Healing the Heart of Democracy: The Courage to Create a Politics Worthy of the Human Spirit: Palmer, Parker J.: 9780470590805: Amazon.com: Books
See all 3 imagesFollow the Author
Parker J. PalmerFollow
Healing the Heart of Democracy: The Courage to Create a Politics Worthy of the Human Spirit Hardcover – September 6, 2011
by
Parker J. Palmer (Author)
4.3 out of 5 stars
146 ratings* NEWS FLASH * Healing the Heart of Democracy called "one of the most important books of the early 21st Century" for those who care about democracy. (Democracy & Education)
* NEWS FLASH * Healing the Heart of Democracy named one of the "Best Books of 2011" on contemplation and social activism. (Spirituality & Practice)* NEWS FLASH * Parker J. Palmer named one of "25 Visionaries Who Are Changing Your World" -- people who "don't just think out loud but who walk their talk on a daily basis." (The Utne Reader)
~ HOPE FOR AMERICAN DEMOCRACY IN AN ERA OF DEEP DIVISIONS ~ In Healing the Heart of Democracy, Parker J. Palmer quickens our instinct to seek the common good and gives us the tools to do it. This timely, courageous and practical work -- intensely personal as well as political -- is not about them, "those people" in Washington D.C., or in our state capitals, on whom we blame our political problems. It's about us, "We the People," and what we can do in everyday settings like families, neighborhoods, classrooms, congregations and workplaces to resist divide-and-conquer politics and restore a government "of the people, by the people, for the people."
In the same compelling, inspiring prose that has made him a bestselling author, Palmer explores five "habits of the heart" that can help us restore democracy's foundations as we nurture them in ourselves and each other: (1) An understanding that we are all in this together. (2) An appreciation of the value of "otherness." (3) An ability to hold tensions in life-giving ways. (4) A sense of personal voice and agency. (5) A capacity to create community. Healing the Heart of Democracyis an eloquent and empowering call for "We the People" to reclaim our democracy. Publishers Weekly, in a *Starred Review*, said "This beautifully written book deserves a wide audience that will benefit from discussing it."
Read more
256 pages
September 6, 2011
======
Editorial Reviews
Review
"He bravely takes on the current political climate, and this book provides therapy for the American body politic. His insights are heart-deep: America gains by living with tension and differences; we can help reclaim public life by actions as simple as walking down the street instead of driving. Hope's hardly cheap, but history is made up of what Palmer calls 'a million invisible acts of courage and the incremental gains that came with them.' This beautifully written book deserves a wide audience that will benefit from discussing it." (A "Starred Review" from Publishers Weekly, 8 August 2011)
“Healing the Heart of Democracy is a hopeful book that lifts up and hallows the heart as a source of inner sight. Inspired by the efforts to understand and undergird democracy by Abraham Lincoln, Alexis de Tocqueville, Rosa Parks, and others; the author sends us on our way rejoicing with the small portion of hope that he has planted in our minds and souls.”
—Spirituality & Practice (http://www.spiritualityandpractice.com/books/books.php?id=21525)
“There is a deep and disturbing cloud hanging over the United States. It is a malaise that is leading to cynicism and self-centeredness. The antidote is to be found in the healing of the heart of our democracy, so that we might emerge from this private focus to a public one, which recognizes our interdependence. I know of no better guide to discerning the problem and the solutions, than this book by Parker Palmer. It is a prophetic book, one that needs to be taken with all due seriousness, if we are to emerge from our malaise stronger and healthier than before.” (Englewood Review of Books , 2011)
From the Author
* A Starred Review from Publishers Weekly * Palmer's...newest was six years in the making. He bravely takes on the current political climate, with its atrophy of citizen participation, the ascendance of an oligarchy that shapes politics, and the substitution of vituperation for thoughtful public discussion. It's a tall order that became even taller because Palmer had to climb out of a pit of depression -- his constitutional proclivity -- to do so. But wrestling with essential questions of public life became therapeutic, and this book provides therapy for the American body politic. Palmer's use of acute 19th-century observers of American life and character -- Tocqueville, Lincoln -- as well as his use of anecdotes and lessons from his own long career provide context and tonic. His insights are heart-deep: America gains by living with tension and differences; we can help reclaim public life by actions as simple as walking down the street instead of driving. Hope's hardly cheap, but history is made up of what Palmer calls "a million invisible acts of courage and the incremental gains that came with them." This beautifully written book deserves a wide audience that will benefit from discussing it. -- August 8, 2011
