2026/11/20

Holding Faith: Creating Peace in a Violent World : David Gee

Kindle




데이비드 지(David Gee)가 쓰고 세라 기틴스(Sarah Gittins)가 일러스트를 맡은 책 《Holding Faith: Creating Peace in a Violent World》의 킨들 샘플 화면입니다.
===
Holding Faith: Creating Peace in a Violent World : David Gee

• 주제: 폭력적인 세상 속에서 평화에 헌신하는 것의 의미와 비폭력, 관계 및 지구에 대한 실천적 신념을 탐구합니다.
• 표지 일러스트: 카페 창가에서 글을 쓰는 사람과 창밖 도시 풍경이 담긴 판화 스타일의 그림입니다.
• 출판 정보: 2011년 퀘이커 북스(Quaker Books)에서 출간되었습니다
===
It is 350 years since Quakers made their declaration of non-violence to Charles II. What does committing to peace mean in a violent world? How might this commitment shape our relationships with one another, ourselves and the Earth? David Gee argues for a contemporary, practical faith that enlivens our humanity and stands with life’s dignity in the face of its violation.
Holding faith is a new title from Quaker Books and was officially launched at Yearly Meeting Gathering in Canterbury at the beginning of August.
===
David Gee is a writer, campaigner and facilitator. He has worked for Quaker Peace and Social Witness and the Alternatives to Violence Project, and in 2008 produced the influential report, Informed Choice on the ethics of military recruitment.
Paperback

First published August 1, 2011
===
Table of contents

Choosing peace
Peace as the dignity of being
Peace as truthfulness
'Shaken'
Turning around
Peace as commitment
Having faith
Re-imagining faith
Faith is what you trust in
Faith is a revolution
Faith is the story you live in
Faith is what you do
Against a violent faith
A word or the Word?
Facing up to violence
Collective violence
Personal violence
Structured violence
Ecological violence
System of violence
Understanding violence
Violence of the cornered
Violence of the violated
Violence as norm
Violence of rivals
Violence of hubris
Violence as symptom
Coming back to ourselves
Alienation: lost in what we are not
Preparing for peace: confronting spiritua violence
Preparing for peace: making space to be ourselves
Creating peace
Love of God
Love of self
Love of neighbour
Starting again
"Conversation in the world"
"Weapons must be spiritual"
"Seek peace and ensue it"
Holy Experiment
"School for peacemakers"
Thanks
Endnotes

Chapter 1: Choosing peace
Chapter 2: Having faith
Chapter 3: Facing up to violence
Chapter 4: Understanding violence
Chapter 5: Coming back to ourselves
===

David Gee

Goodreads Author


Website

Twitter

Genre

Member Since
June 2021


David Gee is a writer and activist. His previous work has included the Informed Choice report on the ethics of military recruitment and managing the Alternatives to Violence Project. Today he works on the campaign to raise the minimum age of military enlistment to 18. He lives on a boat in Oxford.

http://hopeswork.org

http://slumgullion.blog
...more

Average rating: 4.69 · 13 ratings · 5 reviews · 4 distinct works
Hope's Work: Facing the fut...

by
4.75 avg rating — 8 ratings — 4 editions
Spectacle Reality Resistanc...

by
4.60 avg rating — 5 ratings — published 2014
Informed Choice - Armed For...

by
0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings — published 2007
Holding Faith: creating pea...

