2021/10/20

Yoga And The Quest For True Self : Cope, Stephen

Yoga And The Quest For True Self : Cope, Stephen: Amazon.com.au: Books





Follow the Author

Stephen Cope
Follow



Yoga And The Quest For True Self Paperback – 15 September 2000
by Stephen Cope (Author)
4.5 out of 5 stars 230 ratings


Product description

Review
"What a delight to find a book on spiritual practice that's as compelling to read as a good novel. This honest, intelligent, and beautifully written book is required reading for anyone interested in spiritual practice today."
-- Lilias Folan, host of the PBS series Lilias!

"A tour de force...a book grounded in yoga psychology that will be meaningful and useful to spiritual practitioners in many traditions."
--Sylvia Boorstein, author of It's Easier Than You Think and That's Funny, You Don't Look Buddhist

"A down-to-earth, wise, spiritually mature and compassionate teaching that integrates the best of yoga and our own Western humanity. Destined to be a classic."
--Jack Kornfield, author of A Path with Heart
From the Back Cover
Millions of Americans know yoga as a superb form of exercise and as a potent source of calm in our stress-filled lives. Far fewer are aware of the full promise of yoga as a 4,000-year-old practical path of liberation--a path that fits the needs of modern Western seekers with startling precision. Now Stephen Cope, a Western-trained psychotherapist who has lived and taught for more than ten years at the largest yoga center in America, offers this marvelously lively and irreverent "pilgrim's progress" for today's world. He demystifies the philosophy, psychology, and practice of yoga, and shows how it applies to our most human dilemmas: from loss, disappointment, and addiction, to the eternal conflicts around sex and relationship. And he shows us that in yoga, "liberation" does not require us to leave our everyday lives for some transcendent spiritual plane--life itself is the path. Above all, Cope shows how yoga can heal the suffering of self-estrangement that pervades our society, leading us to a new sense of purpose and to a deeper, more satisfying life in the world.

About the Author
Stephen Cope is a psychotherapist who writes and teaches about the relationship between contemporary psychology and the Eastern contemplative traditions. He holds degrees from Amherst College and Boston College. He is currently Scholar-in-Residence at the Kripalu Center for Yoga and Health in Lenox, Massachusetts, the largest residential yoga center in the world. This is his first book.

Product details

Publisher ‏ : ‎ BANTAM DELL; 1st edition (15 September 2000)
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Paperback ‏ : ‎ 384 pages


Customers who viewed this item also viewed




The Wisdom Of Yoga: A Seeker's Guide to Extraordinary Living

Stephen Cope
4.7 out of 5 stars 199
Stephen Cope



Stephen Cope is a psychotherapist, senior Kripalu yoga teacher, and author of Yoga and the Quest for the True Self. He is currently Senior Scholar in Residence at the Kripalu Center for Yoga and Health in Lenox, Massachusetts.

His homepage can be found at: www.stephencope.com



Top reviews

Top review from Australia


Elizabeth

2.0 out of 5 stars Western ideas of yoga.Reviewed in Australia on 21 August 2019
Verified Purchase

The author introduces Yoga to a Western audience. From one particular school of thought. He also interlaces modern psychological ideas throughout.
It wasn't what I was looking for, I wanted to read more first hand accounts, rather than the psychoanalysis of people.
It is well written, just not my cup of tea.


HelpfulReport abuse

See all reviews


Top reviews from other countries

Miss M Wilkinson
5.0 out of 5 stars Fabulously enlightening book on the spiritual/psychological aspects of yogaReviewed in the United Kingdom on 7 July 2019
Verified Purchase

I don't normally leave reviews but I wanted to express just how much I've loved reading this book and what a vital tool I've found it on my yoga path. I've been practising yoga for several years to manage my physical and mental health, and because I never feel closer to myself or more at peace than when I'm in a posture or being with my breath. So I found the blending of a psychoanalytic and yogic perspective really exciting, and it answered a lot of questions about how best to use yoga as a tool for healing and to get closer to your true self. I found the section on developing one's equanimity practice to keep up with the insights gained in awareness practice particularly useful as I have found myself somewhat overwhelmed by the latter in recent times. So this book came at the right time for me and I would absolutely recommend it to anyone who loves yoga or is looking for a way to manage their suffering. I found the first chapter a little slow but after that I couldn't put it down so if you find that too then stick with it, it's so worth it :)

14 people found this helpfulReport abuse

Nicola
5.0 out of 5 stars So much beauty in this bookReviewed in the United Kingdom on 20 September 2020
Verified Purchase

This book expresses what I have experienced directly through my yoga practice but struggled to put into words. It offers a beautiful integration of psychology and spiritually and I'd recommend it to therapists, yoga teachers and anyone interested in embodied spirituality.

2 people found this helpfulReport abuse

TheHolisticTherapist
5.0 out of 5 stars I loved this book so much that I often go back ...Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 September 2016
Verified Purchase

Absolute a must read for yoga teachers, students and practitioners. A blend of personal experience, psychology, yoga and a very in depth discussion of the spiritual path. I loved this book so much that I often go back to re-read certain passages of it. Bravo Stephen for writing such an honest account of the yoga path.

9 people found this helpfulReport abuse

Tm
5.0 out of 5 stars So far so goodReviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 November 2020
Verified Purchase

I buy too many books, but enjoyed this so far. Nice to hear from a mans perspective
Report abuse

Mrs. D. A. Naven
5.0 out of 5 stars Five StarsReviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 May 2018
Verified Purchase

An extremely thought provoking book. It is a 'must' read for everyone who takes Yoga seriously .

4 people found this helpfulReport abuse
See all reviews

==================================================

Yoga and the Quest for the True Self

by
Stephen Cope
4.14 · Rating details · 1,802 ratings · 166 reviews


Millions of Americans know yoga as a superb form of exercise and as a potent source of calm in our stress-filled lives. Far fewer are aware of the full promise of yoga as a 4,000-year-old practical path of liberation—a path that fits the needs of modern Western seekers with startling precision. Now Stephen Cope, a Western-trained psychotherapist who has lived and taught for more than ten years at the largest yoga center in America, offers this marvelously lively and irreverent "pilgrim's progress" for today's world. He demystifies the philosophy, psychology, and practice of yoga, and shows how it applies to our most human dilemmas: from loss, disappointment, and addiction, to the eternal conflicts around sex and relationship. And he shows us that in yoga, "liberation" does not require us to leave our everyday lives for some transcendent spiritual plane—life itself is the path. Above all, Cope shows how yoga can heal the suffering of self-estrangement that pervades our society, leading us to a new sense of purpose and to a deeper, more satisfying life in the world. (less)


Paperback, 384 pages
Published September 5th 2000 by Bantam (first published October 5th 1999)
Original Title
Yoga and the Quest for the True Self

Write a review

Apr 29, 2012Craig Shoemake rated it it was amazing
Shelves: indian-religion, yoga, indian-philosophy, meditation, kundalini-yoga, kripalu-yoga, yoga-and-psychotherapy
It is not often I use the “M word” to describe a book. No, I’m not talking about munchkin books or maleficient books. I’m talking about masterpieces. I am not certain if Stephen Cope’s bestseller is a masterpiece. Maybe it is, maybe not. Either way, it is pretty damn good.

This is one of those books that entertains and educates you in a visceral way right from the start. Large chunks are written in immediate narrative format–as in “he said,” “I said,” etc. It is Stephen Cope’s personal yoga story–a sort of “pilgrim’s progress,” if you will–as well as the yoga story of his many friends and acquaintances before and during his long and continuing stay at the Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health in Stockbridge, Massachusetts.

We meet a man, a practicing Boston psychotherapist, who for a variety of reasons was feeling unsettled and dissatisfied with his life and then, somewhat to his dismay, found himself joining a religious community to do…what? Much of the book is an answer to that and related questions: What did he want? Why? What was he trying to do at Kripalu? What was–is–the meaning of yoga? What is enlightenment? Is such a thing possible? Are there enlightened people in this world? And what happens when all the things we try to keep hidden are revealed for the world to see?

Stephen Cope furrows through all these questions and more. His sincerity, his intensity, his intelligence, make the book a gripping read. Its pages educate the reader even as Cope the protagonist is educated by his experiences in the ashram. Yoga philosophy is pondered over, its depths turned up, and its many connections to Western psychotherapy reflected upon, all in gratifyingly sober, lucid prose. This is no idealistic hippy’s tale, nor a wide-eyed New Age search for Reality. In point of fact, it is one man’s search for himself, even as he helps us understand that the discipline, the science, the art of yoga, is there to help us lay ourselves bare to ourselves.

“You will know the truth and the truth shall set you free.” This book is a testament to these words, but it goes beyond them for the “truth” as yoga reveals to Stephen Cope is an ever living, organic thing, the stuff of our lives, which we either enjoy and let go of or cling to and warp, eventually to destroy.

You will find yourself in this book. In one of the many personal portraits Cope draws, you will find your own symptoms and neuroses, your fears, dreams and failings. And when you do, you will know that yoga has something to offer you. There is so much teaching here, and it is given in such generous, gentle and wise ways. Most of all, I think the primacy of ourselves as bodily beings, as thinking, feeling, dreaming animals of earth, is borne out. The body really is our temple, and yoga is our puja, an act of adoration, discipline and feast. Cope nails it in what might be the defining statement of the book: “Because yoga asanas are not so much about exercise as they are about learning and unlearning, it is not the movement itself, but the quality of attention we bring to the movement that makes postures qualify as yoga” (230). If this is so–and I know it is–then any act, any breath, any thought done with full and alive attention, is yoga.

Bobby Fischer once said “Chess is life.” I would say “Yoga is life,” and Stephen Cope’s book has made this truth abundantly clear.

