is a pentecostal manifestation of the Nonchurch movement and represents another Japanese effort to recover apostolic Christianity.54 Dissatisfied with both the doctrinal rigidity of Western mission churches and the intellectualism of Uchimura's disciples, Teshima Ikuro
(1910–1973) founded his movement in 1948. Since a considerable amount of information is now available in English, I will only draw attention to some key characteristics that distinguish this movement from other versions of Nonchurch Christianity and provide a basis for comparison with the other "apostolic" movements considered above.55
Uchimura had insisted that the Japanese were capable of reading the Bible by themselves, without depending on the confessions and commentaries of the mission churches. Operating on the basis of this Nonchurch principle, Teshima read the Bible and found that it was full of elements missing from both Nonchurch Christianity and the transplanted mission churches. The "original gospel," he discovered, was a charismatic form of religion and always accompanied by such phenomena as healings, spirit baptism, and speaking in tongues. These manifestations of the living Christ were no longer available in the trans
Teshima Ikuro *, founder of the Original Gospel movement, at one of the larger Bible study meetings.
planted mission churches. In fact, Teshima observed, most church leaders no longer even believed in the healing power of God. In short, the established churches had exchanged the living apostolic faith for a doctrinal system about Christianity. Teshima identified fully with Uchimura's effort to develop an independent and indigenous expression of Christianity by returning to the original Scriptures. In the following statement Teshima explains his view that the Nonchurch movement had also become a "stagnant" form of Christianity in the hands of Uchimura's disciples:
The followers of the Nonchurch movement attach great importance to the study of the Bible. Now this has become for them a substitute for faith. Some think they are saved as long as they study Biblical terminology, and in extreme cases, the meaning of Greek texts. But there is no salvation in the study of the letter. As it is written, "For the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life" (2 Cor 3:6). We cannot be saved until we encounter the living Christ, the great "I AM" who stands behind the Scriptures.56
Teachers in the Nonchurch movement may be good Biblical scholars, Teshima acknowledges, but they lack the living faith of the New Testament.57 As we observed in chapter three, Teshima was extremely critical of the transplanted mission churches and what is regarded as a misguided concern to present the
Western "shell" of Christianity (see page 37 above). He was also disillusioned with the lifeless form of Christianity into which the Nonchurch movement had degenerated. His harshest words, however, were reserved for Japanese Christian pastors who collaborated with the missionaries in order to stay on the payroll of mission churches. These pastors were unable to articulate the Gospel for the Japanese and simply parroted what the Western missionaries wanted them to say—
"wagging their tails like dogs to please their masters,"as he put it—just to receive their stipend. 58 Teshima was determined to establish an independent and selfsupporting form of Christianity that was both apostolic and indigenous.
The Jewish Roots of Apostolic Christianity
In 1948 Teshima began publishing his own magazine, The Light of Life, and began to elaborate his own understanding of Christianity in writing, as had been the tradition of most teachers in the Nonchurch movement.59 In 1949 the pentecostal features of spirit baptism, healing, and speaking in tongues, which had initially only affected Teshima and his immediate disciples, spread throughout his Bible study group in Kumamoto. This event, which is now referred to as the "Makuya Pentecost," led to his break with the Nonchurch movement as a whole.60 The term makuya is the Japanese term for the tabernacle, or tent, used as the portable sanctuary in which God dwelt among the Israelites in the desert. Teshima began referring to his movement as Makuya or the Original Gospel following the controversy with Nonchurch leaders over his pentecostal faith. Even though he continued to claim his faith was an expression of the Nonchurch tradition, he dropped the reference to the Nonchurch movement from the cover of his magazine in response to the continued criticism from Uchimura's successors. Yanaihara Tadao, for example, complained that within thirty years of Uchimura's death a "heretical" form of Christianity had been launched under the Nonchurch banner.61 Takahashi Saburo* similarly refused to recognize Teshima's as a legitimate movement since it had strayed from central Nonchurch emphases (forgiveness of sins, the resurrection, and the second coming of Christ) and had become enamored with healing and speaking in tongues.62
In addition to these charismatic and pentecostal features, Teshima's search for the "original gospel" also led him to a deeper appreciation of the Jewish roots of Christianity. In order to recover authentic apostolic Christianity, he felt that it was necessary to remove the effects of two thousand years of Europeanization and attempt to revive the earliest form of Christian worship. One of the most vis
ible consequences of this decision may be seen in his adoption of the menorah in place of the cross as the central religious symbol of his movement. This sevenbranched lampstand had been a common symbol for Jews since its use in the tabernacle of the Israelites to represent the presence of the living God. The New Testament indicates that this symbol was also important for early Christians. In the Revelation to John (1:12–20), for example, the Son of Man appears in the midst of seven golden lampstands, which indicates that the menorah was understood by the earliest Christians as the symbol of the living Christ ( ). It took centuries before the cross became widely accepted as the symbol of Christianity. According to my informants, Teshima's decision to adopt this earlier Jewish symbol was also motivated by the fact that most Japanese found the cross to be such a "cruel and tragic image" that it was unsuitable to serve as the symbolic focus for Christian worship in Japan.
In 1961 Teshima made his first world pilgrimage, traveling to India, the United States, Greece, and Israel. The Bible came alive for him during his visit to the Holy
Land and this experience subsequently influenced the way he would train his own disciples. 63 True to the Nonchurch tradition, Teshima already placed considerable emphasis on the study of the Bible in the original Hebrew and Greek. His time in Israel convinced him that it was also important to live and study in the Holy Land in order to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation of the world of the Bible and the Jewish traditions that were so important
The menorah is the symbolic focus and representation of the presence of God at Original Gospel meetings.
to Jesus. Teshima felt that Japanese Christians could learn more about the Biblical tradition directly from Jews in Israel than from the Western church traditions and theological scholarship. He also thought it was important for young people to experience the patriotism of Jews in Israel and hoped it would serve to inspire and revive the Japanese spirit that had disappeared in postwar Japan following the military defeat in 1945.
In 1962 he began sending his younger disciples to study for a year or longer in Israel. To date over 700 students have studied Hebrew in Israel and worked parttime on a kibbutz. Some have also pursued academic degrees at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. 64 Academic studies alone, however, were inadequate preparation for becoming an evangelist in the Original Gospel movement. In order to cultivate a spirit of total dependence on God, Teshima adopted the "biblical" practice of sending his disciples out two by two—with no money or change of clothes—with the expectation that God would guide them and supply all their needs as they traveled and preached the gospel. This approach to discipleship and training was based on the example of Jesus recorded in Mark 6:7–13. Teshima felt that trust in God could only be cultivated through difficult trials and personal experiences. This form of spiritual training continues today as the elders in the movement send out their disciples in the spring or fall on these missionary journeys.65
In addition to sending students to Israel, Teshima organized an annual pilgrimage to the Holy Land and through these trips cultivated ties with many Jewish leaders. He regularly invited Israeli dignitaries to Makuya meetings and hosted other Jewish leaders in Japan. Following the SixDay War of 1967, Teshima initiated numerous activities to generate Japanese support for the state of Israel. As his son Isaiah explained not long ago, his father proudly "called himself a NeoZionist," which for him meant "a commitment to dialogue with the spirit of Israel for reviving the original spirit or values of the Bible in Japan as well as supporting the state of Israel in which the Holy History proceeds."66
Since Teshima's death in 1973, his wife and other leaders within the movement have strengthened the relationship with Israel and placed even greater stress on the
Jewish roots of Christianity. Each year in February or March a twoweek pilgrimage to the Holy Land is organized and usually attracts between 100 to 300 members. Several years ago, 1,600 members joined the pilgrimage in order to join in the celebrations surrounding the 3,000th birthday of Jerusalem. In 1988 the movement established a Makuya Center in Jerusalem to provide a community for members studying in Israel and to offer courses on Japanese language and culture.67 The
Original Gospel movement also operates a publishing
company that specializes in books and resources for the study of Hebrew and produces translations of important works by Israeli scholars.
The ongoing relationship with Israel and contact with Jewish traditions has continued to reshape religious practice within the movement. One of the results of sending students to study and experience the religious life of Israel has been the gradual incorporation and adaptation of Jewish practices. A number of Jewish folk songs are included in the Original Gospel hymnbook and regularly sung at various services and events. 68 The Jewish Shabbat is also widely celebrated among Makuya members in Japan. In the early 1980s Makuya leaders also instituted a bar mitzvah initiation ceremony for young people in the movement. During spring break each year, anywhere from 50 to 100 junior high school students (aged 12–13) from all over Japan gather for three days of intensive religious practice at the "sacred sites" of Kumamoto and Mount Aso in Kyushu*. (Mount Aso is where the founder had his powerful encounter with the living God and experienced his call to religious work, and nearby Kumamoto is where he began the Original Gospel movement.) Young people stay in the Makuya retreat center at Mount Aso, but also visit the
Kumamoto center and nearby gravesites of the founder and his early disciples. The program includes lectures on the history of the movement, videos of the founder, worship services, and various ascetic practices, such as omisogi (water ablutions for purification) and hiwatari (walking across a bed of hot coals). It is not surprising to learn that young people are rather preoccupied and anxious about this last ritual obligation and test of faith.
The Original Gospel and Japanese Spirituality
In addition to Teshima's concern to rediscover the charismatic and Jewish dimensions of apostolic Christianity, he was also committed to the process of indigenization and sought links between biblical faith and Japanese spiritual traditions. While other indigenous leaders had focused on the value of bushido* or Buddhist and Confucian traditions, Teshima was more concerned with the Japanese spiritual traditions prior to the arrival of foreign cultures. The beautiful, noble, sacrificial spirit taught by our forebears, Teshima claimed, is the key to the Japanese understanding of the cross of Christ. The Kojiki, Nihon shoki, and Man'yosho* are regarded as important resources for understanding the earliest Japanese spirit.69 Already in Teshima's first book, The Love of the Holy Spirit, we see his deep appreciation for early Japanese spirituality in the life of Emperor Jinmu, who relied on the Sun Goddess in order to lead the Japanese people:
Makuya members doing hiwatari at one of the annual conventions.
I am moved by the legacy of the Emperor Jinmu who emerged from difficulties by depending on the power of the heavenly spirit, an appropriate lesson to be deeply engraved upon the hearts of the Japanese who are now groaning under the hard, postwar conditions. It is amazing that the ancient Japanese had such heightened spirituality. Whenever they met difficulties, they relied upon the fuyu * (military authority, support, grace, merciful bestowal) of the divine spirit. They firmly believed that if only they had the merciful bestowal of the spirit upon them, they could break through any difficulties and that the spirit itself would crush down any enemies. With this firm belief they did ukehi (receiving of spirit) and otakebi (loud cries); such were their unique spiritual traits.70
Teshima's "Christianization of the preChristian past" included his interpretation that the ancient Japanese fellowship with the gods referred to in the Kojiki and Nihon shoki was in fact communication with the heavenly spirits referred to as angels in the Bible. These Japanese forebears not only provided exemplary models of spirituality and dependence on God, but also revealed what true humanity was intended to be.71 This is also what the life of Jesus in the gospel reveals to us. It is the aim of the Original Gospel movement, Teshima explains, to join in Jesus' mission to restore this true humanity to all people. Although Teshima was particularly concerned with Japanese spirituality before the arrival of Buddhism and Confucianism from China, he also recognized the valuable contribution of Japanese Buddhists, such as Kobo* Daishi, Honen*, Nichiren, and Hakuin and, like Kawai Shinsui, refers to this heritage as the Old Testament for Japanese.72
Makuya members participating in omisogi purification rituals.
This deep appreciation for ancient Japanese spirituality led Teshima to adopt certain ascetic practices from indigenous traditions for spiritual training within the Makuya movement. These include misogi water purification rituals, including takiabi ( ) or walking across a bed of hot coals. The ascetic disciplines were regarded as important methods of bodily training and spiritual purification, and particularly important for individuals who had difficulty concentrating on spiritual matters. At the annual convention in March 1958 Teshima initiated the hiwatari, a common practice among Yamabushi, mountain priests, as a regular spiritual exercise for Makuya members. 73 He reasoned that if Christianity was truly the highest religion, its followers should be able to prove the power of the living God by walking across the burning coals. This became a standard practice at annual conventions and, as we noted above, became an important event in the mitzvah rite of passage for young people in the movement.
Recent Emphases and Nationalistic Tendencies
In spite of condemnation by various Nonchurch teachers over the past several decades, Makuya leaders have recently been reemphasizing their identity as an expression of the Nonchurch tradition. The Original Gospel magazine, Light of Life, for example, regularly carries articles about Uchimura and usually publishes a confession of faith that defines the movement in terms of Nonchurch principles.
The room where services are held at Original Gospel movement's Kumamoto Juku in Kyushu *. The appearance of the Japanese flag at Makuya meetings occurred after
Teshima returned from a visit to the United States and
found U.S. flags displayed in churches. He thought this
was equally valid for Japanese Christians and encouraged
Makuya members to show national pride by displaying the flag in services and on national holidays.
The Original Gospel Creed
We lament Japan's spiritual desolation and long for the revival of the Japanese spirit.
We long for the revival of religion in the hearts of the Japanese people and pray for the restoration of the Original Gospel.
We stand on the principle of NonChurchism. Therefore, we neither belong to nor establish any church or denomination, and simply seek to learn from the Old and New Testaments.
We long for the purification of Christianity and at the same time love the other religions of Japan and venerate the character of the founders (saints) of Japan.
We transcend all political parties and with love, good intention, and peace we anticipate the sanctification of Japanese society and seek to promote social justice and love of one's neighbor.
It is undeniable that this movement shares many things in common with the Nonchurch tradition: independence from Western church traditions and rejection of the sacramental system and denominational polities, an emphasis on studying the Bible in the original languages, and the practice of meeting primarily in rented halls and members' homes, rather than investing in church buildings. Teshima and his followers also claim that their Zionistic orientation is also rooted in the views of Uchimura.
74 In spite of these shared features, Uchimura would undoubtedly be uncomfortable with the emotional nature of Makuya's pentecostal services and the recent neonationalistic tendencies evident in the movement.
In recent years the movement has been making special efforts to educate Japanese young people in the riches of early Japanese history. The movement's magazine
Light of Life has been publishing a cartoon series dealing with the spiritual leadership of Jinmu Tenno*, the first emperor, and the establishment of the nation of
Japan.75 This neonationalistic orientation is also evident in the articles written by key leaders in the movement. The founder's second wife and current symbolic head, Teshima Chiyo, for example, strongly urges Japanese to celebrate the national holiday honoring Emperor Jinmu as one way to reconfirm their identity and recover national pride.76 She reminds her readers that the emperor was the father of the nation and ruled according to the will of heaven. While Japan's past may not be all glorious, it is necessary to educate the new generation of young people regarding the riches of the past so that they can have pride as Japanese. She expresses dismay at the recent trend in school textbooks that tends to interpret history in a negative light, stressing Japan's role in the modern period primarily as an invader of its Asian neighbors. Almost no attention is given, however, to the character and sacrifice of so many Japanese who died on behalf of the emperor during Japan's modern century.
The editor of the Light of Life, Nagahara Shin, similarly writes that it is necessary for Japanese to recover their "roots" in order to reestablish a positive Japanese identity. His article concludes with a photo of Yasukuni Shrine and a reference to the sacrificial spirit of those Japanese who were willing to give their lives for the nation. This spirit has been lost in modern Japan, but it can be recovered once again if the gospel is grafted onto this early foundation.77 In a postwar educational system that has forgotten the riches of the Japanese cultural heritage, a significant dimension of the Makuya mission is to nurture a healthy Japanese nationalism among its youth. In short, it is time for the revival of the Japanese spirit ( ) according to the power of the original gospel.
Conclusion
In this chapter we have seen how diverse native and foreign elements have been combined to create several different Japanese versions of apostolic Christianity. We have only highlighted some of the distinguishing characteristics and sketched some of the complicated transnational relations (the U.S., Taiwan, Israel) and influences that have shaped the development of each of these movements. In sharp contrast to the indigenous groups examined in previous chapters, these apostolic movements have rediscovered the charismatic and pentecostal dimensions of the faith. In the case of the Spirit of Jesus Church and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, leaders have also rediscovered the strands of biblical tradition that legitimize an ordained and setapart priestly order within Christianity and have created structures and polities that resemble Western churches in many respects. One area that deserves more detailed attention is the manner in which these movements have reinterpreted the Bible and adapted rituals in order to address concerns related to Japanese folk religion and the world of spirits and ancestors. It is to this fascinating development that we now turn our attention.
Chapter Seven—
Japanese Christians and the World of the Dead
The transplantation of Western Christianity to Japan over the past century has involved a fundamental clash between the missionary message and the religious consciousness and values of most Japanese. This is particularly apparent in relation to the indigenous beliefs and practices related to ancestors and the spirits of the dead. This area of difficulty is not unique to the missionary experience in Japan, but something missionaries have struggled with repeatedly throughout Asia and Africa. Some familiarity with these traditional beliefs and practices is required in order to appreciate the nature of the clash that has occurred in the Protestant missionary encounter with Japan. Following a brief introduction to this native tradition and the dominant Protestant missionary response, this chapter will examine how Japanese
Christians, particularly those belonging to the independent and indigenous movements, have reinterpreted the Bible in a manner that more effectively addresses Japanese religious and cultural concerns.
The Place of Ancestors and Spirit Belief in Japanese Culture
In the context of Japan, the constellation of beliefs and practices associated with ancestors and the world of the dead is commonly referred to as folk religion. The somewhat illdefined folk religious tradition represents the undercurrent of Japanese consciousness that continually reappears and reshapes other religious traditions. In fact, Hori Ichiro * refers to folk religion as the comparatively stable ''substructure" of Japanese religion.1 Miyake Hitoshi elaborates on the point:
It is within the frame of reference provided by folk religion that the organized religions have made their way into Japanese society. Only as they accommodated themselves to folk religion and its implicit norms did the institutional religions find acceptance and begin to exercise influence on people in their daily life.2
While the term "accommodation" here seems less than adequate to capture the complexity of the indigenization process, at the very least it must be recognized that a transplanted religious tradition that fails to address the concerns represented by this religious "substructure" will have serious difficulties in Japan. This is one of the serious dilemmas facing most transplanted Protestant mission churches.
It has long been recognized that the ancestral cult is a central feature of Japanese folk religion. In its classical or traditional form, the ancestral cult refers to the "belief in the superhuman power of the dead who are recognized as ancestors, and the rituals based on this belief."3 Ancestors were originally understood to be founders of households (ie) and successive household heads. Thus ancestor veneration was essentially a patrilineal phenomenon. The interpretative framework for the ancestral cult is a cosmology that recognizes the interdependence between two spheres: the world of the living and the spirit world of the dead. The world of the dead, traditionally associated with mountains, is populated by various kami (gods), animal spirits, spirits of dead ancestors, and protective spirits. According to the worldview of Japanese folk religion, one's situation in this life is causally influenced by the spirit world. Health problems, business failures, and personal problems are frequently attributed to the failure of descendants to properly care for their ancestors. If the appropriate rituals are
not performed, the ancestor suffers and cannot achieve lasting peace. Often wandering spirits "are said to be suffering from the emotional state of urami—bitterness, ill will, enmity, spite or malice." 4 Individuals suffering misfortune in this life often see the cause in the urami of some unpacified spirit. In order to pacify such spirits, individuals must perform memorial services and make special offerings; until the needs of the ancestors are met through rituals, they will more than likely function as malevolent spirits exacting retribution (tatari) upon the descendants.
Many observers predicted that these spirit beliefs and ancestral rites would disappear as a result of modernization and democratization. Two specialists in this field, Hoshino Eiki and Takeda Dosho*, however, maintain that "even today there is no sign that the Japanese concern for their ancestral spirits has diminished."5 Although studies indicate that modernization and urbanization have significantly modified the family structure and the conception of ancestors,6 the concern with ancestral rites and appropriate care for the deceased is still a dominant feature of contemporary Japanese religion and culture. Survey research, as well as studies of new religious movements and trends in popular culture, indicate the widespread persistence of these traditional concerns.
Survey Research
Although most Japanese do not have a clearly conceptualized religious commitment, the NHK Survey on Japanese Religious Consciousness discovered over a decade ago that many share certain religious feelings and common religious sensibilities.7 The attitude of the Japanese toward ancestors is one important area explored in this study. Almost 60 percent responded affirmatively to the question, "Do you feel a deep spiritual connection with the ancestors?" The central place of ancestors in Japanese religiosity is also reflected in ritual behavior. Some 57 percent of respondents to this survey have a Buddhist altar, with 28 percent worshipping before it each day. Similarly, 69 percent regularly participate in Buddhist rituals at the family graves during obon or at the time of the spring and autumn equinoxes. The high rate of such ritual behavior suggests that there is still a relatively strong consciousness of the ancestors among many Japanese.8
Another question in the survey that sheds light on the place of ancestors in Japanese religious consciousness is, "What is the meaning of shinko* (faith or belief) to you?" The study classified the answers given to this question by those respondents claiming to have a personal religious faith (i.e., 892 individuals out of the total of 3,600 interviewed), and discovered that 12 percent of the responses indicated that faith was understood as showing respect for the ancestors.
This survey did discover that urbanization has had a negative impact on some of these traditional beliefs and practices: 71 percent of those living in rural or village communities "felt a close connection with the ancestors," but the number declined to 56 percent in the metropolitan areas of Tokyo and Osaka. Daily worship before a Buddhist altar is 37 percent and occasional worship is 64 percent in village communities or rural areas, but declines to 23 percent daily worship and 37 percent occasional worship in urban areas.
New Religious Movements
Urbanization has clearly contributed to the decline of traditional practices that were primarily based in rural communities and extended families. At the same time the population shift to urban areas has made possible the rapid growth of new religious movements during the postwar period. Although founders of New Religions have introduced "new" revelations, gods, and rituals, these movements are nevertheless often regarded as revitalized expressions of folk religion. 9 Without denying that there are "new" elements in the New Religions, their relative success in contemporary Japan is certainly due in part to their effectiveness in relating to the "old" concerns for ancestors and spirits of the dead.
Studies of many new religious movements reveal an ongoing concern for spirits and ancestors and an emphasis on rituals enabling their members to deal appropriately with the dead and transform malevolent spirits into protective ones. Helen Hardacre's research indicates that both Reiyukai* and Kurozumikyo* stress the importance of ancestor worship in one form or another. Byron Earhart's study of GedatsuKai revealed that the founder had provided innovative means of more effectively dealing with spirits and ancestors, such as the amacha ( ), both new methods of restoring harmonious relations with the dead.
Winston Davis, in his study of Mahikari, discovered a similar preoccupation with the dead: "Knowing how to feed and worship the spirits of one's ancestors has been the key to health and happiness for many Mahikari followers." Likewise, Ian Reader notes that the taizo* ( ) fire rituals performed at Agonshu*'s popular Star Festival, is for the purpose of bringing peace to the restless spirits of ancestors and suffering souls who are causing physical and spiritual trouble for the living.10
We need to note here that new religious movements have also contributed to the transformation of the ancestor cult from a focus on a family's patrilineal forebears to a broader concern with the ancestors of both sides of the family. This
"bilateral pattern of ancestor worship," Helen Hardacre observes, "is more congruent with the nuclear family." 11 The concern for the spirits of the dead has also been extended in recent years to the spirits of mizuko or aborted and stillborn children. Many traditional Buddhist sects as well as New Religions provide memorial services for mizuko in response to the felt needs of Japanese women who are struggling with a sense of guilt and condemnation associated with the spirits of the dead fetuses.12
Ancestors and Spirits in Popular Culture
In addition to New Religions, the mass media has become a crucial "carrier" (albeit a less stable one) of beliefs and practices related to spirits and ancestors. TV programs, for example, frequently feature popular spiritual healers and psychics who advocate the ritual care of angry or disgruntled spirits in order to achieve happiness, peace, and good fortune in this life. The printed media is even more important in transmitting these folk beliefs. In bookstores across Japan one will almost always find a section labeled "the spiritual world." Here one will find books, magazines, cassettes, and videos on a wide range of topics, including healing, astrology, divination, methods for controlling the spiritual world, and ways of communicating with the spirits of the deceased. While the influence of imported New Age phenomena is not without significance, the "new" syntheses of indigenous and foreign beliefs have not fundamentally altered the cosmology and framework of traditional folk religion. The message is essentially the same, and it is transmitted with the power of modern technology. Unhappiness, illness, and assorted life problems are still, for the most part, attributed either to bad karma from one's previous existence or to the spirits of the dead.
Numerous popular authors publish volume after volume of guides to the spirit world and to the manipulation of the spirits for one's own benefit. Kuroda Minoru, for example, a former member of Mahikari and veteran comic (manga) artist, began a religious movement called Subikari Sekai Shindan in 1980. Kuroda gathered a following (a large percentage of whom are juniorhigh and highschool girls) when he began publishing a series of "spirit world comics." A recent book contains cartoons that deal with the tormenting spirits of mizuko (aborted or stillborn fetuses) and the reality of the spirit world.13 Spirits of the Dead in the World of Business
New religious movements and the mass media are not the only "carriers" of traditional religious concerns. Religious shrines and rituals concerned with the
Scenes depicting the spirits of aborted fetuses from the Japanese comic book, The Woman Who Sells Souls.
dead have even appeared in what most people would regard as the most "modern" and "secular" of all places: the Japanese company and factory. This is an area receiving considerable attention in recent years, with scholars suggesting that in some cases business enterprises appear to be taking over certain of the roles traditionally played by religion. 14 Many of these companies not only have rituals for thisworldly health, safety, and financial success but also maintain company graves. At the wellknown religious center of Mt. Koya*, for example, there are some 90 company grave sites. While some of these graves were established as early as 1938, most were not built until the late 1960s, when the extended family began to decline rapidly as a result of urbanization. Today these companies hold memorial services for the founder of the company and for individuals who died while in service to the company. (Colonel Sanders would no doubt roll over in his Louisville grave were word to reach him that in Japan Kentucky Fried Chicken celebrates a Broiler Thanksgiving Festival and a memorial service on his behalf) Upper management and individuals who served on company boards are also often enshrined and memorialized after their death. In this way the company is providing many religious services once regarded as the exclusive domain of the extended family.
In spite of the processes of modernization and urbanization, beliefs and practices related to the ancestors and the spirit world are still relatively strong in contemporary Japan. It is hardly unreasonable for us to assume that these beliefs and practices were even more prominent in the early Meiji period during the first encounter between the Protestant missionaries and the Japanese. How did the earliest Protestant missionaries respond to this area of religious concern?
Protestant Missionary Theology and the Ancestors
As we discussed earlier, Protestant missionary theology and practice have tended to emphasize a total discontinuity between the Christian faith and Japanese beliefs and practices related to the dead. This was true for the earliest pioneer missionaries of the late nineteenth century as well as for the wave of evangelical Protestant missionaries that arrived in Japan during the postwar period. As noted in chapter three, the missionary view was that various indigenous traditions would need to be "displaced" to make room for the Gospel and authentic Christian faith. The gospel preached by most missionaries included the teaching that there is no hope for those who die without faith in Christ. Kazuo Yagi explains the "normative" missionary view as follows:
Protestants see human destiny as a separation to heaven or hell immediately after death. The first result of the Protestant view is that it is too late to pray for the dead, because their eternal destiny has already been determined at death. The second result is the unbearable estrangement of the heavenbound Japanese Christian from his entire nonChristian ancestral line who are bound for hell. 15
For individualistic Americans this was clearly not an issue, but for most Japanese the offer of personal salvation apart from the household and ancestral line represented an overwhelming existential crisis. In short, the Bible of the missionaries provided no basis for comfort or hope for the larger extended family.
The theological vacuum with regard to the ancestors was accentuated by the missionary demand for ritual purity on the part of Japanese converts. The first generation of Christians in Japan was under a great deal of pressure to comply with the iconoclastic policy of the missionaries. The early history of Protestant Christianity in Japan abounds with stories of individuals being cut off from their families or isolated in their communities because of their newfound faith and consequent refusal to participate in household ancestor rites or community festivals. It has not been uncommon for zealous new Christians, following the instructions of their missionary teachers, to burn their family Buddhist altars, ancestral tablets, and Shinto altars—understandably creating innumerable family conflicts.
It was not just the missionaries who took this uncompromising approach. In his social history of the early Protestant mission churches, Morioka Kiyomi reports that the leader of the Congregational Church and founder of Doshisha* University, Niijima Jo*, following his return to Japan in 1874 after a decade of study in the United
States, took a similarly hard line regarding these traditional practices.16 When he returned to his own home, he explained to his parents that there was only one true God and that all gods made by human hands were simply idols. He promptly took down the kamidana, carried it out to the garden, and burned it. In subsequent lectures and preaching he explained that Christian commitment and faith required that one abandon the gods and buddhas and avoid participation in rituals before the kamidana and butsudan.
Morioka points out that it was extremely difficult for individuals to comply with the demand to dispose of the altars and memorial tablets unless the entire household converted to the faith. On the whole, it appears that Japanese converts found it much easier to get rid of the kamidana than the butsudan and ihai, since the latter represented the ancestors to whom the living were indebted. Morioka also notes that there was some variation in the responses of a main
household (honke) and its branches (bunke). It was particularly difficult for the honke, given their stronger sense of family history and obligation to the ancestors, to comply with the demands of missionary teachers and Japanese Christian leaders like Niijima.
The clash between Protestant theology and Japanese religious sensibilities was rooted in the fact that the missionary carriers of the New Religion
came from a culture that gave primacy to the nuclear family and to shortterm separation rites for the dead. The Japanese receivers of the New Religion came from a culture that gave primacy to the ie system and to longterm liminal rites for the household dead. 17
In the Japanese context, proper care and respect for the dead involved not only taking part in a number of rituals surrounding the funeral itself, but also the performance of annual festivals and memorial rites over the course of many years. The annual or cyclical rites are usually observed several times each year. On the spring and fall equinoxes (higan), families usually visit the household grave to clean the site and offer prayers and incense. In July or August (depending on the region of Japan) the spirits of the dead are believed to return to the home place for the severalday period referred to as obon. This is a time of family celebration that surrounds the welcoming and sending off of the ancestral spirits and that often involves visiting the household grave.
Linear rites, or memorial services ( hoji*), are normally conducted over a thirtythree year period, and include services on the seventh day and fortyninth day following a death, on the first anniversary and subsequent years (i.e., the 3rd, 7th, 13th, 17th, 23rd, 27th, and 33rd years following the death) in accordance with Buddhist tradition. Death anniversaries during the intervening years are often occasions for ritual observances before the family altar.
Ritual care of the dead beyond the funeral was clearly not a part of the Protestant tradition transplanted to Japan in the late nineteenth century. When the stark and simple Protestant funeral and burial service was compared with the traditional postfunerary rites extending over a period of many years, it is not surprising that many Japanese regarded Christianity as an "antifamily" religion that did not show proper concern for the dead.
Memorialism in Indigenous Christianity
For many Japanese, including the founders of most indigenous Christian movements, a religion that held out no hope for the salvation of the ancestors and pro
hibited members from showing respect towards them was, in effect, no religion at all. Eternal separation from those who preceded one in this life was regarded as unacceptable. As far as many Japanese Christians are concerned, there is still a vacuum in Protestant theology regarding the ancestors and relations between the living and the dead. Nor did Uchimura Kanzo *, the founder of the Nonchurch movement, seriously engage the issues with which we are concerned here.18
It has been a number of indigenous movements that developed much later in the 1930s and 1940s that finally began to read the Bible in light of Japanese folk religious concerns. The most representative groups to address these issues are the Glorious Gospel Christian Church, the Spirit of Jesus Church, the Original Gospel, and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, all founded in the 1930s and 1940s. Many Protestant missionaries have regarded these indigenous developments as unfortunate expressions of syncretism and a deviation from normative Christianity. Indigenous leaders, nevertheless, regard their views as biblical and their elaboration of the Christian faith to be no less than the fulfillment of Jesus' promise to his disciples that "when the Spirit comes he will guide you into all truth" (John 16: 13).
This does not mean that indigenous leaders have disagreed with missionary teaching on all counts. Some continue to accept the missionary view that the native ancestral cult was to be shunned as nothing more than "idol worship." The Spirit of Jesus Church, for example, regards the Buddhist altar, ancestral tablets, and amulets from Shinto shrines as dwelling places of evil spirits. According to church representatives, the ancestral cult is a direct violation of the second commandment against worshipping false gods. Converts are usually assisted by pastors in burning the memorial tablets and other nonChristian religious paraphernalia. In spite of this symbolic rejection of traditional practices, the Spirit of Jesus Church by no means neglects the ancestors (as we shall see below).19
Most other indigenous movements, by contrast, have adopted a much more tolerant approach. Japanese leaders have come to view the missionary attitude toward these matters as an unnecessary stumbling block for potential Japanese converts and most have made concerted efforts to remedy the problem, which they regard as a misinterpretation of Christianity. In a very practical handbook published by the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, for example, considerable attention is given to the problem of ancestors and care for the dead. A userfriendly questionandanswer format provides guidance on a number of topics for church members. The chapter entitled "Concerning Ancestor Veneration" explains the true Christian position with regard to the ancestors as follows:
In accordance with the Scriptures, the orthodox Christian church teaches that we are to respect our parents and truly honor our ancestors, and for this reason we reverently hold memorial services and festivals for the comforting of the spirits. Although we take special care of the dead and have high regard for our ancestors, in Christianity we do not worship the dead. As human beings, we should only worship the one true God who is the creator of heaven and earth and the source of our being; although we pray to God for the eternal peace of the dead, we do not worship the dead. 20
A similar viewpoint is expressed in a special anniversary issue of the Original Gospel's monthly magazine Seimei no hikari (Light of life), which records the results of a symposium on the theme "Ancestral Rites and Memorial Services." The discussion is introduced with this explanation:
Christianity is misunderstood as a religion that does not show proper care and respect for the ancestors. One of the causes of this misunderstanding is that foreign missionaries taught Japanese that "they must get rid of their Shinto and Buddhist altar, since they represent nothing but idol worship."21
The editor goes on to explain that ritual care of the ancestors is not actually worship, but an expression of gratefulness and respect toward those to whom the living are indebted. While these explanations emphasize that it is "Christian" to show respect and care for the dead, we will show how these and other indigenous movements have moved far beyond the mere memorialism suggested by these publications.
Although these movements differ in their teachings regarding participation in the traditional practices, at the very least all have provided alternative and functionally equivalent rituals to remember and care for the dead (see table 5). Following a brief description of these ritual observances, we will consider the theological explanation for these practices in several representative groups.
In all the movements in which the founder has died, some memorial ritual has been institutionalized. In the case of the Nonchurch movement, there is a long tradition of holding memorial lectures and banquets in Tokyo and the Kansai areas on the Sunday nearest to 28 March, the death anniversary of Uchimura. The lectures are primarily regarded as opportunities for evangelism and outreach, but at the same time comprise ritual expressions of respect for Uchimura. Other groups hold actual memorial services on behalf of the founder. Christ Heart Church, for example, holds a service for the founder, Kawai Shinsui, in early August at the conclusion of a threeday retreat for study and training. The memorial service is preceded by several days of lectures, meditation, and
Table 5. Memorialism and Ritual Cae of the dead in Japanese Christian Movements
Annual Memorial Lecture in honor of Uchimura Kanzo * (Osaka*).
cleaning of the head church facilities and graves. The church makes a point of not holding services in midAugust since it would conflict with the traditional obon observances, in which many members continue to participate with their nonChristian relatives. Teshima Ikuro*, the founder of the Original Gospel movement, is also memorialized in annual services. In addition, the elderly members of the Kumamoto Original Gospel Church (where this movement began) clean the cemetery plot and offer fresh flowers every three days at the grave of Teshima and some of his earliest disciples. In the case of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, the founder, Father Otsuki* ( reibo kinenbi).
While founders usually receive special attention, similar ritual care is provided for regular members and their families. All of the movements have Christianized the cyclical and linear rites for the dead observed by the majority of Japanese. The cyclical rites often involve an annual Common Memorial Service for Comforting of the Spirits ( godo* ireisai) during the obon season or a congregational memorial service on Easter Sunday. Christ Heart Church holds such a service on 29
April, a national holiday, in remembrance of Emperor Showa*'s birthday. Since it is a holiday, it is easier for church members to gather at the head church near Mount
Fuji. On the occasion of these services the founder's photograph is displayed and surrounded with flowers. In addition
Believers of the Christ Heart Church praying at the church grave sites following the annual memorial service for the Founder (Fujiyoshida).
to scripture readings and hymns, the service includes a reading of the names of all deceased members. The head of the church offers words of comfort and remembrance. This is followed by a taperecorded sermon by the deceased founder. Following the service, members leave the church building to offer their respects at the grave of the founder and the crypt that holds the ashes of the deceased. The day concludes with a luncheon, a time of reflection, and a sharing of memories and stories regarding those who have passed away.
Annual memorial services also hold an important place in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. In addition to memorializing the dead according to the Roman Catholic calendar (on All Saints' Day in November, for example), leaders recognize that it is important for the church to provide services at times during the year when Japanese are most conscious and concerned about the ancestors, such as obon or higan. During these services members hold the photograph of the deceased family member on their lap until they are instructed to bring them forward and place them on a table at the front of the sanctuary for a pastoral prayer. The service concludes with a "vicarious mass" or Lord's Supper on behalf of the dead. The names of the deceased are read and the living receive the bread and wine on their behalf. This is a concrete manifestation of the "communion of the saints," and it is understood that the dead are receiving this communion spiritually in heaven.
Linear rites are also observed in various ways by most of these movements. These often follow the Buddhist custom of performing memorial services for the
dead after so many days, months, and years (firstyear anniversary, third, seventh, and so on). In response to requests from members, leaders or pastors of most of these movements hold memorial services in the church or in members' homes according to the usual schedule of linear memorial rites. In the weekly church bulletins of the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church, for example, there are announcements regarding the death anniversaries of various members that indicate how many years it has been since they were "called to heaven." 22 Several of the movements have also composed hymns commemorating the dead for these services.23 Almost all the leaders and pastors of these movements regard such memorial services as prime opportunities for evangelism. While many Japanese would resist attending regular services at a Christian church, most friends and relatives find it difficult not to attend memorial rituals.
Memorial services are also quite common in the Nonchurch movement, but there is no set ritual or liturgy for such occasions. Some individuals hold family services in the home, while others organize memorial services with the Nonchurch group to which they belong. Sometimes a hall is rented for the occasion and a meal is shared together. Reflecting the Nonchurch movement's individualistic stance on matters of faith, there is considerable variation in both the content and timing of services. A Nonchurch group in Hamamatsu, for example, holds a special meeting on 15 August each year to remember the defeat of Japan that ended the war. This is, of course, during the obon season, a time when it is natural for Japanese to remember the dead. Although the primary concern of the meeting is to reflect on the responsibility of Christians with regard to world peace, it includes a communal memorial service for a number of individuals from their circle who died in the war. Another common practice in the Nonchurch movement is to honor the deceased through the publication of a special memorial volume of essays in a book or magazine.
In sharp contrast to Protestant missionary policy, many indigenous movements allow their members to maintain the traditional Buddhist altar in the home. Christ Heart Church, for example, sees no conflict between Christian faith and ancestor veneration. In fact, their members are encouraged to show proper respect toward traditional customs, and their participation in Buddhist ancestral rites with nonChristian family members is not regarded as problematic. Similarly, leaders in the Original Gospel movement encourage their members to pray where their ancestors prayed—in front of the Buddhist altar. When a meeting is held in the home of a member who has a Buddhist altar, the leader will simply place a menorah (the symbol of God and light used in Makuya worship) in front of the altar and hold the worship service with the doors of the butsudan
opened. The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus encourages its members to maintain, as an alternative to the Buddhist altar, a Christian family altar as a focus for worship and prayer. Memorial tablets are replaced by small wooden crosses inscribed with the names or "spiritual names" of the deceased family members. This adaptation resembles the traditional Buddhist practice of giving a kaimyo *, or Buddhist name, to the deceased. In this way the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is providing concrete and visible means for their members to show their nonChristian relatives and neighbors that Christianity is a religion that shows special care and respect for the dead.
It would be wrong to leave the impression that only the indigenous movements have adapted to the needs of many Japanese to show special care and respect for the ancestors. In fact, many of the Christian churches related to denominations from Europe and North America have instituted a wide range of postfunerary rites over the course of the past century. There are a number of helpful studies documenting these ritual developments in various denominations. David Reid has analyzed the manner in which members of the United Church of Christ in Japan have adapted Christian practices to indigenous ancestral rituals. Similarly, Nishiyama Shigeru's study of the Anglican Church revealed that the ancestral cult has significantly transformed the practice of Christianity within this denomination. David Doerner's survey of a Roman Catholic parish likewise showed that numerous accommodations have been made to indigenous beliefs and practices related to the dead. As Berentsen notes, the Roman Catholic tradition has a more natural affinity to the ancestral cult than Protestant forms of Christianity because of its long practice of "offering liturgical prayers and Holy Mass for the dead."24 More recently, Mark Luttio has shown how the Lutheran Church has created a funeral rite that is more compatible with Japanese religious sensitivities and concerns. Luttio also provides a helpful analysis of the funeral rite developed by the Japan Evangelical Church (JELC) in 1993, comparing this ritual not only with the JELC's first funeral rite of 1897 but also with traditional Buddhist rites for the dead. Faithful to the early missionary tradition, the 1897 rite consisted of only a funeral and burial (on the same day). The 1993 rite has adapted and incorporated many elements found in the protracted process of ritual care provided by the Japanese Buddhist tradition. Although these churches have made numerous ritual adaptations, for the most part they have failed to address the theological questions and concerns related to ancestors and various spirits.25
Typical family altars in the homes of Holy Ecclesia of Jesus members, with a wooden cross inscribed with the name of a deceased family member (left), and a more elaborate example (right).
