2022/03/15

Crow people - Wikipedia



https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=333063728841609&set=a.105513604929957


Crow people - Wikipedia

Crow people

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Crow Tribe of Montana
Apsáalooke
Flag of the Crow Nation.svg
Tribal Flag
Pauline Small.jpg
Pauline Small on horseback. She carries the flag of the Crow Tribe of Montana. As a tribal official, she is entitled to carry the flag during the Crow Fair parade.
Total population
12,000 enrolled members
Regions with significant populations
United States (Montana)
Languages
Crow, English, Plains Sign Talk
Religion
Christianity, Crow Way, Tobacco Society
Related ethnic groups
Hidatsa
Crow Indians, c. 1878–1883

The Crow, whose autonym is Apsáalooke ([ə̀ˈpsáːɾòːɡè]), also spelled Absaroka, are Native Americans living primarily in southern Montana. Today, the Crow people have a federally recognized tribe, the Crow Tribe of Montana,[1] with an Indian reservation located in the south-central part of the state.[1]

Crow Indians are a Plains tribe, who speak the Crow language, part of the Missouri River Valley branch of Siouan languages. Of the 14,000 enrolled tribal members, an estimated 3,000 spoke the Crow language in 2007.[2]

During the expansion into the West, the Crow Nation was allied with the United States against its neighbors and rivals, the Sioux and Cheyenne. In historical times, the Crow lived in the Yellowstone River valley, which extends from present-day Wyoming, through Montana and into North Dakota, where it joins the Missouri River.

Since the 19th century, Crow people have been concentrated on their reservation established south of Billings, Montana. Today, they live in several major, mainly western, cities. Tribal headquarters are located at Crow Agency, Montana.[3] The tribe operates the Little Big Horn College.[2]

Name[edit]

The autonym of the tribe, Apsáalooké or Absaroka, means "children of the large-beaked bird"[4] and was given to them by the Hidatsa, a neighboring and related Siouan-speaking tribe. French interpreters translated the name as gens du corbeau ("people of the crow"), and they became known in English as the Crow. Other tribes also refer to the Apsáalooke as "crow" or "raven" in their own languages.[5] The identity of the bird this name was meant to refer to originally is lost to time, but many Apsáalooké people believe it references the mythical Thunderbird.[6]

History[edit]

In the Northern Plains[edit]

Landscape on the Crow Indian Reservation, Montana

The early home of the Crow Hidatsa ancestral tribe was near Lake Erie in what is now Ohio. Driven from there by better armed, aggressive neighbors, they briefly settled south of Lake Winnipeg in Manitoba.[7][page needed] Later the people moved to the Devil's Lake region of North Dakota before the Crow split from the Hidatsa and moved westward. The Crow were largely pushed westward due to intrusion and influx of the Cheyenne and subsequently the Sioux, also known as the Lakota.

To acquire control of their new territory, the Crow warred against Shoshone bands, such as the Bikkaashe, or "People of the Grass Lodges",[8] and drove them westward. The Crow allied with local Kiowa and Plains Apache bands.[9][10][11] The Kiowa and Plains Apache bands later migrated southward, and the Crow remained dominant in their established area through the 18th and 19th centuries, the era of the fur trade.

Their historical territory stretched from what is now Yellowstone National Park and the headwaters of the Yellowstone River (E-chee-dick-karsh-ah-shay in Crow, translating to "Elk River") to the west, north to the Musselshell River, then northeast to the Yellowstone's mouth at the Missouri River, then southeast to the confluence of the Yellowstone and Powder rivers (Bilap Chashee, or "Powder River" or "Ash River"), south along the South Fork of the Powder River, confined in the SE by the Rattlesnake Mountains and westwards in the SW by the Wind River Range. Their tribal area included the river valleys of the Judith River (Buluhpa'ashe, or "Plum River"), Powder River, Tongue RiverBig Horn River and Wind River as well as the Bighorn Mountains (Iisiaxpúatachee Isawaxaawúua), Pryor Mountains (Baahpuuo Isawaxaawúua), Wolf Mountains (Cheetiish, or "Wolf Teeth Mountains") and Absaroka Range (also called Absalaga Mountains).[12]

Once established in the Valley of the Yellowstone River[13] and its tributaries on the Northern Plains in Montana and Wyoming, the Crow divided into four groups: the Mountain Crow, River Crow, Kicked in the Bellies, and Beaver Dries its Fur. Formerly semi-nomad hunters and farmers in the northeastern woodland, they adapted to the nomadic lifestyle of the Plains Indians as hunters and gatherers, and hunted bison. Before 1700, they were using dog travois for carrying goods.[14][15]

Enemies and allies[edit]

Ledger drawing of a Cheyenne war chief and warriors (left) coming to a truce with a Crow war chief and warriors (right)
A scout on a horse, 1908 by Edward S. Curtis

From about 1740, the Plains tribes rapidly adopted the horse, which allowed them to move out on to the Plains and hunt buffalo more effectively. However, the severe winters in the North kept their herds smaller than those of Plains tribes in the South. The Crow, Hidatsa, Eastern Shoshone and Northern Shoshone soon became noted as horse breeders and dealers and developed relatively large horse herds. At the time, other eastern and northern tribes were also moving on to the Plains, in search of game for the fur trade, bison, and more horses. The Crow were subject to raids and horse thefts by horse-poor tribes, including the powerful Blackfoot ConfederacyGros VentreAssiniboinePawnee, and Ute.[16][17] Later they had to face the Lakota and their allies, the Arapaho and Cheyenne, who also stole horses from their enemies. Their greatest enemies became the tribes of the Blackfoot Confederacy and the Lakota-Cheyenne-Arapaho alliance.

In the 18th century, pressured by the Ojibwe and Cree peoples (the Iron Confederacy), who had earlier and better access to guns through the fur trade, the Crow had migrated to this area from the Ohio Eastern Woodland area of present-day Ohio, settling south of Lake Winnipeg. From there, they were pushed to the west by the Cheyenne. Both the Crow and the Cheyenne were pushed farther west by the Lakota, who took over the territory west of the Missouri River, reaching past the Black Hills of South Dakota to the Big Horn Mountains of Wyoming and Montana. The Cheyenne eventually became allies of the Lakota, as they sought to expel European Americans from the area. The Crow remained bitter enemies of both the Sioux and Cheyenne. The Crow managed to retain a large reservation of more than 9300 km2 despite territorial losses, due in part to their cooperation with the federal government against their traditional enemies, the Sioux and Blackfoot. Many other tribes were forced onto much smaller reservations far from their traditional lands.

The Crow were generally friendly with the northern Plains tribes of the Flathead (although sometimes they had conflicts); Nez PerceKutenai, Shoshone, Kiowa and Plains Apache. The powerful Iron Confederacy (Nehiyaw-Pwat), an alliance of northern plains Indian nations based around the fur trade, developed as enemies of the Crow. It was named after the dominating Plains Cree and Assiniboine peoples, and later included the StoneySaulteauxOjibwe, and Métis.

Historical subgroups[edit]

By the early 19th century, the Apsáalooke fell into three independent groupings, who came together only for common defense:[18]

  • Ashalaho ('Many Lodges', today called Mountain Crow), Awaxaawaxammilaxpáake ('Mountain People'), or Ashkúale ('The Center Camp'). The Ashalaho or Mountain Crow, the largest Crow group, split from the Awatixa Hidatsa and were the first to travel west. (McCleary 1997: 2–3)., (Bowers 1992: 21) Their leader No Intestines had received a vision and led his band on a long migratory search for sacred tobacco, finally settling in southeastern Montana. They lived in the Rocky Mountains and foothills along the Upper Yellowstone River, on the present-day Wyoming-Montana border, in the Big Horn and Absaroka Range (also Absalaga Mountains); the Black Hills comprised the eastern edge of their territory.
  • Binnéessiippeele ('Those Who Live Amongst the River Banks'), today called River Crow or Ashshipíte ('The Black Lodges') The Binnéessiippeele, or River Crow, split from the Hidatsa proper, according to tradition because of a dispute over a bison stomach. As a result, the Hidatsa called the Crow Gixáa-iccá—"Those Who Pout Over Tripe".[19][20] They lived along the Yellowstone and Musselshell rivers south of the Missouri River and in the river valleys of the Big Horn, Powder and Wind rivers. This area was historically known as the Powder River Country. They sometimes traveled north up to the Milk River.
  • Eelalapito (Kicked in the Bellies) or Ammitaalasshé (Home Away From The Center, that is, away from the Ashkúale – "Mountain Crow").[21][22] They claimed the area known as the Bighorn Basin, from the Bighorn Mountains in the east to the Absaroka Range to the west, and south to the Wind River Range in northern Wyoming. Sometimes they settled in the Owl Creek MountainsBridger Mountains and along the Sweetwater River in the south.[23]

Apsaalooke oral history describes a fourth group, the Bilapiluutche ("Beaver Dries its Fur"), who may have merged with the Kiowa in the second half of the 17th century.

Gradual displacement from tribal lands[edit]

Crow Indian territory (areas 517, 619 and 635) as described in Fort Laramie treaty (1851), present Montana and Wyoming

When European Americans arrived in numbers, the Crows were resisting pressure from enemies who greatly outnumbered them. In the 1850s, a vision by Plenty Coups, then a boy, but who later became their greatest chief, was interpreted by tribal elders as meaning that the whites would become dominant over the entire country, and that the Crow, if they were to retain any of their land, would need to remain on good terms with the whites.[24]

By 1851 the more numerous Lakota and Cheyenne were established just to the south and east of Crow territory in Montana.[25] These enemy tribes coveted the hunting lands of the Crow and warred against them. By right of conquest, they took over the eastern hunting lands of the Crow, including the Powder and Tongue River valleys, and pushed the less numerous Crow to the west and northwest upriver on the Yellowstone. After about 1860, the Lakota Sioux claimed all the former Crow lands from the Black Hills of South Dakota to the Big Horn Mountains of Montana. They demanded that the Americans deal with them regarding any intrusion into these areas.

The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1851 with the United States confirmed as Crow lands a large area centered on the Big Horn Mountains: the area ran from the Big Horn Basin on the west, to the Musselshell River on the north, and east to the Powder River; it included the Tongue River basin.[26] But for two centuries the Cheyenne and many bands of Lakota Sioux had been steadily migrating westward across the plains, and were still pressing hard on the Crows.

"Eight Crow prisoners under guard at Crow agency, Montana, 1887"

Red Cloud's War (1866–1868) was a challenge by the Lakota Sioux to the United States military presence on the Bozeman Trail, a route along the eastern edge of the Big Horn Mountains to the Montana gold fields. Red Cloud's War ended with victory for the Lakota. The Treaty of Fort Laramie (1868) with the United States confirmed the Lakota control over all the high plains from the Black Hills of the Dakotas westward across the Powder River Basin to the crest of the Big Horn Mountains.[27] Thereafter bands of Lakota Sioux led by Sitting BullCrazy HorseGall and others, along with their Northern Cheyenne allies, hunted and raided throughout the length and breadth of eastern Montana and northeastern Wyoming, which had been for a time ancestral Crow territory.

