2025/10/18

Catherine Hogarth —The forgotten wife of Charles Dickens


The forgotten wife of Charles Dickens

Lucinda HawksleyFeatures correspondent
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20160519-the-forgotten-wife-of-charles-dickens

As the wife of such a star, Catherine began to be overlooked. Meanwhile, while she was as happy as her husband at first, her multiple pregnancies – from which she barely got the chance to recover before getting pregnant again – began to take their toll on her health, energy and their marriage.

Now, for more than a century, Catherine has been marginalised and misremembered as a dull, frumpy wife. Even the sole Dickens biopic ever to have been made by the film industry focused not on Catherine, but on Ellen Ternan, Dickens’s mistress (a relationship that was ultimately the reason he separated from Catherine).

But the real story of Catherine is that of a fun-loving young woman who, as the wife of an international celebrity, travelled widely and had the opportunity to see and experience things that most women of her era and social status did not. She and Charles were very keen amateur actors, for example. Catherine not only performed in shows at home, but on stage in both the United States and Canada.

For more than a century, Catherine has been marginalised and misremembered as a dull, frumpy wife

Another of Catherine’s achievements? Publishing a book. When I researched it, I was infuriated to discover how many people – even respected academics – have claimed that it was written by Charles.

This view is intensely patronising, implying as it does that Catherine couldn’t possibly have had the intelligence to write a book. But it is also extraordinary to claim that Charles would have willingly added to his already punishing writing schedule only to publish a book under a female pseudonym – at a time when most female authors were being forced to write under masculine pen names in order to be published.

Steve Vidler/Alamy The dining room in the Dickens’s house in London, now the Charles Dickens Museum (Credit: Steve Vidler/Alamy)Steve Vidler/Alamy
The dining room in the Dickens’s house in London, now the Charles Dickens Museum (Credit: Steve Vidler/Alamy)

 Catherine’s book is entitled What Shall We Have for Dinner? A guide for young wives more than a recipe book, it advises on household tasks and producing menus for up to 18 people. In essence, Catherine was the first Mrs Beeton – a decade and a half before the actual Mrs Beeton published her now-iconic cookbook.

Now, visitors to the Charles Dickens Museum have the chance to discover all of this – and the vibrant, witty and interesting woman who was ‘the other Dickens’.

The Other Dickens is open until 20 November 2016.

Lucinda Hawksley’s new book Charles Dickens and his Circle is published by the National Portrait Gallery in the UK and the US.

This story is a part of BBC Britain – a series focused on exploring this extraordinary island, one story at a time. Readers outside of the UK can see every BBC Britain story by heading to the Britain homepageyou also can see our latest stories by following us on Facebook and Twitter.

If you liked this story, sign up for the weekly bbc.com features newsletter, called “If You Only Read 6 Things This Week”. A handpicked selection of stories from BBC Future, Earth, Culture, Capital, Travel and Autos, delivered to your inbox every Friday.