Reading the Bible with Japanese Eyes
The most significant development with regard to the dead is the theological view of many indigenous leaders that Christians have a legitimate mission to the spirit world
(referred to in table 1, pages 14–15, as the "extension of salvation to the spirit world"). Upon reading the Bible for themselves, Japanese discovered that the New Testament contained a number of texts that were relevant to their concerns for the extended family and ancestors. Guided by their individualistic gospel, Protestant missionaries had apparently overlooked or effectively ignored these passages. Reading the same Bible as their missionary predecessors, the leaders of indigenous movements have all concluded that it is not only proper for Christians to show respect toward the dead but that there is hope for those who died without encountering the Gospel in this life. These leaders appeal to the same biblical texts when making claims regarding the potential salvation of the preChristian dead. The locus classicus is found in 1 Peter:
For Christ also suffered for sins once for all, the righteous for the unrighteous, in order to bring you to God. He was put to death in the flesh, but made alive
in the spirit, in which also he went and made a proclamation to the spirits in prison, who in former times did not obey, when God waited patiently in the days of Noah, during the building of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were saved through water (3:18–22).
And in the following chapter:
For this is the reason the gospel was proclaimed even to the dead, so that, though they had been judged in the flesh, they might live in the spirit as God does (4:6).
An ordained elder of the United Church of Christ in rural Shikoku, seated in front of the family altar,
showing Buddhist memorial tablets standing next to the crucifix.
The ministry to the world of the dead is understood as a continuation of the work begun by Jesus Christ when he descended into hades and preached to the imprisoned spirits who had rejected Noah's message from God in an earlier period of salvation
The church altar of a United Church of Christ congregation in rural Shikoku displaying photos of deceased members and a Buddhist memorial tablet at the annual memorial service on Easter Sunday.
history. This interpretation can best be understood with reference to the traditional worldview and familial orientation referred to above.
The Spiritualistic Worldview
Except perhaps for Uchimura's Nonchurch movement, these indigenous movements share what we might call a "spiritualistic worldview" not unlike the cosmology of Japanese folk religion. Their interpretation of the New Testament and their soteriological claims regarding the spirits of the dead must be understood in terms of their belief in the reality and interdependence of "this world" and another ''spirit world" (i.e., the world of the ancestors). The lands of the living and the dead are regarded as interdependent and linked symbolically through prayer, preaching, and other ritual behavior. While this worldview may resemble that of the folk religious tradition introduced earlier, indigenous leaders maintain that it is also the worldview of Jesus and the early Christian movement.
Belief in the reality of a separate world of spirits and supernatural beings able to causally affect our world is hardly a novel idea or one foreign to the world of the Bible. As we noted in chapter three, Marcus J. Borg has argued that we cannot accurately understand the place of Jesus in the JudeoChristian tradition without giving serious attention to the "world of Spirit." 26 While the notion of "another world" may be alien to postenlightenment Westerners, Borg maintains that Jesus belonged to the charismatic stream of Judaism that took this worldview for granted, and that he served as a mediator between this world and the world of Spirit. The Japanese movements under consideration believe that they have been given the religious authority by Jesus Christ to continue this mediation between the two worlds. For some this interpretation is related to their reading of Matthew 18:18–20:
Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. Again, truly I tell you, if two of you agree on earth about anything you ask, it will be done for you by my Father in heaven. For where two or three are gathered in my name, I am among them.
This passage suggests an interdependence between this world and the spirit world and indicates that followers of Jesus have been authorized to influence the state of affairs in both worlds. According to Murai Jun, the founder of the Spirit of Jesus Church, the tragedy of Western Christianity is that it no longer recognizes that the church has been given the authority to forgive sins. This has apparently been forgotten along with all the signs, miracles, and wonders that characterized the early church.
Sugita Kotaro *, the founder of the Glorious Gospel Christian Church, encouraged his followers to pray on behalf of the ancestors with the understanding that the gospel of Christ could reach them in the spirit world. In volume 2 of The Glorious Gospel, Sugita writes, in rather Pauline fashion, that he is "certain in the Lord" that "offering prayers of intercession on behalf of the dead is a good and proper thing for believers to do. Although there is no Scriptural text stating that those prayed for will necessarily be saved, neither is there a text instructing us not to pray for the dead."27 Sugita goes on to explain that God expressed his parental heart for all humankind in sending his son to die for the sins of the world. It is the height of selfishness and selfcenteredness for us to think that God hated those individuals who lived before the revelation of Christ and only loves those of us who had the opportunity to encounter the Gospel over the past two thousand years. The fact that Christ descended into hell and preached to the imprisoned spirits is a clear indication that God cares for the dead as well as the living. He concludes that Christians should pray for the spirits of the dead, but should not assume that each person prayed for will necessarily be saved. While there are grounds for optimism, ultimately it is God who decides whose name will be written in the Book of Life.
The leaders of other movements indicate even greater confidence in the efficacy of their prayers for the dead and their preaching to the spirit world. According to the Original Gospel symposium referred to above, "Ancestral Rites and Memorial Services," the founder, Teshima Ikuro*, taught that Christian memorial services were important rituals in the life of faith. Instead of chanting the Buddhist sutras* on these occasions, however, one should read from the Bible. As the Bible teaches, "Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God." Teshima explained that the spirits of the dead cannot eat material bread, but they can eat the word of God. That is why the most appropriate memorial rite is to read to them the word of God. Through our prayerful reading of the Bible, the "wandering spirits'' receive guidance and are pointed in the direction of Christ. In contrast to the missionary tradition, Teshima taught that there is no need to throw out the Buddhist altar and memorial tablets. In fact, one should open the doors to the altar and preach the gospel to the ancestors. In this way, preaching and intercessary prayers on behalf of the dead are recognized as efficacious.
Imahashi Atsushi, a disciple of Teshima and founder of the LifeGiving Christ, explained to me that the first thing he did after his healing and conversion experience was to evangelize his ancestors.28 He went before the Buddhist family altar and reported his conversion to the ancestors, praying that they
would also receive the light of Christ. Because of the example of Christ recorded in 1 Peter, Imahashi has every confidence that the dead can hear the gospel preached to them and ultimately be saved. According to Imahashi, this is what it means to confess that Jesus Christ is Lord both of this world and of the spirit world.
This type of care for the dead has become a rather common ingredient of pastoral care in the movements under consideration. A seasoned pastor of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus told me that he is often asked by members to pray for ancestors or family members who died without faith. On one such occasion he instructed them to place the photographs of the two deceased family members in the living room alcove, and they all joined together in prayer for their salvation. As the pastor prayed fervently, he could see the two spirits struggling in the world of darkness. "At that point," he explained, "the spirit of Christ within me proclaimed, 'I am the resurrection and the life.' At that moment these two spirits were indwelled by Christ and transformed into light. Then I saw them rise to heaven." Another leader described a similar pastoral visit as follows:
One of the members of my church had recently lost her unbelieving husband and could not find peace. She felt that her husband's spirit was hovering like a dark cloud about the house, and she asked me to pray for him. I visited her home and she showed me her husband's photograph and the container holding his ashes. I clutched the container close to my heart and began to pray for him with the words of Christ, "I am the resurrection and the life." I called out his name and prayed that he would believe the gospel. When I finished praying she and I both felt great relief, and the Spirit confirmed in our hearts that he had been saved. After this pastoral visit, she was no longer troubled by his presence.
It is clear that concern for the dead is not abstract or philosophical, but a pressing existential matter. Furthermore, these examples illustrate the fundamental belief in the interdependence of this world and the spirit world and the power of the living to influence the world of the dead. In most cases, the salvific work of Christ in the other world is confirmed through visions, dreams, and the inward witness of the Holy Spirit.
Familial Orientation
As the foregoing examples suggest, notions of familial solidarity clearly shape the Japanese interpretation of the salvation of those already in the spirit world. The words of Paul and Silas to the Philippian jailer (Acts 16:31) are interpreted from a Japanese cultural perspective and taken very literally: "Believe on the
Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household" (emphasis added). The Japanese household (ie) is an extended family that includes both present and past members (ancestors). A Japanese expression that combines a Buddhist notion of merit with a Confucian familial orientation is often used to illustrate this interpretation of interdependence:
If one family member takes monastic vows, then up to nine generations of the whole household will be saved by virtue of his merit.
Commenting on this expression, one leader explained:
Since I have escaped the sin of Adam, so did my family. But this is not because of my virtue, but through the grace of Christ. I have confidence that my ancestors are saved, and I have been blessed by the fact that most of my living family members have also been saved.
Just as Abram was called by God and became a source of blessing for all the families of the earth (Gen. 12: 1–2), an individual's salvation in Christ can become the source of blessing to others, both the living and the dead.
Care for the Dead in the Spirit of Jesus Church
The Spirit of Jesus Church links salvific work in the spirit world and the notion of "household" salvation to the longforgotten ritual of vicarious baptism referred to in I Cor. 15:29, a key New Testament passage on the resurrection of the dead:
Otherwise, what will those people do who receive baptism on behalf of the dead? If the dead are not raised at all, why are people baptized on their behalf?
According to this church, it is through the ritual of vicarious baptism ( ) that the blessings of individual salvation can be extended to past generations as well. In a work entitled Biblical Theology, the founder, Murai Jun, placed considerable emphasis on this teaching. According to Murai, the biblical teaching of the salvation of the dead has been hidden from the church since the second century, when the church ceased to practice "water" and "spirit" baptism. ''It is in these last days," Murai writes, "that this great mystery has been revealed to the Spirit of Jesus Church." 29 When newcomers visit one of the churches, they are presented with the Gospel and encouraged to accept it for their own salvation and, at the same time, informed that there is also salvation for the ancestors through vicarious baptism.
How does this work out in practice? Members can request that ancestors be baptized at the same time they are, or whenever they become concerned about the salvation of those who have gone before. A member simply states the ancestor's name, announces his or her relationship to the deceased, and then undergoes baptism by immersion on their behalf. It is significant to note here that the church also performs baptism for mizuko (aborted and stillborn children). In this way, the Spirit of Jesus Church is responding to the felt needs of Japanese women to deal with the sense of guilt and the curse associated with the spirit of a mizuko. Through this ritual the Good News of the forgiveness of sins is communicated to the dead, and their spirits are transported from hades to heaven. 30 Although their bodies decay in the grave, their spirits can be saved through the forgiveness of sins. Believers are assured that they may lay aside all their doubts and misgivings regarding the state of their ancestors following this ritual. A pastor in Okinawa explained to me that prior to the ritual of vicarious baptism many members have disturbing visions of the wandering spirits of the dead. Following this ritual care, however, the spirits are felt to be at peace and there are no longer any troubling spiritual encounters.
This understanding of vicarious baptism is expressed clearly in a hymn by that title in the church's Spirit Hymns.31 Vicarious Baptism
I
The spirits of our longsleeping ancestors still now are weeping in sorrow.
Spring passes, summer comes, autumn goes and winter comes, But hades is eternally winter's dead of night.
II
Like the neverending shadowy darkness of hades tears are flowing.
Crossing over the river of death, the anguish of that day. Even now they are in the bitter harbor.
III
The ship that goes out knows no bottom, Sinking deeper and deeper in the depths. Still now the salvation of our ancestors is closed, Eternal spirits anguishing ceaselessly.
IV
Evil spirits come like a whirlpool, Frantically seeking salvation.
Faintly hearing the splash of water,
The mysterious work of atonement in songs from heaven.
V
By and by the gates of hades are opened Through the name of Jesus.
The substitutionary baptism of descendants in the world— Oh, what immeasurable grace!
VI
Oh, the cries of joy reverberate! Our ancestors have been saved!
The light of grace shines all around,
The songs of the angels thunder throughout heaven and earth.
Concern for the dead does not end with the ritual of baptism. The aforementioned Common Memorial Service for Comforting of the Spirits is also an important service in all Spirit of Jesus churches. According to one church representative, the significance of this service is that it allows living believers to join with the spirits of the dead in common prayer to Jesus Christ. In this it certainly resembles the Buddhist obon festival, a central motif of which is reunion and fellowship with the dead. There is some variation in the observance of this service from church to church. In one church on the island of Shikoku, for example, this service is held each August, and members bring a list of deceased family members for inclusion in prayer. 32 Memorial services are also performed numerous times throughout the year according to the requests of members (these services often follow the Buddhist custom to perform memorial services for the dead after so many days, months, and years). Although there is no incense, Buddhist altars, or ancestor tablets, the Common Memorial Service for Comforting of the Spirits is clearly the functional equivalent of the Buddhist memorial service that Japanese view as important for showing proper respect to ancestors and for assuring their eternal peace.
The concern for the dead is also manifested in the Daiseikai ( ), a meeting lasting several days that is held annually in each district or region. In eastern Japan, for example, a memorial service is observed during the Daiseikai each May for the founder and for pastors who have died. In addition to the general memorial services for the dead, the Tokyo church (headquarters) also
observes annually in March a special memorial service for the founder and first bishop of the Spirit of Jesus Church.
The Japanese Christian Response to Indigenous Spirit Beliefs
While many Japanese Christians are deeply concerned about the salvation of their ancestors, they also harbor fears about the possible misfortune (tatari) they may suffer at the hands of malevolent spirits of the dead known as onryo * . These concerns are deeply rooted in Japanese history, according to Hori Ichiro*, and became widespread in the early Heian period (784–1185).33 It has long been believed that individuals who die a violent or untimely death due to war or some unforeseen accident are filled with hate and bitterness and will return to cause harm to those in this world.34 Missionary theology and practice provide little or no solace to Japanese Christians who are troubled by such fears. This is clearly an important dimension of pastoral care in the Japanese context, but something one will not find seriously addressed in the practical theology curriculum of any Protestant seminary in Japan. The leadership in most indigenous Christian movements, on the other hand, accepts these as "real concerns" and responds with prayers and ritual care that empowers many members to carry on with everyday life. Teachings regarding the efficacy of prayer, preaching to the spirit world, and vicarious baptism not only provide for the salvation of the dead but also help safeguard the living against these potentially dangerous spirits.
A participant in Original Gospel's symposium on "Ancestral Rites and Memorial Services" confided that she had been deeply troubled for years at the "bad death" of her parents resulting from the bombing of Hiroshima. She sought peace first in Seicho* no Ie (a New Religion) and then through dedicated participation in a Christian church. Neither provided the solution for her spiritual distress. All of this changed when she encountered the Original Gospel movement and discovered the power of Christ over the spirit world. Her story is as follows:
After joining the Original Gospel movement I was blessed with a happy marriage, and my husband and I began our life of faith together. However, when each of our children was born the spirits of my parents would appear, and my mother, in a rather mad and lunatic form, would demand, "Let me meet the children." These were my parents who had died of an illness resulting from the atomic bomb and had left me behind as a young child. I just could not bear this recurring image of my parents.
One evening at the Original Gospel retreat on Mount Hiko I finally prayed fervently, "Lord, please save the souls of my parents who are wandering in the
spirit world." That night I had a dream of my father and mother encircled by light and accompanied by the elders of the Original Gospel. And with the most joyful look on their faces, I saw them moving through a tunnel of light. Through this dream I was convinced and assured that Christ had saved my parents. Since that time only my mother's happy face has appeared to me. 35
Although concern for the dead is related most often to immediate family members and relatives, most of these movements extend their care to include the muenbotoke
( ), the nameless or unknown dead who wander about with no descendants to properly care for their needs. Members of the Original Gospel movement in Okinawa, for example, were troubled by visions of the thousands upon thousands who died on the Okinawan islands as the Pacific War came to an end. These nameless ones had never received a proper funeral or memorial rites and were destined to wander about the spirit world. Through the founder's teaching they realized that these spirits could be saved by Christ in the spirit world. With this inclusive understanding of Christ's salvific work, members of the Original Gospel held a special service before a memorial stone for the war dead of Okinawa and prayed for their peace and salvation in the other world. Participants reported that they experienced a spiritual vision of these many suffering spirits being rescued as they joined in collective prayer on their behalf
Another example is the care accorded the Catholic martyrs on the island of Kyushu* by the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. In certain areas in Kyushu popular religious beliefs regarding dangerous "wandering spirits" became associated with Christianity because of the large number of Catholics who were killed there in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. It is not uncommon to hear stories attributing suffering, illness, or tatari to these Christian ghosts. Father Otsuki*, the founder, made a pilgrimage to Kyushu with a number of pastors and visited the various sites of the martyrs. Recalling that these martyrs were killed without the opportunity to participate in a last mass, Father Otsuki poured wine on each grave site and held a memorial mass to comfort their spirits. The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus has now established several churches in Kyushu in memory of these longforgotten and largely ignored Catholic martyrs. Today scores of pastors and members make pilgrimages to Kyushu in order to visit these sites and honor the faith and sacrifice of the martyrs through memorial services. For these Japanese Christians, the "communion of saints" is an experienced reality as they partake of bread and wine vicariously on behalf of the fallen martyrs.
Conclusion
In the various ways discussed above, indigenous Christian movements have extended the scope of salvation to the spirit world. Their ritual care of ancestors and wandering spirits brings peace to those already in the other world as well as protection for those still in the land of the living. While some may consider these spirits to be passively awaiting the final consummation of all things, others see them as taking on a more active role. According to the Spirit of Jesus Church, for example, vicarious baptism releases the spirits of the dead from hades and transports them to heaven, where they pray for family members remaining on earth. Just as a dead person is transformed into a benevolent ancestor through Buddhist memorial services, the Spirit of Jesus Church transforms their dead through baptism into benevolent ancestors who perform intermediary prayers (torinashi no inori) on their behalf. Similarly, some members of Spirit of Jesus Church refer to those in the other world as "protective spirits," and understand them to function much like guardian angels. In other words, the spirit world is populated with beings who provide protection and intercession on behalf of the living.
In this context it is interesting to recall Max Weber's view that one of the consequences of the Protestant Reformation was the "unprecedented inner loneliness" experienced by the single individual as a result of being cut off from the mystery and magic of medieval Catholicism. 36 This "disenchantment of the world" through rationalization left the lone individual responsible for his or her fate without the comforting resources of priests, sacraments, and saints. One could make the case that these indigenous Christian movements have contributed in a small way to the "reenchantment of the world" through their recognition of the interdependence of the visible and invisible realms and the power of ritual over the living and the dead. In this way, their understanding of the unseen world has more in common with the
Roman Catholic tradition than with Protestant Christianity.37
Chapter Eight—Comparative Patterns of Growth and Decline
As we have seen, since the reopening of Japan to the West in the late nineteenth century scores of denominations and sects have made their way from Europe and North America in an attempt to Christianize Japan, but institutionally affiliated Christians still amount to only about one percent of the population. When one considers the human and financial resources invested by both Roman Catholic and Protestant churches, as well as the efforts of indigenous Christian movements, it is hardly a picture of success. In a word, the story of Christianity in Japan is often portrayed as one of "failure" in comparison to the remarkable success of Christianity in Africa,
Latin America, and nearby Korea. What is it about Christianity, or about Japanese society and culture, that has made the proselytization so difficult? This chapter
will briefly introduce sociological research on patterns of "growth" and "nongrowth" and consider some of the key difficulties related to the transplantation of Christianity in Japan.
The Sociology of Transplanted Churches
A review of research on church growth in Japan reveals that a large proportion of the studies focus on the early period of the Protestant missions. The most authoritative work in this regard is undoubtedly Morioka Kiyomi's Japan's Modern Society and Christianity. This study draws on earlier research by Morioka and his students, and provides a social history along with an analysis of mission work and church formation from 1852 to 1912. Morioka gives considerable attention to both the contextual factors (the sociopolitical climate, the legal situation, the struggle with indigenous religious practices) and the internal institutional factors (leadership, religious rivalry, higher criticism, and liberal theology) that shaped growth and decline patterns during the period studied.
Another helpful study, which draws on Morioka's earlier work, is Yamamori Tetsunao's Church Growth in Japan: A Study in the Development of Eight
Denominations, 1859–1939. The author provides a comparative analysis of growth patterns in the Anglican, Presbyterian, American Baptist, Congregational,
Methodist, Disciples of Christ, Southern Baptist, and Seventhday Adventist churches during five historical periods. He examines both the sociocultural setting
(contextual factors) and institutional factors that influenced growth patterns in each period. For example, the author argues that between 1882 and 1889, the era of "openness to the West," the Congregational and Presbyterian churches made rapid progress because they sent more missionaries, trained national leaders at a quicker pace, organized more selfsupporting churches, and emphasized education and work in strategic areas.
Robert Lee's Stranger in the Land develops a theoretical framework based largely upon national contextual factors. In a historical overview of Christianity in Japan (including the early Catholic period), Lee relates the growth and decline patterns to a typology of "responses" that range from periods of cordial welcome to times of hostility and persecution. While Lee provides a helpful perspective on early Christian activity in Japan, his primary focus is on the United Church of Christ (Kyodan *) during the early postwar period. The Kyodan was actually quite successful at attracting new members during this period. From 1947 to 1951, for example, the
Kyodan recorded over 10,000 baptisms a year, compared with less than 3,000 for 1990. Membership retention, however, was
more difficult. It seemed that scores were going out the back door as others came through the front door.
Several years after Lee's study appeared, the investigation of church growth became a major preoccupation of sociologists in North America. Serious discussions of church growth and decline in the United States began with the publication of Dean M. Kelley's Why Conservative Churches are Growing in 1972. 1 The basic thesis developed by Kelly in this controversial book can be summarized as follows: evangelical churches are growing because they fulfill the primary function of a religion, that of providing ultimate meaning to human life. Liberal or more ecumenical bodies, on the other hand, are declining because they tend to neglect this central function, focusing instead on various social issues. While Kelly does not fault the ecumenical churches for their social concerns, he maintains that failure "to undergird their activities with adequate grounding in ultimate meaning" has contributed to organizational decline. Kelley documents his argument with considerable data from both mainline (declining) denominations and evangelical (growing) churches in the United States.
Since the publication of Kelly's work, growing and declining denominations have been distinguished primarily in terms of their conservative or liberal theological orientation. Subsequent research has shown that church growth is related to a complex pattern of interacting factors and cannot be traced to a single cause. A volume edited by Dean R. Hoge and David A. Roozen under the title Understanding Church Growth and Decline provides a helpful antidote to simplistic explanations.2 The researchers collaborating on this collection of case studies developed a more comprehensive framework for understanding organizational growth and decline, drawing attention to contextual factors that apply as much to religion as to any other institution.
About a decade after Hoge and Roozen's work, Wade Clark Roof and William McKinney provided another study of denominations in the United States that generally supported Kelley's earlier distinction between growth and decline in terms of theological orientation and further clarified the demographic factors that encourage these patterns.3 Kelley's work focused on growth due to conversions, evangelistic outreach, and new church development. The size of a religious organization, however, is also dependent on the "natural growth" that occurs over time. Studies have shown that class, educational level, and theological heritage shape differential fertilities from group to group, and that upward mobility leads to a decline in fertility and birthrates. While more active membership recruitment and new church development on the part of conservative religious bodies cannot be discounted, Roof and McKinney's study as well as
others indicate that higher birthrates and more effective religious socialization largely explain the current patterns of growth and decline.
These recent perspectives on the sociology of church growth have not yet been systematically applied to the study of Japanese Christianity. Nevertheless, we can at least observe that patterns of church growth in Japan today resemble those found by researchers in the United States. An examination of denominational statistics reveals that older Japanese churches, though not in decline like their counterparts in North America, are recording only modest church growth. For example, the United Church of Christ in Japan and the Anglican Church showed membership increases of approximately five percent over the past decade, while Japanese churches identified more closely with American evangelicalism recorded significantly higher growth rates of fifteen percent or more during the same period. These higher growth rates, however, are not significantly altering the overall picture of Christianity in Japan since the total numbers are small, amounting to only a few hundred new members each year. 4
Indigenization: A CureAll?
One frequently hears that the primary reason why churches have experienced only minimal growth in Japan is because they are still Western in orientation and have failed to develop indigenous forms of leadership, organization, and worship. Robert Lee, for example, concluded that the "Westernness" of Christianity represents a major obstacle to church growth in Japanese society. In one of the only articles on the sociology of missions, David Heise similarly pointed out that "foreign churches often are rejected if their social organization is too dissimilar to native patterns."5 Hayashi Minoru more recently characterized the Christian movement in Japan as "a Westernized, nongrowing, and weakened form of Christianity."6 The general consensus appears to be that succesful transplantation and church growth require indigenization. If indigenization is the "cure'' for nongrowth, one would expect to find indigenous movements to be dynamic and growing. An overview of growth and decline patterns of representative organizations, however, reveals a more ambiguous pattern.
Nonchurch Movement
The Nonchurch movement has recorded significant growth since Uchimura Kanzo* began his Bible meetings in 1900 with twentyfive students in his home. This initial group of disciples became the nucleus of other Nonchurch associa
Table 6. Location and Number of Nonchurch Movement Meetings in 1967
LOCATION HOME RENTED ROOMS HOSPITALS SCHOOLS WORKPLACE TOTAL
Tokyo 48 20 6 8 9 91
5 Other urban centers 22 14 4 3 3 46
Other regions 187 25 13 13 9 247
Total 257 59 23 24 21 384
Figures taken from Takahashi Saburo *, [In search of the Spirit of the Nonchurch movement] (Tokyo: Shinkyo* Shuppansha, 1970), 196.
tions. By 1905 there were fourteen branches of the Kyoyukai* (Fellowship of Disciples), and supporters of Uchimura grew in number through his public lectures in rented facilities and the publication of his magazine, Bible Studies. A gift from a supporter in 1908 made it possible to build Imai Kan, a hall near Uchimura's home, which became the center for his ongoing lectures. In 1919 Uchimura moved his Sunday lectures to a rented hall in Otemachi*, where 600 to 700 people attended each week. These numbers, however, do not adequately reflect the true size of Uchimura's following. In one of the earliest issues of his magazine he had already referred to his ideal of "a church on paper" to describe the relationship between himself and his growing number of readers. Uchimura reports that by 1928 Bible Studies had 4,200 subscribers, and his Sunday lectures had a "paying membership of 552, with a large waiting list" of individuals who wished to attend.7
Although some observers thought that the Nonchurch movement would decline and disappear after the death of Uchimura, it has in fact expanded as his disciples pursued independent evangelistic activities, organized groups, and published their own monthly magazines. On the basis of magazine subscriptions and attendance at Nonchurch meetings, John Howes suggested a Nonchurch membership of between 50,000 and 100,000 in 1957.8 While this number seems rather high, the number of publications and organized groups does indicate a substantial following. On the basis of a survey conducted in 1967, Takahashi Saburo argued that Uchimura's prophetic spirit and mission had been effectively transmitted. Takahashi discovered over 50 different monthly magazines published by various disciples between 1920 and 1966, and found a total of 384 different groups throughout the country (see table 6).9 Since
well over half of these groups met in homes, it is not unreasonable to assume that most were small gatherings of five to ten people, though the statistics include several Bible lecture meetings held in rented halls with over one hundred persons in attendance. Although Takahashi did not estimate the actual number of participants, a decade later Carlo Caldarola's study placed the membership at about 35,000. 10
If Caldarola's membership figure for the mid1970s is accurate, it is apparent that the movement has experienced a steady decline for the past two decades, since, according to recent information, there are only about 300 Nonchurch groups active today. The number of charismatic teachers has declined considerably and many groups operate on the basis of a rotating leadership. Most groups are struggling to carry on with only five to ten members, though several larger groups still remain— the Bible lectures ofSekine Masao, for example, still attract over 100 people each week, and close to 1,000 still subscribe to his magazine. Similarly, Takahashi Saburo*'s weekly lectures are attended by 50 or more and his magazine is sent to almost 2,500. It is still very difficult to calculate the actual number of people involved in the Nonchurch movement, but 5,000 is probably a fair estimate.11 A national meeting of Nonchurch groups has been held each year since 1987 to discuss the many critical issues the movement faces today. The first annual meeting was attended by 361 individuals and attendance in subsequent years has averaged about 300. According to the records of these meetings, the number of independent evangelists declined considerably during the third generation of the Nonchurch movement, and young people today generally do not find it very attractive. Furthermore, the members are struggling to meet the needs of aging followers who are without pastoral care as groups disband following the retirement or death of the leader. It remains to be seen whether these coordinated national efforts will be able to revitalize the movement.12
The Way
The Way, the second oldest indigenous movement, has experienced a similar pattern of growth and decline. Founded by Matsumura Kaiseki in 1907, it had a membership of 271 by 1911, with a main church in Tokyo and several branch churches around the country. Over the next two decades groups were organized on university campuses (Tokyo Imperial University, Keio*, Waseda, Tokyo Agricultural University) and branch churches were established in prefectures throughout
Japan (from Kyushu* to Hokkaido*). In 1936, at the age of 78, Matsumura retired and appointed his adopted son and closest disciple to succeed him
as head of the movement. That same year, The Way published a membership list of 309 pages with the names and addresses of some 4,300 members. This list included 101 members located overseas, for the most part in Japanese colonies such as Manchuria, and a few in immigrant communities in North and South America.
13 On the basis of the records I have been able to locate, this was the peak of the group's membership. Although it continued to record new members through the 1940s and 1950s, the number of deaths and the increasing number of "inactive" members has meant a steady decline in the postwar period. By 1970 the movement had declined to a membership of 2,343, affiliated with nine churches.14 Although The Way continues to print 1,000 copies of its quarterly journal The Way, the actual membership nationwide is no more than 300. Most of these members are quite elderly, and there are no signs that an influx of young people will revitalize this group. While several small groups scattered around Japan still meet occasionally during the year, the only remaining church is the headquarters in Tokyo, where several meetings are held each month.
Christ Heart Church
Although it is difficult to find accurate statistics on the early development of Christ Heart Church, it seems to have followed a pattern of growth and decline not unlike that of the groups discussed above. The initial growth of Christ Heart Church was strongly influenced by its close relation to the Gunze Silk Factory in Ayabe City, Kyoto Prefecture. Hatano Tsurukichi (1858–1919), the President of Gunze, was a committed Christian who wanted to operate Gunze according to Christian principles. To that end he invited Kawai Shinsui, the founder of Christ Heart Church, to serve as the director of Gunze's education department in 1909, in which capacity Kawai served until 1935. During this time he led morning worship services, gave lectures, and directed Seishu* Gakuin (Academy for the Cultivation of Sincerity), a school for training Gunze instructors. Kawai's influence spread across Japan as these instructors were sent to various branch factories around the country. By 1917 Gunze had grown to include 17 factories and 5,000 employees. The number of employees peaked at over 21,000 in 1934.
It is in this context that Kawai established Christ Heart Church in 1927. He first built a dojo* on Gunze property in Ayabe and shortly thereafter on the grounds of several branch factories. Services were usually attended by the president, factory managers, and numerous employees. Kawai would also visit factories that did not have a dojo and give lectures from time to time.
At one point there were as many as 30 groups around Japan. Some insiders claim that at one time Kawai had 20,000 followers, but this number represents the approximate number of Gunze employees who were influenced by Kawai rather than actual church members. According to one observer, the membership in 1960 exceeded 3,000. 15 If that is an accurate number, it has seriously declined since that time. Although the church reports that it still has 27 groups around the country with a membership of 1,315, most are no longer active. While 900 copies of the church publication The Mind of Christ are printed each quarter, the de facto membership nationwide is no more than several hundred. The Tokyo church, which is the largest, has declined to a membership of 43 and has a regular attendance of only 15 to 20. Smaller branch churches usually have a gathering of only four or five people.
The aging process is clearly taking its toll. Many of the earliest members have already passed away, a number of elderly can only rarely attend services, and the church is largely unable to attract the younger generation. With only a handful of recognized teachers to provide instruction and lead religious activities, services at many of these branch churches consist of listening to taperecordings of the founder's lectures or discussing Kawai's writings. The situation is so critical that at an annual meeting several years ago the founder's grandson, the organization's current head, indicated that within a matter of a few years it would no longer be possible to maintain the church buildings or publish the magazine.
Spirit of Jesus Church
The remarkable growth figure reported by the Spirit of Jesus Church was one of the factors that prompted my own initial research on indigenous movements.
Organized as an independent group in 1941, this institution, like many other Christian denominations in Japan, did not see significant growth until after the Second World War. In 1950 the head church in Tokyo was built, and two years later a Bible school was established to train pastors. By 1958 the Spirit of Jesus Church had grown to a membership of 28,000 and become what Charles Iglehart referred to as the thirdlargest Protestant denomination in Japan.16 The group continued to grow steadily on into the 1970s, and has reported phenomenal growth for the past decade. By the early 1990s the church claimed a membership of 420,000 (240,000 men, 180,000 women), with some 300 ministers (60 percent women), close to 200 churches, and over 400 evangelistic house churches. Anyone who has attended a meeting and received "water" and "spirit"
baptism (the latter being authenticated by speaking in tongues) is counted as a member.
While case studies reveal that this church has experienced remarkable growth for the Japanese context, the membership figures are clearly inflated and cannot be accepted at face value. 17 As we noted in an earlier chapter, the Spirit of Jesus Church practices baptism for the dead, more specifically baptism for the ancestors of living members. Some observers have been overheard suggesting rather cynically that this practice is guaranteed to result in rapid church growth. On more than one occasion I have inquired whether the membership statistics include the baptized dead, but church leaders indicate that such baptisms are recorded in a separate category and have nothing to do with their membership statistics. The church has most recently clarified these statistics by indicating that there is an "active membership" of 23,283 individuals who regularly attend meetings and engage in church activities of one kind or another. Representatives maintain, however, that the larger figure accurately reflects the number who have been "saved" through the Spirit of Jesus Church.18
An examination of church attendance shows that the figure for "active membership" is the most helpful for understanding the actual strength of this movement. One rural church on the island of Shikoku which I visited reports a membership of over 600 (including four house churches). Regular attendance at weekly meetings in the mother church was from three to fifteen people, while close to fifty attended the annual memorial service for the dead in August. Similarly, the Tokyo district reports a membership of over 80,000, but attendance at weekly services in the main church averages around 500. In addition, there are some twenty house meetings on various days throughout the week with attendance ranging from ten to thirty. The Okinawa Spirit of Jesus Church reports a membership of 7,464, but the pastors informed me that regular weekly attendance is between 180 and 200, and 400 to 500 would attend the Christmas and Easter services. If one generalizes from these three examples, the active membership is probably less than ten percent of the total claimed.19 Although the Spirit of Jesus Church continues to report thousands of baptisms, these claims are not accompanied by a serious increase in "active" members. It seems safe to assume that the "glory'' days of the movement are over.
The Original Gospel Movement
As noted in an earlier chapter, the Nonchurch movement is also important for the other groups it has given birth to throughout its history. Largely because the
Nonchurch movement has no central authority or bureaucracy, it has functioned as the fountainhead of indigenous Christianity in Japan, giving rise to many other movements such as the Original Gospel. The latter, we may recall, is a Pentecostal movement started by Teshima Ikuro *, one of several denominational founders dissatisfied with the intellectualism of Nonchurch Christianity. The Original Gospel is also organized on the home Bible study group model and meets in the homes of leaders and in rented facilities.
The Original Gospel, according to Carlo Caldarola's study, had grown by the 1970s to a membership of 60,000 and was organized into some 500 home Biblestudy groups around the country.20 Since the death of the founder in 1973, however, it has declined, like most other movements. The movement today consists of approximately 10,000 members, 100 teachers, and 94 Original Gospel groups (divided into 500 house groups).21 This membership figure, however, does not represent a net increase of 10,000 new conversions to Christianity: according to church leaders, about 50 percent of the members were earlier associated with other Christian churches.
Holy Ecclesia of Jesus
The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus is one of the few indigenous movements that is still expanding in size today.22 In 1946 Otsuki* Takeji left the Holiness Church with a small group of disciples and began the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus in Hiroshima. Three years later he moved to Kyoto, which has been the center of the movement for almost fifty years. In the first decade, Otsuki and his followers organized 59 churches and attracted a membership of 1,172. The church has grown steadily under the charismatic leadership of Father Otsuki (as he is affectionately called by his followers), and today has over 100 churches, a trained leadership of over 224 evangelists and ministers, a total of 5,379 members, 1,601 associate members, 1,001 catechumens or "seekers of the way," 479 youth in the junior high school program, and 2,948 in the church school program for younger children. In sum, this is a movement involving some 10,000 people. Compared to other Christian churches in Japan, participation rates are very high, with over 7,000 people on average attending weekly services.
Although this is still a growing movement, demographic changes in Japanese society over the past decade are beginning to have an impact. Fifteen years ago young people involved outnumbered adults, but this is no longer the case. The number of young people involved in church school programs has declined significantly: junior high Sunday school attendance was 479 in 1986,
but declined to 344 in 1995; elementary Sunday school attendance was 4,300 in 1986 but only 2,519 in 1995. The difficulty in recruiting youth for church programs is a problem that affects not only the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. The declining birthrate and the heightened competition in Japan's educational system are having a negative impact on all Christian churches. Hugh Trevor points out that there has been a drop of approximately 50 percent in youth attendance for all denominations:
The main reason has been the increasing pressure put upon even primaryschool children (ages 6 to 11) to study at juku (entrance exam cram schools) to gain entrance to prestigious middle schools and some of the juku are on Sundays. Most of them are on weekdays, but the children get so tired, they want to have Sundays free. . . . The loss of children is all the more serious because the majority of those who become Christians as adults usually tell of some favorable experience they had at a church when young, and fewer children in Sunday school now means fewer adults for the churches in the future. 23
While Holy Ecclesia of Jesus churches may still be enjoying a period of growth at the present time, the overall drop in the numbers involved in the church school programs suggests that future growth—or even maintenance of the status quo—will become increasingly difficult.
When placed in historical perspective it is apparent that most of these groups recorded significant growth while the charismatic leader or founder was alive but tended to decline after his death. Most movements at present are barely holding their own or are in a state of rapid decline.24 It is true that if we add up the membership of all of the indigenous movements, the total probably constitutes ten percent or more of the active Christian population in Japan. Nevertheless, in spite of their efforts most movements have not been able to sustain longterm growth. The explanation that the general lack of response to Christianity in Japan relates to its failure to indigenize does not accord with the observable facts.
In light of the overall pattern of decline, we must recognize that what is indigenous for one generation may appear strange or outdated to a subsequent generation. The fact that most indigenous movements are not recording significant growth today suggests that most hold little more attraction for the average Japanese than transplanted mission churches. Milton Yinger has pointed out that "what will give one generation a sense of unifying tradition may alienate parts of another generation who have been subjected to different social and cultural influences."25 Commitment to an indigenous form that may have
been meaningful half a century ago undoubtedly discourages the creation of new forms relevant to presentday cultural situations. An indigenous Christianity for contemporary Japanese, in other words, would look quite different from the forms developed much earlier this century.
A study of postcharisma decline patterns in indigenous movements also raises the question of whether groups can dig their own graves through "overindigenization." Comparative studies of religious movements indicate that growing groups are the ones that maintain a "medium level of tension" with the larger society. Rodney Stark explains that a "movement must maintain a substantial sense of difference and considerable tension with the environment if it is to prosper. Without significant differences from the conventional faith(s) a movement lacks a basis for successful conversion." 26 Thus some indigenous Christian movements in Japan (The Way, for example), may have become so indigenous that there is minimal tension and ineffective mobilization of members for recruitment activities.27
Theories of church growth and studies of indigenization may show us how some churches more effectively mobilize members for recruitment activities, allocate resources for new church development, or attract members with an indigenous or contextual theology, but such studies do not really explain why Christianity has largely been rejected in Japan. We must remember that for decades approximately one percent of the Japanese have been church members. All the while, churches continue to report membership increases. Clearly, the "circulation of the saints" phenomenon is not limited to the religious scene in North America.28 The hard reality is that the rate of defections, denominational switching, and the growth of the Japanese population have kept mainline, evangelical, and indigenous churches alike from gaining a larger share of the market in Japan's religious economy.
