2022/05/20

8] Mystical Tradition: Islam

 Mystical Tradition: Judaism, Christianity, and Islam



Table of Contents


Professor Biography ....................................................................................i
0] Course Scope 1
===
Judaism1]
Lecture One A Way into the Mystic Ways of the West 4
Lecture Two Family Resemblances and Differences 9
Lecture Three The Biblical Roots of Western Mysticism 14
===
Judaism2]
Lecture Four Mysticism in Early Judaism 18
Lecture Five Merkabah Mysticism 22
Lecture Six The Hasidim of Medieval Germany 26
Lecture Seven The Beginnings of Kabbalah 30
Lecture Eight Mature Kabbalah—Zohar 34
===
Judaism3]
Lecture Nine Isaac Luria and Safed Spirituality 38
Lecture Ten Sabbatai Zevi and Messianic Mysticism 42
Lecture Eleven The Ba’al Shem Tov and the New Hasidism 46
Lecture Twelve Mysticism in Contemporary Judaism 50
===
Christian4]
Lecture Thirteen Mystical Elements in the New Testament 54
Lecture Fourteen Gnostic Christianity 58
Lecture Fifteen The Spirituality of the Desert 62
Lecture Sixteen Shaping Christian Mysticism in the East 66
===
Christian5]
Lecture Seventeen Eastern Monks and the Hesychastic Tradition 70
Lecture Eighteen The Mysticism of Western Monasticism 74
Lecture Nineteen Medieval Female Mystics 78
Lecture Twenty Mendicants as Mystics 82
===
Christian6]
Lecture Twenty-One English Mystics of the 14th Century 86
Lecture Twenty-Two 15th- and 16th- Century Spanish Mystics 89
Lecture Twenty-Three Mysticism among Protestant Reformers 93
Lecture Twenty-Four Mystical Expressions in Protestantism 96
Lecture Twenty-Five 20th-Century Mystics 100
===
Islam7]
Lecture Twenty-Six Muhammad the Prophet as Mystic................. 104
Lecture Twenty-Seven The House of Islam........................................ 108
Lecture Twenty-Eight The Mystical Sect—Shi’a.............................. 112
===
Islam8]
Lecture Twenty-Nine The Appearance of Sufism............................. 116
Lecture Thirty Early Sufi Masters.......................................... 120
Lecture Thirty-One The Limits of Mysticism—Al-Ghazzali ........ 123
Lecture Thirty-Two Two Masters, Two Streams............................ 127

===
Islam9]
Lecture Thirty-Three Sufism in 12th–14th Century North Africa...... 131
Lecture Thirty-Four Sufi Saints of Persia and India....................... 134
Lecture Thirty-Five The Continuing Sufi Tradition....................... 137
Lecture Thirty-Six Mysticism in the West Today ........................ 141
===
Timeline ................................................................................................... 145
Glossary ................................................................................................... 154
Bibliography............................................................................................ 163
====

Lecture Twenty-Nine The Appearance of Sufism

 

 

Scope: For a religion that, in its exoteric form, is so anti-ascetical, the

emergence of Sufism (the distinctive form of mysticism in the Islamic tradition) in the early 8th century is something of a surprise, as is its remarkable success. This lecture assesses various possible causes for this development, then sketches the Sufi way of life as a path (tariqa) of knowledge, love, and prayer. The lecture concludes with a general guide to the stations and states of the Sufi’s progression toward Allah, as well as some of the tensions created by this powerful form of mysticism within the House of Islam.  

Outline

I.      The appearance and the continued flourishing of Sufism as the dominant form of Islamic Mysticism is a surprise to those who are unaware of the place it holds in the history of this religious tradition.

A.     A Hadith of the Prophet declares, “There are no monks in Islam,” and the Qur’an has a strong anti-ascetical tendency: Marriage, property ownership, and political involvement are all encouraged.

1.      The Shari’ah was developed and organized by scholars (ulama) with little attention to the internal response of the individual.

2.      The ulama, furthermore, was closely attached to the political power of the caliphate, with a concern for the Islamic state.

3.      Islam, in this framework, is a religion of the will (obedience) and the mind but not necessarily of the heart.

B.     Sufism offers a powerful alternative way of being Muslim, both within and at the fringes of the Shari’ah.

1.      It emphasizes the individual’s response to Allah through mind, heart, and mystical experience.

2.      Politically, its system of Sufi brotherhoods (orders) offers a place not totally defined by the theocratic state.