(2) Facebook



The Vintage News

·
Follow

ooSntpdsre 0buml984Sart6mcg10eef 33ac1e9i g01i6at2iltp30i:5m ·


She bore ten children — and buried three with her own hands. She crossed oceans beside him, endured the storms of his fame and failures, and kept a turbulent household alive.
And yet Catherine Hogarth — wife of Charles Dickens — was cast aside, maligned, and erased.
Dickens, celebrated as a genius, painted her as “fat, lazy, jealous, and dull.” He aired their private anguish in public, publishing a letter that turned him into the victim. The world wept for him. Few spared a tear for her.
But who would not stumble after ten pregnancies? Who would not break beneath the grief of burying children? Catherine was no weakling. She endured with fierce resilience.
Their marriage did not collapse from her faults, but because Dickens fell for a younger actress, Ellen Ternan. Divorce was scandalous in Victorian England, so Catherine was branded the problem. Dickens even built a wall inside their home to divide her from the family.
At last, Catherine put on her hat, stepped outside, and never returned. In leaving, she lost her children, her home, her place in society.
Near the end of her life, she asked only for one thing: that Dickens’s early love letters be published — proof that she had once been cherished. Even that wish was denied.
But her story endures. Catherine Dickens was never a burden. She was a survivor.
Wayne Reed
I had never heard this before, so it does present a darker side to Charles Dickens. This is a disturbing revelation, but I often wonder why this is being so widely publicized now, unless there is also a more sinister intent to destroy or erase Charles Dicken’s legacy and contributions to literature. After all, would there be no Charles Dickens there would be no Great Expectations, no Oliver Twist, no Tale of Two Cities, no David Copperfield, and no Tiny Tim or Ebenezer Scrooge. The man’s creative genius and effort to spotlight the plight of the poor, (widely based on his own childhood hardships) should not be buried with a vengeful hatchet. I am not saying his wife’s alleged mistreatment and negligence did not happen, but I question the intent of focusing on a mostly negative image of a once great man whose literary success and contributions to Mankind cannot be denied. Any thoughts?
Helen Chadwick
Wayne Reed just because you are outstanding person in your field doesn’t make you a nice or kind person.
It just makes you a genius in that particular field … thats all !
Rosemary Hill
Wayne Reed I did know about this. I enjoy the work of Dickens but he did have a much darker side. People are indeed complex.
Joan Green
Wayne Reed This has not just been published. I heard about it years ago. A man who celebrated Christmas and family, had a dark side too. She was "fat" because she had given birth ten times. She probably became "jealous" because her husband was having an affair with younger attractive woman. Women in those days did not have the opportunity to make it on their own as they do today. She was a strong woman who dared, eventually, after years of mental cruelty, to leave her children. How heartbreaking.
Nikki Armstrong
Wayne Reed maybe her family know of her side through journals and her love letters and wants the world to know she was a good woman.
Maria Garcia
Wayne Reed interestingly..Picasso, Hemingway, Dickens and so many other greats have given so much to world literature and the Arts, but butchered and abused the hearts of those who made it possible to succeed. They presented as a Messiahs of the arts and understood the power of words, often used against their wives and lovers, while they became dispensable. I see these greats as fragments of a whole.. to keep grounded.
  • Reply
  • Edited
Eileen Wiggins
Wayne Reed I’ve known this for a long time
John Morgan
Sad if true, but what do we really know or can we rally know about the entire situation? Certainly not enough to draw any solid definite conclusions.
Kathleen Tekakwitha Meloche
Wayne Reed Perhaps, it forces us to recognize and separate a great writer from a not so great man.
Lois Guthrie Marr
Wayne Reed true, I wouldn’t take anything seriously from a blip on FBook…no reference as to where the poster(s), the Vintage News, get their info. Who are the researchers with Vintage News, etc.
Time to do some of my own research on the subject
  • Reply
  • Edited
Jade Laurich
Wayne Reed women’s stories are worthy of being told.
Richard Bono
For a writer who showed such empathy for humanity, he also had a very dark personal side.
Annie Alleyne Taylor
Those “great men” of the past often had a very dark side. The personal lives of Albert Einstein, Karl Marx, Pablo Picasso and many more reveals bullies and abusers of women. The behavior of Einstein to his first wife Mileva Maric and his insulting List of Instructions was an example of his selfish nastiness. Great man - but not a GOOD man. Ugh 😣
Jac Pd
Richard Bono He wrote about the squalor and poverty in and around the Workhouse that he saw in Chatham when he was a boy ( Oliver Twist). About the Debtors prison his father ended up in ( Little Dorrit). Also the prisoner who escaped from the prison hulks and Miss Havisham in Great expectation. However did he show empathy? Did he do anything to help these people?
Dorothy Zeiss Young
Richard Bono the son he sent to Australia is another horrible thing he did
Shammi Thorsrud
Richard Bono yes, the dark side of the moon
Laraine Elizabeth Turner