~ ENDORSEMENTS ~
* We have been trying to bridge the great divides in this great country for a long time. In this book, Parker J. Palmer urges us to "keep on walking, keep on talking"--just as we did in the civil rights movement--until we cross those bridges together. -- U.S. Congressman John Lewis, recipient of the Martin Luther King Jr. Nonviolent Peace Prize and the Presidential Medal of Freedom
* The book we need for recovering the heart, the very core, of our selves and our democracy. -- Krista Tippett, host of public radio's On Being and recipient of a 2013 National Humanities Medal
* A master work by a master, a clear and uplifting resource that keeps shining light in all the dark places. Palmer is that rare, deep seer who is at home in the streets, a teacher by example who has the courage to stand openly and honestly in the public square. -- Mark Nepo, author of The Book of Awakening and As Far As the Heart Can See
* Can we keep our sights on the vision of what we aspire to be while working constructively to transform realities that do not yet fulfill that vision? How do we remain "open hearted" so that we can engage creatively with citizens who hold different views of the challenges we face?Healing the Heart of Democracy asks these necessary questions and inspires us to answer. -- Joan Blades, co-founder of MoveOn.org and Living Room Conversations
* A book born for this moment. Wise, evocative, and pragmatic at its core, this dream for a new politics is grounded in dignity and liberty for all. -- Terry Tempest Williams, author of The Open Space of Democracy
* In this inspiring book, I find encouragement that all of us, citizens and elected officials alike, can learn to bridge the divides that keep us from genuinely respecting one another. By sharing his own life's struggles, Palmer reveals the common struggles we all endure. He provides us with a way forward, a way forward with hope. -- U.S. Senator Tammy Baldwin
* A gracefully written anthem to democracy [that] breaks new ground in marrying the capacity of the human heart with the tensions inherent in politics [and] breathes new life into what it means to be a citizen--accountable, compassionate, fiercely realistic. -- Peter Block and John McKnight, coauthors of The Abundant Community
* A "must read" for everyone who is concerned about the state of our democracy and has ever despaired about what can be done. Palmer's stories, plainspoken analysis, and penetrating insights will inspire you to claim your full human capacities and to take part in healing democracy "from the inside out." -- Martha L. McCoy, Executive Director, Everyday Democracy
* The most important manifesto in generations for breaking through the divisiveness that has paralyzed our democracy. -- Bill Shore, founder of Share Our Strength, author of The Imaginations of Unreasonable Men
* All who harbor concerns about American politics will find in this book a wise and kindred spirit who reminds us of choices we can make to help "reweave the tattered fabric of our civic life." You will close this book appreciating how much you can do, and how much depends on you. -- Diana Chapman Walsh, President Emerita of Wellesley College
* A courageous work that is honest and true, human and humble, glitteringly intelligent and unabashedly hopeful. Palmer gives us constructive language, historical context and a practical vision for how we as individuals and communities can get to the real heart of the matter. -- Carrie Newcomer, activist and singer-songwriter, The Geography of Light and Before and After
* Could not be more timely and needed. As one who has been guided through a time of personal reflection with Parker Palmer, I invite you to join in a journey through these chapters. -- U.S. Congresswoman Lois Capps, grandmother, mother, nurse, and seeker after democracy
* A brave and visionary book. Palmer re-imagines our political lives as a deeply personal process within which all Americans--especially those of us inheriting this broken polity--have a chance to be heard, heal, and get on with the eternal work of perfecting this nation. -- Courtney E. Martin, author of Do It Anyway: The New Generation of Activists
* Palmer has been our mentor as we've weathered the rough and tumble of political life. In this compelling new book, he challenges us to recognize that a more vital democracy begins within each of us, as we learn to hold the tensions inherent in community life and no longer fear to tread that most difficult terrain--the broken places in our own hearts. -- Kathy Gille served for twenty years as a senior congressional aide. -- Doug Tanner, her husband, is a founder and former president of The Faith and Politics Institute.