C.     Sufism’s relation to exoteric Islam has always been both emphatic and debated.

1.      The ulama has responded variously to Sufism, with attempts to resist it, co-opt it, and reform it.

2.      In certain times and places, Sufism has represented the dominant expression of Islam and one of its powerful missionary impulses.

3.      Even internally, the question arises of the degree to which Sufism is properly an expression of Islam or a universal mystical religion.

II.    The origins of the movement remain, to a large extent, obscure and disputed.

A.     Sufism is generally thought to have arisen in Basra (in Iraq) in the 8th century, though some manifestations could be earlier; internally, Sufis trace their origins either to ‘Ali or to Abu Bakr. 

B.     The etymology of the term Sufi is debated even within the tradition: Does it come from suf (“wool,” referring to the garments worn by Sufis); safa (“purity”); ashab (or ahl) al-suffa

(“companions/people of the porch”), or sufiya (a transliteration of the Greek sophia, meaning “wisdom”)?

C.     Possible factors contributing to the rise of Sufism include the following:

1.      Neoplatonic Greek philosophy or Gnostic groups (Iraqi Mandeans), or Persian Dualism (Manichaeism);

2.      Jewish mystics or Christian dissident groups (the monks of East Syria);

3.      The rigidity of the Shari’ah and the corruption of the caliphate during the Umayyad dynasty;

4.      The universal impulse within all religions for a commitment to personal transformation.

III.  Like Islam itself, the basic components of the Sufi way of life are both simple and difficult.

A.     The Sufi is a traveler or seeker who sets out to follow the path toward Allah.

1.      The goal is unity with that which is most real (al-haqq), in contrast with that which is illusory.

2.      In order to follow the right path (tariqa) toward God, dedication and discipline are required.

B.     The Sufi Orders provide the social framework for the seeker to move securely in the path.

1.      The role of the shaykh, a spiritual leader with absolute authority over the disciple (murid), is decisive; the zawiah is the place of gathering.

2.      The communal structure of the brotherhoods provides support to the seeker.

C.     The Sufi follows a threefold path of knowledge, love, and prayer toward union with al-haqq.

1.      Knowledge includes both esoteric knowledge concerning ascent and theosophical knowledge of the relation of the self to God; elements of Gnosticism and Pantheism are sometimes found.

2.      The Sufi cultivates an emotional response of love, as well as external obedience; the use of erotic language to express the love of Allah is not uncommon.

3.      The characteristic prayer of the Sufi is recollection (dhikr); sometimes, this involves the use of music (sawa) and the recitation of the “names of Allah” on prayer beads.

D.     The Sufi’s progression is marked by definite stages and states on the path to Allah.

1.      Stages are the result of human effort and include repentance, watchfulness, renunciation, poverty, mortification, and absolute trust in Allah. The prayer of recollection moves one along this path.

2.      States are gifts of Allah over which the Sufi has no control. The highest two states are “passing away” (fana) and “passing away of passing away” (fana al-fana).

IV.   Like mysticism in Judaism and Christianity—but perhaps even more dramatically—Sufism has posed problems for the exoteric tradition in Islam.

A.     At the theoretical level, the tendency of Sufi Monotheism to move toward Pantheism, the esoteric reading of the Qur’an, and the exaltation of the saints can all erode the Shari’ah and even the shahadah.

B.     At the practical level, the cultivation of saints has given rise to a number of problematic associations, and the power of the brotherhoods always challenges the authority of the ulama.

 

Recommended Reading:

Nicholson, R. A. The Mystics of Islam.

 

Questions to Consider:

1.      Compare the Sufi brotherhood to Jewish and Christian mystical communities, noting points of similarity and dissimilarity.

2.      Why is sexual asceticism a feature of renunciation in Christianity but not in Judaism and Islam?

Lecture Thirty Early Sufi Masters

 

 

Scope: In this sampling of Sufi passages from the 8th–10th centuries, we see how the Qur’an was mystically interpreted and how the quest for Allah could be captured by the form of traditional Arabic poetry (the qasida). This lecture discusses traditions associated with the famous female Sufi RƗbi’a al-‘Adawiyya, al-Muhasibi, Abu Yazid al-Bistami, and Abu al-Qasim al-Junayd and concludes with the controversial figure of Mansur al-Hallaj, who was executed for heresy.