On 25 June 1876, the Lakota Sioux and Cheyenne achieved a major victory over army forces under Colonel George A. Custer at the Battle of the Little Big Horn in the Crow Indian Reservation,[28] but the Great Sioux War (1876–1877) ended in the defeat of the Sioux and their Cheyenne allies. Crow warriors enlisted with the US Army for this war. The Sioux and allies were forced from eastern Montana and Wyoming: some bands fled to Canada, while others suffered forced removal to distant reservations, primarily in present-day Montana and Nebraska west of the Missouri River.

In 1918, the Crow organized a gathering to display their culture, and they invited members of other tribes. The Crow Fair is now celebrated yearly on the third weekend of August, with wide participation from other tribes.[29]

Crow Tribe history: a chronological record[edit]

1600–1699[edit]

A group of Crow Natives went west after leaving the Hidatsa villages of earth lodges in the Knife River and Heart River area (present North Dakota) around 1675–1700. They selected a site for a single earth lodge on the lower Yellowstone River. Most families lived in tipis or other perishable kinds of homes at the new place. These Indians had left the Hidatsa villages and adjacent cornfields for good, but they had yet to become "real" buffalo hunting Crows following the herds on the open plains.[30] Archaeologists know this "proto-Crow" site in present Montana as the Hagen site.[31]

1700–1799[edit]

Some time before 1765 the Crows held a Sun Dance, attended by a poor Arapaho. A Crow with power gave him a medicine doll, and he quickly earned status and owned horses as no one else. During the next Sun Dance, some Crows stole back the figure to keep it in the tribe. Eventually the Arapaho made a duplicate. Later in life, he married a Kiowa woman and brought the doll with him. The Kiowas use it during the Sun Dance and recognize it as one of the most powerful tribal medicines. They still credit the Crow tribe for the origin of their sacred Tai-may figure.[32]

1800–1824[edit]

The trading posts built for trade with the Crows

The enmity between the Crow and the Lakota was reassured right from the start of the 19th Century. The Crows killed a minimum of thirty Lakotas in 1800–1801 according to two Lakota winter counts.[33] The next year, the Lakotas and their Cheyenne allies killed all the men in a Crow camp with thirty tipis.[34]

In the summer of 1805, a Crow camp traded at the Hidatsa villages on Knife River in present North Dakota. Chiefs Red Calf and Spotted Crow allowed the fur trader Francois-Antoine Larocque to join it on its way across the plains to the Yellowstone area. He travelled with it to a point west of the place where Billings, Montana, is today. The camp crossed Little Missouri River and Bighorn River on the way.[35]

The next year, some Crows discovered a group of whites with horses on the Yellowstone River. By stealth, they captured the mounts before morning. The Lewis and Clark Expedition did not see the Crows.[36]

The first trading post in Crow country was constructed in 1807, known as both Fort Raymond and Fort Lisa (1807–ca. 1813). Like the succeeding forts, Fort Benton (ca. 1821–1824) and Fort Cass (1832–1838), it was built near the confluence of the Yellowstone and the Bighorn.[37]

The Blood Blackfoot Bad Head's winter count tells about the early and persistent hostility between the Crow and the Blackfoot. In 1813, a force of Blood warriors set off for a raid on the Crows in the Bighorn area. Next year, Crows near Little Bighorn River killed Blackfoot Top Knot.[38]: 6 

A Crow camp neutralized thirty Cheyennes bent on capturing horses in 1819.[39] The Cheyennes and warriors from a Lakota camp destroyed a whole Crow camp at Tongue River the following year.[40] This was likely the most severe attack on a Crow camp in historic time.[41][42]

1825–1849[edit]

The Crows put up 300 tipis near a Mandan village on the Missouri in 1825.[43] The representatives of the US government waited for them. Mountain Crow chief Long Hair (Red Plume at Forehead) and fifteen other Crows signed the first treaty of friendship and trade between the Crows and the United States on 4 August.[44] With the signing of the document, the Crows also recognized the supremacy of the United States, if they actually understood the word. River Crow chief Arapooish had left the treaty area in disgust. By help of the thunderbird he had to send a farewell shower down on the whites and the Mountain Crows.[45]

In 1829, seven Crow warriors were neutralized by Blood Blackfoot Indians led by Spotted Bear, who captured a pipe-hatchet during the fight just west of Chinook, Montana.[38]: 8 

In the summer of 1834, the Crows (maybe led by chief Arapooish) tried to shut down Fort McKenzie at the Missouri in Blackfeet country. The apparent motive was to stop the trading post's sale to their Indian enemies. Although later described as a month long siege of the fort,[46] it lasted only two days.[47] The opponents exchanged a few shots and the men in the fort fired a cannon, but no real harm came to anyone. The Crows left four days before the arrival of a Blackfeet band. The episode seems to be the worst armed conflict between the Crows and a group of whites until the Sword Bearer uprising in 1887.

The death of chief Arapooish was recorded on 17 September 1834. The news reached Fort Clark at the Mandan village Mitutanka. Manager F.A. Chardon wrote he "was Killed by Black feet".[48]

The smallpox epidemic of 1837 spread along the Missouri and "had little impact" on the tribe according to one source.[49] The River Crows grew in number, when a group of Hidatsas joined them permanently to escape the scourge sweeping through the Hidatsa villages.[50]

Fort Van Buren was a short-lived trading post in existence from 1839–1842.[51]: 68  It was built on the bank of the Yellowstone near the mouth of Tongue River.[48]: 315, note 469 

In the summer of 1840, a Crow camp in the Bighorn valley greeted the Jesuit missionary Pierre-Jean De Smet.[52]: 35 

From 1842 to around 1852,[53]: 235  the Crows traded in Fort Alexander opposite the mouth of the Rosebud.[51]: 68 

The River Crows charged a moving Blackfeet camp near Judith Gap in 1845. Father De Smet mourned the destructive attack on the "petite Robe" band.[54] The Blackfeet chief Small Robe had been mortally wounded and many killed. De Smet worked out the number of women and children taken captive to 160. By and by and with a fur trader as intermediary, the Crows agreed to let 50 women return to their tribe.[55]

1850–1874[edit]

De Smet map of the 1851 Fort Laramie Indian territories (the light area). Jesuit missionary De Smet drew this map with the tribal borders agreed upon at Fort Laramie in 1851. Although the map itself is wrong in certain ways, it has the Crow territory west of the Sioux territory as written in the treaty, and the Bighorn area as the heart of the Crow country.
Crow Indian Chief Big Shadow (Big Robber), signer of the Fort Laramie treaty (1851). Painting by Jesuit missionary De Smet.
Lone Dog's Sioux winter count, 1870. Thirty Crows killed in battle.

Fort Sarpy (I) near Rosebud River carried out trade with the Crows after the closing of Fort Alexander.[51]: 67  River Crows went some times to the bigger Fort Union at the confluence of the Yellowstone and the Missouri. Both the "famous Absaroka amazon" Woman Chief[53]: 213  and River Crow chief Twines His Tail (Rotten Tail) visited the fort in 1851.[53]: 211 

In 1851, the Crow, the Sioux and six other Indian Nations signed the Fort Laramie treaty along with the US. It should ensure peace forever between all nine partakers. Further, the treaty described the different tribal territories. The US was allowed to construct roads and forts.[56]: 594–595  A weak point in the treaty was the absence of rules to uphold the tribal borders.[51]: 87 

The Crow and various bands of Sioux attacked each other again from the mid-1850s.[57]: 226, 228 [58]: 9–12 [59]: 119–124 [60]: 362 [61]: 103  Soon, the Sioux took no notice of the 1851 borders[62]: 340  and expanded into Crow territory west of the Powder.[63]: 46 [64]: 407–408 [65]: 14  The Crows engaged in "… large-scale battles with invading Sioux …" near present-day Wyola, Montana.[65]: 84  Around 1860, the western Powder area was lost.[62]: 339 [66]

From 1857 to 1860, many Crows traded their surplus robes and skin at Fort Sarpy (II) near the mouth of the Bighorn River.[51]: 67–68 

During the mid-1860s, the Sioux resented the emigrant route Bozeman Trail through the Powder River bison habitat, although it mainly "crossed land guaranteed to the Crows".[51]: 89 [67]: 20 [68]: 170, note 13  When the Army built forts to protect the trail, the Crows cooperated with the garrisons.[51]: 89 and 91 [69]: 38–39  On 21 December 1866, the Sioux, Cheyenne and Arapaho defeated Captain William J. Fetterman and his men from Fort Phil Kearny.[51]: 89  Evidently, the US could not enforce respect for the treaty borders agreed upon 15 years before.[51]: 87 

The River Crows north of the Yellowstone developed a friendship with their former Gros Ventre enemies in the 1860s.[51]: 93 [61]: 105  A joint large-scale attack on a big Blackfoot camp at Cypress Hills (Canada) in 1866 resulted in a chaotic withdrawal of the Gros Ventres and Crows. The Blackfoot pursued the warriors for hours and killed allegedly more than 300.[61]: 106 [70]: 140 

In 1868, a new Fort Laramie treaty between the Sioux and the US turned 1851 Crow Powder River area into "unceded Indian territory" of the Sioux.[56]: 1002  "The Government had in effect betrayed the Crows…".[69]: 40  On 7 May, the same year, the Crow ceded vast ranges to the US due to pressure from white settlements north of Upper Yellowstone River and loss of eastern territories to the Sioux. They accepted a smaller reservation south of the Yellowstone.[56]: 1008–1011 

The Sioux and their Indian allies, now formally at peace with the US, focused on intertribal wars at once.[71]: 175  Raids against the Crows were "frequent, both by the Northern Cheyennes and by the Arapahos, as well as the Sioux, and by parties made up from all three tribes".[72]: 347  Crow chief Plenty Coups recalled, "The three worst enemies our people had were combined against us …".[73]: 127 and 107, 135, 153 

In April 1870, the Sioux overpowered a barricaded war group of 30 Crows in the Big Dry area.[58]: 33  The Crows were killed to either last or last but one man. Later, mourning Crows with "their hair cut off, their fingers and faces cut" brought the dead bodies back to camp.[74]: 153  The drawing from the Sioux winter count of Lone Dog shows the Crows in the circle (the breastwork), while the Sioux close in on them. The many lines indicates flying bullets. The Sioux lost 14 warriors.[75]: 126  Sioux chief Sitting Bull took part in this battle.[58]: 33 [76]: 115–119 

In the summer of 1870, some Sioux attacked a Crow reservation camp in the Bighorn/Little Bighorn area.[77] The Crows reported Sioux Indians in the same area again in 1871.[78]: 43  During the next years, this eastern part of the Crow reservation was taken over by the Sioux in search of buffalo.[79]: 182  In August 1873, visiting Nez Percés and a Crow reservation camp at Pryor Creek further west faced a force of Sioux warriors in a long confrontation.[51]: 107  Crow chief Blackfoot objected to this incursion and called for resolute US military actions against the Indian trespassers.[51]: 106  Due to Sioux attacks on both civilians and soldiers north of the Yellowstone in newly established US territory (Battle of Pease BottomBattle of Honsinger Bluff), the Commissioner of Indian Affairs advocated the use of troops to force the Sioux back to South Dakota in his 1873 report.[80]: 145  Nothing happened.