(less)
flag21 likes · Like · 1 comment · see review



Sep 10, 2010David Guy rated it liked it
I picked this book up on a whim because I have been doing yoga and reading up on it, and I was intrigued by the title. Cope is a therapist who went to Kripalu (a yoga center in Western Massachusetts) and basically never left. He writes very well, and tells a lot of stories. There was something about the book I found vaguely annoying, maybe all the upper middle class angst of many of the people he was talking about. There was also a lot more psychiatric jargon than I was interested in; I'm nore interested in spiritual practice than in therapy. That having been said, the book has stayed with me, and the basic concept of a false vs. true self seems quite true to me. One can't do justice to it in a few words, but basically the false self is one that we create out of concepts; the true self is the one that is living our daily physical life, and that we too often avoid by going off into our heads. He also mentioned something that R.D. Laing said at a conference of Buddhists and therapists that keeps coming back to me: Human beings are afraid of three things. Their own minds, other people, and death. (less)
flag9 likes · Like · comment · see review



Dec 20, 2015Anne Palmer rated it it was amazing
As a yoga teacher, I figure I am supposed to read yoga books. However I find within three chapters of most books on the subject I am either distracted or bored, or I have already absorbed what I need from the author. That was not the case with this book, which I read daily and finished within two weeks. Yoga and the Quest for the True Self was recommended to me years ago, and I didn't even read it when my yoga studio 8 Limbs held a book group around it. But when a writer friend urged me to give it a chance, I finally relented, to my great advantage. Cope, a psychotherapist who has lived at Kripalu for several decades, uses a memoir framework to deliver some of the most personally valuable teachings about yoga I have received. I recommend this book to yoga practitioners of all levels. Be here now. Read it. Now. (less)
flag8 likes · Like · comment · see review



May 13, 2015Sunshine rated it it was amazing
Shelves: njsunshinebookclub, to-buy
Absolutely transformational. Revolutionized the way I see yoga, myself, life, and relationships with people. There is so much to learn and so much more growth needed, but grateful for a read that deepened my spirituality and religious convictions and changed my perspective for the better.

And my notes from the book because it is a library book and I couldn't underline:

“Most of the branches of Vedanta hold one fundamental view in common: all individual souls are one with the ground of being, the Absolute. Because all beings are one with the great river of life, we are all, in effect, just a single soul. We are, in the classical dictum, ‘One without a second’” (page 42.)

“what we are seeking is already at the core of our nature. ‘We are that’ which we seek. We are already inherently perfect; we have already arrived; and we have the potential in each moment to wake up to our true nature. In the words of one extraordinary teacher whom we’ll meet later on in the book, ‘everything is already OK’” (page 42).

“When we begin to see clearly who we really are, according to this view, we feel a natural friendliness toward all beings. Beneath the surface of our separation, we feel the hidden,unseen threads that link us. We know that we’re exactly alike inside. We’re the same being. As author John Welch says, ‘We are each like a well that has its source in a common underground stream which supplies all. The deeper down I go, the closer I come to the source which puts me in contact with all other life’” (page 43).

“All mystical paths have taught that the union with God, or with the Absolute, subtly transforms the self. Each time we penetrate into samadhi, we have a small death-rebirth experience. Samadhi the world as we know it—its boundaries and categories. The deeper into union I penetrate, the less I am ‘I,’ and the more I am ‘we.’ For this reason, the merger with the One is known to create psychological upheaval and world-shattering shifts in perception” (page 43).

“This love is so overwhelming that you will lose consciousness of the conventional world. You will not be able to entertain the slightest feeling of personal ownership, not even toward the body, which is the most precious and jealously guarded possession of most persons. There will no longer be any instinctive notion that the body or the mind constitutes your being” (page 44).

“The word yoga itself means, literally, to be ‘yoked’—or to be in union. Eventually, repeated penetrations into mystic union transform the physical structure of the body, the personality, and the mind” (page 44).

“In Christianity, don’t you have this understanding: God is both—what do you say—immanent and transcendent? God is both here, within, right now, and is also everywhere? At the same time? It is the same God, the same Reality. Just our language has trouble capturing it. This is the wonderful thing about yoga. You find God right here, right now. In the body. You become a fully alive human being. You become jivan mukta—awake this lifetime. As a human being. Not in, what did you say? Transcendent realm with the angels. No. Not at all. You see, you are an angel” (page 48).

“‘Deep eternity,’ in Emily Dickinson’s phrase, is right here, right now. It is the subtle interior anatomy of the body—and the subtly interior anatomy of this entire world of form.
‘The goal of human life,’ says Ramakrishna,’ is to meet God face to face.’ But the magic is this: if we look deeply into the face of all created things, we will find God. Therefore, savor the world, the body. Open it, explore it, look into it” (page 55).

“When we pay close attention to the world of the many, we inevitably discover the One” (page 58).

“Gitanand was telling the story of a dialogue between a Vedic master and a Western student. ‘The student, confounded by the radically different worldview embodied by his teacher, asks, “Do we live in the same world?” Replies the teacher, ‘Yes, we do. It’s just that you see yourself in the world, and I see the whole world in myself.’ Yogis insist on seeing the world from the inside out” (page 70).

“We can experience the entire reality of the universe directly through a full exploration of the phenomena of our own bodies, feelings, minds. There is nothing that is ‘out there’ that is not also ‘in here’” (page 70).

“‘Disappointment,’ he said, ‘is a much more fertile ground for spiritual practice than dreams’” (page 89).

#1 of page 90-92
“In order for us to fully inhabit our bodies, we need certain kinds of responses from our environment. These include empathic holding, nurturing, mirroring, challenge, optimal frustration, and optimal disillusionment. Problems begin to happen in our developing sense of self when, as infants and children, our real emerging needs and capacities are not met with adequate mirroring, nurturing and sustaining responses. In the post industrial West, the problems of the disembodied sense of self are pandemic. The reasons for this are simple: Because of the breakdown of the extended family in the latter half of this century, we depend upon the depleted resources of small nuclear families, where hard working parents may already feel stretched and needy themselves. This nuclear family upon which we place most of our hopes is all too often an impoverished emotional environment for children. Overburdened parents feel fragmented, insecure, and in some cases terrified by the needs they feel they should be meeting but cannot. They’re hungry to get their own unsatisfied needs met” (page 91).

“The false self is born when the environment does not welcome the self to be as it is” (page 93).

“There is no telling precisely at what chronological age the self will come to one of these crossroads. One thing is certain: these times of meltdown are precious. A delicate window is opened into the very terrain explored and mastered by yogis and buddhas and seers of all kinds. In these times, the soul has a heightened potential to discover the real. There is a palpable longing for the mother, for matter, for the earth, and along with this an openness to the father, to the spirit, to consciousness.
In his commentary on the Yogasutras, Bhagwan S. Rajneesh identifies this meltdown of ‘me’ and ‘mine’ in adulthood as the entry point into yoga” (page 97).

“May we be protected together.
May we be nourished together.
May we work together with great vigor.
May our study be enlightening.
May there be no hatred between us.
Om peace, peace, peace.

Lead us from the unreal to the real.
Lead us from darkness to light.
Lead us from death to immortality” (page 100-101).

“‘Just being in my body makes me happy. I don’t have to do anything, or prove anything. What freedom!’ For the first time in her adult life, Amy had tasted the possibility of a life not lived in the head—or in the abstraction of the edo-ideal—but in the very real world of current direct kinesthetic experience” (page 106).

“The body likes living in reality. Stepping down onto the solid ground of reality always feels better than living in delusion. It may be painful, but there is life in it, energy in it, and, like the ground, it holds us up in a way that delusion does not. ‘Only reality is wholly safe’” (page 112).

“The genius of yogic practice is that it cultivates the capacity to experience a close-range, moment-by-moment inspection of reality. In fact, yoga teaches that living fully in the moment is the only doorway into the hidden realities of the Self” (page 113).

Amrit Desai:
“If you want to experience the joyous ecstasy that life offers, there is one commitment that is absolutely fundamental: the commitment to live in the moment. With that commitment as your guiding focus, whatever you do in your daily life is part of your transformational process. Your commitment to living in the moment becomes your vehicle for spiritual growth.

Living in the moment, however, is the most dangerous situation anybody ever faces in life, because everything you have ever avoided is revealed to you when you live in the moment. You get to face all the denied contents of your subconscious as the reappear again and again through the events of your life” (page 113-114)

“the goal of the reality project is not to disengage from the phenomenal world, but to turn to embrace it more deeply—to discover its hidden depths. And in order to do that paradoxically, we do not reject the vicissitudes of the embodied life. We no not reject suffering. Rather, we turn and go through the doorway of suffering. We turn to embrace our neuroses, our conflicts, our difficult bodies and minds, and we let them be the bridge to a fuller life. Our task is not to free ourselves from the world, but to fully embrace the world—to embrace the real” (page 115).

“Through the practice of yoga, the physical structure is said to be ‘baked,’ or refined, creating a form strong enough to tolerate and hold the powerful energies of the fully alive human being without being roiled or destroyed by them. Without the creation of this hard wiring, as Viveka saw, it was simply not possible to tolerate the subtle levels of awareness into which the quest would take him. Like Viveka, without the development of a compassionate and equananimous body and mind, we literally cannot bear what the seer reveals to us” (page 124).

“‘Laymen often think that the best way to deal with any difficult situation is not to deal with it—to forget it. But you and I have the experience that the only way you can forget is to remember” (page 130).

“do we uncover conflict or do we build up the self?...Both of these pillars of the reality project have to be developed in the context of relationship. We cannot become real in isolation” (page 139).

“My grandparents were most important self-objects for me, allowing me to relax into the stable, calm, nonanxious, powerful, and protective environment that they created with their care. Within the vast and safe container of their nurturing, I was allowed to discover my true self” (page 142).

“The truth is, however, that all the yoga postures in the world cannot create the opening of the heart. In their original context, yogic practices were completely submerged in a web of relationship” (page 142-143).”

“that which is damaged in relationship must also be healed within relationship, and character can only truly be transformed through relationship—not through solitary practice” (page 144).

“Ramakrishna always used the language of the mother and child in explaining his relationship with God. As he once put it, ‘One must have the yearning for God of a child when his mother is away’” (page 145).

“about the importance of other human beings in the ongoing creation of th self. He understood that only other human beings can initiate us into the Real. One of his most useful proverbs was this: ‘Company is more powerful than willpower’” (page 166).

“When we carry a heavy load of repressed, hidden, and unitegrated experience, we are constantly seeking out relationships that will help us hold this experience, to reveal it in the actual dramas of our lives, and, hopefully, eventually bring it to a more successful conclusion—to heal it” (page 182).

“Reality must be, in a sense, triangulated. It takes two sets of eyes, not just one, to accurately locate the third point in space. The ‘third’ becomes a powerful still point, constructed out of the interaction of two minds and hearts” (page 183).

“‘Sometimes, rest is the highest spiritual practice’” (page 241).

“Real healing happens in relaxation, and unless we’re relaxing, we are not healing” (page 242).

“What begins as an experientially grounded practice—one that asks us to take nothing at all on faith, indeed, asks only that we pay attention to the body—brings us finally and inexorably back to God. The physical is revealed to be spiritual. The spiritual is revealed to be physical” (page 268).