Richard Bono But why now—when the man has been centuries dead and unable to defend these accusations, which could be FALSE???
Tammy RF
Richard Bono I suppose we all do… with some notable exceptions, of course.
Steven Kirschbaum Chitwood
Richard Bonothat type are usually inveterate hypocrites.
Jenifer Gray
Richard Bono A very dark side.
Rosalyn Marhatta
Richard Bono He was abused as a child.
"Most relevant" is selected, so some replies may have been filtered out.
Maria Mbog
Similar to Albert Einstein's wife who was a very bright and educated individual she helped a lot with his work and studies yet got no recognition for all the help she gave him .....honestly these men 🙄
Ann Hennessey
Amazing woman to have 10 children. That in itself shows she was a strong woman. Makes me sad reading this. I do not understand how any man could let down the mother of his 10 children and in such a disrespectful way. RIP Catherine.
  • Reply
  • Edited
Alison Eleri Stanford
On a brighter side he took a young lover and moved in with her while supporting his wife and children in the family home. After having 10 children something tells me that she was quite relieved not to have to do her wifely duty. Dickens suffered from depression and some say he was bi-polar. Everyone has their own story. I think that he maligned her to justify leaving her for a much younger woman.
Pat MacDonald
Sadly this is still the fate of many women today 😢 but fortunately the woman of today are Educated & can support & be there for their children ! Take heart ladies & Encourage your daughters to be learnard & Strong 💪 & to never doubt themselves!
Kathy Vargyas
Catherine Hogarth's story is a powerful reminder of the challenges women faced in Victorian England.
Les Powell
Dickens was not a nice guy. What an irony considering the Christmas Carol theme.
Helen Medcraft
Age old story - woman loses her sex appeal and the man falls for younger model. They are driven by what’s in their trousers!!! 🙃
Rachael Bishop
Thankfully, the internet changes how we learn and share stories so the narrative men try to force can be challenged.
Katherine Sneve
Yes, Dickens was not a good husband.
Margaret Thomas Amani
I never liked Charles Dickens stories they were always morbid probably a reflection of his reality.
Winston Uy
It's ironic that Dickens wrote about social injustices, yet he perpetrated one against his wife. He would have made a great villain in his novels!
Janine Brill
I have known about this for years and years, he was a horrible man, but great writer!
Kat Kathleen
Charles Dickens publicly slandered and maligned her terribly even trying to keep her children away from her. She gave Dickens Love Letters to their daughter as proof he once loved her. She maintained her dignity throughout Dickens infidelity in their marriage. 
Yvonne Bernier Hatline
Dickens wrote great stories but he was arrogant
June Warriner
So sad y,et he is only remembered for his books not the brute he obviously was,
Gill Graham-Harvey
He was a great writer but awful, weak man.
Judy Ann MacMillan
Oh I feel this so much. Am never surprised to find out that geniuses were not "nice guys'
Catherine Wholey
He was horrible to her but of course the woman is blamed as was the norm in those days if there was a problem with a marriage
Annalyn Jones
There my great great grandparents .Not many men where very nice back those .women easily replaced and didn’t have rights
Favorite Yaya
Too often, devoted women that support a man, in every way, before he becomes successful or famous, are cast aside once he has achieved his goals. Times haven’t changed that much since Dickens, sadly.
Vickie Macky
Maybe one of his 10 children found out about the story and how he degraded their mother and caused her to leave her children and home and now wants revenge or maybe another chapter is opening up amongst the Dickens children to write about they’re Daddy and tell about his life style…😉or could be some of Dickens grandchildren or great grandchildren to get revenge for their mother or grandmother or great grandmother…! Life goes on
Kathleen Kastorff
He liked her enough to stay on top of her.
Ann Barcoe
I have always loved Charles Dickins work,and many a man has left their poor wife for younger model,but to treat the woman who gave him ten children the way he did was unforgivable.
Jean Claxton
What a real prick Charles Dickens’s was!
I had actually read about Catherine’s story before
  • Reply
  • Edited
Eileen Jones
Some people never change. They minimize, deflect, and blame others to feel superior. But the truth always comes to light, and their schemes will backfire.
Dale Sharpe
That is people for you. The same couple who swear their undying love for each other can quickly turn sour for many reasons. Maybe Charles had too many expectations of Catherine and too little of himself as a husband and father?
Melinda Saunders
I like Dickens’ work. So I was shocked to find out that he also tried to have her committed to ‘shut her up.’ When she was outing him. The several doctors he approached refused which says a lot about how he was regarded because it was a common result of estrangement or separation where the men would try this tactic. It’s very sad to realise there was a level of hypocrisy in his work.
Sue McLaughlin
Dickson's may have been a brilliant author but he was a very bad hunman being. I had no respect for him as a person.
Long live Catherine 's legacy.
Christine Clark
Catherine is the champion
Della Isaacs
God bless her.
Julie Alli Palmer-Blackwell
Respect for her.
As for him, there are no words.
Anne Clarkson