1875–1899[edit]

Crooks army before battle of the Rosebud. The Crow and Shoshone scouts and the Army are crossing Goose River on the way to the Rosebud in 1876. The equestrian woman may be either the Crow berdache Finds-them-and-kills-them or the Crow amazon The-other-magpie.[81]: 228 

Two years later, in early July 1875,[82]: 75  Crow chief Long Horse was killed in a suicidal attack on some Sioux,[73]: 277–284  who previously had killed three soldiers from Camp Lewis on the upper Judith River (near Lewistown).[83]: 114  George Bird Grinnell was a member of the exploring party in the Yellowstone National Park that year, and he saw the bringing in of the dead chief. A mule carried the body, which was wrapped in a green blanket. The chief was placed in a tipi "not far from the Crow camp, reclining on his bed covered with robes, his face handsomely painted".[83]: 116  Crow woman Pretty Shield remembered the sadness in camp. "We fasted, nearly starved in our sorrow for the loss of Long-Horse."[81]: 38 

Exposed to Sioux attacks, the Crows sided with the US during the Great Sioux War in 1876–1877.[62]: 342  On 10 April 1876, 23 Crows enlisted as Army scouts.[79]: 163  They enlisted against a traditional Indian enemy, "... who were now in the old Crow country, menacing and often raiding the Crows in their reservation camps."[84]: X  Charles Varnum, leader of Custer's scouts, understood how valuable the enrolment of scouts from the local Indian tribe was. "These Crows were in their own country and knew it thoroughly."[85]: 60 

Notable Crows like Medicine Crow[86]: 48  and Plenty Coups participated in the Rosebud Battle along with more than 160 other Crows.[65]: 47 [73]: 154–172 [69]: 116 

The Battle of the Little Bighorn stood on the Crow reservation.[69]: 113  As most battles between the US and the Sioux in the 1860s and 1870s, "It was a clash of two expanding empires, with the most dramatic battles occurring on lands only recently taken by the Sioux from other tribes."[63]: 42 [64]: 408 [62]: 342  When the Crow camp with Pretty Shield learned about the defeat of George A. Custer, it cried for the assumed dead Crow scouts "… and for Son-of-the-morning-star [Custer] and his blue soldiers …".[81]: 243 

On 8 January 1877, three Crows participated in the last battle of the Great Sioux War in the Wolf Mountains.[87]: 60 

In the spring of 1878, 700 Crow tipis were pitched at the confluence of Bighorn River and Yellowstone River. Together with Colonel Nelson A. Miles, an Army leader in the Great Sioux War, the big camp celebrated the victory over the Sioux.[51][88]: 283–285 

Culture[edit]

Subsistence[edit]

Buffalo Jump
The Oath Apsaroke by Edward S. Curtis depicting Crow men giving a symbolic oath with a bison meat offering on an arrow

The main food source for the Crow was the American bison which was hunted in a variety of ways. Before the use of horses the bison were hunted on foot and required hunters to stalk close to the bison, often with a wolf-pelt disguise, then pursue the animals quickly on foot before killing them with arrows or lances. The horse allowed the Crow to hunt bison more easily as well as hunt more at one time. Riders would panic the herd into a stampede and shoot the targeted animals with arrows or bullets from horseback or lance them through the heart. In addition to bison the Crow also hunted bighorn sheepmountain goats, deer, elk, bear, and other game. Buffalo meat was often roasted or boiled in a stew with prairie turnips. The rump, tongue, liver, heart, and kidneys all were considered delicacies. Dried bison meat was ground with fat and berries to make pemmican.[89] In addition to meat, wild edibles were gathered and eaten such as elderberries, wild turnip, and Saskatoon berries.

The Crow often hunted bison by utilizing buffalo jumps. "Where Buffaloes are Driven Over Cliffs at Long Ridge" was a favorite spot for meat procurement by the Crow Indians for over a century, from 1700 to around 1870 when modern weapons were introduced.[90] The Crow used this place annually in the autumn, a place of multiple cliffs along a ridge that eventually sloped to the creek. Early in the morning the day of the jump a medicine man would stand on the edge of the upper cliff, facing up the ridge. He would take a pair of bison hindquarters and pointing the feet along the lines of stones he would sing his sacred songs and call upon the Great Spirit to make the operation a success.[90] After this invocation the medicine man would give the two head drivers a pouch of incense.[90] As the two head drivers and their helpers headed up the ridge and the long line of stones they would stop and burn incense on the ground repeating this process four times.[90] The ritual was intended to make the animals come to the line where the incense was burned, then bolt back to the ridge area.[90]

Habitation and transportation[edit]

Crow Lodge of Twenty-five Buffalo Skins, 1832–33 by George Catlin
Crow men trading on horseback
Three Crow men on their horses, Edward S. Curtis, 1908

The traditional Crow shelter is the tipi or skin lodge made with bison hides stretched over wooden poles. The Crow are historically known to construct some of the largest tipis. Tipi poles were harvested from the lodgepole pine which acquired its name from its use as support for tipis.[91] Inside the tipi, mattresses and buffalo-hide seats were arranged around the edge, with a fireplace in the center. The smoke from the fire escaped through a hole or smoke-flap in the top of the tipi. At least one entrance hole with collapsible flap allowed entry into the tipi. Often hide paintings adorned the outside and inside of tipis with specific meanings attached to the images. Often specific tipi designs were unique to the individual owner, family, or society that resided in the tipi. Tipis are easily raised and collapsed and are lightweight, which is ideal for nomadic people like the Crow who move frequently and quickly. Once collapsed, the tipi poles are used to create a travois. Travois are a horse-pulled frame structure used by plains Indians to carry and pull belongings as well as small children. Many Crow families still own and use the tipi, especially when traveling. The annual Crow Fair has been described as the largest gathering of tipis in the world.

The most widely used form of transportation used by the Crow was the horse. Horses were acquired through raiding and trading with other Plains nations. People of the northern plains like the Crow mostly got their horses from people from the southern plains such as the Comanche and Kiowa who originally got their horses from the Spanish and southwestern Indians such as the various Pueblo people. The Crow had large horse herds which were among the largest owned by Plains Indians; in 1914 they had approximately thirty to forty thousand head. By 1921 the number of mounts had dwindled to just one thousand. Like other plains people the horse was central to the Crow economy and were a highly valuable trade item and were frequently stolen from other tribes to gain wealth and prestige as a warrior. The horse allowed the Crow to become powerful and skilled mounted warriors, being able to perform daring maneuvers during battle including hanging underneath a galloping horse and shooting arrows by holding onto its mane. They also had many dogs; one source counted five to six hundred. Dogs were used as guards and pack animals to carry belongings and pull travois. The introduction of horses into Crow society allowed them to pull heavier loads faster, greatly reducing the number of dogs used as pack animals.

Attire[edit]

The Crow wore clothing distinguished by gender. Women wore dresses made of deer and buffalo hide, decorated with elk teeth or shells. They covered their legs with leggings during winter and their feet with moccasins. Crow women wore their hair in two braids. Male clothing usually consisted of a shirt, trimmed leggings with a belt, a long breechcloth, and moccasins. Robes made from the furred hide of a bison were often worn in winter. Leggings were either made of animal hide which the Crow made for themselves or made of wool which were highly valued trade items made specifically for Indians in Europe. Their hair was worn long, in some cases reaching the ground.[92] The Crow are famous for often wearing their hair in a pompadour which was often colored white with paint. Crow men were notable for wearing two hair pipes made from beads on both sides of their hair. Men often wore their hair in two braids wrapped in the fur of beavers or otters. Bear grease was used to give shine to hair. Stuffed birds were often worn in the hair of warriors and medicine men. Like other plains Indians the Crow wore feathers from eagles, crows, owls, and other birds in their hair for symbolic reasons. The Crow wore a variety of headdresses including the famous eagle feather headdress, bison scalp headdress with horns and beaded rim, and split horn headdress. The split horn headdress is made from a single bison horn split in half and polished into two nearly identical horns which were attached to a leather cap and decorated with feathers and beadwork. Traditional clothing worn by the Crow is still worn today with varying degrees of regularity.

The Crow People are well known for their intercut beadwork. They adorned basically every aspect of their lives with these beads, giving special attention to ceremonial and ornamental items. Their clothing, horses, cradles, ornamental and ceremonial gear, in addition to leather cases of all shapes, sizes and uses were decorated in beadwork.[93] They gave reverence to the animals they ate by using as much of it as they could. The leather for their clothing, robes and pouches were created from the skin of buffalo, deer and elk. The work was done by the tribeswomen, with some being considered experts and were often sought by the younger, less experienced women for design and symbolic advice.[94] The Crow are an innovative people and are credited with developing their own style of stitch-work for adhering beads. This stitch, which is now called the overlay, is still also known as the "Crow Stitch".[93] In their beadwork, geometric shapes were primarily used with triangles, diamonds and hour-glass structures being the most prevalent. A wide range of colors were utilized by the Crow, but blues and various shades of pink were the most dominantly used. To intensify or to draw out a certain color or shape, they would surround that figure or color in a white outline.[93]

The colors chosen were not just merely used to be aesthetically pleasing, but rather had a deeper symbolic meaning. Pinks represented the various shades of the rising sun with yellow being the East the origin of the sun's arrival.[93] Blues are symbolic of the sky; red represented the setting sun or the West; green symbolizing mother earth, black the slaying of an enemy[94] and white representing clouds, rain or sleet.[93] Although most colors had a common symbolism, each piece's symbolic significance was fairly subjective to its creator, especially when in reference to the individual shapes. One person's triangle might symbolize a teepee, a spear head to a different individual or a range of mountains to yet another. Regardless of the individual significance of each piece, the Crow People give reverence to the land and sky with the symbolic references found in the various colors and shapes found on their ornamental gear and even clothing.[93]

Some of the clothing that the Crow People decorated with beads included robes, vests, pants, shirts, moccasins and various forms of celebratory and ceremonial gear. In addition to creating a connection with the land, from which they are a part, the various shapes and colors reflected one's standing and achievements. For example, if a warrior were to slay, wound or disarm an enemy, he would return with a blackened face.[94] The black color would then be incorporated in the clothing of that man, most likely in his war attire. A beaded robe, which was often given to a bride to be, could take over a year to produce and was usually created by the bride's mother-in-law or another female relative-in-law. These robes were often characterized by a series of parallel horizontal lines, usually consisting of light blue. The lines represented the young women's new role as a wife and mother; also the new bride was encouraged to wear the robe at the next ceremonial gathering to symbolize her addition and welcoming to a new family.[93] In modern times the Crow still often decorate their clothing with intricate bead designs for powwow and everyday clothing.

Gender and kinship system[edit]

The Crow had a matrilineal system. After marriage, the couple was matrilocal (the husband moved to the wife's mother's house upon marriage). Women held a significant role within the tribe.

Crow kinship is a system used to describe and define family members. Identified by Lewis Henry Morgan in his 1871 work Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family, the Crow system is one of the six major types which he described: EskimoHawaiianIroquois, Crow, Omaha, and Sudanese.[citation needed]

The Crow historically had a status for male-bodied two-spirits, termed baté/badé,[95] such as Osh-Tisch.[96][97]

21st-century[edit]

Geography[edit]

The Crow Indian Reservation in south-central Montana is a large reservation covering approximately 2,300,000 acres (3,600 sq mi; 9,300 km2) of land area, the fifth-largest Indian reservation in the United States. The reservation is primarily in Big Horn and Yellowstone counties with ceded lands in RosebudCarbon, and Treasure counties. The Crow Indian Reservation's eastern border is the 107th meridian line, except along the border line of the Northern Cheyenne Indian Reservation.