“You thought that union was a way you could decide to go.
But the soul follows things rejected and almost forgotten.
Your true guide drinks from an undammed stream” -Rumi (page 273).

people to look into:
Marion Woodman: student of Carl Jung
Sylvia Boorstein: psychologist and senior American teacher of Buddhism
Jacquelyn Small: pioneer in the synthesis of spirituality and addictions work
Tom Yeomans: poet, psychologist, and leader in field of spiritual psychotherapy

“‘This is so much that wisdom of Jung,’ continued Marion (Woodman). ‘If we allow ourselves to be ravished the by the irrational, we are compelled to face our own evil. Trust takes on a new dimension. In knowing our own darkness, we know what another’s darkness can release. We learn to forgive and to love. Then, we don’t know from moment to moment what will happen next. As your Pashupats clearly understood—this is God’s country, not ours’” (page 289).

“After long searches here and there, in temples and in churches, in earths and in heavens, at last you come back, completing the circle from where you started, to your own soul and find that He, for whom you have been seeking all over the world, for whom you have been weeping and praying in churches and temples, on whom you were looking as the mystery of all mysteries shrouded in the clouds, is nearest of the near, is your own Self, the reality of you life, body, and soul” -Swami Vivekenanda (page 290).

“In order to hear the teaching, we must slow down, cultivate awareness, and tune in. Most of all, we have to drop our hopes and dreams and preconceived notions of how it should be. We must look at how it is. We must look with a mind that lets go. Then we will see” (page 292).

“And the worst part is that at the same time that we’re leaning in toward the magic powers [of another], we will miss the real, more subtle, ordinary magic of transformation in our lives” (page 295).
“As I sat with myself…” (page 295). emphasis added, with not by

“Whatever transformation was happening was surely going to be by grace, not effort. Through letting go, rather than hot pursuit” (page 295).

“When all is said and done, most of the stages of spiritual practice are stages of grief work” (page 296). (less)
flag4 likes · Like · 1 comment · see review



Oct 11, 2016Saiisha rated it it was amazing
Shelves: self-help, spiritual, reviewed
I loved this book! I didn't quite know what to expect when I picked it up, but yoga has been dear to me all my life, and of course, the quest for the true self is central to yoga philosophy, so I had to read it. It's a well-written, well-researched book, but with none of the pedantic clinginess to theory - which is difficult to avoid when the author's trying to deal with a 4,000 year old philosophy, that has evolved and morphed over all those years.

But Stephen Cope brings a delightful fresh eye to yoga by bringing the reader along on his journey as a student of yoga. It's a satisfying journey to be part of, from the moment he decides to step into Kripalu Yoga Center, to how he integrates the different teachings into an understanding of his own in the end. I was surprised that he included the stories about the falling apart of Kripalu amidst the scandals of its leader, and then how the community came together to rebuild it again. I also appreciated the appendix about the metaphysics of yoga.

It was a valuable read. I took lots of notes. And I'll probably revisit it from time to time.

If you're interested in spirituality, philosophy, yoga, etc., join my Old Souls Book Club (https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/...) for other recommendations and thought-provoking conversations! (less)
flag5 likes · Like · comment · see review



May 19, 2012Dianne Lange rated it really liked it
This classic goes on my to reread, reread, and reread shelf. So many lessons in living, spirituality, psychology. Cope says it best: "Such a simple lesson. Such a dfficult lesson. It doesn't matter what you call it: Yoga. Buddhism. Christianity. Relaxation. Consciousness. As Ajahn Chah says, 'Teach the essence of freedom from grasping and call it what you like.' " (less)
flag4 likes · Like · comment · see review



Dec 24, 2009Clif Brittain rated it liked it
I wrote a totally brilliant review of this book that will reveal all the secrets of yoga. However, I was on a public terminal and the session timed out, losing the entire review. You lose.
flag3 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jul 13, 2012Kris Anderson rated it it was amazing
This was the book that first introduced me to Vipassanna meditation which I eventually took part of in the sub-tropical alps of south central Mexico.
I'll call it the beginning to a new me. (less)
flag3 likes · Like · comment · see review



Dec 21, 2015Harriette rated it it was amazing
This book changed my life.
flag3 likes · Like · see review



Jul 04, 2014Byron Stripling rated it it was amazing
This was one of those life changing books for me! I don't do Yoga on a regular basis but still the thoughts and observations the author makes have really touched me personally. Rather than continue trying to describe the book - I'd encourage you to read it and leave you with this quote from the book.
From page 129...
"We can 'put away' the lunatic, raging aunts and the sex -obsessed alcoholic uncles of our psychic life. We can lock them up in the basement of our consciousness. But the more energy we expend in securing the basement door, the more dramatic their appearance will be when they get out. To paraphrase Carl Jung, that which we hold unaware in our unconscious will eventually come to us as fate."

The book is full of these kinds of gems. (less)
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jul 06, 2015Sian Lile-Pastore rated it really liked it
Y'know what? This book is great, almost five stars. It combines personal stories, psychotherapy, yoga and yoga philosophy and also quotes both Moonstruck and Fame. I'm all in. (less)
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jun 03, 2016Deadra rated it it was amazing
In preparation for my upcoming yoga teacher certification class. Loved the book and can't wait to start in class learning. (less)
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jun 29, 2019Greg Williams rated it really liked it
Shelves: inspiration-spirituality, health
Insightful and interesting deep-dive into yoga practice, inner wisdom and its connection with traditional/historical Indian spirituality.

That said, I have a long-standing aversion to yoga, stemming I think, from always feeling lanky and awkward since I was a little kid. When I try to cross my legs (not comfortable) and try to lean forward, nothing much happens and I stay upright while looking in awe at the weird contortionists all around me who seem to be able to lay their foreheads on the mat. Crazy.

So I read this to get a better understanding of yoga, and I did get that. Perhaps a bit more than I was ready to chew, as it seemed to get down into the weeds as it went on, and then into the root structure of the weeds, and at one point felt like a textbook glossary of terms I didn’t care about. But for some - perhaps even me in a decade or so - it may help better define very specific conditions related to the effective practice of yoga.

I’m a believer in simplicity and I do think any practice can get mired down in unimportant details. Including every religion I’ve ever studied.

So I’m going to ascribe 4 stars because I think this is an important, wise discussion of this topic that I so resist. I do understand the transformative nature of yoga because I’ve read so much about the immense value people get from it. I’m trying, not by bit. Mostly because I want to invest in my future and be a fit and flexible elder man some day. I’ll get there - some day. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Apr 18, 2020Jeanne rated it liked it · review of another edition
Shelves: psychology, read-2020, religion-and-mindfulness
Stephen Cope, a psychotherapist and scholar-in-residence at Kripalu, argued that we are not who we believe ourselves to be – our true self remains hidden behind the identities, values, and goals that we have mistakenly accepted as real. Fear and shame prevent us from being true to ourselves. Rather than listening to our true voice, rather than accepting our rejected parts, we run and hide. This alienated from the self – and from God – results in suffering.

But:

What we are seeking is already at the core of our nature. “We are that” which we seek. We are already inherently perfect; we have already arrived; and we have the potential in each moment to wake up to our true nature. (p. 42)

What instead? We can listen to ourselves, accept and trust our body, our breath and live each moment fully. We do not choose against any part of whom we are, but choose and accept all. We need to learn to listen to and trust our inner demons – and learn that these rejected parts of ourselves are not demons at all.

How? Yoga and meditation provide opportunities to slow down, cultivate awareness, and tune in to the True Self. They allow us to drop our hopes, dreams, and preconceived notions of how life should be, of who we should be. Rather than believe false stories about who and what we, we must search with an open mind. Only then can we really see.

I love yoga for multiple reasons, but I tend to think that this is a path rather than the path. Nonetheless, Cope outlines a useful path.
(less)
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Feb 22, 2021A.M.G. ☮Hippie/Fantasia☮ rated it liked it
Recommends it for: Those looking to study the spiritual aspects of yoga (specifically Kripalu yoga)
Shelves: spirituality, nonfiction
Rating: 3.5 / 5 (rated down for now until a re-read)

I'll admit, part of the reason that I'm finally putting this down now is because I've just discovered Wicca and it is much more compatible with my faith in its open-ended manner rather than the direct and exact views expressed by Cope in his work. Nearly a year ago, when I first picked up this work, it was the beginning of the pandemic and perhaps I felt that I needed some structure and preciseness in my life; now, I feel the need for just the opposite.

That's not to say that my rating should reflect Cope's writing or that I don't agree with some of the things that he says--I do. In fact, the first half or so of the book are full of underlines and circlings of mine for the things that really did speak to me in reading this author's work.

However, at one point he just sort of lost me, and so far I haven't managed to convince myself back into reading this, and forcing myself isn't doing any good, so for now I'm going to set it aside and leave it at that. This is definitely something that I plan to take another look at in the future, as it really is well-written and has some good insights, but right now it isn't what I need, and that's a good enough reason to set it aside. (less)
flag1 like · Like · see review



May 09, 2018Alex Boon rated it liked it
Very strange book. Took me a long time to get through it and spent much of that trying to figure out whether I liked it or not. The author certainly has my respect and there were several things in there that have gone in my personal quotes book. If you start out reading it and want to scream "cuuuuult" and run for the hills, stick with it. It does get better and includes a good discussion of the broken and outdated "guru" model. Parts of it are meandering and difficult to get through, I think it could be 25% shorter without much loss but overall I recommend it if you have an interest in the more traditional yoga model and yoga communities. The most interesting and important thing I took away from the book is the importance of developing awareness and equanimity side by side. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Mar 15, 2021Gina rated it liked it
There were parts of it that I found really annoying, which ultimately means that yogic philosophy is not for me, though that can be many different things. Regardless, for most of the part where Cope is charting his path, it was just affirming my love for and revelry in attachment.

(My main interest in yoga is being more bendy, and that is primarily carnally motivated, so there is that.)

The section where he goes over three different practitioners and the ways in which yoga helped them were the ones I cared about most. I realize there are other paths toward healing, but it is good that there are different things that can work for other people. I also think the appendix is very valuable.