 

Outline

I.      In the remaining lectures, we will examine some of the many writings produced by mystics in the Sufi tradition. Two important sources for the symbolism of Sufi Mysticism are pre-Islamic poetry and the Qur’an and Hadith.

A.     Of special importance is the nasib, the first part of the Arabic poetic form called the qasida, which tropes the meeting of lovers, the separation of lovers, and the recollection of the beloved.

1.      The qasida also supplies the imagery of stages and stations in the quest for the beloved.

2.      This love poetry provides the framework for Sufi Mysticism; a 7th-century example of this kind of poem, “To the encampments of Máyya,” gives us a sense of it.

B.     Early Sufis paid special attention to the Isra and miraj of the Prophet, which are only intimated in the Qur’an (in Suras 17:1 and 53) but are elaborated dramatically by early Hadith.

C.     The imagery is given a systematic structure by the Sufi path of knowledge, love, and prayer toward “the real” (al-haqq), as we see, for example, in “On Annihilation” (fana) by Abu al-Qasim alJunayd (d. 910).

II.    The example of two early Sufis demonstrates the complexity of the traditions that grew up around such saints.

A.     RƗbi’a al-‘Adawiyya al-Qaysiyya (d. 801) is the most notable early female Sufi, whose sayings and deeds are memorialized, among

those of 71 other masters, in the Friends of God by Faridu d-Din ‘Attar (d. 1230).

1.      The significance of, and reasons for, honoring RƗbi’a as a woman are explained in the first sections of the book.

2.      The individual entries by RƗbi’a resemble those found in the Christian Sayings of the Desert Fathers and the ancient chreia.

3.      RƗbi’a lived a life of extreme poverty and trust in Allah, exhibiting utterly selfless devotion.

4.      Her sanctity is marked by the wonders that are attributed to her.

B.     Abu Yazid al-Bistami (d. 874) was a Persian who grew up in a family of ascetics and was noted for his dramatic experiences and the radical statements he made with reference to his states. 1.                 We have several versions of Bistami’s miraj, including that in ‘Attar’s Friends of God: Like the Prophet, he ascends to the seventh heaven, then flies freely through all the Earth.

               2.     The scholastic character of the early Sufi movement is seen in

The Book of Flashes by Abu Nasr as-Sarraj (d. 988), in which Junayd and Sarraj engage in an imaginary dialogue interpreting Bistami’s shocking statements.

III.  The writing of early masters reveals the serious intellectual attention given to the Sufi’s path toward al-haqq.

A.     In The Book of Observance of the Rights of God, al-Muhasibi (d. 857) uses the form of a dialogue between master and student to elaborate a moral psychology that focuses on the elimination of human egoism.

B.     In his exposition of the seven stages in The Book of Flashes, asSarraj proceeds dialectically, treating the views of the beginners, then the select, then the knowing, building, in this fashion, a complex understanding of each stage in conversation with earlier authorities.

C.     In the short essays called Some Points on Tawhid (unity), alJunayd offers four remarkably compressed statements on the mystic’s experience of annihilation (fana).

IV.   One of the most controversial figures in the history of Sufism is Mansur al-Hallaj (d. 922), whose life and teaching generated both rejection and admiration.

A.     Born in Iran, Hallaj made a pilgrimage to Mecca and traveled and taught extensively; he studied with Junayd but was ultimately rejected by him.

1.      It is not clear whether the controversy surrounding Hallaj arose from his popularization of Sufi teachings outside the taquiya or the radical character of his statements concerning Tawhid: “I am al-haqq. I am truth.” 

2.      He was brought to trial for heresy in the ‘Abbasid capital of Baghdad, imprisoned, tortured, and executed; the manner in which he bore his trials was much admired.

B.     The few extant writings from al-Hallaj show that he was a serious student of the Sufi way.

1.      In addition to collected aphorisms (The Sayings of Hallaj) and some poetry of disputed attribution, only a single sustained work of al-Hallaj remains, the Tawasin.

2.      In the Tawasin, Hallaj reflects on Iblis (the devil) as a tragic lover.

 

Recommended Reading: 

Sells, M. A. Early Islamic Mysticism (Classics of Western Spirituality.)