The Dilemmas of Christianity in Japan
In considering the difficulties facing Christianity in Japan it is important to recall that it is a New Religion in this context and cannot be viewed and analyzed in quite the same way as Christianity in North America. As a foreignborn religion, Christianity has faced a number of obstacles in Japan that New Religions must struggle with in other countries. Rodney Stark has identified eight conditions for a New Religion to be successful in a given society. Here I would like to consider three that are particularly important for understanding the predicament of Christianity as a New Religion in Japan. Stark writes:
New religious movements are likely to succeed to the extent that they (1) retain cultural continuity with the conventional faiths of the societies in which they appear or originate; (2) maintain a medium level of tension with their surrounding environment; are deviant, but not too deviant; and (3) occur within a favorable ecology, which exists when (a) the religious economy is relatively unregulated and (b) conventional faiths are weakened by secularization or social disruption. 29
Most scholars would agree that cultural "discontinuity" has been the defining characteristic of Christianity in Japan. Cultural discontinuity and the conflict between Christianity and Japanese religiosity can be traced back to the earliest period of missionary activity in the sixteenth century. Roman Catholic missionaries met with considerable success during their earliest work, but continually faced the difficulty of communicating their exclusivistic truthclaims in an environment that accepted multiple divinities and forms of religious practice.30 Morioka Kiyomi, a leading sociologist of religion who has given considerable attention to the problems surrounding the transplantation and indigenization of Christianity in Japan,31 explains that an understanding of a doctrinally pluralistic idea of god is embedded in the Japanese worldview. Consequently, Christianity necessarily encountered a negative reaction in Japan since its interpreters emphasize exclusive belief in one transcendent god. Indigenous Christian movements, in spite of significant cultural adaptations and a fulfillment theology, have also had difficulty in dealing with this basic Japanese religious orientation.
In a more recent study, Winston Davis contrasts the religious pluralism of the West, where individuals are faced with genuine alternatives, with the syncretistic religiosity that has evolved over the centuries in Japan.32 While there have been "single practice" religious traditions demanding exclusive commitment from their followers (Soka* Gakkai, for example), this has been the exception rather than the rule. Most Japanese participate in annual religious events and lifecycle rituals associated with various Buddhist and Shinto traditions. Hence Japanese pluralism consists of a division of labor among the gods and is most accurately understood as a syncretistic system of "layered obligations," a model that Christianity has tended to clash with because of its claims to the sole possession of truth. Since most Japanese have been integrated into the system of household (Buddhist) and communal (Shinto) religious obligations, personal commitment to the Christian religion has remained extremely difficult.
As a proscribed religion for over two centuries (until 1873), Christianity was popularly understood and referred to as a heretical religion and evil teaching.
The exclusivism emphasized by early Protestant missionaries and their criticism of indigenous religious practices did little to alleviate this widespread perception. The history of Christian mission in Japan abounds with stories of individuals being cut off from their families because of their newfound faith. Refusal to participate as a household member in ancestor veneration or, following the instructions of missionaries, burning ancestral tablets or altars for the Shinto gods has led to innumerable family conflicts. For a variety of reasons, then, Japanese belonging to this "single practice sect" have had to live with the stigma of belonging to a deviant religion. With these "costs" of membership in mind, it is understandable why early converts to Christianity tended to be individuals who had lost their earlier status and position in society and were open to alternatives (for example, the dispossessed samurai class, particularly those from clans that had supported the Tokugawa government and had been excluded from positions in the Meiji government) or individuals who were in privileged positions—landowners and small industrial manufacturers—that made them less susceptible to community sanctions. In sum, Christianity has been "too deviant" for widespread acceptance by Japanese.
The fact that Christianity has been regarded as a deviant religion for much of its history in Japan is closely related to the political order within which it has had to operate. Reiterating Stark's third condition, in order for new religious movements to be successful the religious economy needs to be "relatively unregulated," and established religions must be in decline or "weakened by secularization or social disruption." Although Japan has not been without periods of social disruption and religious decline, the religious life of the masses has usually been closely monitored by those in political power. The brief success recorded by Roman Catholic missionaries in the sixteenth century, for example, was followed by strict measures of regulation ordered by successive military rulers during the Tokugawa period (1603–1867). Christianity became a proscribed religion, with Buddhism being used for registration and social control (i.e., for the identification of religious deviants). Consequently, many Christians were executed, and those who managed to survive did so only by going underground. While there were periods of relative openness and freedom after the Meiji Restoration, the overarching trend until 1945 was mass conformity to the civil religion of State Shinto and the emperor system (see chapter two).
With the defeat of the Japanese in 1945, political conditions finally became more favorable for the growth of Christianity. Under General Douglas MacArthur, the
Supreme Commander of the Allied Powers (SCAP) during the occupation, a new "Bill of Rights" was issued that effectively dismantled the old
social order. State Shinto was disestablished and reduced to a voluntary organization, while the Religious Bodies Control Law (which had both suppressed and used religious minorities for State purposes) was abolished.
Demographic changes related to postwar industrialization also helped to create a more favorable environment for Christian missionary activities. Since Christian churches were largely concentrated in metropolitan areas (unlike Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples), urbanization should have favored the growth of Christian organizations, but it now appears that Japanese new religious movements were the only ones effectively to capitalize on this population shift and deregulated religious economy.
Intersocietal Relations: The Neglected Dimension
In order to understand the general failure of Christianity in Japan we need to consider more than the difficult internal political conditions or the failure of Western churches to indigenize. It is also important to recognize that intersocietal relations at the time of emplantation have been a major factor in determining the Japanese perception of Christianity as a deviant religion and the consequent course of church diffusion and growth. This is not to deny the importance of evangelistic zeal and missionary efforts, but to recognize that international political relationships also create either "inhibiting" or "facilitating" conditions for the spread of religions. As long as an imported religion retains its "foreign" character, it will more than likely appeal only to marginal individuals. For wider acceptance to be achieved the imported religion must be rooted in the culture of the receiving society to the extent that it is no longer perceived as an alien or deviant phenomenon.
This issue has received significant attention in Robert Montgomery's recent work on social identity theory, macrosocial relations, and the spread of religions. Montgomery proposes that we shift our focus away from the analysis of missionary efforts and strategies to the "perceptions" of the receivers, which are shaped largely by international political relations that divide groups into dominant or subordinate positions. 33 Montgomery's theoretical perspective is worth quoting at length:
The underlying conditions affecting the acceptance of religions introduced from the outside are found in the quality of relationships between receiving groups and other groups, including groups from which New Religions are being introduced. A key factor in these relationships for acceptance of a New Religion is perception by the receiving group of the direction from which threat
or domination is coming. If a religion is introduced from a source not perceived as threatening, while at the same time there exists some threat for which the New Religion provides a resource for resistance, then a favorable condition is established for reception of the New Religion. Thus, if domination or threat is perceived as coming from sources other than the source of the New Religion, then the New Religion may be seen as a resource in establishing both group and individual identities that are important contributors to the maintenance of societies. . . .
If, on the other hand, a group from which a New Religion is being introduced is perceived as threatening the existence or the distinctive identity of a society, then a condition encouraging resistance to the New Religion is established. Resistance may take several forms, depending on conditions. There may be a resurgence of traditional religion. If the traditional culture has been strongly challenged, there may be a variety of religious movements spawned that mix elements from the old culture with elements from a new culture. 34
This analysis not only helps explain the receptiveness to Christianity of tribal or ethnic minority groups in certain societies, but also the divergent responses to Christianity in South Korea and in Japan. Christianity was initially perceived as a foreign religion in both Korea and Japan. In Korea, however, this perception was transformed by sociopolitical circumstances during the period of the nation's colonization by Japan. For Koreans the threat of domination was not from the source of the New Religion but from another occupying power. Although Protestant missionaries in Korea were largely "apolitical" and stressed personal salvation and piety, many Koreans discovered that Christianity also provided an "oppositional ideology" for resisting the Japanese government. As a result many Christians became deeply involved in movements for independence and refused to cooperate with the Japanese government in countless ways. Throughout this difficult period the affirmation of Christianity became a way for Koreans to assert their national identity over against the culture of their Japanese colonizers. In short, circumstances beyond the control of any mission strategist led to a positive linkage between Christianity and Korean culture, and provided the basis for the remarkable postwar growth of the Christian faith in Korea. This transformation of "perception" did not occur in Japan because the source of Christianity was also the source of the greatest threat to Japanese autonomy. Nor was there any substantive shift in this outlook during the postwar period; Christianity merely changed from being the religion of the enemy to being the religion of the Occupation government. David Martin makes the point succinctly:
The Korean experience is, in certain respects, the obverse of the Japanese; in other respects the two societies are very similar. The Japanese are the imperial nation for whom the Americans were rivals, and the Koreans are the colonized nation for whom the Americans were liberators. 35
Some observers have suggested that slow church growth in postwar Japan may be due in part to the fact that Japanese Christians have been less open about their personal faith and less aggressive in proselytization than their counterparts in Korea. Perhaps this is just another example of Christians being "real" Japanese by exercising restraint in talking about themselves in public. There are many situations, however, in which Japanese do not feel so compelled: members of many new religious movements actively proselytize in a variety of public places, including train stations, parks, and busy commercial streets. The fact is, the Japanese are quite capable of being open and aggressive. The reason Japanese Christians tend to be less demonstrative about their faith is that there is still a degree of stigma attached to Christianity. An individual's cultural identity as a "Japanese" seems to be threatened by membership in a Christian church, whereas such difficult questions of "identity" do not arise in the case of indigenous New Religions.36
The Transplantation of Korean Christianity to Japan
With approximately onequarter of the population now belonging to Protestant or Catholic congregations, South Korea is a country in which transplanted Christianity can almost be considered an indigenous religion. Over a decade ago, for example, when the Korean Protestant churches celebrated their 1984 centennial, the Presbyterians among them already outnumbered their counterparts in the United States. Dynamic church growth has been accompanied by increasing involvement in international mission. While there were just under a hundred Korean missionaries serving overseas fifteen years ago, a 1995 survey discovered that the number had grown by then to 3,272 in 119 countries.37
One of the most significant developments in Korean Christianity since the Second World War has been the organization of the Full Gospel Central Church by Paul Yonggi Cho. Cho was educated in the Assemblies of God Bible College in Seoul and ordained as an Assemblies of God minister several years after beginning his evangelistic work. Although Cho was deeply influenced by the Assemblies of God and maintains close ties with Pentecostalism worldwide, the Full Gospel Central
Church (now called the Yoido Full Gospel Church) is
essentially an independent and indigenous church, and represents the most influential stream of Korean Pentecostalism. This church has been actively engaged in mission work in Japan for approximately two decades. As an Asian and experiential expression of Christianity, it represents a clear alternative to the transplanted Western churches that dominated the earlier phase of Protestant mission to Japan, and as such deserves serious attention. 38
The Yoido Full Gospel Church
Beginning in 1958 as a tent church with just five members, the Yoido Full Gospel Church has experienced rapid growth over the past three decades and now claims a membership of 620,000 members, making it not only the largest Pentecostal church in Asia but also the largest in the world. After collapsing from overwork and stress in 1964, Cho learned the importance of delegating responsibilities to others. Under his charismatic leadership there are now 633 pastors, 400 elders, and 50,000 deacons or deaconesses shepherding his burgeoning flock. The church operates a Sunday school program with an enrollment of over 26,000, a tenweek training course for home cell leaders, a sixteenweek training course for church officers and lay leaders, and a threeyear Bible Institute for training pastors. The Bible Institute already has close to 300 graduates and a current enrollment of 294.
Yoido Full Gospel Church is now a finely tuned organization with its membership divided into 50,000 home cell groups in 406 subdistricts throughout Seoul. These cell groups are centered on prayer and Bible study and constitute the major means of pastoral care and evangelism.39 It is probably most accurate to view Yoido Full Gospel Church as a distinct denomination since it includes nine satellite churches, affiliated churches, and educational institutions, and has sent over 250 missionaries overseas. On a given Sunday several hundred thousand members will worship in one of the seven services at the main sanctuary (seating 25,000), by closed circuit television in one of the nine overflow chapels (seating another 25,000), or by video in one of the nine satellite churches. Over one hundred buses transport members to services from throughout Seoul and outlying areas. Thousands of Sunday School children and teachers can be found meeting in small groups throughout the halls and rooms of either the tenstory Christian education center or the thirteenstory world mission center. Foreign members and international guests, who receive special care, are provided with headsets and instructions for locating the channel with simultaneous interpretation in their own language. (One can choose among English, Chinese,
German, and French.) Sunday services are also broadcast throughout Korea from twelve radio stations and four television stations.
Church growth is clearly a major concern of Cho and the Yoido Full Gospel Church. In 1976 Cho established Church Growth International (CGI) to sponsor conferences and seminars aimed at promoting church growth worldwide. According to a recent Yoido Church publication, 1.3 million pastors and church leaders from forty countries have participated in CGI seminars.
Sung Rak Baptist Church and Berea Academy
Another important Pentecostal influence in presentday Korea is the Sung Rak Baptist Church in Seoul. Its founder, Ki Dong Kim, experienced a conversion accompanied by healing, baptism in the spirit, speaking in tongues, and prophetic visions. In 1961, at the age of twentyone, Kim began his ministry as a lay evangelist with a primary emphasis upon healing and exorcism. Eight years later Kim founded Sung Rak Baptist Church with a small flock of seven members. Although officially a Baptist church, it has been Pentecostal in nature from its inception. Allnight prayer gatherings, revival meetings, exorcisms, healings, and speaking in tongues are the regular fare at this Baptist Church. Jae Bum Lee explains:
Ki Dong Kim's ministry is well known as a ministry of exorcism in Korea. He has led nine hundred exorcism meetings since 1961. During the same time he has reportedly raised seven people from the dead. . . . He healed 120,000 people who were crippled, blind, deaf, cancerous, and demon possessed. Kim states that he has cast out demons from four hundred thousand people and that fiftynine of those were completely crippled people. 40
By the mid 1980s Sung Rak Baptist Church had grown to a membership of nearly 25,000 and had a pastoral staff of 73. Like the organizational structure of the
Yoido Full Gospel Church, Sung Rak provides pastoral care and outreach through 1,300 home cell groups. Although not nearly as large as the Yoido Church, the Sung Rak Baptist Church, Lee maintains, is the ''fastest growing superchurch in Korea today."
The influence of this stream of Pentecostalism extends far beyond the walls of the Sung Rak Baptist Church. Believing that all Christians can be miracle workers and exorcists, Kim began Berea Academy in 1978 to train and cultivate these gifts in lay people. Very quickly, however, the student body of Berea Academy came to include seminarians training for the ministry as well as pastors dissatisfied with their own denominations. The curriculum of study is based
upon Kim's practical experience with exorcism and his biblical exposition of demonology (subsequently published as a threevolume work, Demonology, in 1985 and 1986). By 1985 graduates of this training program had reached 1,119. Some of these graduates have gone on to start similar schools. Hahn ManYoung, for example, a professor of music at Seoul National University, who systematized the theology (demonology) of Ki Dong Kim, established Grace Academy and a new church in Seoul. Similarly, TaiKa Lee, a disciple of both Ki Dong Kim and Hahn ManYoung, started another academy in Masan and is reported to have a thriving church of over 10,000 members. The pattern of church growth through schism is clearly not confined to Korean Presbyterians and their 32 denominations.
The Shamanization of Korean Christianity
It is not by mere chance that allnight prayer meetings, exorcisms, prayer mountains, and healing services are found in Korean churches. Although Pentecostal church leaders would deny the influence of "pagan religion," most scholars agree that shamanism has been the central force in shaping the development of Korean Pentecostalism. 41 ByongSuh Kim explains that "shamanism is the belief system of thisworldly blessings—material wealth, good health, and other personal and familial wellbeing."42 In Korean society the shaman (mudang) serves as a link between ordinary people and the spirit world, which is populated by numerous gods, ancestors, and spirits. Through rituals and offerings shamans can control the spirit world (transforming malevolent spirits into protective spirits), perform healings and exorcisms, and bring about concrete benefits for individuals in this world. Whether regarded as "syncretism'' or "contextualization," this shamanistic orientation has undeniably permeated Korean Christianity. In The Korean Minjung in Christ, David Suh expresses this view forcefully:
Korean Protestantism has almost been reduced to a Christianized mudang religion. That is, the form and language of the worship service are Christian, but the content and structure of what Korean Christians adhere to are basically mudang religion. Although missionaries rejected shamanism and thought that it had been destroyed, Korean Christianity has become almost completely shamanized.43
The influence of shamanism is apparent in the theology of Pentecostal leaders as well as in the practices associated with prayer mountains.
Paul Yonggi Cho's theology might best be viewed as a synthesis of Korean shamanism, Robert Shuller's "positive thinking," and the pragmatism of the Church Growth school of missiology associated with Fuller Theological Seminary's School of World Mission (Pasadena, California). The shamanistic orientation of Cho's theology is clear in his exegesis of 3 John 2: "Beloved, I wish that thou mayest prosper and be in health, even as thy soul prospereth." This passage is the foundation for what Cho refers to as the Threefold Blessing of Salvation:
"Thy soul prospereth" means that by believing in Jesus Christ we live an abundant life spiritually and "thou mayest prosper" means that we are blessed with material things through a life in which all things work together for good; "thou mayest be in health" means that believers who have received salvation are blessed to be delivered from the pain of sickness because Jesus paid the price of healing at Calvary. 44
According to Bong Ho Son, professor of philosophy at Seoul National University, this "triple meter faith" (as it is popularly referred to) leads to an "excessive emphasis on earthly blessings."45 If one does not experience healing or personal prosperity then there must be some unconfessed sin or lack of commitment to religious duties. More active participation in religious services, trips to prayer mountain centers, or speaking in tongues will surely bring about the desired results. As Grayson has observed, "Attendance at church and fervent prayer are believed to create a condition in which the person will be blessed."46
The influence of the shamanic worldview can also be seen clearly in the demonology of Ki Dong Kim and the Berea Academy. Kim teaches that this world is hades and that individuals who die without Christ become evil spirits and wander about in this world and possess people. Suffering and various kinds of illness are caused by these unclean spirits, who enter a person and use their energy. Exorcism, then, necessarily becomes a central concern of Kim's church. Healing involves calling the spirit of the dead person by name and casting it out in the name of Jesus Christ.
Kim's etiology of illness is essentially that of traditional Korean shamanism. Kwangil Kim explains that, according to early shamanistic diagnosis, one of the primary causes of sickness is "a wandering spirit, the spirit of an ancestor, any dead person, or any evil spirit."47 Traditionally, the shaman discovers the identity of the ancestor or spirit responsible for causing the illness through trance or divination. In the case of Christian shamans or exorcists, this seems to occur primarily through dialogue with the possessed person.
The prayermountain centers (kidowon) established by churches all over Korea are another concrete expression of shamanistic Christianity. According to Yohan
Lee's study, there were only two Christian prayermountain centers in Korea before 1945; by 1982 the number had increased to 289. 48 The Yoido Full Gospel Church established Osanri Prayer Mountain Sanctuary in 1973 under the leadership of Cho's motherinlaw Choi Jashil. Today the Osanri center consists of a main sanctuary seating 10,000, two smaller sanctuaries seating 5,000 each, 300 private prayer grottoes, and Westernstyle dormitories accommodating 3,000 people. Free shuttle bus service from Yoido Church to the Osanri center is provided daily on an hourly basis. Sung Rak Baptist Church also maintains three prayermountain centers, although none of them is as large as Yoido's Osanri center. Religious activities in these centers include mass prayer meetings as well as private regimens of prayer and fasting. Koreans stream to these mountain centers seeking baptism in the Holy Spirit, personal healing, and answers to prayers for health, wealth, fertility, and success in this life. These centers also cultivate the charismatic gifts. Yohan Lee, for example, reports that "to practice speaking in tongues, some prayer mountain centers push the participants in the prayer meeting to repeat 'Hallelujah' seven hundred times or nine hundred times."49 In addition to prayermountain centers related to specific churches or denominations, there are many independent centers with pastors who specialize in healing particular illnesses.
The Expansion of Korean Pentecostalism to Japan
Since the late 1970s, Paul Yonggi Cho's Full Gospel Church has been actively engaged in missionary outreach to Japan, and is rapidly becoming one of the most visible and influential forms of Pentecostalism in the country. This is a particularly significant development in light of the long history of difficult relations between Korea and Japan. Cho probably expressed the feelings of most Korean missionaries to Japan when he wrote:
You must realize how hard it was for me to go to Japan. After knowing about the millions of people massacred by the Japanese before 1945, I had a great hatred toward the Japanese people. However, God healed my heart when I confessed my sin. I now travel to Japan every month.50
The mission to Japan began in 1976 with the organization of a church in Osaka. Two years later another church was established in Tokyo, and numerous branch churches and home cell groups have been organized since that time. By
1989 the Japan Full Gospel Mission consisted of twenty missionaries, nine churches, and a membership claimed to be over five thousand. 51 Cho began television evangelism in 1978 and currently broadcasts a halfhour "Invitation to Happiness" program each week on seven different stations across Japan. His version of Pentecostalism is also spread through Japanese translations of his books and a monthly newsletter. His book The Fourth Dimension, for example, has already sold 20,000 copies.
Along with television evangelism and church planting, Cho has placed considerable emphasis upon training people for pastoral work and mission in Japan. In 1985 Cho established a Tokyo campus of the Asian Church Growth Institute (ACGI) and, two years later, another branch in Osaka. Students attend regular classes or enroll in the correspondence course and use taped lectures. The ACGI is essentially a threeyear course and involves a sixmonth internship in Korea during the final year of the program. In a recent year there were approximately two hundred students in the Tokyo program and thirty in the one in Osaka.
Healing Services and Testimonials in the Japan Grace Academy
On a much smaller scale Berea and Grace academies have also made their way into Japan through pastors, itinerant evangelists, healers, literature, and tapes. One base for the Japan Grace Academy is a thriving Gospel church in Yokohama. The pastor of this church and director of the academy belonged to a Presbyterian church in Korea before coming to Japan for the first time as a missionary many years ago. Because of the slow growth of Christianity in Japan he returned to Korea disheartened, but a time of study at Grace Academy gave him the "power" to continue his missionary work. Since his return, the church has grown to approximately one hundred members through his ministry of "signs and wonders."
One evening I attended a special healing service at a Gospel church in Yokohama that featured KeiFa Kim, a "shamaness" from Hallelujah Kito*in, one of the prayermountain healing centers in Korea. Kim appeared in a striking white dress and was introduced by the pastor. The service began with a video tape showing her, with thousands in attendance, engaged in her successful healing ministry in Korea. The video was rather graphic, showing her perform surgery with only her hands and fingernails on patients suffering from a variety of infections, skin diseases, growths, and tumors. The video and lively hymn singing created a climate of expectation. During this time forms were distributed to the audience so that individuals could indicate whether they wished to receive
healing at the close of the service. The form required a signature acknowledging that Kim would bear no responsibility and explained that "healing" can often take several weeks. In the meantime one should attend church, pray, and use the medicine Kim provided (olive oil and holy water from the Hallelujah Center). One should not go to a hospital or see a doctor during this time.
Her preaching was punctuated with standup testimonies by individuals and families who had benefited from her healing touch over the past several years. At considerable expense they had gone to her prayermountain healing center and spent days (in some cases even weeks) in search of healing. In one testimonial, a man indicated that he had made three such trips to Korea for relief from back trouble (taking a gift of some 700,000 yen on his last visit). After several days at the Hallelujah Kito *in (prayer center) he still had not been healed. The shamaness indicated that lack of faith and spiritual problems at home were preventing the cure. He called Japan to check on the situation at home and learned that his daughter had just performed a mizuko kuyo* (memorial service for an aborted fetus) in front of the family Buddhist altar. On hearing this, the Korean healer informed him that he must have his family shut the doors to the room containing the Buddhist altar in order to control the evil spirits. This they apparently did: the man gained the faith required for healing and returned to Japan.
Another testimony was given by a father who stood at the front of the sanctuary with his young daughter, whom he had taken to the same Hallelujah PrayerMountain center for healing after doctors in Japan had failed to cure her unusual illness. At the center in Korea, the girl's parents were instructed to chant the Apostles' Creed while a special ingredient placed on the child's stomach burned for several minutes. According to the father's testimony, the girl was miraculously healed and the family returned to Japan. Although not nearly as visible as Cho's brand of Pentecostalism, the Berea and Grace academies are slowly making their way into independent and charismatic churches in Japan through a network of itinerant evangelists and faith healers.
The Future of Korean Pentecostalism in Japan
Since the late 1970s Japan has been undergoing what sociologists and journalists refer to as a "religion boom" or a "revival of magic and occultism." An important dimension of this socalled revival has been the development of numerous New Religions with a shared emphasis on religious experience, spirits, and exorcism. The future of Pentecostal Christianity in Japan must be con
sidered in light of this postmodern revival of folk religiosity. 52 An important feature of Japanese folk religion is the importance placed upon rituals oriented to "thisworldly benefits." Hori Ichiro* explains that "the magicoreligious needs and emotional associations of the Japanese people are important factors of receptibility in the process of borrowing or selection of foreign religions in Japan."53 Protestant Christianity in Japan, which, for the most part, has been isolated in an intellectual middleclass ghetto, has been highly critical of what might be called mass religiosity. Pentecostal forms of Christianity, on the other hand, share a great deal in common with the New Religions flourishing in contemporary Japan, as both tend to emphasize religious experience and thisworldly benefits. In an interview, one Japanese Pentecostal leader explained it this way:
Evangelicals have long taught the message of salvation from sin, but failed to teach the biblical message of healing and economic blessings from God. This emphasis on material blessings is something emphasized by Cho and is an important part of the Gospel.
Generally speaking, the experienceorientation of religious "seekers" today does not predispose them toward participation in most Japanese Christian churches, which tend to be "clergycentered institutions"54 characterized by intellectualism and predictability. In contrast, Pentecostal churches, particularly those recently imported from Korea, tend to be "memberoriented" groups marked by high rates of active participation on the part of believers, and by the effective employment of lay leaders in recruitment work. This is not to deny the high status of charismatic pastors in Pentecostal churches, where powerful, miracleworking ministers are frequently ''idolized" by the laity. The point here is that Pentecostal churches tend to "empower" members through instruction and gifts of the spirit. Whereas established religions and churches tend to monopolize spiritual power in the hands of an elite clergy, Pentecostal churches and New Religions provide opportunities for rapid upward spiritual mobility. Charismatic or shamanistic powers are not restricted to the founder or pastor. Winston Davis refers to this tendency as the "democratization of magic" in the New Religions.55 With only a few days of training, any member can achieve power over the spirit world and perform acts of healing and exorcism.
In his study of Japan's New Religions, Hayashi Minoru argues:
The Christian movement in Japan, which largely represents a Westernized, nongrowing, and weakened form of Christianity, can become biblically dynamic and culturally relevant if it becomes more willing to learn critically from the growth dynamics of the New Religions.56
A critical factor in the acceptance and growth of a religion in Japan, he explains, is the "spiritual power"—not the academic qualifications—of a religious leader. This power enables the leader to meet the practical needs of Japanese people. In this context, Hayashi advocates "power evangelism" and suggests that Christianity needs to recover the "signs and wonders" of the New Testament if it is to make progress in Japan. Apparently, only a Christian "shamanism" can compete with the shamanism of the New Religions.
In many ways the Pentecostal churches from Korea embody the approach advocated by Hayashi, but so do many of the homegrown movements considered earlier, where shamanistic leaders perform signs and wonders on a daily basis and assure the faithful of God's blessing upon the living (and sometimes the dead). It is undeniable that some of these churches are growing faster than Westernoriented churches and often serve a social class largely untouched by other Protestant denominations, and that they represent a dynamic stream of Asian Christianity deserving of serious attention. Nevertheless, as indicated earlier, their significance should not be overestimated. Recent statistics indicate that of the less than one percent of the Japanese population represented by the country's 1,057,088 Christians, probably no more than onetenth belong to Pentecostal churches or to charismatic congregations within the Roman Catholic Church or conventional Protestant denominations.
A decade ago Paul Cho Yonggi wrote, "God has now given me a promise that ten million Japanese are going to be saved in the decade of the eighties." 57 While Full Gospel Churches in Japan have recorded significant progress over the past decade, the results are far short of Cho's optimistic forecast. In spite of their many efforts, these churches still consist largely of recent Korean immigrants or spouses of interethnic marriages. Cho is busy training evangelists in Japan who will likely contribute significantly to the expansion of Full Gospel Pentecostalism in the years ahead. Still, as we approach the end of the 1990s, the cumulative membership amounts to no more than the smallest fraction of the grandiose predictions of its leader.
Pentecostal Christianity may "fit" the current social climate better than the intellectual expressions of Christianity associated with Western churches. This fact alone, however, hardly assures church growth in the Japanese context. The decline of indigenous Pentecostal movements has shown us that much. Daniel Adams also helpfully reminds us that church growth in Korea is related to a unique historical experience and is not readily transferred to other situations:
The differences between Yoido Full Gospel Church and churches in other countries is not so much the presence or absence of the Holy Spirit as it is the process of indigenization and the unique blending together of syncretism, nationalism, and utopianism in Korea. 58
Unlike the Koreans, many Japanese still tend to regard Christianity as a "stranger in the land" and incompatible with Japanese cultural identity. Furthermore, many still regard Koreans as an inferior race and are unlikely to seek religious solace in churches dominated by religious leaders from a former colony. Homegrown New Religions, on the other hand, since they are rooted in indigenous religious traditions and emphasize cultural continuity, are more likely to meet the needs of the urban masses and revitalize the spiritualistic worldview of the Japanese.
Chapter Nine—The Broader Context of Japanese Christianity
Since the initial transmission of Roman Catholicism to Japan in the sixteenth century, Christianity has generally been regarded as an intrusive force in Japanese society and often referred to as a "foreign" and "evil" religion. Despite the seemingly insurmountable obstacles—cultural discontinuity, social stigma, and, until fifty years ago, strict government control—numerous transplanted and independent churches have managed to establish an organizational presence in Japan. In this study I have tried to look at this process not through the eyes of the foreign missionaries but from the perspective of the Japanese, who were not mere passive recipients of transplanted Christianity but active agents who reinterpreted and reconstructed the faith in terms that made sense to them. Over the years most representatives of Protestant mission
churches have regarded these indigenous developments as unfortunate expressions of syncretism and a deviation from normative Christianity. As we have seen, however, to the Japanese founders themselves their elaboration of the Christian faith was nothing other than the fulfillment of Jesus' promise to his disciples that "when the Spirit comes he will guide you into all truth" (John 16:13).
However much the views of these Japanese leaders may have clashed with Protestant missionary theology, their approach was firmly rooted in Christian tradition. As early as the second century a similar process of Christian interpretation was advanced by Justin Martyr (c. 100–165), whose primary concern was to relate his faith to the Greek philosophical and cultural traditions. Although Justin did criticize many ideas in Greek philosophy, there were others he esteemed as compatible with his understanding of Christianity. In fact he accorded certain elements of truth in Greek philosophy a position similar to that of the Old Testament. These "preChristian" truths in Hellenistic culture were regarded as a "preparation" for the coming of Christ, the divine Logos. According to Justin's First Apology, the preincarnate Logos not only was working through the Greek philosophers, but they were also Christians to the extent that they lived according to the Logos. The implications of this interpretation were farreaching, as Jean Danielou has suggested:
To renounce idolatry and to accept Christianity ceases for the Greek to be a betrayal of his tradition, and becomes instead an act of loyalty to the best elements of it. Socrates is a forerunner of Christ no less than Moses, and Christianity is the plenary manifestation of something which sages had possessed only in a partial revelation. 1
Like Justin Martyr, the indigenous leaders we have considered played a similar role in providing Japanese Christians with a sense of cultural continuity. Commitment to Christ for them did not necessitate a total rejection of the past or a "betrayal" of Japanese traditions, as many Protestant missionaries maintained. Rather, the best elements of this preChristian past could be affirmed as a part of the Christian way. Particulars aside, the mere phenomenon of these indigenous movements testifies to the fact that a number of Japanese have succeeded in disengaging Christianity from its Western orientation and the negative associations with which it has been encumbered for several centuries. It is not that they set out to gainsay the contribution of Western Christian traditions and missionary efforts, but simply to recognize that the influence of that contribution is subject to limits in other religious histories and contexts.
The "Ways" of Japanese Christianity
In the course of the previous chapters we have seen how differents streams of foreign influence have blended in diverse ways with indigenous elements to produce a number of alternative Japanese Christian traditions. It has become clear that, despite certain ingredients shared in common by these movements, each of them represents a distinct gestalt and subculture. Notwithstanding the popular myth of the homogeneous Japanese, these movements point to a considerable degree of cultural and religious diversity beneath the surface harmony and order for which modern Japan prides itself In a largely unknown work published over three decades ago (which I found buried in the archives of the United Church of Christ in Japan), a certain Miyazaki Akira insists that in order to make sense of the development of Christianity in Japan one must take into account the cultural pluralism of Japanese society . "Japanese culture is not a single unified culture," he writes, "but a complex of cultures." 2 Given this pluralism, Miyazaki argued that we should expect indigenous Christianity to appear in diverse forms as a result of its encounter with the native traditions of Shinto, Buddhism, Confucianism, Shugendo*, and Bushido*. Our own studies have borne this out. Any simple caricature of "a Japanese Christianity" is quickly confounded by the diverse patterns of appropriation that have appeared over the course of Japan's modern century.
Just as Europeans and North Americans require diverse cultural expressions of Christianity, the Japanese also have different tastes and dispositions. It is hardly surprising that, alongside a variety of denominations and sects of Western origins, an equal variety of indigenous Christian groups—high church, low church, evangelical, pentecostal, shamanistic, and so on—should flourish in Japan. Carlo Caldarola's reference to the Nonchurch movement as the Japanese Way of Christianity needs qualification. It may be the way for a small group, a predominantly highly educated elite, but there are many other ways to be Christian and Japanese. In this sense, our microsociological studies of rather marginal indigenous Christian movements has provided substantial support for the macrosociological understanding of Japan as a more heterogeneous society than is often recognized in many popular characterizations.
Indigenous Christian movements not only differ in their theology, practice, and style of worship but also in their models of organization and definition of gender roles. Uchimura adopted the Confucian educational model based on a personal relationship between teacher and disciple as the most suitable approach for organization of the Nonchurch movement. This maledominated
Confucian model was largely adopted by a number of other movements, including The Way, Christ Heart Church, Original Gospel movement, the Japan Ecclesia of
Christ, and the LifeGiving Christ. All these groups rejected Western church polities, the notion of an ordained clergy, and the accompanying system of sacraments. 3 A number of other movements, however, have accepted (with some adaptation) the distinction between clergy and laity, and have established Bible schools or seminaries to train individuals for the ordained ministry. These include the Christian Canaan Church, the Spirit of Jesus Church, the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church, and the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. Among these movements we also find observance of the traditional rites of baptism and the Lord's Supper, as well as of other rituals related to care of the dead. Interestingly, these latter movements all share a charismatic or pentecostal orientation and tend to be egalitarian, allowing women to take an active part in the ordained ministry rather than confining them to domestic duties or to supportive roles behind the scene.4 In contrast to the dominance of male teachers in the Nonchurch movement, for example, 60 percent of the ministers in the Spirit of Jesus Church are women, perhaps reflecting their central role in traditional folk religion and shamanism.
Although the Nonchurch movement has been known to represent a "manly expression" of Christianity, in recent years women have taken on a more active role by offering alternative activities and critical perspectives on the conservative Confucian orientation of the movement. Today there is a Women's Planning Group based at the Imai Hall, a center that functions as the national headquarters for the Nonchurch movement. This group sponsors regular weekday meetings that include panels and lectures by women on a wide range of topics, including the modern family, education, and the liberation of women. In a lecture I attended, a feminist scholar and active member spoke plainly about how far behind the Nonchurch movement was with regard to recognizing the rights and gifts of Japanese women. Male teachers have dominated the Nonchurch movement since Uchimura's day, she explained, and very few men have expressed interest in the lives and concerns of women. The centrality of male teachers has created a strong hierarchical structure in which women have been expected to take the passive role as students. Even though
Nonchurch Christianity rejects the clergylaity distinction, the elevation of male teachers within the movement in reality undermines the principle of the priesthood of all believers. In recent years, women have been allowed to participate more actively in Nonchurch meetings, but they are still only allowed to give informal talks, while the formal Bible lectures continue to be monopolized by the men.5
Charisma and Leadership Succession
The fact that there are diverse "ways" and subcultures within Japanese Christianity should not blind us to the common features shared by many movements.
Comparative analysis has revealed an interesting and recurrent pattern that has appeared in many movements as the founder's charisma has been institutionalized along the lines of the traditional household (ie) system. Although this family system has been regarded as a factor discouraging some Japanese from converting to
Christianity, a study of leadership succession in indigenous movements indicates that once conversions do occur, the social organization of the newfound faith is often patterned on the household system. This principle of social organization and leadership succession has a long history in Japan. Religious authority in major Buddhist sects, for example, has been transmitted through fatherson blood lineage ( kechimyakusojo *) since Shinran (1173–1262), the founder of the Shinshu* sect of Pure Land, married and had a family.6
Most Japanese Christian movements, with the exception of those following the principles of the Nonchurch movement, have adopted or adapted this traditional pattern of leadership succession to various church polities (see figure 5). Although religious authority is not always passed from father to son, it tends to stay in the family of the founder. Matsumura Kaiseki and his wife were childless but adopted a son to take over as head of The Way. The adopted son's wife, and then daughter, succeeded him as head of this religious body. Leadership of this movement only transferred outside of the family when illhealth forced the daughter to resign from this position. Christ Heart Church is now in its third generation of leadership. The founder, Kawai Shinsui, was succeeded initially by his son; almost a decade ago, leadership was transferred to his grandson. In the Spirit of Jesus Church, religious authority was transferred to the founder's wife, who has served as bishop for many years now. According to my informants, their daughter is expected to be the next bishop. The wife of Matsubara Kazuhito, founder of the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church, similarly assumed leadership following her husband's death. The same thing occurred in the Glorious Gospel Christian Church. Even those movements that adopt elements from imported organizational forms tend to institutionalize charisma within the founder's family. The founder of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, Otsuki* Takeji, is still living and a powerful influence on the movement, but he has officially retired. Two years ago his son was elected to the position of Shiboku ( , bishop or president). Representatives of all of these movements would
Figure 5.
Leadership Succession in Indigenous Christian Movements
insist that leadership is not based on blood or heredity (seshu * ), but this seems to be the most natural form of religious succession in the Japanese context.7 This pattern, while rather common in indigenous movements, is by no means unique to Japan.8
The Nonchurch movement, which rejected both Western church polities and religious succession based on the household principle, is now facing a number of difficulties related to its loose association of Bible study groups organized around the Confucian teacherdisciple relationship. As we noted earlier in this study, Uchimura established the principle that a group would disband upon the retirement or death of the teacher. No arrangements were made for the continuation of a particular group or for the formal education of successive leaders for the movement. It is not surprising to discover that the Nonchurch movement, as well as Christ Heart Church and The Way, which have also relied on the informal relationship between teacher and disciple for their future leadership, are now having to cope with a shortage of leaders. If the history of religious movements teaches us anything it is that charisma tends to be shortlived. Some religious groups effectively prepare for the eventual disappearance of this powerful force, while others fail to face the reality in time. The Way and Christ Heart Church seem almost resigned to their fate of continual decline. The Nonchurch movement, on the other hand, is making some efforts to meet the new challenges that have accompanied the postcharisma stage of development.
Uchimura would probably be dismayed to find that the movement he founded has undergone considerable institutionalization in its struggle to survive. In 1986, the Imai
Hall Library and Nonchurch Archives were opened next door to the building where Uchimura once lectured and now serves as a resource center for the movement. The following year the first nationwide Nonchurch meeting was held. This has now become an annual event and is usually attended by more than three hundred members from around the country.9 Leaders have realized that groups must coordinate their efforts and resources in order to insure the survival of a movement with a majority of elderly members.10 Even though the need for mutual support and collaboration is widely recognized, many of those involved expressed concern that the holding of national annual meetings may give the false impression that Nonchurch Christianity is just another denomination or sect. In deference to Uchimura, the organizers have been careful to point out that the annual meeting has no official status and is simply a free association of "brothers and sisters in Christ who simply wanted to deepen their fellowship with each other."11
Current leaders have recognized that the movement is in crisis as it makes the transition from the third to fourth generation. During the second generation immediately following Uchimura there were many active leaders engaged in evangelistic work. The number declined considerably with the third generation in the postwar period, and indications are that the number of teachers and evangelists will decrease even more rapidly with the fourth generation. The continual replenishment of the movement by charismatic leaders that had been envisioned in the early phase of the movement has simply not materialized. The shortage of evangelists has obliged leaders to search for alternative ways of cultivating successors. In 1992 the Nonchurch Study Center ( ) was established in order to provide for the continuing education of members and training of evangelists. The program began with 110 applicants. 12 It is interesting to note that, whereas two decades ago, as Carlo Caldarola observed, Nonchurch leaders regarded ''seminary classes as useless,"13 today's leaders have realized that a more formal program of theological education is necessary for the longterm growth—perhaps even survival—of the movement. The curriculum resembles that of almost any denominational seminary and includes lectures and seminars in Old Testament Language and Literature, New Testament Greek, Christian Theology (with a focus on Theology of Japan), Christian Ethics, New Testament history, Faith and Society, and Nonchurch History.14 The only components apparently missing from a typical seminary curriculum are courses in homiletics, pastoral counseling, and church government or polity.