* A book that should be read and talked about in every family, book club, classroom, boardroom, congregation and hall of government in our country. Palmer writes with clarity, good sense, balance, honesty, humor and humility, focusing on the essence of what is needed from each of us for the survival of our democracy. -- Thomas F. Beech, President Emeritus, the Fetzer Institute
Read more
Product details
Publisher : Jossey-Bass; 1st edition (September 6, 2011)
Language : English
Hardcover : 256 pages
4.3 out of 5 stars
146 ratingsVideos for this product
2:52
3:23
The First Home of Democracy
Merchant Video
2:40
The Politics of the Brokenhearted
Merchant VideoUpload your videoAbout the author
Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Follow
Parker J. PalmerPARKER J. PALMER is a writer, teacher, and activist whose work speaks deeply to people in many walks of life. Author of ten books—including several best-selling and award-winning titles—that have sold two million copies, Palmer is the Founder and Senior Partner Emeritus of the Center for Courage & Renewal. He holds a Ph.D. in sociology from the University of California at Berkeley, as well as thirteen honorary doctorates, two Distinguished Achievement Awards from the National Educational Press Association, and an Award of Excellence from the Associated Church Press. In 1998, the Leadership Project, a national survey of 10,000 educators, named him one of the 30 most influential senior leaders in higher education and one of the 10 key agenda-setters of the past decade. In 2010, he was given the William Rainey Harper Award (previously won by Margaret Mead, Marshall McLuhan, Paulo Freire, and Elie Wiesel). In 2011, the Utne Reader named him as one of "25 Visionaries Who Are Changing Your World.” In 2021, the Freedom of Spirit Fund, a UK-based foundation, gave him their "Lifetime Achievement Award” in honor of work that promotes and protects spiritual freedom. For 20-plus years, the Accrediting Commission for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) has given annual Parker J. Palmer “Courage to Teach” and “Courage to Lead” Awards to directors of exemplary medical residency programs. "Living the Questions: Essays Inspired by the Work and Life of Parker J. Palmer," was published in 2005. Born and raised in the Chicago area, he has lived in NYC, Berkeley, CA, Washington, DC, and Philadelphia, PA. He currently lives in Madison, Wisconsin.
Read less
Products related to this item
Sponsored Customer reviews
4.3 out of 5 stars
Top reviews from the United States
daniel noe4.0 out of 5 stars Promising, but incompleteReviewed in the United States on August 13, 2015
Verified PurchaseI recently read Parker J. Palmer’s book Healing The Heart Of Democracy, a book about political strife and incivility in America, much like a book I wrote in 2012 that I must mention because it gives me something to compare it to (The Nutcase Across The Street). I bought it because it speaks to my interests.
Part of Palmer's proposed solution to our partisan problems consists of learning to let our hearts “break open” rather than “break apart.” This is poorly explained, but I think he means that after having our hearts broken we are then able to empathize with others, including those whose hearts are broken over issues we don’t care about or would prefer to be settled in ways they would not. This is the main theme running through the whole book.
Another part of his solution consists of learning to connect with others outside of our immediate circles of friends, learning not to fear strangers – especially those of different races, socio-economic classes, etc. Simply living in an urban area where one has to negotiate a path through crowds can help one develop the habit of respecting others and Palmer also suggests numerous other ways this might be done formally and informally. He claims connecting with others also has the added benefit of making us less dependent on centralized power for our needs, making us less vulnerable to manipulation and fascism. He claims individualism leads to despotism because when people no longer need others, they stop caring and are easily divided by those that would overpower and subdue us.
Most of this makes sense to me, but in my experience the only way to keep the peace sometimes is for people to separate. Rather than trying to push everyone into working together or living where there are crowds, people should be able to escape and live as they want without interference. Individualism may lead to despotism, but it seems to me much more likely for the lack of individualism to lead to despotism. One cannot rule alone (or else I’d already be doing it) without widespread allegiance to a system – allegiance that could not exist if more people were more independent.
Other proposals include leading by example to change hearts rather than change the law, seeking consensus rather than majority (or plurality), respecting the rights of minorities, respecting the democratic process, and respecting the constitutional system of checks and balances to slow down change to the point that society can safely absorb it. He wants us to “live in the tension” of never having any issue permanently settled.
