0:50
An experience I would wish for many is one day to find oneself away from home.
0:58
Not necessarily out of one’s own country but at least outside familiar territory, outside your bubble,
1:03
and immersed in a completely different world. And in that world to experience the condition of foreigner.
1:10
It is then view of come to have a different outlook on foreigners.
1:22
Bishop Pierre Claverie challenges us through his message. His life and death shine a light
1:29
on the essential question of meeting with that “other” who is so different.
1:35
He writes: “more and more everywhere, men of all races, all cultures
1:42
and all religions are called to live together. And where human groups coexist without communication,
1:49
violence is near: misunderstandings develop in the fertile ground of ignorance
1:56
and of scorn for the other. Therefore, it is urgent to work towards making possible meeting
2:02
in respect and confidence”.
2:11
Pierre Claverie was born on the eighth of May 1938 in Algiers, in the Bab-el-Oued district,
2:17
to a French family in Algeria for four generations.
2:22
The unity of his family brought him human and spiritual balance.
2:27
He inherited his mother’s love of life and his father’s determined character.
2:34
For nearly forty years, with astonishing regularity, and in spite of great responsibilities,
2:41
he kept up a weekly correspondence with his family, sharing with them the details of his life
2:48
his reactions to events, but also his faith, his prayer, his religious life.
2:57
Having become a Dominican and been ordained bishop of Oran, he was assassinated in 1996.
3:05
Mohamed Bouchikhi, a young Muslim friend, who had come to meet him at the airport, died with him.
3:14
Inspired by this friendship, the Dominican brother Adrien Candiard wrote a play “Pierre and Mohamed”,
3:22
a monologue in which the actor plays turnabout the two characters.
3:29
Using texts and sermons by Bishop Claverie and inventing speech for Mohamed,
3:35
this play which has been performed more than 800 times bears homage to Pierre Claverie’s friendship for Muslims, for Algerians.
3:44
A friendship which went the full length.
4:00
He grew up in that Algeria, he the little French boy,
4:08
and I don’t understand how he could have loved it.
4:14
I don’t understand how he can love it, when he sees it like that, today.
4:23
How he can love it enough not to leave it, not to go back to France?
4:35
How can you love a sick country
4:41
that suffers and devours itself?
4:49
For me, that is the mystery of Pierre.
5:06
Bishop Pierre Claverie, a friend to the Algerians
5:17
Perhaps because I did not know the others
5:23
or that I denied their existence, one day they jumped in front of me
5:32
and affirmed their existence.
5:38
The appearance of others, the recognition of them,
5:44
the adjusting to them, became, for me, obsession.
5:55
That was probably the origin of my religious vocation.
6:05
Otherness is the great question of his life finally, since for the first seventeen years of his youth,
6:12
he lived beside the other without seeing him: the Muslim other, the Algerian other.
6:18
He began to evolve when towards the age of eighteen, he leaves Algiers for university studies in France, in Grenoble.
6:27
This departure from Algeria is for him a kind of injury, he loses his place of origin,
6:32
that warm Mediterranean. He arrives in Grenoble, he says: “It rains all the time here”. And then, most importantly, he discovers a politically conscious university
6:41
where his ignorance about colonial reality is shaken by young students,
6:46
or even professors, with political positions. This will bring him to an interior path
6:52
where are woven at the same time his religious vocation and his human vocation of personal opening.
7:03
Having entered the Dominican order and been ordained priest, he agreed to return to Algeria
7:09
when most of the Europeans established on Algerian territory for over 150 years
7:15
had to leave. Almost a million of those now called “pieds-noirs” (black feet)
7:22
cross the Mediterranean in conditions which are often difficult.
7:28
Independence was granted to Algeria in 1962 after 8 years of struggle between the FLN, National Liberation Front,
7:37
and the French army. A struggle which left many dead
7:43
and involved attacks, torture and massacres in both Algeria and France.
7:51
The Church of Algeria also experience upheaval: the churches were empty almost overnight.
7:59
Pierre Claverie was present in Algeria and endured this period of great change.
8:08
He is very close to Bishop Teissier who is already bishop of Oran. And with Henri Teissier and others,
8:15
he will accomplish his work as a theologian accompanying the reflection of a Church
8:23
which must find sense in its presence among a people principally Muslim.