by
0.00 avg rating — 0 ratings — published 2011 — 2 editions
==

==
Choosing peace
Fifteen years ago I was one of five thousand people taking part in a demonstration against the new M77 motorway, whose route was cutting through ancient woodland near Glasgow. The march led from the humdrum bustle of the city centre, out into the countryside to the threshold between the half-built motorway's path and the forest.
It was dusk by the time we arrived. The place was on a hill and there were views of miles around. From the far horizon the motorway snaked towards us, a familiar alien ripping through the land. There was such power there. On the other side the protesters, who had been living in the forest for months, were clambering over the limbs of the trees. There was power here, too; a kind of passion for life. They get called 'protesters' - people with a complaint to make - but first of all they are believers.
I felt caught between these two realities; one of that creative passion that flows from life and dignifies us, and the other a kind of sprawling presumption of entitlement to the world. In that moment I felt pressed to choose between them. I had either to stand with life and the living world or dumbly acquiesce to the road's brash violation of it.
This dualistic and emotionally charged response to the road and the forest seems romantically simplistic now. Nonetheless, its essential truth still resonates: that a tension between the free abundance and integrity of life on the one hand and a hollow thoughtlessness that violates life on the other, runs right through the drama of the world and everyone in it.
Peace as the dignity of being
We owe the word 'peace' to the Latin pax, meaning agreement (cf. 'pact') and derived from the Indo-European root pag, meaning 'fetter': something held down or back. From this comes the everyday sense of peace, defined in the negative as a state or place clear of disturbance or volatility. But the biblical Hebrew word shalom (Arabic salaam), meaning something like 'wholeness', is also rendered in English as 'peace'. Unlike the 'peace' of pax, shalom is associated with wholeness, abundance, health, well-being-the integrity of our common aliveness. Biblical uses of shalom imply a sense of the dignity and vibrancy of our being flourishing as it should, which demands not to be violated.
The peace of shalom abounds almost anywhere we choose to look. It is there in the procession of seasons, the intricacies of ecosystems and the precise migrations of birds. It is even there in the laws of physics, simple, fecund and mysterious as they are. The love between parents and children, between friends and for welcoming strangers, and in kids who can turn any spare nook or cranny into a place to play, all testify to the ubiquity of peace as shalom. In these things the dig-nity of our being affirms itself.
Yet around our aliveness, not as part of it, we persistently violate one another, our ecological neighbourhood and ourselves. A concern for the dignity of one another's being is plainly not always leading our choices, nor is it axiomatic in the economic, political, cultural systems we participate in. The global capitalist consensus that powerfully shapes our societies allows the richest 80 people in the world to hold the same collective wealth as the poorest third of the population earns in a year. Here again are two worlds in one: life's integrity and abundance on one hand and on the other its persistent violation. Whether or not we realise it, we create these two worlds in the choices we make every day and also in how societies are organised.
Peace as truthfulness
The authenticity of our humanity is at stake in the choices we make as individuals, communities and societies. From a peace-making point of view, how truthful we are being to ourselves is reflected in how well, with good faith, we create peace and stand against violence. To choose peace, then, is to bend towards a rela-tionship with the world that allows fundamental needs to be met in life-giving rather than life-destroying ways, and to work for a society in which that choice becomes more possible to make. In this light, a commitment to peace is not so much an add-on for a good life, nor an ideological view about the moral failure of violence, but a practical expression of a feeling for what life and society are really about.
Met with violence, our authenticity is tested: will we stand with life in the face of its violation? For every 'for' there is an 'against'. The M77 protesters are doing more than protecting the forest and what it means for them; they are also opposing the life-destroying forces and norms that the motorway represents. Yet the choice between peace and violence, life and death, is not always an obvious one. If the motorway is symptomatic of our collective spiritual and ecological myopia it is still someone's creative project: it generates work; there is an honest feeling of accomplishment when the job is complete; and now most of us use it as if it had always been there.
So in committing to peace there is an authentically necessary confrontation, but it is not between the 'good guys' and the 'bad guys', which is a convenient conceit, but between life and the violation of life between peace and violence. The motorway may not be part of the peace but its engineer is. In standing for peace and against violence, we might stand against what the engineer is doing and not against him as a person. Nonetheless, we are still taking sides.
As the dignity of our being, peace is both received it is in the fabric of the universe and created in the choices we make. Peace-making depends on the authenticity of the relationship we as individuals and societies choose to have with the world: how it dignifies our common being or violates it. Consider this statement by the Quaker John Lynes:
What shook me was a map of the world. In black were the principal arms-exporting nations - in red were the areas where major wars had been fought since 1945. The black and the red areas did not overlap. This was my road to Damascus. Then and there I saw where my choice lay; with the Crucified or with the crucifiers.2
When most of us see such a map we might spend a moment to lament a violent world and pop a few coins in a pot marked 'Donations'. John, in contrast, is left viscerally shaken as if he has seen the world for the first time. Through his experience of the map the violence of the arms trade is communicated with unusual power. This has taken him to a turning point, at which a choice is demanded of him about nothing less than how he will live.
By using the symbols of a faith story, John invites us to imagine our way into the meaning of his experience. In likening the modern trade in arms to the Cruci-fixion, he identifies the human devastation of a business that thrives on war with the violation of a guiltless man nearly 2,000 years ago. His words challenge their reader to further connect the two phenomena as violations of a kind that are pre-meditated, indulgent, legally sanctioned and socially convenient. Like the people who came to watch the crucifixion of Jesus, the arms trade has its casual onlookers - people who stop for a while to gaze at the map and then walk on. But John is held. Were he to walk on from the map, he would be complicit with the crucifiers. Instead, he is pressed to stand with the crucified: with Jesus the peace-maker and with all those affected by war. His authenticity is being tested and he cannot ignore, dodge or forget the choice that faces him without radically di-minishing who he is as a human being. His commitment to living truthfully has become inseparable from a commitment to peace-making.