He seems unaware that the problem with our current political situation is that we cannot agree on what is constitutional, what is democratic, and which minority rights to respect. Do we respect the reproductive rights of the mother? Or the right-to-life of the baby? Do we have greater respect for a president elected by the states through the electoral college or for a congress elected by much smaller (and often gerrymandered) districts? Did Bush commit an unconstitutional act by ordering troops into Iraq? Did Obama commit an unconstitutional act by signing the ACA? The problem is not that we can’t settle our disagreements; the problem is that we can’t even agree on the process to go about settling our disagreements.
In my book, I propose that we talk more to each other in order to eventually reach an agreement on these issues. Palmer expects us to live at peace without ever reaching an agreement. My solution may very well be too impractical and idealistic, but Palmer’s solution is no solution at all!
Overall, it is a very interesting book packed with numerous nuggets to think over. I have already pointed out above why I think it is incomplete, but his ideas could still be an important first step to get us to negotiate honestly. It also gives an important historical perspective to our connection with strangers that most people (including myself) seem to lack. The book is actually about much more than politics. It is about getting along, socialization, intimacy, and communication. I give it at least four stars.
10 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
Marianna Cacciatore5.0 out of 5 stars A Gift of Great Value - Finding Our True VoiceReviewed in the United States on September 10, 2011
Verified PurchaseParker Palmer is one of the few people I know who can write about the heart and politics in the same sentence and not diminish either but, in fact, deepen our understanding of both. He does not offer a schmaltzy version of the heart. Rather, a very hardy and honest description that includes atrocities driven by emotions. He goes to the core when he writes of heartbreak and asks what we can do "so that it yields life, not death?"
In these cynical times we think of politics as mostly the purview of powerful politicians. For me, Parker dispelled that idea by offering page after page of thoughtful insight, historical information, and practical ideas that got me thinking of ways I can actively contribute to strengthening this gift of democracy I was born into.
"The impulses that make democracy possible--and those that threaten it--originate in the heart, with its complex mix of heedless self-interest and yearning for community. From there, these impulses move out into our relations with each other in families, neighborhoods, workplaces, voluntary associations, and the various settings of public life...these are the places where we can make a difference, too, once we free ourselves from the illusion that we are at the mercy of forces beyond our control." (from pages 22 & 23)
He goes on to write about holding the tension of opposites--with true-life "political" stories to illustrate this ideal and skill; "habits of the heart" that help us live a democratic life; and interesting ways to widen the scope of community to include those beyond our family and chosen friends. All in service of We the People finding our voice and using a combination of "Chutzpah and Humility" to take our rightful place in the creation of the life we share.
If I could have one wish it would be that everyone, upon reading this book, becomes inspired to take personal actions to strengthen the democratic life most of us take for granted. This book has the power to do just that. I close this review with a passage at the core of the book's teaching:
"Heart...is a word that reaches far beyond our feelings. It points to a larger way of knowing--of receiving and reflecting on our experience--that goes deeper than the mind alone can take us. The heart is where we integrate the intellect with the rest of our faculties, such as emotion, imagination, and intuition. It is where we can learn how to "think the world together," not apart, and find the courage to act on what we know." (pgs. 17 & 18)
Parker Palmer has given us a gift of great value. Everyone should know it exists.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
Mare5.0 out of 5 stars Book in excellant shapeReviewed in the United States on July 12, 2022
Verified PurchaseGoing to be an informative read for our fractured country.
Book arrived earlier that promised!!!
Helpful
Report abuse
shager5.0 out of 5 stars Prepare to be challenged and comfortedReviewed in the United States on August 28, 2011
Verified PurchaseIn this season of rabid partisanship, when, I admit it, it can be deeply satisfying to rant and rail(regardless of your political persuasion)against those "other" people who are clearly bent on destroying the country, Parker Palmer makes us take a good, hard look at what's underneath our smugness and our judgments. He astutely diagnoses our fears and anxieties. He, thankfully, holds us to a higher standard, not only to save ourselves, but to save the country as well.
I had begun to feel cynical and a bit hopeless about the state of things, doubting the ability of many of our leaders to see beyond anything except their own self-interest. I'm thinking I will send a copy of this book to each of my congresspeople. Maybe those reading this review will think to do the same--I think it might help. Palmer reminds us once again what it means to be a citizen, and best of all, that each of us has a responsibility, and the ability, to become a true citizen again. I'm now looking for examples everywhere in my small town of places that serve as public places, and people who are exhibiting those qualities of hospitality and openness that define the best of us. I want to support those people and places however I can, and become a more hospitable person myself.