 

Questions to Consider:

1.      Comment on the remarkable sophistication of the Sufi way already in the early centuries of the Islamic era.

2.      How do the statements of oneness with Allah affect the perception of what constitutes Monotheism?

Lecture Thirty-One The Limits of Mysticism—Al-Ghazzali

 

 

Scope: The first centuries of Islam saw both a spectacular spread of the religion and an explosion of intellectual energy. Islam provided the context for innovative speculation in philosophy and theology. This lecture touches on some of the issues raised, their influence on medieval Jewish and Christian thinkers, and the contributions made by one of Islam’s most important thinkers, Abu Hamed Mohammad ibn Mohammad al-Ghazzali, whose life as a Sufi was exemplary and whose intellectual labors brought mystical speculation firmly within the framework of the Shari’ah.

 

Outline

I.      The creative energy unleashed by early Islam expressed itself not only in political and religious expansion but equally in cultural excellence.

A.     In virtually every field—mathematics, science, medicine, architecture, literature, and music—Muslim contributions were superior to their Christian counterparts in Europe.

1.      The era of Islamic ascendancy was that of Europe’s darkest hours, from the 7th to the 9th centuries.

2.      Europe only slowly caught up with the period of Islam’s greatest brilliance, from the 10th to the 12th centuries, with the universities that came into being in the 12th and 13th centuries.

B.     Internal to Islam, the same creative impulses led to intellectual tensions that required attention.

1.      Could ijtihad (“free inquiry”) be applied as much to the doctrines of Islam as to its law? This is the question of theology (kalam).

2.      Was there any possibility of reconciling the rational inquiry associated especially with Greek philosophy and the Qur’an?

3.      Were there limits to the Sufi experience for it to remain within Islam?

C.     On each of these points, one of the great figures in the history of Islam, Abu Hamed Mohammad ibn Mohammad al-Ghazzali (10581111), made a fundamental contribution.

II.    Each of the tensions in some fashion involved the relationship between revelation and human reason. 

A.     An early theological dispute divided Muslims on the question of faith and works, but the most important theological debate concerned determinism and free will, a tension that arose from the extreme position of the Qur’an on each point: How can Allah both be all-powerful and hold humans accountable?

1.      The rationalist position was represented by the Mu’tazila party, which made human reason the measure of the Qur’an. God’s justice must be measured by the human understanding of justice; as a consequence, the Qur’an is not an eternal word but a human word.

2.      The Orthodox party, represented by Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 855), appealed to Allah as revealed through the Qur’an as an absolute measure: We know justice from Allah’s actions; the Qur’an is, thus, eternal and not subject to human reason.

3.      A mediating position was offered by Abu’l-Hasan al-Ash‘ari (d. c. 936), who applied reason to faith but still made faith the measure of the Qur’an. He distinguished between the physical Qur’an as a finite expression and the eternal word of Allah seeking a compromise. 

B.     Islamic philosophers similarly challenged the ultimate truth of the Qur’an on the basis of Greek philosophy, above all, the thinking of Plato and Aristotle.

1.      Al-Farabi (d. c. 950) and Ibn Sina (also called Avicenna, d. 1037) challenged the teaching of the Qur’an on creation (the world is eternal) and on the physical resurrection (only the soul is immortal). For them, the choice was stark: reason or revelation.

2.      After the challenge of al-Ghazzali, the Spanish Arabic philosopher Ibn Rushd (also called Averroës, d. 1198) offered a position closer to that of faith and mediated a version of Aristotle to Jews (Moses Maimonides) and Christians (Thomas Aquinas).

C.     In its own fashion, Sufism also challenged the adequacy of revelation found in the Qur’an.

1.      Statements arising out of ecstasy, such as those of Bistami and Hallaj, could challenge the teaching on the unity of Allah. Had Sufis discovered new things about Allah not found in the Qur’an?

2.      Did Sufism escape or transcend the ethics of the Shari’ah and, therefore, exist outside the boundaries of Islam?

III.  In his life and his writings, al-Ghazzali experienced and sought to resolve these intellectual and spiritual tensions.

A.     He wrote more than 70 books. His Deliverance from Error (c.

1100) is something of an intellectual and spiritual autobiography.

1.      Born in Tus in Iran, al-Ghazzali was a brilliant student of law, philosophy, and theology. He was appointed professor or dean at Nizamiyah University in Baghdad (1091), where he lectured to as many as 300 students at a time.