The southern border is from the 107th meridian line west to the east bank of the Big Horn River. The line travels downstream to Bighorn Canyon National Recreation Area and west to the Pryor Mountains and north-easterly to Billings. The northern border travels east and through Hardin, Montana, to the 107th meridian line. The 2000 census reported a total population of 6,894 on reservation lands. Its largest community is Crow Agency.

Government[edit]

Crow flag seen from Interstate 90 at the Crow Indian Reservation, Big Horn County, Montana

Prior to the 2001 Constitution, the Crow Tribe of Montana was governed by its 1948 constitution. The former constitution organized the tribe as a general council (tribal council). The general council held the executive, legislative, and judicial powers of the government and included all enrolled, adult members of the Crow Tribe, provided that women were 18 years or older and men were 21 or older. The general council was a direct democracy, comparable to that the Haudenosaunee Confederacy.

The Crow Tribe of Montana established a three-branch government at a 2001 council meeting with its 2001 constitution. The general council remains the governing body of the tribe; however, the powers were distributed to three separate branches within the government. In theory, the general council is still the governing body of the Crow Tribe, yet in reality the general council has not convened since the establishment of the 2001 constitution.

The executive branch has four officials. These officials are known as the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Secretary, and Vice-Secretary. The Executive Branch officials are also the officials within the Crow Tribal General Council, which has not met since 15 July 2001.

The current administration of the Crow Tribe Executive Branch is as follows:

  • Chairman: Frank White Clay
  • Vice-Chairman: Lawrence DeCrane
  • Secretary: Levi Black Eagle
  • Vice-Secretary: Channis Whiteman[98]

The Legislative Branch consists of three members from each district on the Crow Indian Reservation. The Crow Indian Reservation is divided into six districts known as The Valley of the Chiefs, Reno, Black Lodge, Mighty Few, Big Horn, and Pryor Districts. The Valley of the Chiefs District is the largest district by population.

The Judicial Branch consists of all courts established by the Crow Law and Order Code and in accordance with the 2001 Constitution. The Judicial Branch has jurisdiction over all matters defined in the Crow Law and Order Code. The Judicial Branch attempts to be a separate and distinct branch of government from the Legislative and Executive Branches of Crow Tribal Government. The Judicial Branch consists of an elected Chief Judge and two Associate Judges. The Crow Court of Appeals, similar to State Court of Appeals, receives all appeals from the lower courts. The Chief Judge of the Crow Tribe is Julie Yarlott.

Constitution controversy[edit]

According to the 1948 Constitution, Resolution 63-01 (Please note: in a letter of communication from Phileo Nash, then Commissioner of Indian Affairs, to the B.I.A. Area Director, as stated in the letter and confirmed that 63-01 is an Ordinance in said letter) all constitutional amendments must be voted on by secret ballot or referendum vote. In 2001, major actions were taken by the former Chairperson Birdinground without complying with those requirements. The quarterly council meeting on 15 July 2001 passed all resolutions by voice vote, including the measure to repeal the current constitution and approve a new constitution.

Critics contend the new constitution is contrary to the spirit of the Crow Tribe, as it provides authority for the US Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) to approve Crow legislation and decisions. The Crow people have guarded their sovereignty and Treaty Rights. The alleged New Constitution was not voted on to add it to the agenda of the Tribal Council. The former constitution mandated that constitutional changes be conducted by referendum vote, using the secret ballot election method and criteria. In addition, a constitutional change can only be conducted in a specially called election, which was never approved by council action for the 2001 Constitution. The agenda was not voted on or accepted at the council.

The only vote taken at the council was whether to conduct the voting by voice vote or walking through the line. Critics say the Chairman ignored and suppressed attempts to discuss the Constitution. This council and constitutional change was never ratified by any subsequent council action. The Tribal Secretary, who was removed from office by the BirdinGround Administration, was the leader of the opposition. All activity occurred without his signature.

When the opposition challenged, citing the violation of the Constitutional Process and the Right to Vote, the Birdinground Administration sought the approval of the United States Department of the Interior (USDOI), Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA). The latter stated it could not interfere in an internal tribal affair The federal court also ruled that the constitutional change was an internal tribal matter.[citation needed]

Leadership[edit]

Crow Tribal Chairperson Carl Venne and Barack Obama on the Crow Indian Reservation in Montana on 19 May 2008. Obama was the first presidential candidate to visit the Crow Tribe.

The seat of government and capital of the Crow Indian Reservation is Crow Agency, Montana.

The Crow Tribe historically elected a chairperson of tribal council biennially; however, in 2001, the term of office was extended to four years. The previous chairperson was Carl Venne. The chairperson serves as chief executive officer, speaker of the council, and majority leader of the Crow Tribal Council. The constitutional changes of 2001 created a three-branch government. The chairperson serves as the head of the executive branch, which includes the offices of vice-chairperson, secretary, vice-secretary, and the tribal offices and departments of the Crow Tribal Administration. Notable chairs include Clara NomeeEdison Real Bird, and Robert "Robie" Yellowtail.

On 19 May 2008, Hartford and Mary Black Eagle of the Crow Tribe adopted US Senator (later President) Barack Obama into the tribe on the date of the first visit of a US presidential candidate to the nation.[99] Crow representatives also took part in President Obama's inaugural parade. In 2009 Dr. Joseph Medicine Crow was one of 16 people awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom.

During the United States federal government shutdown of 2013, the Crow Tribe furloughed 316 employees and suspended programs providing health care, bus services and improvements to irrigation.[100]

In 2020, the Tribal Chairman AJ Not Afraid Jr. endorsed President Donald Trump's reelection, along with endorsing Republicans Steve Daines for the SenateGreg Gianforte for Governor and Matt Rosendale for the U.S. House.[101]

Notable Crow people[edit]

Delegation of important Crow chiefs, 1880. From left to right: Old Crow, Medicine Crow, Long Elk, Plenty Coups, and Pretty Eagle.
  • Eldena Bear Don't Walk (Crow/Salish/Kutenai, b. c. 1973), lawyer, judge, politician, first woman to serve as the Chief Justice of the Crow Nation
  • Bull Chief (c. 1825 – unknown), war chief (pipe carrier), who fought against Lakota, Nez Percé, Shoshone, and Piegan Blackfoot warriors, he also resisted white settlement of Crow territory
  • Curly (or Curley) (also known as Ashishishe/Shishi'esh, c. 1856 – 1923), Indian Scout and warrior
  • Goes Ahead or Ba'suck'osh (also Walks Among the Stars, 1851–1919), Indian Scout and warrior, husband of Pretty Shield
  • Hairy Moccasin or Esh-sup-pee-me-shish (c. 1854 – 1922), Crow Indian Scout and warrior
  • Half Yellow Face or Ischu Shi Dish (c. 1830 – c. 1879), Crow Indian Scout and warrior, war leader (pipe carrier) and leader of the six Crow Scouts who assisted General George A. Custer
  • Issaatxalúash, also Two Leggings (mid-1840s – 1923); bacheeítche (local group leader) of River Crow, war leader (pipe carrier), during the first years of the reservation era
  • Donald Laverdure, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Indian Affairs at the US Department of the Interior
  • Joe Medicine Crow, also PédhitšhÎ-wahpášh (1913–2016), the last war chief (pipe carrier) of the Crow Tribe, educator, historian, author, and official anthropologist
  • Janine Pease, an American Indian educator and advocate and the first woman of Crow lineage to earn a doctorate degree
  • Wendy Red Star, visual artist
  • Plenty Coups, Crow chief who cooperated with the government against other more hostile tribes, ensuring the Crow kept much of their traditional lands.
  • Pretty Eagle, fellow war chief of Plenty Coups, who worked with him to ensure the tribe's cooperation with the federal government.
  • Pretty Shield (c. 1856 – 1944), medicine woman, wife of Goes Ahead, a scout at the Battle of the Little Bighorn
  • Shows as He Goes, war chief
  • Pauline Small or Strikes Twice In One Summer (1924–2005), first woman to serve in Crow Tribal Council
  • Frank Shively (c. 1877 – unknown), football coach
  • Supaman, also Christian Parrish Takes the Gun, rapper and fancy dancer
  • Noah Watts, also Bulaagawish (Old Bull), actor and musician, best known for his role as Ratonhnhaké:ton, the main character of Assassin's Creed III
  • Bethany Yellowtail (Crow/Northern Cheyenne), fashion designer based in Los Angeles
  • Robert Yellowtail (1889–1988), leader of Crow Tribe, first Native American to hold position of Agency Superintendent
  • White Man Runs Him (c. 1858 – 1929); Crow Indian Scout and warrior, step-grandfather of Joe Medicine Crow
  • White Swan, also Mee-nah-tsee-us (White Goose, c. 1850 – 1904), Indian Scout and warrior, cousin of Curly.

See also[edit]

Citations[edit]