He teaches us something else too: that we don't have to be afraid of conflict; that in fact democracy is an "argument without end". How we disagree, however, is critically important, all important, in fact. Learning to hold the tensions of democracy in an open, respectful way is not only good for the country, it's good for our souls as well.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book, and its timing couldn't be more perfect.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuseSee all reviewsTop reviews from other countries
Maura McGrath maura mcgrath
4.0 out of 5 stars Four StarsReviewed in Canada on May 27, 2015
Verified Purchase=====
Healing the Heart of Democracy: The Courage to Create a Politics Worthy of the Human Spirit
Parker J. Palmer
4.06
813 ratings134 reviews
Hope for American democracy in an era of deep divisions In Healing the Heart of Democracy, Parker J. Palmer quickens our instinct to seek the common good and gives us the tools to do it. This timely, courageous and practical work--intensely personal as well as political--is not about them, "those people" in Washington D.C., or in our state capitals, on whom we blame our political problems. It's about us, "We the People," and what we can do in everyday settings like families, neighborhoods, classrooms, congregations and workplaces to resist divide-and-conquer politics and restore a government "of the people, by the people, for the people."
In the same compelling, inspiring prose that has made him a bestselling author, Palmer explores five "habits of the heart" that can help us restore democracy's foundations as we nurture them in ourselves and each other:
An understanding that we are all in this together An appreciation of the value of "otherness" An ability to hold tension in life-giving ways A sense of personal voice and agency A capacity to create community Healing the Heart of Democracy is an eloquent and empowering call for "We the People" to reclaim our democracy. The online journal Democracy & Education called it "one of the most important books of the early 21st Century." And Publishers Weekly, in a Starred Review, said "This beautifully written book deserves a wide audience that will benefit from discussing it."
Genres
Nonfiction
Politics
Spirituality
Leadership
Philosophy
Social Justice
Religion
...more
256 pages, Hardcover
First published September 6, 2011
Book details & editions
240 people are currently reading
1,412 people want to read
About the author
Profile Image for Parker J. Palmer.
Parker J. Palmer
54 books462 followers
Follow
Parker J. Palmer (Madison, WI) is a writer, teacher and activist whose work speaks deeply to people in many walks of life. Author of eight books--including the bestsellers Courage to Teach, Let Your Life Speak, and A Hidden Wholeness--his writing has been recognized with ten honorary doctorates and many national awards, including the 2010 William Rainey Harper Award (previously won by Margaret Mead, Paulo Freire, and Elie Wiesel). He is founder and senior partner of the Center for Courage Renewal, and holds a Ph.D. from the University of California at Berkeley.
Show more
Readers also enjoyed
Items 1 to 4 of 20
Book Cover
Silent Compassion: Finding God in Contemplation
Richard Rohr
4.33
452
Book Cover
The Divine Conspiracy: Rediscovering Our Hidden Life in God
Dallas Willard
4.19
13.8k
Book Cover
The World Cafe: Shaping Our Futures Through Conversations That Matter
Juanita Brown
4.1
422
Book Cover
All the Beauty in the World: The Metropolitan Museum of Art and Me
Patrick Bringley
4.18
683
All similar books
Ratings & Reviews
My Review
Profile Image for Sejin.
Sejin
3 reviews
September 2, 2018
Write a Review
quaker
Friends & Following
No one you know has read this book. Recommend it to a friend!
Community Reviews
4.06
813 ratings134 reviews
5 stars
299 (36%)
4 stars
316 (38%)
3 stars
158 (19%)
2 stars
28 (3%)
1 star
12 (1%)
Search review text
Search review text
Filters
Displaying 1 - 10 of 133 reviews
Profile Image for robin friedman.
robin friedman
1,778 reviews
208 followers
Follow
September 15, 2022
The Politics Of The Brokenhearted
In times of national difficulty, it is both tempting and desirable to step back, reflect upon the situation, and see what might be done to make things better. The process might carry its own danger in the rush to either easy or impracticable answers. I took the opportunity offered by the Amazon Vine program to read Parker J. Palmer's new book "Healing the Heart of Democracy: the Courage to Create a Politics Worthy of the Human Spirit" for the insight it might have on our national situation as witnessed by the recent budget and debt-ceiling deliberations and their aftermath. Palmer wrote his book before these events occured, but they make his examination all the more timely. Palmer (b.1939) received his PhD in Sociology from the University of California at Berkeley in 1970. This book was my first exposure to his work, but he is a noted writer on educational and social issues with a focus on spirituality.