2.      His polymathic studies led to an intellectual and spiritual crisis in 1095; he abandoned his career and, after a pilgrimage to Mecca, lived as a Sufi. In Sufism, he found a certitude that was based in experience and located in the heart, not the mind.

3.      He lectured again at Nizamiyah in 1106, then returned to his hometown, where he died in 1111.

B.     In the realm of philosophy, al-Ghazzali is best known for his Aims of the Philosophers, summarizing Ibn Sina’s teaching, and The Incoherence of the Philosophers, a rebuttal of the philosophical positions advanced, in particular, by Ibn Sina.

1.      He challenges the capacity of philosophy to know what it claims to know, adopting an epistemological skepticism. Only Allah “causes”; only faith gives secure knowledge of what is real.

2.      Ibn Rushd wrote The Incoherence of the Incoherence in response to al-Ghazzali. 

C.     In other areas, al-Ghazzali represented a mediating position that enabled faith and the intellectual and mystical life to remain in conversation.

1.      In jurisprudence, he championed the Shafi’i school, which recognized the role of ijtihad, “free inquiry.”

2.      In theology, he adopted the Ash‘ari position and developed further the agreement of faith and reason, faith remaining primary, but reason inquiring into faith for its internal coherence.

3.      In mysticism, he argued that the knowledge and morality of the Sufi must fit within the exoteric frame of the Shari’ah.

Mystic knowledge is the din, the inner meaning of the legal system. 

D.     A major work that pulls all these threads together in a systematic fashion is al-Ghazzali’s Revival of Religious Learnings (or Revival of Religious Sciences).

1.      The work consists of four parts of 10 chapters each, with the first two parts dealing with the exoteric tradition (acts of worship, norms of daily life) and the second two parts dealing with transformation (the ways to perdition and the ways to salvation).

2.      Both the structure and the contents of the work affirm the consonance of the exoteric and esoteric.

 

Recommended Reading:

Hitti, P. K. Islam: A Way of Life.

 

Questions to Consider:

1.      Why was the reconciling intellectual work of al-Ghazzali so critical for the future of Islam?

2.      Why was his life experience as a Sufi essential for al-Ghazzali to achieve his reconciliation of the exoteric and esoteric traditions?

Lecture Thirty-Two Two Masters, Two Streams

 

 

Scope: Sufi Mysticism navigates between an emphasis on knowledge and an emphasis on love. Two 13th-century masters, both prolific writers, represent the two emphases and have exercised substantial influence on subsequent generations of Sufi teachers. Ibn al-‘Arabi was born in Spain but spent the greater part of his life in Damascus. Jalal ad-Din Rumi was born in Afghanistan but spent his mature life in Turkey. He is the founder of the Mawlawi order of Sufis, and his poetry stresses the role of love in attaining unity with Allah.

 

Outline

I.      Mysticism within Islam (as in Judaism and Christianity) is far from an individualistic or random phenomenon: It develops in three interconnected contexts.

A.     Mysticism thrives in the context of a community of religious practice.

1.      Beyond the demands of the Shari’ah are the instruction, disciplines, rituals, and spiritual guidance of Sufi Orders.

2.      At times, tension develops between the demands of the fellowships and the expectations (and perceptions) of the ulama.

B.     Mysticism expresses itself in the context of authoritative texts and traditions.

1.      In Judaism, mysticism centers in Torah; in Christianity, it involves interpretation of the Bible.

2.      Muslim mystics engage the Qur’an (the “Mother of All Books”), Hadith, and the works of earlier Sufis, often with intense and close textual interpretation.

C.     Mysticism involves the context of personal life experiences that stimulate the reinterpretation of texts.

1.      Most obvious are the experiences of prayer that yield ecstasy or insight (“flashes”).

2.      Also important are the experiences of family, travel, study, love, and friendship.

D.     These factors come together in distinctive fashion in two of the great Sufi masters, Ibn al-‘Arabi, and Jalal ad-Din Rumi.

II.    The way of knowledge is illustrated by Ibn al-‘Arabi (1165–1240), called al-Shaykh al-Akbar (“The Great Master”) by the many who have been shaped by his learning and mystical insight.

A.     His life is full of colorful incident and travel, perfectly exemplifying the image of the Sufi as wanderer.

1.      Of Arabic lineage, he was born in Spain and was educated in Islamic lore in Seville; he held a position as a minor official, married the first of several wives, and at around the age of 20, joined the Sufi path.

