2026/03/01

Ancient Judaism (Max Weber) - Wikipedia

Ancient Judaism (book) - Wikipedia

Ancient Judaism (book)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Ancient Judaism
First English translation (publ. Free Press)
AuthorMax Weber
Genrereligious history
Publication date
1917

Ancient Judaism (German: Das antike Judentum) is an essay written by the German economist and sociologist Max Weber in the early 20th century. The original edition appeared in the 1917–1919 issues of the Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik. Marianne Weber, his wife, published the essays as Part Three of his Gesammelte Aufsatze zur Religionssoziologie in 1920–1921. An English translation was made in 1952 and several editions were released since then.[1]

It was his fourth and last major work on the sociology of religion, after The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, The Religion of China: Confucianism and Taoism and The Religion of India: The Sociology of Hinduism and Buddhism. In this work he attempts to explain the factors that were responsible for the early differences between Oriental and Occidental religiosity.[2] It is especially visible when the mysticism developed by Western Christianity is compared with the asceticism that flourished within the religious traditions of India.[2] Weber's premature death in 1920 prevented him from following Ancient Judaism with his planned analysis of the Psalms, the Book of Job, Rabbinic Judaism, early Christianity and Islam.

Weber wrote that

Anyone who is heir to traditions of modern European civilization will approach problems of universal history with a set of questions, which to him appear both inevitable and legitimate. These questions will turn on the combination of circumstances which has brought about the cultural phenomena that are uniquely Western and that have at the same time (...) a universal cultural significance[2]

Weber notes that Judaism not only fathered Christianity and Islam, but was crucial to the rise of the modern Western world, as its influence was as important as those of Hellenistic and Greco-Roman civilizations.

Types of asceticism and the significance of ancient Judaism

Weber noted that some aspects of Christianity sought to conquer and change the world, instead of withdrawing from its imperfections. This fundamental distinctiveness of Christianity (when compared to Eastern religions) stems originally from ancient Jewish prophecy. Weber stated his reasons for investigating ancient Judaism:

For the Jew (...) the social order of the world was conceived to have been turned into the opposite of the one promised for the future, but in the future it was to be overturned so that Jewry could be once again dominant. The world was conceived as neither eternal nor unchangeable, but rather as being created. Its present structure was a product of man's actions, above all those of the Jews, and of God's reaction to them. Hence the world was a historical product designed to give way to the truly God-ordained order [...] There existed in addition a highly rational religious ethic of social conduct; it was free of magic and all forms of irrational quest for salvation; it was inwardly worlds apart from the path of salvation offered by Asiatic religions. To a large extent this ethic still underlies contemporary Middle Eastern and European ethics. World-historical interest in Jewry rests upon this fact. [...] Thus, in considering the conditions of Jewry's evolution, we stand at a turning point of the whole cultural development of the West and the Middle East[3]

History and social organization of Ancient Israel

Weber analysed the interaction between the Bedouins, the cities, the herdsmen and the peasants, the conflicts between them, and the rise and fall of United Monarchy of Israel and Judah. The brief time of United Monarchy divided the period of confederacy since the Exodus and the settlement of the Israelites in Canaan from the period of political decline following the division of the monarchy.[4] Weber discusses the organisation of the early confederacy, the unique qualities of Israelite relations to the God of Israel, the influence of foreign cults, types of religious ecstasy and the struggle of the priests against ecstasy and idol worship. Later he describes the times of the Division of the Monarchy, social aspects of Biblical prophecy, social orientation of the prophets, demagogues and pamphleteers, ecstasy and politics, ethic and theodicity of the Prophets.

Those periods were significant for religious history, as the basic doctrines of Judaism that left their mark on Western civilisation arose during those times.[4]

Reinhard Bendix summarising Weber's work writes:

...free of magic and esoteric speculations, devoted to the study of law, vigiliant in the effort to do what was right in the eyes of the Lord in the hope of a better future, the prophets established a religion of faith that subjected man's daily life to the imperatives of a divinely ordained moral law. In this way, ancient Judaism helped create the moral rationalism of Western civilisation[5]

See also

Citations

  1.  Jacob, Edmond (1973). "Max Weber, Le Judaïsme antique, traduit de l'allemand par Freddy Raphael. « Recherches en sciences humaines », 31. Paris, Pion, 1971". Revue d'Histoire et de Philosophie religieuses. 53 (1): 77–79.
  2.  Bendix 1977, p. 200.
  3.  Bendix 1977, p. 204.
  4.  Bendix 1977, p. 213.
  5.  Bendix 1977, p. 256.

References

  • Bendix, Reinhard (1977) [1960]. Max Weber: An intellectual portrait. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-03503-4.