At the same time as these efforts are being made to train more leaders, one also hears widespread criticism of the traditional "teachercentered" pattern of leadership in the movement.15 Dissatisfaction is not confined to women and younger members. A number of elderly members find that their needs are not adequately addressed by the fluid form of social organization Uchimura favored. What does an elderly member do when his teacher retires or dies and the group dissolves? Who provides pastoral care for the elderly who are unable to attend meetings? Who will provide a Christian funeral if one outlives one's teacher? According to one report, the anonymity of the larger Bible study meetings can sometimes even mean that a person's illness, or even death, can go unnoticed. Overdependence on a declining number of elderly teachers is also regarded as a major cause for the failure of the movement to attract young people and reach out to children and women.
As noted in chapter four, the Nonchurch movement has always met in rented facilities or homes. For the most part, this was regarded positively because it freed members from the heavy financial burdens of purchasing property and
building in Japan. Today, however, numerous Bible study groups are reporting that it is becoming increasingly difficult to rent appropriate facilities for holding regular meetings. Members also complain that dependence on rented quarters usually means that not enough time is available for fellowship and discussion among members following the Bible lecture. These and other inconveniences have led some members to be so bold as to suggest the radical idea that it might be good for Nonchurch groups to invest in their own buildings. 16
The dilemmas currently faced by the Nonchurch movement serve to remind us that indigenous movements cannot be viewed in static terms. Indigenization is an ongoing process and movements must cope with changing generational needs and cultural concerns. Indigenous movements "are seldom standing still in their understanding of God, themselves, and others. They are continually evolving and trying new ideas and forms."17 As movements seek to address new situations, they can evolve in various directions—even in the direction of rapprochement with established church traditions.
Alternative Patterns of Appropriation
At the conclusion of my study, I am persuaded that the story of the transmission and cultural diffusion of Christianity in Japan does not lend itself to a simple faceoff between the acceptance of transplanted Christianity on the one hand and the development of alternative indigenous Christian movements on the other. The range of responses and patterns of appropriation is much broader and more complex. I agree with Wendy James and Douglas Johnson, who argue that "Christianity does not necessarily spread as an organic entity; partial elements, themes, symbols, practices, are characteristically taken up by a particular culture or civilization, ethnic class, or interest group, at a particular time."18 While my own studies have focused on indigenous movements, the influence of the Christian tradition is not confined to organizational forms such as these. After all, the number of Japanese belonging to either transplanted churches or indigenous Christian movements represents less than one percent of the population. In one sense, this seems to suggest that the vast majority of the Japanese have had little time for the evangelistic appeals of either Western missionaries or indigenous Christian leaders.
At the same time, a much higher percentage of Japanese have appropriated elements of Christianity or tried to make sense of Jesus on their own terms apart from organized forms of religion. In the deregulated religious economy of the postwar period, attitudes toward Christianity have generally become more
favorable and encouraged many Japanese to widen the scope of their eclectic orientation to include features related to this foreignborn religion.
Although based on data gathered over ten years ago, the NHK Survey of Japanese Religious Consciousness provides helpful information for understanding how
Japanese perceptions of Christianity have been gradually changing in recent decades. 19 The findings of the survey presented a slightly more optimistic picture of Christianity in Japan than provided by denominational statistics: two percent of the Japanese identify themselves as Christian and twelve percent feel a certain empathy for Christianity. Jan Swyngedouw has noted that while empathy for Buddhism and Shinto increase with age,
Christianity shows a completely reverse trend. In the 16–19 age bracket, it reaches a favorable claim of 29.7 percent to go gradually down to 4.5 percent and 5.4 percent for, respectively, the 60–69 and the over70 age brackets. Moreover, Christianity evokes empathy among 14 percent of the "unbelievers," almost equal to Shinto, but this drops to about 5 percent with the believers.20
Within a decade of this survey, these more positive attitudes toward Christianity have resulted in new patterns of ritual behavior. As noted in the opening chapter, Japanese religiosity is characterized by a stronger emphasis on ritual than on doctrine. As a rule, Japanese do not commit themselves to one particular religious organization; rather, they participate in the annual festivals and rituals of both Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples throughout the year. A religious division of labor also characterizes the rites of passage: Shinto dominates rituals associated with birth and Buddhism monopolizes rituals connected with death. Although an exclusive commitment to Christianity is still rare among Japanese, in recent years many have begun to accept the ritual contribution of Christianity (on their own terms) into the traditional division of labor. Until the Taisho* period (1912–1926), Japanese weddings were performed without religious officials. Shinto priests began to perform wedding ceremonies after this time, modeling their services to a certain extent on Western church weddings. Today, however, Christian churches are becoming a significant competitor for this role in the Japanese religious division of labor.21
The fact that Christian weddings are becoming increasingly popular among young couples today suggests that the stigma associated with Christianity may be declining.
A survey conducted in 1991 discovered that the percentage of Christian or churchrelated weddings was 35.9 percent in the Kanto* region and 23.8 percent in the
Kansai region. Similarly, a survey conducted the following year found that 31 percent of the weddings conducted in Japan were Christian.22
To a certain extent, the growing popularity of Christian weddings has been promoted by the highly publicized church weddings of TV personalities and movie stars. For whatever reasons, Christianity seems to be finding a niche for itself in the complex of Japanese folk religion by performing this fashionable if compartmentalized role. This trend of "Christian" weddings represents a natural Japanese appropriation of another religious tradition into the rites of passage in contemporary society.
A significant number of church representatives, both Japanese and foreign, have been critical of this piecemeal adoption of Christianity, which takes over ritual without engaging the individual in a serious faith commitment. At the same time, many others argue that wedding services provide one of the few positive points of contact between churches and younger Japanese. To this end many pastors and missionaries have devoted themselves to the "wedding ministry" as a way to present Christian perspectives on human relationships, family, and marriage to people who would otherwise know nothing of the church. The wedding ministry has also become a significant business enterprise, providing a source of income for clergy, missionaries, churches, and major hotels fitted out with Western wedding chapels. It remains to be seen if this approach will have longterm benefits for increasing membership in the churches of Japan. At the very least, the fact that scores of younger Japanese are choosing Christian weddings indicates that the present environment is much more open to Christianity and that much of the social stigma attached to the Christian faith has declined during the postwar period.
In addition to this selective ritual adaptation, there are numerous other examples of the appropriation of Jesus into Japanese religious culture outside the established churches. One of the most interesting examples is the folk tradition, passed down in a legend by the people of Shingo * village, Aomori Prefecture, that links the historical Jesus to Japan. They claim that after growing up in Galilee, Jesus traveled to Japan and stayed in their village until he returned to begin his public ministry in Judea at the age of thirtythree. He returned to Japan after a dramatic escape that had his lookalike Japanese brother Isukiri crucified in his place. As the legend goes, Jesus died at the age of 106 and was buried in Shingo village. There is a large cross erected on a mound to mark the burial site of Jesus, which is also where villagers observe the tradition of an annual Bon Festival dance, though the lyrics used in the song to accompany the dance differ from those of other regions.23 In an effort to stimulate the local economy, the government tourist bureau now prints Japanese and English brochures to publicize its claim to fame.24
Grave of Jesus in Aomori, Japan.
The selective appropriation of elements from the Christian tradition is also a prominent feature of a number of Japanese New Religions. Many of the Japanese New
Religions have felt compelled to find some place for the Christ figure in their mythologies. 25 Here it is worth looking briefly at several examples of how Jesus has been understood by some New Religious Movements. Tensokokyo* ( ) is a messianic movement based in Nagoya that draws on both Buddhist and Christian traditions. It does not use the Bible in worship or teaching, but its sacred text, La Voco de Sfinkso (The Voice of the Sphinx, written by the founder), is permeated by biblical themes and ideas (particularly from Genesis and Revelation), and the teachings of the movement draw on many doctrines and practices of the Christian church. The founder is understood to be a manifestation of the second coming of Christ and the future Buddha (Maitreya), thus superseding both Buddhism and Christianity.
Dancing (bonodori) in front of the grave of Jesus.
Although Tensokokyo * has a low profile and is relatively unknown, two other movements that have been the focus of considerable media attention over the past decade have also freely appropriated ideas from the Christian tradition. Asahara Shoko*, the founder of Aum Shinrikyo*, began his movement with an initial emphasis on traditional Buddhist teachings and ascetic practices aimed at personal liberation and enlightenment. To this Asian tradition he added apocalyptic ideas from the Bible and came to regard himself as a messianic figure who was destined to lead his followers in the establishment of an ideal society referred to as the Kingdom of Shambhala. With the publication of two small books, which declared his messianic identity, Asahara's character became increasingly authoritarian as he elaborated an apocalyptic vision with himself as a central character in the unfolding drama.26 It is still difficult to fathom, but what began as a loose association of yoga practitioners evolved into a movement bent on mass destruction. He and his followers are now on trial—many of them already serving prison terms—for their involvement in the sarin gas attack on the Tokyo subway system on 20 March 1995, which resulted in twelve deaths and thousands of injuries. Since the arrest of Asahara and some of his key followers, numerous other violent crimes have been confirmed by confessions and or evidence presented at the ongoing trials.
One final example is provided by Okawa* Ryuho*, a prominent new age figure, who founded the Science of Happiness Association (Kofuku* no Kagaku) in 1986 when he was only thirtythree years old. A graduate of the University of Tokyo and former salaried worker, Okawa began to attract a following through the publication of his "spirit world" books. In a period of four years he published almost 150 books, which together sold around 4 million copies. Okawa claims to communicate in trance with spirits from the "other world" and writes down the messages he receives. These have been published as collections of spirit revelations and consist of messages from such luminaries as Buddha, Jesus Christ, Edgar Cayce, Swedenborg, Newton, and Picasso. Jesus Christ is a significant figure, but just one of many spirits sending messages to this world. From all of these guiding spirits Okawa has synthesized an eclectic vision for building a New Age Civilization that integrates personal and public happiness.27
The place of Jesus Christ in Japanese New Religions requires a fulllength study of its own. I mention these examples only in order to locate the movements documented in this study in their wider cultural context and to show that interest in Jesus (or even Christianity) in Japan extends far beyond the boundaries of established churches and indigenous movements. While many Japanese New Religions find a place for Jesus Christ or incorporate beliefs or ideas from
the JudeoChristian tradition, they also claim to be establishing new paths that transcend or supersede Christianity. In contrast to these New Religions, the movements considered in this book were founded by Japanese who identify themselves as a part of the Christian tradition, though independent of the Western churches. What all of these examples indicate is that established churches in the West cannot control how the Christian tradition will be appropriated in other times and places. 28
The Global Context
For many years Western scholars assumed that a spiritualistic worldview would soon be a thing of the past as the process of modernization extended throughout the world. Rodney Stark, for example, remarked as recently as 1990 that "during the last century only one social science thesis has come close to universal acceptance among Western intellectuals—that the spread of modernization spells doom for religious and mystical beliefs."29 Secularization was regarded as an inevitable global process explaining the consequences of modernization for religious institutions and individual religiosity. The appearance of scores of new religious movements worldwide and the growth of PentecostalCharismatic Christian movements has forced sociologists and historians of religion to rethink this rather simplistic interpretation of the changing nature and role of religion in modern societies.
The sociological study of religion has clearly been burdened by a Eurocentric orientation for many years. Just as Western church leaders often expected the younger churches to simply accept their authority and theological traditions, there has been a tendency for academics to assume that the Western experience of modernization and secularization would be definitive for all humankind. Peter Berger's The Sacred Canopy, one of the few best sellers in the sociology of religion, played a leading role in disseminating this point of view. In this important and popular work, Berger concluded that "it is safe to predict that the future of religion everywhere will be decisively shaped by the forces that have been discussed in this and the preceding chapters."30 In a word, nonWestern countries were expected to follow the Western pattern of development with only minor variations.
We have slowly begun to recognize that masses of humanity are likely to live on the margins or outside of the benefits of societal modernization for many years to come and, more than likely, will remain embedded in local cultural tra
ditions for the foreseeable future. Of those who have reaped the benefits of modern technology, many have chosen not to adopt the modern secular frame of mind that characterized the European experience of modernization. It is becoming increasingly clear that the human capacity to combine various elements from traditional and modern technological cultures has been profoundly underestimated. Over three decades ago, Herbert Passin noted perceptively:
Modernization does not mean the complete and instant displacement of the traditional. The process is not uniform; it affects the separate cultural elements, areas of thought, and population groups that make up a nation in different ways. Certain elements of traditional culture may remain completely unaltered. . . . The result is that a modern sector grows up alongside the traditional one. Although the modern sector tends to expand, it is by no means certain that the final culmination of this process is the complete obsolescence of the traditional. At the very least, for long periods they can coexist side by side. 31
Passin's remarks were not originally made with reference to religion, but his nuanced understanding of the impact of modernization is certainly more accurate for religion than the many "tired" theories of secularization. This is not to suggest that the Japanese are extraordinarily religious or that Japanese society is more religious today than in premodern times, but simply to point out that modernization has ambivalent effects on religion.32 In short, the sociological theory regarding modernization and secularization developed on the basis of Western or European history does not fit the case of Japan's modernization. A unilinear conception of modernization and religious decline cannot adequately account for the course of development in many nonWestern regions of the world.
The world has changed a great deal over the past thirty years and Peter Berger has been willing to admit that he got it wrong. In more recent years, he has written that "a theory that sees secularization as inextricably linked with modernity runs into serious difficulties. . . . There are vast regions today in which modernization has not only failed to result in secularity but has instead led to reaffirmation of religion." While holding to his earlier views with regard to the secularization process in Northern Europe, he now points out that "the rest of the world is as furiously religious as ever, and possibly more so."33 In their attempt to make sense of this "big picture," Irving Hexham and Karla Poewe suggest:
The "rereligionization" of the world has something to do with the global breakdown of modernity, most obviously since the 1970s. The five world religions, Judaism, Islam,
Buddhism, Hinduism, and Christianity, have inspired
folk or urban popular movements that seem to criticize a widespread sense of inner disintegration, anomie, dislocation, and most important, an absence of an overall perspective. 34
It is not surprising to find that many of these movements are particularistic (ethnic, nationalistic, and religious) and seek to provide some kind of symbolic anchor in the cultural flux and ambiguity of modern society. The indigenous and independent Christian movements are an important part of this larger global phenomenon.
In the Japanese context, we have found that most movements have been unable to sustain longterm growth in spite of indigenization. The transplantation and diffusion of Christianity is a complicated process that cannot be reduced to the simple formula, "Missionary efforts and investments + indigenous cultural adaptations = numerical success." This is not to deny the importance ofindigenization for the successful diffusion of a foreignborn religion. By comparing the situation of Christianity in Japan with that of South Korea, we noted a number of important political and cultural factors that have discouraged the widespread acceptance of this new faith. The different patterns of development in Korea and Japan, for example, indicate that macropolitical relations at the time of emplantation is a critical factor shaping the subsequent trajectory of religious diffusion. While indigenous movements in both countries have made similar cultural adaptations, it has been the Korean movements that have grown dynamically and become active in global crosscultural mission.
Since the time when Protestantism was first transplanted to Japan, Christianity in the West has undergone significant changes. Today most Protestant missionaries recognize the need to develop contextual theologies and forms of worship appropriate to different cultural contexts. Efforts in this area have moved far beyond earlier concerns with establishing "selfsupporting" local churches to a consideration of new ways of conceiving and interpreting the Christian faith. The Roman Catholic Church has also expressed a deeper sensitivity to the needs and concerns of nonWestern Christians under the banner of "inculturation." In spite of these developments in missiological circles and Western theology, it remains to be said that most of the theologizing that occurs in indigenous and independent Christian movements in Asia and Africa has been ignored or simply written off as syncretistic aberration. With the exception of the Nonchurch movement, the groups taken up in this study are largely unknown either inside or outside of Japan. Although Christian ecumenism today recognizes the importance of interfaith dialogue and mutual understanding among
the world religions, the views and perspectives offered by indigenous Christian movements are usually not accorded similar respect or taken seriously.
Indigenous movements in Japan and elsewhere represent serious efforts to make sense of the Christian faith in light of local cultural traditions and concerns. These movements have remained relatively small in Japan, but the issues and questions with which they have struggled are suggestive of what is occurring among the developing churches in other nonWestern societies. "When Christianity is taken out of the European cultural tradition," George R. Saunders observes, "the nature of kinship, lineage connections, and the role of ancestors often become problematic." 35 These new theological concerns are patent in the development of Christianity both in East Asia and the African continent.36 There is no escaping the fact that postEnlightenment European or North American Christianity can no longer be regarded as the measuring rod for defining a "normative" Christianity.
For some years the more astute observers have been telling us that it is no longer accurate to think of Christianity as a Western religion. David Barrett has noted, for example, that for eighteen centuries over 90 percent of the Christian population was Caucasian. The decline in European churches and the growth of Christianity in the nonWestern world over the past century have changed the face of Christianity. We may still be prone to think of Christianity as a Western religion, but by 1981 nonwhites formed the majority of all Christians and by the late 1980s 56 percent of the Christian population was located outside the West in SubSaharan Africa, Latin America, and Asia.37 Andrew F. Walls writes about the implications of this demographic shift:
Within the last century there has been a massive southward shift of the center of gravity of the Christian world, so that the representative Christian lands appear to be in Latin
America, SubSaharan Africa, and other parts of the southern continents. This means that Third World theology is now likely to be the representative Christian theology.38
We are only beginning to grasp what this new definition of "center" and "periphery" will mean for religion in the coming century, but there is already clear evidence that dynamic new forms of Asian and African Christianity are already having a significant impact on the Western churches.39
For some time professional theologians have been attempting to address the issues that have emerged from the encounter with the "great traditions," but it is primarily the leaders of indigenous movements who are involved in a serious Christian engagement with the "little traditions" (i.e., folk or primal religious
traditions) that shape the concerns of the masses throughout Asia and Africa. Almost a decade ago Donald Dayton made an appeal to open the ecumenical door and
''let the riffraff in," referring to the contributions that the Holiness and Pentecostal movements have to make to the larger Christian community. 40 These marginal movements in the United States were on the cutting edge of the antislavery movement in the 1830s and affirmed women in ministry well in advance of the established or mainline churches. And, as we remarked above, Christian ecumenism all but systematically excludes the views and perspectives offered by indigenous Christian movements. Perhaps if the door were opened a little wider, Western churches would find there is something to learn from the many indigenous and independent movements that are developing throughout the nonWestern world.
Whether or not the established churches will accept these movements as equal partners in dialogue remains to be seen. Those of us engaged in the comparative study of religion, in any case, must take these movements more seriously, however bizarre and anachronistic they may appear at times, however much they may disturb our own religious—or secular—sensibilities. Bruce Lawrence has put it well:
At the end of this century religion remains feisty and fissiparous, pragmatic and progressive, thisworldly and otherworldly. It will persist as a major social force into the next century, and among the believers whom it might count in its fold may be a new generation of social scientists willing to observe more closely and categorize with new respect what an older generation had first spurned as outdated and then mislabeled as "damaged goods."41
For my part, I doubt that in the coming century the religious fold will be teeming with social scientists who are "true believers." But whatever our deepest convictions as scholars may be, one things seems clear: if we are going to provide an accurate and reliable guide to the world of Christianity in the years ahead, we must be willing to cast our nets more widely to include the kinds of movements and new forms of faith considered in these pages.
Appendix—
Bibliographical Guide to Indigenous Christian Movements
The purpose of this appendix is to provide an introduction to the basic literature available on each of the movements considered in this study. Brief resumes are also provided for the groups that did not receive systematic attention in chapters 4 to 6. Additional details scattered throughout the various chapters may be garnered by consulting the Index for the names of founders or particular movements. For those who wish to pursue personal contact, addresses and contact persons for each movement may be found in the Christian Yearbook, which is published annually in Japanese by the Kirisuto Shinbunsha of Tokyo.
The groups are arranged chronologically, according to the year of their founding.
Nonchurch Movement
Founder: Uchimura Kanzo *
Year Organized: 1901
Treatment: Chapter 4
General Bibliographies
Resources on Uchimura Kanzo and the Nonchurch movement are abundant and extensive holdings may be found in the archives of the Imai Hall and the International Christian University Library.
[An inventory of Imai Hall Resource Center holdings]. Tokyo: Imai Kan Seisho Kodo* Kyoyukai*, 1990.
[An inventory of the Uchimura Kanzo memorial collection]. Tokyo: International Christian University, 1997 (third edition).
Primary Sources
Uchimura Kanzo. [Complete works of Uchimura Kanzo]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1981–1984.
The Complete Works of Kanzo* Uchimura, with notes and comments by Taijiro Yamamoto and Yoichi Muto*. Tokyo: Kyo* Bun Kwan, 1971.
This is a sevenvolume collection of Uchimura's English writings, including his diary "How I Became a Christian," and various other essays and editorials published between 1886 and 1924.
[Nonchurch history, vol. I: The first period: The formative years], edited by the Nonchurch Historical Research Association. Tokyo: Shinkyo* Shuppan, 1991.
Tamura Kosan* [Proceedings of the 1985 Nonchurch summer colloquia]. Tokyo: Mukyokai* Kaki Konwakai Jimukyoku, 1986.
(1987) [Proceedings of the first Nonchurch Christianity national meeting]. Tokyo: Mukyokai Kirisutokyo* Zenkoku Shukai* Jimukyoku, 1988.
This is an important resource for understanding the Nonchurch movement today. Published each year since 1988, the proceedings record lectures, regional reports, and summaries of various group discussions.
Secondary Sources
Caldarola, Carlo. Christianity: The Japanese Way. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1979.
Howes, John F. "The NonChurch Christian Movement in Japan." The Transactions of the Asiatic Society of Japan, Third Series 5 (1957), 119–37.
———. "Uchimura Kanzo * and Traditional Japanese Religions." Japanese Religions 2/1 (1960), 23–30.
———. "Japanese Christians and American Missionaries," in Marius B. Jansen, ed. Changing Japanese Attitudes toward Modernization. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965, 337–68.
———. "Japanese Christianity and the State: From Jesuit Confrontation/Competition to Uchimura's Noninstitutional Movement/Protestantism," in Steven Kaplan, ed. Indigenous Responses to Western Christianity. New York: New York University Press, 1995, 75–94.
Jennings, Raymond P. Jesus, Japan, and Kanzo* Uchimura: A Brief Study of the NonChurch Movement and its Appropriateness to Japan. Tokyo: Kyo* Bun Kwan, 1958.
Miura, Hiroshi. The Life and Thought of Kanzo Uchimura, 1861–1930. Grand Rapids, Michigan: William B. Eerdmans, 1996.
Moore, Ray A. ed. Culture and Religion in JapaneseAmerican Relations: Essays on Uchimura Kanzo, 1861–1930. Ann Arbor: Center for Japanese Studies, The University of Michigan, 1981.
Norman, William H. H. "Kanzo Uchimura: Founder of the NonChurch Movement." Contemporary Religions in Japan 5/1 (1964), 34–44.
Ohara Shin [The life of Uchimura Kanzo]. Tokyo: PHP Kenkyujo*, 1992.
The Way
Founder: Matsumura Kaiseki
Year Organized: 1907
Treatment: Chapter 5
Primary Sources
Matsumura Kaiseki [Fifty years in the faith]. Tokyo: Dokai* Honbu, 1926; 1989 revised edition.
———. [Dokai guidebook]. Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1917.
———. [Dokai catechism]. Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1919.
———. [New religion]. Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1925.
———. [The Dokai bible]. Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1928.
———. [A critique of religions]. Tokyo: Dokai * Jimusho, 1929.
———. [The Dokai faith]. Tokyo: Toho* Shoin, 1934.
Matsumura Kichisuke [Lament not the dark night: Selections from Genshi shiroku]. Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1949.
Magazine: [The way], published quarterly. Secondary Sources
Akiyama Shigeo [Stories of Meiji figures: One lineage of Christianity]. Tokyo: Shinkyo* Shuppansha, 1982.
Kato* Masao [The thought of Matsumura Kaiseki, religious reformer: An attempt to unite eastern and western thought]. Tokyo: Kindai Bungeisha, 1996.
Ouchi* Saburo* [Bulletin of the Institute for Japanese Culture, Tohoku* University] 12 (1976), 1–18.
———. [Uchimura Kanzo studies] 8 (1977), 68–82.
[The library of modern literature], vol. 45. Tokyo: Showa* Joshi Daigaku Kindai Bungaku Kenkyushitsu*, 1977.
This is a particularly helpful resource that includes an overview of Matsumura's life and writings (199–208) and a chronological bibliography of his publications (209–68).
Christ Heart Church
Founder: Kawai Shinsui
Year Organized: 1927
Treatment: Chapter 5
Primary Sources
Kawai Shinsui [A eulogy on Jesus Christ]. Tokyo: Kobundo*, 1927. The English version is available as A Eulogy on Jesus Christ, trans. Yoshinobu Kawai, Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1961.
Kawai Shinsui [The education of Confucius and my experience]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan* Shuppanbu, 1946.
———. [The superior man and inferior man]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1953.
———. [The sincerity of God and my experiences]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan * Shuppanbu, 1956. The English version is also available as My Spiritual Experiences, trans. Kawai Yoshinobu. Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1970.
———. [The religious solution to the labor problem]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1964.
This booklet addresses labor problems from the perspective Kawai developed as director of education at the Gunze Silk Factory.
———. . Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1970.
———. [The mysteries of Galatians]. Fujiyoshida: Kirisuto Shinshu* Kyodan* Jimukyoku Shuppanbu, 1965.
———. [Lectures on the perfect teaching]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1977.
———. . Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1969.
———. . Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan, 1981.
Magazine: [The mind of Christ], published quarterly.
Secondary Source
Otsuka Eisan [Kawai Shinsui Sensei at Gunze]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1931.
Glorious Gospel Christian Church
Founder: Sugita Kotaro*
Year Organized: 1936
Sugita Kotaro* converted to Christianity as a result of reading the Bible during a long illness following a period of military service. In preparation for the Christian ministry, he enrolled in the theological seminary of the Holiness Church in Tokyo. Following graduation and ordination, he was sent by Bishop Nakada Juji* to serve as the pastor of the Holiness congregation in Aso, Kyushu*. Sugita could
not accept the hierarchical structure of the Holiness Church and established the Glorious Gospel Christian Church as an independent movement in 1936. The name of the church was taken from 1 Timothy 1:11, which makes a specific reference to the "glorious gospel of God." Although he rejected the religious authority of the Holiness tradition, he continued to observe the sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper and maintained the Holiness Church emphasis on divine healing.
Like Uchimura in his Nonchurch movement, Sugita rejected the clergylaity distinction. All Christians are expected to be witnesses of the gospel and those who are called to be evangelists must be selfsupporting like the Apostle Paul (who was a tentmaker). Sugita supported himself as a math and English teacher and received no regular salary from the church. The church does not require a membership fee or tithe, but simply encourages members to support the church as God leads them.
Over the years, a number of members donated their land or homes to establish 10 churches around the country. The membership peaked at approximately 3,000 in the late 1970s, but has declined rapidly over the past decade and is down to 1,000. The founder's wife, Ikuko, succeeded him in 1972, but no clear program for training leaders was ever established. Worship services today follow the typical Protestant pattern of hymns, Bible reading, and prayers, but members listen to a taped sermon by the founder since no one has been properly trained to continue this role. The annual convention held in August is still attended by 200 to 300 members, but observance of the Lord's Supper has been abandoned since it is too much trouble to distribute bread and wine to that many people. This ritual has now been modified and is called a "spiritual Lord's Supper" ( ); no elements are distributed but a brief time of meditation is observed. Like the founders of other indigenous movements, Sugita took a hopeful approach to the fate of the ancestors who died without hearing and responding to the gospel of Christ in this life. He was also more tolerant of his followers participating in Buddhist memorial rites and provided alternative memorial services to meet the felt needs of Japanese and to indicate that Christians also showed care and respect for the dead (see chapter 7, pages 105, 114). Primary Sources
[A popular introduction to the glorious gospel]. Aso, Kyushu *: Eiko* no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai* Shuppanbu, 1952.
A simple introduction to the basic teachings of this church that follows a questionandanswer format.
———. [The glorious gospel, part 1]. Aso, Kyushu *: Eiko* no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai* Shuppanbu, 1954.
———. [The glorious gospel, part 2]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1961.
———. [Sermons on the glorious gospel, vol. 1]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1955.
———. [Sermons on the glorious gospel, vol. 2]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1958.
———. [Hymns of the glorious gospel]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1941.
This is a hymnbook of 82 pages; all of the lyrics were written by the founder, with the exception of one by his wife, but melodies were borrowed from various Christian hymns and Japanese songs.
Writings by the Founder's Wife
Sugita Ikuko [People who return to Eden]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1964.
This volume records the story of the founder's faith, relationships with other Christian churches, and the development of the independent Glorious Gospel Christian Church.
———. [The Holy Spirit's admonitions to various churches]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1980.
———. [The Glorious Gospel Christian Church: The faith and witness of the founder]. Aso, Kyushu: Eiko no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai Shuppanbu, 1972.
Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church
Founder: Matsubara Kazuhito (1905–1966)
Year Organized: 1939
The founder of the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church, Matsubara Kazuhito, first came into contact with Christianity through the Mino Mission while a junior high student. While a student at Kyoto University he began to study Christianity more seriously after hearing lectures on science and religion by Sato* Teikichi, a Christian professor. Following graduation from university he moved to Kobe* and became an elementary school teacher. He converted to
Christianity as a result of attending services led by an evangelistic group related to Barclay Baxton (1860–1946), a lowchurch Anglican who served as a missionary in Kobe * and Matsue from 1890 to 1891. Matsubara subsequently felt a call to be an evangelist and attended Bible school (Shioya Seisho Gakusha) for one year to prepare for the ministry. He began independent evangelistic work in 1939. During the postwar period, the Ichibaku Church has grown to include 18 churches (primarily in the Nagoya and Kansai areas) and a membership of over 1,000. The founder died in 1966 and his wife, Saki, has led the church since that time.
This is an independent and indigenous church, but the evangelical and Holiness mission traditions provide the primary theological foundation for the church. Like the Holiness traditions, the church emphasized baptism of the Holy Spirit and healing; speaking in tongues, however, is not recognized as a legitimate practice for public worship, although some members exercise the "gift" in private. The founder emphasized divine healing and often anointed individuals with oil and held special healing services. This is much less common today, but occasionally a healing service is held. The church observes both baptism and the Lord's Supper.
A memorial service is held for the founder each May and for other deceased members on Easter Sunday and in the fall on a Sunday preceding the autumn equinox ( ) of the deceased between the church cemetery and the Buddhist family grave in an effort to accommodate the needs and concerns of nonChristian relatives.
At the head church in Nagoya average Sunday attendance is over 200 and signlanguage is provided for a small deaf group in the front of the church. The church service has a Biblical and evangelical orientation, with members following the sermon with their Bibles opened. The church actively supports revivals and crusades directed by various evangelical groups in Japan, making its identity as a distinct and separate subculture weaker than other indigenous movements.
Primary Sources
[One Ear of Wheat: The faith and life of Matsubara Kazuhito]. Nagoya: Ikeru Kirisuto Ichibaku Kyokai*, 1972.
This is a memorial volume that contains the founder's own brief autobiography, numerous photographs of the founder from childhood through his adult ministry,
several of his sermons, and reflections by various leaders and members from various congregations of the Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church.
Matsubara Saki [If one grain of wheat dies]. Tokyo: New Life, 1986.
A collection of sermons by Matsubara Kazuhito, edited by his wife and current head of the church.
[Living Christ one ear of wheat], a monthly newsletter.
Christian Canaan Church
Founder: Taniguchi Toku
Year Organized: 1940
The Christian Canaan Church was founded by Taniguchi Toku, who converted to Christianity through contact with Plymouth Brethren missionaries from England.
After his conversion he experienced the baptism of the Holy Spirit and formed this independent Japanese Pentecostal Church. The group began with house meetings in 1940. The headquarters of this church is in Sakai City south of Osaka and churches are concentrated in the Kansai area. As the Church is too small to maintain its own theological school, its pastors are trained at various Bible colleges and seminaries in the area. According to a recent Christian Yearbook, it now has ten churches, four evangelistic meeting places, a membership of almost 2,500, and 31 pastors (twothirds of whom are women).
The Bible is the standard of faith for this church, which uses the old literary translation with which the founder began. The primary concern of this group is to practice Christianity according to the Bible and the power of the Holy Spirit. Baptism of the spirit, speaking in tongues, healing, are all features this group shares in common with other Pentecostal churches. The church observes baptism and the Lord's Supper, as well as Christian memorial services for the dead according to the traditional Japanese calendar and family custom.
Japan Ecclesia of Christ
Founder: Koike Tatsuo
Year Organized: 1940
Koike Tatsuo was born in 1904 and educated at Tokyo Imperial University. He became attracted to Christianity as a young man as a result of attending the
Bible lectures of Uchimura Kanzo *, the wellknown founder of the Nonchurch movement. After his conversion, he attended a Nonchurch Bible study group led by Takeshi Fujii, one of Uchimura's disciples, for a period of five years (1925–1930). In 1940 Koike established his own independent Bible study group based on the Nonchurch tradition. Over the next several decades, Koike's circle of influence widened and he eventually organized 12 groups around the country.
Although rooted in the Nonchurch movement, Koike became very critical of Uchimura and the ''narrow intellectualism" of his disciples. He argued that both transplanted churches and Nonchurch Christianity were too conceptual in orientation. What people need is life, not just abstract teaching. This interpretation of Christianity was deeply influenced by Koike's experience of spirit baptism in 1950, while participating in a special evangelistic meeting with Teshima Ikuro*, the charismatic founder of the Original Gospel movement.
In 1979, after 50 years of academic life, Koike retired from his position as professor of German Literature at the University of Tokyo. He devoted the remainder of his life to evangelistic work and died in 1996 with no clear successor.
Primary Source
, 1988.
The Spirit of Jesus Church
Founder: Murai Jun
Year Organized: 1941
Treatment: Chapter 6
Primary Sources
Murai Jun [Biblical theology: Basic doctrines]. Tokyo: Iesu no Mitama Kyodan*, 1957.
———. [A guide to Christianity]. Tokyo: Iesu no Mitama Kyokai* Honbu, n.d.
Secondary Sources
Anzai Shin [Folk religion and society], vol. 5. Tokyo: Kobunsha*, 1980, 268–79.
———. [The acceptance of Christianity in the southern islands]. Tokyo: Daiichi Shobo *, 1984.
Mullins, Mark R. "Japanese Pentecostalism and the World of the Dead: A Study of Cultural Adaptation in Iesu no Mitama Kyokai*." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies, 17/4 (1990), 353–74.
The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus
Founder: Otsuki* Takeji
Year Organized: 1946
Treatment: Chapter 6
Primary Sources
Otsuki Takeji [The collected works of Otsuki Takeji]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 17 volumes, 1976–1997.
Over the past 20 years 17 volumes of Otsuki's writings have appeared under his penname Gensen. One last volume is scheduled to be published in the near future.
———. [Meditations on the Holy Land]. Kyoto: Sei Iesu Kai Logos Sha, 1993.
Otsuki Fudeko [Aiming for Jerusalem]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing, 1993.
This is a history of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus from its founding in 1946 until 1967, written by the founder's wife.
———. [Selections from Rebecca]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing, 1993.
Parts 1 and 2 of this volume are selections from Otsuki Fudeko's essays, talks given to the Mariya Kai women's group, and notes from her diaries. Part 3 consists of selections written about her by close associates.
Sato* Toshio [The tracks of revival]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing, 1996.
A volume prepared in 1996 to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus. It provides a historical overview of the life of Father Otsuki until the establishment of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus in 1946, drawing on Otsuki's writings and interview materials.
Miscellaneous Church Publications [Witnesses].
A magazine published for members of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus and not usually distributed to outsiders.
[The grapevine].
A short (4–6 pages) monthly publication used for evangelism and religious education. Approximately 80,000 copies are distributed through the 100 churches nationwide.
[The grapevine: a compilation for evangelistic use]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 1991.
A concise introduction to the beliefs and practices of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus based on articles published from the monthly news.
[Logos].
A journal published by Logos Theological Seminary.
. [Serving the word: An introduction to Biblical doctrine, vol. 1, Doctrine of Holy Scripture]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 1974.
A textbook used for training ministers and evangelists at Logos Theological Seminary.
[vol. 2, Doctrine of God, doctrine of man]. Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 1974.
A textbook used for training ministers and evangelists at Logos Theological Seminary.
Sanctifying Christ Church
Founder: Konmoto Kaoru
Year Organized: 1948
Konmoto Kaoru was born in 1914 and converted to Christianity at the age of seventeen as a result of attending a small home Bible study meeting. He went on to attend the Shioya Seisho Gakusha, a Bible school with roots in the early missionary work of Barclay Baxton (1860–1946), a lowchurch Anglican, who served as a missionary in Kobe * and Matsue, 1890–1891. He began independent evangelistic work in the early postwar period by holding services on the street, tent revival meetings, and services in the homes of early converts. Kobe was the center of these evangelistic efforts and became the church headquarters. In 1952, Konmoto organized a Bible school ( ) to train evangelists within the Kobe church. Thirty individuals have prepared for ministry in the jukustyle Bible school. Over the past fifty years, Konmoto and his disciples have organized eleven congregations.
Konmoto's primary concern has been to establish independent and selfsupporting churches faithful to the apostolic tradition. While Japanese churches
can learn from the experience of foreign churches and missionaries, they should not seek to copy them. Unlike some of the other indigenous Christian movements, Konmoto's writings and messages are essentially Biblical expositions and contain little or no reference to Asian religious traditions. Special emphasis is placed on the biblical teachings regarding spirit baptism and sanctification. The church observes the sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper and has developed memorial services in response to the Japanese concern to show special care and respect for the deceased. The founder is nearly ninety years old and preparing to designate one of his disciples to assume his position as head of the church ( ).
Primary Sources
Konmoto Kaoru [A collection in commemoration of the fortieth anniversary of the founding of the Sanctifying Christ Church]. Kobe *: Seisei Kirisuto Kyodan* Honbu, 1987.
This volume contains a brief history of the church, photographs, and a collection of testimonials by various members and pastors.
———. [A still small voice]. Kobe: Seisei Kirisuto Kyodan Honbu, 1988.
A collection the founder's writings that includes Bible study outlines, curriculum used for theological education used in Bible school, and several original hymns.
Original Gospel (Tabernacle)
Founder: Teshima Ikuro*
Year Organized: 1948
Treatment: Chapter 6
Primary Sources
Teshima Ikuro [An introduction to the Original Gospel faith]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Seisho Juku, 1969.
———. [The Japanese people and the Original Gospel]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Seisho Juku (Makuya Bible Seminary), 1984.
This is a collection of Teshima's writings published by his wife eleven years after his death.
——— . [The love of the Holy Spirit]. Tokyo: The Makuya Bible Seminary, 1950. The English version was published as The Love of the Holy Spirit, trans. Umemoto Aiko. Tokyo: The Makuya Bible Seminary, 1991.
———. An Introduction to the Original Gospel Faith. Tokyo: Makuya Bible Seminary, 1970.
In addition to Teshima's writings, this volume includes an essay by Dr. Otto Piper, Professor Emeritus of Princeton Theological Seminary, which suggests that Makuya is an indigenous Christian movement that represents a significant "third force" in Japanese Protestantism.
Makuya and Israel: In Memory of Abraham I. Teshima. Tokyo: Makuya Bible Seminary, 1976.
A collection of photographs and accounts of Teshima's involvements with Israel and Zionism. Also included are several reflections by Israelis, which include words of appreciation for Teshima's support of Israel. Includes photos of Teshima and 400 Makuya pilgrims in Israel for the 25th anniversary celebration of Israel's independence.
Magazine: [Light of life], published monthly.
Secondary Sources
Baba Toshihiko [Meijo * University Journal of Humanities] 5 (1967), 1–32.
A description and critique of the Original Gospel movement by a former member and editor of the Makuya magazine Light of Life, who is currently Professor of Philosophy at Meijo University in Nagoya.
———. [One's true self, vol. 1]. Aichi: Chubu* Nihon Kyoiku* Bunka Kai, 1994; see especially 122–40, 174–76.
Caldarola, Carlo. "The Makuya Christian Movement." Japanese Religions 7/4 (1972), 18–34.
———. Christianity: The Japanese Way. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1979. 192–208.
Miyazaki Akira [A study of the Original Gospel]. Tokyo: Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan*, Senkyo* Kenkyujo*, 1965.
Mori Satoshi [The Original Gospel: What is God's Tabernacle (movement)]. Tokyo: New Life Publishing, 1986 (first published in 1965).
This is the fourth booklet by a conservative evangelical author in a series on modern heresies ( ), which also includes Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, and the Unification Church.
Yoshimura Kiichiro* [My teacher, Teshima Ikuro*]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Seisho Juku, 1990.