I liked a good deal of this book especially its personal tone. Palmer tries to combine events and feelings in his life, and the way in which he reflects upon them, with our national experience as Americans. He uses throughout the figure of the "habits of the heart", the title of a book by Robert Beulah which derives from de Tocqueville's "Democracy in America". Palmer discusses his own experiences of loss, disappointment and "brokenheartedness" in his life. When these experiences occur, the spirit, or the heart can be shattered. The better course is to put the pieces together, use disappointment creatively, integrate conflicting feelings and move ahead from weakness to strength. So it is, for Palmer, in a democracy.
Palmer offers some inspiring stories to illustrate what he means. He describes meeting with members of a small African American church in rural Georgia in 1974 who showed the strength and discipline to carry on in hard times. He describes meeting a New York City cabdriver who, while navigating the city streets, explained that the attraction of his job was that it allowed him to hear and consider the varied opinions of the many different types of people who rode in his cab. He praises openness to difficulty and a willingness to accept tensions -- in the form of divergent opinions -- and work through them. Palmer also makes excellent use of historical figures. Abraham Lincoln emerges as the hero of the book for his ability to overcome his own demon of depression and for his attempt to reconcile tensions in a crisis as shown by both his First and Second Inaugural Addresses. Alexis de Tocqueville, for his diagnosis of the strengths and weakness of American democracy also receives valuable discussion. Palmer explains his own conclusions in a few words: "We must be able to say in unison: It is in the common good to hold our political differences and the conflicts they create in a way that does not unravel the civic community on which democracy depends."
There is an excellent focus in the book on commonality and civic life, as witnessed in the use of public streets, bookstores, pubs, libraries and other places where people of different backgrounds and persuasions can meet and get to understand one another. I am writing this review, as I generally do, in a public library, largely because I share Palmer's commitment to the use of public space. Palmer also emphasizes the value of people explaining to one another the reasons why the believe what they do on important, controversial matters, based upon their own experiences without attempting to demonize someone who thinks differently. I tried to follow this good advice after reading the book, as I exchanged lengthy emails with a close friend who holds an opinion different from mine on same sex marriage. Perhaps it helped to air the reasons for one's belief and to understand those of another person.
I liked aspects of this book less well. Palmer does not always handle well his own project of openness to ideas with which he disagrees. He frequently translates his project into support for his own distinct agenda and tends to belittle those who think differently. In a passage early in the book Palmer shows awareness that he does this as he comes close to demonizing his political opponents, perhaps by reducing them to straw men ("Get me going on politicians who distort my faith tradition to win votes or on racial bigots and homophobes who want to translate their personal shadows into public policy, and this nice Quaker boy from the Midwest does a passable imitation of the Incredible Hulk") before half-heartedly catching himself and falling back. There is a good deal of cliche and half-formed ideas in this book intertwined with much that is insightful. I found, for example, Palmer all--too--quick in his uncompromising discussion and rejection of "consumerism". Although Palmer has much good to say about the need to both develop and hold one's opinions and to have a degree of modesty and humility in thinking about the opinions of others, his use of the overused term "chutzpah" distorts and distracts from his point. His discussion of American public education, I thought, made a variety of points, some good, some questionable. In places, I thought Palmer was expecting too much from ordinary citizens. Democracy, and the American political process, was made to accomodate a degree of human weakness. And some of the thinking in the book I thought wooly and undeveloped.
This is a worthwhile book to read and to think through. It has many insights but it is not a panacea, in my view, for understanding the current condition of American democracy. Like much other writing, the book deserves to be read but read critically and with skepticism.
Robin Friedman
13 likes
2 comments
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Michael Kruse.
Michael Kruse
15 reviews
3 followers
Follow
February 14, 2012
I have really appreciated Parker Palmer's books over the years but this book is a profound disappointment. I quit reading at the halfway point. If you are a liberal/progressive, then I suspect you may enjoy the book. It plays very well into the meme that at core of the discord in our country are conservatives. I can't help but feel that Palmer missed an opportunity.