  1. Jump up to:a b "Crow Tribe of Montana"National Indian Law Library. Retrieved 23 April 2016.
  2. Jump up to:a b "Crow (Apsáalooke)"Omniglot. Retrieved 14 October 2019.
  3. ^ "Crow Tribe of Indians". Crow Nation. Retrieved 14 October 2016.
  4. ^ Johnson, Kirk (24 July 2008), "A State That Never Was in Wyoming"The New York Times
  5. ^ William C. Sturtevant, Handbook of North American Indians: Southwest (1979, ISBN 0160504007), page 714: "Among other tribes the Crow are most commonly designated as 'crow' or 'raven'."
  6. ^ "Crow Expressions"Western Heritage Center. Retrieved 19 October 2021.
  7. ^ Barry M. Pritzker: A Native American Encyclopedia
  8. ^ Phenocia Bauerle, The Way of the Warrior: Stories of the Crow People, Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, ISBN 978-0-8032-6230-0
  9. ^ Peter Nabokof and Lawrence L. Lowendorf, Restoring a History, Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2004. ISBN 0-8061-3589-1ISBN 978-0-8061-3589-2
  10. ^ John Doerner, "Timeline of historic events from 1400 to 2003", Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument
  11. ^ Timeline and citations, Four Directions Institute
  12. ^ Rodney Frey: The World of the Crow Indians: As Driftwood Lodges, Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2009, ISBN 978-0-8061-2560-2
  13. ^ "The Crow Society"crow.bz. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 13 January 2016.
  14. ^ Dog travois, Women of the Fur Trade
  15. ^ "Forest Prehistory", with pictures of dog travois, Helena National Forest Website
  16. ^ Osborn, Alan J. "Ecological Aspects of Equestrian Adaptation in Aboriginal North America", American Anthropologist 85, nos l. and 3 (Sept 1983), 566
  17. ^ Hamalainen, 10–15
  18. ^ Crow names, American Tribes
  19. ^ Bowers 1992: 23
  20. ^ Lowie 1993: 272–275
  21. ^ Timothy P. McCleary: The Stars We Know: Crow Indian Astronomy and Lifeways, Waveland Press Inclusive, 1996, ISBN 978-0-88133-924-6
  22. ^ Lowie 1912: 183–184
  23. ^ Barney Old Coyote Archived 12 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine, Turtle Island Storyteller
  24. ^ Plenty Coups and Linderman, Plenty-Coups, Chief of the Crows, 2002, p. 31-42.
  25. ^ Brown, Mark H (1959). The Plainsmen of the Yellowstone. University of Nebraska Press. pp. 128–129. ISBN 978-0-8032-5026-0.
  26. ^ "Text of the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1851, see Article 5 relating to the Crow lands". Archived from the original on 12 August 2014. Retrieved 24 September 2014.
  27. ^ "Text of Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, See Article 16, creating unceded Indian Territory east of the summit of the Big Horn Mountains and north of the North Platte River". Archived from the original on 26 November 2011. Retrieved 24 September 2014.
  28. ^ Kappler, Charles J.: Indian Affairs. Laws and Treaties. Vol. 2, Washington 1904, pp. 1008–1011.
  29. ^ 93rd Annual Crow Fair. Welcome from Cedric Black Eagle, Chairman of the Crow Tribe.
  30. ^ Wood, Raymond W. and A.S. Downer (1977): Notes on the Crow-Hidatsa Schism. Plains Anthropologist, Vol. 22, pp. 83–100, p. 86.
  31. ^ Wood, Raymond W. and A.S, Downer (1977): Notes on the Crow-Hidatsa Schism. Plains Anthropologist, Vol. 22, pp. 83–100, p. 84.
  32. ^ Boyd, Maurice (1981): Kiowa Voices. Ceremonial Dance, Ritual and Song. Vol. 1. Fort Worth.
  33. ^ Mallory, Gerrick (1886): The Dakota Winter Counts. Fourth Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, 1882–'83, Washington, pp. 89–127, p. 103.
  34. ^ Mallory, Gerrick (1893): Tenth Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, 1888–'89, Washington, p. 553.
  35. ^ Wood, Raymond W. and Thomas D. Thiessen (1987): Early Fur trade on the Northern Plains. Canadian Traders among the Mandan and Hidatsa Indians, 1738–1818. Norman and London, pp. 156–220.
  36. ^ Ewers, John C. (1988): Indian Life on the Upper Missouri. Norman and London, p. 54.
  37. ^ Hoxie, Parading Through History(1995), p. 68.
  38. Jump up to:a b Dempsey, Hugh A (1965): A Blackfoot Winter Count. Occasional Paper No. 1. Calgary.
  39. ^ Hyde, George E. (1987): Life of George Bent. Written From His Letters. Norman, p. 23.
  40. ^ Hyde, George E. (1987): Life of George Bent. Written From His Letters. Norman, pp. 24–26.
  41. ^ Linderman, Frank B. (1962): Plenty Coups. Chief of the Crows. Lincoln/London, p. 190
  42. ^ Linderman, Frank B. (1974): Pretty Shield. Medicine Woman of the Crows. Lincoln and London, p. 168.
  43. ^ Jensen, Richard E. & James S. Hutchins (2001): Whell Boats on the Missouri. The Journals and Documents of the Atkinson-O'Fallon Expedition, 1824–26. Helena and Lincoln, p. 143.
  44. ^ Kappler, Charles J. (1904): Indian Affairs. Laws and Treaties. Vol. 2, pp. 244–246.
  45. ^ Curtis, Edward S. (1970): The North American Indian. Vol. 4. New York, p.48.
  46. ^ Denig, Edwin Thompson (1961): Five Indian Tribes of the Upper Missouri. Siouc, Arickaras, Assiniboines, Crees, Crows. Norman, p. 181
  47. ^ Audubon, Maria R. (Ed.) (1960): Audubon and his Journals. Vol. 2. New York, p. 179.
  48. Jump up to:a b Chardon, F.A. (1997): F.A. Chardon's Journal at Fort Clark, 1834-139. Lincoln and London, pp. 4 and 275.
  49. ^ Hoxie, Parading Through History (1995), p. 132.
  50. ^ Bowers, Alfred W. (1965): Hidatsa Social and Ceremonial Organization. Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology. Bulletin 194. Washington, p. 24.
  51. Jump up to:a b c d e f g h i j k l m Hoxie, Parading Through History (1995), p. 109.
  52. ^ De Smet, Pierre-Jean (1905): Life, Letters and Travels of Father Jean-Pierre De Smet, S.J., 1801–1873. Vol. 1. New York.
  53. Jump up to:a b c Kurz, Rudolph F. (1937): Journal of Rudolph Friederich Kurz. Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology. Bulletin 115. Washington.
  54. ^ De Smet, Pierre-Jean (1847): Oregon Missions and Travels over the Rocky Mountains in 1845–46. New York, p.177.
  55. ^ Bedford, Denton R. (1975): The Fight at "Mountains on Both Sides". Indian Historian, Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 13–23, p. 19.
  56. Jump up to:a b c Kappler, Charles J. (1904): Indian Affairs. Laws and Treaties. Vol. II. Washington.
  57. ^ Greene, Candace: Verbal Meets Visual: Sitting Bull and the Representation of History. Ethnohistory. Vol. 62, No. 2 (April 2015), pp. 217–240.
  58. Jump up to:a b c Stirling, M.W. (1938): Three Pictographic Autobiographies of Sitting Bull. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections. Vol. 97, No. 5. Washington.
  59. ^ Paul, Eli R. (1997): Autobiography of Red Cloud. War Leader of the Oglalas. Chelsea.
  60. ^ Beckwith, Martha Warren: Mythology of the Oglala Dakota. The Journal of American Folklore. Vol. 43, No. 170 (Oct.-Dec., 1930), pp. 339–442.
  61. Jump up to:a b c McGinnis, Anthony (1990): Counting Coups and Cutting Horses. Intertribal Warfare on the Northern Plains, 1738–1889. Evergreen.
  62. Jump up to:a b c d White, Richard: The Winning of the West: The Expansion of the Western Sioux in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries. The Journal of American History. Vol. 65, No. 2 (Sept. 1978), pp. 319–343.
  63. Jump up to:a b Calloway, Colin G.: The Inter-tribal Balance of Power on the Great Plains, 1760–1850. The Journal of American Studies. Vol. 16, No. 1 (April 1982), pp. 25–47.
  64. Jump up to:a b Ewers, John C.: Intertribal Warfare as a Precursor of Indian-White Warfare on the Northern Great Plains. Western Historical Quarterly. Vol. 6, No. 4 (Oct. 1975), pp. 397–410.
  65. Jump up to:a b c Medicine Crow, Joseph (1992): From the Heart of the Crow Country. The Crow Indians' Own Stories. New York.
  66. ^ Serial 1308, 40th Congress, 1st Session, Vol. 1, Senate Executive Document No. 13, p. 127.
  67. ^ Utley, Robert M.: The Bozeman Trail before John Bozeman: A Busy Land. Montana, the Magazine of Western History. Vol. 53, No. 2 (Sommer 2003), pp. 20–31.
  68. ^ Stands in Timber, John and Margot Liberty (1972): Cheyenne Memories. Lincoln.
  69. Jump up to:a b c d Dunlay, Thomas W. (1982): Wolves for the Blue Soldiers. Indian Scots and Auxiliaries with the United States Army, 1860–1890. Lincoln and London.
  70. ^ Grinnell, George Bird (1911): The Story of the Indian. New York and London.
  71. ^ Deloria, Vine Jr. and R. DeMallie (1975): Proceedings of the Great Peace Commission of 1867–1868. Washington.
  72. ^ Hyde, George E. (1987): Life of George Bent. Written From His Letters. Norman.
  73. Jump up to:a b c Linderman, Frank B. (1962): Plenty Coups. Chief of the Crows. Lincoln/London.
  74. ^ Koch, Peter: Journal of Peter Koch – 1869 and 1870. The Frontier. A Magazine of the Northwest. Vol. IX, No. 2 (Jan. 1929), pp. 148–160.
  75. ^ Mallory, Gerrick (1896): The Dakota Winter Counts. Smithsonian Institution. 4th Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology, 1882–'83. Washington.
  76. ^ Vestal, Stanley (1932): Sitting Bull, Champion of the Sioux. A Biography. Boston and New York.
  77. ^ Serial 1449, 41st Congress, 3rd Session, Vol. 4, House Executive Document No. 1, p. 662.
  78. ^ Lubetkin, John M.: The Forgotten Yellowstone Surveying Expeditions of 1871. W. Milnor Roberts and the Northern Pacific Railroad in Montana. Montana, the Magazine of Western History. Vol. 52, No. 4 (Winter 2002), pp. 32–47.
  79. Jump up to:a b Bradley, James H.: Journal of James H. Bradley. The Sioux Campaign of 1876 under the Command of General John Gibbon. Contributions to the Historical Society of Montana. Pp. 140–227.
  80. ^ Kvasnika, Robert M. and Herman J. Viola (1979): The Commissioners of Indian Affairs, 1824–1977. Lincoln and London.
  81. Jump up to:a b c Linderman, Frank B. (1974): Pretty Shield. Medicine Woman of the Crows. Lincoln and London.
  82. ^ Webb, George W. (1939): Chronological List of Engagements Between The Regular Army of the United States And Various Tribes of Hostile Indians Which Occurred During The Years 1790 To 1898, Inclusive. St. Joseph.
  83. Jump up to:a b Grinnell, George Bird (1985): The Passing of the Great West. Selected Papers of George Bird Grinnell. New York.
  84. ^ Medicine Crow, joseph (1939): The Effects of European Culture Contacts upon the Economic, Social, and Religious Life of the Crow Indians. A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Department of Anthropology, University of Southern California.
  85. ^ Varnum, Charles A. (1982): Custer's Chief of Scouts. The Reminiscences of Charles A. Varnum. Including his Testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry. Lincoln.
  86. ^ Porter, Joseph C. (1986): Paper Medicine Man. John Gregory Bourke and His American West. Norman and London.
  87. ^ Pearson, Jeffrey V.: Nelson A. Miles, Crazy Horse, and the Battle of Wolf Mountains. Montana, the Magazine of Western History. Vol. 51, No. 4 (Winter 2001), pp. 52–67.
  88. ^ Miles, Nelson A. (1897): Personal Recollections and Observations of General Nelson A. Miles. Chicago and New York.
  89. ^ "Crow Indian Recipes and Herbal Medicine"Scribd. Retrieved 13 January 2016.
  90. Jump up to:a b c d e Keyser, James (1985). "The Plains Anthropologist". Plains Anthropologist. Anthropology News. 30 (108): 85–102. doi:10.1080/2052546.1985.11909269JSTOR 25668522.
  91. ^ Wishart, David J. Encyclopedia of the Great Plains Indians. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2007. 89.
  92. ^ Letter No. 8 George Catlin "...most of them were over six feet high and very many of these have cultivated their natural hair to such an almost incredible length, that it sweeps the ground as they walk; there are frequent instances of this kind among them, and in some cases, a foot or more it will drag on the grass as they walk, giving exceeding grace and beauty their movements. They usually oil their Hair with a profusion of bear grease every morning"
  93. Jump up to:a b c d e f g Powell, P (1988). To Honor the Crow People. Chicago: Foundation for the Preservation of American Indian Art and Culture, Inc.
  94. Jump up to:a b c Lowie, R (1922). Crow Indian Art. New York: Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History.
  95. ^ Robert Harry LowieSocial Life of the Crow Indians (1912), page 226
  96. ^ Will Roscoe (2000). Changing Ones: Third and Fourth Genders in Native North America. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-0-312-22479-0.
  97. ^ Scott Lauria Morgensen, Spaces Between Us: Queer Settler Colonialism and Indigenous Decolonization (ISBN 1452932727, 2011), pages 39-40, quotes Crow historian Joe Medicine Crow speaking about the treatment of badés and Osh-Tisch by a US government agent.
  98. ^ "Crow Tribe Executive Branch"Crow Tribe of Indians. Retrieved 14 October 2019.
  99. ^ "Obama Adopted into Crow Nation"The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 4 July 2008.
  100. ^ Brown, Matthew (2 October 2013). "Shutdown hits vulnerable Indian tribes as basics such as foster care, nutrition threatened"Minnesota Star-Tribune. AP. Archived from the original on 4 October 2013. Retrieved 3 October 2013.
  101. ^ "Crow Tribal Chairman endorses Trump campaign"Indian Country Today. Retrieved 29 September 2020.