A biography of Teshima by one of his close disciples.
LifeGiving Christ
Founder: Imahashi Atsushi
Year Organized: 1966
This movement is essentially an independent version of the Original Gospel movement. Following a oneyear period of study in Israel as a Makuya member, Imahashi returned to Japan in 1964 and began his ministry as an evangelist under the direction of Teshima Ikuro *. A serious disagreement with Teshima forced him out of the Original Gospel movement and he began his own independent ministry in 1966. The LifeGiving Christ movement today consists of seven small ecclesia (house churches) under the direction of Imahashi.
Primary Sources
Imahashi Atsushi [A record of my conversion]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1991.
———. [Lectures on the Gospel of John]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1976.
———. [Lectures on the Revelation of John]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1981.
———. [Lectures on Genesis]. Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1989.
Magazine: [Lifegiving Christ], published monthly since 1966.
Okinawa Christian Gospel
Founder: Nakahara Masao
Year Organized: 1977
The founder of the Okinawa Christian Gospel, Nakahara Masao, was born in the town of Itoman on the main island of Okinawa in 1948. His father died when he was still a young child and he grew up in rather difficult circumstances. Following high school he moved to Kyoto and enrolled in a professional school in order to obtain credentials as a radiologist. It was while he was in Kyoto that he began to attend services at a Plymouth Brethren church. Within three months he converted to the Christian faith and received baptism. Nakahara returned to Okinawa to work as a radiologist in a local hospital. In 1977 an experience of divine healing and revelation from God led him to resign from his position as an Xray technician to devote the remainder of his life to evangelis
tic work. His independent Christian fellowship grew rapidly and in less than twenty years had six branch churches, two mission outreach centers, and a membership of approximately 1,500. The movement also maintains several residences (brotherhouses for men and sisterhouses for women) to care for individuals who are troubled by various spiritual and psychological problems. This is a charismatic movement in which the practices of speaking in tongues, prophecy, healing, and exorcism play a central role.
Secondary Sources
Ikegami Yoshimasa [A stage for demons and the Holy Spirit: The world of salvation as seen in popular Okinawan Christianity]. Tokyo: Dobutsusha *, 1991.
——. "Okinawan Shamanism and Charismatic Christianity," The Japan Christian Review 59 (1993), 69–78.
Notes
References to works listed in the General Bibliography at the conclusion of this volume (pages 261–65) appear in the notes in abbreviated form, and Japanese titles listed there are given here in their English translation only.
Chapter 1—
Christianity as World Religion and Vernacular Movement
1 Hexham and Poewe, New Religions as Global Cultures, 41, 43.
2 Robert W Hefner, "The Rationality of Conversion," in Robert W Hefner, ed., Conversion to Christianity, 5.
3 Walls, The Missionary Movement in Christian History, 7.
4 "Introductory Essay: on 'Native Christianity'," in Wendy James and Douglas H. Johnson, eds., Vernacular Christianity, 12, emphasis added.
5 Wilbert R. Shenk, "Toward a Global Church History," International Bulletin of Missionary Research 20/2 (1996), 50.
6 "Converting Buddhism to Christianity, Christianity to Buddhism," Japanese Religions, 22/2 (1997), 112.
7 The Diffusion of Religions, 13.
8 This is the definition provided by Morioka Kiyomi in "A Conceptual Examination of the Indigenization of ForeignBorn Religions," 52. Morioka makes a basic distinction between "acculturation" and "indigenization," explaining that in studies of acculturation the central focus or concern is to what extent the native culture has changed under the influence of a foreign religion; studies of indigenization, on the other hand, are primarily concerned with the nature and degree of change in the foreignborn religion through contact with native religion and culture.
9 An important elaboration of this point may be found in Sanneh, Translating the Message.
10 Tradition Old and New (Exetor: The Paternoster Press, 1970), 17–18.
11 André Drooger, "Syncretism: The Problem of Definition, the Definition of the Problem," in Jerald D. Gort, Hendrik M. Vroom, Rein Fernhout, and Anton Wessels, eds., Dialogue and Syncretism: An Interdisciplinary Approach (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989), 16.
12 Maruyama Masao, Studies in the Intellectual History of Tokugawa Japan, trans. Mikiso Hane (Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1974), 331.
13 See his now classic text, The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion (Garden City: Anchor Books, 1969).
14 This term I have borrowed from Winston Davis's Japanese Religion and Society, 31.
15 See, for example, Watanabe Shoko *, [Japanese Buddhism], (Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1958), 102–32; and Morioka, "A Conceptual
Examination of the Indigenization of ForeignBorn Religions," 55. Some of the difficulties involved in the transplantation of Japanese Buddhism to individualistic North America are closely related to the fact that it is tied to this cult of the dead; see my earlier study, "The Organizational Dilemmas of Ethnic Churches: A Case Study of Japanese Buddhism in Canada," Sociological Analysis 49/3 (1988), 226.
16 For a concise introduction and statistics on representative major New Religions in Japan, see Shimazono's "New Religious Movements," in Mullins et al., Religion and Society in Modern Japan, 221–30. For more details and an extensive bibliography, see Dictionary of New Religions, edited by Inoue Nobutaka.
17 Jan Swyngedouw, "The Christian Churches and Heretical Movements," in Kumazawa and Swain, eds., Christianity in Japan, 1971–1990, 184; emphasis added.
18 For an important examination ofindigenization within the United Church of Christ in Japan (Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan*), the largest Protestant denomination in Japan, see David Reid, New Wine.
19 Robert J. Smith, "Something Old, Something New," 722.
20 Regarding the earlier case of transplantation from China, Albert M. Craig explains that "the eighth and ninth centuries were the time of Sinification, when Japan was deeply influenced by Chinese culture and institutions. . . . Then, as the embassies to China came to an end, Japan entered a period of digestion or indigenization, when the borrowed institutions were simplified and reshaped to fit Japanese society and its needs." See his "Introduction" to Albert M. Craig, ed., Japan: A Comparative View (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1978), 6–7.
Chapter 2—
The Social Sources of Christianity in Japan
1 This present exercise finds parallels in the classic work of H. Richard Niebuhr, The Social Sources of Denominationalism (1929). Over half a century ago, Niebuhr identified transplanted immigrant churches from Europe and new forms of American sectarianism as the primary social sources of denominational subcultures in the United States. One of Niebuhr's central concerns was with the "Americanization" of the immigrant churches, similar to the process we refer to as indigenization in this study. Although the development of indigenous movements in Japan certainly resembles some forms of sectarianism in America, it should be noted that the character and orientation of transplanted "mission churches" differs considerably from that of the "immigrant churches" in the United States. The aim of the mission churches has been to transmit a universal truth, not to preserve the language and culture of the old country. In the very act of translation, mission churches were transformed and inevitably began to differ from their sponsoring mother churches in the home country. As this study will show, however, many missionaries were unable to distinguish their religious message from their cultural baggage in a manner that could satisfy some Japanese leaders.
2 See P F. Saeki, The Nestorian Documents and Relics in China (Tokyo: Maruzen, 1951), for a discussion of Nestorian relics in Japan from the tomb of the envoys from Kublai Khan who were executed in 1280 and from the tomb of others who died during the Mongolian invasion of 1281 (444–47).
3 For helpful studies of this initial period of missionary expansion, see Charles Ralph Boxer, The Christian Century in Japan, 1549–1650 (Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1951); Joseph Jennes, A History of the Catholic Church in Japan from Its Beginnings to the Early Meiji Era, 1549–1873 (Tokyo: Oriens Institute for Religious Research, 1973, rev. ed.); Neil S. Fujita, Japan's Encounter with Christianity: The Catholic Mission in PreModern Japan (New York: Paulist Press, 1991); and Andrew C. Ross, A Vision Betrayed: The Jesuits in Japan and China, 1542–1742 (Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books, 1994).
4 The literature on this indigenous kakure kirishitan tradition is vast. For helpful resources in English, see Ann M. Harrington, Japan's Hidden Christians (Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1993) and the chapters by Stephen Turnbull and Christal Whelan in Breen and Williams, Japan and Christianity.
5 In his Studies in the History of the Christian Churches in the Meiji Period, Ohama Tetsuya notes that not everything was harmonious during the socalled period of cooperation. He recalls the dismay of Dr. Hepburn when Jonathan Goble and his wife, the first Baptist missionary couple to Japan, refused to remain in the Sunday worship service and participate in the sacrament of communion with other Protestant missionaries. This was one small incident pointing to the "sectarianism" and "denominationalism" that would characterize the Protestant missionary movement in subsequent years (11).
6 In this review of the earliest cooperative mission efforts and the shift to a denominational orientation, I have relied on Morioka Kiyomi, Japan's Modern Society and Christianity, 65–86; and Ohama *, Studies in the History of the Christian Churches, 10–12.
7 For a standard treatment of the role of the three "bands" in the development of Protestant Christianity in Japan, see Kuyama Yasushi, Modern Japan and Christianity, 43–54.
8 Murata Shiro* argues that "the fact that the Covenant group at Sapporo had no knowledge of or instruction in the real nature of the church is not a little responsible for the subsequent development of Uchimura's movement." See his "The Character of the Protestant Church in Japan," The Japan Christian Quarterly 25/3 (1959), 204–5. For a similar observation, see Ohama, Studies in the History of the Christian Churches, 33.
9 Watanabe Zenta, "The Lack of Cultural Consciousness and Power in the Church of Japan," Japan Christian Quarterly 25/1 (1959), 48–49.
10 [Christian yearbook] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1981), 446–47.
11 This is found in Cary's summary of the Second Conference of Protestant Missionaries in his A History of Christianity in Japan, vol. 2, 166.
12 Although Protestant missions pioneered in the field of education, particularly for girls and women, the government subsequently stepped in and began to dominate this area. William K. Bunce explains:
From the time of the opening of the first school for girls in Japan in 1870 to the time when government schools for women were being promoted around 1900, the history of education for women in Japan is almost identical with the history of the Christian schools for girls. In 1905, Christian high schools for girls represented 70 percent of the total number of girls' schools. However, by 1930, government education for women had advanced to the point where the Christian schools totaled less than 5 percent.
Religions in Japan: Buddhism, Shinto, Christianity (Tokyo: Charles E. Tuttle, 1955), 158.
13 This information was originally reported in Cyril H. Powles, Victorian Missionaries in Meiji apan, The Shiba Sect: 1873–1900 (Toronto: University of Toronto, York University Centre on Modern East Asia, 1987), appendix 4, 162. It was brought to my attention in Helen Hardacre's review of Notto R. Thelle's Buddhism and Christianity in Japan in the Journal of Japanese Studies 15/1 (1989), 316–20.
14 This is not to deny the significant contribution of Protestant mission work to Japan's modernization, particularly in the fields of education and social welfare. However, in the view of Ernest E. Best, because Protestant Christianity ''failed to influence in any essential way those who held positions of decisive authority within the power structure of the nation, its influence was never determinative for the society as a whole." Christian Faith and Cultural Crisis: The Japanese Case (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1966), 173.
15 [Christian yearbook] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1976), 472–73. See Ikado Fujio, Religion in a Secular Society, 292–97, for a discussion of the link between Protestantism and the whitecollar class.
16 I have borrowed this expression from Helen Hardacre's Shinto and the State: 1868–1988 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989).
17 Ebisawa Akira, the Executive Secretary of the National Christian Council of Japan, expressed this civil religious theology quite clearly in a 1939 article commemorating the second anniversary of the war with China:
The policy of extending even to the continent our family principle which finds its center in an Imperial House so that all may bathe in its holy benevolence—this policy, can we not see?—is none other than the concrete realization on earth of the spiritual family principle of Christianity, which looks up to God as the Father of mankind and regards all men as brethren. This is the Christian conception of the kingdom of God. The basis of the Japanese spirit also consists in this; and thus, wonderful to relate, it is one with Christianity. Nay, this must indeed be the Great Way of Heaven and Earth.
Quoted in Darley Downs, Effects of Wartime Pressures on Churches and Missions in Japan (New York: Union Theological Seminary, Master of Sacred Theology Thesis, 1946), 32–35, from the National Christian Council Bulletin, 186, 1939.
18 For another example of this pattern of accommodation, see my recent case study of a Christian school during this same period, "The Struggle for Christian Higher Education in Japan: A CaseStudy of Meiji Gakuin University," in Gerard Dekker, Donald Luidens, and Rodger Rice, eds., Rethinking Secularization: Reformed Encounters with Modernity (New York: University Press of America, 1997).
19 Not all Christian groups gave in to the demands of the state. For a more detailed treatment of this period and an analysis of the Christian churches and sects that resisted these nationalistic pressures, see my "Ideology and Utopianism in Wartime Japan: An Essay on the Subversiveness of Christian Eschatology," Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 21/2–3 (1994).
20 New Wine, 80.
21 Modern Japan and Shinto Nationalism: A Study of PresentDay Trends in Japanese Religions (New York: Paragon, 1963), 95. Reflecting on the Protestant movement in Japan, Taiwan, and Korea between 1865 and 1945, A. Hamish Ion rather critically suggests:
Missionaries, even after more than 70 years of Christian work in Japan, had failed to instill courage into Japanese Christians. In sharp contrast to the Japanese, the steadfastness of Korean and Taiwanese Christians in the face of persecution reveals no lack of courage. . . . The Japanese Christian movement failed to resist the demands of the Japanese government for complete state control over the movement. Despite the long exposure to Christian ideals and values, indigenous cultural values and national concerns remained paramount in determining the reactions of Japanese Christians.
The Cross and the Rising Sun, vol. 2, The British Protestant Missionary Movement in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan, 1865–1945 (Waterloo, Ontario: Wilfrid Laurier University Press, 1993), 5–6.
22 World Christian Encyclopedia (New York: Oxford University Press, 1982), 423.
23 My suspicion is that the higher percentage indicated by survey research is probably related to the influence of certain wellknown Japanese Christian writers (such as Endo * Shusaku*, Sono Ayako, and Miura Ayako) and the numerous Christian educational institutions throughout Japan. For example, when compared with the number of private schools associated with other major religious organizations in Japan, the disproportionate role of Christians in this field is striking. By the early 1960s, for example, the number of Christian schools exceeded the number of Buddhistand Shintorelated institutions combined. While there were 652 Buddhistrelated schools (10 universities, 1 junior college, 77 high schools, 68 junior high schools, 1 elementary school, 410 kindergartens, and 85 "other"), and only 92 Shintorelated schools (2 universities, 1 junior college, 5 high schools, 6 junior high schools, 1 elementary school, 45 kindergartens, and 32 "other"), there were 840
Christianrelated educational institutions (22 universities, 47 junior colleges, 106 high schools, 116 junior high schools, 33 elementary schools, 445 kindergartens, and 71 "other").The miscellaneous institutions in the ''other" category include specialized schools for religious education and training (theological schools or seminaries in the case of Christianrelated schools). Reported in [The current state of education in Christian schools in Japan] (Tokyo: Education Association of Christian Schools, 1961), 133.
24 Inazo* Nitobe, The Intercourse between the United States and Japan: A Historical Sketch, in [Collected works of Nitobe Inazo] (Tokyo: Kyobunkan*, 1970), vol. 13, 468.
25 Inazo Nitobe, The Intercourse between the United States and Japan, 470. Sociologist Anzai Shin similarly suggests:
The Church has forgotten to distinguish, even in its own western terms, the essential from the nonessential. It took many centuries for western Christianity to fashion a
beautiful square peg, and she has been trying to drive it into a round hole in Japan; the peg will not fit.
Cited in Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way, 13.
26 See Inoue et al., Dictionary of New Religions. This indispensable volume contains over a thousand pages of information on new religions in Japan. This volume contains basic information on over three hundred religious movements and brief histories of over four hundred founders and leaders in Japanese religious movements (including basic information on several of the founders and movements mentioned in this book).
27 See Shimazono, Salvation Religions in Contemporary Society, 72.
28 In his helpful discussion of the use of typologies for comparative analysis in the study of Japanese religion, Winston Davis notes that "a good bridge is one that helpsus to move forward, beyond the familiar. Once it has been crossed, we may leave it behind and be on our way" (Japanese Religion and Society, 15). For an alternative approach focusing on religious thought and Japanese intellectual history, readers are referred to the wellknown work of Takeda Kiyoko, Indigenization and Apostasy. Takeda identifies the following five patterns of indigenization in Japanese Christianity: compromise ( haikyogata *), confrontation ( tsugikigata).
29 Sociology Reinterpreted, 4.
30 See Nishiyama Shigeru, "Youth, Deprivation, and New Religions: A Sociological Perspective," The Japan Christian Quarterly 57/1 (1991), 10.
31 Here I am drawing on rather standard distinctions made by sociologists in their revisions of the churchsect typology. See, for example, Roland Robertson, The
Sociological Interpretation of Religion (New York: Schocken, 1970), 120–28, and Meredith McGuire, Religion: The Social Context (Belmont, California: Wadsworth Publishing Co., 1981), 110–13. The selfdefinition or selfunderstanding of a religious group is important not only for churchsect theorizing but also for analyzing indigenization, and this has been taken into account in this typology.
32 This typological framework was developed as a critical response to Morioka Kiyomi's fourfold typology of indigenization, which appeared in his "A Conceptual
Examination of the Indigenization of ForeignBorn Religions," 52–57. In developing this alternative framework I am indebted to Ikegami Yoshimasa, Tsukuba University, who read my earlier critique of Morioka and made several helpful suggestions. Drawing upon churchsect theory, Morioka suggested that the nature of indigenization can be analyzed in terms of the following coaxial framework (see figure 6). One axis has to do with the relationship between the foreignborn religion and the receiving society. Is it sectarian in orientation and critical of the values and behavior of the larger society or is it essentially affirmative (churchlike) in its orientation? Is the foreignborn religion in tension with the larger society or in a state of harmonious coexistence? The second axis has to do with the nature and degree of change in the imported religion. Here the question is whether in the process of cultural adaptation changes have occurred only in external form (nonessential aspects) or have reached to the core of the reli
Relationship with Society Degree of Change
Change in Form Change in Essentials
NegativeRejecting (Sectlike) A
Isolation C
Clandestinization
AffirmativeAccepting (Churchlike) B
Indigenization D
Submergence
Figure 6.
Typology of Indigenization (Morioka, 1972)
gion. A combination of these two axes leads to four possible types: isolation, indigenization, clandestinization, and submergence.
The utility of churchsect theory for sociological research has been questioned, particularly the approaches taken by Troeltsch and Niebuhr, because definitions of organizational types have been based upon the notion of "theological compromise" with the world (see Alan W Eister, "H. Richard Niebuhr and the Paradox of Religious Organization: A Radical Critique," in Charles Y Glock and Phillip E. Hammond, eds., Beyond the Classics? Essays in the Scientific Study of Religion (New York: Harper and Row, 1973). Morioka was unable to avoid this problem in his attempt to develop this fourfold typology of indigenization. In analyzing the nature and degree of change in the imported religion, Morioka's approach required that one determine whether in the process of cultural adaptation changes had occurred only in external form (nonessential aspects) or have reached to the core (essentials) of the religion. Without denying that this is a legitimate area of theological and missiological concern, it does not provide a helpful basis for comparative sociological research. Theologians and churches have considerable difficulty in determining the "core" of the faith and "boundaries" that delimit acceptable doctrine and practice. A typology that requires such a distinction is problematic. In terms of Morioka's framework, for example, the Spirit of Jesus Church would not be regarded as an "authentic'' example of indigenization because it has dropped some "essentials" and still exists in tension with the larger society (placing it in the "clandestinization" category). Similarly, established churches would consider this group as heretical because of its rejection of trinitarian formulations of the Christian faith. The approach I am advocating here is to examine all groups that define themselves as Christian, then document what they do with the Christian faith when free of the control of Western churches, rather than exclude them prematurely on the basis of theological criteria. I should point out that several years after the 1972 article appeared, Morioka published Japan's Modern Society and Christianity, in which he stressed the importance of understanding the participants' view of reality in making sense of indigenization (279). He notes, for example, that the attitude of the believer towards what might be regarded as heretical practices is important. The Christian interpretation accorded certain practices is what distinguishes the "submergencetype" from the "indigenizedtype." This observation, however, was not integrated into his typology.
33 I have used the denominational category in order to emphasize the selfunderstanding of these groups, even though they lack the characteristics normally associated with a denomination in the West (i.e., central bureaucracy, complex organizational structure, and formal system for ministerial training and ordination).
34 [Complete works of Uchimura Kanzo *] (Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1981–1984) vol. 18, 256 (1911); emphasis in original.
35 These comments are from a sermon on the Lord's Supper by founder Murai Jun at the Naikai Spirit of Jesus Church on 20 August 1962. A transcribed manuscript of the taped sermon was made available to me. Field research and interviews with various pastors have shown me that Murai effectively transmitted his sectarian stance to his followers.
36 Modern Japan and Shinto Nationalism, 95; emphasis added.
Chapter 3—
Charisma, Minor Founders, and Indigenous Movements
1 Jesus: A New Vision (San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1987), 225–26.
2 For a detailed study of the New Testament texts that deal with the charismatic nature of Jesus' religious experience and the early Christian movement, see James D.
G. Dunn, Jesus and the Spirit: A Study of the Religious and Charismatic Experience of Jesus and the First Christians as Reflected in the New Testament (London: SCM Press, 1975). For a more recent treatment of spirit belief in the New Testament and the role of Jesus as an exorcist and healer see Stevan L. Davies, Jesus the Healer: Possession, Trance, and the Origins of Christianity (New York: Continuum, 1995).
3 Morton T. Kelsey observes, for example, that in the third century "the order of exorcists soon grew so large that one bishop in Rome complained that they outnumbered the priests." Healing and Christianity: In Ancient Thought and Modern Times (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1973), 153.
4 See D. B. Barrett, "Global Statistics," in Stanley M. Burgess and Gary B. McGee, eds., Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1988), 810–30.
5 Earhart's approach in Gedatsukai and Religion in Contemporary Japan was based on dissatisfaction with the sociological explanations that attributed the birth of New Religions primarily to social crisis and anomie. Following a critique of Western reductionistic accounts of New Religions, Earhart develops a model that draws attention to prior religious influences and the innovations brought about by founders. This framework provides a helpful corrective to approaches that ignore religious elements and attribute the emergence of New Religions to social dislocation or some form of deprivation. For another important discussion of the inadequacies of the "crisis approach" to New Religions, see Hardacre's Lay Buddhism in Modern Japan, 30–34.
6 Powles, "Foreign Missionaries and Japanese Culture in the Late Nineteenth Century," 17–18.
7 Powles points out, for example, that more tolerant or accommodating attitudes toward Japanese religion and culture were to be found in the Russian Orthodox and Anglican missionary traditions ("Foreign Missionaries and Japanese Culture in the Late Nineteenth Century," 14–28).
8 Joseph M. Kitagawa, "The Contemporary Religious Situation in Japan," Japanese Religions 2/2–3 (1961), 40–41.
9 [Complete works of Uchimura Kanzo *] (Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1981–1984) (hereafter CWUK), vol. 1, 159 (1886).
10 CWUK, vol. 29, 476–47 (1925–1926).
11 The Japanese terms Teshima uses here are gaikaku ( [Light of life].
12 CWUK, vol. 22, 233 (1915–1916).
13 [Fifty years in the faith] was first published in 1926. The headquarters of The Way (Tokyo: Dokai* Honbu) published a revised edition in 1989 to coincide with the fiftyyear memorial service of his death.
14 Information on Kawai Shinsui's life may be found in the study by [Kawai Shinsui Sensei at Gunze] (Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1931), and Kawai's own record, My Spiritual Experiences, trans. by Yoshinobu Kawai (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1970).
15 See Marius Jansen, ed., Changing Japanese Attitudes toward Modernization (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965), 5.
16 Jansen also makes the interesting observation that the revival of Confucianism in reaction to the West in the late Meiji period no longer symbolized Chinese tradition, but the best of native tradition:
The very enthusiasm of the Westernization mood provoked misgivings about the degree to which it was necessary to learn "the ways of Chou" and provided an opening for a return of Confucianists, who now appeared as defenders of the Japanese, and not the Chinese, tradition. Their spokesmen were numerous, but the common element was to be found in warnings that the native tradition ought not to be jettisoned so uncritically.
Changing Japanese Attitudes toward Modernization, 70.
17 Notto Thelle helpfully reminds us that this indigenous impulse "was not merely a result of antiWestern reaction, but sprang out of a deep concern for Christian propagation." Buddhism and Christianity in Japan, 174.
18 Earhart, Gedatsukai and Religion in Contemporary Japan, 236.
19 While these are the three major sources, Shimazono points out that elements of Shinto, mikkyo*, kakure nembutsu, Christianity, and spiritualism, have also been incorporated into various new religions (Salvation Religions in Contemporary Society, 55ff).
20 Admittedly, this distinction is often difficult to make due to the eclectic nature of religious belief and practice. Nevertheless, the category of "folk religion" is widely accepted in the world of Japanese religious scholarship. See for example, Hori, Folk Religion in Japan; Komoto * Mitsugu, [Folk religion in the modern city], in Omura* Eisho* and Nishiyama Shigeru, eds., The Religion of People Today; Miyake Hitoshi, "Folk Religion," in Noriyoshi Tamaru and David Reid, eds., Religion in Japanese Culture. In chapter seven, I consider in some detail the manner in which indigenous Christian groups have addressed folk religious concerns and the ancestor cult. For a discussion of the problematic nature of this distinction and an alternative conceptualization of religion in Japan in terms of "common religion," see the forthcoming book by Ian Reader and George J. Tanabe, Jr., Practically Religious: Worldly Benefits and the Common Religion of Japan (Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press).
21 The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, one of the few exceptions, does expect members to confess the Apostles' Creed.
22 The experiential orientation of missionaries from the Assemblies of God and Holiness church traditions is undeniable. For the first half century of Protestant mission work in Japan, however, there were no representatives from these Western church traditions.
23 Although Dunn's primary concern in this work is to identity the diverse streams within early Christianity, he does not deny that there are common or unifying elements across these traditions. See Unity and Diversity in the New Testament: An Inquiry into the Character of Earliest Christianity (London: SCM Press, 1990), 373–74; emphasis added.
24 Earhart, Gedatsukai and Religion in Contemporary Japan, 236.
25 Joachim Wach, Sociology of Religion (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1944), 133. Thomas F. O'Dea argued similarly:
From the unusual religious experiences of unusual people the founded religions emerge, translating and transforming the insights of founders into institutional structures. Thus there arise the formed and formulated entities of beliefsystems, systems of ritual and liturgy, and organization. It is important therefore especially in the study of the founded religions to begin with a phenomenological analysis of the religious experience as such, for out of it emerge the chief dimensions of religious institutions as well as their chief functional problems.
"Five Dilemmas in the Institutionalization of Religion," Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 1/1 (1961), 31. This concern has been raised again more recently in a number of areas. In the sociology of religion, for example, see Rodney Stark, "Normal Revelations: A Rational Model of 'Mystical Experiences'," in David G. Bromley, ed., Religion and the Social Order: New Developments in Theory and Research (Greenwich: JAI Press, 1991). This concern has also appeared in the study of the New Testament and early Christianity. Larry W Hurtado, for example, suggests:
Especially in the study of new religious movements and the development of religious innovations, such as early Christianity, greater attention should be given to the creative role of the religious experiences of founders and founding groups. . . . History, both ancient and more recent, affords us many examples of new religious movements often arising as an innovative reinterpretation of an established religious tradition, an innovation
flowing from an altered hermeneutical perspective provided by potent religious experiences of influential members and/or groups in the new movement.
One God, One Lord: Early Christian Devotion and Ancient Judaism (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1988), 126–27; emphasis added. Stevan L. Davies similarly argues that religious experience (pneumatology) preceded doctrine (Christology) in the early Christian movement. See his Jesus the Healer: Possession, Trance, and the Origins of Christianity (New York: Continuum, 1995).
26 See Max Weber, The Sociology of Religion, trans. Ephraim Fischoff (Boston: Beacon Press, 1963), 46.
27 Werner Stark, The Sociology of Religion: A Study of Christendom (New York: Fordham University Press, 1970), 4:84.
28 Anthony J. Blasi, Making Charisma: The Social Construction of Paul's Public Image (New Brunswick, New Jersey: Transaction Publishers, 1991), 14–15.
29 Fujii Masao, "Founder Worship in Kamakura Buddhism," in George A. DeVos and Takao Sofue, eds., Religion and the Family in East Asia (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984), 156.
30 Hoshino Eiki, "A Pillar of Japanese Buddhism: Founder Belief," Journal of Oriental Studies 26 (1987), 80. For an interesting discussion of the shift from "institutional charisma" to "personal charisma" in Japanese Buddhism, see Mori Ryukichi *, [Charisma] (Tokyo: Shunjusha*, 1995), 32–43.
31 For a more detailed treatment, see [Founders and their surroundings], edited by the Shukyo* Shakaigaku Kenkyukai* (Tokyo: Yuyama*, 1987), 23–26.
32 Summarizing the Weberian perspective on charisma, Robin Theobald notes:
Charismatic authority involves a relationship between a group of followers or disciples and a leader to whom they attribute extraordinary qualities. The leader has a mission or message which in some way harmonizes with the basic needs, hopes, desires, ambitions or fears of his followers. However, during the early stages of charismatic upsurge leader and message are inseparable as the prime orientation of the followers is to the person of the leader himself.
"The Role of Charisma in the Development of Social Movements," Archives de Sciences Sociales des Religions 49/1 (1980), 85.
33 [The mysteries of Galatians] (Fujiyoshida: Kirisuto Shinshu* Kyodan* Jimukyoku Shuppanbu, 1965). This volume is based on lectures Kawai gave at the Gunze Silk Factory during 1928 and 1929.
34 Kawai Shinsui, My Spiritual Experiences, trans. by Yoshinobu Kawai (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1970), 12. In this spiritual autobiography, Kawai records numerous revelatory experiences throughout his life at Mt. Fuji and elsewhere.
35 In his study of Ellen G. White and Seventhday Adventism cited above, Robin Theobald makes a similar observation:
Although it is true that Mrs. White did not produce her own "Bible," in reality it seems to be the case that her writings are treated on a par with the Bible. In sermons and in Bible study meetings passages from the Bible and Mrs. White's interpretation of them are often mingled in a manner which makes them virtually indistinguishable. "The Role of Charisma in the Development of Social Movements," 98.
36 Nakamura Hajime, The Ways of Thinking of Eastern Peoples: India, China, Tibet, Japan, ed. by Philip P. Wiener (Honolulu: EastWest Center Press, 1964), 454; emphasis added.
37 Minor founders in Japanese movements are prime examples of what Irving Hexham and Karla Poewe have recently referred to as "iconic leadership," particularly important in various African independent churches and other new religious movements (see New Religions as Global Cultures, 55).
38 CWUK, vol. 25, 592 (1920); emphasis added. Some years earlier, Uchimura wrote about the importance of direct religious experience as follows:
They call us mystics because we do not walk with them, and work like them; because we trust in the invisible Spirit, and not in visible institutions, organizations, "Christian movements," and those things. Mystics? Yes, we rather like the name. Was not Luther a mystic, and Paul the greatest of all mystics? "And it shall come to pass in the last days, saith God, I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh; and your sons and daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams"; i e., they shall all be mystics. Why then should we not attempt to be mystics ourselves, and be unlike unmystical, practical, political, worldserving modern Christians? CWUK, vol. 20, 274 (1914).
39 For a helpful discussion of Uchimura's "charisma" and emphasis on "returning to the original Scriptures," see [The structure of modern culture: Modern culture and Christianity] (Tokyo: Chikuma Shobo *, 1972), 301–2.
40 Teshima Ikuro*, the founder of the Original Gospel movement, left the Nonchurch movement because it lacked the power of the Holy Spirit and miracles of New Testament Christianity. Although the movement initially represented a return to Biblical Christianity, Teshima thought that it had stopped short and become another conceptual or intellectual expression like the Western churches. What is missing in both established churches and Mukyokai* is the living Christ and power of the Holy Spirit. See [The collected works of Koike Tatsuo] (Tokyo: Nihon Kirisuto Shodan*, 1982), 200.
41 See Kawai, My Spiritual Experiences, 4, 22; and [Kawai Shinsui's lectures on the Analects of Confucius], ed. by E. Yasui (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan*
Shuppanbu, 1970). Kawai is not alone in his development of a "fulfillment" theology in the Japanese context. Teshima Ikuro * provides a similar interpretation of Asian religions and various Buddhist saints. In fact, Part II of a volume of his collected writings is entitled "the Old Testament of Japan" and explores the teachings and experiences of various religious leaders (such as Kobo* Daishi, Honen*, Nichiren, and Hakuin) who have shaped the Japanese religious tradition (Teshima, The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 55). Teshima finds in these Asian traditions numerous experiences, teachings, and practices that can be usefully incorporated in the development of a Japanese Christian spirituality.
42 See one of the early issues of Dokai*'s magazine [The way] 7 (November 1908).
43 See [A first collection of Dokai poems] (Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1929, first ed.).
44 [The Dokai bible] (Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1928).
45 See (1772–1859).
46 This viewpoint is expressed in a number of Teshima Ikuro's writings. For one example, see The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 51–52.
47 In the case of the Okinawa Christian Gospel movement, exorcism receives a particular emphasis. See the helpful study by Ikegami, A Stage for Demons and the Holy Spirit, 78–105.
Chapter 4—
The Fountainhead of Japanese Christianity Revisited
1 Complete Works of Uchimura Kanzo*, vol. 30, 192 (1926–1927); hereafter referred to as CWUK, with volume number, page, and original year of publication. Emphasis added.
2 F. F. Bruce, Tradition Old and New (Exetor: Paternoster Press, 1970), 15.
3 [An inventory of Imai Hall Book and Resource Center holdings] (Tokyo: Imai Kan Seisho Kodo* Kyoyukai*, 1990).
4 Mukyokai* leader Yanaihara Tadao, for example, emphasizes this point in his preface to Emil Brunner's [The Nonchurch movement in Japan]
(Tokyo: Kishinsha, 1959), an article translated by Yanaihara Tadao and Takahashi Saburo* from the German original "Die Christliche NichtKircheBewegung in
Japan," Evagelische Theologie 4, 1959. See also Emil Brunner, "A Unique Mission in Japan: The Mukyokai ('NonChurch') Movement in Japan," in Walter
Leibrecht, ed., Religion and Culture: Essays in Honor of Paul Tillich (London: SCM Press, 1959). In an effort to alleviate some of the tension between Mukyokai and the established churches, Brunner in 1954 even addressed the General Assembly of the United Church of Christ in Japan, the largest Protestant denomination, and appealed for mutual respect and recognition. Brunner insisted that "both believe in Jesus Christ, the Son of God, as our only Savior. The Body of Christ is not limited to the Church. The Mukyokai people are right in saying, 'If ecclesia is translated by "church," then there is ''salvation outside the church".' The Lord of the
Church is free to use other means than those of the institutional church to draw people to Himself and make them disciples. But the spirit of Christ
also does use the churches and their sacraments for His work and purpose." Emil Brunner, "Ecclesia and Evangelism," Japan Christian Quarterly 21 (April 1955), 154–55.
5 Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way, vii.
6 "The World and Japan in Young Uchimura Kanzo *'s Work," KBS Bulletin on Japanese Culture, No. 115 (August–September) 1972, 1–28. Ohara Shin makes a similar observation, writing that "it is ironic that Uchimura and his friends in Sapporo, usually called the 'Sapporo Band,' were in the 1870s and 1880s among the most Americanized people in Japan. Most of their schooling was in English, and their correspondence, except with their parents, was all written in English. Yet it was from this group that a man like Uchimura could emerge to call for a Christian faith adapted to Japan without any formal institutions"(see his essay, "The Thought of Uchimura Kanzo and Its Relevance to Contemporary American Religion," in Ray A. Moore, ed., Culture and Religion in JapaneseAmerican Relations: Essays on Uchimura Kanzo, 1861–1930 (Ann Arbor: Center for Japanese Studies, The University of Michigan, 1981), 116.
7 Although Uchimura did not have a direct relationship with Clark, he nevertheless felt indebted to him and expressed a deep appreciation and respect for his witness to the Christian faith. See Uchimura's tribute, "The Missionary Work of William S. Clark, Ph.D., LL.D., ExPresident of Amherst Agricultural College" (originally published in The Christian Union, April 22, 1886; see CWUK, vol. 1, 136–41 (1877–1892). The full text of the "Covenant of Believers in Jesus" is also recorded in this article.
8 CWUK, vol. 3, 117 (1894–1896).
9 CWUK, vol. 29, 429–30 (1925–1926).
10 CWUK, vol. 3, 131 (1894–1896).
11 On the relationship between Mukyokai* and Quakerism, see [Proceedings of the 1985 Nonchurch summer colloquium] (Tokyo: Mukyokai Kaki Konwakai Jimukyoku, 1986), 27–35.
12 CWUK, vol. 31, 132 (1928).
13 Paul Peachey, "MukyokaiShugi: A Modern Attempt to Complete the Reformation," The Mennonite Quarterly Review 35 (Jan. 1961), 71.
14 See Hiroshi Miura, The Life and Thought of Kanzo Uchimura, 1861–1930 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1996), 43–49, regarding Uchimura's changing views on Japan's military involvements in Asia and his eventual conversion to pacifism.
15 Regarding Uchimura's involvement in the "Second Coming of Christ" movement, see [The life of Uchimura Kanzo] (Tokyo: PHP, 1992), 328–29.
16 Uchimura writes that this doctrine was "very unpopular" among Japanese churches and notes that he was "attacked and adversely criticized" by such wellknown
Christian leaders as Rev. Danjo* Ebina (Congregationalist), Dr. T. Sugiura (Episcopalian), Rev. K. Shiraishi (Methodist), Rev. T. Tominaga (Presbyterian), and Rev.
S. Uchigasaki (Unitarian). Uchimura
records, for example, that "Rev. Danjo * Ebina, the leader of Congregational Churches in Japan, characterizes belief in the Second Coming of Christ as 'destructive to national existence, unreasonable, unscientific, unbiblical and unchristian"' (CWUK, vol. 24, 486 [1918–1919]).
17 This expression is borrowed from Kwame Bediako's Christianity in Africa: The Renewal of a NonWestern Religion (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press/Orbis Books, 1995), 75–87.
18 CWUK, vol. 29, 425 (1925–1926).
19 CWUK, vol. 29, 456 (1925–1926); emphasis added.
20 CWUK, vol. 3, 10 (1894–1896).
21 CWUK, vol. 22, 161 (1915–1916). A decade later, Uchimura similarly wrote: "As far as Japan is concerned, there are many things in Bushido* and Buddhism which come very close to Christianity; and by judicious use of these, preaching Christianity is made very much easier. There is no need of presenting Christianity as a strange religion to my countrymen." CWUK, vol. 29, 454 (1925–1926).
22 CWUK, vol. 25, 362 (1920).
23 See Uchimura's discussion of this ideal in his chapter on "Nakae Toju*: A Village Teacher," CWUK, vol. 3, 249–67 (1894–1896). The samurai background and Confucian orientation of Uchimura and many other Japanese Christians in Meiji Japan has been noted in a number of studies. Sumiya Mikio, for example, points out that many of the early Japanese Christians came from the samurai class and had a strong background in Confucianism. Of the first eleven members of the Yokohama Band (Kokai*, ). He notes that their NeoConfucian education served as a preparation for their conversion to Christianity as well as influenced their subsequent interpretation of the faith (Christianity and the Formation of Modern Japan, 15, 26–28). In addition to the importance of the Confucian background, Kudo* Eiichi draws attention to the downward mobility of many from the samurai class during this period as a significant factor in their conversion to Christianity (Studies in the Economic History of apanese Christian Society, 37–44).
24 One of the problems associated with this group occurred when Uchimura proposed that the Apostles' Creed be used as the confession of faith that each member of the Brotherhood be required to sign. This proposal generated a critical reaction, with Uchimura being accused of taking a "backward step" into Western ecclesiasticism. Regarding these early organizational efforts, see William H. H. Norman, "Kanzo Uchimura: Founder of the Nonchurch Movement," Contemporary Religions in Japan 5/1 (1964), 34–44.
25 The contrast between ordained clergy in Christian denominations and charismatic leadership in Mukyokai* is elaborated by [The structure of modern culture: Modern culture and Christianity] (Tokyo: Chikuma Shobo*, 1972), 302–3.
26 Ohara Shin, "The Thought of Uchimura Kanzo* and Its Relevance to Contemporary American Religion," in Ray A. Moore, Culture and Religion in JapaneseAmerican Relations, 126.
27 "Mukyokai *: Churchless Christians in Japan," Japan Christian Quarterly 52/3 (1986), 172.
28 Regarding Uchimura's conservative Confucian orientation with regard to women, see Ohara, The Life of Uchimura Kanzo*, 15–18, 47, 112. According to Ohara, Uchimura's Confucian understanding of the place of women was a source of conflict with the churches and mission schools. His first wife, Asada Take, with whom he had such difficulty, was educated at Doshisha* in Kyoto and Kyoritsu* Jogakko* in Yokohama. As an intellectual fluent in English, she was a new type of woman and rather distant from Uchimura's Confucian ideal.