I know he is a Quaker pacifist. I've suspected his political views were to the left based on other writing I've seen. I have no problem with that. But his topic is "Politics Worthy of the Human Spirit." Every few pages he trots out examples of the values and misbehavior that are contrary to his aims and they are invariably those of conservative citizens (without him ever explicitly saying this.) The outrageous values and misbehavior of the left are not on his radar. And that is the problem.
We each see our opponents actions as threatening and crazy but we feel justified in our threatening and crazy behavior because we know our opponents wrong. That is how Tea Party rallies (where some park service people report that participants left venues as clean or better than when they came) can be dubbed terrible hate-filled racist mob, while the Occupy Movement with its illegal occupation of property, vandalism, defecating and urinating on police vehicles and passersby, is heralded as a wonderful expression in Democracy. (I actually think both movements are hopeful signs of our democracy, that both have their excesses.) That is how there can be obsessive anger at activists talking about death panels, while be oblivious to the President calling Congress terrorists and hostage takers, as well as the VP and leading Democrats talking about Republican desires to kill people.
The first step in restoring democracy is to resolve not to use other people's bad behavior as excuse for your own. I don't think Palmer is there. I will continue to give his "Let Your Life Speak" book to others as gifts. I still think his "The Active Life" book is one of the best books I've read. But this book simply isn't worth my time.
christian-life
politics
4 likes
6 comments
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Joyce.
Joyce
425 reviews
56 followers
Follow
February 18, 2017
Published in 2011, this book still rings true, perhaps even more so. We Americans have been greatly divided for a long time and sadly to say, remain so today.
This book discusses how we Americans can strive to bridge that gap because: "When we forget that politics is about weaving a fabric of compassion and justice on which everyone can depend, the first to suffer are the most vulnerable among us -- our children, our elderly, our mentally ill, our poor and our homeless. As they suffer, so does the integrity of our democracy." And so, "Every time we fail to bridge our differences, we succumb to the divide-and-conquer tactics so skillfully deployed by individuals and institutions whose objective is to take us out of the political equation. We the People then become fearful and suspicious of each other and widen the gap further."
This book challenges us to realize that we can do something about this gap, not only by becoming politically active, but by simple acts of listening to one another, finding the common ground from which to build upon and more.
The book is well researched and direct. This book is for those who would like to help make our democracy better and trying to figure out how to work in that direction.
inspiration
4 likes
2 comments
Like
Comment
Profile Image for George.
George
Author
14 books
50 followers
Follow
December 9, 2019
Important and wise but it wasn’t revelatory for me. It was a good summary of needed principles but maybe in way that felt too theoretical and abstract.
political-and-social-critique
3 likes
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Kyra deGruy Kennedy.
Kyra deGruy Kennedy
33 reviews
1 follower
Follow
April 14, 2017
I love Parker J Palmer SO much. This book was divine. Both practical and emotional, it completely shifted my perspective about divisiveness and how to bridge the gap between polarities. Highly recommend!
3 likes
3 comments
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Kathrina.
Kathrina
508 reviews
127 followers
Follow
June 23, 2018
Really useful.
teaching-social-justice-working-gro
3 likes
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Payson Rigsbee.
Payson Rigsbee
42 reviews
13 followers
Follow
November 13, 2020
great book, chapters were too long for me but that’s personal preference. truly loved the ‘habits of the heart’ very thought-provoking, especially for people deeply engaged in the political process.
2 likes
Like
Comment
Dnicebear
152 reviews
3 followers
Follow
January 20, 2012
Yes! I want to be involved in democracy that stays rooted in reality while dreaming of possibility and is willing to enter the gap between the two to bring it about. Parker Palmer has encouraged me in previous books to see myself as a teacher and to let my life speak. Now, I'm with him again into this exploration into being part of "we the people" in a way that allows respect and true sharing of who we are. "Life in the company of strangers" really seems possible here, and in a way that honors the human heart. Terry Tempest Williams speaks of the heart as the "first home of democracy." Parker goes on to say: "If our hearts are large and supple enough to hold the tensions of democracy's basic questions in a life-giving way, they produce ideas and ideals that feed a living democracy. If our hearts are so small and brittle that they implode or explode under tension, they produce 'ideals' like Aryan supremacy and 'ideas' like the Nazis' 'Endlosung,' their chilling, 'final solution.'" (p. 152)
2 likes
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Deidra.
