2020/04/21

Christian mission - Wikipedia

Christian mission - Wikipedia



Christian mission

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Christian mission is an organized effort to spread Christianity to new converts.[1] Missions involve sending individuals and groups, called missionaries, across boundaries, most commonly geographical boundaries, to carry on evangelism or other activities, such as educational or hospital work.[2] Sometimes individuals are sent and are called missionaries. When groups are sent, they are often called mission teams and they do mission trips. There are a few different kinds of mission trips: short-term, long-term, relational and those that simply help people in need. Some people choose to dedicate their whole lives to mission. Missionaries have the authority to preach the Christian faith (and sometimes to administer sacraments), and provide humanitarian aid. Christian doctrines (such as the "Doctrine of Love" professed by many missions) permit the provision of aid without requiring religious conversion.

History of Christian missions[edit]

The earliest Christian mission, then, the Great Commission and Dispersion of the Apostles, was active within Second Temple Judaism. Whether a Jewish proselytism existed or not that would have served as a model for the early Christians is unclear, see Circumcision controversy in early Christianity#Jewish background for details. Soon, the expansion of the Christian mission beyond Judaism to those who were not Jewish became a contested issue, notably at the Council of Jerusalem. The Apostle Paul was an early proponent of this expansion, and contextualized the Christian message for the Greek and Roman cultures, allowing it to reach beyond its Hebrew and Jewish roots.
From Late Antiquity onward, much missionary activity was carried out by members of religious ordersMonasteries followed disciplines and supported missions, libraries, and practical research, all of which were perceived as works to reduce human misery and suffering and glorify the Christian God. For example, Nestorian communities evangelized parts of Central Asia, as well as Tibet, China, and India.[3] Cistercians evangelized much of Northern Europe, as well as developing most of European agriculture's classic techniques. St Patrick evangelized many in Ireland. St David was active in Wales.
During the Middle AgesRamon Llull (c. 1232 – c. 1315) advanced the concept of preaching to Muslims and converting them to Christianity by means of non-violent argument.[4] A vision for large-scale mission to Muslims would die with him, not to be revived until the 19th Century.
Additional events can be found at the timeline of Christian missions.

Medieval[edit]

During the Middle Ages Christian monasteries and missionaries such as Saint Patrick, and Adalbert of Prague propagated learning and religion beyond the boundaries of the old Roman Empire. In the seventh century Gregory the Great sent missionaries, including Augustine of Canterbury, into England. The Hiberno-Scottish mission began in 563.
In the late thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries, Franciscans such as William of RubruckJohn of Montecorvino, and Giovanni ed' Magnolia were sent as missionaries to the Near and Far East. Their travels took them as far as China in an attempt to convert the advancing Mongols, especially the Great Khans of the Mongol Empire. (Also see Medieval Roman Catholic Missions in China.)

Catholic missions after 1492[edit]

One of the main goals of the Christopher Columbus expedition financed by Queen Isabella of Spain was to spread Christianity. During the Age of Discovery, Spain and Portugal established many missions in their American and Asian colonies. The most active orders were the JesuitsAugustiniansFranciscans and Dominicans. The Portuguese sent missions into Africa. These are some of the most well-known missions in history. While some of these missions were associated with imperialism and oppression, others (notably Matteo Ricci's Jesuit mission to China) were relatively peaceful and focused inculturation rather than cultural imperialism.
In both Portugal and Spain, religion was an integral part of the state and evangelization was seen as having both secular and spiritual benefits. Wherever these powers attempted to expand their territories or influence, missionaries would soon follow. By the Treaty of Tordesillas, the two powers divided the world between them into exclusive spheres of influence, trade and colonization. The proselytization of Asia became linked to Portuguese colonial policy.
Portuguese trade with Asia rapidly proved profitable from 1499 onwards, and as Jesuits arrived in India around 1540, the colonial government in Goa supported the mission with incentives for baptized Christians. Later, the Church sent Jesuits to China (1552 onwards) and to other countries in Asia.[5][6]

Protestant missions[edit]

The Reformation unfolded in Europe in the early 16th century. For over a hundred years, occupied by their struggle with the Catholic Church, the early Protestant churches as a body were not strongly focused on missions to "heathen" lands.[7] Instead, the focus was initially more on Christian lands in the hope to spread the Protestant faith, identifying the papacy with the Antichrist.[8]
In the centuries that followed, Protestant churches began sending out missionaries in increasing numbers, spreading the proclamation of the Christian message to previously unreached people. In North America, missionaries to the Native Americans included Jonathan Edwards (1703–1758), the well-known preacher of the Great Awakening (ca 1731–1755), who in his later years retired from the very public life of his early career. He became a missionary to the Housatonic Native Americans (1751) and a staunch advocate for them against cultural imperialism.[8]
As European culture has been established in the midst of indigenous peoples, the cultural distance between Christians of differing cultures has been difficult to overcome. One[clarification needed] early solution was the creation of segregated "praying towns" of Christian natives. This pattern of grudging acceptance of converts[clarification needed] played out again later in Hawaii when missionaries from that same[which?] New England culture went there. In the course of the Spanish colonization of the Americas, the Catholic missionaries learned the languages of the Amerindians and devised writing systems for them. Then they preached to indigenous people in those languages (QuechuaGuaraniNahuatl) instead of Spanish, to keep Indians away from "sinful" whites. An extreme case of segregation occurred in the Guarani Reductions, a theocratic semi-independent region established by the Jesuits in the region of the future Paraguay between the early 17th century and 1767.
From 1732 onwards the Moravian Church began sending out missionaries.
Around 1780, an indigent Baptist cobbler named William Carey began reading about James Cook's travels voyages in Polynesia. His interest grew to a furious sort of "backwards homesickness", inspiring him to obtain Baptist orders, and eventually to write his famous 1792 pamphlet, "An Enquiry into the Obligation of Christians to use Means for the Conversion of Heathen". Far from a dry book of theology, Carey's work used the best available geographic and ethnographic data to map and count the number of people who had never heard the Gospel. It inspired a movement that has grown with increasing speed from his day to the present.[citation needed]
In the United States, the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions (ABCFM) was chartered in 1812.
Protestant missionaries from the Anglican and Lutheran and Presbyterian traditions starting arriving in what was then the Ottoman Empire in the first half of the 19th Century. This eventually let to the creation of what are today the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land and the see of the Anglican Bishop in Jerusalem.[9] Furthermore, it was during this time that the Christian and Missionary Alliance started their missionary activity in Jerusalem.[10]
American "Hard-shell Baptists", "Anti-Mission Baptists", or "Old School Baptists" adhering to strict Calvinism rejected all mission boards, Bible tract societies, and temperance societies as nonbiblical. The mainstream of the Baptist denomination, however, supported missionary work.
Thomas Coke, (1747–1814) the first bishop of the American Methodists, was "the Father of Methodist Missions". After spending time in the newly formed United States of America strengthening the infant Methodist Church alongside Episcopal colleague Francis Asbury, the British-born Coke left for mission work. During his time in America, Coke worked vigorously to increase Methodist support of Christian missions and of raising up mission workers. Coke died while on a mission trip to India, but his legacy among Methodists – his passion for missions – continues.

China[edit]

Missionary preaching in China using The Wordless Book
A wave of missions, starting in the early 1850s, targeted inland areas, led by Hudson Taylor (1832–1905) with his China Inland Mission (1865– ). Taylor was later supported by Henry Grattan Guinness (1835–1910) who founded (1883) Cliff College, which continues as of 2014 to train and equip for local and global mission.
The missions inspired by Taylor and Guinness have collectively been called[by whom?] "faith missions" and owe much to the ideas and example of Anthony Norris Groves (1795–1853). Taylor, a thorough-going nativist, offended the missionaries of his era by wearing Chinese clothing and speaking Chinese at home. His books, speaking, and examples led to the formation of numerous inland missions and of the Student Volunteer Movement (SVM, founded in 1886), which from 1850 to about 1950 sent nearly 10,000 missionaries to inland areas, often at great personal sacrifice. Many early SVM missionaries traveling to areas with endemic tropical diseases left with their belongings packed in a coffin, aware that 80% of them would die within two years.

British Empire[edit]

In the 18th century, and even more so in the 19th century, missionaries based in Britain saw the Empire as a fertile field for proselytizing for Christianity. All the main denominations were involved, including the Church of England, the Presbyterians of Scotland, and the Nonconformists. Much of the enthusiasm emerged from the Evangelical revival. Within the Church of England, the Church Mission Society (CMS) originated in 1799[11] and went on to undertake activity all around the world, including in what became known as "the Middle East".[12][13]
Before the American Revolution, Anglican and Methodist missionaries were active in the 13 Colonies. The Methodists, led by George Whitefield (1714-1770), were the most successful and after the revolution and entirely distinct American Methodist denomination emerged that became the largest Protestant denomination in the new United States.[14] A major problem for colonial officials was the demand of the Church of England to set up an American bishop; this was strongly opposed by most of the Americans had never happened. Increasingly colonial officials took a neutral position on religious matters, even in those colonies such as Virginia where the Church of England was officially established, but in practice controlled by laymen in the local vestries. After the Americans broke free, British officials decided to enhance the power and wealth of the Church of England in all the settler colonies, especially British North America (Canada).[15]
Missionary societies funded their own operations that were not supervised or directed by the Colonial Office. Tensions emerged between the missionaries and the colonial officials. The latter feared that missionaries might stir up trouble or encourage the natives to challenge colonial authority. In general, colonial officials were much more comfortable with working with the established local leadership, including the native religions, rather than introducing the divisive force of Christianity. This proved especially troublesome in India, were very few local elites were attracted to Christianity. In Africa, especially, the missionaries made many converts. Of the 21st century there were more Anglicans in Nigeria than in England.[16][17]
Missionaries increasingly came to focus on education, medical help, and long-term modernization of the native personality to inculcate European middle-class values. They established schools and medical clinics. Christian missionaries played a public role, especially in promoting sanitation and public health. Many were trained as physicians, or took special courses in public health and tropical medicine at Livingstone College, London.[18]

After 1870[edit]

By the 1870s Protestant missions around the world generally acknowledged the long-term material goal was the formation of independent, self-governing, self-supporting, self-propagating churches. The rise of nationalism in the Third World provoked challenges from critics who complained that the missionaries were teaching Western ways, and ignoring the indigenous culture. The Boxer Rebellion in China in 1898 involved very large scale attacks on Christian missions and their converts. The First World War diverted resources, and pulled most Germans out of missionary work when that country lost its empire. The worldwide Great Depression of the 1930s was a major blow to funding mission activities.[19]
In 1910, the Edinburgh Missionary Conference was presided over by active SVM and YMCA leader (and future Nobel Peace Prize recipient) John R. Mott, an American Methodist layperson, the conference reviewed the state of evangelism, Bible translation, mobilization of church support, and the training of indigenous leadership.[20] Looking to the future, conferees worked on strategies for worldwide evangelism and cooperation. The conference not only established greater ecumenical cooperation in missions, but also essentially launched the modern ecumenical movement.
The next wave of missions was started by two missionaries, Cameron Townsend and Donald McGavran, around 1935. These men realized that although earlier missionaries had reached geographic areas, there were numerous ethnographic groups that were isolated by language, or class from the groups that missionaries had reached. Cameron formed Wycliffe Bible Translators to translate the Bible into native languages. McGavran concentrated on finding bridges to cross the class and cultural barriers in places like India, which has upwards of 4,600 peoples, separated by a combination of language, culture, and caste. Despite democratic reforms, caste and class differences are still fundamental in many cultures.
An equally important dimension of missions strategy is the indigenous method of nationals reaching their own people. In Asia this wave of missions was pioneered by men like Dr G. D. James of Singapore,[21] Rev Theodore Williams of India[22] and Dr David Cho of Korea. The "two thirds missions movement" as it is referred to, is today a major force in missions.
Most modern missionaries and missionary societies have repudiated cultural imperialism, and elected to focus on spreading the gospel and translating the Bible.[citation needed] Sometimes, missionaries have been vital in preserving and documenting the culture of the peoples among whom they live.
Often, missionaries provide welfare and health services, as a good deed or to make friends with the locals. Thousands of schools, orphanages, and hospitals have been established by missions. One service provided by missionaries was the Each one, teach one literacy program begun by Dr. Frank Laubach in the Philippines in 1935. The program has since spread around the world and brought literacy to the least enabled members of many societies.[citation needed]
During this period missionaries, especially evangelical and Pentecostal missionaries, witnessed a substantial increase in the number of conversions of Muslims to Christianity.[23] In an interview published in 2013 a leader of a key missionary agency focused on Muslims claimed that the world is living in a "day of salvation for Muslims everywhere."[24]
The word "mission" was historically often applied to the building, the "mission station" in which the missionary lives or works. In some colonies, these mission stations became a focus of settlement of displaced or formerly nomadic people. Particularly in rural Australia, missions have become localities or ghettoes on the edges of towns which are home to many Indigenous Australians. The word may be seen as derogatory when used in this context.
Additional events can be found at the timeline of Christian missions.