8:29
If it is not a question of proselytism: “I am here to make you change”, what does one say?
8:37
There is a whole reflection to be made on friendship, witness, companionship, being with.
8:47
He entered fully into the project of our Church, with Cardinal Duval, who set us in that direction,
8:58
and of Vatican II, to be a Church reaching out in a society, in society.
9:06
I think the Church in Algeria is marked by that condition of minority identity.
9:15
All Christians together, Catholics, Protestants, Evangelicals,
9:21
if we are 30,000 out of 40 million inhabitants it is the maximum.
9:32
Pierre Claverie learned Arabic with Lebanese sisters of the Holy Hearts.
9:37
He studied Islam and creates links of friendship with many Algerian Muslims.
9:45
Made director of the centre for diocesan studies, les Glycines, in 1973 in Algiers,
9:52
he will taught Arabic to Algerians.
9:57
He was ordained bishop of Oran in 1981 following Bishop Teissier.
10:04
In spite of all his responsibility, he wished to remain a religious and did not give up his ministry of Dominican preaching.
10:12
He spent his vacations preaching retreats and, each month, wrote the editorial in the bulletin of the diocese of Oran,
10:18
taking an active part in the social and political life of Algeria.
10:27
Where he was once more quite creative was in that, of course, our churches were empty,
10:33
we no longer needed our presbyteries, and so he said “But that is wonderful!
10:39
We can turn them into platforms for service and meetings”. That was his expression: platforms for service and meetings.
10:44
That is to say instead of whining about the fact that we were not very numerous, we turned it around and tried to be positive.
10:54
He always told us: the first step is the hardest. The words I would like to keep: get out of yourself.
11:01
He said to us: go out, we must get out of ourselves. Have an open door then go beyond self.
11:13
His message was immediately a sign
11:18
to the intellectuals of Oran that they had there not only
11:26
a bishop in charge of the Christian community of Western Algeria but a man who reflected on Algerian society,
11:37
on the evolution of the world. A man of faith who was capable of illuminating that reflection
11:42
not only by his Christian identity but also by the experience of the arabo-muslim world.
11:58
Through that experience caused by the isolation, then the crisis and the emerging of the individual,
12:06
I acquired the personal conviction that humanity can exist only in the plural.
12:14
The moment we pretend to possess the truth
12:20
or to speak in the name of humanity, in the Catholic Church, we have had sad experience of that in our history,
12:30
we fall into totalitarianism and exclusion. No one possesses the truth.
12:41
Everyone seeks it.
12:48
One does not possess God. One does not possess the truth.
12:56
And I need, I need the truth of others.
13:09
He is firm in his convictions, he is a Christian, he is a bishop, he is a theologian,
13:14
he believes that Christ gives him full access to God. But what he wants to say is that our understanding
13:20
is still on the road and while we are on the road it might be worth while to look at others along the road.
13:28
What is interesting is that he shows that a Muslim on the road near him
13:34
also contributes things to his knowledge of God.
13:40
When I see the history of salvation, when I see God’s pedagogy in accompanying his people,
13:47
it is never all or nothing. It is never just a yes or a no. It is never binary logic.
13:53
It is always an accompaniment, it is always a process, including Christ’s companionship with his disciples.
14:00
It was not at the very beginning that he asked them: ”Do you recognize me as the Messiah?
14:06
Then you are my disciples”. He called them and bit by bit,
14:12
he asked them to recognize him. He led them to recognize him as Messiah.
14:19
And so, this accompaniment can turn into friendship, brotherhood, mutual questioning,
14:29
bringing me also as a Christian to see how to deepen my grounding in Christ.
14:40
The responsibility of Christians, to my mind, is to make their faith audible
14:47
by hearing the questions put forth by Islam and Muslims,
14:53
undoing preconceived ideas and making possible a common ground,
15:02
at least at the human level, in this opening towards God.
15:13
The time for dialogue cannot yet begin, he told me: for before the time for dialogue
15:24
there must be time for friendship.
15:34
Friendship Friendship which makes possible real talk,
15:44
talk that listens, talk that does not deny the other by trying to convince him,
15:52
that is what he came to live in Algeria.