This is so common with men who think they are special. The scientist who was paralysed, can't remember his name, he was another genius who was selfish and vile to his wife!
Jean Holden
It’s the same today men cry the victim when it’s all there fault they change the narrative to fit their infidelities, poor Lady never stood a chance so sad !!!
Jennifer Williams
I don’t think I can ever enjoy his stories ever again.
Pamela Stapleton
He allowed contact with one daughter, must be Katie. Because In the end she asked a daughter Katie to deliver one of her rings & a message to him still professing her love, forgiving him for everything & blessing him! Poor woman 💔
Patricia Carroll
He was a jerk. This is sad.
Jennifer Sanders
He was narcissistic
Tom Fellows
Charles Dickens was a wife abuser.
Heather Weir
The most disturbing part is that Dickens tried to have Catherine committed to an asylum,using his power in a male-dominated society to paint her as unstable. He even turned their children against her, using his status as provider to isolate and control her.
Brenda Rust
Seems some men have not changed much over the centuries.
Dessislava Kolarova
He’s just another one of many artist who were as**oles in real life
Lisa Gabrielcich
I didn't know he was such a horrible person. Men could get away with so much in Victorian times. So sad.
Susan Gann
He made her have all these kids and then didn't want her cause she was chubby
Luce Law
Charles Dickens was such an a-hole.
Claire Tremblay
Dickens sounds like he was a real &&&&ens. She deserved so much better!
  • Reply
  • Edited
Corrie Luns
men do that!
Susan Farley
What a tragic story
Hendrika Buffone
Terrible guy this Dickens was.
Patricia Duke
Some men back then were horrible to their wives. But had kid after kid with them...He was one fir the books.
Darcy Harefeld
I had no idea. So Dickens was not such a good man after all. 😢 Fame and money cankers lives.
Beth Lukefahr Lewis
Pig His books are overrated and too damned long
Adrienne Obbard
Very interesting. Life was very hard for women in those days. No way out.
Lara Shargorodsky
Charles Dickens shamelessly deserted Catherine , behaved like a real despicable monster immoral and amoral in every respect , it was most appalling to read the book about the young actress, her family’s behavior and Dickens’ role in Miss Ternan’s life. Piercing….
Kathi Snook
God knows her and that is all that is truly important. Maybe Charles ended in heaven too but at least she isn’t shackled to him there.
Karen Taylor
By all counts, Dickens was a literary w@nker then 😡
  • Reply
  • Edited
Paula Hartley
What an amazing woman what a cruel evil man
Sean Davis
Good Lord! This sounds positively Dickensian.
Mary Jones
Sad just sad..
Louise Culmer
It was Dickens who decided she should move out. Only their eldest son went with her.
Sandie Robbins
It makes me want to weep how awful he was to his wife, the vicious git!!.
Jennie Hudson
I can remember going to his house when I was a child it's now a museum...his wife had a disability or was severely depressed..I rambert she birthed about 10 kids and he was having an affair with her sister
Max Headroom
U know it was going bad she didn’t get the 🛏️
Pamela Corbett
Don’t forget the obsession he had in his own home with Catherine’s seventeen-year old sister who died suddenly.
He went into a deep depression, saying he wanted to be buried with her. Poor wife.
Amanda Hill
Tale as old as time....
Chris Hopkins
She was trapped in an unhappy marriage. In those days there was no escape. Very sad that she appears to have been estranged from her children.
Katarzyna Kopytek-Portlouis
Hmm I dont like him anymore and anything he wrote
Christine Lambert
He has the word Dick in his name
Marise Smith
Shameful but typical of people who become famous x
Marcia Hill
He was so cruel.
Karen Evoy Ramstedt
An amazing woman.
Jay Burston
What a horrible heartless man. Shameless
Dewana Healy
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE LETTERS??????
Sherrod Shiveley
This is AI. Actually he took up with his wife’s sister 😢
Dara McCarty
Unfortunately , men adore young women! He was a cad!
Sonny Piccirillo
I think many of our celebrity men and politicians are evil. Power is all they want. Control. egotistical, devious and very sinister people.
  • Reply
  • Edited
Avis Marrington
So sad 😞 I'm glad I'm a woman now and not then. I see Dickens different now.
Joanna Chuza
Never liked Charles Dickens literature.
Christian Hoffman
The guy had multiple mental and physical health issues. It’s a wonder he did much at all
Belinda Burke
I love Charles dickens and read much about his early life, he’s one of my favourite authors .. I did read that he succumbed to the charms of a younger woman but never knew he treated his own wife, mother of his children with such disdain .. very sad !
Sandy Hollenbeck Bailey
Men always make excuses for wanting sex. ‘I’m a hunter.’ Ugh
Lisa Roberts Wise-Wideman
Dickens was a Dick ens
Louise Harrington
Every family has secrets.
Kala Nash
Awe poor Catherine, he was no looker himself, probably looked the same since he was 14, creepy guy. Her children loved her that’s all that matters.
Rebecca Kaler Langley
If this is true, he kept enjoying her sexually for her to have his 10 children!!! He must have been a very selfish and insecure narcissist.
Jim Leber
Behind every great man is a greater woman.
  • Reply
  • Edited
Joseph MacDonald
Looks like Lindsey Graham
Anna Carol Senger
Dickens was a CAD
Camille Claudel
a new category: literary covert malignant narcissist