2.      An account of a meeting with the philosopher Ibn Rushd celebrates the great “opening” to spiritual insight al-‘Arabi had accomplished “as a beardless youth.”

3.      He wrote his first book, Contemplation of the Holy Mysteries, early in life.

4.      Restless travels brought al-‘Arabi to Mecca, where he began The Meccan Openings. Before leaving Spain, however, he also wrote the book that has been excerpted as the Sufis of Andalusia.

5.      In his travels, he met a young woman who served as a muse for his love poetry, The Interpreter of Desires.

6.      Further travels led him to Konya (and his best disciple, Sadr ad-Din al-Qunawi) and finally, to Damascus.

B.     Al-‘Arabi was a prolific writer, with some 700 writings attributed to him; about 400 of these works are extant, most of them unedited or untranslated. As a result, his influence remains largely among Sufis.

1.      The Meccan Openings consists of 2,500 pages in Arabic. It is vastly learned, eclectic, and unsystematic: a treasure house of Gnostic lore.

2.      The Interpreter of Dreams is the collection of love poetry that kept al-‘Arabi in trouble with authorities, who suspected that the work was not mystical but merely erotic.

3.      The Bezels of Wisdom (Fusus al-Hakim) is al-‘Arabi’s most influential work, giving rise to many commentaries. He treats the wisdom brought by 27 of Allah’s prophets, including Jesus, based on a close analysis of Qur’anic verses.

C.     Al-‘Arabi’s teaching is nonsystematic even as it is theosophical: It resembles outbursts of affirmation or revelation more than logical argument. The theme of divine immanence is pervasive.

1.      The question of “the one and the many” is examined in his close analysis of the names of Allah.

2.      The doctrine of “oneness of being” (wahdat al-wajud, though al-‘Arabi does not use that term) struggles with the “realness” of God’s existence and the relative nonbeing of existence.

3.      The divine immanence underlies his convictions concerning the “perfect man” (al insan al-kamil), the image toward which the Sufi strives.

III.  The way of love is emphasized by Jalal ad-Din Rumi (1207–1273), called Mawlana (“our Lord”) by followers, who is recognized not only as a great saint but as one of the world’s great poets.

A.     In contrast to that of Ibn al-‘Arabi, the life of Rumi was settled and largely domestic.

1.      He wrote the New Persian of his native land (Iran) and was born into a family of scholars and mystics.

2.      His name, Rumi (“Roman”), was given him because he lived in Konya, in present-day Turkey, formerly part of the Roman Empire.

3.      Married and with two sons, he took over his father’s madrassa at age 25 but started his public life of preaching in the mosques of Konya in 1240.

4.      His most important relationship was with the dervish Shams-e Tabrizi in the years 1244–1248, bringing out new aspects of his spirituality and inspiring his poetry.

5.      The experience of such intense friendship and its loss became an analogy from his own life for the Sufi’s love of Allah.

B.     Although he wrote some prose works—lectures, sermons, and letters—it is Rumi’s poetry (inspired by the sama’ of song and dance) that defines his place in Sufism and world literature.

1.      The Masnawi Ma’nawi (Spiritual Couplets) is a single poem of 25,000 verses in six books, with 300 longer and shorter anecdotes dealing with love. It has been called the “Qur’an in the Persian language.”

2.      The Diwan-i Shams-i Tabrizi (Works of Shams of Tabriz) includes 40,000 lines of ghazals and other miscellaneous love poems.

C.     Rumi’s teaching is, as appropriate to poetry, indirect and affective, exploring every dimension of the love relationship between God and the mystic.

1.      Rumi’s is a religion of love, and he does not tire of describing the beloved, especially in terms of mercy.

2.      One of his poignant themes is that of the loss of the beloved, with its attendant heartache, and the joy that accompanies reunion.

3.      The deepest form of love involves escape from the selfish impulses of the ego.

D.     Rumi is the founder of the Mawlawi Sufi Order that spread throughout Turkey and played a significant role in its culture and history.

1.      This order of Sufis was especially associated with dance and song.

2.      Throughout its long history, the order was led by a descendant of its founder.

 

Recommended Reading:

Nasr, S. H. ed., Islamic Spirituality.

 

Questions to Consider:

1.      Consider the ways in which community, the study of texts, and personal experience shaped the two mystics in this lecture.

2.      Why has Rumi gained such renown as a representative of Sufi Mysticism?