I guess after what happened with Gurudev at Kripalu that there are still people who were listening to Oshi (Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh)... I think there is a problem with gurus in general that makes total sense, and I believe they are missing some lessons with that. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Jun 27, 2020Meriam lahlou rated it really liked it
This is not a book you can read in one setting but I did enjoy it. I got a little lost with all the deities' references because I didn't buy some of the beliefs. However, I loved the tales of individual experiences and I could relate to those. It also made me do a lot of deep thinking and introspection. I even had some cool moments of surrender and small revelations during my yoga practices. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Apr 11, 2009Rochelle rated it did not like it
Shelves: spirituality
When I started to read this book I was skeptical. Many people try very hard to either "psychologize" spirituality, or "spiritualize" psychology. It is normal I guess in our "have it all, popular culture." I feared that, in his enthusiasm for a newly minted perspective, Cope was doing just that. Although his framework is decidedly East-coast, psychotherapist, white upper-class, gay male, with all of the historically and socially privileged angst this package carries (who else can afford to take a year or two off without having to continue to generate a source of income, and dedicate that year to healing a broken heart and partake in some soul searching?), his genuine desire to understand the quest and the object of his quest are genuine enough that the reader is willing to go along for the ride. It is not hard to see that, eventually, Kripalu, this oft-recreated Eden, will prove to be as flawed as the one of Biblical fable, as vulnerable people look to someone other than themselves to take responsibility for their lives, resulting in emotional and spiritual damage to some and financial woes to the ashram--Paradise regained, lost, re-designed. He writes about this with some compassion and discretion, but eventually decides that the growth he has experienced was worth what turned into a very deep personal commitment. Seeker, be warned. He does just that, making sure to explain what the characteristics of a healthy spiritual program is and is not. When all is said and done, the reader is rewarded with a very readable, highly personal exploration of Yoga as it relates to individual growth, as well as some rudimentary understanding of the psychoanalytical process, but please be reminded that this is one man's memoir and experience. As with most things of this nature, it is impossible to generalize about the outcome of similar spiritual journeys. This caveat notwithstanding, the title does deliver what it promises, and I would probably read another book from this author. As a bonus, there is an easy-to-understand appendix on yoga terms and some background on this ancient and richly complex practice. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Apr 19, 2021Megan S rated it it was ok
Shelves: meditation-spirituality
I tried. I got 4/5ths of the way. The first part of this book was really distasteful to me. Having been dogmatically religious myself and having now let go of religion, I felt so uncomfortable reading his early experiences with the guru and the spiritual community the author joined. When he talks about the mystical feelings he got just from touching the guru, his description was identical to how myself and members of my church community described feeling the spirit of god, being prayed for, or “slain in the spirit.” Very disconcerting that he never fully challenged the unhealthy atmosphere at this centre. Yes he does touch on the fact the guru should not be worshipped, but these statements fall flat after his vivid descriptions. Clearly he was fully converted and unable to reasonably assess the community, which was frustrating to read as it was much more clear from the readers point of view that the community was unhealthy.
There were some interesting parts here, but little yogic teaching which is why I wanted to read the book. Some of his psychoanalytic musings were fascinating and enlightening. Some were absolutely toxic, especially once mixed with religious ideas. When he said that a child may have deserved its own abandonment due to actions in a past life (with the attitude of, who knows? Maybe?) I couldn’t read much more. What a horrific thought. Such ideas only come from deep saturation in completely unreasonable religious doctrines and are extremely psychologically damaging. As damaging as the Puritanism that he disparages on and off throughout the book.
This book had interesting parts, and a few distressing parts, but it was not what I was looking for when I desired to learn more about yoga. Would not recommend it. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Sep 01, 2019Edith rated it it was amazing
Surprisingly amazing. Read for a yoga book club and not something I'd have sought out myself. This is partly a narrative about the author's ten-year stay at the Kripalu commune; partly a commentary on yoga philosophy; partly the author (an experienced psychotherapist)'s observations on the psychological dimensions of communal living, yoga, and guru-student relationships; and partly directly applicable practical advice.

A rarity among yoga authors, Cope doesn't mindlessly accept wacky ideas that have no support, and yet doesn't shy away from esoteric concepts either. He talks about how it is important to bring equal amounts of skepticism, common sense, and openness to these topics, and to my mind he did exactly that in writing this book. He has a sense of humor about the weird stuff, too.

My favorite parts were his discussions about breath control as an unconscious defense mechanism. (Hard to summarize; worth reading if you're into yoga.) (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Sep 03, 2015Missy rated it it was amazing
I bought this book well before I even planned to visit Kripalu. When I purchased it I didn't even realize the author was a teacher at Kripalu. I started this book about 2 weeks after my visit to Kripalu and I have to say that that made the read for me richer and deeper than if I had read it without ever having visited Kripalu. Stephen's descriptions took me back to my time at the Stockbridge Bowl and the Berkshires. I felt like I was breathing the mountain air in once again. Thank you Stephen for allowing me to relive my R&R Retreat while at the same time getting to read a first hand experience back to the days of Amrit Desai and the downfall and rebuilding of Kripalu. Plus all of the rich history before it was a yoga center. I'm sorry I'm finished with the book. I want to go back to Kripalu again! (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Jan 07, 2016Amy rated it it was ok
This book had many things going for it: a well-qualified and knowledgeable author, cool merging of Western psychology and Eastern/yogic philosophy, stories for human interest, a scandal to keep it from being too utopia, and a fantastic appendix that gives an accessible summary of thousands of years of yoga philosophy. I also found it off-putting: Cope often assumed his readers had certain experiences or feelings, and I didn't relate at all. Perhaps his social circles/clientele skew in certain ways that don't include me. Or maybe because I'm already converted to yoga there were fewer epiphanies to be had from his account. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Jul 08, 2018Alison rated it it was amazing
Very insightful and honest renderings of experiences and literature. I stayed at Kripalu a year or so before the Gurudev was exposed, and the place freaked me out with its zombie-ness. So I was very pleased to read the historical context for that time, what happened, what followed, how the community repaired. I think Meditations on the Mat was a better fit for the inspirational effects I was expecting from this book. I do love Cope's writing, so loving and earnest and well-read, so it wasn't time wasted. (less)
flag1 like · Like · see review



May 14, 2017Justin Green rated it it was amazing
This was a great i.e. entertaining and interesting read, plus the author's personal journey, background and experience are so invaluable in the way he manages to synthesize eastern and western mindsets, philosophies and practices for a 21st century western audience i.e. dudes like me. Very grateful and thoroughly recommend this book. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review

2021/10/19

Read The Franciscan Heart of Thomas Merton Online by Daniel P. Horan | Scribd Books

Read The Franciscan Heart of Thomas Merton Online by Daniel P. Horan | Books

The Franciscan Heart of Thomas Merton: A New Look at the Spiritual Inspiration of His Life, Thought, and Writing
By Daniel P. Horan

5/5 (1 rating)
287 pages
5 hours
Included in your membership!
at no additional cost
====
Description
Daniel Horan, O.F.M., popular author of Dating God and other books on Franciscan themes—and expert on the spirituality of Thomas Merton—masterfully presents the untold story of how the most popular saint in Christian history inspired the most popular spiritual writer of the twentieth century, and how together they can inspire a new generation of Christians.

Millions of Christians and non-Christians look to Thomas Merton for spiritual wisdom and guidance, but to whom did Merton look? In The Franciscan Heart of Thomas Merton, Franciscan friar and author Daniel Horan shows how, both before and after he became a Trappist monk, Merton’s life was shaped by his love for St. Francis and for the Franciscan spiritual and intellectual tradition. Given recent renewed interest in St. Francis, this timely resource is both informative and practical, revealing a previously hidden side of Merton that will inspire a new generation of Christians to live richer, deeper, and more justice-minded lives of faith.


Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith : Francis S Collins

Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith : Francis S Collins: Amazon.com.au: Books  
Francis S Collins
====


====



Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith Hardcover – 1 July 2010
by Francis S Collins  (Author)
4.5 out of 5 stars    60 ratings
===

Product description
Review
"Any seeking clarity on the debate between reason and faith will find this an engrossing collection."--The Bookwatch

"As I read through the chapters, I felt I was at a banquet table with old friends. What a feast Francis Collins has served!"--Philip Yancy, author of What's So Amazing About Grace

"Because I teach in the area of faith and reason I have a shelf full of anthologies, and I have to say that this is the most varied and interesting of them all."--Nancy Murphy, co-author of Did My Neurons Make Me Do It? and Professor of Christian Philosophy at Fuller Theological Seminary

"BELIEF is more than an anthology; it is a provocation, a brilliant, wide ranging and powerful series of readings on the possibilities, problems and mysteries of faith. This book belongs on the shelf of every believer - and every serious skeptic."--Rabbi David Wolpe, author of WHY FAITH MATTERS

"Francis S. Collins--a foremost geneticist and author of the bestselling The Language of God--has compiled a rich array of readings in his new book."--America Magazine

"This life-giving, faith-filled and hard-nosed collection reveals why, as St. Anselm wrote, true faith always seeks to understand."--Rev. James Martin, SJ, author of My Life With the Saints

A wonderful expose on the different arguments for religious and spiritual beliefs. These readings are critical for our understanding of religion and will be essential for fostering greater dialogue about the nature of religion in the future. An important read for anyone interested in the study of religion and spirituality.--Andrew Newberg, M.D., author of Why God Won't Go Away
From the Back Cover
"Is there a God?" is the most central and profound question that humans ask. With the New Atheists gaining a loud voice in today's world, it is time to revisit the long-standing intellectual tradition on the side of faith. Francis Collins, New York Times bestselling author of The Language of God and renowned physician and geneticist, defends the reason for faith in this provocative collection. Collins is our guide as he takes us through the writings of many of the world's greatest thinkers -- philosophers, preachers, poets, scientists -- both past and present, including such luminaries as C. S. Lewis and Augustine, and unexpected voices such as John Locke and Dorothy Sayers. Despite the doubts of a cynical world, this essential companion proves once and for all the rationality of faith.

"In the twenty-first century, many seem to have concluded that the spiritual experience and the life of the mind ought to occupy separate domains, and that disruptions, conflicts, and disenchantments will result if the firewall comes down. Surely humanity's ongoing search for truth is not enriched by such limitations. In the words of Socrates, the key to a fully mature and richly rewarding life, both for us as individuals and as a society, is to 'follow the argument wherever it leads, ' unafraid of the consequences. If this collection of essays provides even a small encouragement in this direction for the seeker, the believer, or the skeptic, that will be gratifying indeed." -- from the Introduction

Read more
Start reading Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith on your Kindle in under a minute.

Don't have a Kindle? Get your Kindle here, or download a FREE Kindle Reading App.

Sponsored 
Product details
Publisher ‏ : ‎ HarperCollins Religious - US (1 July 2010)
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 352 pages

Customer Reviews: 4.5 out of 5 stars    60 ratings
Follow
Francis S Collins
Francis S. Collins, M.D., Ph.D., helped to discover the genetic misspellings that cause cystic fibrosis, neurofibromatosis, Huntington's disease, and a rare form of premature aging called progeria. A pioneer gene hunter, he led the Human Genome Project from 1993 until 2008. For his revolutionary contributions to genetic research, he was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2007, and the National Medal of Science in 2009. He is a member of the Institute of Medicine and the National Academy of Sciences, and has a longstanding interest in the interface between science and faith. He currently serves as the Director of the National Institutes of Health. He lives in Bethesda, Maryland, and in his spare time he enjoys riding a motorcycle and playing guitar.