John's language of story and symbol belongs to what Walter Brueggemann calls the 'prophetic imagination'. It is a way of seeing (and being in) the world that reaches beyond the bare facts to apprehend something of their meaning as a whole. Those who believe Jesus was the one son of a creator God will interpret John's statement in light of that belief. Those who do not can nonetheless get a sense of its meaning. Whatever our beliefs may be, unless we as readers push the question away entirely we cannot help but ask where we stand: with the crucifying structures of the arms trade or the peace-making crucified and all those who suffer in war. Whatever the Christian story means to us, and however much or little we might feel involved in it, John's statement puts us all on the hook.
'Shaken'
==
John wrote, "What shook me..." and then, "...I saw where my choice lay...". The theologian Andrew Shanks speculates that such "shakenness" generates the conditions of greater authenticity, by which new, life-affirming social movements may occur. He explains that the philosopher Jan Patočka first used the term to describe Charter 77, the underground movement that seeded popular resistance to the Soviet domination of Czechoslovakia. The movement's founding declar-ation, which Patočka signed, describes it as "a free, informal and open association of people of different convictions, different faiths and different professions". It appealed not to people's existing religious or political views but to something more elemental: their common situation as human beings whose freedom had been stolen. By the risky method of samizdat, by which activists clandestinely copied and passed on the outlawed declaration, the movement grew. Over two decades later it culminated in the almost entirely non-violent Velvet Revolution of 1989 when another founding figure of Charter 77, the writer Václav Havel, was inaug-urated as the first President of the Czech Republic.
Andrew Shanks explains that in describing the Charter 77 signatories as "shaken", Jan Patočka referred to their common experience of being jolted into an authentic, passionate response to the violence of their situation. Their shakenness began to move them away from living "within a lie" - their complicity with the regime - and towards living "within the truth", which is to say a more honest way of being. Just as importantly, they drew together into what Patočka called the "solidarity of the shaken". In this, Shanks argues, lies the critical importance of shakenness for the birth and growth of new social movements, as "the shaken" seek one another out as allies and friends. In the case of movements like Charter 77, and perhaps also the Quaker movement, people are being drawn together in their common shakenness, committed to living more authentically and being more deeply engaged in the world. For these, such commitment is a life choice rather than a lifestyle choice.
The shaken might well belong to a religious denomination, organisation or political party. Their first loyalty, however, is to being a movement of common solidarity in a shared feeling for what is authentic and powerful enough to move society away from a lie towards truth. And the shaken, in being passionate, are radicalised; they are people of the radix, or root, of life. A measure of our organisations, including Quaker ones, is how well they serve this loose movement of gathered and gathering people working to turn themselves and the world around.
Turning around
The turn towards peace, initiated by the shakenness that John Lynes and Andrew Shanks describe, is a small revolution from which grows larger, slower evolutionary change. The biblical Greek term for this kind of revolution-evolution is metanoia. Although normally translated into English as 'repentance', as in remorse for sin, metanoia means something like the 'turning-around' of life and the world. Quakers call this experience 'convincement', based on the early Quaker term 'convicted', meaning found guilty of one's sin and turned around towards a new kind of life. For Quakers, like many other religious communities, faith concerns this turning away from life within a lie towards a newly felt authenticity. It is made real (or not) by how we act in the world.
Metanoia has a private, spiritual dimension but its purpose is practical and emancipatory. I saw it in a harassed single mum at a parenting group who started to kneel down when talking to her toddler, trying to enter his world for a few minutes each day. It was there, too, when a soldier friend decided the war in Iraq was wrong, left the army and started to wake the rest of us up to the reality of war. And when a woman who fell into a rage and beat someone up, her metanoia was to find help; she pinned a diagram of nonviolence principles on her fridge door as a daily reminder. These were not isolated changes but signs of lives turning around as each person moved into what they described in their own words as more authentic and life-giving ways of being in the world. Such mini-revolutions are how the world begins to change.
If our own metanoia is inevitably inconsistent - because we are lax and this sort of change does not proceed in a rationally ordered way - then it is not surprising that our social, collective metanoia from violence to peace is so slow and uncertain, if indeed it is happening at all. However, it is well within our power to be an influence by participating in the processes of change and sometimes giving the social tree a shake. And this works. In the eighteenth century, the American John Woolman travelled among his own slave-owning Quaker community and challenged them gently but persistently on the inconsistency between what they were professing and what they were doing. He endured repeated "yes, but..." responses until eventually the penny dropped and Quakers began releasing their slaves and campaigning together for abolition. One metanoia leads to another.
Peace as commitment
A commitment to peace in the sense described here concerns a determination to respect the dignity of one another's being in the way we live, commune and organise our societies. More than a critique of violence, then, a peace commitment is first a passion for the promise of life. It means searching for an authentic relationship with others, working to re-create the world as fit for flourishing relationships, and resolving to resist and refuse the multiple violations of violence. In other words, it is a way of holding faith with life and making this count in a pervasively violent world.
The word 'commitment' originally meant 'bringing together', and in this sense a commitment to peace focuses the will, marshals our resources and brings us together in the same passion for the dignity and vibrancy of being alive. These choices have a profoundly ethical dimension in that they have consequences in the world also. Yet they are more than this, for they lead to larger and deeper freedom of being. The M77 activists drew together in hope of not only a more ethical society but one that is more alive; I see them not so much as the righteous but as the alive. So peace is a matter of both the ethical integrity of our choices and of the passion, freedom and communion in which they are made. In this way, a commitment to peace leads into what the Quaker Adrian Rose calls a "greater em-brace" of our riven, beautiful world: to be a little more unsettled, engaged and alive.
==