Contemporary concepts of mission[edit]

Sending and receiving nations[edit]

Major nations not only send and fund missionaries abroad, but also receive them from other countries. In 2010, the United States sent out 127,000 missionaries, while 32,400 came to the United States. Brazil was second, sending out 34,000, and receiving 20,000. France sent out 21,000 and received 10,000. Britain sent out 15,000 and received 10,000. India sent out 10,000 and received 8000. Other major exporters included Spain at 21,000 sent out, Italy at 20,000, South Korea at 20,000, Germany at 14,000, and Canada at 8,500. Large recipient nations included Russia, receiving 20,000; Congo receiving 15,000; South Africa, 12,000; Argentina, 10,000; and Chile, 8,500. The largest sending agency in the United States was the Southern Baptist Convention, with 4,800 missionaries, plus 450 support staff working inside the United States. The annual budget is about $50,000 per year per missionary. In recent years, however, the Southern Baptist foreign missionary operation (the International Mission Board) has operated at a deficit, and it is cutting operations by 15 percent. It is encouraging older missionaries to retire and return to the United States.[25]

Modern missionary methods and doctrines among conservative Protestants[edit]

The Lausanne Congress of 1974, birthed a movement that supports evangelical mission among non-Christians and nominal Christians. It regards "mission" as that which is designed "to form a viable indigenous church-planting and world changing movement." This definition is motivated by a theologically imperative theme of the Bible to make God known, as outlined in the Great Commission. The definition is claimed to summarize the acts of Jesus' ministry, which is taken as a model motivation for all ministries.
This Christian missionary movement seeks to implement churches after the pattern of the first century Apostles. The process of forming disciples is necessarily social. "Church" should be understood in the widest sense, as a body of believers of Christ rather than simply a building. In this view, even those who are already culturally Christian must be "evangelized".
Church planting by cross-cultural missionaries leads to the establishment of self-governing, self-supporting and self-propagating communities of believers. This is the famous "three-self" formula formulated by Henry Venn of the London Church Missionary Society in the 19th century. Cross-cultural missionaries are persons who accept church-planting duties to evangelize people outside their culture, as Christ commanded in the Great Commission (Matthew 28:18–20Mark 16:15–18).
The objective of these missionaries is to give an understandable presentation of their beliefs with the hope that people will choose to following the teaching of Jesus Christ and live their lives as His disciples. As a matter of strategy, many evangelical Christians around the world now focus on what they call the "10/40 window", a band of countries between 10 and 40 degrees north latitude and reaching from western Africa through Asia. Christian missions strategist Luis Bush pinpointed the need for a major focus of evangelism in the "10/40 Window", a phrase he coined in his presentation at the missionary conference Lausanne 1989 in Manila. Sometimes referred to as the "Resistant Belt", it is an area that includes 35% of the world's land mass, 90% of the world's poorest peoples and 95% of those who have yet to hear anything about Christianity.
Modern mission techniques are sufficiently refined that within ten to fifteen years, most indigenous churches are locally pastored, managed, taught, self-supporting and evangelizing. The process can be substantially faster if a preexisting translation of the Bible and higher pastoral education are already available, perhaps left over from earlier, less effective missions.
One strategy is to let indigenous cultural groups decide to adopt Christian doctrines and benefits, when (as in most cultures) such major decisions are normally made by groups. In this way, opinion leaders in the groups can persuade much or most of the groups to convert. When combined with training in discipleship, church planting and other modern missionary doctrine, the result is an accelerating, self-propelled conversion of large portions of the culture.
A typical modern mission is a co-operative effort by many different ministries, often including several coordinating ministries, such as the Faith2Share network, often with separate funding sources. One typical effort proceeded as follows:
  1. A missionary radio group recruits, trains and broadcasts in the main dialect of the target culture's language. Broadcast content is carefully adapted to avoid syncretism yet help the Christian Gospel seem like a native, normal part of the target culture. Broadcast content often includes news, music, entertainment and education in the language, as well as purely Christian items.
  2. Broadcasts might advertise programs, inexpensive radios (possibly spring-wound), and a literature ministry that sells a Christian mail-order correspondence course at nominal costs. The literature ministry is key, and is normally a separate organization from the radio ministry. Modern literature missions are shifting to web-based content where it makes sense (as in Western Europe and Japan).
  3. When a person or group completes a correspondence course, they are invited to contact a church-planting missionary group from (if possible) a related cultural group. The church-planting ministry is usually a different ministry from either the literature or radio ministries. The church-planting ministry usually requires its missionaries to be fluent in the target language, and trained in modern church-planting techniques.
  4. The missionary then leads the group to start a church. Churches planted by these groups are usually a group that meets in a house. The object is the minimum organization that can perform the required character development and spiritual growth. Buildings, complex ministries and other expensive items are mentioned, but deprecated until the group naturally achieves the size and budget to afford them. The crucial training is how to become a Christian (by faith in Jesus Christ) and then how to set up a church (meet to study the Bible, and perform communion and worship), usually in that order.
  5. A new generation of churches is created, and the growth begins to accelerate geometrically. Frequently, daughter churches are created only a few months after a church's creation. In the fastest-growing Christian movements, the pastoral education is "pipelined", flowing in a just-in-time fashion from the central churches to daughter churches. That is, planting of churches does not wait for the complete training of pastors.
The most crucial part of church planting is selection and training of leadership. Classically, leadership training required an expensive stay at a seminary, a Bible college. Modern church planters deprecate this because it substantially slows the growth of the church without much immediate benefit. Modern mission doctrines replace the seminary with programmed curricula or (even less expensive) books of discussion questions, and access to real theological books. The materials are usually made available in a major trading language in which most native leaders are likely to be fluent. In some cases, the materials can be adapted for oral use.
It turns out that new pastors' practical needs for theology are well addressed by a combination of practical procedures for church planting, discussion in small groups, and motivated Bible-based study from diverse theological texts. As a culture's church's wealth increases, it will naturally form classic seminaries on its own.
Another related mission is Bible translation. The above-mentioned literature has to be translated. Missionaries actively experiment with advanced linguistic techniques to speed translation and literacy. Bible translation not only speeds a church's growth by aiding self-training, but it also assures that Christian information becomes a permanent part of the native culture and literature. Some ministries also use modern recording techniques to reach groups with audio that could not be soon reached with literature.

Among Roman Catholics[edit]

For Catholics, “Missions” is the term given to those particular undertakings by which the heralds of the Gospel, sent out by the Church and going forth into the whole world, carry out the task of preaching the Gospel and planting the Church among peoples or groups who do not yet believe in Christ.[26]
Vatican II made a deep impact on Catholic missions around the world. The Church's relations to non-Christian religions like Judaism and Islam were revisited.
A steep decline in the number of people entering the priesthood and religious life in the West has made the Church look towards laity more and more. Communities like Opus Dei arose to meet this need.
Inculturation increasingly became a key topic of missiological reflection for Catholics. Inculturation is understood as the meeting of the Christian message with a community in their cultural context.
Liberation Theology and liturgical reform have also been important in forming and influencing the mission of the Catholic Church in the 20th and 21st Centuries.
In relation to mission, Pope Benedict XVI made the re-evangelization of Europe and North America a priority in his own ministry,[27] even while the upper leadership of the Roman Catholic hierarchy and the college of cardinals has more members from Latin America, Africa, and Asia than ever before.[28]
Key documents on mission for Catholics during this period are Evangelii nuntiandi by Pope Paul VI and Redemptoris missio by Pope John Paul II.

Print and new media in mission[edit]

Christian mission organisations have long depended on the printed word as a channel through which to do mission. At times when countries have been "closed" to Christians, great efforts have been made to smuggle Bibles and other literature into those countries. Brother Andrew, the founder of Open Doors, started smuggling Bibles into communist countries in the 1950s.[29] Operation Mobilisation was established in 1957 by George Verwer.[30] Other Christian publishers, such as Plough Publishing, provide free books to people in the UK and US as a form of mission.[31] The Bible Society translates and prints Bibles, in an attempt to reach every country in the world.[32]
The internet now provides Christian mission organisations a convent way of reaching people in the form of podcasts. Podcasts provide a way of dissemination for a message that has potential to endanger the recipient, since it is very hard to track who has downloaded a specific podcast. An example of this is the Crescent Project.[33] Other podcasts, such as the Life Together podcast[34], The Sacred, and Harvest are aimed at both non-Christians and Christians in the home country.[35]

Reverse mission[edit]

The shift in world Christian population from Europe and North America to the non-Western world, and the migration of Africans, Asians, and Latin Americans to the West has given rise to what some have termed "reverse mission." It demonstrates a reversal of the missionary movement, in that it reverses the direction of earlier missionary efforts.[36]

Criticism[edit]

Communicating diseases[edit]

Europe's contact with indigenous since 1492 has killed 100 million from the imported diseases to which tribes had no immunity.[37] Missionaries, along with other travelers, brought diseases into local populations. Smallpoxmeasles, even the common cold, have been blamed on their arrivals.[38] David Igler of the University of California, Irvine, includes missionary activity as a cause of spreading germs. However, he says that commercial traders were the main agents of disease.
... other diseases arrived on non-commercial voyages; missionary activities certainly spread germs, and Spanish conquests had dispersed deadly germs in parts of the Americas and Pacific prior to the late eighteenth century. Yet, for the period between the 1770s and the 1840s, trading vessels were the main agents of disease, creating in the Pacific what Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie has called a "paroxysm" of the "microbian unification of the world." By 1850, the microbes of Europe, Asia, and Africa circulated in almost every Pacific population.[39]

Response[edit]

Political scientist Robert Woodberry uses statistics to argue that conversionary Protestants were a crucial catalyst in spreading religious liberty, education, and democracy. He shows that statistically the prevalence of such missionaries account for half of the variance in democracy in Africa, Asia, Latin America and Oceania.[40] In a 2014 Christianity Today article, he remarks, "Areas where Protestant missionaries had a significant presence in the past are on average more economically developed today, with comparatively better health, lower infant mortality, lower corruption, greater literacy, higher educational attainment (especially for women), and more robust membership in nongovernmental associations."[41]

Controversy and Christian missionaries[edit]