Customer reviews
4.5 out of 5 stars
Top reviews
Top reviews from Australia
There are 0 reviews and 0 ratings from Australia
Top reviews from other countries
TheUnseendimension
5.0 out of 5 stars Great references for any thinking theist
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 29 April 2019
Verified Purchase
For the theist, this collection of works carefully compiled by Francis and team should give you reason to be confident in your beliefs beyond just the personal/spiritual experiences you may have had or not as the case may be. For the atheist who is willing to follow the evidence where it leads and honest enough, this should raise some important questions to ponder on.
Some of the chosen writers not the easiest to comprehend but good thing is the book has several views from different writers on the same subject which is just brilliant.
Report abuse
Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Well researched and informative
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 25 March 2016
Verified Purchase
Well researched and informative
Report abuse
Don Munro
5.0 out of 5 stars Great reading and gives Christians greater knowledge when dealing with hard questions.
Reviewed in Canada on 13 May 2016
Verified Purchase
I really enjoy reading this book. Francis Collins was an atheist and became a Christian. He also covers the views of Many of histories great minds and their views on Christianity. You can check it out on Amazon.
One person found this helpful
Report abuse
Mr. B. Shepherd
5.0 out of 5 stars Thoroughly enjoyable, and highly recommended.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 June 2010
Verified Purchase
Any anthology of this sort is bound to draw argument and disapproval from some. The book itself is a compilation of extracted chapters from over 30 author's major works.

Whilst the major argument is bound to centre on weather a certain piece should have been included or whether another article would have been better suited the book has more than enough to cater for everyone's individual tastes, no matter how varied. For me, the highlights included:

St Anselm - God as being that which nothing greater can be conceived
Blaise Pascal - On Pascal's Wager
Keith Ward - On the irrationality of `religion' as a construct
Desmond Tutu - On suffering and Nelson Mandela
Timothy Keller - On justice and misconceptions
Martin Luther King - On human dignity
Paul Brand - On his experiences as a medical surgeon
John Polkinghorne - On the correlation between science and faith
Mother Teresa - On human kindness
Anthony Flew - On rationality, and following the argument wherever it goes

For me these articles stood out amongst the rest, however, for others I'm sure different articles would be listed.

The book itself is nicely presented, in good size front. Each essay is designed to be read in a singular sitting, and therefore none of the essays are particularly long. At the start of each article Collins gives an introduction to the author and the piece included. The purpose of the book is to highlight intellectual theism and the rationality of faith.

Whether the arguments made convince you is irrelevant. Rather as Alister McGrath says: "the hallmark of intelligence is not whether one believes in God or not, but the quality of the processes that underlie one's beliefs". Thus this book is all about the processes that underlie belief.

Overall I was thoroughly pleased by the book itself and found it highly enjoyable. It's definitely a book I'll keep as I'll no doubt revisit certain articles at different points. On this basis I give the book 5 stars and a thorough recommendation to all.
Read less
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
S. Meadows
3.0 out of 5 stars Mixed blessings
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 27 April 2010
Verified Purchase
As with any anthology of writings, this is going to be hit and miss. There are some outstanding sections in here that has prompted me to read the full books from which extracts are taken, and there are some that leave you wondering what the point of their inclusion was. The standout writings are those by Tom Wright and Deitrich Bonhoeffer. It was almost inevitable that Alister Mcgrath would have to be included, but the selection that was used was not his best. Perhaps his chapter on faith in "Dawkins' God" would have been a better choice. The early part of the book is tough-going and took several re-reads to fully grasp the arguments.

Is it good? Undoubtedly. Is it likely to convince many people to alter their views? Probably not.

A worthwhile read, but The Language of God remains Collins' best work to date.
One person found this helpful
================
Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith
 Want to Read
Rate this book
1 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
Preview
Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith
by Francis S. Collins
 3.96  ·   Rating details ·  216 ratings  ·  20 reviews
"Is there a God?" is the most central and profound question that humans ask. With the New Atheists gaining a loud voice in today's world, it is time to revisit the long-standing intellectual tradition on the side of faith. Francis Collins, New York Times bestselling author of The Language of God and renowned physician and geneticist, defends the reason for faith in this provocative collection. Collins is our guide as he takes us through the writings of many of the world's greatest thinkers -- philosophers, preachers, poets, scientists -- both past and present, including such luminaries as C. S. Lewis and Augustine, and unexpected voices such as John Locke and Dorothy Sayers. Despite the doubts of a cynical world, this essential companion proves once and for all the rationality of faith.

"In the twenty-first century, many seem to have concluded that the spiritual experience and the life of the mind ought to occupy separate domains, and that disruptions, conflicts, and disenchantments will result if the firewall comes down. Surely humanity's ongoing search for truth is not enriched by such limitations. In the words of Socrates, the key to a fully mature and richly rewarding life, both for us as individuals and as a society, is to ‘follow the argument wherever it leads,' unafraid of the consequences. If this collection of essays provides even a small encouragement in this direction for the seeker, the believer, or the skeptic, that will be gratifying indeed." -- from the Introduction (less)
GET A COPY
KoboOnline Stores ▾Book Links ▾
Hardcover, 352 pages
Published March 2nd 2010 by HarperOne (first published 2010)
ISBN0061787345 (ISBN13: 9780061787348)
Edition LanguageEnglish
Literary AwardsSan Francisco Book Festival for Compilations/Anthologies (2010)
Other Editions (2)
Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith 
Little Book of Belief
All Editions | Add a New Edition | Combine
...Less DetailEdit Details
EditMY ACTIVITY
Review of ISBN 9780061787348
Rating
1 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
Shelves to-read edit
( 1073rd )
Format Hardcover edit
Status
October 19, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
October 19, 2021 – Shelved
Review Write a review
 
comment
FRIEND REVIEWS
Recommend This Book None of your friends have reviewed this book yet.
READER Q&A
Ask the Goodreads community a question about Belief
54355902. uy100 cr1,0,100,100 
Ask anything about the book
Be the first to ask a question about Belief

LISTS WITH THIS BOOK
The Language of God by Francis S. CollinsGod's Undertaker by John C. LennoxThe Evolution of Gods by Ajay KansalThe Triple Path by James Kenneth RogersThe Great Partnership God, Science and the Search for Meaning by Jonathan Sacks
Science and Faith
73 books — 28 voters
Mere Christianity by C.S. LewisThe Bible Unfiltered by Michael S. HeiserThe Lost World of Scripture by John H. WaltonThe Works of His Hands by Sy GarteThe Forgotten Trinity by James R. White
Elegant Christianity
115 books — 4 voters


More lists with this book...
COMMUNITY REVIEWS
Showing 1-30
 Average rating3.96  ·  Rating details ·  216 ratings  ·  20 reviews

Search review text


All Languages
More filters | Sort order
Sejin,
Sejin, start your review of Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith

Write a review
Stephanie
Jun 30, 2010Stephanie rated it it was amazing
Shelves: read-2010, christian-nf
Belief-Francis S. Collins
HarperOne, 2010
312 pages
Essays; Inspirational

Source: Library

Summary: An anthology exploring faith and visiting the works of many brillaint thinkers including those expected as CS Lewis and St. Augustine as well as the unexpected like Dorothy Sayers.

Thoughts: The book is divided in to different sections with essays relating to a particular theme are grouped together. Originally I was just going to share my favorites but since I loved almost all of them, I decided to go through each and highlight particular thoughts. The first is a selection from NT Wright introducing thoughts on justice and spirituality. I enjoyed it a lot.

The second section is classic essays about faith from such philosophers as Plato, Augustine, and Pascal. I had a lot of trouble reading these because the style is so different from what I'm used to. The nice thing about this book though is that you can skip around and just read however much you want. I struggled through these difficult sections though and I think I learned a lot.

The third section is called "The Meaning of Truth" and this was a very good section, probably my second favorite. OS Guinness has a beautiful selection from his book Time for Truth which has jumped on to my to-read list. Madeleine L'Engle takes a personal approach to truth, sharing many examples from her own life. And Dorothy L Sayers (probably best known for her Lord Peter mysteries) wrote an entertaining essay including a "review" of the book of John and ending with a poem on truth.

Then there is "Loving God With All Your Mind" goes back to the Scripture: "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind" -Matthew 22:37 and stresses the last which has a tendency to be overlooked.

Next "Faith and the Problem of Evil and Suffering," which was probably my favorite section and the one that hit me the most. Art Lindsley, Desmond Tutu, and Elie Wiesel wrote so clearly and made so much sense to me. I don't want to blather about it but it was good.

"Faith and the Cry of Justice" was also a good section as it shows the ways in which the church has failed to respond to injustice but also how it has fought for it.

"The Harmony of Science and Faith" was an important section for me. It features two selections from two physicians who have wrestled with the intersection of science and faith. My college Christian community has struggled with spreading the Word because of the presumed gap between science and faith expressed by many college students.

"Miracles, Longing, and Mysticism" features CS Lewis among others, making this a fabulous section. Lewis's essay is about miracles and our perceptions around such. Alister McGrath incorporated excerpts from stories about two of my favorite detectives and Thomas Merton shared briefly about mysticism.

Then we have "Love and Forgiveness as Pointers to God" with selections from Dietrich Bonhoeffer who was killed by the Nazis and Viktor Frankl who survived four Nazi concentration camps inspiring me with their deep insights. Mother Teresa also has several writings that convict me of selfishness to finish out the chapter.

"Voices from the East" has selections from Gandhi and the Dalai Lama, offering different perspectives on faith informed by their experiences in the East rather than the Western mindset of most of the other contributors.

The last section is titled "The Irrationality of Atheism" and was one I was particularly intrigued by. But I interpreted the title differently. I was hoping for more of an apologetic approach while they showed logical inconsistencies and flaws in the atheistic approaches.

Overall: I'm feeling pretty good about this so I'm going to say 5/5.