Further reading

Posted by at

Books by Irving M. Zeitlin Goodreads

Books by Irving M. Zeitlin (Author of Ideology and the Development of Sociological Theory) | Goodreads

===

Irving M. Zeitlin
Irving M. Zeitlin
Average rating 3.75 · 111 ratings · 13 reviews · shelved 515 times


Showing 26 distinct works.
sort by 

Ideology and the Developmen...
by 
 3.92 avg rating — 40 ratings — published 1968 — 11 editions
Rulers and Ruled: An Introd...
by 
 4.33 avg rating — 12 ratings — published 1996 — 4 editions
The Historical Muhammad
by 
liked it 3.00 avg rating — 10 ratings — published 2007 — 13 editions
Ideología y teoría sociológica
by 
 3.62 avg rating — 8 ratings — published 1997 — 4 editions
Jesus and the Judaism of Hi...
by 
 3.71 avg rating — 7 ratings — published 1988 — 13 editions
Nietzsche: A Re-examination
by 
really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 6 ratings — published 1994 — 8 editions
Religious Experience, The: ...
by 
 3.50 avg rating — 6 ratings — published 2003 — 2 editions
Jews: The Making of a Diasp...
by 
 3.50 avg rating — 6 ratings — published 2012 — 10 editions
The Social Condition of Hum...
by 
 3.80 avg rating — 5 ratings — published 1981 — 2 editions
Marxism: A Re-Examination
by 
 3.60 avg rating — 5 ratings
Capitalism and imperialism;...
by 
 3.33 avg rating — 3 ratings — published 1972 — 3 editions
Ancient Judaism: Biblical C...
by 
 2.50 avg rating — 2 ratings — published 1984 — 13 editions
Plato's Vision: The Classic...
by 
really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 1 rating — published 1993 — 2 editions



===


===



Read sample
Contents
Acknowledgement
Preface
1 The nature of polytheism
2 The patriarchs and their God
3 Social origins of ethical monotheism
4 The Israelites in Canaan: infiltration or conquest
5 The rise of the monarchy
6 Religion and society under the kings
7 Classical prophecy and the concern for social justice
8 Exile and return
Epilogue
Appendix
Bibliography
Index




Ancient Judaism: Biblical Criticism from Max Weber to the Present Paperback – 25 September 1986
by Irving M. Zeitlin (Author)
5.0 5.0 out of 5 stars (2)

This book is a major contribution to the sociology of religion and to religious and biblical studies. Beginning from the classic work of Max Weber, the author analyses the origins of Judaism in the light of more recent scholarship. The result is a work that will become a standard point of reference in its field, and will be of great interest to the general reader as well as the specialist.
==

Review
'Zeitlin's sociology of Old Testament Judaism is a model of careful scholarship.' Sociological Review

'Irving M. Zeitlin demonstrates courage and a talent for analytical thinking in his extraordinarily interesting Ancient Judaism.' The Jerusalem Post Magazine

From the Inside Flap

This book is a major contribution to the sociology of religion and to religious and biblical studies. Beginning from the classic work of Max Weber, the author analyses the origins of Judaism in the light of more recent scholarship. The result is a work that will become a standard point of reference in its field, and will be of great interest to the general reader as well as the specialist.

Zeitlin sets out to criticize both those modern scholars who have cast doubts on the scriptural account of the history of Israel, and those who hold that the religion of Israel originated either as polytheism or as a fusion of Baal and Yahweh. He finds unconvincing the non-sociological modes of approaching these all-important questions. Following Max Weber's interparative method, Zeitlin strives to grasp the subjective meanings which the actors themselves attributed to their conduct. Drawing on biblical and extra-biblical evidence, he addresses the question of how the actors concerned - whether they were patriarchs, prophets, judges, kings or the people - understood themselves, their world and their faith.

Weber pioneered the application of this method throughout his writings on the sociology of religion and most notably in his own work `Ancient Judaism'. Over sixty years have elapsed since the publication of that book and in the interval significant changes have taken place in the field of biblical scholarship. Zeitlin therefore completes his study with a critique, suggesting that in certain respects Weber's view must be substantially modified.

From the Back Cover
This book is a major contribution to the sociology of religion and to religious and biblical studies. Beginning from the classic work of Max Weber, the author analyses the origins of Judaism in the light of more recent scholarship. The result is a work that will become a standard point of reference in its field, and will be of great interest to the general reader as well as the specialist.

Zeitlin sets out to criticize both those modern scholars who have cast doubts on the scriptural account of the history of Israel, and those who hold that the religion of Israel originated either as polytheism or as a fusion of Baal and Yahweh. He finds unconvincing the non-sociological modes of approaching these all-important questions. Following Max Weber's interparative method, Zeitlin strives to grasp the subjective meanings which the actors themselves attributed to their conduct. Drawing on biblical and extra-biblical evidence, he addresses the question of how the actors concerned - whether they were patriarchs, prophets, judges, kings or the people - understood themselves, their world and their faith.

Weber pioneered the application of this method throughout his writings on the sociology of religion and most notably in his own work `Ancient Judaism'. Over sixty years have elapsed since the publication of that book and in the interval significant changes have taken place in the field of biblical scholarship. Zeitlin therefore completes his study with a critique, suggesting that in certain respects Weber's view must be substantially modified.

About the Author
Irvine Zeitlin is Professor of Sociology at te University of Toronto. His previous publications include Rethinking Sociology (1973), Ideology and the Developement of Sociological Theory (1981), and The Social Conditions of Humanity (1984).
Read less

Product details
Publisher ‏ : ‎ Polity
Publication date ‏ : ‎ 25 September 1986
Edition ‏ : ‎ 1st
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Print length ‏ : ‎ 325 pages

==





Posted by at
Subscribe to: Comments (Atom)