General references[edit]

  • Thomas H. LeforgeMemoirs of a White Crow Indian, The Century Co., 1928, hardcover, ASIN B00086PAP6
  • Alma Hogan Snell, Grandmother's Grandchild: My Crow Indian Life, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 2000, hardcover, ISBN 0-8032-4277-8
  • Charles Bradley, The Handsome People: A History of the Crow Indians and the Whites, Council for Indian Education, 1991, paperback, ISBN 0-89992-130-2
  • Frank B. Linderman, Plenty-Coups: Chief of the Crows, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 1962, paperback, ISBN 0-8032-5121-1
  • Frank B. Linderman, Pretty-shield: Medicine Woman of the Crows, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 1974, paperback, ISBN 0-8032-8025-4
  • Fred W. Voget and Mary K. Mee, They Call Me Agnes: A Crow Narrative Based on the Life of Agnes Yellowtail Deernose, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, Oklahoma, 1995, hardcover, ISBN 0-8061-2695-7
  • Frederick E. Hoxie, Parading through History: The Making of the Crow Nation in America 1805–1935, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 1995, hardcover, ISBN 0-521-48057-4
  • Helene Smith and Lloyd G. Mickey Old Coyote, Apsaalooka: The Crow Nation Then and Now, MacDonald/Swãrd Publishing Company, Greensburg, Pennsylvania, 1992, paperback, ISBN 0-945437-11-0
  • Henry Old Coyote and Barney Old Coyote, The Way of the Warrior: Stories of the Crow People, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 2003, ISBN 0-8032-3572-0
  • Jonathan Lear, Radical Hope: Ethics in the Face of Cultural Devastation, Harvard University Press, 2006, ISBN 0-674-02329-3
  • Joseph Medicine Crow, From the Heart of the Crow Country: The Crow Indians' Own Stories, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 2000, paperback, ISBN 0-8032-8263-X
  • Keith Algier, The Crow and the Eagle: A Tribal History from Lewis & Clark to Custer, Caxton Printers, Caldwell, Idaho, 1993, paperback, ISBN 0-87004-357-9
  • Michael Oren Fitzgerald, Yellowtail, Crow Medicine Man and Sun Dance Chief: An Autobiography, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, Oklahoma, 1991, hardcover, ISBN 0-8061-2602-7
  • Peter Nabokov, Two Leggings: The Making of a Crow Warrior, Crowell Publishing Co., 1967, hardcover, ASIN B0007EN16O
  • Robert H. Lowie, The Crow Indians, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Nebraska, 1983, paperback, ISBN 0-8032-7909-4
  • Robert H. Lowie, Crow Indian Art, The Trustees, 1922, ASIN B00086D6RK
  • Robert H. Lowie, Material Culture of the Crow Indians, The Trustees, 1922, hardcover, ASIN B00085WH80
  • Robert H. Lowie, Minor Ceremonies of the Crow Indians, American Museum Press, 1924, hardcover, ASIN B00086D3NC
  • Robert H. Lowie, Myths and Traditions of the Crow Indians, AMS Press, 1980, hardcover, ISBN 0-404-11872-0
  • Robert H. Lowie, Religion of the Crow Indians, The Trustees, 1922, hardcover, ASIN B00086IFQM
  • Robert H. Lowie, Social Life of the Crow Indians, AMS Press, 1912, hardcover, ISBN 0-404-11875-5
  • Robert H. Lowie, The Crow Language, University of California Press, 1941, hardcover, ASIN B0007EKBDU
  • Robert H.Lowie, The Tobacco Society of the Crow Indians, The Trustees, 1919, hardcover, ASIN B00086IFRG
  • Robert H. Lowie, 1914, The Crow Sun Dance, hardcover, ASIN B0008CBIOW
  • Rodney Frey (ed.), Stories That Make the World: Oral Literature of the Indian Peoples of the Inland Northwest. As Told by Lawrence Aripa, Tom Yellowtail and Other Elders. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1995. ISBN 0-8061-3131-4
  • Rodney Frey, The World of the Crow Indians: As Driftwood Lodges, Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1987. ISBN 0-8061-2076-2

External links[edit]

Sung Deuk Oak [피터즈 통신 9] 변통론

(16) Facebook: Sung Deuk Oak
Favourites 1t1a n4s58Mcarcgh ahtt 06e4:222l 
[피터즈 통신 9]


밤새 무고하셨습니까?
서울에서 개역 성경을 마무리하고 있는 피터즈입니다. 두 번에 걸쳐 개역 성경(1938) 번역에 대해 말하려고 합니다.
 
인생이 고단하고 궁한 분이 많아서 먼저 변통에 대해서 말씀드리겠습니다. <주역>을 보면 인생사는 궁변통구의 순서로 흘러가지요. 사면초가와 같은 궁(窮)이 닥칠 때는 솟아날 구멍이 바로 변화입니다. 기존의 길에서 변화를 추구하다보면 통(break through)으로 나아갑니다.

  궁즉변, 변즉통을 줄이면 변통론이 되지요. 변통론이야 말로 중국과 한국의 오래된 지혜입니다. 하늘은 스스로 돕는 자를 돕고, 쥐구멍에도 (벽을 헐면) 볕 들 날이 있다는 게 운명을 개척하는 변통론을 표현해 줍니다. 운명론적인 새옹지마와는 약간 다른 뜻이겠지요. 지난 날을 복기하면서 잘못된 것이 있으면 고치고 새로운 공간에서 새 일을 도모하기 바랍니다. 변화의 1차 대상은 나입니다.

제 인생에도 궁한 날이 많았습니다. 이전 편지에도 썼지만, 저는 열 두 살에 상인이었던 아버지 사업이 러시아인의 박해로 파산하고, 짐나지움에서 의대로 진학하려 했지만 인종차별로 포기하고 노동자가 되었으며, 22세에 이민 길에 올랐으나 직업을 구하지 못했지요. 1895년 일본 나가사키에서 개종하고 권서가 되어 서울에 왔으나 한국도 청일전쟁 후라 살기가 팍팍했습니다. 1902년 미국에서 신학교를 마치고 한국에 오려고 했으나 사랑에 빠진 여인을 만나 결혼을 했기에 시민권 문제로 필리핀으로 가야했고, 새 언어인 스페인어를 배웠습니다.
 
2년 후 1904년에 다시 서울에 임명되었지만, 러일전쟁이 일어났고, 러시아인이라 한국에 있을 수 없어 아내와 미국으로 갔습니다. 1905년 서울에 돌아왔지만 이번에는 아내 엘리자베스가 병에 결려 죽었습니다. 2년 후에 결혼한 에바 필드 의사와 행복하게 살았지만, 제가 1931년 개역성경 개역을 전담하여 서울에 온 후 1932년에 소천했습니다. 두 번에 걸친 상처(喪妻)는 제 인생에서 가장 견디기 힘든 고통이었습니다. 1934년 안식년으로 미국에 가서 평소 알고 지내던 앤 쿠퍼와 결혼하고 서울에 오려니 경제 대공황으로 인해 선교자금이 부족한 선교본부는 저를 파송할 뜻이 없었습니다. 겨우 독신 월급만 받는 조건으로 아내와 함께 서울에 왔지요.
 
그러나 저는 1897년에 시편을 번역한 이후, 오랫 동안 한국에서 사역하면서 한국어를 익히고 공부하면서 언제가 성경 번역 일을 하고 싶었습니다. 베어드 목사가 안식년 때 필라델피아에 가서 랍비에게 히브리어를 배우면서까지 완성하려고 했으나 이루지 못하고 돌아가셨습니다. 이제 제가 그 번역을 맡아 완성해야 할 사명감을 느끼고 1931년에 구약 개역을 시작했습니다. 저는 개역을 마치는 것이 소원이었으므로, 적은 월급으로 지난 여러 해 이 일에 매진해 왔습니다.
 
궁하지만 변하여 통합니다. 통은 막힌 자들과의 소통이요, 벽을 뚫어내는 것이요, 하던 일을 멈추지 않고 추진하여 새 세상을 맞이하는 것입니다. 여러분이 믿는 가치, 여러분이 가진 사명을 위해 7년, 20년 한결같이 밀고가면 통의 시간이 올 것입니다. 몇 달 바짝 하다가 실망하는 일은 실패자들이 하는 일입니다. 말이 통하는 세상, 숨을 쉬는 세상, 생각이 자유로이 흘러다니는 세상, 상대를 있는 그대로 인정하는 세상을 기대합니다.
 
또한 곤궁할 때는 기도할 때입니다. 시편 4장 1절입니다. "내 의의 하나님이여, 내가 부를 때에 응답하소서. 곤란 중에 나를 너그럽게 하셨사오니, 나를 긍휼히 여기사, 나의 기도를 들으소서." 모세가 홍해 앞에서 사면초가가 되었을 때 그는 솟아날 구멍인 하늘을 향해 기도했습니다. 그때 바다가 열리고 육지와 같은 마른 길이 생기고 이끝에서 저끝으로 통했습니다.
저는 이제 성경 개역을 마무리하고 조용히 쉬면서 이 글을 씁니다. 주의 위로가 모두에게 넘치기를 빕니다.
 
"우리가 선을 행하되 낙심하지 말지니 포기하지 아니하면 때가 이르매 거두리라." (갈 6: 9)
1938년 초에,
서울에서 피터즈 올림

추신, 제 개역 작업에 대해서는 옥성득, <대한성서공회 2>(1994)에 실린 다음 글을 읽어보세요. 그가 신학교 시절에 쓴 글이라 좀 거칠지만 개요는 알 수 있고, 개역 번역에 대해 더 알고 싶으면 그 책의 다른 부분을 보기 바랍니다. 구약 개역 번역 본문에 대해서는 다음 편지에 쓰겠습니다.

