Cover: I was attracted by the simple orange spine peeking out at me on the shelves. I'm not entirely sure why orange but it is an unconventional choice.
(less)
flag3 likes · Like  · comment · see review
Callum Iles
Jul 11, 2011Callum Iles rated it really liked it
The three hundred of so pages contained within the bindings of Belief have changed the world and continue to do so each day. The insights compiled are the foundations of modern day Christian belief, and take the reader from Ancient Greece to post-World-War-2 England to the American civil rights movement to Nazi Germany and to the heights of Tibet.
No review could do justice to the messages of the 33 brilliant minds, but I will highlight a few that inspired and broadened my thinking. N.T. Wright clearly and directly sets the scene with a look at the need for belief while Blaise Pascal brings his mathematical logic to the argument of human reasoning. Madeleine L’Engle shows her depth of insight by explaining the importance of emphasizing the Truth found in Christianity rather than just reducing it to a series of facts. We are then challenged by pastor Timothy Keller who reveals how, many problems people have with the church today are legitimate and much of the church agrees with them, however without the strength of the church, many more injustices would have continued. Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s teaching calls all to love and exemplifies the heart behind his ultimate sacrifice, and Alvin Plantinga’s sojourn on the irrationality of naturalism brings a childhood simplicity to an adult argument.
One important thing to note is that even amongst these amazing thinkers, the writings of C.S. Lewis standout like a city on a hill. His eloquence, clarity of thought, humility and authority show much of why he is revered as the pinnacle of Christian thought.
I thoroughly recommend this to anyone who wants to be subjected to new names in Christian and secular philosophy. There is hope, insight and joy contained in Belief and you will come away with a new found precision as to why exactly you believe.
(less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Katia
Sep 15, 2010Katia rated it liked it
Shelves: non-fiction, religion
I randomly saw this on the nonfiction shelf at my library and was eager to give it a read, as I've been on a nonfiction/religion/philosophy kick lately. I have to admit that I only made it through about 65% of the essays, as some of them were too abstruse for my liking. I expected the general theme to be more of an examination of the reasonS why faith and God are such an important part of life, not the reasonING as to why they do/do not exist. I've never been great at logic problems, and some of the inclusions in this book were convoluted or hard to get into for my casual nighttime or lunchtime reading. I think if I was to pore through it slowly at my own pace I would greatly appreciate all of the selections, but because it's a library book I needed to return it by the due date (after already renewing it once!) That being said, I really enjoyed most of the pieces I did read, especially those from Madeleine L'Engle, C.S. Lewis, Mother Theresa, and the foreword by Francis Collins. Overall, I wish I could give it 3 1/2 stars. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Ryan
Mar 29, 2010Ryan rated it liked it
This anthology of arguments for belief in God focuses mainly on the Western/Christian concept of deity; however, there are a few selections from Jewish and Eastern perspectives. The book covers a very wide arena. While all of the writings argue for belief in deity, they do not all have the same concept of deity. The various arguments for belief are inconsistent in their epistemology and ontology. There is also some inconstancy among these authors in their definition of the divine. Considering everything, Collins has produced a very thought-provoking anthology; nevertheless, it falls short in its ambition to present a consistent argument for belief in the supernatural. Critical readers will find that many of the arguments presented are simply fallacious while others are unfalsifiable, vague, and confusing. I enjoyed this book but I think it raises more questions and doubts than it does answers. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Ryan Manns
Nov 28, 2011Ryan Manns rated it really liked it
Shelves: religion
This is a great collection of essays to have for anyone who believes in God. Great ideas from not only Christians but also from Jewish and Eastern religions. Some of the essays were a little hard to follow in the "Classic Arguments" chapter, and some others felt a little out of place but overall it was worth the read. For anyone who wants to know the best essays were the ones written by Madeleine L'Engle, Art Lindsley, Elie Wiesel, John Polkinghorne, C.S. Lewis, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Gandhi, The Dalai Lama, Alvin Plantinga, and Antony Flew. So if you don't have time to read all the book but want a taste of it these are the essays I would recommend for anyone. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Jim Gleason
Sep 23, 2021Jim Gleason rated it it was ok
Shelves: current-affairs, historical, faith-based, religious, spiritual
I could only get so far with this book, placed in my library by my wife's download to our library, not a personal choice. I began with high hopes given the variety of writers on this very meaningful and interesting topic, but, despite giving it a real try, I can't stay interested at the level needed for follow the logical writings of so many famous deep thinkers on the subject. So, as I've recently learned the term, 'DNF' I confess that I DNF's this book. (where DNF means 'Did not finish' if that term is new to you as it was to me) (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Preston
Aug 26, 2017Preston rated it really liked it
This book is a collection of persuasive essays and excerpts arguing the existence of God. I am very fond of seeing logical and scientific arguments on both sides of this debate, and consequently really enjoyed reading this.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Drew
Jul 14, 2012Drew rated it it was amazing
Shelves: religion, philosophy
Belief sets out to demonstrate that "faith" and "reason" (as they are commonly talked about) are not opposed to each other. By presenting powerful writings from several different authors, it aims to undo that perception. People need not abandon their rationality to embrace a religious view. Even if someone ends up disagreeing with the conclusions of the various authors, and remains skeptical, they cannot possibly say the authors are not engaging with their own reason. There is room for respectful dialogue and debate on these issues.

The best part about this collection is that it introduced me to many new writers: John Polkinghorne, Dorothy Sayers, Os Guinness, John Stott, Madeleine L'Engle, and Tim Keller to name a few. It also introduced me to ideas from people I already love to be familiar with.

One of the first sections contained "Classical Arguments" and classical writers. The difference in writing style from their time period struck me. For one, the confidence that Augustine, Anselm of Canterbury, Thomas Aquinas, and John Locke had in asserting God's existence was extraordinary, compared to many contemporary voices. Secondly, these pieces especially forced me to read and consider them slowly. But this was likely a positive thing, since it seemed to sharpen my mind, as with any other "older" books that take us out of our immediate context. That alone should make their inclusion worthwhile. (The historical value was also neat to observe, especially when it comes to the influence of Plato and Aristotle on Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, and the Middle Ages in general.)

"The Meaning of Truth" section was particularly important. Os Guinness' countering of post-modern attempts to downgrade the status of Truth, Madeleine L'Engle's observation that truth is often reduced to only mere facts, and Dorothy Sayers' synthesis of Biblical and secular history possess remarkable insights to how (post-)moderns think.

A number of pieces were not only intended to challenge skeptics and answer objections to belief, but also to challenge believers. Paired with the importance of seeking Truth, entries like John Stott's claim that Christians especially cannot slack off on using their minds and developing the intellect.
Tim Keller responds to believers-behaving-badly by stating that they fall pitiably short of their creed and ideals. The legendary Martin Luther King, Jr., Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Mother Teresa spur us Christians (which, not to mention the Jewish Elie Wiesel and Hindu Gandhi) to actively and tirelessly work and perhaps endure hardship and even suffering for a just cause.

As already mentioned, there were a few non-Christian sources (Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Pagan) provided for the reader. Although they seemed somewhat awkwardly included, they proved valuable nonetheless (such as the Dalai Lama's approach on modern science). I personally wish there had been more included, since it can be beneficial for anyone to consider figures outside of their own faith, and also because it is enlightening to see how much agreement we can find with such people.

Finally, although the collection as a whole never dismisses rationality or science (since that would undermine its very case), certain authors take pains to point out how separate philosophical ideas are often smuggled in with scientific work or "modern progress". Former atheist Antony Flew, G.K. Chesterton, and the Dalai Lama make the general point, Alvin Plantinga does this with Evolution, and Hans Küng looks at Psychology. Finally, John Polkinghorne, both a physicist and Anglican clergyman, presents a sophisticated religious approach to science.

By organizing this, Francis Collins has made a strong contribution to this area of thought. It is not only a library of considerable intelligence, but it is a grand gateway to many of these authors and more. Perhaps its chief value is renewing interest and grounds for discussion in the ordinary people who seek to live the examined life. I highly recommend it for anyone interested in exploring the Big Questions, and who like to keep their head while admiring the lofty heavens. (less)
flagLike  · see review
Giedra
Nov 25, 2011Giedra rated it liked it
Enjoyed this collection of readings from a variety of sources--from Plato and Thomas Aquinas to Madeleine L'Engle and Martin Luther King, Jr. to Desmond Tutu and Gandhi.

The readings are divided into following sections:

Classic Arguments for Faith and Reason
The Meaning of Truth
Loving God with All Your Mind
Faith and the Problem of Evil and Suffering
Faith and the Cry for Justice
The Harmony of Science and Faith
Miracles, Longing, and Mysticism
Love and Forgiveness as Pointers to God
Voices from the East
The Irrationality of Atheism

I think my favorite selections were those by Desmond Tutu (an excerpt from his book God Has a Dream, entitled God Believes in Us), Martin Luther King, Jr. (a sermon called "A Tough Mind and a Tender Heart"), and Gandhi.


A few quotes/gleanings:

Tim Keller: "Alister McGrath points out that when the idea of God is gone, a society will 'transcendentalize" something else, some other concept, in order to appear morally and spiritually superior. The Marxists made the State into such an absolute, while the Nazis did it to race and blood. Even the ideals of liberty and equality can be used in this way in order to do violence to opponents.....[then quotes Madame Roland during French Revolution saying Liberty, what crimes are committed in your name]"

Tim Keller: idea that fanatics are not those that are too committed to the gospel, but those that are not committed enough. They are fanatically zealous, but "not fanatically humble, sensitive, loving, empathetic, forgiving, or understanding--as Christ was." Fanatics are often Pharisaical.

MLK, Jr.: "The softminded man always fears change. He feels security in the status quo, and he has an almost morbid fear of the new....Softmindedness often invades religion. This is why religion has sometimes rejected new truth with a dogmatic passion..... A nation or a civilization that continues to produce softminded men purchases its own spiritual death on an installment plan.... But we must not stop with the cultivation of a tough mind. The gospel also demands a tender heart.... The hardhearted person never truly loves..., lacks the capacity for genuine compassion... He depersonalizes life.... Nonviolent resistance...combines toughmindedness and tenderheartedness and avoids the complacency and do-nothingness of the softminded and the violence and bitterness of the hardhearted."

John Polkinghorne: In discussion on harmony between science and faith, he discusses how rationality does not take a single form, becuase of the diversity of reality, citing the vast differences in the character of the quantum world compared to that of the everyday world of Newtonian physics. As he puts it, "Quantum entities have to be known on their own terms and in accordance with their idiosyncratic rationality. It would scarcely be surprising if similar considerations applied to knowledge of the divine."

John Polkinghorne: "Human history and individual introspection both show that there is something awry with humanity."

Alister McGrath quoting Tennyson from poem "The Ancient Sage":
For nothing worthy proving can be proven,
nor yet disproven: wherefore thou be wise,
cleave ever to the sunnier side of doubt.

G.K. Chesterton: "But what we suffer from to-day is humility in the wrong place... A man was meant to be doubtful about himself, but undoubting about the truth; this has been exactly reversed. Nowadays the part of a man that a man does assert is exactly the part he ought not to assert--himself. The part he doubts is exactly the part he ought not to doubt--the Divine Reason... The old humility made a man doubtful about his efforts, which might make him work harder. But the new humility makes a man doubtful about his aims, which will make him stop working altogether." "Scoffers of old time were too proud to be convinced; but these are too humble to be convinced." (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Brian
Sep 25, 2014Brian rated it really liked it
Shelves: religious, science
Dr. Collins states in the introduction: "The increasingly secular Western world seems to be loosing touch with the long history of intellectual arguments supporting a rational basis for faith." Personally, I see no conflict (actually just the opposite) between the truth I see in nature (including evolution) and belief in the God of Abraham. The conflict we see today is largely, in my opinion, contrived by lazy "scientists" and religious leaders to help them maintain control and wealth.