"This proselytization will mean no peace in the world. Conversions are harmful to India. If I had the power and could legislate I should certainly stop all proselytizing ... It pains me to have to say that the Christian missionaries as a body, with honorable exceptions, have actively supported a system which has impoverished, enervated and demoralized a people considered to be among the gentlest and most civilized on earth".[42]
In India, Hindu organisations such as the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh assert that most conversions undertaken by zealous evangelicals occur due to compulsion, inducement or fraud.[43] In the Indian state of Tripura, the government has alleged financial and weapons-smuggling connections between Baptist missionaries and rebel groups such as the National Liberation Front of Tripura.[44] The accused Tripura Baptist Christian Union is a member body of the Baptist World Alliance.[45]
"In mid-May, the Vatican was also co-sponsoring a meeting about how some religious groups abuse liberties by proselytizing, or by evangelizing in aggressive or deceptive ways. Iraq ... has become an open field for foreigners looking for fresh converts. Some Catholic Church leaders and aid organizations have expressed concern about new Christian groups coming in and luring Iraqis to their churches with offers of cash, clothing, food or jobs.... Reports of aggressive proselytism and reportedly forced conversions in mostly Hindu India have fueled religious tensions and violence there and have prompted some regional governments to pass laws banning proselytism or religious conversion.... Sadhvi Vrnda Chaitanya, a Hindu monk from southern India, told CNS that India's poor and uneducated are especially vulnerable to coercive or deceptive methods of evangelization.... Aid work must not hide any ulterior motives and avoid exploiting vulnerable people like children and the disabled, she said."[46]
In an interview with Outlook Magazine, Sadhvi Vrnda Chaitanya said "If the Vatican could understand that every religious and spiritual tradition is as sacred as Christianity, and that they have a right to exist without being denigrated or extinguished, it will greatly serve the interests of dialogue, mutual respect, and peaceful coexistence."[47]

Aid and evangelism[edit]

While there is a general agreement among most major aid organizations not to mix aid with proselyting, others see disasters as a useful opportunity to spread the word. One such an occurrence was the tsunami that devastated parts of Asia on December 26, 2004.[48]
"This (disaster) is one of the greatest opportunities God has given us to share his love with people," said K.P. Yohannan, president of the Texas-based Gospel for Asia. In an interview, Yohannan said his 14,500 "native missionaries" in India, Sri Lanka and the Andaman Islands are giving survivors Bibles and booklets about "how to find hope in this time through the word of God." In Krabi, Thailand, a Southern Baptist church had been "praying for a way to make inroads" with a particular ethnic group of fishermen, according to Southern Baptist relief coordinator Pat Julian. Then came the tsunami, "a phenomenal opportunity" to provide ministry and care, Julian told the Baptist Press news service.... Not all evangelicals agree with these tactics. "It's not appropriate in a crisis like this to take advantage of people who are hurting and suffering", said the Rev. Franklin Graham, head of Samaritan's Purse and son of evangelist Billy Graham."[49]
The Christian Science Monitor echoes these concerns... "'I think evangelists do this out of the best intentions, but there is a responsibility to try to understand other faith groups and their culture,' says Vince Isner, director of FaithfulAmerica.org, a program of the National Council of Churches USA."[50]
The Bush administration has made it easier for U.S. faith-based groups and missionary societies to tie aid and church together.
For decades, US policy has sought to avoid intermingling government programs and religious proselytizing. The aim is both to abide by the Constitution's prohibition against a state religion and to ensure that aid recipients don't forgo assistance because they don't share the religion of the provider.... But many of those restrictions were removed by Bush in a little-noticed series of executive orders – a policy change that cleared the way for religious groups to obtain hundreds of millions of dollars in additional government funding. It also helped change the message American aid workers bring to many corners of the world, from emphasizing religious neutrality to touting the healing powers of the Christian God.[51]

Christian counter-claims[edit]

Missionaries say that the government in India has passed anti-conversion laws in several states that are supposedly meant to prevent conversions from "force or allurement," but are primarily used, they say, to persecute and criminalize voluntary conversion due to the government's broad definition of "force and allurement." Any gift received from a Christian in exchange for, or with the intention of, conversion is considered allurement. Voice of the Martyrs reports that aid-workers claim that they are being hindered from reaching people with much needed services as a result of this persecution.[52] Alan de Lastic, Roman Catholic archbishop of New Delhi states that claims of forced conversion are false.[53]
"'There are attacks practically every week, maybe not resulting in death, but still, violent attacks,' Richard Howell, general secretary of the Evangelical Fellowship of India tells The Christian Science Monitor today. 'They [India's controlling BJP party] have created an atmosphere where minorities do feel insecure.'"[54] According to Prakash Louis, director of the secular Indian Social Institute in New Delhi, "We are seeing a broad attempt to stifle religious minorities and their constitutional rights...Today, they say you have no right to convert, Tomorrow you have no right to worship in certain places."[55] Existing congregations, often during times of worship, are being persecuted.[56] Properties are sometimes destroyed and burnt to the ground, while native pastors are sometimes beaten and left for dead.[57][58][59][60][61][62][63]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Mission"Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 8 January 2013.
  2. ^ https://www.dictionary.com/browse/missionary
  3. ^ Jenkins, Philip (2008). The Lost History of Christianity: The Thousand Year Golden Age of the Church in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia —and How It Died.
  4. ^ Bridger, J. Scott (February 2009). "Raymond Lull: Medieval Theologian, Philosopher, and Missionary to Muslims" (PDF)St Francis Magazine5 (1): 1–25. Retrieved 7 January2013.
  5. ^ Liam Matthew Brockey, Journey to the east: The Jesuit mission to China, 1579–1724(Harvard University Press, 2009)
  6. ^ Županov, Ines G. (2005). Missionary Tropics: The Catholic Frontier in India (16th–17th centuries). University of Michigan. ISBN 978-0-472-11490-0.
  7. ^ Roy, Olivier (2010). Holy Ignorance. New York: Columbia University Press. pp. 48–56. ISBN 978-0-231-70126-6.
  8. Jump up to:a b Walls, Andrew F. (November 2016). "Eschatology and the Western Missionary Movement". Studies in World Christianity22 (3): 182–200. doi:10.3366/swc.2016.0155.
  9. ^ Miller, Duane Alexander (December 2007). "The Installation of a Bishop in Jerusalem"Anglican and Episcopal History76 (4): 549–554. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
  10. ^ Miller, Duane Alexander (June 2010). "Renegotiating the Boundaries of Evangelicalism in Jerusalem's Christian Quarter"Anglican and Episcopal History79 (2): 185–188. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
  11. ^ Ward, Kevin (2006). A History of Global Anglicanism. New York: Cambridge U Press. p. 34.
  12. ^ Susan Thorne (1999). Congregational Missions and the Making of an Imperial Culture in Nineteenth-Century England. Stanford University Press, ch 1. ISBN 9780804765442.
  13. ^ Andrew Porter, Religion versus Empire?: British Protestant Missionaries and Overseas Expansion, 1700–1914 (2004)
  14. ^ Mark A. Noll, The Rise of Evangelicalism: The Age of Edwards, Whitefield and the Wesleys(2010).
  15. ^ Andrew Porter, "Religion, Missionary Enthusiasm, and Empire," in Porter, ed., Oxford History of the British Empire (1999) vol 3 pp 223–24.
  16. ^ Norman Etherington, ed. Missions and Empire (Oxford History of the British Empire Companion Series) (2008)
  17. ^ Porter, "Religion, Missionary Enthusiasm, and Empire," (1999) vol 3 ch 11
  18. ^ Ryan Johnson, "Colonial Mission and Imperial Tropical Medicine: Livingstone College, London, 1893–1914," Social History of Medicine (2010) 23#3 pp 549–566.
  19. ^ Erwin Fahlbusch, ed. The Encyclopedia of Christianity (1999) 1:301, 416–7
  20. ^ Gairdner, Temple (1910). Echoes from Edinburgh 1910. London: Anderson & Ferrier.
  21. ^ James-Nathan, Violet (2000). "One". In Jonathan James and Malcolm Tan (ed.). That Asia May Know: Perspectives on Missions in Asia (40th Anniversary Commemorative ed.). Asia Evangelistic Fellowship International. pp. 8–43. ISBN 978-0-646-39763-4.
  22. ^ "Indian Evangelical Mission". Retrieved 1 February 2014.
  23. ^ Miller, Duane Alexander (February 2010). "Woven in the Weakness of the Changing Body: the Genesis of World Islamic Christianity" (PDF)CTFC2. Retrieved 7 January 2013.
  24. ^ Blincoe, Bob; Duane Alexander Miller (January 2013). "The Day of Salvation for Muslims Everywhere: an interview with Bob Blincoe"Global Missiology10 (2). Retrieved 7 January2013.
  25. ^ Tamara Audi, "Cash-Strapped Missionaries Get a New Calling: Home—Years of overspending to support Southern Baptist missionary work has led to budget crunch," Wall Street Journal 25 October, 2015.
  26. ^ Decree on the Mission Activity of the Church: Ad Gentes. (Para. 6) In Vatican II Documents, (1965), Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
  27. ^ Edwards, Tito (June 2010). "Benedict Opens New Evangelization of Europe and America Office"The American Catholic. Retrieved 18 January 2013.
  28. ^ Palmo, Rocco. "B16's October Surprise". Retrieved 18 January 2013.
  29. ^ Ireland, Open Doors UK &. "Open Doors history"www.opendoorsuk.org. Retrieved 2017-06-15.
  30. ^ Mobilisation, Operation. "About Operation Mobilisation"Operation Mobilisation. Archived from the original on 2016-12-24. Retrieved 2017-06-15.
  31. ^ "About Us"Plough. Retrieved 2017-06-15.
  32. ^ "Home"www.biblesociety.org.uk. Retrieved 2017-06-15.
  33. ^ "Podcast — Crescent Project"Crescent Project. Retrieved 2018-11-22.
  34. ^ "Bruderhof Communities"SoundCloud. Retrieved 2018-11-22.
  35. ^ "Podcasts - Harvest: Greg Laurie"Harvest: Greg Laurie. Retrieved 2018-11-22.
  36. ^ Ojo, Matthew (2007). "Reverse Mission". In Bonk, Jonathan J. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Mission and Missionaries. London: Routledge. pp. 380–382.
  37. ^ Is It Ethical to Leave Uncontacted Tribes Alone?Time (magazine), 4 June 2015.
  38. ^ Witmer, A. C. (September 1885). "The Islands of the Sea"The Gospel in All Lands. New York, NY: Methodist Episcopal Church Mission Society: 437. Retrieved 2011-11-20.
  39. ^ Igler, David (June 2004). "Diseased Goods: Global Exchanges in the Eastern Pacific Basin, 1770–1850"The American Historical Review. Chicago, Illinois: American Historical Association. 109 (3): 693–719. doi:10.1086/530552. Retrieved 2011-11-20.
  40. ^ Robert D. Woodberry, "The missionary roots of liberal democracy," American Political Science Review 106.2 (2012): 244–274 / online
  41. ^ "Missions: Rescuing from Hell and Renewing the World". 2014-01-13.
  42. ^ The Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi Volume 24, p. 476 Note: This quote isn't in this volume. In fact the volume only contains 474 pages; volume 64 p.20 has the first sentence only:This proselytization will mean no peace in the world
  43. ^ "Why Anti-Conversion Law needed". Archived from the original on 2008-12-02. Retrieved 2008-02-24.
  44. ^ Subir Bhaumik (18 April 2000). "Church backing Tripura rebels". BBC News. Retrieved August 9, 2007.
  45. ^ [1] Archived April 15, 2009, at the Wayback Machine
  46. ^ Carol Glatz (May 19, 2006). "Legislating conversions: Weighing the message vs. the person". Catholic Online. Archived from the original on July 1, 2007. Retrieved August 7,2007.
  47. ^ Seema Sirohi (October 2, 2006). "Father Complex". OutlookIndia.com. Archived from the original on June 30, 2013. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  48. ^ Burke, Jason (January 16, 2005). "Religious aid groups try to convert victims"The Guardian. Retrieved June 19, 2013.
  49. ^ "In Asia, some Christian groups spread supplies – and the word". Knight-Ridder Newspapers. January 12, 2005. Retrieved June 19, 2013.
  50. ^ Jane Lampman (January 31, 2005). "Disaster Aid Furthers Fears of Proselytizing". Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  51. ^ "Bush brings faith to foreign aid"Boston.com. The Boston Globe. October 8, 2006. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  52. ^ "Country Map – India". Persecution.com. Retrieved August 7, 2007.[permanent dead link](website requires anonymous creation of a username and password account to be able to view)
  53. ^ "Indian Express". Archived from the original on 2009-04-12. Retrieved 2013-04-15.
  54. ^ Ted Olsen (September 1, 2003). "Weblog: Missionaries in India Concerned as Hindu Activists Break Up Prayer Meeting". Christianity Today. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  55. ^ Ted Olsen (September 1, 2003). "Weblog: Missionaries in India Concerned as Hindu Activists Break Up Prayer Meeting". Christianity Today. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  56. ^ "Christian murdered in Kerala". Christian Today – India Edition. February 14, 2007. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  57. ^ "Two Nuns accused and held for trying to "convert" students". Evangelical Fellowship of India. Archived from the original on September 28, 2007. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  58. ^ "Five arrested for assaulting trainee priests in Panvel". Evangelical Fellowship of India. March 7, 2007. Archived from the original on September 28, 2007. Retrieved August 7,2007.
  59. ^ "Christians attacked in Jalampur, Dhamtari in Chhattisgarh". Evangelical Fellowship of India. January 10, 2006. Archived from the original on September 28, 2007. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  60. ^ Jacob Chaterjee (February 12, 2007). "Hindu radicals attack believers in Karnataka". Christian Today – India Edition. Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  61. ^ Jacob Chaterjee (February 20, 2007). "Hindu radicals attack Bible college students during outreach; two in critical condition". Christian Today – India Edition. Retrieved August 7,2007.
  62. ^ Jacob Chaterjee (February 6, 2007). "Hindu radicals attack Christian prayer meeting in Bihar". Retrieved August 7, 2007.
  63. ^ Jacob Chaterjee (February 18, 2007). "Hindu fanatics oppose Christian-run orphanage and Bible center in Himachal Pradesh". Christian Today – India Edition. Retrieved August 7,2007.