54Paul Dongwon Goh and 53 others
===

한국어에서 양역변통론 의 뜻은 무엇인가요?
 한국어 사전에서 양역변통론 의 정의

양역변통론 

조선 후기 민폐(民弊)의 제1차적 요인인 양역폐의 해소를 위해 양역제의 개선과 개혁을 주장하던 여러 논의의 총칭. 
효종 때 일부 관료에 의해 제기된 이래 숙종년간에 이르러서는 재야의 유생들까지 의견을 제시할 정도로 활발해졌고, 그 결과 마침내 1750년(영조 26) 균역법의 제정을 보게 하였다.
===
양역 
조선시대 양인(良人:양반계급을 제외한 일반 서민)이 국가에 대하여 부담한 의무[國役].
==
변통 
대변이 나오는 것을 말하는데, 개인차가 크기 때문에 그 정상 회수에 대해서는 엄밀하게 한정할 수 없다. 일반적으로 1일 1회가 많으며, 1일 1~2회 또는 2일에 1회라는 사람도 있다. 배변의 회수가 감소 또는 변량이 감소하기 때문에 불쾌감을 동반한 경우를 변비라고 하며, 변의 경도가 감소되는 것을 설사라고 한다.
==
균역법 은 조선 후기 군역을 대신하는 군포를 2필에서 1필로 줄인 군역세법 개혁이다. 호당 군포를 부과한 것이 아니라, 토지 1결당 군포를 부과하여 지주들의 납세를 촉진시키려 하였다.

===

지식백과 더보기

문서 저장하기
contents.history.go.kr›data

아크로벳(pdf)Ⅱ. 양역변통론과 균역법의 시행 - 국사편찬위원회
양역변통론과 균역법의 시행 1. 양역의 편성과 폐단 2. 양역변통론의 추이 3. 균역법의 시행과 그 의미 103 Ⅱ. 양역변통론과 균역법의 시행 1. 양역의 편성과 폐단 1) 양역의 편성 조선 후기의 양역이란 전기의 군역에서 양반층이 빠져나감으로써 남게 된 일반 양인층만이 졌던 군역을 가리키며, 부담형태도 군사활동을 하는 立役보 다는 국가재정을 뒷받침하기 위한...
문서 저장하기
contents.history.go.kr›front

2) 양역변통론의 대두 - 우리역사넷
양역변통논의는 대개 현종 말년부터 표면화된 것으로 말해진다. 인조 연간부터 계속된 중앙 軍門의 강화가 役摠(군역 부담자의 총숫자)의 증가를 수반하면서 진행되다가, 훈련도감의... 전자는 군제변통론의 형태로 현종 9∼10년경 山黨이란 정치세력에 의해 주장되지만 현종 초부터 먼저 논의된 것은 후자였다. 병조 재정의 주된 수입원은 후일 二軍色이라 불리는...
문서 저장하기
desert.tistory.com

[조선] 9. 조선 후기 수취 체제의 개편 (영정법, 대동법, 양척동일법, 균역....
양역변통론 ]→ 농병일치론(유형원) 호포론(영조) - 논쟁만함 [ 균역법] → 영조 1년1필 균역청 → [호포법] 양반도 군포징수 환곡 [의창] → 무이자, 원곡부족 → [상평창] 1/10 이자... 양역 변통론의 대두 (1) 양역의 폐단으로 농민은 유망이나 피역으로 저항 (2) 양역변통론 1) 구전론 - 인구 단위로 돈을 징수 2) 유포론 - 무위도식하는 자에게 징수 3) 결포론 - 전결에서...
2012.05.25.
문서 저장하기
contents.history.go.kr›front

3) 양역변통론의 전개 - 우리역사넷
그런데 위의 기록만으로는 그의 호포론이 양역제 자체의 철폐를 전제로 한 대변통론인지, 아니면 도고·아약징포의 탕감·감면으로 인한 부족 재정만을 확보하려는 것인지 분명치 않다. 그의 호포론에 대한 조정의 검토에서 그가 “물고·아약에서의 징포를 먼저 탕감하고 관청을 하나 세워서 호포법을 행하며 나아가 軍兵·公私賤의 제도까지 모두 변통할 것”을 말하자...
검색결과 더보기

VIEW

전체 블로그 카페
기본뷰타임라인뷰멀티미디어뷰


문서 저장하기
대표2020.09.11.전한길한국사양역변통론 병농일치제
저는 양역변통론 주장은 유형원으로만 알고있었는데 지문 중 '성인 남자에게 2결의 토지를 나누어 주고 병농일치의 군대조직을 제안하였다.'가 맞는 지문으로 나오는데 양역변통론은 유형원이랑 홍대용도 주장하였나요??...
양역변통론과 역역을 토지에 부과군역폐단고ㅏ 양역변통론 관계
문서 저장하기
공식2021.11.26.인터비즈(InterBiz)성군 영조도 실패한 조세 개혁.. 개혁은 왜 힘들까?ㅣ인터비즈
이 같은 군역의 폐단을 바로잡고자 등장한 것이 ‘양역변통론(良役變通論)’이다. 국가재정의 부족과 사회에 누적된 불만은 심각한 사태였다. 영조도 그 심각성을 인지했다. 어떤 면에서는 탕평책보다 더 심각한 안건이...5
#인터비즈#네이버비즈니스#비즈니스#경제#경영#영조#조선시대#리더십#조세#세금
문서 저장하기
대표2019.11.05.전한길한국사양역변통론을
양역변통론을 영조가 실시해보고 연구해보고자 양역사정청을 설치 한건가요? 그리고는 변통론 중 균역법을 확정한 뒤 시행하니깐 균역청을 설치햇고 양역사정청이 모테가 되고 이후에는 선혜청이랑 균역청이 통합되나요?
양역변통론유형원

===







개혁정신과 원불교 4. 유교의 개혁운동과 원불교 [개혁정신과 원불교 [교리 [기사본문 - 원불교신문

개혁정신과 원불교 4. 유교의 개혁운동과 원불교 < 개혁정신과 원불교 < 교리 < 기사본문 - 원불교신문

개혁정신과 원불교 4. 유교의 개혁운동과 원불교

기자명 류성태 교무
입력 2020.07.23


류성태 교무

[원불교신문=류성태 교무] 정도전과 권근은 조선 건국의 개혁주의 사상가이다. 이들은 고려불교를 비판하고 유학을 국교로 삼고 개혁의 선봉에 섰다. 유교를 국가 개혁의 사상적 근간으로 삼고 이성계를 도와 조선 건국에 공을 세웠다. 불교를 극복하고 유교로의 전개는 건국 초기의 개혁이라는 이슈가 강력하게 필요했기 때문이다.

뒤이어 조선 선조 때 율곡은 수기치인(修己治人)을 통해 시대의 변화를 바르게 파악하고 새롭게 변화하려는 변통론(變通論)과 사회모순을 개혁하는 경장론(更張論)을 주장했다.

시대의 구폐를 개혁하고 백성을 구제하기 위해서 인정(仁政)과 삼강오륜의 이념에 근거한 개혁운동을 전개한 것이다. 그의 상소문 『만언봉사(萬言封事)』에서는 지시(知時), 시의(時宜)를 거론하며 개혁을 강조한 것이 이와 관련된다.


이처럼 조선의 개혁론으로서 변통론경장론 등은 후대의 실사구시(實事求是)를 지향하는 실학자들의 개혁정신으로 이어진다. 최한기, 이익, 정약용, 유형원이 그들이다. 이익은 이에 말한다. “법이 오래가면 폐해가 생기고, 폐해가 생기면 반드시 개혁이 있어야 한다.” 경장(개혁)하지 않으면 나라는 망할 것이라는 논리이며, 혹 실패를 한다고 해도 다시 경장해야 치국이 된다는 것이다. 최한기도 ‘새로운 것으로 낡은 것을 바꾸는’ 변혁의 중요성을 인지해 차라리 옛것을 버릴지언정 지금을 버릴 수는 없다는 진보정신을 표방했다. 정약용은 도탄에 빠진 민중에게 희망을 불러일으키도록 사회의 개혁의 경세론을 집대성했다.

근세 유교의 개혁론 중 돋보이는 것은 백암 박은식의 ‘유교구신론(儒敎求新論)’이다. 그는 불혹의 40세(1898)부터 망국의 52세 때에 심기일전해 사회 계몽운동가로 변신했다. 독립협회에 가입하고 황성신문과 대한매일신보의 주필로서 교육문화의 개혁운동을 추진했던 백암은 유교구신론을 통해 사변적인 성리학의 한계를 직시하고 심학인 양명학으로써 유교를 근대화하고자 하였다.

계몽적 애국운동가로서 박은식, 신채호, 정인보 등은 나라를 구하려는 유교개혁 운동을 펼쳤지만 아쉽게도 급변하던 시류 속에 개혁을 완수하지 못했다. 유교의 개혁운동은 실학자들의 열망에도 큰 성공을 이루지 못한 채 경술국치라는 암울한 역사에 매몰되고 말았다.

유교의 『변통론』, 『경장론』 『구신론』에서 못다 이룬 개혁의 꿈은 ‘개벽(開闢)’의 닻으로서 소태산의 『혁신론』, 정산의 『건국론』 태동의 마중물이었다. 국가와 사회를 변화시키려는 변통(變通), 개혁하려는 경장(更張), 새로움을 추구하려는 구신(求新)이 원불교의 선천을 마감하는 ‘개벽(開闢)’과 같은 상징성을 지니고 있음은 흥미롭다.

조선유교의 개혁이슈들이 불교개혁의 소태산과 정산의 삼교 활용의 정신으로 이어지고 있음이 주목된다. 유교의 개혁사상이 원불교 교법의 ‘사실적 도덕의 수행’, ‘실학적 교리’, ‘의례의 예전’에 용해되어 새 시대의 개혁운동으로서 응용되고 있기 때문이다.

여기에서 우리에게 남겨진 과제가 있다. ‘주역’의 혁괘(革卦) 5효에서는 인간사의 대변혁에 또한 대인(大人)이 요청된다고 했으니, 원불교의 대인은 과연 누구인가 하는 점이다. ‘주역’의 우환의식을 새기면서 원불교 미래의 불안감을 극복할 수 있는 개혁 프로그램의 실제적·실용적 대안을 제시하는 자일 것이다.

/원광대학교

[2020년 7월 24일자]




이이의 변통론

이이의 변통론

조선 전기 경세론과 불교비판

이이의 변통론

이이(李珥)는 사회 개혁의 문제와 관련하여 바꿀 수 있고 또 바꿔야 하는 것과 바꿀 수 없는 것을 구분하여 설명하고 있다. 이는 개혁에 있어서 근본적인 이념과 구체적인 실현 방법의 문제에 관한 논의라고 할 수 있다. 이이는 우선 때에 맞게 법을 바꾸는 '변통'(變通)의 중요성을 강조하였다. '변통'이란 말은 『주역』의 "역은 궁하면 변하고 변하면 통하며, 통하면 오래 계속된다. 그렇기 때문에 하늘에서 이를 도와서, 길하여 이롭지 않은 것이 없다는 것이다."[易窮則變, 變則通, 通則久, 是以自天祐之, 吉無不利., 「계사 하」2]에서 연원하는데, 기존의 질서나 제도가 제대로 작동하지 않는 상황에 닥치면 변화시켜 통하게 해야 한다는 뜻이다.