29 Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way, 90–93. In a 1926 essay Uchimura explained that Christianity involved both "other power" and "selfpower" (CWUK, vol. 29, 249–53, 1925–1926). When compared with the views of Matsumura Kaiseki and Kawai Shinsui, the focus of the following chapter, it will become clear that faith and dependence on "other power" is the dominant emphasis in Uchimura's interpretation.
30 CWUK, vol. 29, 521 (1925–1926).
31 At the first memorial following Uchimura's death in 1930, for example, [A collection of Uchimura Kanzo* memorial lectures on Christianity] (Tokyo: Kirisutokyo* Yakan Koza* Shuppanbu, 1972), 222–25.
32 See, for example, I Timothy 3 , 5, and Titus, and I Peter 5. For helpful discussion of early institutionalization reflected in the New Testament canon, see Raymond E. Brown, The Churches the Apostles Left Behind (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1984), 31–46, and James D. G. Dunn's Unity and Diversity in the New Testament: An Inquiry into the Character of Earliest Christianity (London: SCM Press, 1990 edition; originally published in 1977), 344, 359–66.
Chapter 5—
Christianity as a Path of SelfCultivation
1 For a concise overview of Matsumura's life and work see [The universe] and widely known for his controversial book in English, The Japanese Bride (Harper and Brothers, 1893), which described various marriage customs and the generally low status of women in Japanese society.
2 See vol. 45 [The library of modern literature] (Tokyo: Showa* Joshi Daigaku Kindai Bungaku Kenkyushitsu*, 1977), 209–68.
3 References to Matsumura's wider influence on new religious movements may be found in Inoue et al., Dictionary of New Religions, 853, 896.
4 Ouchi * Saburo*, 8 (1977), 70–71.
5 This is recounted in Matsumura's [Fifty years in the faith] (Tokyo: Dokai* Jimusho, 1929, 1989 reprint edition), 34–35. Elsewhere he mentions many other problems, so this particular crisis was probably just the "last straw" for Matsumura.
6 For a helpful discussion of the impact of Western science and the theory of evolution on Japanese Protestant leaders in Meiji Japan, including Matsumura Kaiseki, see Helen Ballhatchet, "The Religion of the West versus the Science of the West: The Evolution Controversy in Late Nineteenth Century Japan," in Breen and Williams, eds., Japan and Christianity, 107–21.
7 A concise introduction to Kanamori's views and the debate surrounding the New Theology in Japan may be found in Akio Dohi's, "The First Generation: Christian
Leaders in the First Period," in Yasuo Furuya, ed. and trans., A History of Japanese Theology, 21–34. Dohi summarized Kanamori's basic position as follows:
"Although there are various religions in Japan, a religion of truth and life will triumph. However, one religion or denomination cannot monopolize the truth of religion. So far as Christianity is concerned, the Bible's miracle stories, the prohibition of smoking and drinking, the imported denominational disputes from foreign countries, and the ritualization of Christianity are stumbling blocks for Japanese people" (22).
8 Matsumura uses the term kaikakuteki kirisutokyo* ( [A critique of religions] (Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1929), 64. This is, of course, in stark contrast to what the mission churches meant by "reformed," i.e., a recovery of"Biblical" Christianity.
9 In the following synopsis I have relied heavily on the following works: Matsumura's religious autobiography, Fifty Years in the Faith; an extensive review of articles in the magazine [The Dokai faith] (Tokyo: Toho* Shoin), 1934.
10 The Way 7 (November 1908).
11 Suzuki, Studies of Trends in Meiji Religious Thought, 137.
12 Matsumura, A Critique of Religions, 61–66. 13 Matsumura, A Critique of Religions, 57–67.
14 Matsumura explains that the remarkable aspects of Jesus are his utter dependence on God the Father and his submission of all to the will of God. But it is a fact that Jesus was only a young man of thirty years, and in terms of knowledge, personality, insight, was not yet fully developed. He also did not have the knowledge of evolution and other facts, that have been
discovered in our time. He also showed signs of weakness in his prayer in Gethsemane, asking the Father to take "this cup from him." His "remuneration morality" ( [The Dokai * bible] (Tokyo: Dokai Jimusho, 1928), 25.
15 See chapter three (48–51) for a brief discussion of Matsumura's openended canon and critical edition of the Bible.
16 There have been numerous printings of this booklet. I am using the postwar edition (Tokyo: Dokai Shuppanbu, 1977).
17 Matsumura claims that the faith of The Way can be distinguished from traditional Christianity because it combines faith in the OtherPower of God with human effort and selfdiscipline; see New Religion, 82, 354–55.
18 The Christian theology of atonement, Matsumura argues, is something the Apostle Paul elaborated and cannot be found in the original teaching of Jesus. In this parable, no sacrificial death is required (see Matsumura, The Dokai Bible, 75).
19 For helpful background on Yomeigaku* in the Tokugawa period and its influence on many Protestant leaders in the Meiji period, see [Dictionary of Japanese religion] (Tokyo: Kobundo*, 1994 abridged version,) 499–500; Jan Van Bremen, "NeoConfucianism in Japan: Heritage and Vista," Senri Ethnological Studies 29 (1990) 75–86; and Sumiya, Christianity and the Formation of Modern Japan, 26–28.
20 See The Faith of The Way, 32.
21 Dokai Guidebook.
22 These ritual adaptations and guidelines for corporate and individual worship are described in The Faith of The Way, 14–23.
23 This appears in an article by Matsumura Kichisuke in The Way, 567–74 (1959), 7.
24 For details regarding these publications see the bibliographical guide to Kawai's works in the appendix.
25 Kawai's mentor, Oshikawa Masayoshi, was an important Christian figure during the Meiji period. Oshikawa (1851–1928) was the third son of a samurai family in Matsuyama. At the age of nineteen he went to Tokyo to study and eventually entered Yokohama Eigakko* run by Ballagh and Brown. Under their influence he professed the Christian faith and was baptized by Ballagh in 1872. With these missionaries and other early Japanese Christians he helped organize the first church in
Yokohama. Following nine years of evangelistic work in Niigata, he moved to Sendai to assist W E. Hoy in the establishment of Sendai The
ological School ( ), which later became Tohoku * Gakuin. He left Tohoku Gakuin in 1901 to become involved in politics, but was not very successful. The collection of correspondence (1026 letters) between Kawai and Oshikawa from 1893 to 1929 reveals their extremely close relationship (see [The samurai who became a Christian: Oshikawa Masayoshi] (Tokyo: Kindai Bungeisha, 1991).
26 See chapter three (38–39) for additional biographical details and discussion of Kawai's break with the mission churches.
27 Here I am quoting from My Spiritual Experiences, trans. Kawai Yoshinobu (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1970), 13, the English translation of Kawai's [The sincerity of God and my experiences] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1956).
28 My Spiritual Experiences, 14. 29 My Spiritual Experiences, 15.
30 Kawai Shinsui, [Lectures on the perfect teaching] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Shuppanbu, 1977), 1. This volume is based on lectures Kawai gave at Gunze Silk Company between 1925 and 1932, while he was director of education.
31 My Spiritual Experiences, 22–23; emphasis added. Kawai's communion with the spirit world was apparently not limited to his encounter with Confucius. According to one informant, Kawai was also involved in communication with other spirits through the medium (reinosha* ).
32 The Japanese expression here , appears repeatedly in various publications of Christ Heart Church.
33 In his lectures on Galatians, Kawai points out that people often misunderstand him and think he teaches that all religions are the same because he so often quotes from Buddhist and Confucian sources. While they are not the same, Kawai maintains that they do share a great deal in common ( [The mysteries of Galatians] (Fujiyoshida: Kirisuto Shin Shudan Jimukyoku Shuppanbu, 1965), 21–22. This volume is based on lectures Kawai gave during morning worship services at Gunze (1928–1929).
34 In addition to Kawai Shinsui's writings, in this section I am particularly indebted to helpful discussions and interviews with Kawai Hideo, the founder's grandson and current head of Christ Heart Church.
35 Kawai, Lectures on the Perfect Teaching, 232.
36 Kawai, Lectures on the Perfect Teaching, 108 and 222.
37 Here, Kawai's interpretation departs from the Protestant tradition and more closely resembles the Catholic teaching regarding purgatory.
38 The Japanese term here is [Rules for believers] (Fujiyoshida: Kirisuto Shinshu * Kyodan* Jimukyoku Shuppanbu, 1940). The same expression reappears in many of his lectures and writings.
39 In a lecture on the "Sermon on the Mount" (19 March 1961) Kawai explained that he could not accept the recent German theology that rejected the divinity of Christ and that he continued to follow the incarnational theology (i.e., "the Word became flesh") found in the Gospel of John. This lecture was republished in the church's magazine [The mind of Christ] 191 (1993), 10–11.
40 This appears in an explanatory note in his A Eulogy on Jesus Christ, trans. Kawai Yoshinobu (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1961), 68–69.
41 [A memorandum of talks by Sangetsu Kawai Shinsui] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shin Shudan* Shuppanbu, 1969), 154. This is a collection of lectures, sermons, and talks given by Kawai at various locations from 1940 to 1962.
42 The locus classicus for this model of discipleship in the New Testament is Luke 6:40: "A disciple is not above the teacher, but everyone who is fully qualified will be like the teacher."
43 While the Pure Land tradition has a negative connotation for Kawai, it is interesting to recall here that this was the Japanese Buddhist tradition for which Uchimura Kanzo* had such high regard (see chapter four, 64–66).
44 See Yasui, A Memorandum of Talks by Sangetsu Kawai Shinsui, 198.
45 In the introduction to [A eulogy on Jesus Christ] (Tokyo: Kobundo, 1927), for example, Kawai recounts how moved he was by a letter written by
Francis Xavier to one of his disciples, prior to his departure for mission work in Japan in the sixteenth century. In this letter Xavier instructed his disciple to continue ascetic practices and to meditate every morning on the life of Christ. Kawai explains that he wrote A Eulogy on Jesus Christ so that Japanese Christians could pursue a similar path of discipline.
46 The English translation of the creed appears in Kawai's My Spiritual Experiences, 30; emphasis added.
47 This is referred to as his [Inaugural proclamation] and recorded in A Eulogy on Jesus Christ (1927), 23, 236–38.
48 Kawai claims that it is the first time in the history of Christianity that this kind of composition on the life of Christ has been attempted. He notes, however, that his work resembles a similar text on Asvagosa*'s life of Buddha, Buddhacarita, though the latter is much longer and reads more like a biography (see the introduction to the 1927 version, 9).
49 The following synopsis is based on a more detailed discussion of the meaning of these vows found in Kawai's lecture, [The Lord's prayer and the seven great vows], given on 3 April 1960, and reprinted in The Mind of Christ 174 (1990), 1–14. The earliest version of the Vows was published in 1939 and was entitled the "Six Great Vows"
( ). It did not include the fifth vow of the final version published in 1951, which is recognized as a part of the official church canon today.
50 The original Buddhist vows may be given as: (1) I vow to save boundless numbers of sentient beings; (2) I vow to extinguish innumerable evil passions; (3) I vow to study all the inexhaustible Buddhist teachings; and (4) I vow to attain the supreme Buddha way. Cited from Hisao Inagaki, A Dictionary of apanese Buddhist Terms (Kyoto: Nagata Bunshodo *, 1992), 522.
51 Kawai also claims that the Seven Great Vows and Prayers supersede even the Lord's Prayer recorded in the New Testament. This is because, unlike the Lord's Prayer, the Vows include the additional commitment to love and respect God's Son.
52 This is an adaptation of the first of the four vows of the Buddha (see note 50 above), to save boundless numbers of sentient beings. Kawai explains that he added the word , the whole universe, to this vow in order to incorporate the Apostle Paul's teaching that all of creation groans and waits for the appearance of the children of God (Romans 8:19–21). Kawai explains that this vow includes the intention to work for the salvation of all sentient beings, but at the same time to seek to preserve and cultivate all created things, such as trees, plants, water, and mountains.
53 The following summary draws on Kawai Shinsui's writings as well as sermons, lectures, interviews, and instruction by Kawai Hideo, the grandson of the founder and current head of Christ Heart Church.
54 At a training session during the annual retreat several years ago, Kawai Hideo distributed a handout with the founder's teaching regarding meditation ( ) and provided the following instructions:
At the initial stage of meditation it is best to close one's eyes, since external things easily lead to distraction. After some practice, one should be able to meditate with one's eyes open without being distracted. As the focus ( ) to think about being a "living sacrifice"; you simply are a living sacrifice. If one is sitting in meditation on a chair, consider the chair to be the altar and one's body the offering to God. Through this process one will become quiet and pure. In time this will lead to the experience of union with God. One should not be preoccupied with achieving this experience of satori, for God will give it to you when the time is right; that is, when you have prepared an appropriate place, that is, a heart of sincerity and good faith. (Author's fieldnotes)
55 See his lecture, "My Spiritual Experiences," given in Sendai on 1 October 1961, and recently republished in the Christ Heart Church magazine The Mind of Christ 191 (1995), 24.
56 Kawai, Lectures on the Perfect Teaching, 100.
57 Takahashi's own account of her pilgrimage was published after her death as [Calling on the immeasurable goodness of God] (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1952).
In a lengthy postscript (341–460), Kawai Shinsui explains that the way of Christ includes feminine beauty and virtue ( ), which Takahashi fully expressed in her life of faith.
58 My guess is that the ritual places so much emphasis on OtherPower that its observance would distract members from the primary task of selfcultivation.
59 Kyokenjutsu * training began as a part of the educational program for both men and women at Gunze Silk Factory. It was carried over into Christ Heart Church as another helpful discipline for training and exercising the body. Kawai's brother was primarily responsible for this aspect of the movement, and he taught his own particular type of kyokenjutsu, known as Hidashiki kyokenjutsu , using his adopted name. It is not nearly as common today, but instruction for men is still provided at the annual retreat and training program.
60 The Shingaku movement was founded by Ishida Baigan (1685–1744) and mobilized into a nationwide movement by his disciple and successor, Teshima Toan*
(1718–1786). For helpful resources on this movement, see Robert Bellah's wellknown study, Tokugawa Religion: The Values of PreIndustrial Japan (Boston: Beacon Press, 1970), and the more recent study by Janine Anderson Sawada, Confucian Values and Popular Zen: Sekimon Shingaku in EighteenthCentury Japan (Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press, 1993).
61 See Shimazono, Salvation Religions in Contemporary Society, 55–76, and Hardacre, Kurozumikyo* and the New Religions of Japan, 16–31.
Chapter 6—
Japanese Versions of Apostolic Christianity
1 Ikado Fujio's analysis of the education levels and social status of Protestant church members has shown that this stereotype is not without foundation; see his Religion in a Secular Society, esp. 292ff.
2 Tetsunao Yamamori, Church Growth in Japan, 53.
3 Ariga Tetsutaro*, "From Confucius to Christ: A Feature of Early Protestantism in Japan," Japanese Religions 2/2–3 (1961), 11.
4 Christianity: The Japanese Way, 208.
5 [Led by the Spirit: A history of the first thirty years] (Tokyo: Japan Assemblies of God, 1979), 23.
6 This is mentioned in Murai Jun's sermon on the Lord's Supper preached at Nakai Spirit of Jesus Church on 20 August 1962.
7 In his study of Pentecostal movements in China, Daniel H. Bays notes that a 1919 doctrinal statement of the True Jesus Church defined its beliefs, practices, and membership requirements as follows:
Chapter 7—
1. receive full immersion facedown baptism;
2. seek the baptism of the Holy Spirit, with speaking in tongues as evidence;
3. keep Saturday as the Sabbath for worship;
4. seek the power of healing and of exorcising demons;
5. in communion break the bread, not cut it;
6. implement the sacrament of footwashing among church members;
7. have ordination by the laying on of hands;
8. have no time limit for Sabbath worship;
9. all have the right to speak during services;
10. all be permitted to pray aloud during services;
11. seek revelation of the Holy Spirit in choosing overseers (jiandu, "bishops"), elders (zhanglao), and deacons (zhishi); 12. if evangelists, not receive a set salary;
13. devote their heart, spirit, and livelihood to the Lord, and give at least 10 percent of their income.
In a subsequent statement, the True Jesus Church also instructed other churches to purify themselves by teaching the unitary and undivided (shu'i wu'er) "true God" and to "baptize only in the name of Jesus," rather than persisting in teaching the manmade doctrine of the Trinity (sanwei iti). Murai's adoption of several of these doctrines and practices led to his separation from the Japan Bible Church upon his return to Japan. Cited from Daniel H. Bays, "Indigenous Protestant Churches in China, 1900–1937: A Pentecostal Case Study," in Steven Kaplan, ed., Indigenous Responses to Western Christianity (New York: New York University Press, 1995), 134–35. For additional background on the True Jesus Church, see Murray A. Rubinstein, The Protestant Community on Modern Taiwan: Mission, Seminary, and Church (New York: M. E. Sharpe, 1991).
8 For one treatment of the "Jesusonly" unitarianism within North American Pentecostalism, see Thomas A. Robinson, "The Conservative Nature of Dissent in Early Pentecostalism: A Study of Charles F. Parham, the Founder of the Pentecostal Movement," in Malcolm R. Greenshields and Thomas A. Robinson, eds., Orthodoxy and Heresy in Religious Movements: Discipline and Dissent (Lewiston: Edwin Mellen Press, 1992), 134–61.
9 Bays, "Indigenous Protestant Churches in China, 1900–1937: A Pentecostal Case Study," 137–38.
10 C. Norman Kraus, "Dispensationalism," in Mark A. Noll and Nathan O. Hatch, eds., Eerdmans Handbook to Christianity (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1983), 327–30.
11 J. D. Douglas, ed., The New International Dictionary of the Christian Church (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Corporation, 1974), 103.
12 While adult converts are usually baptized immediately, the church does practice infant baptism for the children of members. This practice probably reflects Murai's own early background in the Methodist Church. Unlike other churches, however, there is no special education for confirmation of faith later in life. It is simply expected that children will eventually receive spirit baptism and speak in tongues as they grow up in the church.
13 In their forthcoming book, Practically Religious: Worldly Benefits and the Common Religion of apan (Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press), Ian Reader and George J. Tanabe, Jr., suggest that one of the reasons that the Christian churches have failed to make much headway in Japanese society is their failure to take seriously the "common religion of Japan." The Spirit of Jesus Church is clearly one exception to this general pattern. I am indebted to Ian Reader for sharing portions of this manuscript with me prior to publication.
14 The Spirit of Jesus hymnbook, [Spirit hymns], also reflects this concern for healing and various miracles (see hymns 18 and 28).
15 Here I am indebted to Anzai Shin's informative analysis of the Spirit of Jesus Church in Okinawa in his The Acceptance of Christianity in the Southern Islands, 1984, 125–26.
16 One pastor reminded me in an interview that it was Judas, the "treasurer," who caused Jesus so much trouble. In other words, it is best not to entrust laity with heavy responsibility in financial matters.
17 The influence of Jewish tradition is also apparent in other areas of the Spirit of Jesus Church. For example, this church observes the Sabbath as the primary day of worship (although they still hold meetings on Sunday). Also, "unleavened bread" must be prepared for the sacrament of the Lord's Supper.
18 See his [Religion and history] (Tokyo: Yamamoto Shoten, 1977), 42.
19 Yamamori, Church Growth in Japan, 118–19; I have also relied on Yamamori for a synopsis of Holiness Church growth (especially 116–22). Apparently, Nakada's interpretation of various passages in the Bible "included the idea that the Japanese people were probably a part of one of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel. Thus at the Second Coming of Christ the Japanese, too, would enter into the same blessings promised to the Israelites with the restoration of their nation." See John Jennings Merwin, "The Oriental Missionary Society Holiness Church in Japan, 1901–1983" (Pasadena: Doctor of Missiology Thesis, School of World Mission, Fuller Theological Seminary, 1983), 379.
20 This is recorded in the volume of Otsuki *'s recollections, (Kyoto: Sei Iesu Kai Logos Sha, 1996), 66–67.
21 In the following account, I am drawing on several interviews with Father Otsuki, selections from his Gensenshu* (a seventeenvolume collection of his writings, sermons, and lectures) and various church publications.
22 Otsuki, for example, refers to Isaiah's vision of God in the temple: "And I said: 'Woe is me! I am lost, for I am a man of unclean lips, and I live among a people of unclean lips; yet my eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts!' Then one of the seraphs flew to me, holding a live coal that had been taken from the altar with a pair of tongs. The seraph touched my mouth with it and said: 'Now that this has touched your lips, your guilt has departed and your sin is blotted out'"(Isaiah 6:5–7). Another passage he found expressive of his own experience is recorded in Ezekiel: ". . . the heavens were opened, and I saw visions of God" (1:1). "So I opened my mouth, and he gave me the scroll to eat. He said to me, Mortal, eat this scroll that I give you and fill your stomach with it. Then I ate it; and in my mouth it was as sweet as honey" (3:2–3). For more details, see his account in The Tracks of Revival, 109–13.
23 [To change and become a new person], Logos 138 (1996), 27.
24 While the founder frequently presents additional revelations from God, some guidelines are observed in order to prevent the movement from falling into heresy. Both clergy and laity who claim to have received a special revelation from God must present it for considera
tion to the leadership of the church ( [Regulations of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus] (Kyoto: Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, 1996), 5.
25 Holy Ecclesia of Jesus publications suggest that the Apostle Thomas spread "authentic" Christianity (i.e., "calling on the name") to the East and may have influenced the development of a new form of Buddhism in China, the Amida faith, which eventually became a popular form of Buddhism in Japan. See, for example, [The grapevine: a compilation for evangelistic use] (Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 1991), 105.
26 The basic expression used to refer to this conversion and lifetransforming experience is [Serving the word: An introduction to Biblical doctrine, vol. 1, Doctrine of Holy Scripture] (Kyoto: Logos Publishing, 1974), 5–11; The Grapevine, 78–108.
27 For background on the early development of nembutsu in Japan, see Hori Ichiro, Folk Religion in Japan, 73–74, and chapter three.
28 Otsuki * grew up in this religious atmosphere and recalls that on the occasion of his mother's untimely death his father sat quietly beside her chanting Namu Amida Butsu (see The Tracks of Revival, 49).
29 William J. Jackson, "NameDevotion in Indian Religions and Kaveri Delta Namasiddhanta," Journal for the Study of Religions 7/2 (1994), 33, 42; emphasis added.
30 For a concise statement on the centrality of healing to the mission of the church, see [Complete salvation and healing in the name of Jesus], Logos 138 (1996), 1–5. It should be noted that the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus distances itself from Pentecostal movements and does not recognize speaking in tongues as a valid manifestation of spirit baptism.
31 During the Tokugawa period, the kakure kirishitan ("hidden Christians") resorted to concealing Christian symbols in statues of Buddha in order surreptitiously to continue practicing the foreign religion proscribed by the authorities. As Neil S. Fujita explains: "engravings of the Madonna with the baby Jesus were modified to look like a representation of Kannon (the embodiment of Buddha's mercy) holding a child. The sign of the cross was often concealed at the back of a Buddha's statue." Japan's Encounter with Christianity: The Catholic Mission in PreModern Japan (New York: Paulist Press, 1991), 238. It was one of these statues that was apparently discovered at the site of this healing spring.
32 A testimonial by one member who followed these methods and experienced healing is recorded in the church paper, The Grapevine 453 (11 November 1993). In addition to the testimonial, this issue also provides a brief description of the miraculous spring and compares it to a similar manifestation in the nineteenth century in Lourdes, France.
33 Otsuki writes that he abandoned his mistaken and warped view of the Roman Catholic tradition after reading the diary of Ignatius of Loyola, whom he came to regard as a great spiritual leader. This led him to reconsider many aspects of the Catholic tradition that have been
disregarded by most Protestants, including the saints and mystics as models for Christian spirituality and the important role of Mary in salvation history. Otsuki *'s new appreciation of Roman Catholic spirituality is expressed most clearly in his recent collection of meditations [Meditations on the Holy Land] (Kyoto: Sei Iesu Kai Logos Sha, 1993).
34 While all followers are encouraged to prepare a written confession, it is not something that is rigorously checked before individuals are allowed to participate in the communion service. Individual pastors submit their written confessions to the shiboku ( , bishop or president of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus).
35 While Father Otsuki is still living and recognized as the spiritual guide of the movement, he no longer holds an official position in the church. His son, Otsuki Masaru, now holds the highest office of shiboku (see note 34 above). Ordained clergy are responsible for the selection of the bishop at the general meeting. At this meeting twentyfour ministers are also elected to serve as representatives on the church council. This council then selects five ministers to serve as elders, who are responsible for ministerial assignments for the entire church. The bishop, nevertheless, continues to exercise considerable authority. Clergy are expected to receive the bishop's approval before distributing any publications that have not already received the church's endorsement. Likewise, the bishop's prior approval is required for all special events sponsored by the ministers of local churches, such as films or guest speakers invited from outside the church.
Ordained leaders are referred to as clergy ( seikyoshi*, women), all of whom are graduates of Logos Theological Seminary. Each May the church holds a threeday seminar for members seriously considering entering the ministry. The minimum requirements for applying to the program for ministerial preparation are the experience of the indwelling Christ, a clear sense of God's call to ministry, and graduation from either a university or junior college. As many as 100 attend this seminar each year to explore the possibility of training for the ministry and between twenty and thirty apply for admission. Of that number, only ten candidates are selected for admission to the fouryear study program at Logos Theological Seminary.
36 This teaching is based on the following New Testament passage: "And all of us, with unveiled faces, seeing the glory of the Lord as though reflected in a mirror, are being transformed into the same image from one degree of glory to another; for this comes from the Lord, the Spirit" (2 Cor 3:18). It is by the indwelling of the Spirit and practice of spiritual disciplines that we can be remade in the image (icon) of God. In recent years, Otsuki has borrowed from the Greek Orthodox tradition to refer to this process as divinization ( ). In sum, the goal of the Christian life is sainthood.
37 Compared with other Protestant churches, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus places far greater emphasis on the notion that the ordained clergy are a special priesthood setapart from the laity for religious work. To symbolize this distinctive identity, the church requires religious leaders to wear special clothing designed by Father Otsuki. For those who satisfactorily complete the first year of training at Logos there is a special service for putting on the religious garments for the first time.
38 It is interesting to note that religious diffusion over kinship ties is prominent at the leadership level within this movement just as in the Spirit of Jesus Church. The percentage of
ordained clergy from the Matsuda and Otsuka * families is particularly striking. One evangelist informed me, for example, that following her parents' conversion to the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, five of their seven children received the call to ministry, attended Logos Theological Seminary, and entered fulltime Christian ministry. Ten of her cousins have also been trained and ordained as clergy.
39 Regarding Nakada's views, David G. Goodman and Masanori Miyazawa explain that he "believed the Holiness Church had a unique role to play in the realization of Japan's divine mission. 'If we love our nation and fellowcountrymen,' he preached, 'we should pray ever more earnestly for the Jews.' The Holiness Church had been praying fervently for the salvation of the Jews and had been making monthly contributions on their behalf, and Nakada was convinced God would take notice of these devotions." Jews in the Japanese Mind: The History and Uses of a Cultural Stereotype (New York: The Free Press, 1995), 55.
40 These revelations are recorded in [The holy way], Gensenshu* vol. 2, 335, and The Tracks of Revival, 123.
41 Otsuki sees the debate that has gone on among Christians and Jews for nearly two thousand years over the identity of the Messiah as futile. At this time it is more important to simply pray for the coming of the Messiah. His identity will be clear enough to all people at his coming. Although the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus does attempt to evangelize the Jews, Otsuki teaches that the movement will somehow have a role to play in fulfilling the prophecy regarding the 144,000 people of Israel who will be marked by God's seal (Rev 7:2).
42 All of these efforts represent Otsuki's concern to follow the example of the Apostle Paul, who sought to be "all things to all men" and "give no offense to Jews or Greeks" (1 Cor 9:20–21, 10:32–33). Out of respect to the Jews, therefore, Otsuki wears a yarmulke when receiving Jewish visitors and makes a point not to wear a clerical collar, which for many symbolizes centuries of persecution by the established church. In recent years Father Otsuki rarely appears without the yarmulke (even when receiving a "gentile" visitor like myself).
43 A report of this concert tour is contained in the church magazine [The witness] 75 (1996), 16–31.
44 For another brief description of these activities, see BenAmi Shillony, The Jews and the Japanese: The Successful Outsiders (Tokyo: Charles E. Tuttle, 1991), 212–13.
45 Part of the inspiration for establishing this center came from the moving encounter the director had with the father of Anne Frank in Europe some twentyfive years ago. In their conversations, Otto Frank challenged Rev. Otsuka Makoto not just to feel sorry for the death of his daughter and many others but to do something on behalf of peace.
46 Reported in The Japan Times, 19 June 1995, 2.
47 Interview notes, 22 May 1996, Rev. Otsuka Makoto; and [Guidebook: The Holocaust Memorial Hall] (Kyoto: Logos Publishing, 1995).
48 The week before Pentecost, for example, Holy Ecclesia of Jesus churches hold prayer meetings every night to ask God to pour out his spirit on themselves and on
Jerusalem, chanting "Come Holy Spirit, Come to Jerusalem, O Holy Spirit."
49 [The Holy Ecclesia of Jesus hymnbook] (Kyoto: Sei Iesu Kai Logos Publishing, 1990).
50 Even the Japanese garden at Logos Theological Seminary was designed by the founder in the shape of the Holy Land, with streams and ponds representing the Jordan river and the Sea of Galilee—one more way of reminding the movement of its spiritual roots and final goal.
51 In 1982 the church published [A joyful household sabbath] (Kyoto: Sei Iesu Kai Logos Sha, 1982), a short booklet and cassette that provided simple guidelines for observing family worship in the home, including instructions on lighting the candles, singing songs in Hebrew and Japanese, words for the blessing of children, blessing and thanksgiving to the wife, and prayers before and after dinner. The introduction explains that this tradition has held together the Jewish people for 3,500 years and points out that Jesus Christ was also raised in this tradition. Readers are assured that following this ritual of family worship will help preserve peace and harmony in their own family in a society characterized by widespread divorce and family conflict. I should point out that observances related to the Jewish calendar and traditions are more likely to be observed by members in the Kansai area, who have more frequent contact with Jewish guests visiting the headquarters in Kyoto. The students enrolled in Logos Theological Seminary observe the sabbath ritual and dinner each Friday evening and look forward to this weekly celebration. One of my most unusual experiences as a field researcher was to participate in this Japanese version of sabbath in the secluded seminary in the mountains outside of Kyoto with Japanese seminarians singing and praying in Hebrew.
52 See his Meditations on the Holy Land. This collection of meditations is based on Otsuki *'s three pilgrimages. It is divided into sections on the Holy Land, Europe, and Greece and Asia Minor, reflecting his special interest in Israel as well as his concern to recover the valuable insights and examples of Roman Catholic and Orthodox spirituality as seen in the lives of the mystics and saints.
53 A furoshiki is a multipurpose cloth, typically between eighteen and twentyfour inches square, used to wrap up and carry items in lieu of a bag. As the
Chinese characters suggest, the term was originally used to refer to a cloth used to gather up one's personal effects at a public bath. The prefix o* in this case means
"large."
54 Two other movements based on Nonchurch Christianity are the Nihon Kirisuto Shodan* (Japan Ecclesia of Christ), founded by Koike Tatsuo in 1940, and Ikasu Kirisuto (LifeGiving Christ), founded by Imahashi Atsushi in 1966. Imahashi was a part of the Original Gospel movement but was forced to leave following a serious disagreement with Teshima.
55 For resources in English, see the sociological study by Carlo Caldarola, "The Makuya Christian Movement," Japanese Religions 7/4 (1972), 18–34; and chapter 7 of his Christianity: The Japanese Way, 192–208; , originally published
in 1950; and An Introduction to the Original Gospel Faith (Tokyo: Makuya Bible Seminary, 1970). This volume includes an essay by Otto Piper, Professor
Emeritus of Princeton Theological Seminary, who suggests that the Original Gospel is an indigenous Christian movement that represents a significant "third force" in Japanese Protestantism. Makuya and Israel: In Memory of Abraham I. Teshima (Tokyo: Makuya Bible Seminary, 1976), is a memorial collection of photographs and accounts of Teshima's involvements with Israel and Zionism published several years after his death.
56 Teshima Ikuro *, An Introduction to the Original Gospel Faith (Tokyo: Light of Life Press, 1970), 45. 57 [The Japanese people and the original gospel] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Seisho Juku, 1984), 190.
58 Teshima, The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 20–24.
59 These magazines are so important for Nonchurch groups that Ohara Shin refers to this movement as a "paperChurch":
Uchimura and his close followers who became sensei in the Sunday lectures usually published their own small monthly magazines, which were sent directly to each participant's home. Mukyokai can therefore be called a "paperChurch" in the sense that the magazines keep alive the relationship between a sensei and followers. The members dislike sacraments, but they value the magazines and books and are eager to receive their teacher's periodic publications.
See his essay, "The Thought of Uchimura Kanzo* and Its Relevance to Contemporary American Religion," in Ray A. Moore, ed., Culture and Religion in JapaneseAmerican Relations: Essays on Uchimura Kanzo*, 1861–1930 (Ann Arbor: Center for Japanese Studies, The University of Michigan, 1981), 125.
60 Teshima's biographer and close disciple, [My teacher, Teshima Ikuro] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Seisho Juku, 1990), 184.
61 Quoted in [Mukyokai* history, vol. 3, The third period: Age of concentration], edited by the Mukyokai Historical Association (Tokyo: Shinkyo* Shuppansha, 1995), 158.
62 See [In search of the spirit of Mukyokai] (Tokyo: Shinkyo Shuppansha, 1970), 197.
63 On this trip he made contact with Pentecostal leaders in the United States, among them Oral Roberts, and was impressed to discover that the apostolic faith was still alive in the West.
64 Two of Teshima's sons, in fact, completed degrees at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem before proceeding to the United States for doctoral studies. One completed his doctorate under Abraham Heschel at the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York. Another went on to complete doctoral studies in Hebrew Literature and Jewish hermeneutics at Harvard University.
65 In Japanese this practice is referred to as musentoho dendo *. Testimonies regarding the spiritual benefits of these "evangelistic walks" appear from time to time in the Original Gospel magazine Light of Life.
66 See Isaiah Teshima, "Abraham Teshima's Makuya and Pinchas Peli," Jewish Spectator 54/4 (1990), 57–60, an article by the founder's son that provides helpful insight into the Zionistic orientation of the movement.
67 For a description of various Original Gospel activities in relation to Israel see Light of Life 512 (1994), and Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way, 203–4.
68 See the [Makuya hymnbook] (Tokyo: The Committee for the Makuya Hymnbook, 1992).
69 Teshima, The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 27.
70 Teshima, The Love of the Holy Spirit, 13.
71 The Japanese phrase he uses here is . See Teshima, The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 31–32.
72 Teshima, The Japanese People and the Original Gospel, 55.
73 This explanation was provided by Dr. Yuro* Jacob Teshima, the founder's second son; the same development is also noted by Yoshimura Kiichiro*, My Teacher, Teshima Ikuro*, 298.
74 This point has also been widely recognized by scholars outside of Teshima's circle. See, for example, Goodman and Miyazawa, Jews in the Japanese Mind, 40– 46, and Doron B. Cohen, "Uchimura Kanzo* on Jews and Zionism," Japan Christian Review 1 (1992), 111–20.
75 For some examples, see Light of Life 521 (1995) and 538 (1997).
76 [Oh Japan! On the occasion of founding day] Light of Life 537 (1997), 13–17.
77 See [The establishment of identity], Light of Life 533 (1996), 40–45.
Chapter 7—
Japanese Christians and the World of the Dead 1 Hori, Folk Religion in Japan, 18.
2 Miyake Hitoshi, "Folk Religion," in Tamaru and Reid, eds., Religion in Japanese Culture, 80.
3 Morioka Kiyomi, "Ancestor Worship in Contemporary Japan: Continuity and Change," in George A. DeVos and Takao Sofue, eds., Religion and Family in East Asia (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1984), 201.
4 Robert J. Smith, Ancestor Worship in Contemporary Japan (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1974), 44.
5 Hoshino Eiki and Takeda Dosho*, "Mizuko Kuyo* and Abortion in Contemporary Japan," in Mullins, Shimazono, and Swanson, eds., Religion and Society in Modern Japan, 174–75.
6 For treatment of changes in the ancestral cult, see Smith, Ancestor Worship in Contemporary Japan, 220–26; Morioka, ''Ancestor Worship in Contemporary Japan," 206; Hardacre, Lay Buddhism in Contemporary Japan, 101–3; Komoto * Mitsugu, [Folk religion in the modern city], in Omura* and Nishiyama, eds., The Religion of People Today, 49; 71–74.
7 The Religious Consciousness of the Japanese. For a helpful review of the NHK survey results in English, see Swyngedouw, "The Quiet Reversal," 4–13.
8 A more recent review of various opinion polls on Japanese religious beliefs also found that ancestral concerns and spirit beliefs remain strong. Fleur Wöss concluded that "belief in continuing family ties beyond death is still one of the pillars of Japanese religious sentiment. . . . The majority believe that the reikon separates itself from the dead body and becomes a benevolent ancestor, provided that the proper rituals are conducted by family members." Furthermore, he found that spirit belief was particularly high among young people: "Threequarters of teenagers believe in the existence of yurei*—spirits, the same percentage in the curse of malevolent spirits in general." "When Blossoms Fall, Japanese Attitudes towards Death and the Otherworld: Opinion Polls 1953–1987," in Roger Goodman and Kirsten Refsing, eds., Ideology and Practice in Modern Japan (London: Routledge, 1992), 94–95.
9 For this line of argument see Shimazono Susumu, "Spiritbelief in New Religious Movements and Popular Culture: The Case of Japan's New Religions," The Journal of Oriental Philosophy 26/1 (1987); Komoto, "Folk Religion in the Modern City," and [Japan's folk religion] (Tokyo: Niwano Foundation, Research Forum, 1992).
10 Hardacre, Lay Buddhism in Contemporary Japan (chapter four) and Kurozumikyo* and the New Religions of Japan, 151, 173–76; Earhart, GedatsuKai and Religion in Contemporary Japan, 172–90; Winston Davis, Dojo*: Magic and Exorcism in Modern Japan, 41–46; and Ian Reader, "The Rise of a Japanese 'New New Religion': Themes in the Development of Agonshu*," Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 15/4 (1988), 238–40.
11 Hardacre, Lay Buddhism in Contemporary Japan, 106.
12 See Hoshino Eiki and Takeda Dosho*, "Mizuko Kuyo* and Abortion in Contemporary Japan," in Mullins et al., Religion and Society in Modern Japan, 171– 90, and Richard Fox Young, "Abortion, Grief and Consolation: Prolegomena to a Christian Response to Mizuko Kuyo," Japan Christian Quarterly 55/1 (1989).
13 [The woman who sells souls] (Tokyo: Toen* Shobo*, 1990).
14 See, for example, [What is happening in religion?] (Tokyo: Heibonsha, 1990); and David C. Lewis, "Religious Rites in a Japanese Factory," in Mullins et al., Religion and Society in Modern Japan, 157–70.
15 Dickson Kazuo Yagi, "Protestant Perspectives on Ancestor Worship in Japanese Buddhism: The Funeral and the Buddhist Altar," Japanese Religions 15/1 (1988), 30.
16 Morioka, Japan's Modern Society and Christianity, 101–12; 142–43.
17 Reid, New Wine, 108–9. In this section I am drawing on Reid's helpful explanation of linear and cyclical rites for the dead, especially 103–7.
18 One Uchimura scholar, for example, notes that the wellknown disciple of Uchimura, Yanaihara Tadao, visited his teacher shortly after the death of his father to inquire about the fate of those who died without encountering Christ in this life. Uchimura candidly replied that this was something for which he had no answer (see Ohara, The Life of Uchimura Kanzo * 257).
19 Anzai gives considerable attention to the negative approach of the Spirit of Jesus Church in his book, The Acceptance of Christianity in the Southern Islands.
The Okinawa Christian Gospel movement takes a similarly hard line regarding the traditional ancestral cult (see Ikegami, A Stage for Demons and the Holy Spirit, 66–67).
20 [The grapevine] (Kyoto: Logos Publishing Company, 1991), 148.
21 [Light of life] 500 (1993), 136–43.
22 Written in the church bulletin, for example, as (i.e., first or secondyear memorial since being "called to heaven").
23 The founder of the Sanctifying Christ Church ( ), for example, has written hymns commemorating the first anniversary of the death of his father and the tenth anniversary of the death of his mother, as well as a special hymn commemorating the tenthyear anniversary since the church built a crypt at a cemetery in
Kobe*.
24 Berentsen, Grave and Gospel, 196–98.
25 See Reid, New Wine; Nishiyama, "Indigenization and Transformation of Christianity in a Japanese Community"; Doerner, "Comparative Analysis of Life after Death in Folk Shinto and Christianity"; and Luttio, "The Passage of Death in the Japanese Context.'' 26 See Jesus: A New Vision (San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1987), 225–26.