Further reading[edit]

  • Anderson, Gerald H., (ed.) Biographical dictionary of Christian missions, Simon & Schuster Macmillan, 1998
  • Arles, SigaTheological Education for the Mission of the Church in India: 1947 - 1987, New York: Peter Lang, 1992.
  • Bainbridge, William F. Around the World Tour of Christian Missions: A Universal Survey (1882) 583 pages; full text online
  • Barnes, Jonathan S. Power and Partnership: A History of the Protestant Mission Movement (Wipf and Stock Publishers, 2013)
  • Barrett, David, ed. World Christian Encyclopedia, Oxford University Press, 1982.
  • Beaver, R. Pierce. "North American Thought on the Fundamental Principles of Missions During the Twentieth Century." Church History 21.4 (1952): 345–364.
  • Beaver, R. Pierce. ed American Missions in Bicentennial Perspective(1977).
  • Beaver, Robert Pierce. American Protestant Women in World Mission: History of the First Feminist Movement in North America. (WB Eerdmans Publishing Company, 1980).
  • Beaver, Robert Pierce. Church, state, and the American Indians: two and a half centuries of partnership in missions between Protestant churches and government (Concordia Pub. House, 1966).
  • Beaver, Robert Pierce. Missionary Motivation through Three Centuries (1968).
  • Best, Jeremy. "Godly, International, and Independent: German Protestant Missionary Loyalties before World War I." Central European History (2014) 47#3 pp: 585–611.
  • Bevans, Stephen B. A Century of Catholic Mission (2013) excerpt; wide-ranging survey focused on 20th century worldwide
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia, (1913) online, worldwide detailed coverage
  • Cnattingius, Hans. Bishops and societies: A study of Anglican colonial and missionary expansion, 1698–1850 (1952)
  • Dries, Angelyn. The missionary movement in American Catholic history (Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 1998)
  • Dunch, Ryan. "Beyond cultural imperialism: Cultural theory, Christian missions, and global modernity." History and Theory 41.3 (2002): 301–325. online
  • Dwight, Henry Otis et al. eds., The Encyclopedia of Missions (2nd ed. 1904) Online, Global coverage Of Protestant and Catholic missions.
  • Endres, David J. American Crusade: Catholic Youth in the World Mission Movement from World War I Through Vatican II (2010)
  • Etherington, Norman, ed. Missions and Empire (Oxford History of the British Empire Companion Series) (2008)
  • Fitzpatrick-Behrens, Susan. The Maryknoll Catholic Mission in Peru, 1943–1989: Transnational Faith and Transformation (2012)
  • Glazier, Michael and Monika K. Hellwig, eds., The Modern Catholic Encyclopedia, Liturgical Press, 2004
  • Glover, Robert H. The Progress of World-Wide Missions, rev. by J. Herbert Kane., Harper and Row, 1960
  • Graham, Gael. Gender, culture, and Christianity: American Protestant mission schools in China, 1880–1930 (P. Lang, 1995)
  • Herzog, Johann Jakob, Philip Schaff, and Albert Hauck. The New Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge, 12 volumes, Funk and Wagnalls Company, 1910–11
  • Hollinger, David A. Protestants Abroad: How Missionaries Tried to Change the World but Changed America (2017) excerpt
  • Huntley, Martha. Caring, growing, changing: a history of the Protestant mission in Korea (Friendship Press, 1984)
  • Hutchison, William R. (1993). Errand to the World: American Protestant Thought and Foreign Missions. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 9780226363103.
  • Kane, J. Herbert. A Concise History of the Christian World Mission, Baker, 1982
  • Latourette, Kenneth Scott. A History of the Expansion of Christianity, 7 volumes, (1938–45), the most detailed scholarly history
  • MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years (2009)
  • Moreau, A. Scott, David Burnett, Charles Edward van Engen and Harold A. NetlandEvangelical Dictionary of World Missions, Baker Book House Company, 2000
  • Neill, Stephen. A History of Christian Missions. Penguin Books, 1986
  • Newcomb, Harvey. A Cyclopedia of Missions: Containing a Comprehensive View of Missionary Operations Throughout the World : with Geographical Descriptions, and Accounts of the Social, Moral, and Religious Condition of the People (1860) 792 pages complete text online
  • Pocock, Michael, Gailyn Van Rheenen, Douglas McConnell. The Changing Face of World Missions: Engaging Contemporary Issues And Trends (2005); 391 pages
  • Ragsdale, John P. Protestant mission education in Zambia, 1880–1954 (Susquehanna University Press, 1986)
  • Robert, Dana L. Christian Mission: How Christianity Became a World Religion (2009), 226pp; short survey
  • Stanley, Brian. The Bible and the Flag: Protestant Mission and British Imperialism in the 19th and 20th Centuries (1990)
  • Stanley, Brian. The Global Diffusion of Evangelicalism: The Age of Billy Graham and John Stott (2013)
  • Tejirian, Eleanor H., and Reeva Spector Simon, eds. Conflict, Conquest, and Conversion: Two Thousand Years of Christian Missions in the Middle East (Columbia University Press; 2012) 280 pages; focus on the 19th and 20th centuries.
  • Tyrrell, Ian. Reforming the World: The Creation of America's Moral Empire (2010) excerpt and text search
  • Tucker, Ruth. From Jerusalem to Irian Jaya:From Jerusalem to Irian Jaya: A Biographical History of Christian Missions (2nd ed. 2004) excerpt and text search
  • Yates, Timothy. The Conversion of the Maori: Years of Religious and Social Change, 1814–1842 (2013)
  • Županov, Ines G. (2005). Missionary Tropics: The Catholic Frontier in India (16th–17th centuries). University of Michigan. ISBN 978-0-472-11490-0.
  • Journal Social Sciences and Missions (Leiden: Brill), 1995–...
Positive or neutral
  • Gailey and Culbertson. Discovering Missions by ISBN 0-8341-2257-X
  • Johnstone Operation World ISBN 1-85078-357-8
  • Moreau, Corwin and McGree. Introducing World Missions ISBN 0-8010-2648-2
  • Olson, C. Gordon. What in the World is God Doing? Global Gospel Publishers, 2003
  • Parker, J. Fred. Mission to the World. Nazarene Publishing House, 1988
  • Van Rheenen Missions by ISBN 0-310-20809-2
  • Winter and Hawthorne, eds. Perspectives on the World Christian Movement ISBN 0-87808-289-1
Critical

External links[edit]

2020/04/08

[김강기명 칼럼] 유럽이 한국으로부터 배울 수 없는 것 | 피렌체의 식탁



[김강기명 칼럼] 유럽이 한국으로부터 배울 수 없는 것 | 피렌체의 식탁

[김강기명 칼럼] 유럽이 한국으로부터 배울 수 없는 것

by 김강기명 | 2020년 4월 7일 | 국제, 정책




피렌체의 식탁은 독일의 문화비평지 <Merkur>의 온라인 블로그에 실린
김강기명 필자의 글 ‘WAS EUROPA VON SÜDKOREA NICHT LERNEN KANN’을 수정 번역해 전재합니다.
필자는 2011년 독일로 가서 베를린자유대학에서 스피노자의 정치철학에 관한 논문으로 박사과정을 밟고 있습니다.
이 글에 등장하는 농담들은 대부분 한국인보다 유럽인들을 향한 것이라고 필자는 설명했습니다. 예컨대 글 말미에 비속어가 들어가 있는데 ‘빌어먹을 틴에이저’라는 말은 독일어 본문에도 일부러 영어로 ‘goddamn bloody teenagers’라고 썼답니다.
마찬가지로 유럽 철학자들의 책 제목을 따와서 그들의 중심 주장들을 비틀고 풍자해 이들을 아는 사람을 향해 집어넣은 농담도 있습니다. <벌거벗은-생명의-비상사태>, <이것은-세계혁명의-기회 만트라>, <아직은-공산주의는-때가-아님>, <출입금지-민주주의의-위기> 등입니다. [편집자]


Was Europa von Südkorea nicht lernen kann



#국내외 언론, 한국식 코로나19 대책을
‘성공적인 민주적 모델’이라 연일 찬사


코로나19 위기 국면에서 개인적으로 가장 이상하게 느껴온 것은 남한이 서구사회의 상당한 주목과 칭찬을 받았다는 점이었다. 파이낸셜타임스 같은 보수 경제지뿐만 아니라 리버럴 미디어인 뉴욕타임스BBC, 좌파 신문인 디 타게스차이퉁(die taz) 등이 연일 앞 다퉈 코비드-19(Covid-19) 대규모 감염 사태를 다루고 있다.
그러면서 소위 한국식 대책을 우리 시대의 위기대응 교과서처럼 소개했고, 미국에서는 백악관 언론브리핑 때마다 “왜 한국처럼 하지 못하는가?”라는 질문이 단골 소재처럼 나왔다.