이이는 여기서 『주역』의 이러한 논리에 대한 정이의 언급을 인용하면서 변통의 중요성을 강조하고 있다. 그리고 법령과 제도는 바꿀 수 있지만 왕도(王道)와 인정(仁政)과 삼강(三綱)과 오상(五常)은 영원히 바꿀 수 없다고 함으로써, 변통의 내용 내지 대상을 법제에 한정시키고 유학의 근본 원리, 봉건적 윤리 질서는 바꿀 수 없다고 하여 변통의 기준을 명확하게 제시하고 있다. 이러한 관점은 리는 두루 통하고 기는 국한된다는 이통기국론(理通氣局論)의 함의와 상응한다고 할 수 있다. 아래의 인용문은 1574년에 쓴 「만언봉사(萬言封事)」의 일부이다.

신의 생각으로는 정치는 때를 아는 것을 귀하게 여기고 일은 실질적인 것에 힘쓰는 것을 중요하게 여깁니다. 정치를 하면서도 때에 알맞게 할 줄 모르고 일을 당하여 실질적인 결과에 힘쓰지 않는다면, 비록 성왕과 현신이 만난다 하더라도 다스림의 효과를 거둘 수 없을 것입니다. […] 이른바 때에 알맞게 한다는 것은 때에 따라 변통해서 법을 제정하여 백성을 구제하는 것을 말합니다. 정이(程頤) 선생께서 『주역』에 대해 논하여 말하기를 "때를 알고 형세를 아는 것이 『주역』을 배우는 큰 방법이다."라고 하셨고, "때에 따라 변화하여 바꾸는[變易] 것이 바로 영원한 도이다."라고 하였습니다. 법이란 시대에 따라 제정하는 것이어서 시대가 변하면 법도 같지 않게 되는 것이기 때문입니다.

순(舜) 임금이 요(堯) 임금을 계승하였으니 당연히 다르게 할 것이 없어야 했을 터인데도 9주(州)를 나누어 12주로 만들었고, 우(禹) 임금이 순 임금을 계승하였으니 당연히 다르게 할 것이 없어야 했을 터인데도 12주를 바꾸어 9주로 만들었습니다. 이것이 어찌 성인들이 변화시켜 바꾸기를 좋아해서이겠습니까? 단지 때에 따른 것에 불과합니다. 예부터 후세에 이르는 수천 년 동안 역대의 다스려지고 어지러웠던 자취는 대체로 이와 같습니다만, 때를 따라 폐단을 잘 구제했던 것은 오직 하(夏)·은(殷)·주(周)의 삼대에서 볼 수 있을 뿐입니다.

삼대 이후로는 폐단을 구제했던 일이 본디 드물기도 하지만, 그 올바른 방법을 다하지도 못하였습니다. 대체로 때를 따라 변할 수 있는 것은 법령과 제도이며, 고금을 통하여 변해서는 안되는 것은 왕도(王道)와 인정(仁政)과 삼강(三綱)과 오상(五常)입니다. 후세에는 원리와 시행방법[道術]이 밝혀지지 못해서 변해서는 안 되는 것을 고치고 바꾸는 때가 있었고 변할 수 있는 것을 굳게 지키는 때도 있었습니다. 이것이 잘 다스려지던 날은 언제나 적고 어지러운 날들이 언제나 많았던 이유입니다. (李珥, 『萬言封事』, 『율곡전서』 5-12ㄴ~14ㄴ)



연관목차

조선 전기 경세론과 불교비판 67/155

조선 전기 경세론과 불교비판
머리말
일러두기

제1부 조선 전기 경세론과 불교 비판 해제
Ⅰ. 조선 전기 경세론 해제
Ⅱ. 조선 전기 불교 비판 해제

제2부 조선 전기 경세론과 불교 비판 해설
1. 경세론
1.1. 총론
1.1.1. 김시습의 명분론
1.1.2. 송흠의 춘왕정월론
1.1.3. 양성지의 민본적 통치론
1.1.4. 양성지의 자주적 통치론
1.1.5. 권벌의 인정론
1.1.6. 조식의 민본사상
1.2. 정치론
1.2.1. 이곡의 정치론
1.2.2. 이첨의 정치론
1.2.3. 정도전의 정치론
1.2.4. 변계량의 정치론
1.2.5. 조광조의 정치론
1.2.6. 이이의 군권제한론
1.2.7. 정인지의 군주찬송가
1.3. 성학론
1.3.1. 이제현의 성학론
1.3.2. 성삼문의 성학론
1.3.3. 이석형의 성학론 1
1.3.4. 이석형의 성학론 2
1.3.5. 이황의 성학론
1.3.6. 이이의 성학론
1.4. 군신관계론
1.4.1. 신용개의 군신관계론
1.4.2. 강희맹의 군신관계론
1.4.3. 김정국의 군신관계론
1.4.4. 이이의 군신관계론
1.4.5. 윤상의 인재 등용론
1.4.6. 이이의 현자등용론
1.4.7. 이이의 군자등용론
1.4.8. 이이의 붕당론
1.5. 법제론
1.5.1. 총론
1.5.1.1. 신용개의 제도론
1.5.1.2. 남수문의 제도론
1.5.2. 토지 제도론
1.5.2.1. 조준의 토지 제도론
1.5.3. 부세 제도론
1.5.3.1. 이이의 공납제 개선안
1.5.4. 교육 제도론
1.5.4.1. 김반의 교육 제도 개혁안
1.5.4.2. 이제현의 유학 진흥 방안
1.5.4.3. 조광조의 유학 진흥 방안
1.5.4.4. 남수문의 교육론
1.5.4.5. 김안국의 교육론
1.5.4.6. 기준의 교육론
1.5.4.7. 신광한의 서원론
1.5.5. 간관론
1.5.5.1. 정도전의 간관론
1.5.5.2. 기준의 간관론
1.5.5.3. 이이의 국시론
1.5.6. 예악론
1.5.6.1. 성현의 음악론
1.5.6.2. 김수온의 예악론
1.5.7. 개혁론
1.5.7.1. 조광조의 개혁론
1.5.7.2. 김정국의 개혁론
1.5.7.3. 이이의 경장론
1.5.7.4. 이이의 변통론 지금 읽는 중
1.5.8. 상벌론
1.5.8.1. 조준의 상벌론
1.6. 대외 관계론
1.6.1. 신숙주의 외세 대응론
1.6.2. 남수문의 외세대응론
1.6.3. 조광조의 대외관계론
1.6.4. 변계량의 자주국가론
1.7. 재이론
1.7.1. 남효온의 재이론
1.7.2. 이색의 재이론
1.7.3. 최항의 천인감응론


2. 불교 비판
2.1. 정몽주의 불교 비판
2.1.1. 불교의 초월적 경향에 대한 비판
2.1.2. 불교의 반윤리성에 대한 비판
2.1.3. 불교의 마음관에 대한 비판
2.2. 정도전의 불교 비판
2.2.1. 유불도 삼교에 대한 종합적 인식
2.2.2. 불교의 심성론에 대한 비판
2.2.3. 불교의 자비에 대한 비판
2.2.4. 불교의 인과응보설에 대한 비판
2.2.5. 불교의 윤회설에 대한 비판
2.2.6. 유교와 불교의 종합적 비교
2.3. 여타의 불교 비판
2.3.1. 백문보의 불교 비판
2.3.2. 이색의 불교 비판
2.3.3. 하륜의 불교 비판
2.3.4. 정극인의 불교 비판
2.3.5. 양희지의 불교 비판
2.3.6. 서거정의 불교 비판
2.3.7. 박상의 불교 비판
2.4. 김수온의 불교 옹호론
2.4.1. 불교 옹호론
2.4.2. 유불 회통론
2.4.3. 불교 신앙 옹호론
2.4.4. 불교적 관점에 의거한 세계 인식
2.5. 절충조화론
2.5.1. 이곡의 절충론
2.5.2. 원천석의 삼교 일리론
2.5.3. 박팽년의 유불 조화론
2.5.4. 성현의 삼교 회통론
2.6. 권근의 불교관
2.6.1. 유불 조화론
2.6.2. 불교 비판
<부록> 조선 전기 인물 해제(가나다순)
(1) 강희맹
(2) 권근
(3) 권벌
(4) 기준
(5) 김반
(6) 김수온
(7) 김시습
(8) 김안국
(9) 김정국
(10) 남수문
(11) 남효온
(12) 박상
(13) 박팽년
(14) 백문보
(15) 변계량
(16) 서거정
(17) 성삼문
(18) 성현
(19) 송흠
(20) 신광한
(21) 신숙주
(22) 신용개
(23) 양성지
(24) 양희지
(25) 원천석
(26) 윤상
(27) 이곡
(28) 이색
(29) 이석형
(30) 이이
(31) 이제현
(32) 이첨
(33) 이황
(34) 정극인
(35) 정도전
(36) 정몽주
(37) 정인지
(38) 조광조
(39) 조식
(40) 조준
(41) 최항
(42) 하륜
참고문헌

출처

제공처 정보
조선 전기 경세론과 불교비판 2004.



저자 강중기


제공처 서울대학교 철학사상연구소 http://philinst.snu.ac.kr


[네이버 지식백과] 이이의 변통론 (조선 전기 경세론과 불교비판, 2004., 강중기)

궁(窮)하면 통(通)하리라! | 리더십 | DBR

궁(窮)하면 통(通)하리라! | 리더십 | DBR: ‘

궁(窮)하면통(通)하리라!
30호 (2009년 4월 Issue 1)

‘궁즉통(窮則通), 궁하면 통하리라.’ 요즘처럼 힘들고 어려운 경제 상
황에서 사람들에게 희망과 용기를 주는 메시지로 쓰이는 구절 가운데
하나다. 사람마다 조금씩 다르게 사용하고 있지만 대체로 2가지로 해석
된다.

첫 번째는 ‘세상은 힘들고 어려울수록 결국 통하게 돼 있다. 기다려라.
문제가 해결될 때까지’로 해석된다. 두 번째는 ‘어려울 때일수록 끝까지
파고들어 답을 찾자. 그러면 반드시 통하리라’는 뜻으로 쓰인다. 두 번
째의 궁(窮)은 ‘끝까지 궁구(窮究)해 답을 찾는다’는 뜻이다. 조금 자의
적인 해석이 가미되긴 했지만, 부지런히 노력하면 반드시 답을 찾을 것이라는 희망의 메시지가 담겨 있다.


‘주역(周易)’ 계사전(繫辭傳) 원문에서는 이렇게 말하고 있다. ‘궁즉변(窮則變), 변즉통(變則通), 통즉구(通則久).’ 궁하면
(窮) 변하고(變), 변하면 통하고(通), 통하면 오래간다(久)는 뜻이다. ‘주역’은 변화에 대한 철학적 사유다. 세상은 변한다.

자연은 음양이 교차하고 춘하추동이 순환한다. 인간 세계도 마찬가지다. 그런데 이 변화에는 어떤 원리가 있다.
‘변화의 원리를 찾아내 미래에 대한 대비를 하자’는 생각을 64괘(卦)와 384효(爻)의 범주를 통해 증명하려고 노력한 고대
인들의 결과물이 바로 ‘주역’이다. 그래서 ‘주역’은 미래 변화 예측이라는 측면에서 점서(占書)로도 해석되고, 변화에 대비
하는 인간의 절제와 겸양 및 수양에 대한 이론서로도 활용된다. 공자는 ‘주역’에 너무나 몰두한 나머지 위편삼절(韋編三絶),