Belief is a collection of writings from thoughtful men and women throughout the ages. It begins with Plato, goes through other classical writers (Thomas Aquinas, John Locke, Blaine Pascal, etc) then goes to western writers from the last 150 years (Desmond Tutu, Elie Weisel, Martin Luther King, Jr., etc) and then goes to eastern voices (Ghandi, Dali Lama, etc) who, using reason, explain the basis for their faith-based belief system.

Ultimately, this collection of writings demonstrates that one can be both a believer in God and intellectually intact - these two options are not mutually exclusive.

The language of some of these intellectual giants was beyond me at times, but reading it was a good exercise. This book is must reading for all thoughtful people. (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Lawyer
Mar 25, 2010Lawyer rated it really liked it
Recommended to Lawyer by: found browing at Barnes and Noble
Shelves: religion, science, faith-and-reason, philosophy
A wonderful anthology of spiritual readings addressing the seeming conflicts between faith and reason. The selections are drawn from classics of Christianity to voices from Eastern religions. Many selections are worthy of multiple readings to capture the precise arguments made by the various authors, from Augustine to the Dalai Llama. If you find Dawkins, Hitchens and Co. cold and strident, you will appreciate Francis Collins careful structuring of this very good anthology. Collins' introductory remarks to each selection are helpful aids for interpretation of a number of the readings. (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Maggie
Jul 07, 2011Maggie rated it it was amazing
Shelves: essay-collection, non-fiction, science, secular-inspirational
a most worthy collection of smart writings on the persistent idea that faith and reason are not in conflict and furthermore that religion and science are not in conflict. francis s. collins is the current director of the human genome project. my most recent learning during this current crash course on this alleged conflict area (religion and science) is "genetic fallacy" ... time to get that one in hand for sure! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_...
(less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Shana
Feb 07, 2014Shana rated it really liked it
the writings of incredibly intelligent, even brilliant, people fill this book. it was a great challenge for my brain. i confess i skipped a bit towards the end, though. i got the gist of what most were saying and it was very encouraging to read - however challenging. i would definitely recommend to anyone.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Frank Peters
Jul 02, 2011Frank Peters rated it really liked it
The book is a collection of essays on belief in God. Collins did a really good job in putting them together, and in covering a large amount of territory. A few articles were sufficiently good and interesting that I had to inflict them on my wife and one of my sons. I am now tempted to purchase books by some of the authors that I have never read before.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Shawn Tickle
May 19, 2013Shawn Tickle rated it really liked it
Shelves: francis-s-collins
Very useful little anthology filled with insightful selections that do not typically appear in other works of this kind. So, this is not just a repetition of selections I have already read in other anthologies.
flagLike  · comment · see review
John
Jan 24, 2016John rated it liked it
A good book. It is not overly detailed, as the work is a collection of essays and chapters from other famous works, but it is interesting. If you are looking for a light read about why faith is plausible, you may want to check this book out.
flagLike  · comment · see review
===



====
Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith
by Francis S. Collins
 3.96  ·   Rating details ·  216 ratings  ·  20 reviews
"Is there a God?" is the most central and profound question that humans ask. With the New Atheists gaining a loud voice in today's world, it is time to revisit the long-standing intellectual tradition on the side of faith. Francis Collins, New York Times bestselling author of The Language of God and renowned physician and geneticist, defends the reason for faith in this provocative collection. Collins is our guide as he takes us through the writings of many of the world's greatest thinkers -- philosophers, preachers, poets, scientists -- both past and present, including such luminaries as C. S. Lewis and Augustine, and unexpected voices such as John Locke and Dorothy Sayers. Despite the doubts of a cynical world, this essential companion proves once and for all the rationality of faith.

"In the twenty-first century, many seem to have concluded that the spiritual experience and the life of the mind ought to occupy separate domains, and that disruptions, conflicts, and disenchantments will result if the firewall comes down. Surely humanity's ongoing search for truth is not enriched by such limitations. In the words of Socrates, the key to a fully mature and richly rewarding life, both for us as individuals and as a society, is to ‘follow the argument wherever it leads,' unafraid of the consequences. If this collection of essays provides even a small encouragement in this direction for the seeker, the believer, or the skeptic, that will be gratifying indeed." -- from the Introduction (less)
GET A COPY
KoboOnline Stores ▾Book Links ▾
Hardcover, 352 pages
Published March 2nd 2010 by HarperOne (first published 2010)
ISBN0061787345 (ISBN13: 9780061787348)
Edition LanguageEnglish
Literary AwardsSan Francisco Book Festival for Compilations/Anthologies (2010)
Other Editions (2)
Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith 
Little Book of Belief
All Editions | Add a New Edition | Combine
...Less DetailEdit Details
EditMY ACTIVITY
Review of ISBN 9780061787348
Rating
1 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
Shelves to-read edit
( 1073rd )
Format Hardcover edit
Status
October 19, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
October 19, 2021 – Shelved
Review Write a review
 
comment
FRIEND REVIEWS
Recommend This Book None of your friends have reviewed this book yet.
READER Q&A
Ask the Goodreads community a question about Belief
54355902. uy100 cr1,0,100,100 
Ask anything about the book
Be the first to ask a question about Belief

LISTS WITH THIS BOOK
The Language of God by Francis S. CollinsGod's Undertaker by John C. LennoxThe Evolution of Gods by Ajay KansalThe Triple Path by James Kenneth RogersThe Great Partnership God, Science and the Search for Meaning by Jonathan Sacks
Science and Faith
73 books — 28 voters
Mere Christianity by C.S. LewisThe Bible Unfiltered by Michael S. HeiserThe Lost World of Scripture by John H. WaltonThe Works of His Hands by Sy GarteThe Forgotten Trinity by James R. White
Elegant Christianity
115 books — 4 voters


More lists with this book...
COMMUNITY REVIEWS
Showing 1-30
 Average rating3.96  ·  Rating details ·  216 ratings  ·  20 reviews

Search review text


All Languages
More filters | Sort order
Sejin,
Sejin, start your review of Belief: Readings on the Reason for Faith

Write a review
Stephanie
Jun 30, 2010Stephanie rated it it was amazing
Shelves: read-2010, christian-nf
Belief-Francis S. Collins
HarperOne, 2010
312 pages
Essays; Inspirational

Source: Library

Summary: An anthology exploring faith and visiting the works of many brillaint thinkers including those expected as CS Lewis and St. Augustine as well as the unexpected like Dorothy Sayers.

Thoughts: The book is divided in to different sections with essays relating to a particular theme are grouped together. Originally I was just going to share my favorites but since I loved almost all of them, I decided to go through each and highlight particular thoughts. The first is a selection from NT Wright introducing thoughts on justice and spirituality. I enjoyed it a lot.

The second section is classic essays about faith from such philosophers as Plato, Augustine, and Pascal. I had a lot of trouble reading these because the style is so different from what I'm used to. The nice thing about this book though is that you can skip around and just read however much you want. I struggled through these difficult sections though and I think I learned a lot.

The third section is called "The Meaning of Truth" and this was a very good section, probably my second favorite. OS Guinness has a beautiful selection from his book Time for Truth which has jumped on to my to-read list. Madeleine L'Engle takes a personal approach to truth, sharing many examples from her own life. And Dorothy L Sayers (probably best known for her Lord Peter mysteries) wrote an entertaining essay including a "review" of the book of John and ending with a poem on truth.

Then there is "Loving God With All Your Mind" goes back to the Scripture: "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind" -Matthew 22:37 and stresses the last which has a tendency to be overlooked.

Next "Faith and the Problem of Evil and Suffering," which was probably my favorite section and the one that hit me the most. Art Lindsley, Desmond Tutu, and Elie Wiesel wrote so clearly and made so much sense to me. I don't want to blather about it but it was good.

"Faith and the Cry of Justice" was also a good section as it shows the ways in which the church has failed to respond to injustice but also how it has fought for it.

"The Harmony of Science and Faith" was an important section for me. It features two selections from two physicians who have wrestled with the intersection of science and faith. My college Christian community has struggled with spreading the Word because of the presumed gap between science and faith expressed by many college students.

"Miracles, Longing, and Mysticism" features CS Lewis among others, making this a fabulous section. Lewis's essay is about miracles and our perceptions around such. Alister McGrath incorporated excerpts from stories about two of my favorite detectives and Thomas Merton shared briefly about mysticism.

Then we have "Love and Forgiveness as Pointers to God" with selections from Dietrich Bonhoeffer who was killed by the Nazis and Viktor Frankl who survived four Nazi concentration camps inspiring me with their deep insights. Mother Teresa also has several writings that convict me of selfishness to finish out the chapter.

"Voices from the East" has selections from Gandhi and the Dalai Lama, offering different perspectives on faith informed by their experiences in the East rather than the Western mindset of most of the other contributors.

The last section is titled "The Irrationality of Atheism" and was one I was particularly intrigued by. But I interpreted the title differently. I was hoping for more of an apologetic approach while they showed logical inconsistencies and flaws in the atheistic approaches.

Overall: I'm feeling pretty good about this so I'm going to say 5/5.