외국어에 능통한 젊은 한국인들은 한껏 부풀어 오른 자존감으로 이런 기사들을 빠르게 번역하고, 또 소셜미디어로 공유한다. 저녁시간에 TV 방송에선 프랑스 에마뉘엘 마크롱 대통령이나 스웨덴 스테판 뢰벤 총리가 위기대응을 위해 문재인 대통령과 상의했다는 뉴스를 연일 내보낸다.
또 동시에 같은 방송에선 사람들은 유럽 상황이 얼마나 지금 나빠지고 있는지를 보여주기 위해선지 지역 봉쇄에도 불구하고 파티를 즐기는 현지 사람들이나, 이탈리아 소도시에 줄지어 있는 관(棺)들을 영상으로 전달한다. 어떤 이들은 성마르게 “(가치 공동체 혹은 진보와 근대화의 상징 혹은 어떤 뜻이든) 유럽은 죽었다”라는 주장을 내놓기도 한다.



이런 한국인들의 국가적 자존감에는 분명 합당한 이유가 있을 것이다. 몇 달 전 독일에서 아시아인 커뮤니티들을 경악하게 만든 슈피겔지의 표지, ‘방호복을 입은 사람’ 이미지와 ‘made in china’라는 제목을 봤을 때만 해도 나는 지금의 상황을 전혀 예측할 수 없었다. 이런 식으로 아시아인들을 전염병의 숙주로서 타자화 하는 게 유럽 엘리트들의 (빌어먹을) 자신감을 보여주는 것 아닌가 하고 생각했기 때문이다.
그런데 누가 알았겠는가. 겨우 한 달도 안 돼 유럽인들이 자가 격리 중인 주택 발코니에서 작은 콘서트들을 열고 이를 인스타그램으로 스트리밍 하는 것 말고는 아무 것도 할 게 없는 상황이 올 거라고 말이다.

며칠 전에는 내가 사는 동네의 어떤 슈퍼마켓에서 사재기를 하는 현지 주민과 맞닥뜨렸다. 안타깝게도 슈퍼마켓 직원들이 매몰차게 제지했기 때문에 그녀는 빈손으로 돌아가야 했는데, 나를 놀래게 만든 것은 그가 매우 젊은 사람이라는 점이었다. 대체, 지금, 유럽에서 무슨 일이 벌어지고 있단 말인가?

매일 나는 유럽의 유명한 철학자들의 글을 읽고 있다. 대부분은 그들이 이전에 하던 이야기를 만트라처럼 반복하는 내용들이었다. 조르조 아감벤의 벌거벗은-생명의-비상사태, 슬라보예 지젝의 이것은-세계혁명의-기회, 알랭 바디우의 아직은-공산주의가-아님, 마르쿠스 가브리엘의 출입금지는-민주주의의-위기 등등. 내가 거기서 발견하고 있는 것은 그들이 크건 작건 그들의 증상을 즐기고 있다는 점뿐이었다. 그러니까, “실재의 사막에 오신 것을 환영합니다!” 한국인들은 아직 들어갈 필요가 없는, 그 실재.

#소위 ‘한국식 해법’의 5가지 요소
왜 서구에선 그렇게 대처 못할까?


그렇다. 한국식 시스템은 훌륭히 작동 중이다. 많은 전문가나 해외 언론들이 분석하고 있는 것처럼 소위 한국식 해법은 다섯 개 정도의 중요한 요소로 이뤄져 있다.
1. 중앙집권화 된 국민건강보험, 
2. 정부의 선제적인 개입, 
3. 빈번하고 광범위하고 확실한 검사, 
4. 보편적인 이동제한이 아닌 감염자들의 동선 추적과 선별적 격리, 
5. 중단 없는 정보공개와 투명한 감시가 그것이다.

이 5가지 요소들은 한국에서만 36명의 생명을 앗아간 2015년의 메르스 위기 이후 한국 정부가 발전시켜온 기술적 대책과 협력적 구조를 배경으로 하고 있다. 이런 해법들을 통해 한국인들은 여전히 폭넓은 이동의 자유를 누리고 있고, 감염률 역시 상대적으로 떨어졌다. 유럽에서의 출입금지령이나 접촉금지령, 중국에서 있었던 혹독한 지역봉쇄나 이동금지령 없이 말이다. 이것은 특히 서구의 많은 의료전문가나 정치인들로부터 (중국의 전체주의 모델과 비교되는) ‘민주적 모델’이라고 찬사를 받았다.

하지만 왜 서구 각국은 한국 정부나 한국인처럼 대처할 수 없는 것인가? 솔직히 나는 유럽 국가들은 한국적 대책의 핵심요소들을 애초부터 도입할 수 없었을 거라 생각한다. 거기에 사용된 기술 중 다수는 “고무장갑이나 귀 청소용 솔”(뉴욕타임스) 정도로 쉬운 기술임에도 불구하고 말이다.

뉴욕타임스의 기자 막스 피셔와 최상훈은 남한식 방역정책이 다른 나라에 도입되려면 두 가지 허들이 있다고 말한다. 
첫째는 엄중한 대책을 도입하려는 정치권의 의지가 약하다는 것, 
둘째는 사회적 신뢰가 부족하다는 것이다. 
그들은 “남한에서 사회구성원 간의 신뢰는 
극도의 대립과 포퓰리즘적 백래쉬(backlash·반발)에 시달리고 있는 서구 민주주의 국가들보다 더 높다”고 덧붙인다.

그러나 이 두 논거는 불충분하고, 사실 헛소리에 불과하다. 과연 프랑스의 외부출입 완전통제의 강도와 한국의 확진자 GPS 추적의 ‘엄중함’을 단순 비교할 수 있을까? 또한 한국에서도 사회적 신뢰의 상실이라든지 가짜뉴스를 비롯한 극우 백래쉬 현상은 한국 언론 뉴스의 단골 소재중 하나다. 아시아의 공동체문화 같은 것은 오리엔탈리즘의 전형적인 요소 중 하나일 뿐이다.
한국의 ‘민주주의’를 중국의 ‘전체주의’와 단순 비교하는 논거 역시 의심의 눈으로 볼 필요가 있다. 무엇보다 ‘무엇이 민주주의’인지 다시 좀 정의를 내려야 하지 않은가. 그러니까 외국 사람들은 지금 한국에 대해서 “전면감시사회의 민주주의적 형태” 같은 헛소리를 지껄이고 있는 것인가?

그럼에도 불구하고, 이 한국식 방역정책의 민주주의적 외양은, 그리고 적어도 겉으로 보기에는 매우 양식 있게 보이는 한국의 행정기관이나 시민들의 행동양식은 우리가 살고 있는 오늘날 세계에 관해 무언가를 이야기해주고 있다. 특히 서구적 근대의 생명정치적 통치성과 관련해서 말이다.
상세한 설명을 피하고 간략히 말하자면, 이 개념은 프랑스의 철학자 미셸 푸코가 소개한 것으로, ‘인구’ 혹은 ‘주민’(population)을 대상으로 한 근대의 통치 및 권력의 작동방식을 말한다.

생명정치적 통치성이란 오늘날 북반구의 세계 혹은 자유민주주의 국가들 사이에서 결코 동일한 모습으로 나타나지 않는다. 이 글에서 나는 ‘문명 간의 투쟁’이라든지 ‘문화상대주의’ 같은 도식을 반복하려는 게 아니다. 이런 거시적 도식 대신에 한국의 생명정치적 상황의 몇 가지 미시적인 특징들을 살펴보려 한다. 주지하다시피, 한국은 분명 문화적으로나, 경제적으로나, 제도적으로나, 외교적으로나 서구적 세계에 속한 나라다.
#한국 모델은 ‘민주’ 아닌 ‘모성적 돌봄’
꼼꼼한 추적, 미시적 통제로 확산 막아

내가 독일에 이주한 것은 2011년이었다. 그 이후로 나는 오직 한 번 한국을 다녀왔는데 그것은 독일생활 6년이 지났을 때였다. 이때의 여행은 나에게 상당히 큰 인상을 남겼다. 처음으로 내가 살았던 나라를 낯설게 느꼈기 때문이다.

서울에 도착하자마자 내가 처음으로 마주한 것은 모든 곳을 빽빽하게 채우고 있는 글자와 인포그래픽이었다. 관(官)에서 만든 것이건, 민간에서 만든 것이건 서울의 모든 공공장소마다 글자로 채워져 있었다. 지하철을 타고 이동할 때는 각종의 길 안내 표지물들이 사람들을 출구 앞 100m 앞에서부터 안내한다. 표지물 안내는 지하철을 타는 내내 이어진다. 화장실이 지하철역 어디에 있는지, 내가 어느 출구로 나가야 하는지 서울의 지하철시스템은 아주 친절하게 알려준다. ‘각종’이라고 말한 이유는 이게 그저 이를테면 화장실 표지판 하나를 말하는 게 아니라 거기까지 이어지는 바닥의 길안내 표지선이나, 모든 출구에 붙어 있는 번호들, 그리고 시각 및 청각적 안내물 등의 복합체이기 때문이다. (그리고 모든 글자가 엄청나게 컸다!)

지하철 플랫폼에 선 승객들은 하이테크 스크린 도어에 의해 보호를 받는데, 그 위에는 적절한 에티켓이라든지, 곧 도착하려는 열차의 구체적인 노선이라든지, 정부의 새로운 세금정책이라든지 하는 것들의 정보가 계속 지나간다. 물론 나는 열화(劣化)된 형식이긴 해도 베를린의 지하철에도 비슷한 게 있다는 것을 잘 알고 있다. (그리고 아마 유럽의 여러 대도시에서 지하철역 정도가 이런 정보들을 가장 많이 제공해주는 공공 공간일 것이다) 하지만 이것은 그저 시작에 불과하다.

서울 시내의 거리는 광고나 정보를 제공하기 위한 현수막으로 가득 차 있다. 그 중 상당수는 이런저런 국가기관이나 관청이 걸어놓은 것들이다. 한 번 생각해 보라. 베를린의 ‘칼 맑스 대로’의 나무들 사이에 현수막이 걸려 있고, 쉴 새 없이 우리에게 “소득공제 신청기간을 잊지 마세요!”라든가 “5월은 가정의 달입니다. 가족 간에 사람을 나눠요”라든가, “여기는 사고다발지역입니다. 조심하세요!”라든가 하는 내용을 상기시키는 장면을 말이다. (그곳에 현수막이 걸려 있다면 그건 그저 월세 인상에 반대하는 세입자들의 현수막뿐이다.)
한국의 공원을 가면 사람들은 구석구석마다 공원에서 취해야 할 올바른 행동을 안내하는 크고 작은 안내판을 만나게 된다. 거기엔 “선진국 시민으로 행동합시다”와 비슷한 슬로건이 붙어있을 때도 있다.

이 여행에서 나는 서울 옆의 성남시에서 운전면허증을 갱신했다. 서류를 접수한지 15분 만에 나는 새 면허증을 받고 집으로 운전을 해서 돌아갔다. 그날은 무려 ‘토요일’이었다. 국민건강보험은 (약간의 과장을 보태면) 전화 한 통 후에 나에게 보험수급자 자격을 다시 부여해 주었다. 내가 발급받은 면허증의 번역을 위해 필요한 서류는 다른 관청에서 발급받았는데, 예약을 할 필요도, 거기에 가서 오래 기다릴 필요도 없었다. 왜냐하면 대부분의 민원업무는 보통 인터넷으로 이뤄지기 때문이다. 베를린으로 돌아온 이후 나는 쇠네베르크 구(區)에서 독일 운전면허증을 신청했는데, 그걸 수령한 것은 12주가 지나서였다. (12시간도, 12일도 아님!)

성남시의 관청 건물 벽면에도 많은 현수막들이 붙어 있었는데, 하나는 시에서 새로 도입한 사회정책 안내를 담고 있었고, 또 다른 것은 구에서 열리는 스포츠행사 일정을 소개하고 있었다. 한국에 가서 만난 모든 공무원들은 믿을 수 없게 친절했고, 항상 웃고 있었는데, 이것은 당연히 그들의 본성에서 나온 건 아니다.
한국에선 공무원들에게도 항상 민간기업의 고객서비스 직원들처럼 행동해야 한다는 압력이 있다. “고객의 소리를 들어라!”는 남한 행정의 정언 명령이다. 이 모든 게 내가 독일에 와서 생활하기 전에는 그저 자연스러운 것으로 받아들였던 것이다.