15:59
It is now and urgent. In the sense that, as always, relations between Christians and Muslims are conflictual,
16:07
from the beginning of their history. In my opinion we must face up to history and accept the difficulties we have
16:14
to understand, get along with and live together. Nevertheless, because the difficulties have increased in recent years,
16:22
it is urgent for men and women of good will to devote themselves perhaps not to an Islamo-Christian dialogue
16:28
in the sense that such a dialogue would deal primarily with doctrine and understanding of texts or of the contents of the faith of one or the other
16:35
but a renewed encounter, an attempt at peaceful encounter. That is what we are trying to live there,
16:41
it is in part the mission of our Church.
16:49
Pierre Claverie did not have an idealistic vision of Islam,
16:55
unlike Islamologists who look at it from afar.
17:00
He liked to say, just as I and others do: "We are not meeting Islam, we are meeting Muslims".
17:07
This is very important. Islam is something abstract, but there are Muslims.
17:13
Moreover, the Second Vatican Council, in its declaration "Nostra Aetate", does not speak of Islam, it speaks of Muslims.
17:23
If we truly believe that God has given himself, revealed himself, spoken, and that he has begun a relationship
17:32
with what it is to be really human in the real world, then he calls his Church to do the same thing.
17:39
Paul VI in his encyclical "Ecclesiam Suam" said also like this.
17:46
He says that "the Church makes conversation with the world". It is her nature, her vocation,
17:52
she is called to make conversation, that is to say to have a dialogue.
17:58
This is what defines the Christian reality because we are inhabited by the Word of God.
18:03
The Word of God is nothing other than this intimate dialogue with God
18:11
made possible by the Spirit and the breath.
18:21
Between 1991 and 2002, Algeria went through a "black decade".
18:28
The electoral process was blocked by the military in order to prevent Islamists from coming to power,
18:35
who had nevertheless won a large majority. The islamists decided to engage in an armed struggle.
18:43
A period of assassinations and violence began, particularly targetting at those who represented civic life:
18:51
the police, magistrates, moderate imams, politicians, teachers, journalists, singers,
18:59
and in a second period of time, foreigners. The traditional Islam of Algeria is an Islam of brotherhood and devotion.
19:13
But the Arabization which took place after independence by professors who came from the Middle East,
19:19
spread radical islamic ideas. These ideas found favourable ground
19:26
because of the corruption of politicians and because of poverty, and islamism made its way into mosques and into hearts.
19:37
It's a geopolitical crisis, a crisis of identity. It's a religious crisis, a regional crisis
19:45
and also a crisis of the muslim religion which was also meeting modernity in a different way.
19:51
And like all crises, it led to a change, a transformation,
19:57
like the crisis of adolescence which leads to adulthood, or it could lead to a crisis of tension:
20:04
we go backwards because we fear change we fear openness.
20:13
From 1991-92 and the increase in lslamist violence,
20:20
the focus was a little bit different. It was "The other has an identity that I don't understand,
20:27
and I need to know how to behave in the face of this resistance"
20:33
I couldn't propose to the Muslim community
20:38
that they followed the path of interior and spiritual renewal
20:44
that the Christian community had been in the process of since Vatican II and even for the last 50 years.
20:51
This religious tradition had its own rhythms.
21:09
Since the beginning of the Algerian drama, I have often been asked:
21:14
What are you doing there? Why do you stay?
21:22
Shake the dust off your sandals!
21:28
Go home! Home?
21:36
Where is our home? We are here because of our crucified Messiah.
21:44
Because of nothing else and nobody else!
21:50
We are there, like being at the bedside of a friend,
21:56
of a sick brother, in silence,
22:03
holding his hand, wiping his forehead.
22:12
Because of Jesus, because it is him who is suffering over there, in this violence
22:17
that spares no one, crucified again in the flesh of thousands innocents.
22:25
Where would the Church of Jesus Christ be if not there?
22:35
I believe the Church is dying from not being close enough
22:41
to the cross of her Lord.
22:50
I believe that Jesus put himself right on the fracture lines of humanity. Where there was rejection, intolerance and brokenness.