27 [The glorious gospel, part 2] (Aso, Kyushu*: Eiko* no Fukuin Kirisuto Kyokai* Shuppanbu, 1961), 53–55.
28 This is also recorded in [A record of my conversion] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1991), 40.
29 [Biblical theology: Basic doctrines] (Tokyo: Iesu no Mitama Kyokai, 1957), 32–33.
30 A similar emphasis on the interdependence of the living and the dead and the practice of various baptisms for the dead may be seen in the Mormon Church. In addition to First Corinthians 15:29, Mormons point to Hebrews 11:40 to support their interpretation that our predecessors depend on us for their complete salvation ("His [God's] purpose was that only in company with us would they be made perfect"). Likewise, Mormons recognize the reality of the unseen spirit world and receive communication from the departed. For an overview of Mormon teaching in relation to African beliefs regarding the dead and the spirit world, see Dennis L. Thomson, "African Religion and Mormon Doctrine: Comparisons and Commonalities," in Thomas D. Blakely, Walter E. A. Van Beek and Dennis L. Thomson, eds., Religion in Africa: Experiences and Expressions (London: James Currey, 1994), 89–99.
31 This is a collection of 166 hymns all said to have been received from heaven by Tsuruhara Tama, a woman who was active in the early years of this church. Since these hymns were given in a revelation directly from God, no changes are permitted. One sociologist has commented upon the "indigenous" character of this hymnbook and suggested that these songs do not have the melodies and rhythms of Western hymns, but are more like Japanese folk songs; see Anzai,"The Spirit of Jesus Church," 277–88. A young Japanese woman to whom I showed this hymn was similarly impressed. She was immediately struck by the Buddhist influence upon the lyrics and the Japanesesounding melody.
32 This, along with records of those "baptized vicariously," resembles the practice of Reiyukai * members in keeping a death register, or Book of the Past ( ); see Hardacre, Lay Buddhism in Contemporary Japan, 65–66.
33 Hori, Folk Religion in Japan, 72–73.
34 For additional background on "bad death," malevolent spirits (onryo* ) in Japanese religion, see Klaus Antoni's "YasukuniJinja and Folk Religion," in Mullins et al., Religion and Society in Modern Japan, 121–32, and Kuroda Toshio, "The World of Spirit Pacification: Issues of State and Religion,'' trans. Allan Grapard, Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 23/3–4 (1996), 321–51.
35 Light of Life (1993), 138–39.
36 The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1958), 104–5.
37 For a helpful recent discussion and comparison of the Protestant and Roman Catholic views of death and the "geography" of the other world, see Tony Walter's The Eclipse of Eternity: A Sociology of the Afterlife (London: Macmillan Press, 1996), 17–18. While Protestants have traditionally taught that individuals go directly to either heaven or hell at the moment of death, the Roman Catholic tradition, with its "threefold eternal geography of HeavenPurgatoryHell," recognizes an intermediate state of the dead and "multidirectional traffic" between this world and the unseen world.
Chapter 8—
Comparative Patterns of Growth and Decline
1 Dean M. Kelley, Why Conservative Churches Are Growing (New York: Harper and Row, 1972).
2 Dean R. Hoge and David A. Roozen, Understanding Church Growth and Decline: 1950–1978 (New York: The Pilgrim Press, 1979).
3 Wade Clark Roof and William McKinney, American Mainline Religion: Its Changing Shape and Future (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1987).
4 For a more detailed discussion and analysis of postwar patterns of growth and decline, see [Problems in the fiftyyear history of the United Church
of Christ in Japan], edited by Morioka Gen (Tokyo: Shinkyo * Shuppansha. 1992), 109–33; 1995 [Christian yearbook, 1995] (Tokyo: Kirisuto Shinbunsha, 1995), 45–49; and Thomas Hastings and Mark R. Mullins, "Denominational Renewal or Fragmentation? An Exploratory Study of Reformed/Evangelical Movements within the United Church of Christ in Japan," Japan Christian Review 64, 1998.
5 David R. Heise, "Prefatory Findings in the Sociology of Missions," 49.
6 Hayashi Minoru, "Learning from the Japanese New Religions" (Pasadena: Doctor of Missiology thesis, Fuller Theological Seminary, 1988), 14.
7 Uchimura, Complete Works of Uchimura Kanzo*, vol. 31, 380 (1928). For other details regarding the early development of the Nonchurch movement, I have relied on William H. Norman, "Kanzo Uchimura: Founder of the NonChurch Movement," Contemporary Religions in Japan 5/1 (1964), 34–44; John F. Howes, "The NonChurch Christian Movement in Japan," The Transactions of the Asiatic Society of Japan, Third Series 5 (1957), 119–37; and Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way.
8 Howes, "The NonChurch Christian Movement in Japan," 124.
9 [In search of the spirit of the Nonchurch movement] (Tokyo: Shinkyo Shuppansha, 1970), 176–78, 197. The groups associated with the Original Gospel movement were excluded from this number since Takahashi regards Teshima's pentecostal version of Nonchurch Christianity as an aberration.
10 Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way.
11 Since many individuals subscribe to more than one Nonchurch publication, membership estimates in the past have been too high. One insider suggested that a more accurate (though rough) estimate of Nonchurch participants could be made by multiplying the three or four hundred groups by ten. There are undoubtedly many more who could be regarded as kakure mukyokai*, individuals who follow Uchimura's understanding of Christianity but do not participate in meetings. Over the years, the
Christian Yearbook ( ) has offered the following estimates for Nonchurch membership: 30,000–50,000 (1958), 15,000 (1966), 1,500 (1970), and 1,414 (1976).
12 For the most recent information on Nonchurch Christianity I am indebted to the staff of Imai Hall for introducing me to various records and reports, especially the published proceedings of the national meetings held since 1987 (see the appendix for details regarding these publications). [Gospel and mission], 49 (March 1994), 25–29.
13 [List of members of The Way] (Tokyo: Dokai* Headquarters, 1936).
14 Reported in the Christian Yearbook (1970).
15 This number was reported in the introduction to the English version of A Eulogy on Jesus Christ, trans. Yoshinobu Kawai (Tokyo: Christ Heart Church, 1961).
16 Iglehart, A Century of Protestant Christianity in Japan, 339. Although outsiders tend to classify this church as "Protestant," this is a designation that the Spirit of Jesus Church representatives reject. They maintain that this church is neither Catholic nor Protestant, but a recovery of the authentic "primitive" church. While outsiders may refer to this church as "Protestant," most add that it is a heretical group because of its practice of baptism of the dead and its rejection of the doctrine of the trinity.
17 See, for example, Anzai, "The Spirit of Jesus Church," 277–88.
18 Comparison with membership in another new religious movement might be helpful here. In a study of Sukyo * Mahikari, for example, Winston Davis estimates "that although as many as one million amulets have probably been distributed to new members, the de facto membership probably numbers about 100,000 to 200,000 or even less" (Dojo*, 7).
19 My observations here are supported by Anzai's study of the Spirit of Jesus Church in Okinawa. He also found that the figures for baptism were very high, but less than ten percent of those reported as baptized members actually attended services; see his The Acceptance of Christianity in the Southern Islands, 119. It might also be helpful to recognize here that Japanese religiosity and understanding of membership are quite different from some Western notions. As a rule, Japanese do not commit themselves to one particular religious organization; rather, they participate in the annual festivals and rituals of both Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples throughout the year. Regular weekly attendance at religious meetings is the exception rather than the norm in Japan. While this church strongly discourages participation in Buddhist and Shinto rituals, their understanding of membership seems similarly undemanding. From my limited observation, there is little pressure placed on members to attend meetings. As long as one has received "water" and "spirit" baptism, other obligations are viewed rather lightly. Hence, the small number of regular attendants does not seem to bother leaders. Members can attend for services and rituals that seem important to them through the year and life cycle just as other Japanese visit Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples for special events or rituals.
20 Caldarola included a chapter on the Original Gospel movement in his book, Christianity: The Japanese Way. About the time Caldarola was conducting his study, the 1976 Christian Yearbook reported that the Original Gospel had 200 groups and 50,000 members. The discrepancy between Caldarola's figures and that of the yearbook indicate how difficult it is to obtain accurate statistics on these groups.
21 The 10,000 figure may be too high, but it is not unreasonable in light of participation rates in various meetings. In 1992, 7,000 members attended the annual meeting, and 1,600 members participated in the pilgrimage to Israel two years ago. Approximately 500 members usually attend the annual threeday study meeting for leaders of the housemeetings.
22 For membership and attendance figures I have relied on church reports made available to me by the head of the Evangelism Division of the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus.
23 Hugh Trevor, Japan's Postwar Protestant Churches (Tokyo: Mimeographed, 1994), 28.
24 Two other indigenous movements show similar patterns of growth and decline. The Glorious Gospel Christian Church, founded in 1936 by Sugita Kotaro *, grew to a membership of 3,929, with seven churches and fourteen centers for evangelism. The membership began to decline after the death of the founder's wife and in 1996 reported membership of only 1,130. The Christian Canaan Church, which was started by Taniguchi Toku with house meetings in 1940, grew in three decades to a membership of 2,797 with eight churches and six centers for evangelism. This church has also begun to show signs of decline, with a total of 2,483 members in 1995. These observations are based on interviews and reports in the Christian Yearbook.
25 Milton J. Yinger, The Scientific Study of Religion (Toronto: CollierMacmillan, 1970), 112.
26 Stark, "How New Religions Succeed: A Theoretical Model," 16.
27 It should be noted that the founder of Christ Heart Church, Kawai Shinsui, made it clear from the beginning that he was not interested in attracting great numbers, but was concerned to train and cultivate the few. Perfection was the goal and selfcultivation was the means. As one of his followers explained: "Kawai Sensei always emphasized that selfcultivation was the number one concern." The emphasis on "perfection" and members' own sense of inadequate progress on the "path to perfection" discourages them from inviting others. Informants note that there are visitors from time to time, but they usually do not return to meetings. "The path is hard and requires considerable discipline," they explain, ''and is not like so many New Religions that worship thisworldly benefits."
28 Reginald W Bibby and Merlin Brinkerhoff, "The Circulation of the Saints: A Study of People Who Join Conservative Churches," Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 12 (1973). Their study of churches in North America discovered that conservative churches tended to benefit from the "circulation of the saints" (i.e., switching from denomination to denomination) and that effective proselytizing of individuals outside of the Christian community was minimal. It would be interesting to know what percentage of the growth reported by evangelical churches in Japan is related to such denominational switching. As noted above, leaders of the Original Gospel Movement estimate that roughly fifty percent of their members come from other Christian churches.
29 Stark, "How New Religions Succeed," 13.
30 This dilemma has been expressed most effectively by Endo* Shusaku* in Silence, a historical novel dealing with this first period of Christian mission in Japan. In one passage the veteran missionary Ferreira, who apostasized under torture, explains to his former student and still zealous missionary Rodrigues the difficulty of transplanting Christianity in the Japanese cultural environment:
The one thing I know is that our religion does not take root in this country. . . . This country is a swamp. In time you will come to see that for yourself This country is a more terrible swamp than you can imagine. Whenever you plant a sapling in this swamp the roots begin to rot; the leaves grow yellow and wither. And we have planted the sapling of Christianity in this swamp. (237)
31 See Morioka's "A Conceptual Examination of the Indigenization of ForeignBorn Religions" and Japan's Modern Society and Christianity.
32 Davis, Japanese Religion and Society, 31.
33 As far as missionary efforts are concerned, it is interesting to note that more Protestant missionaries have been sent to Japan than Korea during the past century (see Grayson, Early Buddhism and Christianity in Korea, 138).
34 Montgomery, "The Spread of Religions and Macrosocial Relations," 38–39. See also his earlier "Receptivity to an Outside Religion: Light from Interaction between Sociology and Missiology," Missiology: An International Review 14/3 (1986), 287–99.
35 David Martin, Tongues of Fire: The Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1990), 155–56.
36 During the postwar period, Christian churches in Korea seem to have filled the role that new religions have in Japan. Apparently only five percent of the South Korean population belonged to a new religion in the early 1980s, while ten to twenty percent of the Japanese are members of one of the new religions (closer to the percentage of Christians in Korea). For the data on South Korea I have relied on Joseph B. Tamney, "Religion in Capitalist East Asia," in William H. Swatos, Jr., ed. A Future For Religion? New Paradigms for Social Analysis (Beverley Hills: A Sage Focus Edition, 1992), 62.
37 Reported in the MARC Newsletter 95/1 (March 1995), 1.
38 Information and current statistics regarding Yoido Full Gospel Church were gathered by the author on a field trip to Seoul in September 1989. Reported statistics should not be taken at face value. There are always inactive members and many "floating Christians" whose membership is reported by more than one church. Even with these qualifications, I would imagine that there are several hundred thousand members active in one of the programs of Yoido Church. Regarding membership composition, I am only aware of one sociological survey of the church conducted by SynDuk Choi in 1978 and reported in his "A comparative study of two new religious movements in the Republic of Korea: the Unification Church and the Full Gospel Central Church," in James Beckford, ed. New Religious Movements and Rapid Social Change (Beverley Hills: Sage Publications, 1986), 113–45. According to Choi's study, the majority of the Full Gospel Church members have less than a high school education and women outnumber men by more than two to one. He summed up the results of this survey with the following generalization: "The educational level, occupation and living conditions of the members of Full Gospel Church show that it is a church of the middle and lower classes." Choi's findings are based upon 300 responses (28 percent men and 72 percent women) to his questionnaire distributed in eight large parishes. For fuller treatment of Yoido Church see the work of Daniel J. Adams, "Reflections on an Indigenous Christian Movement: The Yoido Full Gospel Church," Japan Christian Review 57/1 (1991); Jae Bum Lee's ''Pentecostal Type Distinctives and Korean Protestant Church Growth" (Ph.D. dissertation, School of World Mission, Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, California, 1986), and Boo Woong Yoo's "Response to Korean Shamanism by the Pentecostal Church," International Review of Mission 75/297 (1986), and Korean Pentecostalism: Its History and Theology (New York: Peter Lang, 1988).
39 See Paul Yonggi Cho's "Ministry Through Home Cell Groups," (with John W Hurston) in Ro BongRin and Marvin L. Nelson, eds., Korean Church Growth Explosion (Seoul:
Word of Life Press, 1983) for a discussion of the role of home cell groups in pastoral care and church growth.
40 Jae Bum Lee, "Pentecostal Type Distinctives and Korean Protestant Church Growth," 285.
41 See, for example, James Huntley Grayson's Korea: A Religious History (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989), 205; and David KwangSun Suh's The Korean Minjung in Christ (Hong Kong: The Christian Conference of Asia, 1991), 114–16.
42 ByongSuh Kim, "The Explosive Growth of the Korean Church Today: A Sociological Analysis," International Review of Mission 74/293 (1985), 70.
43 David Suh, The Korean Minjung in Christ, 116.
44 Quoted from the church pamphlet, Yoido Full Gospel Church Doctrine and Creed (n.d.).
45 BongHo Son, "Some Dangers of Rapid Growth," in Ro BongRin and Marvin L. Nelson, eds., Korean Church Growth Explosion (Seoul: Word of Life Press, 1983), 338.
46 James Huntley Grayson's Korea: A Religious History (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989: 205). BongHo Son, extremely critical of Korean church life, goes so far as to say that "many give in order to receive more, based on the shamanistic practice of bribing the demons"; "Some Dangers of Rapid Growth," 339.
47 Kwangil Kim, "Kut and the Treatment of Mental Disorder," in ChaiShin Yu and R. Guisso, eds., Shamanism: The Spirit World of Korea (Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press, 1988), 133.
48 Yohan Lee, "An Analysis of the Christian Prayer Mountain Phenomenon in Korea" (Ph.D. dissertation, School of World Mission, Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, California, 1985), 10.
49 Lee, "An Analysis of the Christian Prayer Mountain Phenomenon in Korea," 51.
50 Paul Yonggi Cho, More Than Numbers (Waco, Texas: Word Books, 1984), 102–3.
51 The growth of the Tokyo Full Gospel Church and its branch churches is described in a book by the senior pastor, Kang Hun Rhee, [The salvation of ten million Japanese souls is possible] (Tokyo: Division of Mission of the Tokyo Full Gospel Church, 1989). The growth of Full Gospel churches in Japan over the past decade is undoubtedly related to the fact that these ethnic churches provide a home away from home for many Korean immigrants working in Japan. The degree of success in incorporating Japanese into these ethnic organizations varies from church to church. In most Full Gospel Churches the Japanese membership is below 20 percent (many spouses of interethnic marriages). I have been informed, however, that there are some exceptions. The church in Fukuoka (southern Japan), for example, is dominantly Japanese. What is clear, in any case, is that these churches are making an effort to transcend ethnic boundaries. This is hardly the only factor related to their growth. Following the model of Yoido Church in Seoul, all of these churches have organized multiple services on Sunday and scores of home cell groups. The Tokyo Church, for example, has six worship services on Sunday. Two are conducted in Japanese and four in Korean (with simultaneous interpretation provided for three of these).
52 For an overview of this social context, see my essay "Japan's New Age and NeoNew Religions: Sociological Interpretations," in James R. Lewis and J. Gordon Melton, eds., Perspectives on the New Age (Albany, New York: State University of New York, 1992), 232–46.
53 Hori, Folk Religion in Japan, 14.
54 I borrowed this term from Kenneth J. Dale's Circle of Harmony: A Case Study of Popular Japanese Buddhism (Tokyo: Seibunsha, 1975), 157.
55 Davis, Dojo *, 302.
56 Hayashi Minoru, "Learning from the Japanese New Religions" (Pasadena: Doctor of Missiology thesis, Fuller Theological Seminary, 1988), 14.
57 Paul Yonggi Cho, More Than Numbers, 119.
58 Daniel J. Adams, "Reflections on an Indigenous Christian Movement: The Yoido Full Gospel Church," The Japan Christian Quarterly 57/1 (1991), 43.
Chapter 9—
The Broader Context of Japanese Christianity
1 Jean Danielou, A History of Early Christian Doctrines before the Council of Nicaea, vol. 2: Gospel Message and Hellenistic Culture. Translated by J. A. Baker (Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1973), 33.
2 See [A study of the Original Gospel] (Tokyo: Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan* Senkyo* Kenkyujo*, 1965), 62. To my knowledge, this represents the only effort by one of the established churches to study an indigenous movement in Japan. In addition to elaborating the "pluralistic" perspective on Japanese culture and providing some basic information on the Original Gospel movement, the author suggests that the success of indigenous movements is related in part to the failures and deficiencies of the established churches.
3 There are some exceptions to this generalization. Christ Heart Church, for example, does observe baptism as a rite of initiation. Also, some groups related to the Nonchurch tradition may observe baptisms on an occasional basis, but these have not become institutionalized requirements.
4 On the gender issue, the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus should be placed in an intermediate position on a continuum between the Confucian maledominated approach of the Nonchurch movement on the one end and the egalitarian pentecostal Spirit of Jesus Church on the other. Women called to ministry in the Holy Ecclesia of Jesus are recognized as "gifted" and receive theological education. Following graduation from Logos Theological Seminary, however, they can only be ordained as teachers (seikyoshi* bokushi) are allowed to officiate at the Lord's Supper and perform the benediction at the end of worship services. If women marry after completion of this seminary training, they are expected to devote themselves fully to housework and to the care and education of their children. Of course, they are expected to play a supportive role in their husband's pastoral work and church activities. While this church gives men priority in the hierarchy of religious authority, it is widely recognized that many women are some of the most successful evange
lists. They often begin evangelistic activities in difficult new a reas, and after establishing a church of fifty to one hundred members, they move on to begin a new work and pass on the job of pastoral care to one of the ordained men. This is, of course, a typical pattern in many Christian churches and mission organizations.
5 These observations are based on the lecture by (6) [Speaking from a woman's point of view]. For a more accessible English volume by a Japanese feminist from the Nonchurch tradition, see Hisako Kinukawa's Women and Jesus in Mark: A Japanese Feminist Perspective (Maryknoll: Orbis Books), 1994.
6 For historical background and discussion of leadership succession and transmission of religious authority in Japanese Buddhist sects, see Michael Solomon, "Kinship and the Transmission of Religious Charisma: The Case of Honganji,"Journal ofAsian Studies, 33/3 (1974), 403–13; and Fujii Masao, "Founder Worship in Kamakura Buddhism," in George A. DeVos and Takao Sofue, eds., Religion and the Family in East Asia (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1986), 155–
67. For a helpful analysis of this pattern of leadership succession in Japanese New Religions unrelated to the Christian tradition, see Inoue Nobutaka, Deciphering New Religions, 150–57.
7 Leadership succession in the Original Gospel, a movement based on Nonchurch principles, is a bit more complicated. Following the death of Teshima in 1973, the movement has continued under the joint leadership of the teachers based primarily in Tokyo, but also in Kumamoto (Kyushu *), where the movement began. Carlo Caldarola observed that Mrs. Teshima is recognized as the most powerful figure in the movement, since "she is regarded as the living memory of Teshima and his personality and charisma are perceived to be still operative in the movement through her" (Christianity: The Japanese Way, 198). He went on to speculate that Teshima's son, Jacob, who was at the time completing doctoral studies in Jewish studies in the United States, would eventually return to Japan "to take up the mantle of leadership." As it turns out, however, Jacob was unable to accept the direction the Original Gospel had taken since his father's death and left the movement to establish the Gilboa Institute of the Humanities, where he is currently active as an independent scholar of Biblical and Judaic Studies. There is now some speculation that Issac Teshima, the founder's son by his second marriage, who recently completed doctoral studies at Harvard in Hebrew Bible and
Jewish hermeneutics, may return to take an active leadership role in the movement. In interviews, however, he indicated that academic work would most likely be his primary calling.
8 Even in the rather individualistic North American context, for example, Billy Graham's son was appointed as his successor in the Billy Graham Association and Jimmy Swaggart's son appears to be waiting in the wings to assume leadership of the evangelistic television ministry if it survives the scandals associated with his father's ministry.
9 The proceedings of these annual meetings have been published each year since 1988 as [The proceedings of the Nonchurch Christianity national meeting] (Tokyo: The Office of the Nonchurch Christianity National Meeting), and are available from the Imai Hall in Tokyo. These are probably the most useful publications for understanding the situation of the Nonchurch movement today.
10 This was reflected in the composition of those who attended the first nationwide meeting: the majority of participants was over age 50, with 68 percent of the participants in the 50–80 age bracket; only twelve percent of the participants were age 30 or younger; see [The proceedings of the first Nonchurch Christianity national meeting] (Tokyo: The Office of the Nonchurch Christianity National Meeting, 1988), 79.
11 Here I am drawing on [The proceedings of the third Nonchurch Christianity national meeting] (1990), 4.
12 As it turns out, some of the applicants were interested nonChristians, so the classes not only educate members but also represent an opportunity for reaching new people.
13 Caldarola, Christianity: The Japanese Way, 75–76.
14 [The proceedings of the sixth Nonchurch Christianity national meeting] (1993), 62.
15 This style of leadership is often referred to as the takotsubo (octopuspot) type, since the vertical relationship between teacher and disciple is strong, but horizontal relationships between members tend to be weak. This is particularly the case with the larger Bible study groups in the city, but less so in rural areas where the groups tend to be small and familylike; see Proceedings of the Third Nonchurch Christianity National Meeting, 39.
16 Some members also mention the difficulty of finding their own burial site at a Buddhist temple graveyard or elsewhere since Nonchurch groups do not maintain theirown properties; see Proceedings of the Third Nonchurch Christianity National Meeting, 47, 53.
17 This observation was initially made with reference to the African independent churches, but it is equally true for these Japanese movements; see Joel Kailing, "Inside, Outside, Upside Down: In Relationship with African Independent Churches," International Review of Mission 77 (January 1988), 40. The personal reflections of Harold Turner, who spent a large part of his career researching the African Independent churches, provides a helpful illustration of how these movements are in process: "As one in the high Reformed tradition of sound doctrine and decency and order in worship it would have been nonsense to
suggest that I might actually enjoy dancing in African independent churches with a very uncertain Christology. And now the church where I did most of my dancing is a member of the WCC." "A Global Phenomenon," in Allan R. Brockway and J. Paul Rajashekar, eds., New Religious Movements and the Churches, 14.
18 See their "Introductory Essay: on 'Native Christianity'," in Wendy James and Douglas H. Johnson, eds., Vernacular Christianity, 5.
19 The Religious Consciousness of the Japanese. This survey was carried out in November 1981 with interviews conducted in 300 locations in rural and urban settings across Japan. A total of 3,600 individuals over age 16 were interviewed. Out of this number there were 2,692 (74.8 percent) usable (valid) interviews. Of the total sample, 44.7 percent (1,203 ) were male and 55.3 (1,489) were female.
20 "The Quiet Reversal: A Few Notes on the NHK Survey of Japanese Religiosity," Japan Missionary Bulletin 39/1 (1985), 5–6 .
21 Here I am drawing on Jan Swyngedouw's discussion of the division of labor in Japanese religion and the new ritual contribution of Christianity. See his The Structure of Harmony and Apportionment.
22 The two surveys mentioned were conducted by Sanwa Bank and the Bridal Market Research Institute. For more details see BB [Bib Bridal white paper] 7 (Tokyo, 1993).
23 For brief discussions of this legend see John Koedyker, "Another Jesus," Japan Christian Quarterly 52/3 (Summer 1986), 167–69, and [All about Japanese religion] (Tokyo: Nihon Bungeisha, 1997), 214–15.
24 Legends of this kind are not limited to Japan. In India, for example, there is a similar tradition that claims Jesus did not die on the cross in Jerusalem but lived another forty years in Northwest India before his death and burial in the area. This example is mentioned briefly in Diana L. Eck, Encountering God: A Spiritual Journey from Bozeman to Banaras (Boston: Beacon Press, 1993), 113–14; and from a believer's standpoint in Fida Hassnain and Dahan Levi, The Fifth Gospel (Srinagar: Dastgir, 1988).
25 For a more detailed treatment, see the following studies by Richard Young, "The 'Christ' of the Japanese New Religions" and "The LittleLad Deity and the Dragon Princess." Young has shown how the "Christ" (whether related to the Jesus of the gospel or not) has been revered and integrated into indigenous belief systems, but often for reasons of personal selfaggrandizement and to promote or legitimize aspirations toward a specious universality. In the latter study, he analyzes how Fujita Himiko incorporates Jesus, along with other deities and saints, into the mythology of Megami no Umi ( , Ocean of the Goddess).
26 See his [Proclamation as Christ] (1991), and part 2 of the same work (1992). For additional information on Asahara and Aum Shinrikyo *, see Ian
Reader, A Poisonous Cocktail? Aum Shinrikyo's Path to Violence (Copenhagen: Nordic Institute for Asian Studies, 1996); Shimazono Susumu, "In the Wake of
Aum: The Formation and Transformation of a Universe of Belief," Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 22/3–4 (1995), 381–415; and my essays "Aum
Shinrikyo * as an Apocalyptic Movement," in Thomas Robbins and Susan J. Palmer, eds., Millennium, Messiahs, and Mayhem (New York: Routledge, 1997), 313–24, and "The Political and Legal Response toAumRelated Violence in Japan," Japan Christian Review 63 (1997), 37–46.
27 An English translation of Okawa's* work on Christ was published as The Spiritual Guidance of esus Christ: Speaking on the Resurrection of Love and the Spirit of the New Age (Tokyo: IRH Press, 1991).
28 It is perhaps for this reason that Jaroslav Pelikan, in his illuminating cultural history, refers to Jesus Christ as "the Man Who Belongs to the World." Jesus through the Centuries: His Place in the History of Culture (New York: Harper and Row, 1987), 220–21. Richard Young, who has examined the place of Jesus in a number of Japanese New Religions, similarly writes that "Jesus Christ belongs to the public domain. Like it or not, his is a name that can neither be registered, trademarked, or copyrighted . . ." ("The 'Christ' of the Japanese New Religions," 117).
29 Rodney Stark, "Modernization, Secularization, and Mormon Success," in Thomas Robbins and Dick Anthony, eds., In Gods We Trust: New Patterns of Religious Pluralism in America (New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1990), 201.
30 Peter L. Berger, The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion (Garden City, New York: Doubleday, 1967), 171.
31 Herbert Passin, "Modernization and the Japanese Intellectual," in Marius B. Jansen, ed. Changing Japanese Attitudes toward Modernization (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965), 482–83; emphasis added.
32 This point has been helpfully elaborated by Munakata Iwao in his essay, "The Ambivalent Effects of Modernization on the Traditional Folk Religion of Japan," 99– 126.
33 Peter L. Berger, A Far Glory: The Quest for Faith in an Age of Credulity (New York: Anchor Books, 1992), 28, 32; see also "Epistemological Modesty: An Interview with Peter Berger," The Christian Century 114 (29 October 1997), 974. This revised view finds substantial support in David B. Barrett's most recent statistical update, which reports that there are "over 15,000 distinct, separate, and different religions and religious movements. Two or three entirely new nonChristian religions are begun on earth every day." See his "Annual Statistical Table on Global Mission: 1997," International Bulletin of Missionary Research 21/1 (January 1997), 24. My guess is that Barrett's total figure is too small, since several hundred New Religions have been documented in Japan alone.
34 Irving Hexham and Karla Poewe, "Charismatic Churches in South Africa: A Critique of Criticisms and Problems of Bias," in Poewe, ed., Charismatic Christianity as a Global Culture, 60.
35 "Transformations of Christianity: Some General Observations," in George R. Saunders, ed., Culture and Christianity, 181.
36 For some representative works treating indigenous concerns with kinship, spirits, exorcism, healing, and ancestors in various regions of the world, see Harold W
Turner, Religious Innovation in Africa: Collected Essays on New Religious Movements (Boston: G. K. Hall and Co., 1979); Gerhardus C. Oosthuizen, The
HealerProphet in AfroChristian Churches (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1992); Alan Hunter and KimKwong Chan, Protestantism in Contemporary
China (Cambridge University Press, 1993); and Steven Kaplan, ed., Indigenous Responses to Western Christianity (New York: New York University Press, 1995).
37 David B. Barrett, ed. World Christian Encyclopedia: A Comparative Survey on Religions in the Modern World, A.D. 1900–2000 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1982), 9.
38 Andrew F. Walls, The Missionary Movement in Christian History, 9–10.
39 In an important international and crosscultural study of charismatic and pentecostal movements, for example, Irving Hexham and Karla Poewe discovered that these new forms of Christianity were developing simultaneously in various local contexts and mutually influencing each other through international networks, associations, and modern technology. "It is this international perspective," Hexham and Poewe conclude, "that brought home the lesson that North American and European churches are as deeply affected by African, Asian, and Latin American churches as vice versa." See "Charismatic Churches in South Africa," 66.
40 Donald W Dayton, "Yet Another Layer of the Onion: Or Opening the Ecumenical Door to Let the RiffraffIn," The Ecumenical Review 40/1 (1988), 87–110.
41 "Global Religion(s): Hope or Hoax of the 20th Century?," Harvard University Center for the Study of World Religions News 3/2 (1966), 1–3.
General Bibliography
Abe Yoshiya. "From Prohibition to Toleration: Japanese Government Views Regarding Christianity." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 5/2–3 (1978), 107–38.
Anzai Shin Sakurai Tokutaro *, ed., [Folk religion and society]. Tokyo: Kobunsha*, 1980, 268–79.
———. [The acceptance of Christianity in the southern islands]. Tokyo: Daiichi Shobo*, 1984.
Berentsen, J. M. Grave and Gospel. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1985.
Berger, Peter and Hansfried Kellner. Sociology Reinterpreted: An Essay on Method and Vocation. Garden City, New York: Anchor Books, 1981.
Breen, John and Mark Williams, eds. Japan and Christianity: Impacts and Responses. London: Macmillan Press, 1995.
Brockway, Allan R. and J. Paul Rajashekar, eds. New Religious Movements and the Churches. Geneva: WCC Publications, 1987.
Caldarola, Carlo. Christianity: The Japanese Way. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1979.
Cary, Otis. A History of Christianity in Japan. Tokyo: Charles E. Tuttle, 1976 (reprint of the 1909 twovolume edition).
Davis, Winston Bradley. Dojo*: Magic and Exorcism in Modern Japan. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1980.
———. Japanese Religion and Society: Paradigms of Structure and Change. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1992.
Doerner, David L. "Comparative Analysis of Life after Death in Folk Shinto and Christianity." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 4/2–3 (1977), 151–82.
Dohi Akio [A history of Protestant Christianity in Japan]. Tokyo: Shinkyo* Shuppansha, 1980.
Doshisha* University Humanities Research Institute, ed. [Studies in Japanese Protestant denominational histories]. Tokyo: Kyobunkan*, 1997.
Drummond, Richard H. A History of Christianity in Japan. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1971.
Earhart, H. Byron. GedatsuKai and Religion in Contemporary Japan. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1989.
Ebisawa Arimichi [Historical dictionary of Christianity in Japan]. Tokyo: Kyobunkan, 1988.
Endo * Shusaku*. Silence. trans. William Johnston. Tokyo: Kodansha International, 1982.
Furuya, Yasuo, ed. and trans. A History of Japanese Theology. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997.
Grayson, James H. Early Buddhism and Christianity in Korea: A Study in the Emplantation of Religion. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1985.
Hardacre, Helen. Lay Buddhism in Contemporary Japan: Reiyukai* Kyodan*, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1984.
———. Kurozumikyo* and the New Religions of apan. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1986.
Hefner, Robert W, ed. Conversion to Christianity: Historical and Anthropological Perspectives on the Great Transformation. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1993.
Heise, David R. "Prefatory Findings in the Sociology of Missions." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 6/1 (1967) 49–76.
Hexham, Irving and Karla Poewe, New Religions as Global Cultures: Making the Human Sacred. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1997.
Hori Ichiro*. Folk Religion in Japan: Continuity and Change. Joseph M. Kitagawa and Alan L. Miller, eds. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1968.
Howes, John F. "Japanese Christians and American Missionaries." In Marius B. Jansen, ed. Changing Japanese Attitudes toward Modernization. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1965.
———. "Japanese Christianity and the State: From Jesuit Confrontation / Competition to Uchimura's NonInstitutional Movement / Protestantism." In Steven Kaplan, ed. Indigenous Responses to Western Christianity. New York: New York University Press, 1995.
Iglehart, Charles W A Century of Protestant Christianity in Japan. Tokyo: Charles E. Tuttle, 1959.
Ikado Fujio [Religion in a secular society]. Tokyo: Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan Shuppankyoku, 1972.
Ikegami Yoshimasa [A stage for demons and the Holy Spirit: The world of salvation as seen in popular Okinawan Christianity]. Tokyo: Dobutsusha*, 1991.
Inoue Nobutaka [Deciphering the new religions]. Tokyo: Chikuma Shobo*, 1992.
Inoue Nobutaka [Dictionary of New Religions]. Tokyo: Kobundo*, 1990.
James, Wendy and Douglas H. Johnson, eds. Vernacular Christianity: Essays in the Social Anthropology of Religion Presented to Godfrey Lienhardt. Oxford: JASO Occasional Papers No. 7, 1988.
Kishimoto, Hideo, ed. Japanese Religion in the Meiji Era. Trans. and adapted by John F. Howes. Tokyo: Obunsha *, 1956.
Kudo* Eiichi [Studies in the economic history of Japanese Christian society: The early Meiji period]. Tokyo:
Shinkyo* Shuppansha, 1980.
Kumazawa Yoshinobu and David L. Swain, eds., Christianity in Japan, 1971–1990. Tokyo: Kyo Bun Kwan, 1991.
Kuyama Yasushi ). [Modern Japan and Christianity: The Meiji period]. Tokyo: Sobunsha*, 1956
Lee, Robert. Stranger in the Land: A Study of the Church in Japan. London: Lutterworth Press, 1967.
Luttio, Mark D. ''The Passage of Death in the Japanese Context: In Pursuit of an Inculturated Lutheran Funeral Rite." The Japan Christian Review 62 (1996), 18– 29.
Montgomery, Robert L. "The Spread of Religions and Macrosocial Relations." Sociological Analysis 52 (1991), 37–53.
———. The Diffusion of Religions: A Sociological Perspective. New York: University Press of America, 1996.
Morioka Kiyomi 109 (1972), 52–77.
———. Religion in Changing Japanese Society. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1975.
———. [Japan's modern society and Christianity]. Tokyo: Hyoronsha*, 1976.
Mullins, Mark R. "Japan's New Age and NeoNew Religions: Sociological Interpretations." In James R. Lewis and J. Gordon Melton, eds. Perspectives on the New Age. Albany: State University of New York, 1992.
———. "Ideology and Utopianism in Wartime Japan: An Essay on the Subversiveness of Christian Eschatology." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 21/2–3 (1994), 261–80.
Mullins, Mark R., Shimazono Susumu, and Paul Swanson, eds. Religion and Society in Modern Japan. Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press, 1993.
Mullins, Mark R. and Richard Fox Young, eds. Perspectives on Christianity in Korea and Japan: The Gospel and Culture in East Asia. Lewiston, New York: Edwin Mellen Press, 1995.
Munakata, Iwao. "The Ambivalent Effects of Modernization on Traditional Folk Religion." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 3/2–3 (1976), 99–126.
Nishiyama Shigeru. "Indigenization and Transformation of Christianity in a Japanese Community." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 12/1(1985), 17–61.
Ohama * Tetsuya [Studies in the history of Christian churches in the Meiji Period]. Tokyo: Yoshikawa Kobunkan*, 1979.
Ohara Shin [The life of Uchimura Kanzo*]. Tokyo: PHP Kenkyusho*, 1992.
Omura* Eisho* [The religion of people today]. Tokyo: Yuhikaku*, 1988.
Pelikan, Jaroslav. Jesus through the Centuries: His Place in the History of Culture. New York: Harper and Row, 1985.
Phillips, James M. From the Rising of the Sun: Christians and Society in Contemporary Japan. Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books, 1981.
Plath, David W "Where the Family of God is the Family: The Role of the Dead in Japanese Households." American Anthropologist 66 (1964), 300–317.
Poewe, Karla, ed. Charismatic Christianity as a Global Culture. Columbia, South Carolina: University of South Carolina Press, 1994.
Powles, Cyril H. "Foreign Missionaries and Japanese Culture in the Late Nineteenth Century: Four Patterns of Approach." The Northeast Journal of Theology (September 1969), 14–28.
Reader, Ian. Religion in Contemporary Japan. London: Macmillan Press, 1991.
Reid, David. New Wine: The Cultural Shaping of Japanese Christianity. Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press, 1991.
Sakurai Tokutaro* [Folk religion and society], vol. 5. Tokyo: Kobunsha*, 1980.
Saniel, Josefa M. "The Mobilization of Traditional Values in the Modernization of Japan." In Robert N. Bellah, ed. Religion and Progress in Modern Asia. New York: The Free Press, 1965.
Sanneh, Lamin. Translating the Message: The Missionary Impact on Culture. Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books, 1989.
Saunders, George R., ed. Culture and Christianity: The Dialectics of Transformation. New York: Greenwood Press, 1988.
Shimazono Susumu [Salvation religions in contemporary society]. Tokyo: Seikyusha*, 1992.
Smith, Robert J. "Something Old, Something New—Tradition and Culture in the Study of Japan." The Journal of Asian Studies 48/4 (1989), 715–23.
Stark, Rodney. "How New Religions Succeed: A Theoretical Model," in David G. Bromley and Phillip E. Hammond, eds. The Future of Religious Movements. Macon, Georgia: Mercer University Press, 1987.
Steward, Charles and Rosalind Shaw, eds. Syncretism/AntiSyncretism: The Politics of Religious Synthesis. London: Routledge, 1994.
Sumiya Mikio [Christianity and the formation of modern Japan]. Tokyo: Shinkyo * Shuppansha, 1961.
Swyngedouw, Jan. [The structure of harmony and apportionment]. Tokyo: Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan* Shuppankyoku, 1981.
———. "The Quiet Reversal: A Few Notes on the NHK Survey of Japanese Religiosity." Japan Missionary Bulletin 39/1 (1985), 4–13.
Takeda Kiyoko [Indigenization and apostasy]. Tokyo: Shinkyo Shuppansha, 1967.
Tamaru Noriyoshi and David Reid, eds. Religion in Japanese Culture: Where Living Traditions Meet a Changing World. Tokyo: Kodansha International, 1996.
Thelle, Notto R. Buddhism and Christianity in Japan: From Conflict to Dialogue, 1854–1899. Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press, 1987.
Turner, Harold W "New Religious Movements in Primal Societies." In John R. Hinnells, ed. A Handbook of Living Religions. London: Penguin Books, 1984.
Wallace, Anthony F. C. "Revitalization Movements." American Anthropologist 58 (1956), 264–81.
Walls, Andrew F. The Missionary Movement in Christian History: Studies in the Transmission of Faith. Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books, 1996.
Yamamori, Tetsunao. Church Growth in Japan: A Study in the Development of Eight Denominations, 1859–1939. South Pasadena: William Carey Library, 1974.