물론 내가 여기서 말하는 것들이 한국과 유럽 사이의 절대적인 차이가 아니라 그저 조그마한 상대적인 차이들이긴 하지만, 이번 코로나19 위기에서 이 차이들은 분명하게 드러나고 있다. 유럽을 기준으로 한다면, 한국 시민들과 국가행정 사이의 거리는 지나치게 가깝다. 한국의 생명정치적 돌봄과 통제는 (근대 남성 부양자 핵가족 모델에서 나온 비유를 사용하는 것에 대한 용서를 미리 구한다. ) ‘모성적’이다.

중앙정부나 지자체는 주민들에게 매 시간마다, 때로는 매 분마다 SMS를 발송해서 코로나19와 관련된 현재 상황을 안내한다. 관청들은 페이스북 페이지에다가 확진자 1명이 이 구역에서 지나다닌 구체적인 경로를 올린다. 거기에는 교회, 카페, 레스토랑, 사무실 등의 이름과 주소가 들어가 있다.
방역당국은 심지어 사용자 동의 없이 스마트폰의 GPS 정보를 수집해서 감염자를 추적한다. 마치 10대 아들의 스마트폰이나 딸의 일기장을 훔쳐보고 지나치게 그들의 삶을 염려하는 걱정 많은 엄마처럼 말이다.
공무원들은 자가 격리를 하고 있는 감염자들을 위해 하루에 두 번 문을 두드리고, 생필품을 공급해 주고, 온갖 노력을 아끼지 않는다. 무엇보다 이 꼼꼼한 추적과 돌봄이야말로 전염병의 확산을 막는데 무척 효과적이었다.

#한국 행정에서 ‘표준 시민’은 아동?
유럽인, 국가통제 최대한 벗어나려 해

유럽 각국은 비상사태를 선포하고 외출·접촉 금지 같은 일단의 부권(父權)적 명령들을 내리고 있다. 철학자인 아감벤 같은 이들은 거기서 ‘삶’(bios, 삶의 형태)이 ‘목숨’(zoe, 벌거벗은 생명)으로 축소되어 취급된다고 본다.
반면에 한국식 대책은 이런 미시적 통제와 모성적 생명의 돌봄을 특징으로 한다. 21세기에 들어와 한국과 독일에서 각각 긴 시간을 살면서 양국의 관료제를 다 경험해 본 입장에서 조심스레 말해 보자면, 한국의 행정이나 사회문화적 환경 속에서 ‘표준 시민’은 ‘아동’이고, 반면에 유럽의 불친절하고 느린 행정에서는 ‘성인’으로 간주되고 있는 것처럼 느껴진다.

앞서 말했듯 나는 유럽 각국이 한국식 정책을 결코 수용하지 못했을 거라 생각한다. 이 모델이 아무리 ‘민주적’이란 이름으로 칭찬 받고 있다고 할지라도 말이다. 왜냐하면 한국 모델의 이 민주적 외양은 사실은 민주주의 체제가 아니라 통치성의 모성적 성격에서 비롯된 것이기 때문이다.
종종 가정에서도 엄마가 아빠보다 조금 더 민주적으로 느껴지듯 말이다. 사실 둘 모두 엄격한 의미의 민주주의와는 상관이 없다. 기껏해야 ‘엄마의 감시’ vs. ‘아빠의 금지’ 정도? 과연 자기 스스로를 (사실 여부를 떠나) 성인이고, 자율적이고, 독립적이고, 자유주의적이고 비판적이라고 생각하는 유럽의 ‘표준 시민’들이 이런 완전한 감시와 통제 정책을 받아들일 수 있을까?

한국인들은 기꺼이 그것을 받아들인다. 그들은 공공서비스와의 이 가까운 거리를 그들의 시민적 권리로 인식한다. 아마도 유럽인들은 국가 통제로부터 최대한 벗어나는 걸 그들의 자유권이라고 생각할 것이다. 한국인들은 미디어나 관청의 캠페인이나, 혹은 소셜미디어를 통해 동료 시민으로서 적절하게 행동하는 법을 서로 배우고 가르친다. 때로 그들은 정부가 발표한 정보를 보고 위기대응정책을 따르지 않는 동료 시민들을 직접 비난하기도 한다.

한국의 위기대응 속에서 우리는 21세기의 기술을 통해 가능해진 비(非)동시적인 권력양식들의 동시적 공존을 발견한다. 18세기의 훈육권력, 19세기의 생명권력, 그리고 20세기의 신자유주의적 통치성이 21세기 하이테크를 기반으로 함께 작동하고 있는 것이다. (물론 이것은 철저히 유럽 중심주의적인 서술이다)
나는 이것이 오로지 한국에서만 발견된다고 생각하진 않는다. 유럽과 북미 바깥의 많은 후발 산업국가들에서 우리는 비슷한 경향을 찾을 수 있다.

#한국, 민주화 과정 아닌 정답에만 몰두
주권의식 높지만 ‘일상 민주주의’ 부족


내전(內戰)으로 산산히 부서진 나라였던 한국에서 서구적 근대는 최대한 빨리 도달해야 할 모델이었다. 아시아·아프리카의 다른 개발도상국과 마찬가지로 한국인들은 급속한 발전이 필요했다. 서구 사회의 약 300년간 이어진 민주화·산업화의 긴 과정은 불필요한 것이었다. 지름길을 위해 필요한 것은 과정이 아니라 오직 ‘정답’이었다. 그들은 열심히 서구적 근대가 제공하는 정답을 공부했다.
한국의 중고등학생들은 늦은 저녁까지 학교에 머물고, 그 다음에는 또 학원에 간다. 거기서 그들은 5지 선다형으로 만들어진 시험지 답안을 찾는데 몰두한다. 1987년의 민주대항쟁 이후에도 이런 교육시스템이나 학습 문화는 크게 달라지지 않았다. 정답을 공부하는 한국 학생들이 학교에서 배울 수 없는 것은 수사학, 연설, 산문쓰기, 의심하기, 비판적인 의견, 자율적 정치 실천 같은 것들이다.

그럼에도 불구하고 한국인은 민주주의의 열성적 지지자들이다. 하지만 여기서 주로 이야기되는 것은 대통령직이나 몇 가지 헌정적 이슈들이다. 그들은 종종 100만 명 넘는 거대한 시위를 통해 현직 대통령들을 끌어내리고 그들의 주권과 시민적 용기를 자랑한 바 있다. 말하자면, 그들은 민주주의란 이름으로 그들의 상징적 아버지들을 즐겨 살해한다.

하지만 엄마­자식 관계란 훨씬 복잡하고, 더 가까운 법이다. 한국인들은 (일본인과 더불어) 시민 에티켓 분야의 세계 챔피언이라 할 수 있는데, 심지어 전술한 대규모 시위 속에서도 그들이 학교에서 배운 올바른 시민의식을 결코 잃지 않을 정도다. 도시에 방화하는 블랙블록이나 아나키스트들의 자리는 어디에도 없다.

한국의 민주주의관에서 부족한 것이 있다면 그것은 학교나 회사, 대학에서 이뤄져야 할 민주적인 일상생활이다. 또한 비판적이고 자율적인, 성숙한 개인들을 기초단위로 하는 의회주의 문화도 종종 과소평가 되는 요소 중 하나다.
그 대신에 한국사회를 지배하는 것은 초(超)서구적인 문화와 태도, 기술 같은 것들이다. 한국은 또한 인터넷 속도 면에서 세계 챔피언이기도 하다. 값비싼 비용이 들어가고, 유럽에서 수백 년간의 계급투쟁에 의해 형성된 복지국가 모델 대신 한국과 비슷한 많은 개발도상국들은 저비용-고효율의 돌봄 국가들을 만들어가고 있다. 코로나 방역에서 성공했다는 남한 정부가 시민들의 경제 지원을 위해 지출하는 금액은 쥐꼬리만한 액수에 불과하다.

앞서 말한 바와 같이 한국 사회에서는 이 모성적인 거버넌스가 편재하고 있다. 코로나19 위기 대응이란 한국에서는 일상적 상태의 조금 더 과격한 연장일 뿐이다.
다르게 말하면 그것은 ‘탈근대 경찰국가’가 조금 더 분명한 형태를 보여주고 있는 것이라 할 수 있다. 발터 벤야민은 <폭력 비판을 위하여>(1929)에서 ‘안전을 이유로’ 행사되는 경찰권력에 대해 “문명화된 국가들의 삶에서 결코 파악 불가능한, 모든 곳에 퍼져 있는 유령적인 현상처럼 형상 없는 권력”이라 말한 바 있다.

탈근대의 경찰국가는 여전히 미시 주권 권력의 모든 곳에 퍼져 있는 현상형태(Erscheinungsform)를 가지고 있다. 하지만 더 이상 ‘유령적’이지 않다. 그보다는 ‘모성적’이다. 시민들은 기꺼이 그들의 어머니 국가의 감시, 통제 그리고 돌봄을 수용한다. 그것은 그들이 가진 ‘시민권’의 중요 요소다. 이것이 바로 한국적 대책이 가지고 있는 민주적 외양의 진짜 얼굴이다.

#민주적인 삶-의-형태란 무엇인가

남한 모델은 21세기의 후발 혹은 초근대화 국가들에서 발전하여 이미 오래 전부터 자칭타칭 “성인된 세계”(디트리히 본회퍼)였던 유럽의 체제와 새롭게 경쟁하는 여러 모델 중 하나일 뿐이다. 하필이면 이번 대규모의 팬데믹에서 유럽은 시민들의 생명(zoe)을 지키는데 있어서 그들 시스템의 열등함을 보여주었다.
어쩌면 유럽인들은 그럼에도 불구하고 성숙한 사람들이라서, 이 비상사태와 목숨을 위협하는 상황 속에서도 그들의 발코니 콘서트 등을 통해 “삶-의-형태”(bios)를 지속하고 있는 건지도 모르겠다. 혹은, 이런 전체적이고 모성적인 경찰국가의 돌봄과 통제를 받아들이기에는 ‘너무’ 성숙한 것일 수도 있다.

우선은 이 격리 상태를 함께 즐기자. 그러고 나서 우리가(내가 이 인칭대명사를 사용하는 것을 용납해주길 바란다.) 만들어야 할 새로운, 민주적인 삶-의-형태가 무엇인지 토론을 시작해 보도록 하자. 하지만 우리가 잊지 말아야 할 사실은 ‘표준시민’이란 보통 전 세계 어디서나 비슷하게 빌어먹을 틴에이저(goddamn bloody teenagers)들이란 사실이다.

----

김강기명 필자

인권사회운동 분야에서 활동하면서 한국사회의 종교(기독교), 정치 및 사회이론에 관한 글을 주로 썼다. 2011년부터 독일 베를린자유대학에서 스피노자의 정치철학에 대한 논문으로 박사과정을 밟고 있다. 주요 저서 및 번역서로 <잉여의 시선으로 본 공공성의 인문학>(공저), <새로운 자본 읽기> (미하엘 하인리히) 등이 있다.