Cover: I was attracted by the simple orange spine peeking out at me on the shelves. I'm not entirely sure why orange but it is an unconventional choice.
(less)
flag3 likes · Like  · comment · see review
Callum Iles
Jul 11, 2011Callum Iles rated it really liked it
The three hundred of so pages contained within the bindings of Belief have changed the world and continue to do so each day. The insights compiled are the foundations of modern day Christian belief, and take the reader from Ancient Greece to post-World-War-2 England to the American civil rights movement to Nazi Germany and to the heights of Tibet.
No review could do justice to the messages of the 33 brilliant minds, but I will highlight a few that inspired and broadened my thinking. N.T. Wright clearly and directly sets the scene with a look at the need for belief while Blaise Pascal brings his mathematical logic to the argument of human reasoning. Madeleine L’Engle shows her depth of insight by explaining the importance of emphasizing the Truth found in Christianity rather than just reducing it to a series of facts. We are then challenged by pastor Timothy Keller who reveals how, many problems people have with the church today are legitimate and much of the church agrees with them, however without the strength of the church, many more injustices would have continued. Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s teaching calls all to love and exemplifies the heart behind his ultimate sacrifice, and Alvin Plantinga’s sojourn on the irrationality of naturalism brings a childhood simplicity to an adult argument.
One important thing to note is that even amongst these amazing thinkers, the writings of C.S. Lewis standout like a city on a hill. His eloquence, clarity of thought, humility and authority show much of why he is revered as the pinnacle of Christian thought.
I thoroughly recommend this to anyone who wants to be subjected to new names in Christian and secular philosophy. There is hope, insight and joy contained in Belief and you will come away with a new found precision as to why exactly you believe.
(less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Katia
Sep 15, 2010Katia rated it liked it
Shelves: non-fiction, religion
I randomly saw this on the nonfiction shelf at my library and was eager to give it a read, as I've been on a nonfiction/religion/philosophy kick lately. I have to admit that I only made it through about 65% of the essays, as some of them were too abstruse for my liking. I expected the general theme to be more of an examination of the reasonS why faith and God are such an important part of life, not the reasonING as to why they do/do not exist. I've never been great at logic problems, and some of the inclusions in this book were convoluted or hard to get into for my casual nighttime or lunchtime reading. I think if I was to pore through it slowly at my own pace I would greatly appreciate all of the selections, but because it's a library book I needed to return it by the due date (after already renewing it once!) That being said, I really enjoyed most of the pieces I did read, especially those from Madeleine L'Engle, C.S. Lewis, Mother Theresa, and the foreword by Francis Collins. Overall, I wish I could give it 3 1/2 stars. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Ryan
Mar 29, 2010Ryan rated it liked it
This anthology of arguments for belief in God focuses mainly on the Western/Christian concept of deity; however, there are a few selections from Jewish and Eastern perspectives. The book covers a very wide arena. While all of the writings argue for belief in deity, they do not all have the same concept of deity. The various arguments for belief are inconsistent in their epistemology and ontology. There is also some inconstancy among these authors in their definition of the divine. Considering everything, Collins has produced a very thought-provoking anthology; nevertheless, it falls short in its ambition to present a consistent argument for belief in the supernatural. Critical readers will find that many of the arguments presented are simply fallacious while others are unfalsifiable, vague, and confusing. I enjoyed this book but I think it raises more questions and doubts than it does answers. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Ryan Manns
Nov 28, 2011Ryan Manns rated it really liked it
Shelves: religion
This is a great collection of essays to have for anyone who believes in God. Great ideas from not only Christians but also from Jewish and Eastern religions. Some of the essays were a little hard to follow in the "Classic Arguments" chapter, and some others felt a little out of place but overall it was worth the read. For anyone who wants to know the best essays were the ones written by Madeleine L'Engle, Art Lindsley, Elie Wiesel, John Polkinghorne, C.S. Lewis, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Gandhi, The Dalai Lama, Alvin Plantinga, and Antony Flew. So if you don't have time to read all the book but want a taste of it these are the essays I would recommend for anyone. (less)
flag1 like · Like  · comment · see review
Jim Gleason
Sep 23, 2021Jim Gleason rated it it was ok
Shelves: current-affairs, historical, faith-based, religious, spiritual
I could only get so far with this book, placed in my library by my wife's download to our library, not a personal choice. I began with high hopes given the variety of writers on this very meaningful and interesting topic, but, despite giving it a real try, I can't stay interested at the level needed for follow the logical writings of so many famous deep thinkers on the subject. So, as I've recently learned the term, 'DNF' I confess that I DNF's this book. (where DNF means 'Did not finish' if that term is new to you as it was to me) (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Preston
Aug 26, 2017Preston rated it really liked it
This book is a collection of persuasive essays and excerpts arguing the existence of God. I am very fond of seeing logical and scientific arguments on both sides of this debate, and consequently really enjoyed reading this.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Drew
Jul 14, 2012Drew rated it it was amazing
Shelves: religion, philosophy
Belief sets out to demonstrate that "faith" and "reason" (as they are commonly talked about) are not opposed to each other. By presenting powerful writings from several different authors, it aims to undo that perception. People need not abandon their rationality to embrace a religious view. Even if someone ends up disagreeing with the conclusions of the various authors, and remains skeptical, they cannot possibly say the authors are not engaging with their own reason. There is room for respectful dialogue and debate on these issues.

The best part about this collection is that it introduced me to many new writers: John Polkinghorne, Dorothy Sayers, Os Guinness, John Stott, Madeleine L'Engle, and Tim Keller to name a few. It also introduced me to ideas from people I already love to be familiar with.

One of the first sections contained "Classical Arguments" and classical writers. The difference in writing style from their time period struck me. For one, the confidence that Augustine, Anselm of Canterbury, Thomas Aquinas, and John Locke had in asserting God's existence was extraordinary, compared to many contemporary voices. Secondly, these pieces especially forced me to read and consider them slowly. But this was likely a positive thing, since it seemed to sharpen my mind, as with any other "older" books that take us out of our immediate context. That alone should make their inclusion worthwhile. (The historical value was also neat to observe, especially when it comes to the influence of Plato and Aristotle on Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, and the Middle Ages in general.)

"The Meaning of Truth" section was particularly important. Os Guinness' countering of post-modern attempts to downgrade the status of Truth, Madeleine L'Engle's observation that truth is often reduced to only mere facts, and Dorothy Sayers' synthesis of Biblical and secular history possess remarkable insights to how (post-)moderns think.

A number of pieces were not only intended to challenge skeptics and answer objections to belief, but also to challenge believers. Paired with the importance of seeking Truth, entries like John Stott's claim that Christians especially cannot slack off on using their minds and developing the intellect.
Tim Keller responds to believers-behaving-badly by stating that they fall pitiably short of their creed and ideals. The legendary Martin Luther King, Jr., Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Mother Teresa spur us Christians (which, not to mention the Jewish Elie Wiesel and Hindu Gandhi) to actively and tirelessly work and perhaps endure hardship and even suffering for a just cause.

As already mentioned, there were a few non-Christian sources (Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Pagan) provided for the reader. Although they seemed somewhat awkwardly included, they proved valuable nonetheless (such as the Dalai Lama's approach on modern science). I personally wish there had been more included, since it can be beneficial for anyone to consider figures outside of their own faith, and also because it is enlightening to see how much agreement we can find with such people.

Finally, although the collection as a whole never dismisses rationality or science (since that would undermine its very case), certain authors take pains to point out how separate philosophical ideas are often smuggled in with scientific work or "modern progress". Former atheist Antony Flew, G.K. Chesterton, and the Dalai Lama make the general point, Alvin Plantinga does this with Evolution, and Hans Küng looks at Psychology. Finally, John Polkinghorne, both a physicist and Anglican clergyman, presents a sophisticated religious approach to science.

By organizing this, Francis Collins has made a strong contribution to this area of thought. It is not only a library of considerable intelligence, but it is a grand gateway to many of these authors and more. Perhaps its chief value is renewing interest and grounds for discussion in the ordinary people who seek to live the examined life. I highly recommend it for anyone interested in exploring the Big Questions, and who like to keep their head while admiring the lofty heavens. (less)
flagLike  · see review
Giedra
Nov 25, 2011Giedra rated it liked it
Enjoyed this collection of readings from a variety of sources--from Plato and Thomas Aquinas to Madeleine L'Engle and Martin Luther King, Jr. to Desmond Tutu and Gandhi.

The readings are divided into following sections:

Classic Arguments for Faith and Reason
The Meaning of Truth
Loving God with All Your Mind
Faith and the Problem of Evil and Suffering
Faith and the Cry for Justice
The Harmony of Science and Faith
Miracles, Longing, and Mysticism
Love and Forgiveness as Pointers to God
Voices from the Ea ...more
flagLike  · comment · see review
Brian
Sep 25, 2014Brian rated it really liked it
Shelves: religious, science
Dr. Collins states in the introduction: "The increasingly secular Western world seems to be loosing touch with the long history of intellectual arguments supporting a rational basis for faith." Personally, I see no conflict (actually just the opposite) between the truth I see in nature (including evolution) and belief in the God of Abraham. The conflict we see today is largely, in my opinion, contrived by lazy "scientists" and religious leaders to help them maintain control and wealth.

Belief is ...more
flagLike  · comment · see review
Lawyer
Mar 25, 2010Lawyer rated it really liked it
Recommended to Lawyer by: found browing at Barnes and Noble
Shelves: religion, science, faith-and-reason, philosophy
A wonderful anthology of spiritual readings addressing the seeming conflicts between faith and reason. The selections are drawn from classics of Christianity to voices from Eastern religions. Many selections are worthy of multiple readings to capture the precise arguments made by the various authors, from Augustine to the Dalai Llama. If you find Dawkins, Hitchens and Co. cold and strident, you will appreciate Francis Collins careful structuring of this very good anthology. Collins' introductory remarks to each selection are helpful aids for interpretation of a number of the readings. (less)
flagLike  · comment · see review
Maggie
Jul 07, 2011Maggie rated it it was amazing
Shelves: essay-collection, non-fiction, science, secular-inspirational
a most worthy collection of smart writings on the persistent idea that faith and reason are not in conflict and furthermore that religion and science are not in conflict. francis s. collins is the current director of the human genome project. my most recent learning during this current crash course on this alleged conflict area (religion and science) is "genetic fallacy" ... time to get that one in hand for sure! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_...
...more
flagLike  · comment · see review
Shana
Feb 07, 2014Shana rated it really liked it
the writings of incredibly intelligent, even brilliant, people fill this book. it was a great challenge for my brain. i confess i skipped a bit towards the end, though. i got the gist of what most were saying and it was very encouraging to read - however challenging. i would definitely recommend to anyone.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Frank Peters
Jul 02, 2011Frank Peters rated it really liked it
The book is a collection of essays on belief in God. Collins did a really good job in putting them together, and in covering a large amount of territory. A few articles were sufficiently good and interesting that I had to inflict them on my wife and one of my sons. I am now tempted to purchase books by some of the authors that I have never read before.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Shawn Tickle
May 19, 2013Shawn Tickle rated it really liked it
Shelves: francis-s-collins
Very useful little anthology filled with insightful selections that do not typically appear in other works of this kind. So, this is not just a repetition of selections I have already read in other anthologies.
flagLike  · comment · see review
John
Jan 24, 2016John rated it liked it
A good book. It is not overly detailed, as the work is a collection of essays and chapters from other famous works, but it is interesting. If you are looking for a light read about why faith is plausible, you may want to check this book out.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Anord
Mar 09, 2011Anord rated it it was amazing
Loved it!
flagLike  · see review
Bruce
Dec 01, 2012Bruce rated it really liked it
Great collection of writings on the subject of belief.
flagLike  · comment · see review
Shane Wagoner
Dec 26, 2013Shane Wagoner rated it it was ok
Does it bother anyone else that every one of these arguments has already been disproven ten times over or is completely off topic?...