Young, Richard Fox. "The LittleLad Deity and the Dragon Princess: Jesus in a New World Renewal Movement," Monumenta Nipponica 44/1 (1989), 31–44.
———. "The 'Christ' of the Japanese New Religions," in Mark R. Mullins and Richard Fox Young, eds. Perspectives on Christianity in Korea and Japan: The Gospel and Culture in East Asia. Lewiston, New York: Edwin Mellen Press, 1995.
[The religious consciousness of the Japanese]. Tokyo: NHK, 1984.
Acknowledgments
The author and publisher wish to thank the following institutions and individuals for permission to reproduce the photographs and illustrations on the following pages of this volume:
pp. 56, 57, 65, 141 Courtesy of the International Christian University Library, Uchimura Kanzo * Collection, Tokyo pp. 74, 79, 80 Courtesy of The Way, Matsumura Kaiseki and Dokai* Archives, Tokyo pp. 83–85, 90, 91 Courtesy of Christ Heart Church, Kawai Shinsui Archives, Fujiyoshida
p. 109 Courtesy of Rev. Hideo Nakamura, Holy Ecclesia of Jesus, Kyoto
pp. 119, 121, 124, 125 Courtesty of Mr. Yuro* Jacob Teshima, Gilboa Institute of Humanities, Fujisawa p. 134 Courtesy of Toen* Shobo*, Tokyo
p. 194 Courtesy of the Shingo Tourist Association, Shingo Village, Aomori Prefecture
[Photographs on pp. 104, 113, 126, 142, 145, 146 are from the author's personal collection.]
The author would like to express appreciation to the following publishers and journals for permission to use and adapt previously published materials in this volume: "The Situation of Christianity in Contemporary Japanese Society." Japan Christian Quarterly 55/2 (1989).
"Japanese Pentecostalism and the World of the Dead: A Study of Cultural Adaptation in Iesu no Mitama Kyokai*." Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 17/4 (1990).
"The Transplantation of Religion in Comparative Sociological Perspective." Japanese Religions 16/2 (1990).
"The Sociology of Church Growth: An Introduction to the Literature." Japan Christian Quarterly 56/1 (1990).
"Christianity as a New Religion: Charisma, Minor Founders, and Indigenous Movements." In Mark R. Mullins, Shimazono Susumu, and Paul Swanson, eds. Religion and Society in Modern Japan. Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press, 1993.
"The Social Forms of Japanese Christianity." In John Breen and Mark Williams, eds. Japan and Christianity: Impacts and Responses. London: Macmillan Press, 1995.
"The Empire Strikes Back: Korean Pentecostal Mission to Japan." Japanese Religions 17/1 (1992) and in Karla Poewe, ed. Charismatic Christianity as a Global Culture, University of South Carolina Press, 1994.
"Christianity Transplanted: Toward a Sociology of Success and Failure." In Mark R. Mullins and Richard Fox Young, eds. Perspectives on Christianity in Korea and Japan. Lewiston: Edwin Mellen Press, 1995.
Index
A
Adams, Daniel J., 255
Adventism, 228
Adventists, 14, 20
African Christianity, 34, 3233, 129, 156, 198200, 228, 231, 248, 25760
Agonshu * , 132, 247
Ama no minakanushi , 76
Amida Buddha. See Buddha
Amulets, 80, 138, 251
Anabaptism, 59
Analects, 51;
Kawai Shinsui's lectures on, 205, 228
See also Confucian/Confucianism;
Confucius
Ancestor(s)/ancestral, 34, 39, 42, 53, 102, 12833, 13539, 14245, 14752, 155, 164, 169, 17576, 199, 206, 226, 24647, 259; cult, 42, 132, 226; rites, 92, 136;
veneration of, 34, 102, 130, 138, 143, 169; worship, 13233, 24647;
spirits, 137; tablets, 136, 138, 169
Angels, 124, 152, 155
Anglican Church, 18, 20, 22, 2627, 33, 144, 157, 159, 208, 212, 225
Anzai Shin , 103, 210, 221, 240, 24849, 251, 261
Apocalyptic, 41, 51, 60, 67, 106, 115, 195, 259
Apostasy, 4, 29, 70, 104, 222, 265
Apostolic Christianity, 41; indigenous movements and, 5152, 97, 128; Holy Ecclesia of Jesus and, 107, 10911;
Original Gospel Movement and, 11721
Arahitogami (living god), 19
Ariga Tetsutaro* , 96, 238
Asahara Shoko* , 195, 258
Ascetic(s) / asceticism, 42, 76, 87, 91, 123, 125, 195, 236
Atonement, 1415, 70, 74, 78, 152, 234
Attendance (at religious services), 16061, 16366, 208, 25051
Aum Shinrikyo* , 195, 258
B
Baba Toshihiko , 214, 244
Bakuhan , 7
Ballagh, James, 13, 38, 42, 71, 234
Ballhatchet, Helen, 233
Bands, three, 16, 219;
Kumamoto B., 16;
Sapporo B., 1617, 5657, 69, 219;
Yokohama B., 16, 38, 42, 7172, 23031
Baptism, 1718, 29, 49, 5152, 57, 59, 78, 80, 82, 9293, 9899, 1012, 105, 107, 11112, 114, 118, 120, 15053, 155, 157, 164, 174, 177, 186, 206, 20810, 213, 215, 228, 23839, 241, 248, 251, 255; for the dead, 98, 164;
vicarious see Vicarious Baptism. See also Spirit baptism
Baptist Church, 1415, 22, 26, 29, 35, 51, 84, 157, 174, 177, 219
Barrett, David, 23, 32, 199, 260
Bays, Daniel H., 99, 23839
Bediako, Kwame, 231
Bellah, Robert N., 238, 264
Berentsen, J. M., 144, 248, 261
Berger, Peter L., 7, 27, 19697, 259, 261
Bibby, Reginald W., 252
Bible, 2, 1417, 2728, 4041, 4647, 51, 5659, 61, 6366, 71, 74, 78, 8082, 8890, 92, 97101, 10311, 113, 11822, 124, 12728, 130, 136, 138, 145, 14748, 15961, 163, 165, 17273, 186, 18991, 19495, 203, 2056, 20810, 21214, 22829, 23334, 23940, 24445, 25657; B.centered, 59, 64, 66; study of, 165;
biblical theology, 98, 150, 210, 248
See also Scriptures
Bishop, 18, 35, 5859, 67, 1013, 105, 153, 187, 205, 224, 239, 24142
Blasi, Anthony J., 44, 227
Bodhisattvas, 88
Bodily training and discipline. See Kyokenjutsu*
Bokushi (pastor), 103, 242, 255
Bon. See Obon
Bonodori (Obon dance), 194
Book of the Past, 249
Borg, Marcus, 3132, 147
Bromley, David G., 226, 264
Brown, Samuel Robert, 13
Brunner, Emil, 27, 5556, 22930
Buddha, 47, 50, 61, 75, 82, 84, 1089, 19495, 23637, 241;
Amida B. , 65, 1089, 241;
B.mind, 86
Buddhism/Buddhist, 12, 45, 89, 39, 42, 44, 46, 6061, 6566, 7576, 86, 93, 96, 124, 169, 185, 192, 194, 197, 21718, 220, 22425, 227, 231, 241, 247,
249, 253, 25556, 262, 265; altar, 13132, 13839, 14344, 148, 179, 247; funeral B., 8;
Japanese, 2, 44, 46, 65, 218, 227, 247, 255; Kamakura B., 227, 256; priests, 7, 231; rituals, 131; schools, 221; teachings, 195, 237; temples, 7, 22, 170, 192, 251; traditions, 2, 34, 44, 81, 85
See also Zen Buddhism;
Pure Land Buddhism
Bunkotsu (division of ashes), 208
Bushido * (way of the warrior), 42, 62, 6466, 123, 185, 231
See also Samurai
Busshinshu* (Religion of the BuddhaMind), 86
See also Zen Buddhism
Butsu , 241
See Buddha
Butsudan (Buddhist altar), 136, 140, 143
See also Buddhism/Buddhist, altar
C
Caldarola, Carlo, 56, 6465, 68, 9697, 161, 165, 185, 190, 202, 214, 222, 230, 232, 244, 246, 25051, 256, 261
Calling on the name, 1078, 110, 241
See also Nembutsu Canon:
scriptural, 28, 4142, 46, 4849, 51, 66, 88, 232, 234, 237;
c. within the c., 42, 66
Cary, Otis, 219, 261 Catechumens, 165
Celibacy, 91, 114
Chanting, 52, 89, 92, 1089, 113, 118, 148, 179, 241, 243
Charisma/charismatic, 31, 33, 35, 37, 39, 41, 4345, 4748, 51, 53, 63, 67, 99, 187, 189, 224, 22728, 256, 266; churches, 179, 25960; features, 4849; founders, 9, 33, 40, 210; institutional, 45, 227; leaders, 10, 33, 4344, 190; movement, 216; routinization of, 4346, 67
Chian'ijiho* (Peace Preservation Law), 19
China/Chinese, 7, 9, 44, 56, 60, 62, 70, 75, 80, 97, 99, 1068, 115, 124, 173, 21820, 225, 228, 23839, 241, 244, 260
Chinkon (spirit pacification), 249
Cho, Paul Yonggi, 172, 17677, 181, 25355
Christ Heart Church (Kirisutoshin Shukyodan*), 2526, 28, 3839, 45, 47, 4951, 69, 81, 8385, 8789, 9193, 13943, 162, 18689, 2045, 225, 227, 23538, 25152, 255, 266
Christendom, 4, 29, 227
Christian Canaan Church (Kirisuto Kanan* Kyokai*), 25, 4950, 52, 97, 140, 186, 188, 209, 252
Christian schools, 22021
Christianity, passim; as antifamily, 137;
as a deviant religion, 5, 12, 16870;
dilemmas of C. in Japan, 130, 167, 191, 218, 226; as a foreign religion, 3, 66, 171, 217, 241;
as a new religious movement, 3, 31, 33, 16768, 17071; as a proscribed religion, 7, 16869, 241; as a Western religion, 9, 199
Christianization, 35, 61, 102, 109, 141, 124, 156, 175
Christmind, 86
Christology, 78, 227, 234, 258
Churchsect theory, 26, 104, 22223
Civil religion, 1920, 169
Clark, William, S. 17, 42, 56, 69, 230
Clergy, 14, 16, 18, 45, 5759, 63, 102, 112, 180, 186, 193, 231, 240, 24243; c.centered, 180;
c.laity, 186, 206
Common religion, 226, 239
See also Folk religion/religiosity
Conflict, 15, 19, 2829, 33, 3839, 47, 71, 7475, 105, 115, 136, 141, 143, 16869, 232, 244
Confucian/Confucianism, v, 9, 3940, 42, 48, 6062, 6465, 7071, 73, 7576, 8081, 85, 92, 96, 12324, 150, 18586, 189, 225, 23132, 23435, 238, 255
Confucius, 5051, 75, 82, 84, 2045, 228, 23435, 238
See also Analects
Congregationalist, 18, 35, 60, 230
Contextual(ization), 6, 15758, 167, 175, 198
Conversion, 34, 66, 70, 76, 148, 158, 165, 167, 174, 187, 20910, 215, 217, 23031, 241, 243, 248, 262 Covenant of Believers, 17, 5758, 219, 230
Creed(s), 8, 17, 3435, 40, 45, 47, 51, 69, 84, 87, 111, 126, 179, 226, 231, 236, 254
Crosscultural, 14, 198, 260
Crucifix, 111, 146
Cult of the dead, 218
See also Dead
Curse. See Tatari
Cyclical rites, 137, 14041, 248
See also Rites/Rituals
D
Daiseikai , 152
Dance, 101, 19394, 258
Danielou, Jean, 184, 255
Danka seido (temple registration system), 7
Davies, Stevan L., 224, 227
Davis, Winston B., 132, 168, 180, 217, 222, 247, 251, 253, 255, 261
Dayton, Donald, 200, 260
Deacons/deaconesses, 67, 103, 173, 239
Dead, v, 8, 85, 9293, 98, 102, 110, 112, 116, 12933, 13555, 164, 174, 176, 181, 186, 206, 209, 211, 218, 24649, 251, 264, 266; baptism for, see Baptism.
Death, 63, 71, 77, 91, 100, 103, 109, 120, 122, 13537, 13940, 143, 145, 151, 153, 16061, 16566, 187, 18990, 192, 208, 213, 225, 232, 234, 237, 241,
243, 245, 24749, 252, 256, 258, 261, 263
Dejudaization, 3
Demonology, 17576
Demons, 98, 174, 216, 229, 238, 248, 254, 262
Denomination/denominationalism, 13, 1516, 20, 22, 24, 26, 28, 31, 3435, 3738, 41, 47, 60, 62, 12627, 144, 159, 163, 167, 173, 18990, 192, 21819, 224, 229, 233, 250, 252, 261
DeVos, George A., 227, 246, 256
Dewesternization, 3, 39
Dialogue, 122, 176, 198, 200, 217, 265
Dispensationalism, 42, 99101, 239
Displacement theology, 36, 60, 85
Dochakuka See Indigenization/Indigenous
Doerner, David L., 144, 248, 261
Dohi Akio 233, 261
Dojo * (practice hall), 92, 162, 247, 251, 255, 261
Dokai* (The Way), 3, 2526, 28, 3738, 42, 4951, 6162, 6970, 7382, 84, 8688, 102, 108, 118, 121, 140, 16162, 165, 167, 18589, 2034, 225,
229, 23334, 250, 266
Doshisha* University, 16, 72, 105, 136, 232, 261
Dunn, James D. G., 41, 67, 224, 226, 232
E
Earhart, H. Byron, 33, 39, 43, 132, 22426, 247, 261
Ebina Danjo* , 64, 23031
Ecclesiasticism, 59, 66, 231
Ecumenism/ecumenical, 8, 29, 40, 93, 110, 158, 198, 200, 260
Elderly, 141, 16263, 18990
Elders, 35, 103, 122, 154, 173, 239, 242
Elite religiosity, 40
Emperor system, 18, 30, 169
Emplantation of religion, 170, 198, 262
Endo* Shusaku* , 221, 252, 262
Enlightenment, 81, 8990, 195
See also Satori
Episcopalianism, 37, 230
Equinoxrelated rituals, 131, 137, 208
See also Higan
Eschatology, 98100, 105, 11415, 221, 263
Established church, 174, 191, 243
Evangelicals/evangelicalism, 9, 1415, 20, 22, 27, 29, 34, 5758, 66, 69, 97, 99, 135, 144, 15859, 167, 180, 185, 208, 214, 250, 252
Evangelism/evangelists, 14, 17, 2324, 345, 63, 71, 97, 1012, 1047, 112, 11415, 122, 139, 143, 148, 158, 161, 163, 165, 170, 17274, 17879, 181, 19091, 206, 20810, 212, 215, 230, 234, 23941, 243, 246, 25052, 25557
Exorcism, 3132, 49, 52, 102, 17476, 180, 216, 224, 229, 247, 259, 261
F
Family, 15, 62, 7071, 77, 82, 92, 103, 110, 112, 118, 13133, 13537, 140, 14250, 152, 15455, 169, 175, 179, 18687, 193, 2089, 220, 227, 234, 244, 24647, 256, 264; altar, 137, 144, 146, 148
Feminism, 64, 186, 256
Festival(s), 7, 71, 92, 112, 132, 13537, 139, 152, 19293, 251
Fetus(es), rituals for aborted, 13334, 179
Filial duties, piety, 39, 77
Fire walking. See Hiwatari
Folk religion/religiosity, 34, 36, 3940, 42, 9596, 1012, 117, 123, 128, 130, 13233, 138, 147, 180, 186, 193, 19899, 210, 226, 241, 24649, 255, 259, 261
62, 264
See also Common religion
Footwashing, 98, 238
Foreign missionaries, 12, 14, 24, 27, 35, 39, 44, 66, 96, 104, 139, 183, 22425, 264
Fuji, Mount, 46, 86, 141, 227
Fujii Masao, 44, 210, 227, 232, 256
Fujii Takeshi , 232
Fukuzawa Yukichi , 7
Fulfillment theology, 8384, 87, 168, 229
Funeral(s), 8, 80, 103, 112, 137, 144, 154, 190, 247, 263;
f. Buddhism, 8
G
Gender, 185, 255
Gense riyaku (thisworldly benefits), 101
Glorious Gospel Christian Church (Eiko * no Fukuin Kirisutokyo*), 25, 49, 52, 97, 138, 140, 148, 18788, 2057, 252
Gods. See Kami
Gohei (sacred strips of paper), 79
Goryo* shinko* (vengeful spirit cults), 249
Grayson, James H., 176, 25354, 262
H
Hades, 100, 146, 15152, 155, 176
Hakuin , 82, 84, 124, 229
Hardacre, Helen, 13233, 220, 224, 238, 247, 249, 262
Healing, 29, 32, 46, 49, 5152, 98, 1012, 1057, 110, 11820, 133, 148, 17480, 206, 2089, 21516, 224, 238, 24041, 259
Heaven, 29, 50, 58, 77, 84, 87, 90, 1001, 127, 136, 139, 14243, 147, 149, 15152, 155, 220, 24849
Heavenpurgatoryhell, 249
Heise, David R., 159, 250, 262
Heisig, James, 4
Hepburn, James Curtis, 13, 71, 219
Heresy, 12, 27, 29, 120, 168, 214, 218, 223, 23940, 251
Hexham, Irving, 2, 197, 217, 228, 25960, 262
Hidden Christians. See Kakure kirishitan
Hierarchy, 59, 102, 112, 186, 206, 255
Higan , 137, 142
See also Equinoxrelated rituals
Hinduism, 5, 197
Hiwatari (fire walking), 12325
Hoji* (memorial service), 137
See also Memorial rites/services
Hokkaido*, 17, 24, 56, 60, 107, 161
Hokuetsu, 60, 73
Holiness Church, 60, 105, 107, 112, 115, 118, 165, 2056, 226, 240, 243
Holtom, D. C. 20, 30
Holy Ecclesia of Jesus (Sei Iesu Kai), 25, 29, 4950, 52, 97, 105, 10718, 128, 138, 14042, 14445, 149, 154, 16566, 18688, 21112, 226, 24144,
251, 255, 266
Holy image (in Christ Heart Church), 9192
Holy names of God, 108
Holy Spirit, 2829, 48, 52, 78, 87, 89, 97, 1001, 105, 110, 112, 123, 149, 177, 182, 207, 209, 213, 216, 22829, 23839, 24344, 246, 248, 262
Honen * , 44, 84, 124, 229
Hori Ichiro* 130, 153, 180, 226, 241, 246, 249, 255, 262
Hoshino Eiki , 44, 131, 227, 2467
Howes, John F., 160, 203, 250, 26263
Hymn(s)/hymnals, 21, 50, 78, 8081, 92, 117, 123, 140, 14243, 151, 178, 2067, 213, 240, 244, 246, 24849
I
Idols/idolatry, 71, 80, 102, 111, 136, 13839, 184
Ie , 7, 130, 137, 150, 153, 187
Iesu Kirisuto san (A Eulogy on Jesus Christ), 51, 88, 9192, 236
Iglehart, Charles W, 163, 251, 262
Ihai (mortuary tablet). See Ancestral tablets
Ikado Fujio , 220, 238, 262
Ikegami Yoshimasa 216, 222, 229, 248, 262
Imahashi Atsushi , 25, 14849, 188, 215, 244, 248
Immigrants, 2, 5, 162, 181, 218, 254
Incense, 80, 137, 152
Inculturation, 6, 198, 263
Independent church, 16, 38, 57, 73, 82, 107
Independent movement, 56, 111, 206, 245
Indigenization/indigenous, 6, 89, 2627, 30, 40, 44, 6869, 93, 96, 123, 130, 159, 16668, 170, 182, 191, 198, 21718, 22223, 248, 252, 26365; leaders, 6, 40, 66, 123, 138, 145, 147, 184;
movements, viiviii, 811, 2425, 2733, 35, 37, 3943, 45, 4748, 51, 5354, 56, 68, 9697, 101, 130, 13839, 14345, 147, 159, 163, 16567, 184, 187, 191, 195, 19899, 201, 203, 2059, 211, 213, 215, 218, 224, 252, 255, 266
Inoue Nobutaka , 218, 222, 247, 256
Ireisai (festival for the comforting of the spirits), 141
Ise Jingu* (Grand Shrine of Ise), 21
Islam, 1, 5, 197
Israel, 50, 66, 83, 1057, 11518, 12023, 128, 21415, 240, 24346, 251
See also Jews/Judaism
J
Jakyo* (evil religion), 12
James, Wendy, 3, 191, 217, 258
Janes, Captain Leroy Lansing, 16
Jansen, Marius, 39, 225
Japan Ecclesia of Christ (Nihon Kirisuto Shodan*), 25, 4849, 52, 97, 140, 186, 209, 228, 244
Japanese New Religions, 26, 33, 39, 4344, 19495, 250, 25556, 25859, 265
Japanese religiosity, 7, 85, 102, 131, 168, 192, 251, 258, 265
Japanese religious consciousness, 23, 131, 192
Japan Holocaust Museum, 116, 243
Japanization, 21, 39
Jesuits, 12, 203, 219, 262
Jesus movement, 31, 66
Jesusonly, 9899, 239
Jews/Judaism, 3, 5, 32, 105, 11517, 12122, 147, 197, 227, 243, 246;
Jewish traditions, 42, 111, 117, 123
See also Israel;
Zionism
Jichinsai (Shinto ceremony of land purification), 78, 102
Jinmu, Emperor , 71, 12324, 127
Jiriki . See Selfpower
Johnson, Douglas, 3, 191
K
Kaimyo * (posthumous Buddhist name), 144
Kakocho* . See Book of the Past
Kakure kirishitan (hidden Christians), 12, 23, 219, 225, 241, 250
Kami (god, gods), 75, 77, 108, 130
Kamidana (kamishelf or altar), 136
Kashiwade (clapping of hands Shintostyle), 79
Kawai Hideo , 188, 205, 23536
Kawai Shinsui , 25, 38, 42, 4547, 4951, 69, 81, 83, 124, 139, 162, 187, 2045, 225, 22728, 232, 23538, 252, 266
Kawai Yoshinobu , 188, 205, 23536
Kechimyakusojo* (fatherson blood lineage), 187
Kelley, Dean M., 158, 249
Kellner, Hansfried, 27, 261
Kiken shiso* (dangerous thoughts), 19
Kimigayo (anthem to the emperor), 21
Kitagawa, Joseph M., 35, 225, 262
Kodo* (Imperial Way), 19
Koike Tatsuo , 25, 188, 20910, 228, 244
Kojiki (Records of Ancient Matters), 123
Komoto* Mitsugu , 226, 247, 262
Konmoto Kaoru , 25, 188, 21213
Korea, 4, 7, 15, 33, 60, 156, 17172, 174, 17782, 198, 221, 25354, 26263, 26566;
Christianity, 172, 175;
Pentecostalism, 173, 175, 177, 179, 253
Kurozumikyo* , 94, 132, 238, 247, 262
Kuyo* (Buddhist memorial service), 179, 24647
Kyodan*. See Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan
Kyokenjutsu* (bodily training and discipline), 42, 85, 238
Kyoyukai* (Assocation of Friends), 62, 160, 202, 229
L
Laity, 5, 1023, 173, 180, 186, 240, 242
Learning of the Heart. See Shingaku
Levitical priesthood, 66
LifeGiving Christ (Ikasu Kirisuto), 25, 49, 52, 140, 148, 186, 188, 215, 244
Linear rites, 137, 14142
Liturgy, 51, 14344, 226
Living Christ One Ear of Wheat Church
(Ikeru Kirisuto
Ichibaku Kyokai*), 25, 49, 52, 97, 140, 143, 18688, 207, 209
Living god. See Arahitogami
Logos Theological Seminary, 113, 117, 212, 24244, 255
Luther, 75, 87, 228
Lutheran Church, 14, 22, 2627, 37, 144, 263
Luttio, Mark, 144, 248, 263
M
Makuya (tabernacle). See Original Gospel Movement
Malevolent spirits. See Onryo*
Man'yoshu* (Collection of Myriad Leaves), 123
MariaKannon , 110
Martin, David, 17172, 253
Maruyama Masao , 7, 217
Matsubara Kazuhito , 25, 18788, 2079
Matsumura Kaiseki , 25, 38, 42, 46, 4951, 6882, 88, 91, 93, 96, 98, 161, 18788, 2034, 225, 229, 23234, 266
Matsumura Kichisuke , 51, 204, 229, 234
Meditation, 50, 65, 77, 8081, 8385, 8890, 9293, 114, 139, 206, 237
Meiji, constitution, 19; government, 12, 18, 169;
Restoration, 7, 30, 70, 169
Meiso* 89. See also Meditation
Memorial rites/services, vii, 92, 112, 131, 133, 135, 137, 148, 15255, 206, 2089, 213 Mencius, 234
Menorah, 111, 121, 143
Methodist Church, 1416, 27, 35, 42, 57, 82, 97, 157, 230, 239
Millennium, 100, 259
Ministers, 58, 112, 163, 165, 180, 186, 212, 242
Minor founders, 3031, 33, 35, 37, 39, 4147, 51, 53, 55, 224, 228, 266
Miracles, 46, 52, 96, 98, 100101, 110, 147, 174, 180, 228, 233, 24041 Missiology, 6, 176, 198, 223, 240, 250, 253, 255 Missionary:
leadership, 13, 38;
movement, 3, 23, 3233, 35, 217, 219, 221, 260, 265; orientation 4; tradition 144, 148
Mission churches, 34, 89, 1213, 17, 20, 2324, 28, 3233, 3637, 40, 43, 4547, 55, 60, 6364, 66, 6869, 82, 87, 9293, 9698, 111, 11820, 130, 136,
166, 218, 233, 235
Mission organizations, 1415, 32, 256
Miyake Hitoshi , 130, 226, 246
Miyazaki Akira , 185, 255
Mizuko (aborted and stillborn children), 133, 151, 179, 24647
Modernization, 8, 1819, 39, 70, 94, 131, 135, 19697, 203, 220, 225, 259, 262, 264
Montgomery, Robert L., 5, 170, 253, 263
Morioka Kiyomi , 136, 157, 168, 21719, 22223, 24647, 250, 252, 263
Mormons, 14, 26, 214, 248, 259
Mortuary tablet. See Ihai
Muenbotoke (nameless or unknown dead), 154
Mukyokai *
See Nonchurch movement
Murai Jun , 25, 29, 42, 46, 50, 97103, 147, 150, 188, 210, 224, 23839, 248 Mystics/mysticism, 87, 196, 226, 228, 242, 244
N
Nagahara Shin , 127, 246
Nakada Juji* , 60, 105, 115, 205, 240, 243
Nakahara Masao , 25, 42, 188, 215
Nakamaki Hirochika , 247, 262
Nakamura Katsumi , 228, 231
Namedevotion, 241
See Holy names of God, Nembutsu
Nationalism, 4, 1820, 30, 39, 43, 64, 125, 127, 182, 198, 221, 224
Nembutsu (invocation of the name of the Buddha), 42, 1089, 225, 241;
n. kirisutokyo* , 107
See also Calling on the name
NeoConfucianism, 42, 51, 72, 76, 78, 81, 84, 93, 231, 234
Nestorian Christianity, 12, 219
New Religions, new religious movements, 8, 2223, 26, 3334, 3940, 4344, 47, 70, 7375, 9496, 13133, 137, 153, 16872, 17982, 19496, 203, 21718,
222, 22426, 228, 23334, 238, 247, 250, 25253, 25556, 25859, 26162, 26466
Nichiren , 39, 4445, 82, 84, 124, 227, 229
Niebuhr, H. Richard, 34, 218, 223
Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan* (United Church of Christ in Japan), 2022, 94, 157, 205, 210, 21314, 218, 227, 236, 255, 262, 265
Nihon shoki (Chronicles of apan), 123
Niijima Jo* , 15, 17, 72, 13637
Nikolai, Bishop, 18
Nishiyama Shigeru , 144, 222, 226, 24748, 262, 264
Nitobe Inazo* , 24, 29, 55, 221
Nonchurch movement (Mukyokai), 2526, 2829, 42, 4749, 5457, 59, 6265, 6869, 82, 93, 96, 111, 11820, 13840, 143, 147, 15961, 16465, 185
91, 198, 202, 206, 210, 22832, 245, 250, 25557
O
O* Yomei* (Chin., Wang YangMing), 51, 72, 76
Obon (festival of the dead), 92, 131, 137, 14143, 152
O'Dea, Thomas F., 226
Ohama * Tetsuya , 219, 264
Ohara Shin , 63, 203, 23031, 245, 248, 264
Okinawa Christian Gospel (Okinawa Kirisutokyo* Fukuin), 25, 49, 52, 140, 188, 215, 229, 248 Omisogi (purification ritual), 123, 125
Omoto* no kami , 76
Omura* Eisho* , 226, 247, 264
Onryo* (malevolent spirits), 13132, 153, 175, 247, 249
Original Gospel Movement (Genshi Fukuin), 2526, 29, 37, 42, 4849, 5152, 96, 11827, 13841, 143, 148, 15354, 16465, 186, 188, 210, 21315, 225, 22829, 24446, 25052, 25556
Oshikawa Masayoshi , 8283, 205, 23435
OtherPower, 65, 69, 76, 87, 93, 109, 234, 238
Otsuka* Makoto , 117, 205, 225, 243
Otsuki* Fudeko , 141, 211
Otsuki Takeji , 25, 42, 46, 50, 10512, 11416, 118, 141, 154, 165, 18788, 211, 24044
Ouchi* Saburo* , 204, 232
P
Pacifism, 57, 5960, 230
Pastor. See Bokushi
Peace Preservation Law. See Chian'ijiho*
Pentecostalism, 3233, 42, 99, 101, 17275, 17779, 181, 196, 211, 239, 253, 266
Pilgrimage, 58, 110, 118, 12122, 154, 237, 244, 251
Poewe, Karla, 2, 197, 217, 228, 25960, 262, 264, 266
Powles, Cyril H., 34, 22425, 264
Prayer, 46, 52, 71, 80, 8990, 92, 98, 102, 106, 10910, 113, 117, 142, 144, 147, 149, 15254, 17377, 179, 234, 23637, 243, 254; p.mountain, 17779
Presbyterian Church, 1314, 16, 18, 2627, 29, 35, 37, 69, 71, 157, 172, 175, 178, 230
Prophets/prophecy, 43, 48, 50, 52, 66, 1056, 216, 228, 232, 243; prophetic tradition, 32, 51, 66, 160, 174 Proselytization, 5, 66, 96, 156, 172, 252 Protestant:
churches, 17, 2324, 9596, 11112, 156, 172, 239, 242, 251; denominations, 7, 18, 20, 48, 181;
missionaries, 7, 1213, 1617, 3435, 50, 70, 95, 135, 138, 145, 169, 171, 184, 198, 219, 253; missionary theology and the ancestors, 13639, 14344, 148, 153, 169, 24748; theology, 87, 13738
Protestantism, 16, 34, 59, 64, 70, 96, 175, 198, 203, 214, 220, 238, 245, 253, 262 Pure Land Buddhism, 2, 65, 87, 1089, 187, 236.
See also Buddhism
Purgatory, 236, 249
Purification, 74, 76, 102, 123, 12526
Puritanism, 59, 64
Q
Quakers, Quakerism, 14, 57, 5960, 230
R
Reader, Ian, 132, 226, 239, 247, 258, 264
Reformation, 32, 59, 155, 230;
Reformed theology, 42, 93
Reibosama (spiritual mother), 14041
Reid, David, 15, 20, 144, 218, 226, 246, 248, 26465
Reifusama (spiritual father), 141
Reikon (spirit or soul), 247
Reinosha* (spirit medium), 235
Reiyukai* , 132, 249, 262
Religion of the BuddhaMind. See Busshinshu*
Religious experience, 41, 4447, 52, 58, 61, 75, 82, 93, 101, 106, 17980, 224, 22628
Religious leaders, vii, 102, 112, 182, 227, 229, 242
Rereligionization, 197
Revelation(s), 4041, 45, 4851, 59, 71, 73, 75, 83, 88, 97, 101, 1057, 115, 121, 132, 148, 184, 19495, 215, 226, 23940, 243, 249; continuing, 48, 50, 83, 107
Rites/rituals, 5, 710, 1921, 30, 32, 37, 40, 42, 46, 49, 52, 55, 59, 78, 80, 9293, 98, 1012, 112, 118, 123, 125, 128, 13033, 13537, 13944, 14748, 15055, 168, 175, 180, 186, 19293, 206, 226, 234, 238, 244, 24748, 251, 255, 258 263
See also Cyclical rites;
Linear rites
Roman Catholic:
Church, 78, 12, 15, 18, 20, 2324, 2627, 29, 3233, 4142, 59, 67, 75, 87, 15455, 16869, 172, 181, 183, 198, 219, 236, 24142, 244, 249, 251; mission, 12; missionaries, 16869
Russian Orthodox Church, 18
S
Sabbath, 7172, 9899, 101, 118, 23840, 244
Sacraments, 59, 78, 92, 99, 102, 11112, 55, 186, 206, 213, 219, 230, 238, 240
Saints/sainthood, 14, 50, 77, 8285, 87, 113, 126, 142, 15455, 167, 229, 242, 244, 252, 258
Sakurai Tokutaro * , 210, 261, 264
Salvation, 2, 14, 29, 3839, 45, 47, 59, 65, 77, 86, 100, 1056, 1089, 11215, 117, 119, 136, 140, 14546, 14955, 171, 176, 180, 216, 222, 225, 229, 237
38, 24143, 248, 254, 262, 264
Samurai, 40, 58, 62, 70, 9596, 169, 231, 23435
See also Bushido*
Sanctification, 1056, 126, 213
Sanctifying Christ Church (Sei naru Kirisuto Kyodan*), 25, 49, 52, 97, 140, 188, 21213, 248
Satori (enlightenment), 45, 65, 81, 9091, 237
See also Enlightenment
Schism, 13, 105, 175
Scriptures, 2, 28, 32, 3436, 41, 4648, 5051, 66, 75, 80, 100, 106, 119, 139, 142, 212, 228, 241
See also Bible
Secularization, 22, 16869, 19697, 220, 259
Seijin shiki (coming of age ceremony), 112
Seiyo* suhai* (worship of the West), 17
Seiza (quiet sitting), 77
Seizensetsu (human nature as essentially good), 76
Selfcultivation, 51, 6869, 71, 73, 7579, 8183, 85, 8791, 93, 101, 232, 238, 252
Selfpower, 65, 69, 87, 93, 232
Seminaries/seminarians, ix, 17, 58, 72, 1056, 11314, 117, 153, 174, 176, 186, 190, 205, 209, 21214, 22021, 23940, 24245, 250, 25355
Senzo no migawari senrei (vicarious baptism for the ancestors), 150
Seshu* (religious succession based on blood or heredity), 189
Seven Great Vows. See Shichi daiseigan SeventhDay Adventists, 99, 157
Shamans/shamanism, 42, 63, 96, 17581, 18586, 216, 25354
Shukyo* dantai ho* (Religious Organizations Law), 19
Shukyo hojin* ho (Religious Juridical Persons Law), 22
Shutoku* (cultivation of moral character), 76
Shenk, Wilbert R., 3, 217
Shichi daiseigan (Seven Great Vows), 51, 88, 2367
Shichigosan (Shinto festival for girls of seven and three and boys of five), 112
Shikoryo* (four basic teachings), 75
Shillony, BenAmi, 243
Shimazono Susumu , ix, 26, 39, 4445, 218, 222, 225, 227, 238, 24647, 258, 26364, 266
Shingaku (Learning of the Heart), 93, 238
Shinto, 78, 1819, 2122, 30, 34, 36, 3940, 42, 7581, 93, 96, 112, 136, 13839, 16870, 185, 192, 22021, 22425, 248, 251, 261; disestablishment of State S., 1819, 2122, 30, 39, 16970; shrines, 8, 21, 93;
S.related schools, 221
Shugoshin (protective spirit), 130, 132, 155, 235
Single practice sect, 169
Smith, Robert J., 9, 246, 264
Soka * Gakkai , 45, 168
Spirit baptism, 5152, 9899, 101, 107, 118, 120, 150, 20910, 213, 239, 241, 251
Spirit of Jesus Church (Iesu no Mitama Kyokai*), 2526, 29, 4950, 52, 9798, 100104, 128, 138, 140, 147, 15051, 153, 155, 16364, 18688, 210, 22324, 23840, 242, 24849, 251, 255, 261
Spirits of the dead, 129, 13233, 137, 14748, 15153, 155; festival for the comforting of, see Ireisai; ill will of, see Urami; malevolent, see Onryo*; pacification of, see Chinkon.; protective, see Shugoshin; vengeful s. cults, see Goryo* shinko*
See also Dead
Stark, Rodney, 4344, 56, 64, 72, 85, 95, 137, 167, 169, 196, 226, 233, 252, 259, 264 Stark, Werner, 43, 227
Sugita Kotaro* , 25, 148, 188, 2057, 248, 252
Suh, David, 175, 254
Sumiya Mikio , 231, 234, 265
Suzuki Norihisa , 232
Swyngedouw, Jan, 8, 192, 218, 247, 258, 265
Syncretism, 67 138, 168, 175, 182, 184, 198, 217, 265
T
Tabernacle Movement. See Original Gospel Movement
Taiwan, 42, 97, 99, 128, 221, 239
Takahashi Mutsuko , 9091, 237 38
Takahashi Saburo* , 16061, 245, 250
Takagi Kenji , 250
Takeda Kiyoko , 131, 222, 24647, 265
Takeda Dosho* , 131, 24647
Takiabi (purification ritual under a waterfall), 125
Tamura Naomi , 232
Taniguchi Toku , 25, 188, 209, 252
Tariki . See OtherPower
Tatari (curse), 131, 15354
Temple registration system. See Danka seido
Tenchi Shusai no Kami (Lord of the universe), 75
Tensokokyo* , 19495
Terauke (temple certification), 7
Teshima Ikuro* , 25, 37, 42, 46, 5152, 11827, 141, 148, 165, 188, 210, 21315, 225, 22829, 238, 24446, 250, 256, 266
Thelle, Notto R., 220, 225, 265
Theological education, 112, 190, 213, 241, 255
Three selfs (selfcontrol, selfpropagation, selfsupport), 2628, 30, 36, 64, 104, 120, 157, 198, 206, 212
Tokugawa period, 7, 12, 18, 93, 169, 234, 241
Tongues, speaking in, vii, 29, 32, 49, 5152, 97101, 118, 120, 164, 174, 17677, 2089, 216, 23839, 241, 253
Trinity, 78, 98, 223, 239, 251
Troeltsch, Ernst, 27, 223
True Jesus Church, 97, 99, 23839
Typology, 10, 2628, 157, 22223
U
Uchimura Kanzo* , 17, 2425, 29, 35, 3738, 42, 4748, 5557, 61, 68, 73, 93, 118, 138, 141, 159, 188, 2024, 210, 22425, 22933, 236, 24546,
248, 250, 264, 266
Unitarianism, 14, 42, 72, 74, 9899, 230, 239
United Church of Christ in Japan. See Nihon Kirisuto Kyodan*
Urami (enmity, ill will of wandering spirit), 131
Urbanization, 13132, 135, 170
Utopianism, 182, 221, 263
V
Vernacular, 1, 37, 9, 217, 258, 263
Vicarious baptism, 76, 102, 142, 15051, 153, 155, 234
Vows, 51, 77, 8889, 9192, 113, 150, 23637
W
Wach, Joachim, 43, 226
Walls, Andrew F., 23, 199, 260
Watanabe Shoko * , 218
Way, The. See Dokai*
Way of the warrior. See Bushido*
Weber, Max, 43, 45, 48, 88, 155, 227
Weddings, 80, 112, 19293
Whitecollar class, 18, 95, 220
Women, 14, 34, 64, 11314, 133, 141, 151, 163, 186, 190, 200, 209, 211, 216, 21920, 232, 238, 242
Y
Yamamori, Tetsunao, 105, 157, 238, 240, 265
Yamato damashii (Japanese spirit), 127
Yanaihara Tadao , 120, 229, 248
Yasukuni Shrine , 93, 127, 249
Yinger, Milton, 166, 252
Yoido Full Gospel Church, 17274, 177, 182, 25355
Yoji* shukufukushiki (special service for blessing infants and children), 112
Yomeigaku* 42, 78, 234
See also O* Yomei*
Z
Zen Buddhism, 2, 65, 8586, 8990, 93, 238
See also Buddhism
Zen Oxherding Pictures, 76
Zionism, 42, 114, 127, 214, 24546
About the Author
Mark R. Mullins is professor of sociology of religion and Christian studies at Meiji Gakuin University, Japan. He is the author of Religious Minorities in Canada (1989), and coeditor of Japanese New Religions Abroad (1991), Religion and Society in Modern Japan (1993), and Perspectives on Christianity in Korea and Japan (1995).