2020/04/07

Viruses, Plagues and History by Michael B.A. Oldstone | Goodreads



Viruses, Plagues and History by Michael B.A. Oldstone | Goodreads







Want to Read

Rate this book
1 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
Preview

Viruses, Plagues and History

by
Michael B.A. Oldstone
3.83 · Rating details · 596 ratings · 38 reviews


The story of viruses and the story of humanity have been intertwined since the dawn of history. The first small cities formed not only the cradle of civilization, but the spawning ground for the earliest viral epidemics, the first opportunity for viruses to find a home in the human herd. This is a story of fear and ignorance, as everything from demons and the wrath of the gods to minority groups have been blamed for epidemics from smallpox to yellow fever to AIDS. It is a story of grief and heartbreak, as hundreds of thousands, sometimes millions, are wiped out in a single year. And it is a story of great bravery and sacrifice, as doctors and nurses put themselves in harm's way to combat yellow fever in Memphis and Ebola in Zaire, and as researchers risk their own lives to test theories of vaccines and the transmission of disease. 


Now, in Viruses, Plagues, and History, Michael B. A. Oldstone tells all these stories as he illuminates the history of the devastating diseases that have tormented humanity.

Oldstone focuses his tale on a few of the most famous viruses humanity has battled, beginning with some we have effectively defeated, such as smallpox, polio, and measles. Nearly 300 million people were killed by smallpox in this century alone -- more than were killed in all the wars of the twentieth century combined. The author presents a vivid account of the long campaign against the virus, the insightful work of Edward Jenner, who created the smallpox vaccine from cowpox virus in 1796, and the monumental efforts of D. A. Henderson and an army of W.H.O. health care workers to finally eradicate smallpox. The smallpox virus remains the only organism that we have deliberately pushed to complete extinction in the wild.


Oldstone then describes the fascinating viruses that have captured headlines in more recent years: Ebola and other hemorrhagic fevers, which literally turn their victims' organs to a bloody pulp; the Hantavirus outbreaks in the southwestern United States and elsewhere; mad cow disease, a frightening illness made worse by government mishandling and secrecy; and, of course, AIDS, often called "the plague of our time." And he tells us of the many scientists watching and waiting even now for the next great plague, monitoring influenza strains to see whether the deadly variant from 1918 -- a viral strain that killed over 20 million people in 1918-1919, more than twice the military and civilian casualties of the First World War -- will make a comeback.


Viruses have enormous power. They have wiped out cities, brought down dynasties, and helped destroy civilizations. But, as Michael Oldstone reveals, scientific research has given us the power to tame many of these viruses as well. Viruses, Plagues, and History shows us the panorama of humanity's long-standing conflict with our unseen viral enemies, from our successes to our continuing struggles. Oldstone's book is a vivid history of a fascinating field, and a highly reliable dispatch from a worker on the frontiers of this ongoing campaign. (less)
---

Paperback, 240 pages
Published April 20th 2000 by Oxford University Press, USA (first published January 1st 1998)
-----



Nov 16, 2012Mike rated it liked it · review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone


This is an educational book through-and-through. Yes, it’s true that I read a lot of what can be considered “educational” or popular science. I like science and its various branches (chemistry, physics, biology, cosmology, etc.) and math. I also like history and medicine. The author references more than one book that I remember reading when I was young and aspirations ruled the universe. For example, “The Microbe Hunters” by Paul de Kruif or books about Robert Koch and Louis Pasteur. (My middle-high school (BLS) is on Ave Louis Pasteur in Boston – just down the street from Harvard Medical School.) I also imagined it might have some overlap with the outstanding “Guns, Germs, and Steel” (which it does).

For the most part this was an interesting and enjoyable book to read. There are several “dry spots” that the casual reader (i.e. one who doesn’t give a rat’s derriere about the actual science of infection and virology) will probably skip over. To his credit, the author suggests this strategy in the opening. Being of sound mind and body (very argumentative proposition, I know) I read it cover-to-cover. Normally I would have read through such a book fairly quickly, but I put it aside for a 3-day business trip in favor of the lighter (and slimmer) “Almost Transparent Blue” by Ryu Murakami.

For the casual reader, this book offers a great retelling of various important plagues/epidemics that afflicted mankind for decades or centuries. You will cower at the human misery and cheer for the triumphs of elimination or near-elimination of various scourges. (I exaggerate only a little. There’s some but not quite so much drama in this book.) For the science-friendly there are discussions about how viruses infect us, how our bodies try (and sometimes fail) to combat these fiends, and how we have created methods to protect ourselves from them.

There is repetition in several places; it is often about a specific disease, but can also be about a person or historical development. Before my “break” I was beginning to get annoyed with the author by this. When I resumed reading, I found more occurrences (and recalled the earlier ones) but reacted less strongly to it. Was it necessary to make each chapter (topic) standalone? Was that the reason or goal? Don’t know and I still think it could have been done with less, but I’m not going to whack him on points too much for it.

This is a great book if you have even a passing interest in medicine and how and who helped keep us from dying like flies in the last 50-100 years. The author is an established and published researcher in his own right, so you are getting the insider’s view of this material. Although I already knew it, his treatment of how humans “game” things (to the exclusion of researchers from prizes that they rightly should have been jointly awarded) is well done and may open a few eyes.

I read the updated (2010) edition of this book. It has new material and is probably improved in other ways, also. The original was published a while back. “3.5” stars, which means a “3” for the GR ranking system.


(less)
flag8 likes · Like · comment · see review



Oct 06, 2014Cadie Sommer rated it it was amazing · review of another edition
Shelves: non-fiction, favorites, highly-rated


I really enjoyed this book. It gave interesting insights into the world of viruses and their history. I have always been an advocate for vaccinations and this book helped to solidify my opinion. I really get disheartened when people say that they are not going to vaccinate because their immune system is strong enough to combat diseases or that vaccines make the immune response of the body weak. Vaccines are the only thing keeping the planet protected from horrible pandemics that have frequently happened. Additionally, vaccines are only protect the whole world population when 80% or more people have received the vaccination and current trends have shown that the actual amount of vaccinate people in the United States is somewhere around 50%. Shocking!!!!

I will leave this description by saying that people rightly believe that immunizations are so important that war torn countries have actually ceased-fire for a few days to offer vaccinations to their population. CEASED-FIRE FOR VACCINATIONS. Chew on that anti-vaccinators! (less)


flag4 likes · Like · comment · see review



Nov 07, 2010Steven Belanger rated it it was amazing · review of another edition
Very well-written, for a scientist. Though there were some very unreadable passages, these were not a distraction, but only made the reader want to challenge himself to read and comprehend, which I didn't completely succeed at. Very exact and detailed in the history of the illnesses; very comprehensive, yet specific; very scary in its descriptions and predictions. I read this for research for an as-yet-untitled novel about plagues or viruses.
flag4 likes · Like · comment · see review



Sep 11, 2019Megan rated it really liked it · review of another edition
Shelves: standalone, nonfiction, dnf, audiobook, history, academic, normal-people-books, science, overdrive-tbd
3 stars for enjoyment, 5 stars for quality.

A excellent survey of the history of various plagues through out history and how the science of treatment has evolved. This was clearly never meant for light pleasure reading, it's more an academic resource. That said, it was easy to follow and take the couldn't finish tag with grains of salt; I got what I wanted from this book and I'm satisfied.
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



May 15, 2014Dan rated it it was ok
Shelves: 2014
Oldstone certainly has a command of the science, and he writes clearly. It's a good survey of various viruses, in that sense. But a few things stand out that prevent me from recommending this book:

1. The book repeats itself constantly, even in the same section. It could have used a more assertive editor.
2. I could have done with a bit less scientific triumphalism and moralizing. I know, vaccine-deniers are horrible (they are). But it just got to be a little much, and it sort of drowned out the story.
3. There were periodic historical inaccuracies throughout the book that I just found galling.

This may have just not been a match for what I was looking for: I wanted more on plagues and history, but this was mainly a survey of viruses, and a lot of present-day stuff. (less)
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jun 03, 2012Betsy Curlin rated it it was amazing
This is one of the best books I've read on the subject of viruses. It covers the major viral outbreaks in recent history, including the 1918 - 1919 influenza epidemic and HIV. Concise and intelligently written this is an informative and enjoyable read.
flag2 likes · Like · comment · see review



Jan 03, 2017Irena Feng rated it liked it · review of another edition
Fascinating topic, very detailed analysis as well; this book was stuffed to the brim with information on all aspects of a wide variety of subjects, giving many examples and backing them up with references. For the most part, this book was a great read; there were some sections that dragged a bit and were a little difficult to plow through for the more casual reader. For a casual reader, this book provides a great opportunity to learn about the broad strokes made by viruses and plagues throughout history; for the more scientifically inclined, Oldstone also manages to weave in some of the science that developed along with human understanding and knowledge. (less)
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Jul 12, 2009Awallens rated it it was ok
this book examines viruses such as yellow fever, measles and polio which have been eradicated or nearly so. It examines how these viruses changed history and how viruses such as AIDS and how a flu epidemic may change history. It has a few chapters dedicated to viruses, how they form, what they do to the body, etc. Those chapters were a bit repetative, and overall I was left relieved I had finished the book. It was an OK read, but a bit to heavy and out-of-date for me.
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Jun 30, 2010Diana rated it it was amazing · review of another edition
Ever wondered about measles, polio, yellow fever, ebola, lassa fever, hanta, or H1N1? This is the book to read. Accessible to readers of most levels though it does get a somewhat technical with viral natural history but still very interesting and kind'a scary! Ignorance is bliss but I don't think I want to be part of that group.
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Oct 27, 2010Virginia rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2005books, nonfiction
Nothing I hadn't read before - Jared Diamond used the same logic - but there was an interesting section at the end, about present and future challenges.
flag1 like · Like · comment · see review



Aug 22, 2019Dennis Littrell rated it liked it
Don't give up on this one too soon

This is an good book that unfortunately starts out in a very forbidding manner with a difficult (at least for me) introduction to the principles of virology in Chapter 1 followed by the principles of immunology in Chapter 2, but then gets very readable. The material on smallpox and yellow fever is fascinating. Oldstone leaves it unclear whether mad cow disease is caused by a miss-manufactured prion protein or by a virus: Others books, including Richard Rhodes' Deadly Feasts: Tracking the Secrets of a Terrifying New Plague (1997), clearly cite the cause as being faulty prion protein production in the brain.

This is not for the squeamish. I confess that there were twenty or so pages on polio that I skipped, not wanting to relive that sadness, although of course the defeat of polio is one of the great triumphs in the history of medicine. Incidentally, the title owes something to the classic Rats, Lice and History, by Hans Zinsser, first published in 1934, a book that has enjoyed a well-deserved and remarkable commercial success not easily duplicated.