Deidra
Author
2 books
49 followers
Follow
January 3, 2017
So many people say they "don't do/talk about politics" when nothing could be further from the truth. We all do politics every day. Our unwillingness to engage politics thoughtfully is what hinders a lot of forward movement, but some of our unwillingness comes from a lack of voices encouraging us to think differently about politics so that we can talk differently about politics. Parker J. Palmer does a great job of helping to reframe the role of politics in everyday life so that we can each be better stewards of our role as people in a political context. I wish it had been required reading before the last few US presidential election cycles.
2 likes
Like
Comment
Profile Image for Melissa.
Melissa
Author
12 books
21 followers
Follow
March 22, 2020
This book has been in my ever-shifting "to be read" pile since shortly after it came out in 2011. I'm not sure why I hadn't picked it up. I would reach for it and then decide that something else was more compelling or more urgent for my non-fiction read-of-the-moment.
For three years now (and in many respects longer), our country's future has seemed in serious jeopardy from the forces of a a divisive politics dominated by a greedy oligarchy and by an incompetent and unhinged ruler (because he behaves as a ruler, not an elected officials, and other elected officials keep enabling his autocratic practices.)
And yet it was not until a couple of weeks before my country was plunged into the chaos of coping with the coronavirus pandemic that I began to read this book. In the past two or three weeks, a time when our president has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that he is incapable of leading and the deadly consequences of the erosion of our democracy have been thrown in sharp relief, the contents of this book became ever more urgent for me.
In it, Palmer explores what he calls, "the politics of the broken-hearted," an apt description for our time if ever I heard one. He says, "There are times when the heart, like the canary in the coal mine, breathes in the world's toxicity and begins to die." And yet, he says, the despair inherent in broken-hearted politics can be a call to re-engage with our common life and find a way to move forward that restores the goodness that is at the heart of our democratic values.
Palmer is no romantic. He is well aware of the tensions inherent in a democratic system, its messiness and inefficiency. He is well aware that our national myths are, as he puts it, aspirations that have never reflected our reality. He argues that "some of America's political pathologies result from the fact that we keep desperately trying to save face." (181) By that, he means that we try to deny the ways in which our nation fails to live up to its highest ideals.
He knows that much of our current national dysfunction grows our of our fear of people who are different and the fact that "we have developed a variety of strategies to evade our differences, strategies that only deepen our fear." (13) Americans are suffering, and we don't know what to do with our suffering. He writes:
"When our ancient fear of otherness is left unacknowledged, unattended, and untreated, diversity creates dysfunctional communities. . . . The benefits of diversity can be ours only if we hold our differences with respect, patience, openness, and hope, which means that we must attend to the invisible dynamics of the heart that are part of democracy's infrastructure." (13)
And yet he finds hope. Palmer identifies five "habits of the heart" that Americans need to heal the heart of our democracy:
1) understanding that we are all in this together
2) developing an appreciation of the value of "otherness."
3) cultivating the ability to hold tension in life-giving ways
4) generating a sense of personal voice and agency
5) strengthening our capacity to create community
He explores the places where we can cultivate these habits of the heart in ourselves and in our communities including our institutions of government, the "free-wheeling" spaces of public life, schools and congregations, and in our personal and virtual (read on-line) lives.
I found his chapters on school and religious institutions and on safe spaces for "deep democracy" particularly compelling.
Palmer notes that "movements of social transformation are sparked by people who are isolated, marginalized, and oppressed but who do not fall into despair." (184) And there is where I find his call to action. He calls on us to listen to those we vehemently disagree with and to work for change rather than to give in to despair or cynicism.
Palmer calls on us to stand in what he calls the "tragic gap," the space between the hard realities of the world and the possibilities for change. If we focus only on the hard realities, he says, we will become paralyzed by cynicism while if we focus too much on the way the world could be, we fall into "irrelevant idealism." (192) Neither extreme is helpful. Instead we must stand in the tragic gap where we can be faithful to "the eternal conversation of the human race, to speaking and listening in a way that takes us closer to truth." (193)
Never has this message seemed more urgent than this week when the full implications of the denigrating of expert knowledge and the power of government to ensure the health of our population have become apparent. We are all endangered because of the illness at the heart of our democracy, and only we the people can do the hard work of healing that illness.
1 like
Like
Comment