22:57
Whether it is fracture lines within people: those who are ill, in despair, alone, rejected,
23:06
or whether it is fractures between groups of people we could take the pharisee and the publican as an example;
23:12
or jews and gentiles, or believers and non-believers.
23:18
So Jesus put himself there and did little else other than to stand there.
23:24
This is the last image that Jesus gave us in his life an image of a man torn apart.
23:30
One hand on the inside and one hand with the excluded.
23:39
He put his disciples onto these same fracture lines with the same mission of healing and reconciliation.
23:47
The church accomplishes its vocation and its mission when it is present in that brokenness which crucifies humanity in its flesh and in its unity.
24:01
Why stay here? And Pierre replied "Even for a single life of someone like Mohamed,
24:10
it is worth risking one’s life" He knew very well that he was going to die.
24:16
How could the storm of fire which fell on Algeria
24:22
and didn’t even spare the monks lost in the mountains, pass by without carrying with it this strong voice
24:30
which spoke on the radio and even on the television?
24:42
If Pierre has to die, allow me to be with him at that moment.
24:58
It would be too sad if Pierre, who loved friendship so much
25:07
did not have a friend by his side
25:13
to accompany him at the hour of his death.
25:52
The death of Monseigneur Claverie and of my son Mohamed
25:58
was a sign of peace, of peace and friendship.
26:05
Their blood, their flesh was mingled and shredded.
26:13
They were mixed together, buried together.
26:19
It is a sign from God that we are all children of God,
26:24
Christians and Muslims. This is the sign of peace and friendship.
26:38
On 1st August 1996, Mohamed Bouchikhi accompanied his friend
26:43
inside the bishop's palace. A bomb was waiting for them.
26:49
At Bishop Pierre Claverie’s burial, many muslims came to pay him hommage.
26:55
He was the last of the 19 religious assassinated in Algeria, among 150,000 dead, victims of the black decade.
27:05
The church which went through this drama with the algerians became at that very moment
27:11
the «Algerian Church»
27:21
Here are the words of this arabic song: We testify that there is no existence except through love
27:28
We testify that there is no life other than in love We testify that there is no man except for love
27:35
We testify that there is no God but Love
28:12
He was assassinated.
28:18
It was terrible. They wanted to shut him up,
28:25
but he speaks even more now.
28:32
It seems to me absolutely essential that in France and everywhere that it is possible,
28:38
Christians and Muslims should build relationships of trust and confidence, of friendship and try to come to a mutual understanding
28:45
so that where that is not possible, we can at least look to the outside,
28:51
and again hope that a future between christians and muslims will be
28:56
open. This is what a friend, Oum el Kheir, told us
29:05
about the presence of the church with other believers : « Be the little stone
29:11
which prevents the door of Islam from closing on itself »
29:18
Personally I believe very much in the importance of meeting. I think that it is with people that we can understand things.
29:24
We can read books, but the most important thing is to meet at home and elsewhere.
29:29
This is the way Europe has to go and I think that if it doesn’t stay as an open Europe,
29:38
a Europe that has values, it too will be forced to shut itself inside a wall,
29:44
I mean what it is doing at the moment, and obviously that will lead to violence.
29:49
The only alternative to violence is to encounter one another.
29:56
Everyone should have at least one muslim friend. Because when you have a muslim friend,
30:01
you have a key to enter into a reality that you don’t understand, which seems strange, possibly threatening.
30:08
So I think we should not be afraid but dare to form friendships.
30:29
From the book of Isaiah, chapter 50, verses 4 and 5
30:34
The Sovereign Lord has given me an instructed tongue,
30:40
to know the word that sustains the weary.
30:45
He wakens me morning by morning, wakens my ear to listen like a disciple.
30:53
The Sovereign Lord has opened my ears, and I have not been rebellious, I have not drawn back.
31:08
Lord you came to meet us when we were still far off.
31:14
Give us the grace of encountering others who are different from us and who might make us afraid.
31:21
Come and disarm in us and in the other, all violence, closeness, contempt and hatred.
31:30
We pray for the Algerian Church, that it might continue to be a sign of your love for all.
31:37
We entrust to you the Chemin Neuf Community and its presence in the monastery of Tibhirine.