--Dennis Littrell, author of “The World Is Not as We Think It Is”
(less)
flagLike · comment · see review



Jan 21, 2018Monical rated it did not like it
I used a textbook co-authored by Oldstone in my college classes, so I shouldn't have been surprised at the boring academic tone of this book. Oldstone just couldn't wean himself from his scientific writing expertise. Even though I know a fair amount about the topics he addresses in this book, I found it turgid, boring and in places not exactly accurate. I also was surprised at the amount of hero worship he demonstrates for some scientists, with a complete lack of critical view (Bob Gallo and HIV comes to mind, but Oldstone spends a lot of time on yellow fever where Reed and his colleagues did a lot of human experimentation-- without comment on the ethics and consent or not that was involved). He also fails to explain some topics-- for example, use of live (!) smallpox virus in variolation-- why didn't that kill people? I haven't been as disappointed in a scientific book since the books that promoted the theory that the black death was caused by anthrax (recently totally disproven!). Oldstone claims that the book "Microbe Hunters" was an inspiration for his own efforts-- maybe once I have recovered from this book I'll give that one a try. (less)
flagLike · comment · see review



Mar 25, 2018Rogue Reader rated it really liked it
Shelves: medicine
Dense and technical at times, a good and detailed overview of man's most dangerous and persistent enemies, though now dates as written in 199. Chapters on Smallpox, Yellow Fever, Measles, Poliomyelitis, viral plagues including hemorrhagic fevers, HIV, influenza and others. Anti-vaxxers need to read the facts of history, not the propaganda.
flagLike · comment · see review



Jun 16, 2018Sian Bradshaw rated it really liked it
This book is a very interesting read for those with expert knowledge. Had I tried to read this before my recent studies, a lot of it would have gone over my head. It was a good read and the historical context of smallpox and yellow fever was new to me.
flagLike · comment · see review



Nov 18, 2019Jenny rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2019
Pretty out of date by now, but I still found it fascinating.
flagLike · comment · see review



Jan 10, 2020WheeldonHS rated it liked it
Shelves: stem, 2020-non-fiction, 2020-kel
Far more US-centric than I expected it to be.
flagLike · comment · see review



Apr 05, 2020Adam rated it liked it
However...
flagLike · see review



Aug 04, 2019Robert & Kelly Cooney rated it it was amazing · review of another edition
Excellent read

Great book. Informative and clear on the devastation uncontrolled microbes can have on humanity. Well worth reading and learning from events where microbes shaped our history.
flagLike · comment · see review



Mar 28, 2020Alexander Anderson rated it really liked it
It’s a bit dry. The author is a Virologist, not a historian or storyteller, do not expect a seat-of-your pants drama or unputdownable comprehensive historical narrative.

The most relevant information is covered with the material on the influenza epidemic of 1918-1919 and the various SARS family of viruses. The information on Polio will probably only be of interest to anyone over 50 who still remembers his school vaccinations against it.

As a little relevant reading for an education about viruses and how they are spread, as well as a startling accurate prediction of the of the possibility of a crises like the current COViD-19 epidemic, it is certainly worth your time. Especially, if you have recently found yourself with extra time on your hands due to the current COViD-19 crises. (less)
flagLike · comment · see review



Nov 15, 2009Tippy Jackson rated it liked it · review of another edition
Shelves: disease, science-history, medicine, health
This was not my favorite general pathology book. It really wasn't very memorable. It's a little outdated. To be fair, I've studied/read about a lot of this stuff already. Still, that's because I find it fascinating and this book wasn't fascinating. It was really too short to explore everything the title suggests. If you're looking for a slightly out of date, but extraordinarily interesting pathology book, I recommend "The coming plague" instead. Good stuff there and even though some of the knowledge of HIV is deficient, the history of this disease is still incredibly relevant. (less)
flagLike · comment · see review



Jan 26, 2015Stephie Williams rated it liked it · review of another edition
A good book, but not great. The book was pretty informative overall. It start with what seemed such promising beginning. However, I quickly discovered the dryness of Oldstone's prose—I was continually thirsty throughout. It just was not a gripping narative. For example: Spillover: Animal Infections and the Next Human Pandemic by David Quammen. (less)
flagLike · comment · see review



Nov 25, 2008Sarah rated it liked it
Shelves: medical, non-fiction, 2009, free-library
this was a fascinating book, but VERY poorly edited. i would have given it four stars if it weren't for the crap editing.

and, of course, the book is 10 years old, so some of the information was out of date.

however, it was still a good read for someone as intrigued by infectious disease as i am.
flagLike · comment · see review



Nov 11, 2015Jean Brandenburg rated it liked it
Shelves: jean-has-read-these
I picked up this book for a quarter at the library sale. While there were pages of dry, technical boring stuff in every chapter, there was also lots of interesting stuff in every chapter. Each chapter was a different disease, like smallpox, polio, yellow fever, hanta virus, measles etc.
I learned a lot, and it's also sort of scary, though virus hunters are still working on cures.
flagLike · comment · see review



Jul 21, 2012RJ rated it liked it · review of another edition
Shelves: public-health-related
solid descriptions of the histories and fights against "old world" diseases, but the emerging infection info is a little sparse (understandable for an older book). this is definitely not a pop sci read, but if you're very interested in the topic it's worth a shot. be warned - it's dense. not really for the casual reader, i think, but if you're into virology or public health overall, go ahead.
flagLike · comment · see review



Oct 07, 2008Jamie is currently reading it
Ultimately unsatisfying, due to a style that doesn't achieve the excitement of The Microbe Hunters (as the author had attempted, based on his own words in the intro), and in fact doesn't really do much in terms of the history or the science.
flagLike · comment · see review



Aug 31, 2009Franziska rated it really liked it
Shelves: health-literature, non-fiction
This was a pretty well-written book on some of the major infectious diseases we've had/have and how we've conquered them. I thought it was a neat book, and it made me feel better about vaccinating my kids.
flagLike · comment · see review



May 24, 2014Susan Olesen rated it it was ok
Not bad, lots of history, but not always dates when you want them. And so out of date they were still arguing over prion vs. virus for CFJ/Mad Cow. Interesting without bogging down, but there are now much more up-to-date books out there.
flagLike · comment · see review



Apr 05, 2013Chris Pederson rated it really liked it
Shelves: non-fiction
Interesting read... gives a summary of how the immune system works and how we have discovered/combated diseases like small pox, yellow fever, polio, measles... too bad anti-vaxxers are making some of these come back.
flagLike · comment · see review



Mar 01, 2012Pancha rated it it was ok
Shelves: science, medicine
Basic info on viruses, what they are, how they infect. Also includes brief histories of diseases we've eradicated or severely limited (smallpox, measles, polio) and recently emergent viruses (AIDS, Ebola, Lassa, Hanta). Good if you're looking for a quick overview.
flagLike · comment · see review



Feb 22, 2010Karen rated it liked it
This book discusses several very interesting subjects. It would have gotten four stars except that, as it is over ten years old, some of the information is out of date. It's still worth reading if the subject matter interests you.
flagLike · comment · see review




eview
"Readable books about viruses by experts are not plentiful enough, and the point of this essay is to recommend a recent arrival by the American virologist Michael Oldstone. In 17 chapters, the author gives the non-specialist reader a complete account of viruses and virus-caused plagues such as smallpox, yellow fever, measles, polio, hemorrhagic fever, Lassa fever, ebola, hantavirus, SARS, West Nile Virus, mad cow disease, and influenza...Read this book (available now)--it's a treat." --Dan Agin, Huffington Post "...marvelously clear to lay readers, yet detailed enough to please and fascinate the professional."--Doody's

Product Description
The story of viruses and humanity is a story of fear and ignorance, of grief and heartbreak, and of great bravery and sacrifice. Michael Oldstone tells all these stories as he illuminates the history of the devastating diseases that have tormented humanity, focusing mostly on the most famous viruses.
Oldstone begins with smallpox, polio, and measles. Nearly 300 million people were killed by smallpox in this century alone and the author presents a vivid account of the long campaign to eradicate this lethal killer. Oldstone then describes the fascinating viruses that have captured headlines in more recent years: Ebola, Hantavirus, mad cow disease (a frightening illness made worse by government mishandling and secrecy), and, of course, AIDS. And he tells us of the many scientists watching and waiting even now for the next great plague, monitoring influenza strains to see whether the deadly variant from 1918--a viral strain that killed over 20 million people in 1918-1919--will make a comeback. For this revised edition, Oldstone includes discussions of new viruses like SARS, bird flu, virally caused cancers, chronic wasting disease, and West Nile, and fully updates the original text with new findings on particular viruses.
Viruses, Plagues, and History paints a sweeping portrait of humanity's long-standing conflict with our unseen viral enemies. Oldstone's book is a vivid history of a fascinating field, and a highly reliable dispatch from an eminent researcher on the front line of this ongoing campaign.

See all Product description




Photoguy41

4.0 out of 5 stars First two chapters may be too academic for lay persons.Reviewed in the United States on May 4, 2018
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
I am a retired microbiologist and do enjoy reading history books on science. The first two chapters had a pretty good review of how the immune system works. But, just a caution, might be too technical for many. However, just skip over to the first chapter on Smallpox and all is well. Well-researched; explanations are good, especially all of the history. Lots of sourcess.

18 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Susan Martin

5.0 out of 5 stars Love Love Love this bookReviewed in the United States on March 13, 2020
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
I highly recommend purchasing this book. It is very difficult to put it down when you start reading it. This writer has done an excellent job documenting in detail many of the killer viruses that have affected the world and how politics and religion impeded the success of diagnosing and treating the patients who suffered. It was intriguing to read the stories of people throughout history who treated these patients and the many personal accounts of people and events that explain in interesting detail about the ones who lived and the ones who died. You will have a much better understanding of killer viruses and become versed on the history of the diagnoses and treatment. Don’t hesitate purchasing this book if it is available. You will be pleased and it will greatly expand your knowledge if you are in the medical profession or not. It is very easy to read and understand for anyone despite their background.

5 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Kayla

5.0 out of 5 stars FantasticReviewed in the United States on May 22, 2018
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
I haven't finished this book yet (it is my daily metro-commute read) but I am extremely pleased with the writing and subjects. Although I am not a virologist, I have always found biology, epidemiology, and medical history to be interesting and this book hits all those points and then some. I would not recommend it to the casual, non-medical reader, but I would definitely recommend it to anyone interested in medical history and science.

11 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Teresa Rich

4.0 out of 5 stars Michael Oldstone covers the material very well. As a ...Reviewed in the United States on June 6, 2016
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Michael Oldstone covers the material very well. As a virologist, I found it interesting and enlightening and I learned some things that I didn't pick up in my immunology courses. Parts of the book are at a college reading level, which may be too detailed for the casual reader, but the sections on the history of various viral diseases is very readable.

16 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Marissa

5.0 out of 5 stars Must readReviewed in the United States on August 6, 2018
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
This book is very informative. It not only goes into the history of all these viruses but it also gives you an overview on how viruses and vaccines work. The author explains everything very well and in ways anyone can understand. I believe everyone should read this. Especially those who are against vaccines.

5 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Ann Julia

4.0 out of 5 stars I love learing about diseasesReviewed in the United States on May 20, 2018
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
I have been searching for a book dedicated to telling the story of measles forever, and this one does. I love learing about diseases, so this was right up my alley.

6 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Nico Vela

5.0 out of 5 stars Good Book on Disease.Reviewed in the United States on October 7, 2019
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
A great book that showcases how disease has, at times, shaped our history.

3 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

Dr. MonkeyBrainsBob

5.0 out of 5 stars Fascinating Scientific Detective StoryReviewed in the United States on November 21, 2014
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
This second edition is a fascinating view of history based on the powerful influence of plagues and viruses, not human politics. It also details the investigative work of pioneers in biology in discovering agents we take for granted today. In light of ebola (and possibly other future epidemics/pandemics), the book offers insight into containment and management. Overall, an exciting reading experience.

6 people found this helpful

HelpfulComment Report abuse

See all reviews from the United States


Top international reviews
Translate all reviews to English

Nick
4.0 out of 5 stars Very readable, but you may wish to miss out some of the first few chaptersReviewed in the United Kingdom on December 30, 2013
Verified Purchase
This is a good read if you are interested in viruses. The early chapters are a bit technical in describing how viruses work and how the body defends (or otherwise) itself. But this can be skimmed if you are not scientific as there are some good summary paragraphs in the text.

The descriptions of each virus and how it affects and has affected human and non human life and history are top class.

For example, how smallpox has been indicated in human life since antiquity, through the affect on American Civil war to modern terror worries. How Lincoln survived the disease, Edward Jenner and Cowpox, variolation and vaccination, and anti viral treatment example, eradication of the disease and so on. I am glad to say that these chapters are not too detailed nor too scientific (I am an ex-scientist) and provide marvellous high level reading.

Recommended if you take an interest in how viruses work, how we defend ourselves and how they have affected the world.

8 people found this helpful

HelpfulReport abuse

jc